Further thoughts on double effect: some preliminary responses

Since the papers in this issue by Alan Donagan, Don Marquis, William Nelson and Warren Quinn raise complex and challenging questions about almost every aspect of my "Who is Entitled to Double Effect", I cannot, in the present context, provide more than preliminary responses to some of the more important issues they raise in the hope that this might contribute to further clarification of the doctrine of double effect (DDE).     

Cultured epithelial autografts: three years of clinical experience with eighteen patients.

Eighteen patients with major burns (mean total body surface area burned was 49% and mean total body surface area with full-thickness burns was 38%) had cultured epithelial autografts applied to 2% to 35% of the body surface area. In six patients successful "take" of greater than 65% occurred, and in 12 patients less than 40% "take" occurred. Most wounds underwent early excision to subcutaneous fat or fascia, and the wounds of 16 patients had been treated previously with homograft. Cultured epithelial autografts were covered with either single or multilayered dressings. Perioperative wound cultures showed that all patients had microorganisms, and appropriate perioperative antibiotic coverage of Staphylococcus epidermidis and Pseudomonas aeruginosa was noted less frequently in the poor take group, which may have influenced subsequent cultured epithelial allograft take. Adherence and stability of cultured epithelial allografts lag behind adherence and stability of meshed split-thickness autograft. The anterior trunk and thighs are the best recipient sites. The number of autograft harvests that were required to close wounds and the length of hospital stay were not significantly decreased by the use of cultured epithelial allografts as compared with comparable full-thickness burns that were treated previously without cultured epithelial allografts. Presently, grafting with cultured epithelial allografts is an adjunct but not an alternative to conventional burn-wound coverage with split-thickness autograft, because engraftment is inconsistent.     

Empirical support for psychological profiles observed in multiple sclerosis

Though increasing attention is being paid to psychological aspects of multiple sclerosis, much research continues to examine patients as differing in quantity rather than quality of psychological abnormality or response. Cluster analysis was used to identify distinctive psychological profiles in a large sample of patients with multiple sclerosis. It employed three measures, carefully chosen to capture the main responses historically observed in multiple sclerosis. These measures were (1) the patient's physical disability-impairment, assessed by a neurologist; (2) physical disability-impairment as perceived and reported by the patient; and (3) self-reported psychological well-being (or distress) independent of physical signs and symptoms. The optimal solution from the cluster analysis separated the 99 patients into 10 clusters, which were collapsed into four profiles, consistent with the labels "depression," "denial," "exaggerated somatic," and "severity-related." These data give strong empirical support to the existence of discrete and distinctive coping styles in multiple sclerosis.     

The Age/Sex Register: estimation of the practice population

Determination of the number of patients served by a family practice is important for health services delivery and research. A sound estimate of the practice population should enhance the patient management responsibilities of the family physician. This methodology uses the Age/Sex Register to provide a series of estimations of a "teaching" unit population. Results of a sample survey indicate that 21.3% of "inactive patients" (those who have not received services from the practice in two years) still consider themselves under the care of the practice. Replication of this approach is suggested for other practices to improve planning and resource allocation.     

Elevated serum insulin-like growth factor binding protein-2 as a prognostic marker in patients with ovarian cancer.

PURPOSE: The purpose of this research was to examine the diagnostic and prognostic significance of elevated serum insulin-like growth factor binding protein (IGFBP)-2 levels in women with ovarian cancer from diagnosis through treatment to relapse or remission. EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN: Serum collected pre- and postoperatively in women newly diagnosed with ovarian cancer, during adjuvant chemotherapy cycles, at 6 months follow-up and at relapse was analyzed for IGFBP-2. Control serum was from women undergoing pelvic or abdominal surgery for benign ovarian disease or nonovarian pathology. RESULTS: IGFBP-2 at diagnosis was significantly elevated (P < 0.0001) in women with ovarian cancer (887 +/- 62 ng/ml) compared with benign controls (337 +/- 25 ng/ml), and women undergoing nonovarian surgery (439 +/- 49 ng/ml) and correlated positively with tumor stage and cellular differentiation but not with CA125. Unexpectedly, IGFBP-2 levels increased additionally 1-week postoperatively in ovarian cancer patients (1581 +/- 90 ng/ml; P = 0.0027) as well as controls (977 +/- 95 ng/ml; P < 0.0001) and was higher in women who had suboptimal debulking compared with optimal debulking of their tumor. IGFBP-2 levels returned to normal in women without evidence of progressive disease, but remained significantly elevated in women who later relapsed. Patients with IGFBP-2 levels in the highest tertile at diagnosis had a significantly shorter progression-free interval and overall survival. CONCLUSION: In ovarian cancer IGFBP-2 is elevated at diagnosis, and corresponds to stage and histology with patients in the highest tertile of IGFBP-2 more likely to relapse and have a poorer outlook. Identification of these patients at diagnosis may allow more individualized, aggressive adjuvant treatment and follow-up, and IGFBP-2 may therefore be an important additional prognostic marker in this disease.     

Communicating oesophageal duplication

Oesophageal duplications are rare congenital abnormalities. Most of them do not communicate with the oesophageal lumen. We present a very uncommon finding of communicating oesophageal duplication in which the connection between the oesophagus and its duplicate portion was demonstrated by CT.     

The relationship between acute rejection and chronic rejection is highly dependent on specific MHC matching: a multi-strain rat heterotopic heart transplant study

BACKGROUND: The impact of acute rejection, immunosuppression, and infection, specifically cytomegalovirus infection, on the development of chronic rejection in the cardiac allograft, has been the subject of a large number of investigations. One of the difficulties in finding associations has been the marked immunologic heterogeneity of the patient population coupled with the lack of the ability to HLA match. Furthermore, the ideal animal model, which duplicates as well as controls for this immunologic heterogeneity, is lacking. METHODS: To try to simulate differences in HLA matching, immunosuppression regiments and cytomegalovirus infection, heterotopic heart transplantation was performed in two separate, complete MHC mismatch, rat strain combinations (WF-LEW, BN-LEW) requiring chronic immunosuppression and employing four separate immunosuppression/infection protocols. Animals were followed for 6 months, killed, and rejection and vascular changes were scored blinded to the group. RESULTS: The mean vascular and acute rejection scores were not significantly different between treatment regiments for either specific strain combination. There was a trend for the subtherapeutic groups to have higher vascular scores. Overall, there were no significant differences in vascular scores between the WF-LEW and BN-LEW groups (1.25+/-0.18 vs. 1.13+/-0.20, P=NS). Similar numbers of WF-LEW and BN-LEW exhibited cellular infiltration and necrosis of the allograft, but the intensity of the response (rejection score) was more severe in the WF-LEW combination (4.54+/-0.22 vs. 3.92+/-0.21, P=0.052) when limiting the analysis to those with myocyte necrosis. There was no significant correlation between acute rejection and vascular lesion severity in the WF-LEW combination (r=0.22, P=NS) but a high correlation between these parameters in the BN-LEW combination (r=0.74, P<0.0001). CONCLUSIONS: These data suggest that, although acute rejection and chronic rejection are related, MHC matching may influence their interdependence. These data also may explain why the clinical association between acute and chronic rejection is difficult to demonstrate.