Are NHS primary care performance indicator scores acceptable as markers of general practitioner quality?

BACKGROUND: In 2002 the Department of Health published a list of 20 indicators to judge the performance of the 302 primary care organisations (PCOs) in England during 2001-2002. General practitioners (GPs) have expressed doubts about the relevance, applicability and evidence base of these indicators for actual practice. AIMS: To fashion NHS performance indicators to be acceptable and relevant to practicing GPs. DESIGN OF STUDY: A Delphi technique followed by simple mathematical modelling. METHODS: We asked a group of 24 senior GP educators to place the Department of Health performance indicators in rank order as markers of quality in general practice. We found just seven indicators comprised 73% of the markers chosen and all seven were chosen by over three-quarters of the responders. Using a simple 'sign test' system, we then calculated a composite points score for all 302 PCOs. RESULTS: We found that there were almost twice as many PCOs at the upper and lower ends of performance and fewer in the middle than we predicted theoretically. The results suggest that pan-PCO or practice factors account for the low performance scores of 16 of 35 PCOs with extremely poor performance and for the high scores of 17 of the 36 PCOs with extremely high performance. CONCLUSION: We have developed a method that shows how numerous Department of Health performance indicators can be merged into a single composite performance score. We show that this composite performance score is easy to derive, simple to interpret, is acceptable to GPs, and has face validity.     

Carotid intima-media thickness as predictor of secondary events after coronary angioplasty.

AIM: Subjects with symptomatic or asymptomatic peripheral arterial or cerebro-vascular disease have an increased risk of death or cardiovascular event. The aim of this study was to determine whether intima-media thickening of the common carotid artery and/or a low ankle brachial index (ABI) are related with an increased risk of cardio-vascular event after percutaneous coronary angioplasty (PTCA). METHODS: One hundred and thirteen consecutive, patients (88 males, 25 females, mean age: 62 years) undergoing PTCA were included. Intima media thickness (IMT) of the common carotid artery and ABI were measured within the 2 days following the PTCA. Subjects were followed up for 10.2 +/- 4 months. The end-point was a composite criterion associating death, non fatal acute myocardial infarction, recurrence or worsening of angina pectoris, hospitalisation for heart failure, new positive exercise stress testing. RESULTS: In the follow-up study a common carotid IMT >0.7 mm was a predictor of event (p=0.03) in the univariate analysis. The other risk factors were unstable angina (p=0.001) and PTCA on the left descending coronary artery (p<0.05). We did not find any relation between the end-point and ABI or presence of atheroma on the common femoral artery. In the logistic regression analysis unstable angina was associated with a 3.14 fold increased risk (IC 95%: 1.51-6.4, p=0.002), subjects without HMG-CoA inhibitors drugs at the inclusion had also an increased risk of 2.5 (IC 95%:1.09-5.75, p=0.02). CONCLUSION: This study suggest that CCA-IMT is associated with an increased risk of cardiac events after PTCA. The measurement of subclinical disease could be useful for identifying high-risk patients.     

Preoperative methicillin‐resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) screening: An effective method to control MRSA infections on elective orthopaedics wards

Background: Methicillin‐resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) infections continue to increase in UK hospitals despite the introduction of various control measures. These infections have serious clinical and economic implications, particularly in relation to elective orthopaedic surgery. Methods: A prospective study was performed from August 2003 to July 2004 to assess the effect of preadmission screening and ‘ring fencing’ of beds on the incidence of infection in an elective orthopaedics unit. Results: The preoperative incidence of MRSA colonization was 2.25% and 53% of these patients had at least one risk factor. There were no postoperative MRSA infections in the ring‐fenced orthopaedic unit. Conclusions: Preoperative screening and ring fencing reduced the MRSA incidence to zero in the operated patients. Mechanisms need to be developed where screening and isolation of MRSA cases can be performed in most, if not all, hospital admissions.     

Agreement between staff and service users concerning the clientele's mental health needs: a Quebec study.

OBJECTIVES: This article examines the differences found between clientele with severe mental health problems and their key health workers in terms of assessing service users' needs in 6 Quebec service areas. METHOD: We questioned 165 pairs of users and staff, using the Camberwell Assessment of Needs questionnaire. The profile of serious and overall problems encountered by clientele from each of the sites was compared. RESULTS: The sites with the greatest degree of user-staff agreement in identifying problems were also the ones where users considered that local services best met their needs. CONCLUSIONS: The study demonstrated that, in needs assessment, major differences exist between the perceptions of users and their key workers in the various sites. These differences can be explained in part by users' individual characteristics, by types of needs, by local particularities, and by service use.     

The effect of diclofenac sodium ophthalmic solution on intraocular pressure following cataract extraction.

Ninety-two nonglaucomatous patients undergoing extracapsular cataract extraction with implantation of a posterior chamber intraocular lens by residents at a Veterans hospital were randomized in double-masked fashion to receive either a topical nonsteroidal antiinflammatory agent, diclofenac sodium 0.1%, or a placebo consisting of vehicle only. One drop of placebo or diclofenac sodium 0.1% was administered on an inpatient basis by trained staff every 6 hours for three doses, starting the afternoon prior to surgery. A further drop was given at 90, 60, 30, and 15 minutes before the operation. Starting 24 hours after surgery, all patients received diclofenac sodium 0.1%. All patients remained hospitalized for 72 hours postoperatively. Mean baseline intraocular pressure (IOP) was 14.0 and 14.1 mm Hg in the diclofenac and placebo groups, respectively. IOP rose 8.6 mm Hg in both groups at 6 hours after surgery. At 24 hours, the mean IOP elevation from baseline was 11.3 mm Hg in the diclofenac group and 9.6 mm Hg in the placebo group (P = .47). Within the first 24 hours, IOP spiked more than 10 mm Hg in 57% (26/46) of the diclofenac patients and in 54% (25/46) of the placebo patients. These results suggest that diclofenac sodium 0.1% drops affect neither the incidence nor the height of IOP elevation following cataract surgery.     

Thioethers as urinary metabolites of thiophene and monobromothiophenes.

1. Thiophene and its two monobromo derivatives were administered to rats and the amounts of thioether excreted in urine were measured by an assay based on Ellman's reagent. This assay, which involves extraction and hydrolysis, was validated by determining extraction and hydrolysis efficiencies for several authentic thioethers including N-acetyl-S-(2-thienyl)-L-cysteine, a previously reported metabolite of thiophene and 2-bromothiophene. 2. The thioethers present in urine of animals dosed with thiophenes have been examined chromatographically. Contrary to previous reports, the present work indicates that S-substituted, N-acetyl-L-cysteines (mercapturic acids) are not important thioether metabolites of thiophene in rats, and the small quantity of such compounds formed does not include either of the two simple S-thienyl derivatives. 3. The two monobromo thiophenes form higher proportions of thioethers than does thiophene, and one of these thioethers, arising from 3-bromothiophene, was identified, chromatographically, as N-acetyl-S-(3-thienyl)-L-cysteine.     

The role of 3D CT in the assessment of acetabular fractures.

A total of 16 patients with acetabular fractures were evaluated by plain radiography, axial computed tomography (CT) and three dimensional (3D) CT. It was possible to classify the fracture type in each case from the plain radiographs alone. Axial CT gave additional detail in certain areas, notably the region of the teardrop, the obturator foramen and the acetabular roof. Intra-articular and impacted roof fragments and associated soft tissue injuries were also shown. 3D CT provided the best and most easily interpreted overall assessment of the fractures. In addition to projections equivalent to the plain radiographs, two other views were of particular clinical value in demonstrating surgically inaccessible areas, namely the view of the pelvis from above and the view of the inner aspect of the fractured hemipelvis. However, fracture lines demonstrated on plain radiographs and axial CT were not always apparent on the 3D CT scans. Although 3D CT is a valuable addition to the imaging of acetabular fractures, it is not a substitute for good quality plain radiography and analysis of the axial CT images.     

Spontaneous angina caused by spasm of the left coronary artery]

A 42 year old woman presented with a one year history of retrosternal chest pain and back pain on effort and at rest sometimes accompanied by minor syncopal attacks. Transient atrioventricular block was documented during one such episode associated with hypotension. Coronary angiography showed spontaneous spasm of the left main coronary artery with clinical symptoms but no electrocardiographic changes. The spasm was relieved by injection of SIN-1. The similarity between the previous clinical symptoms and those observed at coronary angiography was in favour of the diagnosis of spasm of the left main coronary artery without atherosclerotic coronary disease. Treatment with calcium atherosclerotic coronary disease. Treatment with calcium blockers and platelet antiaggregants led to total regression of her symptoms with a follow-up of 5 months.