Red blood cell changes during the evolution of the sickle cell painful crisis.

A longitudinal study of the red blood cell (RBC) deformability, percent of dense erythrocytes, and hematologic parameters has been conducted during 117 painful crises affecting 36 patients with sickle cell anemia between January, 1985 and December, 1990. RBC deformability was determined by osmotic gradient ektacytometry and the percentage of dense cells was quantitated by centrifugation on a discontinuous Stractan density gradient. The data indicate that the painful crisis is a process that follows a bimodal form of evolution. The first phase of the painful crisis is characterized by increase in the severity of pain, increase in the number of dense cells, and a decrease in RBC deformability. In some patients the changes in dense cells and RBC deformability are evident 1 to 3 days before the onset of pain. In addition, the hemoglobin level decreases and the reticulocyte count increases during this initial phase. The second phase of the crisis is characterized by reduction in pain intensity, decrease in the number of dense cells, and increase in RBC deformability to values higher than those seen in the steady state. Moreover, the improvement in RBC deformability and the decrease in the number of dense cells at the end of a crisis seem to constitute new risk factors that may incite a recurrence of the crisis within 1 month in about 50% of painful episodes. The pathophysiologic events responsible for this bimodal behavior of RBCs during painful episodes may represent the appearance of factors that induce (1) preferential trapping of deformable cells in the microcirculation during the first phase of the crisis, followed by a decrease of dense cells and the appearance of new deformable RBCs released from the bone marrow during the second phase of the crisis; or (2) variable sickling of all circulating RBCs during the first phase followed by disappearance of dense RBCs and their replenishment by deformable cells during the second phase.     

Sickle cell anemia with few painful crises is characterized by decreased red cell deformability and increased number of dense cells.

The frequency and severity of the painful sickle cell crisis vary greatly among affected patients. Aside from a high level of Hb F(greater than 20%) there is no established parameter which may modulate the clinical severity of the disease. In this paper we describe two groups of adult patients with homozygous SS and present their characteristics. The division into these two groups was on the basis of relatively low RBC deformability (less than or equal to 37% of control) and high RBC deformability (greater than 65% of control) in the steady state. None of the patients had alpha-gene deletion and all had Hb F level less than 6.0%. Each patient was followed for a minimum of 3 years. The number of dense cells was quantitated by centrifugation on discontinuous Stractan gradient. RBC deformability index in isotonic medium (DI 290) was determined by ektacytometry and expressed as % of control. The patients with low RBC deformability had significantly less painful crises and more leg ulcers than those patients with high RBC deformability. The average number of dense cells was 22.2% and 9.8% of total circulating cells in the first and second group respectively. Moreover, the group with high red cell deformability had 33% mortality during the study period whereas no deaths occurred in the group with low RBC deformability. The data indicate that there is a subset of patients with SS who have relatively few painful crises despite low Hb F level. We wish to designate these by the acronym MIDDD syndrome: Mild disease as far as painful crises are concerned, increased number of Dense cells, and Decreased red cell Deformability. In addition these patients have high incidence of leg ulcers, have low incidence of urinary tract infection, and less mortality. Cellular factors seem to contribute to the incidence of painful crises.     

Monozygotic twins with sickle cell anemia and discordant clinical courses: clinical and laboratory studies.

We describe a rare set of monozygotic twins with coexistent sickle cell anemia and alpha-/alpha alpha thalassemia who have asynchronous painful crises of different frequency and severity. Studies include measurements of cell deformability and other hemorheologic tests, cell density distribution, the percentage of irreversibly sickled cells, adherence of red cells to endothelial cells, membrane heme and membrane free iron, calcium containing internal vesicles and serum antioxidants. Results of these studies, including estimates of organ damage (bone, spleen, retina), were similar except for an increase in red cell membrane free iron in the patient with more frequent and severe painful crises. The study supports the concept that non-inherited factors are important contributors to the frequency and severity of painful crises in sickle cell anemia.     

The incidence of painful crisis in homozygous sickle cell disease: correlation with red cell deformability

To determine whether the vasoocclusive severity of homozygous sickle cell (SS) disease is influenced by cellular dehydration, we correlated the incidence of painful crisis with steady-state measurements of red cell hydration. Sixteen children with SS disease were followed for 3.3 to 8 years (mean, 6.8 years), and a single crisis rate was calculated for each patient. At the time of well visits, cellular hydration was assessed by measuring cell deformability, the percentage of red cells with a density greater than or equal to 1.1056 g/mL, and the percentage of irreversibly sickled cells (ISC). The incidence of painful crisis showed a strong positive correlation with Omax, a deformability measurement reflecting cellular hydration (r = .84, P less than .002), and with hemoglobin concentration (r = .59, P = .04). That is, higher crisis rates were observed in patients with less dehydrated, more deformable red cells and also in patients with higher hemoglobin concentrations. Furthermore, cell deformability and hemoglobin concentration were independent predictors of the incidence of painful crisis, which is consistent with separate effects of these two red cells parameters on vasoocclusive severity.     

The percentage of dense red cells does not predict incidence of sickle cell painful crisis

To test the hypothesis that the tendency of hemoglobin S (HbS) to polymerize within cells is the major determinant of the incidence of vaso-occlusive episodes, we have examined the effect of the percentage of dense cells (as measured by Percoll-Stractan continuous density gradient centrifugation) on the frequency of painful crises in a group of 36 patients with sickle cell disease. No correlation was found between the percentage of dense cells and admissions for crisis. Among the patients with known alpha-gene status (n = 25), the strong correlation between decreased dense cells and alpha-thalassemia (- alpha/alpha alpha) reported previously was confirmed (P less than .001). In addition, in this small subset, patients with alpha- thalassemia (-alpha/alpha alpha) appeared to have a marginally increased number of admissions for sickle cell crisis (t = 2.1910, P less than .05), which was independent of the percentage of dense cells. We conclude that the percentage of dense sickle cells cannot predict the incidence of painful crisis, suggesting that other factors (microcirculatory regulation or other humoral and cellular factors) are more important in the generation maintenance of painful crises than the necessary, but not sufficient, tendency of HbS-containing red cells to sickle.     

Red blood cell deformability as a predictor of anemia in severe falciparum malaria.

Decreased erythropoiesis and increased clearance of both parasitized and noninfected erythrocytes both contribute to the pathogenesis of anemia in falciparum malaria. Erythrocytes with reduced deformability are more likely to be cleared from the circulation by the spleen, a process that is augmented in acute malaria. Using a laser diffraction technique, we measured red blood cell (RBC) deformability over a range of shear stresses and related this to the severity of anemia in 36 adults with severe falciparum malaria. The RBC deformability at a high shear stress of 30 Pa, similar to that encountered in the splenic sinusoids, showed a significant positive correlation with the nadir in hemoglobin concentration during hospitalization (r = 0.49, P < 0.002). Exclusion of five patients with microcytic anemia strengthened this relationship (r = 0.64, P < 0.001). Reduction in RBC deformability resulted mainly from changes in unparasitized erythrocytes. Reduced deformability of uninfected erythrocytes at high shear stresses and subsequent splenic removal of these cells may be an important contributor to the anemia of severe malaria.     

Magnetic resonance imaging of bone marrow in sickle cell disease: clinical, hematologic, and pathologic correlations

A longitudinal, prospective, controlled evaluation of magnetic resonance images (MRI) of long bones in sickle cell patients was undertaken simultaneously with assessment of clinical status and hematologic parameters, including dense erythrocytes. MRI of bone marrow in sickle cell patients during steady states appeared patchy and were markedly different from those in matched controls (P approximately 0). Patients with severe patchiness were older than those with mild or moderate patchiness (P less than .03). Sixty-nine MRI were performed during 28 painful episodes occurring in 14 subjects with sickle cell disease (SCD). Increased signals on intermediate and T2-weighted images were detected in 35.7% of painful episodes. These abnormalities were distinct and not observed to occur spontaneously during the steady-state examinations (P approximately 0). Bone marrow infarcts were confirmed by biopsy in two instances and autopsy in one instance. Dense red cells decreased by 40.81% of baseline during pain crises (P = .00005), more remarkably in those who had pain in the lower extremities (P = .0145). Patients with change in MRI during pain crises had a greater percentage change in the dense cells than those without the change in MRI (69.7% v 31.3%, P = .0120).     

Enhancement of sickle erythrocyte adherence to endothelium by autologous platelets

The increased adhesiveness of sickle erythrocytes (SS RBC) to endothelial cells has been confirmed in a static system utilizing fresh umbilical vein endothelium. Adherence of SS RBC to the endothelium was as great in the presence of calcium-containing buffer as when incubated in plasma. SS RBC suspended in autologous platelet-rich plasma adhered to a greater extent than when suspended in autologous platelet poor plasma. Prostacyclin, thromboxane B2, and an inhibitor of collagen- and epinephrine-induced platelet aggregation (B13.177) did not affect SS RBC adherence to endothelium. Aspirin in a concentration of 5 micrograms/ml slightly decreased SS RBC adherence to endothelium in the presence of platelets. Platelets may play a significant role in the increased adhesiveness of SS RBC to endothelium. To the extent that increased SS RBC adhesiveness contributes to the genesis of painful crises and to the extent platelets augment this adhesiveness, agents affecting platelet function may prove useful in preventing painful crises.     

Fluctuating deformability of oxygenated sickle erythrocytes in the asymptomatic state and in painful crisis

A new gravity filtration technique for the study of sickle cell deformability has shown a significant loss of filterability of oxygenated erythrocytes on day 2 of painful crisis in eight patients with homozygous sickle cell anaemia; there was no increase in irreversibly sickled cell (ISC) count. Serial study (mean of 5.2 occasions) in six out-patients when asymptomatic also showed considerable fluctuation in sickle cell filterability with time; this was again independent of ISC count. Erythrocyte filtration methods demonstrate fluctuations in the rheology of sickle cells that are not detected by ISC counts and which are probably secondary to clinically occult, as well as overt, vaso-occlusive events in the microcirculation.     

Clinical manifestations and erythrocyte adhesion to endothelium in sickle cell syndrome

Painful vasocclusive episodes are one of the most prominent pathological features of sickle cell disease. In addition to abnormal shape and poor deformability, increased adhesion of red cells to endothelium has been reported. On several occasions, we have studied the adhesion of erythrocytes from 30 patients with mixed sickle cell syndromes to evaluate the influence of clinical conditions. The percentage of erythrocytes adhering was significantly higher when erythrocytes from sickle patients were compared with controls (p less than 0.01). Furthermore, adhesion was significantly higher when the patients were in crises (p less than 0.01), and the highest values of all were observed in patients with inflammatory conditions. To investigate the possibility that a limited population of red cells could be responsible for the increase in red cell adhesion, we have measured the HbS concentration in the different washes and found that the HbS concentration was higher in the last washes compared to the first washes. Sickle red cells capable of protein synthesis (young red cells) were labelled with [3H] leucine. The adhesion to endothelial cells of [3H] leucine-labelled red cells was higher than that of the 51Cr-labelled red cells from the same patient. On the other hand, the most dense sickle red cells separated by density gradient adhered to a greater extent than the light red cells. This apparent discrepancy could be partly explained by the presence of [3H] leucine-labelled red cells in the dense fractions of sickle red cells separated by stractan gradient.     

An objective sign in painful crisis in sickle cell anemia: the concomitant reduction of high density red cells

The etiopathologic basis of painful crisis in sickle cell anemia is largely unknown, and no objective criteria for its diagnosis and follow- up exist at present. We have studied 11 patients through 14 painful crises and observed a significant decrease of the densest fraction of red cells in 12 of the 14 crises as determined by isopycnic Percoll- Stractan continuous density gradients. If the first observation is normalized to 100%, the average decrease in dense cells was 77% with a range of 36% to 94%. The time needed for the percentage of dense cells to return to the steady-state level varied from seven to more than 30 days. These findings were in sharp contrast to the stability of the density pattern observed in another group of sickle cell patients, who were studied during crisis-free periods. The mechanism of the disappearance of dense cells could involve selective destruction by the reticuloendothelial (RE) system, selective sequestration in the areas of vasoocclusion, or a combination of both factors.     

Microvascular sites and characteristics of sickle cell adhesion to vascular endothelium in shear flow conditions: pathophysiological implications

To understand the role of sickle cell adherence to the vascular endothelium in the pathophysiology of sickle cell anemia (SS) vasoocclusion, we have carried out a microcirculatory study utilizing the ex vivo mesocecum vasculature of the rat. A single bolus of washed oxy-normal (AA) erythrocytes or oxy-SS cells (unseparated or density-defined SS cell classes) was infused. Hemodynamic monitoring and intravital microscopic observations of the microvascular flow revealed higher peripheral resistance for SS erythrocytes and adherence of these cells exclusively to the venular endothelium but rare or no adherence of AA cells. The extent of adhesion was inversely correlated with venular diameters (r = -0.812; P less than 0.00001). The adhesion of SS erythrocytes is density-class dependent: reticulocytes and young discocytes (SS1) greater than discocytes (SS2) greater than irreversible sickle cells and unsicklable dense discocytes (SS4). Selective secondary trapping of SS4 (dense cells) is found in postcapillary venules where deformable SS cells are preferentially adhered. We conclude that in the oxygenated condition, vasoocclusion can be induced by two events: (i) random precapillary obstruction by a small number of SS4 cells; (ii) increased adhesion of SS1 and SS2 cells in the immediate postcapillary venules. A combination of precapillary obstruction, adhesion in postcapillary venules, and secondary trapping of dense cells may induce local hypoxia, increased polymerization of hemoglobin S, and rigidity of SS erythrocytes, thereby extending obstruction to nearby vessels.     

Evolution of laboratory parameters during sickle cell painful crisis: evidence compatible with dense red cell sequestration without thrombosis

We find that during 51 episodes of sickle cell painful crisis indirect bilirubin fell 52% from its steady state value of 2.3 +/- 1.9 mg% to a value of 1.1 +/- 0.37 mg% at the end of crisis (p less than .00000085). The indirect bilirubin decline correlates with a decrease in the dense sickle cells during crisis (r = .31, p less than .0009). During steady state, both indirect bilirubin and lactic acid dehydrogenase correlate significantly with number of dense red cells (r = .62, p less than .000002 and r = .32, p less than .02 respectively). Platelet counts, beta-thromboglobulin, Platelet Factor 4, and Fibrinopeptide A levels all were elevated during steady state and did not change during the evolution of crisis. These data demonstrate that elevated indices usually associated with platelet activation are a feature of the steady state of sickle cell disease but argue against thrombosis as a factor in the progression of a sickle cell painful crisis episode. The parallel decline of both dense cells and bilirubin during painful crises indicates that the disappearance of dense cells during crisis is not caused by hemolysis and supports the hypothesis that dense red cell sequestration, in the absence of evidence of thrombosis, is an intrinsic component of the evolution of sickle cell painful crisis.     

Interaction between HBS-beta-o-thalassemia and alpha-thalassemia

We have defined the clinical and laboratory characteristics of a group of patients with HbS-beta o-thalassemia plus alpha-thalassemia, by analysis of erythrocyte indices, hemoglobin A2 and F levels, globin biosynthesis studies and alpha-globin gene mapping. Patients with HbS-beta o + alpha-thalassemia closely resembled individuals with HbS-beta o-thalassemia except for balanced globin synthesis ratios and a lower HbF level. The frequency of painful crises, leg ulceration, aseptic necrosis of bone and acute chest syndrome was similar in HbS-beta o + alpha-thalassemia patients and controls with sickle cell anemia (HbSS), HbSS-alpha-thalassemia and HbS-beta o-thalassemia. These findings are consistent with previous work which failed to show a reduction in the vaso-occlusive severity of sickle cell disease by the coexistence of alpha-thalassemia.     

Endothelial cell interactions with sickle cell, sickle trait, mechanically injured, and normal erythrocytes under controlled flow

Increased adhesive forces between sickle erythrocytes and endothelial cells (EC) have been hypothesized to play a role in the initiation of vasoocclusion in sickle cell anemia. Erythrocyte/human umbilical vein EC interactions were studied under controlled flow conditions for normal (AA), homozygous sickle cell (SS), sickle cell trait (AS), mechanically injured normal, and "high-reticulocyte control" RBC by using video microscopy and digital image processing. The number of adherent RBC was determined at ten-minute intervals during a washout period. Results indicate that SS RBC were more adherent than AA RBC. Mechanically injured (sheared) AA RBC were also more adherent than control normal cells but less adherent than SS RBC. AS RBC did not differ significantly in their adhesive properties from normal RBC. Less- dense RBC were more adherent to EC than dense cells for normal, SS, and high-reticulocyte control RBC. The number of cells adherent at a given time during washout was a very strong function of wall shear rate. In addition, at all shear rates studied, the average velocity of individual SS RBC in the region near the EC surface was approximately half that of AA RBC at the same bulk volumetric flow rate through the flow chamber. These findings suggest that the increased adhesion of sickle RBC is at least partially related to the increased numbers of less-dense RBC present. Increased adherence of the less-dense cells to the EC lining vessel walls could contribute to microvascular occlusion by lengthening vascular transit times of other sickle cells.     

P-selectin mediates the adhesion of sickle erythrocytes to the endothelium

The adherence of sickle red blood cells (RBCs) to the vascular endothelium may contribute to painful vaso-occlusion in sickle cell disease. Sickle cell adherence involves several receptor-mediated processes and may be potentiated by the up-regulated expression of adhesion molecules on activated endothelial cells. Recent results showed that thrombin rapidly increases the adhesivity of endothelial cells for sickle erythrocytes. The current report presents the first evidence for the novel adhesion of normal and, to a greater extent, sickle RBCs to endothelial P-selectin. Studies of the possible interaction of erythrocytes with P-selectin revealed that either P-selectin blocking monoclonal antibodies or sialyl Lewis tetrasaccharide inhibits the enhanced adherence of normal and sickle cells to thrombin-treated endothelial cells. Both RBC types also adhere to immobilized recombinant P-selectin. Pretreating erythrocytes with sialidase reduces their adherence to activated endothelial cells and to immobilized recombinant P-selectin. Herein the first evidence is presented for the binding of normal or sickle erythrocytes to P-selectin. This novel finding suggests that P-selectin inhibition be considered as a potential approach to therapy for the treatment of painful vaso-occlusion in sickle cell disease.     

Activated monocytes in sickle cell disease: potential role in the activation of vascular endothelium and vaso-occlusion

Sickle cell anemia is characterized by painful vaso-occlusive crises. It is hypothesized that monocytes are activated in sickle cell disease and can enhance vaso-occlusion by activating endothelium. To test this hypothesis, human umbilical vein endothelial cells (HUVEC) and human microvascular endothelial cells (MVEC) with sickle and normal mononuclear leukocytes were incubated, and endothelial activation was measured. Endothelial cells incubated with sickle mononuclear leukocytes were more activated than those incubated with normal mononuclear leukocytes, as judged by the increased endothelial expression of adhesion molecules and tissue factor and the adhesion of polymorphonuclear leukocytes (PMNL). Monocytes, not lymphocytes or platelets, were the mononuclear cells responsible for activating endothelial cells. Sickle monocytes triggered endothelial nuclear factor-kappa B (NF-kappaB) nuclear translocation. Cell-to-cell contact of monocytes and endothelium enhanced, but was not required for, activation. Antibodies to tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha) and interleukin-1-beta (IL-1beta) blocked activation of the endothelium by monocytes. Peripheral blood monocytes from patients with sickle cell disease had 34% more IL-1beta (P =.002) and 139% more TNF-alpha (P =.002) per cell than normal monocytes. Sixty percent of sickle monocytes expressed the adhesion molecule ligand CD11b on their surfaces compared with only 20% of normal monocytes (P =.002). Serum C-reactive protein, a marker of systemic inflammation, was increased 12-fold in sickle serum than in normal serum (P =.003). These results demonstrate that sickle monocytes are activated and can, in turn, activate endothelial cells. It is speculated that vascular inflammation, marked by activated monocytes and endothelium, plays a significant role in the pathophysiology of vaso-occlusion in sickle cell anemia.     

Adhesion of sickle red blood cells and damage to interleukin-1 beta stimulated endothelial cells under flow in vitro

Two factors that are hypothesized to contribute to vasoocclusive crises in sickle cell anemia are increased sickle red blood cell-endothelial cell interactions and damage to endothelium. Despite considerable study, the mechanisms by which erythrocyte-endothelial interactions occur and the role of endothelial damage have not yet been fully elucidated. In this report, we demonstrate that adhesion and damage may be related in a model of vasoocclusion in sickle cell anemia. Phase contrast microscopy coupled to digital image processing was used to determine the adhesion of sickle red blood cells to 1-, 4-, and 24-hour interleukin-I beta (IL-1 beta) stimulated endothelial calls in a parallel plate flow chamber. Morphological alterations to activated endothelial cells after the perfusion of sickle erythrocytes were also identified. Pretreatment of monolayers with 50 pg/mL of IL-1 beta for 1, 4, and 24 hours caused approximately 16-fold increases in adhesion of sickle cells to activated endothelium at all time points. Results with an Arginine-glycine aspartic acid (RGD) peptide and monoclonal antibodies indicated a role for three different endothelial cell receptors: alpha v beta 3 after 1 hour of IL-1 beta stimulation; E- selectin after 4 hours of IL-1 beta stimulation; and vascular cell adhesion molecule-1 after prolonged exposure to cytokines. Perfusion of sickle, but not normal, erythrocytes resulted in alteration of endothelial morphology. Approximately 6% to 8% damage was observed on 4- and 24-hour IL-1 beta stimulated endothelial cells after the perfusion of sickle cells. Damage to 24-hour activated endothelial cells showed a positive correlation (r = .899) with the number of adherent sickle erythrocytes.     

In vivo studies of sickle red blood cells

The defining clinical feature of sickle cell anemia is periodic occurrence of painful vasoocclusive crisis. Factors that promote trapping and sickling of red cells in the microcirculation are likely to trigger vasoocclusion. The marked red cell heterogeneity in sickle blood and abnormal adhesion of sickle red cells to vascular endothelium would be major disruptive influences. Using ex vivo and in vivo models, the authors show how to dissect the relative contribution of heterogeneous sickle red cell classes to adhesive and obstructive events. These studies revealed that (1) both rheological abnormalities and adhesion of sickle red cells contribute to their abnormal hemodynamic behavior, (2) venules are the sites of sickle cell adhesion, and (3) sickle red cell deformability plays an important role in adhesive and obstructive events. Preferential adhesion of deformable sickle red cells in postcapillary venules followed by selective trapping of dense sickle red cells could result in vasoocclusion. An updated version of this 2-step model is presented. The multifactorial nature of sickle red cell adhesion needs to be considered in designing antiadhesive therapy in vivo.     

Hydroxyurea therapy decreases the in vitro adhesion of sickle erythrocytes to thrombospondin and laminin

The adhesion of sickle erythrocytes to the vascular endothelium and subendothelial matrix probably contributes to the pathogenesis of vaso-occlusive disease. The chemotherapeutic agent hydroxyurea (HU) decreases the frequency of vaso-occlusive crises in patients with sickle cell disease. However, the exact mechanism(s) of HU's effect on vaso-occlusive crises is not fully understood. The goal of this study was to determine the effect of HU therapy on the adhesion of sickle erythrocytes to the subendothelial matrix proteins thrombospondin (TSP) and laminin under conditions of flow in vitro. Erythrocytes from patients with severe sickle cell disease on HU therapy (n = 14) had significantly less adhesion to TSP (687 +/- 92 erythrocytes/mm2, mean +/- SE) than untreated patients with severe disease (n = 18, 1176 +/- 117 erythrocytes/mm2, P = 0.003). In addition, there was significantly less adhesion of erythrocytes to immobilized laminin in patients treated with HU (1695 +/- 293 erythrocytes/mm2) than in the untreated patients (2590 +/- 296 erythrocytes/mm2, P = 0.02). Erythrocytes from an additional nine patients with severe sickle cell disease were studied both before and after initiation of HU therapy. Erythrocytes from these patients became less adhesive to both TSP (P = 0.001) and laminin (P = 0.01), a change that was sustained in most patients throughout the duration of the study (2 months to > 12 months). This study suggests that HU modulates the adhesive phenotype of sickle erythrocytes, an effect that may be in addition to, or independent of, other known effects of HU, such as an increase in fetal haemoglobin level.