Objectives. We examined the effects of gender abuse (enacted stigma), depressive symptoms, and demographic, economic, and lifestyle factors on substance use among transgender women.
Methods. We conducted a 3-year prospective study (December 2004 to September 2007) of 230 transgender women aged 19 to 59 years from the New York Metropolitan Area. Statistical techniques included generalized estimating equations with logistic and linear regression links.
Results. Six-month prevalence of any substance use at baseline was 76.2%. Across assessment points, gender abuse was associated with alcohol, cannabis, cocaine, or any substance use during the previous 6 months, the number of days these substances were used during the previous month, and the number of substances used. Additional modeling associated changes in gender abuse with changes in substance use across time. Associations of gender abuse and substance use were mediated 55% by depressive symptoms. Positive associations of employment income, sex work, transgender identity, and hormone therapy with substance use were mediated 19% to 42% by gender abuse.
Conclusions. Gender abuse, in conjunction with depressive symptoms, is a pervasive and moderately strong risk factor for substance use among transgender women. Improved substance abuse treatment is sorely needed for this population.Previous studies and reports have pointed to a high prevalence of substance use among transgender women.
1,2 In surveys of this population in large US cities, self-reports of alcohol, cannabis, cocaine, amphetamine, methamphetamine, and opiate use have been 4 to 10 times as high as corresponding reports in the general population.
3–6 A recent study of this population in the New York Metropolitan Area observed prevalence estimates of these substances that were, for the most part, marginally higher than previous reports (60.4% for heavy alcohol use, 40.0% for cannabis, 21.7% for cocaine, 3.9% for amphetamines and methamphetamines, and 3.5% for opiates).
7Early clinical studies of this population attributed such high percentages of substance use to a gender identity at odds with sexual anatomy,
8 with later reports emphasizing more socially based conflict described as “gender-variant living in an often hostile world.”
9(p88) Following minority stress theory,
10 the use of alcohol and other drugs in lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender populations is now often understood as resulting from internalized stigma (including transgender phobia directed at oneself) or enacted stigma in the forms of discrimination or psychological or physical abuse by others.
11–13Enacted stigma and substance use have been described in a few studies of lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender populations,
14–16 but longitudinal investigations of these associations are rare,
17 the findings have not been consistent,
18 and no empirical research has focused on stigma and substance use among transgender women.
19Recent prospective studies of transgender women by our research team have pointed to gender abuse (enacted stigma) as a pervasive risk factor for a range of interrelated adverse health outcomes. In one study, gender abuse was associated with incident HIV and sexually transmitted infection in part because of the mediating effect of depressive symptoms.
20 A subsequent study showed moderately strong associations of psychological and physical gender abuse with incident major depression.
21In this study, we furthered this line of inquiry by systematically examining gender abuse, depressive symptoms, and demographic, economic, and lifestyle variables as interrelated risk factors for substance use. We hypothesized that psychological and physical gender abuse (enacted stigma) would be associated with substance use across time. We also hypothesized that these associations would be partially mediated by depressive symptoms (i.e., gender abuse causes depression, which then causes substance use). We have observed associations of gender abuse and depression in our previous studies, and depression, in turn, has been linked to substance use in numerous clinical and population studies.
22 One interpretation of the latter link, the self-medication hypothesis, suggests that depressed individuals use certain substances in an attempt to temporarily ameliorate their symptomatology.
23Against the background of the previous study,
21 which linked 4 background variables (employment income, sex work, social presentation of transgender identity, and hormone therapy) to depression in part because of the mediated effects of gender abuse, we hypothesized that these same background variables would likewise affect substance use in part because of the mediated effects of gender abuse. The link between employment income and gender abuse may reflect the social scrutiny of transgender women’s behavior in a formal workplace environment. Sex work (especially in public venues), social presentation of transgender identity, and physical feminization associated with hormone therapy may increase the public visibility of gender nonconformity and increase the odds of gender abuse as a result.
相似文献