Uncontrolled Web-Based Administration of Surveys on Factual Health-Related Knowledge: A Randomized Study of Untimed Versus Timed Quizzing

Background

Health knowledge and literacy are among the main determinants of health. Assessment of these issues via Web-based surveys is growing continuously. Research has suggested that approximately one-fifth of respondents submit cribbed answers, or cheat, on factual knowledge items, which may lead to measurement error. However, little is known about methods of discouraging cheating in Web-based surveys on health knowledge.

Objective

This study aimed at exploring the usefulness of imposing a survey time limit to prevent help-seeking and cheating.

Methods

On the basis of sample size estimation, 94 undergraduate students were randomly assigned in a 1:1 ratio to complete a Web-based survey on nutrition knowledge, with or without a time limit of 15 minutes (30 seconds per item); the topic of nutrition was chosen because of its particular relevance to public health. The questionnaire consisted of two parts. The first was the validated consumer-oriented nutrition knowledge scale (CoNKS) consisting of 20 true/false items; the second was an ad hoc questionnaire (AHQ) containing 10 questions that would be very difficult for people without health care qualifications to answer correctly. It therefore aimed at measuring cribbing and not nutrition knowledge. AHQ items were somewhat encyclopedic and amenable to Web searching, while CoNKS items had more complex wording, so that simple copying/pasting of a question in a search string would not produce an immediate correct answer.

Results

A total of 72 of the 94 subjects started the survey. Dropout rates were similar in both groups (11%, 4/35 and 14%, 5/37 in the untimed and timed groups, respectively). Most participants completed the survey from portable devices, such as mobile phones and tablets. To complete the survey, participants in the untimed group took a median 2.3 minutes longer than those in the timed group; the effect size was small (Cohen’s r=.29). Subjects in the untimed group scored significantly higher on CoNKS (mean difference of 1.2 points, P=.008) and the effect size was medium (Cohen’s d=0.67). By contrast, no significant between-group difference in AHQ scores was documented. Unexpectedly high AHQ scores were recorded in 23% (7/31) and 19% (6/32) untimed and timed respondents, respectively, very probably owing to “e-cheating”.

Conclusions

Cribbing answers to health knowledge items in researcher-uncontrolled conditions is likely to lead to overestimation of people’s knowledge; this should be considered during the design and implementation of Web-based surveys. Setting a time limit alone may not completely prevent cheating, as some cheats may be very fast in Web searching. More complex and contextualized wording of items and checking for the “findability” properties of items before implementing a Web-based health knowledge survey may discourage help-seeking, thus reducing measurement error. Studies with larger sample sizes and diverse populations are needed to confirm our results.     

Iliopsoas abscess in adolescents with type 1 diabetes mellitus

Iliopsoas abscesses have been reported in adult diabetic patients, but only one case has been so far reported in the pediatric diabetic literature. We report three cases of iliopsoas abscesses in three adolescents with type 1 diabetes mellitus, suggesting that an increased awareness of this condition is required for its early recognition and prompt treatment.     

A preliminary investigation of serological tools for the detection of Onchocerca lupi infection in dogs

Onchocerca lupi is a neglected filarioid causing nodular lesions associated with acute or chronic ocular disease in dogs. Despite the recent appraisal of its zoonotic potential, human cases are increasingly reported in the Old and New Worlds. Therefore, the development of accurate tools for the rapid diagnosis of O. lupi infections in dogs is becoming a priority. In this study, we conducted a preliminary investigation aimed at evaluating the usefulness of a commercially available ELISA test for the detection of O. lupi antigens in canine sera. The potential use of this tool for larger epidemiological studies of canine onchocerciasis is discussed.     

Thermotropic liquid crystals from biomacromolecules

Complexation of biomacromolecules (e.g., nucleic acids, proteins, or viruses) with surfactants containing flexible alkyl tails, followed by dehydration, is shown to be a simple generic method for the production of thermotropic liquid crystals. The anhydrous smectic phases that result exhibit biomacromolecular sublayers intercalated between aliphatic hydrocarbon sublayers at or near room temperature. Both this and low transition temperatures to other phases enable the study and application of thermotropic liquid crystal phase behavior without thermal degradation of the biomolecular components.Liquid crystals (LCs) play an important role in biology because their essential characteristic, the combination of order and mobility, is a basic requirement for self-organization and structure formation in living systems (1–3). Thus, it is not surprising that the study of LCs emerged as a scientific discipline in part from biology and from the study of myelin figures, lipids, and cell membranes (4). These and the LC phases formed from many other biomolecules, including nucleic acids (5, 6), proteins (7, 8), and viruses (9, 10), are classified as lyotropic, the general term applied to LC structures formed in water and stabilized by the distinctly biological theme of amphiphilic partitioning of hydrophilic and hydrophobic molecular components into separate domains. However, the principal thrust and achievement of the study of LCs has been in the science and application of thermotropic materials, structures, and phases in which molecules that are only weakly amphiphilic exhibit LC ordering by virtue of their steric molecular shape, flexibility, and/or weak intermolecular interactions [e.g., van der Waals and dipolar forces (11)]. These characteristics enable thermotropic LCs (TLCs) to adopt a wide variety of exotic phases and to exhibit dramatic and useful responses to external forces, including, for example, the electro-optic effects that have led to LC displays and the portable computing revolution. This general distinction between lyotropic LCs and TLCs suggests there may be interesting possibilities in the development of biomolecular or bioinspired LC systems in which the importance of amphiphilicity is reduced and the LC phases obtained are more thermotropic in nature. Such biological TLC materials are very appealing for several reasons. Most biomacromolecules were extensively characterized in aqueous environments, but in TLC phases, their solvent-free properties and functions could be investigated in a state in which no or only traces of water are present. Water exhibits a high dielectric constant and has the ability to form hydrogen bonds, greatly influencing the structure and functions of biomacromolecules or compromising electronic properties such as charge transport (12–15). Indeed, anhydrous TLC systems containing glycolipids (16–19), ferritin (20), and polylysine have been reported (21–23). However, a general approach to fabricating TLCs based on nucleic acids, polypeptides, proteins, and protein assemblies of large molecular weights such as virus particles remains elusive.Here we propose that the combination of biomaterials with suitably chosen surfactants, followed by dehydration, can be effectively applied as a simple generic scheme for producing biomacromolecular-based TLCs. We demonstrate that biological TLCs can be made from a remarkable range of biomolecules and bio-inspired molecules, including nucleic acids, polypeptides, fusion proteins, and viruses. TLC materials typically combine rigid or semirigid anisometric units, which introduce orientational anisotropy, with flexible alkyl chains, which suppress crystallization (24). In the present experiments, negatively charged biomolecules and bio-inspired molecules act as rigid parts, and cationic surfactants make up the flexible units to produce TLC phases with remarkably low LC-isotropic clearing temperatures, which is another TLC signature. Electrostatic interactions couple these rigid and flexible components into hybrid assemblies, which then order into lamellar phases of alternating rigid and flexible layers (Fig. 1) stabilized by the tendency in TLCs for rigid and flexible to spatially segregate (25).Open in a separate windowFig. 1.Proposed structures of TLCs formed by the biological building blocks complexed with surfactants, showing sketches of various lamellar phases and the corresponding phase transition temperatures (°C). The lamellar bilayer structures are made of, alternately, a sublayer of the biomacromolecules and an interdigitated sublayer of the surfactants, where the negatively charged parts of the biomolecules (e.g., phosphate groups of ssDNA and ssRNA, glutamate residues of supercharged ELPs, and N-terminal glutamate and aspartate residues of pVIII protein in phages) electrostatically interact with the cationic head groups of the surfactants. For the ssDNA–DOAB and ssRNA–DOAB smectic TLCs, the oligonucleotides are randomly orientated in the DNA (RNA) sublayers. For the ELP–DDAB complexes, in addition to the bilayer smectic phase, a modulated smectic (Sm_mod) phase is observed at lower temperature. For the phage–DOAB–DDAB lamellar structures, rodlike virus particles are embedded in a sublayer between interdigitated surfactants with additional in-plane orientational order.     

Brain conditioning is instrumental for successful microglia reconstitution following hematopoietic stem cell transplantation

The recent hypothesis that postnatal microglia are maintained independently of circulating monocytes by local precursors that colonize the brain before birth has relevant implications for the treatment of various neurological diseases, including lysosomal storage disorders (LSDs), for which hematopoietic cell transplantation (HCT) is applied to repopulate the recipient myeloid compartment, including microglia, with cells expressing the defective functional hydrolase. By studying wild-type and LSD mice at diverse time-points after HCT, we showed the occurrence of a short-term wave of brain infiltration by a fraction of the transplanted hematopoietic progenitors, independently from the administration of a preparatory regimen and from the presence of a disease state in the brain. However, only the use of a conditioning regimen capable of ablating functionally defined brain-resident myeloid precursors allowed turnover of microglia with the donor, mediated by local proliferation of early immigrants rather than entrance of mature cells from the circulation.     

High prevalence of serum antibodies reacting with simian virus 40 capsid protein mimotopes in patients affected by malignant pleural mesothelioma

Human malignant pleural mesothelioma (MPM) is considered a rare tumor, but recent estimations indicate that one-quarter million people will die of this neoplasm in Europe in the next three decades. The mineral asbestos is considered the main causative agent of this neoplasm. MPM is largely unresponsive to conventional chemotherapy/radiotherapy. In addition to asbestos exposure, genetic predisposition to asbestos carcinogenesis and to simian virus (SV)40 infection has also been suggested. SV40 is a DNA tumor virus found in some studies to be associated at high prevalence with MPM. SV40 sequences have also been detected, although at a lower prevalence than in MPM, in blood specimens from healthy donors. However, some studies have failed to reveal SV40 footprints in MPM and its association with this neoplasm. These conflicting results indicate the need for further investigations with new approaches. We report on the presence of antibodies in serum samples from patients affected by MPM that specifically react with two different SV40 mimotopes. The two SV40 peptides used in indirect ELISAs correspond to viral capsid proteins. ELISA with the two SV40 mimotopes gave overlapping results. Our data indicate that in serum samples from MPM-affected patients (n = 97), the prevalence of antibodies against SV40 viral capsid protein antigens is significantly higher (26%, P = 0.043) than in the control group (15%) represented by healthy subjects (n = 168) with the same median age (66 y) and sex. Our results suggest that SV40 is associated with a subset of MPM and circulates in humans.     

"It's a hair-dryer…No, it's a drill": misidentification-related false recognitions in younger and older adults

Memory for visual objects, although typically highly accurate, can be distorted, especially in older adults. Here we asked whether also erroneous identifications of visual objects subsequently corrected and replaced by a correct identification might induce false recognitions, and whether this is more likely to occur in older people. For this aim a new paradigm was developed. In the first phase, participants performed a visual object identification task with degraded pictures of objects and produced correct and false but subsequently corrected identifications. In the second phase, participants performed a surprise recognition task in which also false identifications were presented. False identifications elicited false recognitions, with a stronger and more reliable effect in elderly participants, suggesting that correcting the initial visual error is not sufficient to correct the memory for the experience. Moreover, misidentification-related false recognitions coexisted in memory along with correct recognitions of correct identifications. These findings are discussed in relation with age-related deficits in memory updating and strategic retrieval.