Discussing options between patients and health care professionals in genetic diagnosis: ethical and legal criteria

The specific characteristics of genetic data lead to ethical-legal conflicts in the framework of genetic diagnosis. Several international organisations, including UNESCO and the Council of Europe, have enacted rules referring to the use of genetic information. This paper discusses possible legal and ethical criteria that could be used in genetic testing.     

Characterization of gp 50, a major glycoprotein present in rat brain synaptic membranes, with a monoclonal antibody

Several cell lines secreting monoclonal antibodies (Mabs) against a major forebrain synaptic membrane (SM) glycoprotein, gp 50, have been raised. Western blots show that the Mabs react with a polypeptide doublet of Mrs 49 and 45 kDa. These polypeptides exist solely in a concanavalin A (Con A) binding form. Removal of the Con A receptors by digestion with endo-beta-N-acetylglucosaminidase H (endo H) lowers the Mrs of the glycoprotein doublet to 36.5 and 34 kDa. Western blots of 2D polyacrylamide gels indicate that gp 50 exists in several isoforms. Solid phase radioimmunoassay (RIA) and Western blots of brain subcellular fractions show the antigenic material to be concentrated in the SM fraction, but to be present in much lower amounts in synaptic junctions and postsynaptic densities. Gp 50 appears to be brain specific. Regional distribution studies show that it is present in all brain regions but is two-fold concentrated in cerebellum, brainstem and midbrain compared to forebrain. Immunocytochemical studies of several brain regions show that gp 50-like immunoreactivity is neuron specific and is concentrated in selected neuronal species, particularly granule cells. In both cerebellar and hippocampal granule cells gp 50-like immunoreactivity is localized in the perikarya and primary dendrites. Though immunocytochemistry did not show staining of synaptic regions this may be due to masking of the reactive epitope. The results are discussed in terms of the molecular properties of gp 50 and its subcellular localization in brain tissue.     

Dysphagia aortica

Three patients with dysphagia caused by compression of the distal esophagus by a tortuous nonaneurysmal atherosclerotic aorta are described. All three patients were elderly women; systemic hypertension and cardiomegaly were present in two patients. Barium studies of the esophagus showed displacement and compression of the distal esophagus by the thoracic aorta. Debilitating dysphagia was treated surgically in one patient. The other two patients had milder symptoms and were managed conservatively. Esophageal manometry in these three patients showed superimposed pulsations and elevated intraluminal pressure just proximal to the lower esophageal sphincter. To evaluate the significance of these manometric findings and their correlation with clinical symptoms, we reviewed manometric tracings in 47 normal subjects. Ten of these subjects had an elevation of baseline intraluminal esophageal pressure as a result of superimposed vascular pulsations. We conclude that (1) compression of the distal esophagus by a tortuous atherosclerotic aorta in the appropriate setting can lead to clinically significant dysphagia and (2) a manometric finding of vascular compression of the esophagus does not necessarily correlate symptomatic dysphagia.     

Sleep in Pick disease

19 polygraphic sleep recordings from 12 patients with Pick's Disease, including four histologically proved cases, were compared to those of an age-matched control group. Symptoms had been present for a mean 8 years, the patients being aged 59 to 78 (mean 70.5 years). All sleep stages could be identified. Total sleep time was reduced and the number of awakenings was sharply increased. High proportion of stage 1 contrasted with the reduction in the other sleep stages with disappearance of stage 4 in advanced cases. REM Sleep was identified in all recordings, although reduced as a function of the length of the illness; its production as a function of total sleep time was not different from that of the control. REM Sleep appeared often fragmented and with a remarkably short latency, reminiscent of that observed in severely depressed patients.     

Organization of the trigeminal and facial motor nuclei in the hagfish, Eptatretus burgeri: a retrograde HRP study

We studied the trigeminal and facial motor nuclei of the hagfish by the retrograde HRP method. We distinguished 4 components in a single column of the motor nuclei of the trigeminal nerve and the facial nerve, viz., the pars magnocellularis of the trigeminal motor nucleus (mVm), the anterior part of the pars parvocellularis of the trigeminal motor nucleus (mVp1), the posterior part of the pars parvocellularis of the trigeminal motor nucleus (mVp2) and the facial motor nucleus (mVII). Although in Nissl preparations only the mVm could be distinguished from the rest of the nucleus, the boundaries of the other 3 components were clearly demarcated in HRP preparations. Intramuscular injections into two representative antagonistic jaw muscles revealed that there was no apparent topological organization of the neurons pertaining to the opening and closing muscles in the mVm and mVp1, but both antagonistic muscles were innervated bilaterally. Although the hagfish does possess a cartilaginous jaw, the organization pattern of the motor nuclei of the jaw muscles seems to be the most primitive of all living vertebrates.     

Constitutive and 3-methylcholanthrene-induced rat ALDH3A1 expression is mediated by multiple xenobiotic response elements.

The rat class 3 aldehyde dehydrogenase gene (ALDH3A1) is expressed constitutively or by xenobiotic induction depending on the tissue in which it occurs. Although the mechanism that mediates inducible expression has been well characterized, relatively little is known about constitutive regulatory mechanisms. Previous ALDH3A1 promoter analyses have indicated that primary regulatory regions within the ALDH3A1 5' flanking region exert similar effects on both constitutive and inducible ALDH3A1 expression. However, promoter gene analyses that served as the basis of early work were limited by the lack of sufficient 5' flanking region sequence. To gain a more complete picture of how the 5' flanking region regulates both modes of expression, we have subcloned an 8.0-kilobase (kb) fragment from the 5' flanking region of the ALDH3A1 gene and subjected it to reporter gene analyses. We found a region located between 4.8 and 7.8 kb upstream of the noncoding first exon that drives strong ALDH3A1 reporter activity. This region contains xenobiotic response element consensus sequences that mediate constitutive and inducible ALDH3A1 reporter gene expression. Using the new generation of ALDH3A1 reporter constructs, we were unable to confirm the presence of a negative regulatory region that was apparent in previous studies using a shorter fragment of the 5' flanking region. We also demonstrate that 3-methylcholanthrene induces ALDH3A1 expression above high constitutive background in corneal epithelial cells.     

Phase III study of interferon alfa-NL as adjuvant treatment for resectable renal cell carcinoma: an Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group/Intergroup trial.

PURPOSE: To evaluate the role of adjuvant interferon alfa after complete resection of locally extensive renal cell carcinoma. PATIENTS AND METHODS: A total of 283 eligible patients with pT3-4a and/or node-positive disease were randomly assigned after radical nephrectomy and lymphadenectomy to observation or to interferon alfa-NL (Wellferon, Burroughs-Wellcome, Research Park, NC) given daily for 5 days every 3 weeks for up to 12 cycles. Patients were stratified on the basis of pathologic stage. Patients remained on treatment until documented recurrence, excessive toxicity, or patient/physician preference deemed removal appropriate. RESULTS: At median follow-up of 10.4 years, median survival was 7.4 years in the observation arm and 5.1 year in the treatment arm (log-rank P =.09). Median recurrence-free survival was 3.0 years in the observation arm and 2.2 years in the interferon arm (P =.33). Performance status (P =.003), nodal status (N2 v N0, P <.0001), and tumor stage (P =.0002) were significant prognostic factors in multivariate analysis. A proportional hazards model examining the effects of treatment arm and time to recurrence on survival after recurrence among patients who recurred found that random assignment to interferon treatment (P =.009) and shorter time to recurrence (P <.0001) were independent predictors of shorter survival after recurrence. Although no lethal toxicities were observed, severe (grade 4) toxicities including neutropenia, myalgia, fatigue, depression, and other neurologic toxicities occurred in 11.4% of those randomly assigned to interferon treatment. CONCLUSION: Adjuvant treatment with interferon did not contribute to survival or relapse-free survival in this group of patients.