Mortality league tables: do they inform or mislead?

OBJECTIVE--To examine certain methodological issues related to the publication of mortality league tables, with particular reference to severity adjustment and sample size. DESIGN--Retrospective analysis of inpatient hospital records. SETTING--22 hospitals in North West Thames health region for the fiscal year 1992-3. SUBJECTS--All admissions with a principal diagnosis of aortic aneurysm, carcinoma of the colon, cervical cancer, cholecystectomy, fractured neck of femur, head injury, ischaemic heart disease, and peptic ulcer. MAIN MEASURES--In hospital mortality rates adjusted by disease severity and calculated on the basis of both admissions and episodes. RESULTS--The numbers of deaths from specific conditions were often small and the corresponding confidence intervals wide. Rankings of hospitals by death rate are sensitive to adjustment for severity of disease. There are some differences that cannot be explained using routine data. CONCLUSIONS--Comparison of crude death rates may be misleading. Some adjustment for differences in severity is possible, but current systems are unsatisfactory. Differences in death rates should be studied, but because of the scope for manipulating data, this should be undertaken in a collaborative rather than a confrontational way. Any decision to publish league tables of death rates will be on political rather than scientific grounds.     

Elephantiasis: a disease of development in north east Ghana.

A reconnaissance survey for the presence of lymphatic filariasis is made in 41 chiefdoms of north east Ghana. Four disease levels are identified culminating in hyperendemic disease foci associated with two Government-introduced rice irrigation projects. Attention is also drawn to the disease effects of small village dams. Multiple concurrent infections are noted. Within the most stricken irrigation villages, aspects of concealment, stigma and marriage are considered. Failure to control lymphatic filariasis has led to hospital avoidance and neglect of the disease jointly by patients, physicians and nurses. Culpability rests with the irrigation authority and Government health services. An outline is given of possible measures for disease control. A multisectoral policy of 'prevention before development' is strongly advocated.     

Clinical trial of a prevention and treatment protocol for skin breakdown in two nursing homes.

OBJECTIVE: Our objective was to assess the effectiveness of skin care protocols, including a body wash and skin protectant, on skin breakdown in 2 nursing homes. DESIGN: This was a quasi-experimental pretest/posttest design study.Setting and subjects Adult residents (n = 136) of 2 skilled nursing homes consented to participate in this study. Seventy percent were women; the sample average age of 82 years. INSTRUMENTS: A researcher-designed data recording form documented resident demographics, incidence and type of skin breakdown or pressure ulcer, presence of urinary or fecal incontinence, and assessment of the effectiveness of body wash and skin protectant. METHODS: Baseline data on prevalence of pressure ulcers and skin protocol were collected weekly for a 3-month period followed by a week-long educational program by the researchers about skin care and the body wash and skin protectant. During the 3-month trial with the body wash and skin protectant incorporated into routine care, research assistants recorded resident data weekly and researchers again assessed prevalence and incidence of pressure ulcers and skin breakdown weekly. RESULTS: Incorporation of a body wash and skin protectant into a skin care prevention and early intervention protocol in 2 nursing homes documented a decrease in skin breakdowns from 68 pre-intervention to 40 postintervention; the decrease in agency B was statistically significant. There was a statistically significant decrease in stage I and II pressure ulcer incidence overall (pre-intervention = 19.9%, postintervention = 8.1%). Nurses evaluated the body wash and skin protectant as effective for 98% of the time used. CONCLUSION: Implementation of a protocol for skin care along with staff education, including the prophylactic use of a body wash and skin protectant, reduced the incidence of skin breakdown, including pressure ulcers and perineal dermatitis, in 2 long-term care facilities.     

Infected descending aortic fistula

Two patients, each with an infected descending thoracic aortic fistula, are described. The first patient had a postpneumonitic empyema. Thoracostomy tube drainage resulted in obliteration of the empyema cavity. Upon slight withdrawal of the tube, 49 days after its insertion, massive pulsating bleeding occurred through the sinus tract. The bleeding was controlled with manual pressure at the entry site of the chest tube, and the patient was operated upon immediately. A descending aortic defect, 3 cm long X 1.5 cm wide, at the site of the thoracostomy tube was primarily closed. Ten months after the surgical procedure, the patient has had no difficulty referable to her aortic erosion. In the second patient, 9 months after removal of the T-10 vertebra (which had a large cell tumor) and replacement of the vertebra with Dunn's metallic device, hemoptysis and left lower lobe consolidation developed. Aortography demonstrated a lobulated false aneurysm, 4 cm wide X 6 cm long, at the site of Dunn's device. A 16-mm graft was sutured end to side to the descending aorta just distal to the left subclavian artery and to the abdominal aorta below the renal arteries. The false aneurysm was then removed, the two ends of the aorta were sutured, and the stumps were covered with omental graft. Nine months after the repair the patient has had no difficulty referable to the aortic surgery.     

Southern hip exposure

The efficacy of the posterior approach to the hip was analyzed in a retrospective study of 168 consecutive procedures performed by the author. Surgical technique is redefined historically and described in detail. Results are studied in two subgroups of hip surgery patients: endoprosthetic replacement (98) and total joint replacement (70). The factors evaluated were surgical time and blood loss, morbidity (dislocation, infection, pain, and limp), mortality, and complications of surgery. The posterior approach to the hip allowed excellent exposure without transecting tissue planes and creating dead spaces. Operative time averaged less than one hour for all cases, and blood loss, less than 500 cc. The four dislocations that occurred postoperatively were in patients with pre-existing flexion contractures. One superficial infection was noted but there was no increase in morbidity due to pain, limp, or loss of motion. Two total joint replacements were complicated by hematoma formation but occurred in patients who had extensive capsule resection and acetabuloplasty. Excellent and rapid exposure with minimal soft tissue destruction or blood loss coupled with few postoperative complications should encourage orthopedic surgeons to include the posterior approach in their treatment of hip problems.     

Diet and chronic atrophic gastritis: a case-control study

A hospital-based case-control study of gastric cancer precursor lesions was conducted in a high-risk black population in southern Louisiana. Ninety-three subjects with biopsy-proved advanced chronic atrophic gastritis were compared to two control series: a gastroscopy clinic series and a general hospital-admission series. Dietary case-control differences indicated a protective effect associated with fruit and vegetable intake and with dietary vitamin C and a risk elevation associated with milk consumption. The protective effect associated with consumption of fruits, vegetables, and vitamin C is consistent with findings for gastric cancer and with the etiologic hypothesis of intragastric nitrosation. A twofold increased risk was associated with cigarette smoking. Gastric juice pH, NO3-, and NO2- were determined for subjects undergoing gastroscopy, and comparisons were made between this high-risk U.S. group and a Colombian population with a much greater magnitude of risk; the latter had higher NO3- and NO2- levels. An increase in pH was associated with increasing severity of gastric lesions. Levels of pH and NO2- concentration were significantly correlated (P less than .0005); however, in Louisiana the large difference in NO2- concentration associated with pH elevation is not associated with histopathologic severity. Divergent trends with severity of lesions for NO3- concentration were seen in the two populations.     

Evaluation of a peer assessment approach for enhancing the organizational capacity of state injury prevention programs.

To conduct a formative and pilot impact evaluation of the State Technical Assessment Team (STAT) program, a visitation-based (visitatie) peer assessment program designed to enhance the organizational capacity of state health department injury prevention programs. The formative evaluation was based on observational, record review, and key informant interview data collected during the implementation of the first 7 STAT visits. Pilot impact data were derived from semi-structured interviews with state injury prevention personnel one year after the visit. Formative evaluation identified 6 significant implementation problems in the first visits that were addressed by the program planners, resulting in improvements to the STAT assessment protocol. Impact evaluation revealed that after one year, the 7 state injury prevention programs had acted on 81% of the recommendations received during their STAT visits. All programs reported gains in visibility and credibility within the state health department and increased collaboration and cooperation with other units and agencies. Other significant program advancements were also reported. Specific program standards and review procedures are important to the success of peer assessment programs such as STAT. Early impact evaluation suggests that peer assessment protocols using the visitatie model can lead to gains in organizational capacity.