首页 | 本学科首页   官方微博 | 高级检索  
相似文献
 共查询到20条相似文献,搜索用时 375 毫秒
1.
The hospital autopsy rate in Japan dropped from 63.5 per cent in 1972 to 20.9 per cent in 1995. This reduction is attributable to declining interest by clinicians, surgeons and pathologists. The decline is a very serious problem, because the autopsy contributes to what has been called "quality control" of medical care. However, the method of autopsy should change along with advances in diagnostic technology or various changes in the circumstances surrounding medical practice. The most important problem at present is that autopsies require both time and effort. Delayed autopsy reports by pathologists may result in declined interest by clinicians and thus limit the benefits. To shorten the time delay for autopsy reports, clinicians must clarify their clinical questions concerning the deceased patient so that pathologists can readily identify the patients' problems and determine the causes more promptly, clearly and diplomatically. Other suggestions for improvement include the following: the reports should be simpler; the concept that all autopsies must be complete should be eliminated; a hospital accreditor must emphasize that clinicians intend to gain more precise diagnoses by obtaining post-mortem tissues of various organs using biopsy instruments. In addition, communication between pathologists and clinicians must be active to determine the pathogenesis of disease.  相似文献   

2.
The attitudes of 205 consultant British pathologists in four regions were assessed by a postal questionnaire in which they were asked to indicate their level of agreement with 15 statements relating to autopsies. A total of 144 pathologists completed the questionnaire (response rate 70 per cent). Senior pathologists strongly agreed with statements relating to the importance of autopsies within pathology workloads, medical audit, and accreditation for training posts. There was strong support for the attendance of clinicians at autopsy demonstrations and for the suggestion that material from medico-legal autopsies should be made available for teaching and research. There was strong disagreement with the suggestions that advances in diagnostic techniques have diminished the role of autopsies, that performing autopsies does not further pathologists' education, that the cost of autopsies may not be justifiable within a limited budget, and that the autopsy should no longer be part of the MRCPath examination. These results are discussed in the context of the current status of the autopsy in general.  相似文献   

3.
The autopsy as a performance measure and teaching tool   总被引:1,自引:0,他引:1  
A survey of pathology training programs about current operations and attitudes revealed that the autopsy is underused in medical student and pathology resident teaching, is inadequately reported, often does not have a dedicated faculty, is not championed by pathologists or clinicians, is not valued as a performance measure, and is barely used as a resource for medical research. The autopsy can be reestablished as a teaching tool and performance measure, but this will require that the autopsy be recognized as a credible and valuable medical procedure. The autopsy must then be funded; and new sources of both volume and funding, such as incorporating autopsies into payment schedules, into clinical trials, and in pay-for-performance initiatives, must be solicited. Once there is reimbursement for autopsies, pathologists, clinicians, and health care administrators will embrace the autopsy as a new source of revenue and as a valid measure of physician, hospital, and health system performance. Pathologists and the pathology specialty societies must take the lead in the reestablishment of the autopsy and must, at the same time, encourage innovations such as centralization, greater use of Pathology Assistants, and application of molecular techniques. New tools for using the autopsy in medical student teaching should be embraced, and the role of the autopsy in pathology residency programs must be reevaluated.  相似文献   

4.
The national decline in hospital autopsy cases negatively impacts physician education and medical quality control to an unknown degree. The current non-medicolegal autopsy rate is less than 5% of hospital deaths. This study compares internal medicine and pathology resident physician perceptions of the autopsy, including the importance, procurement, technique, and the pathologist-internist interaction. An 84-item survey based on autopsy literature was designed, piloted, and distributed to 214 residents at a single 800+ bed tertiary care academic teaching hospital (Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston) to accomplish this goal. Completed surveys were obtained from 72% of medicine (n = 118) and 84% of pathology (n = 42) residents. Residents strongly agree on the importance of autopsies for education, answering clinical questions, public health, and research. Autopsy rates are deemed inadequate. Internists are comfortable requesting autopsies, but report insufficient guidance and difficulty with answering technical questions. Although not requested on all hospital deaths, internists are more likely to initiate an autopsy request than a decedent's family, and worry significantly less about institutional costs and malpractice litigation than pathologists believe. Internists expressed interest in having an instructional brochure to give families, observing an autopsy, and having increased communication and support with autopsies from pathology residents. The main reasons why autopsy consent is not requested (it is unpleasant, cause of death is known, family is upset or seems unwilling) and why families refuse (patient has suffered enough, body may be handled disrespectfully, religious/moral objections, lack information) were similar for both resident groups. Despite their decline, autopsies still remain important to medicine as indicated by internal medicine and pathology residents at a large academic center. Improving autopsy education, enhancing availability of resources, and strengthening the pathologist-internist collaboration may serve to heighten awareness and ultimately procurement.  相似文献   

5.
The autopsy: A useful tool or an old relic?   总被引:8,自引:0,他引:8  
In a combined retrospective and prospective study, clinical and autopsy data were collected to assess the changes in autopsy rate in recent years, the attitudes of clinicians and pathologists to the autopsy, and the accuracy of ante-mortem diagnosis when compared with autopsy findings. Between 1962 and 1986, the total autopsy rate for hospital patients remained relatively constant, with an increase in Coroner's and a decrease in the hospital autopsy rate. Analysis of 5064 deaths over a 6-year period showed a significantly greater number of males than females coming to autopsy and a decrease in autopsy rate with age for both sexes. Attitudes to the autopsy were assessed using a questionnaire. The majority of clinicians considered the autopsy to be an important investigation despite new diagnostic techniques and confirmed its value in teaching and research. Seventy-seven per cent agreed that autopsy findings occasionally led to modification of the treatment of subsequent patients with the same condition. Pathologists disagreed that the autopsy is outdated in its present form and considered that not enough hospital autopsies are being requested. They also upheld its use and value in education. The cause of death as given by clinicians for a group of 60 patients was inaccurate in 12 cases.  相似文献   

6.
In the light of medical audit, all pathology departments are scrutinizing their hospital autopsy rate. In most countries, the rate has fallen over the last few decades to between 10 and 20 per cent. However, it is still possible to achieve a much higher rate. We compare two neighbouring District General Hospitals (DGHs): Northampton, with the more usual autopsy rate of 11 per cent, and Kettering, with a higher rate of 40-50 per cent. These hospitals are comparable in almost every way except for the system used to request permission for an autopsy. These differences were evaluated and the following factors were found to be of importance in achieving a high rate: (1) centralization of death certificates within the mortuary and personal contact between the certifying doctor and the relatives within the bereavement room; (2) mortuary pathology technicians are designated as bereavement officers and act as coordinators between relatives, clinicians, and pathologists; and (3) regular clinico-pathological meetings and a positive attitude to autopsies by clinicians.  相似文献   

7.
CONTEXT: Autopsy rates have been declining throughout the world, although preservation of the autopsy is considered a fundamental principle of medical care. In France, the 1994 bioethics law requires physicians to inform relatives before performing an autopsy. OBJECTIVE: To analyze the following factors that potentially influence hospital autopsy rates: legal constraints, autopsy reporting times, opinions of physicians requesting autopsies and pathologists regarding the usefulness of autopsy in patient care, and use of autopsy material in research publications. DESIGN: Record of the annual numbers of deaths and autopsies during a 10-year period (1988-1997). Record of the delays for transmission of final autopsy report to the requesting physician. Questionnaire analyzing the possible factors influencing autopsy rate. Categorization of articles published by pathologists according to the use of autopsy material. SETTING: A 1000-bed, university teaching hospital in the Paris, France, area. PARTICIPANTS: Questionnaire addressed to physicians, head nurses, and mortuary staff. RESULTS: A total of 1454 autopsies were reviewed. The autopsy rate declined from 15.4% in 1988 to 3.7% in 1997. This decline was marked after 1994 and tended to be slower for neurologic indications than for other indications. The final report had not been communicated within 180 days in 620 (42.6%) of 1454 autopsies. Fifty-five of 105 respondents considered that the bioethics law was one cause of the recent decrease of autopsy rate. Considering the contribution of autopsy to medical research, 94 (81%) of 116 articles dealing with central nervous system but only 28 (6%) of 464 articles dealing with other organs used autopsy-derived material. CONCLUSIONS: The 1994 bioethics law seems to contribute to the decline of autopsy. Inadequate delays for communicating autopsy results are frequent. Except for neuropathologists, autopsy is a minor source of research material.  相似文献   

8.
In an attempt to better understand the basis and significance of an annual autopsy rate consistently over 45% for the past decade, we recently investigated the attitudes and practices of 36 pathologists and 176 clinicians in our institution with respect to the function of the autopsy service and the utility of the autopsy. The autopsy report was "not used in a consistent manner" by 57% of clinical respondents. Several clinicians thought that autopsy reports were too long (20%) and too slow (38%), but not with the frequency that pathologists did, 73% and 58%, respectively. Significantly more pathologists than clinicians believed autopsy rates have fallen over the past 20 years because (1) people think that everything about the deceased is already known, (2) medical students are poorly educated about the autopsy, (3) pathologists have diminished interest, (4) physicians fear litigation, (5) physicians fear "being wrong," (6) pathologists lack financial incentives, and (7) Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations requirement is not in place. Perceptions regarding the frequency of major discrepancies between clinical and autopsy findings were comparable, 17% and 13%, for pathologists and clinicians, respectively. Our "high" institutional autopsy rate does not reflect concordance of perceptions expressed by clinicians and pathologists and, thus, other factors may be important in the maintenance of an acceptable rate.  相似文献   

9.
J Sidorov 《Academic medicine》1990,65(10):647-649
The impact that a 50-minute lecture on the value of the autopsy had on the subsequent obtaining of autopsies by housestaff training in internal medicine at a teaching hospital was examined in a prospective one-year clinical trial from mid-1987 to mid-1988. The group that attended the lecture (n = 27) did not subsequently obtain a greater mean number or frequency of permissions for autopsies than did the control group (n = 26), whose members did not attend, and did not indicate more frequently in the patients' charts that autopsies had been sought. In addition, in the total group of 53 housestaff, five (9.4%) did not write a pronunciation-of-death entry, and 26 (49%) did not obtain permission for a single autopsy during the study period. Future efforts to enhance the appreciation for the autopsy among physicians in training may need to use more sophisticated techniques than a lecture in order to increase housestaff motivation to obtain consent for autopsies.  相似文献   

10.
The protocols of 2,145 autopsies were retrospectively reviewed and the findings compared with the clinical diagnoses. A sudden decline in the autopsy rate that occurred during the period studied was followed by a highly statistically significant difference in clinical accuracy (P less than 0.01), in favor of the predecline period. The overall rate of major discrepancies was 29 per cent. The most frequently missed diagnoses were infections, which were found in 26 per cent of all autopsies and had not been diagnosed clinically in 63 per cent of these cases. Malignancies occupied second place among overlooked diagnoses in the selected disease categories; in 99 per cent of the cases the malignancy was the principal diagnosis, and it had been misdiagnosed clinically in 42 per cent of these cases. Cerebrovascular disorders were correctly diagnosed in most cases (87 per cent of the patients in this group). Among autopsy diagnoses labeled as the immediate causes of death, the most frequently overlooked were pulmonary embolism and gastrointestinal hemorrhage, which were not recognized in 84 and 78 per cent, respectively. In cases in which clinicians were not entirely confident in their impressions, their diagnoses were usually confirmed at autopsy. In these cases 15 per cent of the patients died soon after admission to the hospital, with accurate diagnoses in 71 per cent. The discrepancies disclosed should be regarded as sufficiently large to mandate continued emphasis on autopsy evaluation as the basis for the control of the quality of patient care.  相似文献   

11.
CONTEXT: We studied 99 appellate court records in cases of alleged medical malpractice and found no relationship between discrepant clinical and autopsy findings and outcome of litigation. Standard-of-care issues and not diagnostic accuracy were at the heart of every case. OBJECTIVE: To characterize and discuss issues related to the autopsy and/or pathologist behavior that were raised in court records of medical malpractice litigation. DESIGN: In 18 appellate court records, issues were raised about quality of autopsy performance and reporting or about death certification. The details of these controversies are succinctly reported here in a manner intended to be instructive to pathologists who perform autopsies in a hospital setting or on a private fee-for-service basis. CONCLUSION: Autopsy reports are intended to provide objective medical information in a coherent format to the patient's medical record, to the attending physician and other concerned staff physicians, to other health care professionals, and to the families of the deceased. Inevitably, occasions arise that require legal counsel to be added to this list of parties with a legitimate interest. Our findings emphasize that incomplete, incoherent, obfuscated, or delayed reporting of autopsy findings do not meet professional standards, are unethical if intentional, and may be counterproductive.  相似文献   

12.
Considerable disparity exists from area to area in the United States in the quality of medicolegal investigation. Much of this type of investigation in this country is still conducted by physicians in general practice, who possess neither specialized medicolegal training nor experience. Forensic autopsies are being performed mostly by hospital pathologists without forensic expertise, who conduct these autopsies in their spare time or as a paid hobby. This article provides guidelines for improved medicolegal investigation and formulation of autopsy reports, including opinions, which have been found to be advantageous in a medicolegal setting of a major metropolitan area and are, in my opinion, also applicable to smaller, even rural, types of jurisdiction.  相似文献   

13.
The Accreditation Committee on Graduate Medical Education requires both sufficient volume and variety of necropsy material for training in anatomic pathology. Since the number of autopsies has declined markedly in the last 20 years, the author sought to determine whether the variety of case material available from the autopsies performed at his teaching hospital had changed during that time span. Major diagnoses were abstracted from the reports of 200 autopsies of adults performed in 1968 and from a period 20 years later (1987, 1988, and part of 1989). Comparison between the two eras' diagnoses revealed very few changes in the incidences of various diseases. This was true even though the racial mix of patients had changed markedly. While declining autopsy rates are of concern, this study suggests that medical educators may not need to be concerned over the variety of autopsy case material. The author makes several suggestions for maximizing the teaching impact of each autopsy.  相似文献   

14.
Scientific Societies of Pathologists from Socialist countries held three symposia to analyse recent developments and future trends in pathology. The author presents his state-of-the-art review at the third symposium (Berlin, 1987) based on international literature data and first-hand experience gained in the field of pathology for the last decades. Some negative tendencies are considered. It is stated, in particular, that the percentage of autopsies performed in those who died at hospitals and at home continues to decrease due to fading interest to autopsy results both from physicians and medical authorities. This can entail growing number of misdiagnoses, unassessed quality of medical aid in complicated cases, biased statistics, undetected infection during life, defects in medical training. Tendencies and tasks facing histopathology and cytological diagnosis are determined as follows: 1) purpose-specific introduction of new techniques and equipment 2) active promotion of interdisciplinary task-force groups of clinicians, pathologists, roentgenologists, etc. to verify diagnosis and develop new techniques 3) establishment of special reference centres 4) overall computerization 5) urgent need in additional skilled staff to satisfy growing technical requirements of molecular biology, genetics and tissue culture. Current research on pathology is believed unsatisfactory. The role of experimental pathology is underestimated. To improve the situation in fundamental pathological research, the author suggests large-scale perestroika involving additional investments and human resources, active participation of scientists, clinical pathologists and medical authorities.  相似文献   

15.
OBJECTIVES: To document the level of involvement and communication with nonpathology clinical personnel regarding autopsies and to document the destination of autopsy reports. DESIGN: The College of American Pathologists Q-Probes format was used to collect information on 15 consecutively performed autopsies per institution or for 6 months, whichever occurred first. The following information was recorded for each autopsy: decedent's age, hospital service, length of hospital stay, whether organs were donated, who was present at autopsy, methods of communicating preliminary and final autopsy results, special techniques used to arrive at a preliminary diagnosis, activities for which the autopsy was used, and destination of final report. PARTICIPANTS: Two hundred fifty-six laboratories collected information on 2755 autopsies. RESULTS: The aggregate autopsy rate was 12.4% (median 8.5%). Nonpathology clinical personnel attended 35.8% of all autopsies. A clinical physician was more likely to attend an autopsy if the patient was from a surgical service. Three primary methods were used to communicate preliminary autopsy results, namely, written reports (82.5%), telephone calls (50.6%), and meetings (11.5%). The primary care physician was sent the autopsy report in 91.1% of cases. Approximately half of the autopsy cases were used in both pathology departmental and extradepartmental activities. Aggregate autopsy data were distributed in the majority of cases to various departmental chairpersons and institutional quality assurance committees. CONCLUSIONS: This study provides a comparative multiinstitutional database for the utilization of autopsy results by clinicians and clinical departments. Although autopsy rates are low, autopsy results are routinely being used for hospital quality assurance activities and for educational purposes.  相似文献   

16.
The study was performed using questionnaires which were filled in by 114 pathologists and 210 clinicians. The pathologists considered the major attractive professional motivations to be the elucidation of clinical aspects and possibility to be engaged in biopsy diagnosis, the most unattractive thing was a small salary. The clinicians supported the view that an autopsy was obligatory, the ratio of supporters to ++nonsupporters among clinicians and pathologists being 2.5:1 and 1:1, respectively. The average expected autopsy cost is 50 levs, but its real one is 84 levs. The overload of dissectors decreases the quality of autopsies and requires the revision of their performance rates. Pathologists's specialization, contact with clinicians, and labour safety are also discussed in the paper. It is only one half of the clinicians who are able to determine which disease is the major one. The death certificates that are filled in by a physician are insignificant (20% of errors are due to improper diagnosis of the major disease). The authors believe that it is high time to set up a national pathoanatomical record office equipped with computers.  相似文献   

17.
Corporate medicine is a cultural response to increasing medical costs, a transformation made possible by an oversupply of physicians. The independence of physicians is being curtailed. Nonetheless, corporate needs for medical efficiency, low costs, and good outcomes match the capabilities of pathology and assure that the specialty will have a major corporate role. Pathologists as individuals may face sharply different outcomes. Those pathologists who own laboratories, who are good managers, who a extremely productive, or who are excellent clinicians have good opportunities, as do a few individuals with highly developed technical or subspeciality skills, Eventually, hospital chains are likely to be replaced by physician-owned or -controlled corporations, further strengthening pathology's role. Pathologists in academic and independent laboratory settings are likely to do well. Pathology organizations must take a leadership role in preparing pathologists for what can be a bright future.  相似文献   

18.
Potential of the autopsy   总被引:3,自引:0,他引:3  
The autopsy was originally performed to understand anatomy. It still has relevance in correlating physiologic and pathologic processes with anatomic structures. In the first half of this century, it was an important tool in experimental investigations, the discovery of new diseases, and the identification and correlation of known clinical entities with particular cells, tissues, and organs. Since the early 1950s, the autopsy has suffered a regression in terms of interest, the number of competent autopsy physicians and of autopsies, financial reimbursement, and a lack of support from the medical community. Simultaneously its relevance to teaching, the ensuring of accurate diagnoses for therapy, and providing material for the investigation of unique human diseases, has increased. It will take a decade of support to produce a reversal of this trend. The leadership resides in the academic institutions that have the most resources. Academic pathologists could help rejuvenate the autopsy by emphasizing the utilization of human tissue for research and for transplantation, giving new significance to the autopsy and reinforcing its roles in patient care and graduate education.  相似文献   

19.
Immunohistochemistry (IHC) is an important part of the diagnostic work-up in surgical pathology, but the use of IHC in autopsy pathology is poorly defined. We measured IHC utilization by pathologists performing 609 consecutive non-medicolegal, hospital-based, adult autopsies over a three-year period. IHC requests on non-neurologic and neurologic material were analyzed separately. Total stains, number of tissue blocks, specific antibody requests, resident trainee involvement, and ordering pathologist were recorded. For all autopsies on which IHC was requested, the final autopsy report was reviewed. IHC was requested on 345 cases (57%), and a total of 4612 stains were performed (mean 13.5 per autopsy). For non-neurologic autopsy tissues, IHC was used most commonly for the accurate diagnosis of malignancy. For neuropathologic autopsy examinations, IHC was employed most commonly to exclude neurodegenerative conditions and correlate ante-mortem clinical neurologic findings. Resident involvement did not significantly impact utilization. Individual pathologists demonstrated a wide variation in IHC utilization. We conclude that IHC is used extensively in Canadian non-medicolegal autopsy pathology reflecting the complexity, extent, and severity of disease in patients dying in a tertiary-care, academic hospital setting. Utilization is strongly influenced by the neuropathology component of these autopsies. The results provide a point of reference for IHC utilization in autopsy pathology.  相似文献   

20.
Clinical and post-mortem assessment of the cause of death   总被引:9,自引:0,他引:9  
Analysis of the clinical and post-mortem assessment of the underlying cause of death in 742 autopsies showed that over- and underdiagnosis cancelled each other out in the majority of the main diagnostic groups, so there was little difference in the total number of cases recorded in the different groups after clinical and post-mortem investigation. However, in the individual case the reliability of the clinical diagnosis varied greatly with the nature of the diagnosis and its degree of certainty. Reliability was for example high with clinically certain arteriosclerotic heart disease and low with cerebrovascular disease. Underdiagnosis of lung cancer is still a problem. Lack of interest in autopsy investigation may be reflection of lack of clinical involvement or therapeutic frustration rather than the use of sophisticated diagnostic procedures, as has been assumed by previous authors. It is suggested that the idea of selection of cases for autopsy should be replaced by selection of autopsies for microscopic investigation on the basis of the macroscopic post-mortem findings. It is suggested also that clinicians might profitably attend autopsies on patients in their sphere of interest that were not admitted under their care.  相似文献   

设为首页 | 免责声明 | 关于勤云 | 加入收藏

Copyright©北京勤云科技发展有限公司  京ICP备09084417号