Objective
Evidence has linked economic hardship with increased intimate partner violence (IPV) perpetration among males. However, less is known about how economic debt or gender norms related to men''s roles in relationships or the household, which often underlie IPV perpetration, intersect in or may explain these associations. We assessed the intersection of economic debt, attitudes toward gender norms, and IPV perpetration among married men in India.
Methods
Data were from the evaluation of a family planning intervention among young married couples (
n=1,081) in rural Maharashtra, India. Crude and adjusted logistic regression models for dichotomous outcome variables and linear regression models for continuous outcomes were used to examine debt in relation to husbands'' attitudes toward gender-based norms (i.e., beliefs supporting IPV and beliefs regarding male dominance in relationships and the household), as well as sexual and physical IPV perpetration.
Results
Twenty percent of husbands reported debt. In adjusted linear regression models, debt was associated with husbands'' attitudes supportive of IPV (b=0.015,
p=0.004) and norms supporting male dominance in relationships and the household (b=0.006,
p=0.003). In logistic regression models adjusted for relevant demographics, debt was associated with perpetration of physical IPV (adjusted odds ratio [AOR] = 1.4, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.1, 1.9) and sexual IPV (AOR=1.6, 95% CI 1.1, 2.1) from husbands. These findings related to debt and relation to IPV were slightly attenuated when further adjusted for men''s attitudes toward gender norms.
Conclusion
Findings suggest the need for combined gender equity and economic promotion interventions to address high levels of debt and related IPV reported among married couples in rural India.Intimate partner violence (IPV) perpetrated by male partners or husbands occurs in high proportions globally as well as in low- to middle-income countries such as India.
1,2 One recent multi-country household study found that 37% of men in India reported having ever perpetrated physical violence against a female intimate partner in their lifetime. The health burden of IPV has been well demonstrated, with significant effects on women''s sexual and reproductive health (e.g., increased sexually transmitted infections, unintended pregnancy, and poor pregnancy outcomes),
3–5 mental health (e.g., anxiety, depression, and substance use),
6,7 as well as a multitude of other poor health outcomes among women and their children (e.g., maternal and child malnutrition and infant death).
8,9Recent research among women has identified economic hardship (e.g., financial dependence on male partners and economic instability) as increasing women''s vulnerability to IPV.
10,11 Although studies have found an association between economic stressors and reports of male IPV perpetration,
12–16 no research has examined debt in relation to these outcomes.Debt and other economic decisions in the context of marriage, particularly in rural India, are largely under the control of husbands. Taking on debt may be associated with economic hardship, heightening stress levels among men, and, in turn, IPV. Also, previous work documenting the association between economic hardship and increased IPV perpetration by males
12–15 has largely been explained by perceptions related to men''s roles financially within the family (e.g., men who do not feel that they are providing financially for their families may perceive that they are not fulfilling their roles as husbands/males, and this perception related to lack of role fulfillment may escalate into violence). Given that a decision to take on debt appears to be largely controlled by men in this context and likely tied to their perceived role of providing financially for the family, a man''s decision to take out loans may be determined, in part, by their support of masculine gender norms (e.g., a man''s role in the family and male dominance and control in the household). In addition, given previous work highlighting the association between masculine gender norms and a number of risk behaviors among boys and men (e.g., substance and tobacco use and behaviors resulting in unintentional injury),
17–21 such gender norms may also be linked to taking on risks associated with debt, as well as debt-acquiring behaviors (e.g., spending money on nonessential goods such as alcohol).Gender norms pertaining to IPV, relationships, and the household are also important driving factors in terms of understanding men''s behaviors related to IPV. Cross-cultural research has shown that societies with greater gender inequities in social norms and policies have a higher prevalence of IPV.
21 In the context of India and elsewhere, women''s low status in families and high levels of societal tolerance and acceptance of IPV promote IPV.
22More research is needed to understand economic hardship, and debt specifically, in relation to attitudes toward gender norms and IPV perpetration. Many studies have hypothesized that stress related to economic hardship and debts increases IPV perpetration;
12–15 however, less research has sought to understand the role of attitudes supportive of men''s more traditional gender norms in relationships or households in contributing to decisions to take on debt as well as in terms of explaining its association with increased IPV perpetration. Increased understanding of the mechanisms that explain associations between economic hardship/debt and IPV is needed to inform prevention approaches, particularly given the increasing number of economic promotion interventions being implemented globally and throughout India.Thus, the primary objective of the current study was to assess household debt in relation to husbands'' support of gender-inequitable norms and norms promoting IPV as well as husbands'' use of IPV against wives. The secondary objective of this study was to assess whether or not gender-based attitudes are important factors in debt and IPV, as well as in explaining an association between debt and increased risk for IPV perpetration among husbands.
相似文献