Failure of Dietary Protein and Phosphate Restriction to Retard the Rate of Progression of Chronic Renal Failure: A Prospective, Randomized, Controlled Trial

SUMMARY Ninety-five patients (63 male, 32 female), age 45±2 years(mean±SEM) with chronic renal failure of varied aetiologywere randomized to receive either a conventional low proteindiet (0.6 g/kg/day protein, 800 mg phosphate; n=33), a low phosphatediet (providing approximately 1000 mg phosphate plus an orallyadministered phosphate binder, minimum protein intake 0.8 g/kg/day;n=30) or to control (minimum protein intake 0.8 g/kg/day, nophosphate restriction; n=32). Patients were reviewed for a minimumof 6 months before randomization and were withdrawn from thestudy if plasma creatinine exceeded 900 µmol/1, plasmaphosphate was > 2.0 mmol/1 or at the onset of uraemic symptoms. Following randomization patients were studied for an averageof 19±3 months. Mean plasma creatinine rose from 398±33to 600±50 µmol/1. Dietary protein intake was estimatedat 0.69±0.02 g/kg/day in the low protein group, 1.02±0.05in the low phosphate and 1.14±0.05 in the controls, phosphateintake was 815±43, 1000± 47, and 1315±57mg/day, respectively. Urinary urea excretion and protein catabolicrates were significantly reduced (p<0.01) only in those onprotein restriction, at 213±9 mmol/24 hours and 0.71g/kg/day, respectively. Phosphate excretion was significantlylower (p<0.05) in both the low protein group (17.9±0.8mmol/24 hours) and the low phosphate group (18.6±1.0mmol/24 hours) compared to controls. Changes in body weight,muscle mass and serum transferrin, albumin and immunoglobulinswere comparable between the groups. Mean blood pressure followingrandomization was 150/89±3/1 (low protein), 148/87±3/1(low phosphate) and 146/87±3/1 (controls). Progression of renal failure was analysed by rate of fall ofcreatinine clearance (ml/min/ 1.73 m²/month), by rate of deteriorationderived from reciprocal plasma creatinine against time plots(1/mmol/year) and to assess individual patient's response totreatment by two phase linear regression (‘breakpoint’)analysis of reciprocal plasma creatinine/time plots. Progressionwas analysed only in patients seen for at least 3 months followingrandomization. The rate of fall of creatinine clearance was not significantlydifferent between the groups (ANOVA): 0.56±0.08 ml/min/1.73m2/month (low protein, n=28), 0.44±0.07 (low phosphate,n=23) and 0.69±0.11 (control, n=27). In 50 patients (18low protein, 16 low phosphate and 16 control) whose rate ofprogression could be calculated before and after randomization,there was a fall in rate of progression averaging 0.18 ml/min/1.73m2/month in those on low protein diet and those on low phosphatediet, but a rise of 0.08 in the controls. These differenceswere, however, not statistically significant. Similar resultswere obtained when the rates of deterioration were calculatedfrom plasma creatinine. Significant individual improvements(p<0.01) in rates of progression by ‘breakpoint’analysis occurred in 17 patients: six on low protein, sevenon low phosphate and in four controls. Sixty-one (72 per cent)of the patients examined by this method showed no significantchange in the rate of progression while seven patients had acceleratedprogression. There was no difference in the requirement formaintenance dialysis facilities between groups. No significant benefit of protein and phosphate restrictionwas therefore demonstrated.     

Polycystic Kidney Disease Re-evaluated: A Population-based Study

A genetic register of all known cases of autosomal dominantpolycystic kidney disease occurring in South and Mid-Wales hasbeen established. In a population of 2.1 million, 209 familieswith affected members were identified, 303 of whom are currentlyalive, 70 on renal replacement therapy. An additional 551 caseswould be predicted amongst family members at 50 per cent and25 per cent risk, giving an apparent prevalence of 1:2459 inthe general population. Five possible new mutations were seenwhere adults with phenotypic autosomal dominant polycystic kidneydisease had both parents alive, age > 55 years with no cystsvisible on ultrasound. The take-on rate for renal replacementtherapy increased during 1970–79 but has apparently reacheda plateau of 4.8 cases per million population per year overthe last 8 years, despite a rapidly increasing acceptance ofuraemic patients as a whole (72/10⁶/year in 1988–89).Considerably more patients with autosomal dominant polycystickidney disease aged over 50 years were started on treatmentin 1980–89 than in 1970–79, but the survival overallimproved with time. All cases of autosomal dominant polycystickidney disease reaching end-stage renal disease are now beingtreated, but the apparent clinical prevalence of this conditionin our region is less than half the supposed gene frequency,suggesting that undiagnosed cases have a benign prognosis.     

Kidney transplants in mice. An analysis of the immune status of mice bearing long-term, H-2 incompatible transplants

Kidney transplants between strains of mice which are incompatible at either the K or the D end of the H-2 complex usually function for prolonged periods supporting the lives of nephrectomized recipients. This occurs with no recipient treatment. With multiple H-2 and non-H-2 determined incompatibilities, transplants may be rejected but more slowly than skin grafts. In the strain combination studied most extensively in these experiments (B10.D2 to B6AF(1)) in which the incompatibility was confined to the K end of the H-2 region, about 70 percent of recipients survived for many weeks with normal blood urea nitrogen levels. Skin grafts between untreated members of these strains were rejected promptly (mean survival time of 13.5 +/- 1.1 days) as were kidney transplants to recipients of prior skin grafts. Donor strain skin grafts to recipients of kidney transplants after kidney transplantation enjoyed greatly prolonged survival whereas skin grafts from a third party (A.SW) were rejected normally. If kidney tissue was transferred in the form of free grafts without primary vascular union, it was rejected promptly leaving its recipient highly immunized. Cellular and humoral immunity to donor antigens declined over the first few weeks after transplantation, and the spleens of long-term recipients contained no “killer cells.” Recipient lymphoid cells could mount active graft versus host reactions to donor strain antigens on transfer to neonatal mice. Nevertheless, they were distinctly less able to respond specifically by the production of killer cells to donor strain antigens after sensitization in vitro. No evidence that this defect was associated with the presence of suppressor cells was forthcoming from several types of in vivo and in vitro tests.     

Monoclonal antibody T101 in T cell malignancies: a clinical, pharmacokinetic, and immunologic correlation

Eight patients with cutaneous T cell lymphomas (CTCL) and five with various other T cell malignancies were treated with mouse monoclonal antibody (MoAb) T101. Doses of 1 to 500 mg were administered weekly over a two-hour period and resulted in one complete remission (convoluted T cell lymphoma) and one partial remission (CTCL). Remission duration was 6 weeks and 3 months, respectively. Frequent toxicities were pruritus, hives, flushing, and shortness of breath. Supraventricular arrhythmias and blood pressure instability were also observed. Complete targeting of peripheral blood T cells was achieved with 1 mg of MoAb in the nonleukemic patients (WBC less than 10,000/microL), and free, bioavailable antibody was present at the next (10-mg) dose level. Even higher doses resulted in substantial antibody excess that persisted for as long as 6 weeks. Serum concentrations of MoAb decreased with increasing number of peripheral blood T cells, and 25 to 35 mg of T101 were required for induction of antibody excess in leukemic patients. Excess antibody induced antigenic modulation, which was of consequence only if MoAb excess persisted to the next treatment. In the original treatment, the rapidly administered MoAb was able to target and remove peripheral blood T cells before the development of antigenic modulation. Antimouse antibodies developed in three patients. Their presence rendered further therapy ineffective and was associated with an anaphylactic reaction in one patient. Development of these antibodies could not be predicted by lymphoproliferative assays. In these assays, however, the T101 protein strongly stimulated the mononuclear cells of the patient who reached the only complete remission of this trial. Immunologic stimulation by the MoAb thus might have played a role in this patient's antitumor response. In summary, therapy with MoAb T101 was specific but only modestly efficacious. Rapid infusion of nonmodulating doses of antibody provided excellent targeting and removal of peripheral blood T cells and might be a valid approach in future trials with immunoconjugated T101.     

Use of influenza vaccines in children with an egg allergy

Children are at increased risk of morbidity from influenza. Influenza vaccines are grown in eggs, leading to a minute amount of egg protein in their composition. Recent research and new practice parameters spurred by the 2009 global influenza pandemic have challenged the need to withhold influenza vaccine from patients with an egg allergy. The available data suggest that anaphylaxis from influenza vaccines is exceptionally rare, even in patients with an egg allergy. Reported allergic reactions to trivalent inactivated influenza vaccine and pH1N1 influenza vaccines have been rare; when reactions occurred, they have not caused anaphylaxis. This position statement reviews the available evidence on influenza vaccine/egg allergy-related anaphylaxis, and recommends protocols to safely administer the trivalent inactivated influenza vaccine in lower- and higher-risk children with an egg allergy.