The ethics and conduct of cross-cultural research in developing countries

Bioethics is the study of moral problems as they relate to health-care delivery. The Hippocratic Oath laid the foundation of medical ethics as we know it today. Advances in medical technology have moved attention away from traditional ethical concepts, which are now either taken for granted or have been accorded the back seat. Contemporary ethical issues that occupy the minds of ethicists include euthanasia, advance directives, in vitro fertilization, surrogate motherhood and transplantation. Some of these are of less concern in developing countries than in the developed world. In developing countries, the ethics of cross-cultural research, the ethics of scarcity and sacrifice, and the activities and ethics of multinational companies assume far greater importance. This discussion will concentrate on the ethics and conduct of cross-cultural research in developing countries. The other important topics of scarcity, sacrifice and multinational activity will be covered elsewhere. Culture is the integrated patterns of human knowledge, beliefs and behaviour of a given community. Culture provides individuals with their identity. To work effectively with people it is necessary to view the world from their perspective. This is particularly important when dealing with people from cultures different from one's own. The world is functionally shrinking and there is interdependence not only in the traditional areas of communication and information transfer but also in the economic, environmental, demographic and migration areas. The concept of ‘global health village’ has now become a reality. In the past, researchers seem to have been motivated to conduct studies in developing countries for a variety of reasons. Whereas some of these are laudable, others are of more dubious ethical implications. This article focuses on issues related to the structural design, process and outcome of such research. Anyone contemplating conducting research in developing countries, especially cross-cultural research, must keep three main points in mind. In particular, the collective wisdom of both foreign and local investigators should be pooled to determine the appropriate research question(s) relevant to the needs of the target population. If human subjects are required for the study, ethical obligations based on the principle of respect for the person and respect for the autonomy of study subject must prevail. Finally constant checks and balances must be in place to ensure benefit of the research, not only to science and society but to individual subjects as well.     

Prevalence of mental illness and its impact on the use of home care and nursing homes: a population-based study of older adults in Manitoba.

OBJECTIVES: To determine the prevalence of mental illness in older adults and its effect on home care and personal care home (PCH) use. METHODS: Using nonidentifying administrative records (fiscal years 1997-1998 to 2001-2002) from the Population Health Research Data Repository housed at the Manitoba Centre for Health Policy, we determined the 5-year period prevalence for individuals aged 55 years and over (119 539 men and 145 752 women) for 3 mental illness categories: cumulative mental disorders (those having a diagnosis of depression, anxiety disorder, personality disorder, schizophrenia, and [or] substance abuse), any mental illness, and dementia. We calculated age-specific and age-adjusted rates of home care and PCH use and the prevalence of mental illness in PCH residents. RESULTS: From the group aged 55 to 59 years to the group aged 90 years or older, the prevalence of mental illness increased with the population's age. The prevalence of any mental illness rose from 32.4% to 45.0% in men and from 42.6% to 51.9% in women, and dementia prevalence rose from 2.0% to 33.6% in men and from 1.3% to 40.3% in women. The age-adjusted annual rates of open home care cases per 1000 population aged 55 and older varied by mental illness grouping (no mental disorder, 57 for men and 91 for women; cumulative mental disorders, 162 for men and 191 for women; dementia, 300 for men and 338 for women). The age-adjusted rates of PCH use per 1000 population aged 75 years and older also varied by mental illness grouping (no mental disorder, 53 for men and 78 for women; cumulative mental disorders, 305 for men and 373 for women; dementia, 542 for men and 669 for women). Among patients admitted to (or resident in) a PCH in 2002-2003, 74.6% (87.1%) had a mental illness, and 46.0% (69.0%) had dementia. CONCLUSIONS: Mental illness affects the use of home care and nursing homes profoundly. Individuals with dementia used home care at 3 times the rate of those having no mental illness diagnosis, and they used PCHs at 8 times the rate.     

Depression symptoms in movement disorders: comparing Parkinson's disease, dystonia, and essential tremor.

Depression is common in Parkinson's disease (PD) and affects 30 to 50% of all patients. In contrast to the wealth of research on depression in PD, little is known about the occurrence of depression in other movement disorders. The primary objective of the current study was to determine whether the high prevalence of depression symptoms seen in PD is also found in other movement disorders, by directly comparing rates of specific depression symptoms and depression severity across PD, dystonia, and essential tremor (ET). Three hundred and fifty-four patients with PD, 83 patients with dystonia, and 53 patients with ET completed the Beck Depression Inventory (BDI). We found no significant between-groups differences for depression severity, frequency, or endorsement of specific depression symptoms. Forty-eight percent of PD patients, 37.3% of dystonia patients, and 34% of ET patients were found to be at least mildly depressed (BDI score of 10 or higher). The most commonly endorsed symptoms were fatigability, difficulty with work, anhedonia, and sleep disturbance. Clinicians should be aware that depression is a frequent problem in dystonia and ET, in addition to PD, and inquire about depression symptoms in these patients so that they can be appropriately treated.     

A new method to measure intraosseous pressures

A new technique for measuring intraosseous pressures involves inserting a miniature transducer directly into the intraosseous space. A high-performance, high-fidelity pressure transducer is easy to assemble and insert. The transducer permits dynamic studies of intraosseous pressure during gait, and constitutes a promising tool for detecting changes in intraosseous pressure in osteoarthritis and osteonecrosis.     

Association between keratoconus and atopy.

Sixty-seven patients with keratoconus were classified according to atopic status. Keratoconus patients with and without atopy did not differ significantly with regard to sex, age of onset, or rate of keratoplasty, but patients with very high IgE levels were more prone to graft rejection. Atopy was less common in patients with unilateral keratoconus, and keratoconus occurred more frequently on the side of the dominant hand. There was a significantly lower frequency of HLA B7 in the keratoconus group than in the controls. No abnormalities of essential fatty acid metabolism were found in keratoconus patients with or without atopy. There was no social class bias in the group. The study included a brother and sister with keratoconus and atopy, and a non-atopic patient whose identical twin did not have keratoconus.     

Eliminating Intensive Postoperative Care in Same-day Surgery Patients Using Short-acting Anesthetics

Background: A multidisciplinary effort was undertaken to determine whether patients could safely bypass the postanesthesia care unit (PACU) after same-day surgery by moving to an earlier time point evaluation of recovery criteria.

Methods: A prospective, outcomes research study with a baseline month, an intervention month, and a follow-up month was designed. Five surgical centers (three community-based hospitals and two freestanding ambulatory surgical centers) were utilized. Two thousand five hundred eight patients were involved in the baseline period, and 2,354 were involved in the follow-up period. Outcome measures included PACU bypass rates and adverse events. Intervention consisted of a multidisciplinary educational program and routine feedback reports.

Results: The overall PACU bypass rate (58%) was significantly different from baseline (15.9%, P < 0.001), for patients to whom a general anesthetic was administered (0.4-31.8%, P < 0.001), and for those given other anesthetic techniques (monitored anesthesia care, regional or local anesthetics; 29.1-84.2%, P < 0.001). During the follow-up period, the average (SD) recovery duration for patients who bypassed the PACU was significantly shorter compared to that for patients who did not bypass, 84.6 (61.5) versus 175.1 (98.8) min, P < 0.001, with no change in patient outcome. Patients receiving only short-acting anesthetics were 78% more likely (P < 0.002) to bypass the PACU after adjusting for various surgical procedures.     

Intussesception after jejunoileal bypass as diagnosed by ultrasound

Eighty patients who had undergone jejunoileal bypass for morbid obesity were examined by ultrasound at their routine follow-up visits to the clinic. Ultrasonographic evidence of intestinal intussusception was found in 15 patients (19%). Two of these patients were asymptomatic. Ultrasonographic findings were confirmed by operation in 6 patients (5 with intussusception, 1 negative).