Web-Based Immersive Virtual Patient Simulators: Positive Effect on Clinical Reasoning in Medical Education

Background

Clinical reasoning is based on the declarative and procedural knowledge of workflows in clinical medicine. Educational approaches such as problem-based learning or mannequin simulators support learning of procedural knowledge. Immersive patient simulators (IPSs) go one step further as they allow an illusionary immersion into a synthetic world. Students can freely navigate an avatar through a three-dimensional environment, interact with the virtual surroundings, and treat virtual patients. By playful learning with IPS, medical workflows can be repetitively trained and internalized. As there are only a few university-driven IPS with a profound amount of medical knowledge available, we developed a university-based IPS framework. Our simulator is free to use and combines a high degree of immersion with in-depth medical content. By adding disease-specific content modules, the simulator framework can be expanded depending on the curricular demands. However, these new educational tools compete with the traditional teaching

Objective

It was our aim to develop an educational content module that teaches clinical and therapeutic workflows in surgical oncology. Furthermore, we wanted to examine how the use of this module affects student performance.

Methods

The new module was based on the declarative and procedural learning targets of the official German medical examination regulations. The module was added to our custom-made IPS named ALICE (Artificial Learning Interface for Clinical Education). ALICE was evaluated on 62 third-year students.

Results

Students showed a high degree of motivation when using the simulator as most of them had fun using it. ALICE showed positive impact on clinical reasoning as there was a significant improvement in determining the correct therapy after using the simulator. ALICE positively impacted the rise in declarative knowledge as there was improvement in answering multiple-choice questions before and after simulator use.

Conclusions

ALICE has a positive effect on knowledge gain and raises students’ motivation. It is a suitable tool for supporting clinical education in the blended learning context.     

Channelrhodopsin-2–XXL,a powerful optogenetic tool for low-light applications

Channelrhodopsin-2 (ChR2) has provided a breakthrough for the optogenetic control of neuronal activity. In adult Drosophila melanogaster, however, its applications are severely constrained. This limitation in a powerful model system has curtailed unfolding the full potential of ChR2 for behavioral neuroscience. Here, we describe the D156C mutant, termed ChR2-XXL (extra high expression and long open state), which displays increased expression, improved subcellular localization, elevated retinal affinity, an extended open-state lifetime, and photocurrent amplitudes greatly exceeding those of all heretofore published ChR variants. As a result, neuronal activity could be efficiently evoked with ambient light and even without retinal supplementation. We validated the benefits of the variant in intact flies by eliciting simple and complex behaviors. We demonstrate efficient and prolonged photostimulation of monosynaptic transmission at the neuromuscular junction and reliable activation of a gustatory reflex pathway. Innate male courtship was triggered in male and female flies, and olfactory memories were written through light-induced associative training.Identifying causal relationships between neuronal activity and animal behavior is a fundamental goal of neuroscience. Crucially, this task requires testing whether defined neuronal populations are sufficient for eliciting behavioral modules. The development of light-gated ion channels that can be genetically targeted to specific cells has provided a unique solution to this challenge. In pioneering work, such optogenetic effectors or actuators were originally used as multicomponent approaches (1–3). The introduction of Channelrhodopsin-1 (ChR1) (4) and especially ChR2 as a light-sensitive cation channel (5) dramatically advanced the field by providing an efficient and straightforward single-component strategy for stimulating neuronal activity (6, 7).Besides cell-specific targeting of appropriate effector elements, precise neuronal control by optogenetics demands efficient light delivery to the neurons of interest. For behavioral studies, photostimulation is ideally accomplished in intact, freely moving organisms and accompanied by functional readouts. The combination of a rich, well-characterized behavioral repertoire and elegant molecular genetics has contributed to Drosophila’s strong impact on behavioral neurogenetics (8, 9). However, low light transmission through the pigmented cuticle presupposes high light intensities for using ChR2 in flies. This obstacle greatly complicates the experimental setup for freely moving animals, and the required light energies can cause heat damage when stimulation is applied over extended time periods. Moreover, limited cellular availability of all-trans-retinal (hereafter retinal for short) demands adding high retinal concentrations as a dietary supplement. If optical access to target cells is not provided by a translucent body wall (e.g., as in nematodes, zebrafish, and Drosophila larvae), an alternative solution is the implantation of an optical fiber directly into the brain. Although this approach has been used successfully in mammals (10), such an invasive procedure is infeasible for the study of intact small organisms.Due to these restrictions in Drosophila, ChR2 has not reached the popularity attained in other organisms, and instead the field has turned mainly to thermogenetic neuronal stimulation (11–13). As with all techniques, there are also drawbacks to using temperature as a stimulus, such as undesired background activity and a multitude of temperature-sensitive cellular processes and behavioral responses. Photo-liberation of caged ATP, combined with genetic targeting of ATP-gated ion channels, has been introduced as a different optogenetic technique in Drosophila (3, 14). However, its applications are constrained by invasive, time-consuming procedures for injection of caged ATP and a limited experimental time window.Here, we introduce improved ChR2 variants as an alternative approach to address these shortcomings in Drosophila. Compared with wild-type ChR2 (ChR2-wt), expression of these mutants in target cells led to strongly enhanced photocurrents. We provide the first report, to our knowledge, of ChR2-T159C (15, 16) in flies and describe a ChR2 variant, ChR2-XXL (extra high expression and long open state), that is characterized by an extended open-state lifetime, elevated cellular expression, enhanced axonal localization, and reduced dependence on retinal addition. As a consequence, this mutant does not require dietary retinal supplementation to depolarize cells, evoke synaptic transmission, and activate neuronal networks at very low irradiance. These features enabled behavioral photostimulation in freely moving flies using diffuse low-intensity light.     

Limiting glutamate transmission in a Vglut2-expressing subpopulation of the subthalamic nucleus is sufficient to cause hyperlocomotion

The subthalamic nucleus (STN) is a key area of the basal ganglia circuitry regulating movement. We identified a subpopulation of neurons within this structure that coexpresses Vglut2 and Pitx2, and by conditional targeting of this subpopulation we reduced Vglut2 expression levels in the STN by 40%, leaving Pitx2 expression intact. This reduction diminished, yet did not eliminate, glutamatergic transmission in the substantia nigra pars reticulata and entopeduncular nucleus, two major targets of the STN. The knockout mice displayed hyperlocomotion and decreased latency in the initiation of movement while preserving normal gait and balance. Spatial cognition, social function, and level of impulsive choice also remained undisturbed. Furthermore, these mice showed reduced dopamine transporter binding and slower dopamine clearance in vivo, suggesting that Vglut2-expressing cells in the STN regulate dopaminergic transmission. Our results demonstrate that altering the contribution of a limited population within the STN is sufficient to achieve results similar to STN lesions and high-frequency stimulation, but with fewer side effects.The subthalamic nucleus (STN) has long been a structure of interest for researchers and clinicians alike. There is ample evidence that high-frequency stimulation of the STN improves symptoms such as tremor, rigidity, and slowness of movement, so called bradykinesia, in patients with Parkinson disease (see ref. 1 for review), but the mechanism through which this is achieved is still unknown. Some studies suggest that electrical stimulation causes a hyperexcitation of this structure (2), whereas others find evidence that the opposite is true (3–5). Other possible interpretations include the activation of the zona incerta, a neighboring white-matter structure (6) or of fibers coming from the motor cortex (7). Bilateral lesions of the STN improve locomotion (8), a result that is consistent with the inactivation hypothesis. However, previous studies have also found cognitive side effects when using high-frequency stimulation of the STN (9), findings supported by lesion studies in experimental animals, which led to abnormalities in operant tasks involving attention and impulsivity (10, 11). The projections of the STN to other regions help explain the multiple roles of this structure: It sends projections to other targets in the basal ganglia, such as the internal segment of the globus pallidus [also termed the entopeduncular nucleus (EP) in rodents] and the substantia nigra pars reticulata (SNr) (12, 13). The STN is also part of a circuit that includes the prefrontal cortex and the nucleus accumbens (14). It is currently unknown, however, whether these different roles reflect a heterogeneous population of cells, characterized by distinct gene expression. If that is the case, it would allow direct control over each cell population, facilitating the investigation of their respective roles. In rodents, the STN is believed to be composed solely of glutamatergic neurons, characterized by expression of the subtype 2 Vesicular glutamate transporter (Vglut2), whereas the other two subtypes (Vglut1 and Vglut3) have not been detected (15, 16). Selective targeted deletion of Vglut2 expression in this nucleus would therefore provide a specific loss-of-function model that would bypass a common problem presented by traditional lesions with pharmacological agents, which have patterns of diffusion that likely affect surrounding structures (17). It is known, however, that Vglut2 is expressed in many other parts of the brain (18), and a complete knockout in the mouse is not viable (19, 20). There is also evidence that the promoter driving expression of the Paired-like homeodomain 2 (Pitx2) gene is strong in the mouse STN (21) but is also not specific to this structure and a full knockout of Pitx2 expression results in premature death (22). To achieve the desired level of specificity, using a conditional knockout technique previously used to eliminate glutamatergic transmission in other cell types (23), we crossed Pitx2-Cre and Vglut2-lox mice, producing Vglut2^{f/f;Pitx2-Cre} conditional knockout (cKO) mice in which Vglut2 expression in the STN was strongly reduced in comparison with expression levels in littermate control mice. To understand the physiological contribution of the selected subpopulation of STN cells, we characterized these cKO mice with regard to anatomical, electrophysiological, and molecular properties, as well as their performance in a range of behavioral tasks.     

Context and dating of Aurignacian vulvar representations from Abri Castanet, France

We report here on the 2007 discovery, in perfect archaeological context, of part of the engraved and ocre-stained undersurface of the collapsed rockshelter ceiling from Abri Castanet, Dordogne, France. The decorated surface of the 1.5-t roof-collapse block was in direct contact with the exposed archaeological surface onto which it fell. Because there was no sedimentation between the engraved surface and the archaeological layer upon which it collapsed, it is clear that the Early Aurignacian occupants of the shelter were the authors of the ceiling imagery. This discovery contributes an important dimension to our understanding of the earliest graphic representation in southwestern France, almost all of which was discovered before modern methods of archaeological excavation and analysis. Comparison of the dates for the Castanet ceiling and those directly obtained from the Chauvet paintings reveal that the "vulvar" representations from southwestern France are as old or older than the very different wall images from Chauvet.