Nonrandomized comparison of open flank versus laparoscopic nephrectomy in 249 patients with benign renal disease

OBJECTIVES: We report the results from a nonrandomized comparison of open flank versus laparoscopic nephrectomy in patients with benign renal disease. METHODS: From January 1993 to December 1997, 249 nephrectomies for benign renal disease were performed at our institution. There were 118 patients in the open flank nephrectomy group (median age 58.5, range 8-89 years) and 131 patients in the laparoscopic nephrectomy group (median age 40, range 16-73 years). Clinical parameters such as operative times, blood loss, transfusion rates, conversion and complication rates, start of oral intake, analgesic consumption, duration of hospitalization and convalescence and short-term mortality were compared among both groups. RESULTS: Median operative time in the open flank nephrectomy group was 90 (range 30-240) min and also 90 (range 41-210) min in the laparoscopic nephrectomy group. In the laparoscopy group 8 patients were converted to open surgery (6.1%). There were 27 complications (20.6%) in the laparoscopic nephrectomy group compared to 30 complications (25.4%) in the open flank nephrectomy group. Postoperatively, patients in the laparoscopic nephrectomy group required less morphine sulfate equivalent (12 vs. 20 mg) for pain control and they had a shorter hospital stay (4 vs. 10 days) and convalescence (24 vs. 36 days). The postoperative parameters are given as medians and reached statistically significant differences in favor of laparoscopic nephrectomy. CONCLUSIONS: Laparoscopic nephrectomy results in a significantly briefer postoperative course when compared to open flank nephrectomy. As a matter of fact laparoscopy in urology is still a center-related procedure and even in these centers only a minority of urologists practice laparoscopy. However, in experienced centers the laparoscopic technique should be offered to patients with benign renal disease who are scheduled for elective nephrectomy.     

Short and long-term morbidity of thoracoabdominal incision for nephrectomy: a comparison with the flank approach

PURPOSE: A thoracoabdominal incision provides optimal exposure for radical nephrectomy, especially for large tumors. Intuitively it is perceived that the morbidity of a thoracoabdominal incision far exceeds that of a flank incision. We compare the morbidity of thoracoabdominal and flank incisions, which to our knowledge has not been reported previously. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A questionnaire assessing postoperative pain, use of pain medications and return to activities was sent to the last 100 renal donors who underwent nephrectomy at our institution through the 11th rib (flank incision, group 1) and the last 100 patients who underwent radical nephrectomy through the 8th to 10th rib (thoracoabdominal incision, group 2). A total of 52 group 1 and 42 group 2 questionnaires were returned. Pain was assessed at 4 periods using a visual analog scale. RESULTS: Length of stay was the same in both groups. There were no differences between groups in terms of pain severity on postoperative day 1, on day of discharge home, 1 month postoperatively and at the time of study (p >0.05). There were no significant differences between groups in times following surgery when pain completely disappeared, when pain medications were discontinued, and when the patient returned to daily activities and work (p >0.05). CONCLUSIONS: Morbidity was comparable for thoracoabdominal and flank incisions in terms of incisional pain, analgesic requirements after discharge home and return to normal activities.     

Hand-assisted laparoscopic vs the open (flank incision) approach to radical nephrectomy

OBJECTIVE: To compare the outcome in contemporaneous groups of patients undergoing hand-assisted laparoscopic radical nephrectomy (HALRN) or open (flank) radical nephrectomy (ORN), as many series worldwide have confirmed the feasibility and advantages of LRN in managing renal cell carcinoma (RCC). PATIENTS AND METHODS: We retrospectively evaluated 44 patients who underwent radical nephrectomy for RCC from 1999 to 2001, 22 by HALRN and 22 by ORN, through an extraperitoneal 11th or 12th rib flank incision. Standard perioperative variables were assessed; a validated questionnaire was also sent to each patient after surgery, allowing them to report their overall satisfaction and the period needed for them to return to both routine and full activities. The outcomes of HALRN and ORN were compared using Wilcoxon rank-sum analysis. RESULTS: There was a statistically significant difference between HALRN and ORN in operative duration, length of hospital stay, total narcotic requirement, pain scores at 1 week and 1 month after surgery, and the time to resume routine and full activity, with all variables (except operative duration) lower in the HALRN group. There were no significant differences between the groups in pain at 1-3 days, estimated blood loss or overall satisfaction. CONCLUSION: Compared with ORN, HALRN is associated with lower narcotic requirement, pain scores, a shorter hospital stay and earlier resumption of routine and full activities. However, several obstacles remain, including increased operative duration and the increased equipment costs.     

腹壁膨出的临床分型与治疗策略选择

腹壁膨出在临床工作中并非罕见,但时常与腹壁切口疝、腰疝等混肴。其是由于腹壁肌筋膜组织的松弛、薄弱甚至缺失导致腹腔内容物向外突出所致。本文将从腹壁膨出的病因,并根据腹壁缺失薄弱大小加以分型,并在此多年临床经验基础上制定诊疗方案提高腹壁膨出的认识及改进治疗效果。     

The less incisional retroperitoneal approach for abdominal aortic aneurysm repair to prevent postoperative flank bulge

One of the postoperative complications of retroperitoneal incision is a flank bulge that is suggested to be caused by 11th intercostal nerve injury leading to denervation of the ipsilateral muscles. To avoid this complication, we have tried to minimize retroperitoneal incision for abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) repair. The feasibility of the less incisional retroperitoneal approach for the repair of AAA to prevent postoperative flank bulge was investigated. Twenty-seven patients undergoing elective repair for infrarenal AAA through the left retroperitoneal approach were divided into group-L (less incision: 11.9+/-1.8 cm, n = 7) and group-C (conventional incision: 17.8+/-1.9 cm, n = 20). All operations were performed by a traditional hand-sewn anastomosis without laparoscopic support. Five bifurcated grafts were used in group-L and 15 in group-C. The postoperative course of all patients was uneventful except that one patient in group-C required reoperation for bleeding. Intraoperative parameters of both groups were almost comparable. All patients in group-L were extubated in the operating theater, whereas it was possible only for 11 patients in group-C. Resumption of alimentation was significantly earlier in group-L (P = 0.0117). There was no significant difference in postoperative hospital stay between groups. No late flank bulge was experienced. Significant late atrophy of the left rectus muscle (left/right thickness-ratio = 0.59+/-0.24) was seen in group-C (P = 0.0042 vs preoperative value), which was not observed in group-L (P = 0.0008 between groups). The less incisional retroperitoneal AAA repair seems feasible and safety technique that might prevent postoperative flank bulge and reduce surgical stress.     

Laparoscopic vs. open nephrectomy. 10 years' results of a nonrandomized comparative study of 549 patients with benign kidney diseases

We report the results from a nonrandomized comparison of open flank vs laparoscopic nephrectomy in patients with benign renal disease. Between 1993 and 2002, 549 nephrectomies for benign renal disease were performed at the Department of Urology of the Medical University of Lübeck and the Urological Department of the Martin Luther University in Halle/Wittenberg. There were 236 patients in the open flank nephrectomy group and 313 patients in the laparoscopic nephrectomy group. Clinical parameters were compared among both groups. Median operative time in the open flank nephrectomy group was 90 min (range: 30-240 min) and also 90 min in the laparoscopic nephrectomy group (range: 41-210 min). There were 54 complications (17.2%) in the laparoscopic nephrectomy group compared to 60 complications (25.4%) in the open flank nephrectomy group. Patients in the laparoscopy group demonstrated clear advantages in terms of analgesic use for pain control, hospital stay, and convalescence. Laparoscopic nephrectomy results in a significantly briefer postoperative course when compared to open flank nephrectomy. However, due to a limited number of patients, a laparoscopic nephrectomy is mainly reserved for laparoscopic centers. Nevertheless, the laparoscopic approach should be offered to the majority of patients with benign renal disease requiring nephrectomy.     

Intercostal nerve block with thoracoabdominal and flank incisions

A double-blind study was done in 90 patients undergoing a rib-resecting thoraco-abdominal incision for testicular cancer or a flank incision for renal surgery to determine the effect of intraoperative intercostal nerve block with bupivacaine hydrochloride on postoperative pain and complications, day of ambulation, and day of oral fluid intake. In the patients treated with bupivacaine, we found a significant reduction in the amount of postoperative analgesia required, but no difference in the day of ambulation or fluid intake. Ten of 45 patients given a placebo nerve block experienced postoperative atelectasis, whereas only 4 of 45 patients in the treated group experienced this complication. We believe that intercostal nerve block is a valuable postoperative adjuvant in patients undergoing flank surgery to reduce the postoperative analgesic requirements and incidence of atelectasis.     

Keeping up with the Jones's: open donor nephrectomy in the laparoscopic era

Several new approaches have been developed to perform donor nephrectomy. These include laparoscopic donor nephrectomy and open donor nephrectomy performed through small incisions, herein referred to as "mini-open donor nephrectomy". In the past, we performed open donor nephrectomy via a standard flank incision. In October 2002, we introduced mini-open donor nephrectomy via an anterior, retroperitoneal approach. Contemporaneously, we offered the option of laparoscopic donor nephrectomy. Herein, we review our single-center experience with these three techniques. Mini-open donor nephrectomy was comparable to the laparoscopic approach for duration of narcotic requirement and donor length of stay. The laparoscopic procedure was more expensive. Both procedures demonstrated improvement over the flank approach by eliminating the risk of pneumothorax, neuropathy, and flank bulge. In addition, length of stay and narcotic requirements were higher with the flank approach. Mini-open donor nephrectomy provides a good alternative to laparoscopic surgery, offering the donor an equivalent convalescence at lower cost and potentially with reduced morbidity.     

多用途的髂嵴上纵切口在后腹腔镜下肾及肾上腺手术中的应用

目的:探讨髂嵴上纵切口在后腹腔镜泌尿外科手术中的应用优势及推广.方法:选择2015年5月-2017年10月在我院采用三通道后腹腔镜途径治疗的肾上腺肿瘤及肾肿瘤患者159例,其中采用传统切口组72例,改良切口组87例,比较两组患者在取标本时间、切口长度(切口长度之和)、切口疼痛评分、切口并发症、下床活动时间、切口疝的发生...     

Laparoscopic cytoreductive nephrectomy as preparation for administration of systemic interleukin-2 in the treatment of metastatic renal cell carcinoma: a pilot study

OBJECTIVES: Cytoreductive nephrectomy is commonly performed in patients with metastatic renal cell carcinoma before systemic interleukin-2 (IL-2) therapy. Open nephrectomy is associated with prolonged recovery during which metastatic disease can progress. The feasibility of laparoscopic cytoreductive surgery in these patients with large renal tumors was examined. The role of tumor morcellation in reducing the recovery period and allowing earlier treatment with IL-2 was investigated. METHODS: Patients with metastatic renal cancer underwent either open nephrectomy (group 1, n = 19) or laparoscopic cytoreductive nephrectomy (n = 11; 6 with tumor morcellation [group 2], 5 with removal of the tumor through a small incision [group 3]). The three groups were compared to evaluate relative recovery, suitability for treatment with IL-2, and laparoscopic port site seeding. RESULTS: A group of 19 patients underwent open nephrectomy (group 1). Eleven patients with a median tumor volume of 377 cm3 (median tumor diameter 9 cm) underwent laparoscopic cytoreductive nephrectomy. Six of these patients underwent tumor morcellation (group 2) and 5 underwent laparoscopic assisted nephrectomy (group 3). There was no difference in patient age, sex, sites of metastatic disease, ECOG status, size of renal tumor, or surgical complication rates among groups. Patients whose tumor was morcellated had reduced postoperative parenteral narcotic requirements and were discharged sooner than patients undergoing open cytoreductive nephrectomy. Time to treatment with IL-2 was shortest in the morcellation group (median time to treatment 37 days). No port site seeding was observed. CONCLUSIONS: Laparoscopic cytoreductive nephrectomy in patients with bulky renal disease is a safe procedure in selected patients. This pilot study demonstrated a significant association of laparoscopic tumor morcellation with less postoperative pain, faster time to discharge, and shorter time to treatment with IL-2. A randomized study is warranted to determine the role of laparoscopic cytoreductive nephrectomy with tumor morcellation.     

Comparison of lumbar flank approach and transperitoneal approach for radical nephrectomy

A retrospective analysis based on Robson's tumor stage classification was performed on 56 patients with renal cell carcinoma who had undergone radical nephrectomy through a lumbar flank approach and 35 who had through a transperitoneal approach. The 5-year survival rates of patients with nephrectomy through the lumbar approach for Robson's stage 1, stage 2 and stage 3 were, respectively, 93.1, 70.4 and 60.0%. In comparison, the respective 5-year survival rates of patients with nephrectomy through the transperitoneal approach for Robson's stage 1, stage 2 and stage 3 were 90.5, 72.2 and 25.0%. As a result, there was no significant difference in survival rates between the two surgical procedures for any of the three Robson's stages. It is further suggested that the lumbar flank approach for radical nephrectomy does not result in poorer prognosis than does the transperitoneal approach, though transperitoneal and thoracoabdominal approaches have been generally recommended.     

Preoperative and Intraoperative Determinants of Incisional Bulge following Retroperitoneal Aortic Repair

Although the left flank retroperitoneal incision is a useful approach for many patients undergoing major aortic reconstruction for aneurysmal and occlusive disease, it has been associated with weakening of the flank muscles, resulting in bulges varying from slight asymmetry to huge hernias. The purpose of this study was to determine if the incidence of this complication correlated with identifiable preoperative or intraoperative factors. Fifty consecutive patients undergoing aortic reconstruction via the retroperitoneal approach were followed for 1 year postoperatively for evidence of disfiguring bulges. Bulges were scored as follows: normal/mild, <1-inch protrusion; moderate, protrusion 1-2 inches; severe, protrusion >2 inches and/or pain or true herniation. Preoperatively, patients were administered a questionnaire to elicit demographic and comorbidity data. Fifty-six percent of patients developed a bulge at 1 year. In 43% of these, the bulge was deemed mild and in 54% moderate. One patient developed a severe bulge. Among preoperative comorbidities, no statistically significant correlations were found on bivariate analysis. However, likelihood ratios for bulge development of 5.5 for renal disease and 3.1 for cancer were demonstrated. Conversely, peripheral vascular disease had a likelihood ratio of 0.21 for bulge formation and emphysema, 0.28. On logistic analysis, incision >15 cm and body mass index (BMI) >23 mg/kg² were found to correlate strongly with bulge formation (p = 0.003, odds ratio = 9.1, and p = 0.018, odds ratio = 16.9, respectively). Together, these yielded a pseudo r ² of 0.32. BMI >23 mg/kg² was found to yield the greatest explanatory power. These same two variables were found to correlate with severity of bulge: p = 0.02 for incision >15 cm and p = 0.006 for BMI >23. Of note, gender, age, and extension of the incision into the interspace were not significant on logistic analysis. Preoperatively, surgeons should warn obese patients and those requiring large incisions for extensive disease of their increased risk for poor healing. Intraoperatively, surgeons should aim to minimize incision length.     

Mini-flank supra-11th rib incision for open partial or radical nephrectomy

OBJECTIVE: To report our approach to partial (PN) or radical nephrectomy (RN) using a supra-11th mini-flank incision, as the widespread availability of advanced imaging has increased the detection of incidental, lower-stage renal tumours that are generally amenable to resection using smaller incisions. PATIENTS AND METHODS: The study included 167 consecutive patients undergoing PN/RN for renal tumours treated between February 2000 and March 2003 using the supra-11th rib mini-flank approach. Variables analysed were age, gender, nephrectomy type (PN vs RN), operative duration, estimated blood loss (EBL), hospital stay, tumour size and location, pathological stage and histology, perioperative transfusions, and complications. Patients undergoing PN were examined for ischaemia type (cold, warm, none) and duration of renal artery clamping. The interval after surgery to initiate solid diet and discontinue patient-controlled analgesia, and overall pain control, were analysed and compared between PN and RN. RESULTS: In all, 133 patients (80%) underwent PN and 34 (20%) RN, at a median age of 61.7 years. The median operative duration was 2.9 h, the EBL 400 mL, tumour size 3.2 cm and median hospital stay 5 days. At a median follow-up of 18.2 months, there were seven (4%) late complications: six patients had a flank bulge and one had a reducible hernia. Surgical margins were negative in 164 (98%) patients. CONCLUSIONS: The supra-11th rib mini-flank incision offers a practical alternative to traditional open or laparoscopic PN or RN. Using a small (8 cm) incision with no rib resection, this approach affords optimum exposure without compromising cancer control, with excellent cosmetic results and a lower risk of late complications at the wound site.     

Incidence,etiology, management,and outcomes of flank hernia: review of published data

Purpose

To review the published data describing the incidence, etiology, management, and outcomes of flank hernia.

Methods

A retrospective review of articles identified with an online search (using the terms “flank hernia”, “flank bulge”, “lateral hernia”, “retroperitoneal aorta hernia”, and “open radical nephrectomy”) was performed. Studies exclusively on lumbar hernia or subcostal hernia were excluded.

Results

All articles retained for analysis (N = 26) were uncontrolled series or case reports; there were no controlled trials. The incidence of incisional hernia in the flank was ~ 17% (total patients analyzed = 1,061). Flank hernia repair was accomplished successfully with a variety of techniques, with overall mean rates of perioperative complications, chronic post-procedure pain, and recurrence equal to 20, 11, and 7%, respectively. Mesh utilization was universal.

Conclusions

The available data of outcomes of flank hernia repair are not of high quality, and recommendations essentially consist of expert opinions. Operative approach (open vs. laparoscopic) and mesh insertion details have varied, but reasonable results appear possible with a number of techniques.

     

Comparison of 1,800 laparoscopic and open partial nephrectomies for single renal tumors

PURPOSE: Laparoscopic partial nephrectomy is an increasingly performed, minimally invasive alternative to open partial nephrectomy. We compared early postoperative outcomes in 1,800 patients undergoing open partial nephrectomy by experienced surgeons with the initial experience with laparoscopic partial nephrectomy in patients with a single renal tumor 7 cm or less. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Data on 1,800 consecutive open or laparoscopic partial nephrectomies were collected prospectively or retrospectively in tumor registries at 3 large referral centers. Demographic, intraoperative, postoperative and followup data were compared between the 2 groups. RESULTS: Compared to the laparoscopic partial nephrectomy group of 771 patients the 1,028 undergoing open partial nephrectomy were a higher risk group with a greater percent presenting symptomatically with decreased performance status, impaired renal function and tumor in a solitary functioning kidney (p<0.0001). More tumors in the open partial nephrectomy group were more than 4 cm and centrally located and more proved to be malignant (p<0.0001 and 0.0003, respectively). Based on multivariate analysis laparoscopic partial nephrectomy was associated with shorter operative time (p<0.0001), decreased operative blood loss (p<0.0001) and shorter hospital stay (p<0.0001). The chance of intraoperative complications was comparable in the 2 groups. However, laparoscopic partial nephrectomy was associated with longer ischemia time (p<0.0001), more postoperative complications, particularly urological (p<0.0001), and an increased number of subsequent procedures (p<0.0001). Renal functional outcomes were similar 3 months after laparoscopic and open partial nephrectomy with 97.9% and 99.6% of renal units retaining function, respectively. Three-year cancer specific survival for patients with a single cT1N0M0 renal cell carcinoma was 99.3% and 99.2% after laparoscopic and open partial nephrectomy, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Early experience with laparoscopic partial nephrectomy is promising. Laparoscopic partial nephrectomy offered the advantages of less operative time, decreased operative blood loss and a shorter hospital stay. When applied to patients with a single renal tumor 7 cm or less, laparoscopic partial nephrectomy was associated with additional postoperative morbidity compared to open partial nephrectomy. However, equivalent functional and early oncological outcomes were achieved.     

Hand-assisted laparoscopic nephrectomy for xanthogranulomatous pyelonephritis with nephrocutaneous fistula after failed flank exploration

Xanthogranulomatous pyelonephritis presenting with nephrocutaneous fistula is a rare condition, and its treatment of choice is nephrectomy. Laparoscopic management has been proved to be challenging in these inflammatory renal conditions. However, there was no previous report in the literature regarding laparoscopic treatment of nephrocutaneous fistula especially after previous operation. In this communication, we report the first case of hand-assisted laparoscopic nephrectomy for xanthogranulomatous pyelonephritis with nephrocutaneous fistula after previous failed flank exploration.     

Two cases of renal angiomyolipoma

Two cases of renal angiomyolipoma without tuberous sclerosis are reported. The first case was of a 35-year-old man with complaints of right upper abdominal and right flank pain. Preoperative diagnosis was right renal angiomyolipoma. Thoracoabdominal radical nephrectomy and lymphadenectomy were performed. The pathological diagnosis was renal angiomyolipoma with lymph node involvement. The second case was of a 46-year-old woman whose left renal mass had been accidentally found by ultrasound study. Preoperative diagnosis was left renal angiomyolipoma. This tumor was enucleated from the left kidney through flank incision.     

Donor nephrectomy in the era of hand-assisted laparoscopic urologic surgery

Living-donor nephrectomy has traditionally been performed through a flank incision with or without rib resection or by an anterior extraperitoneal incision, both of which reduce the willingness of potential donors to undergo the procedure. The first successful human laparoscopic donor nephrectomy was reported in 1995. In order to reduce warm ischemia and operative time and to make the operation safer and easier, some laparoscopic surgeons have used hand assistance. The authors describe their technique for this operation and review the results.     

Renal artery pseudoaneurysm after laparoscopic partial nephrectomy

Delayed bleeding from a renal artery pseudoaneurysm is a rare occurrence after partial nephrectomy. We present 2 cases of renal artery pseudoaneurysm after laparoscopic partial nephrectomy. One patient presented with gross hematuria and flank pain and the other presented with flank pain and a decreasing hematocrit. The patients were treated with selective angioembolization of the pseudoaneurysm. The etiology and management of this potentially life-threatening condition are discussed.