Quantitative study of mucosal wave via videokymography in canine larynges

OBJECTIVES: Vocal fold mucosal wave movements are thought to be important in determining voice characteristics and quality. To see these movements, high-speed cinematography and videostroboscopy have been used clinically; however, these techniques have disadvantages that make them impractical for quantitative measurement of mucosal wave movements. This study explored the feasibility of using line-scan cameras for mucosal wave analysis. METHODS: An excised larynx bench model was used to examine the effects of elongation and changes in subglottal pressure on the amplitude, frequency, and phase difference of vocal fold mucosal movements as calculated from line-scan images. RESULTS: The data showed a positive and linear relationship between an increase in subglottal pressure and amplitude of the mucosal wave; elongation of the vocal folds appeared to decrease the amplitude of mucosal wave upheaval at each level of subglottal pressure. Similarly, increase in subglottal pressure had a positive and linear relationship with increase in frequency of vibration; elongation of the vocal folds further increased the frequency at any given subglottal pressure. Phase difference between the movements of the upper and lower margins of the mucosal lips was estimated and did not appear to be significantly affected by changes in subglottal pressure and elongation. CONCLUSION: The data presented in this study are consistent with relationships that we would expect to be true from currently accepted models of vocal fold vibration.     

First results of clinical application of videokymography

Objectives: Stroboscopy is based on the assumption that the vibration of the vocal folds is stable and regular. Irregular vibrations, which are common in voice pathology, cannot easily be studied and described in a reliable way. Videokymography overcomes most of these drawbacks. Design: The use of the recently invented videokymography for studying vocal fold vibrations in patients is introduced. Method: Videokymography, using a modified CCD-video camera, works in two modes: standard and high speed. In standard mode the vocal folds are displayed on a video monitor in the usual way, providing 50 images per second (or 60 in the National Television Standards Committee (NTSC) system). This is used for routine laryngoscopic and stroboscopic examination of the larynx. In high-speed mode (nearly 8000 images per second) only one line from the whole image is selected and displayed on the x-axis of the monitor; the y-axis represents the time dimension. Results: All kinds of vocal fold vibrations, including those leading to pathological rough, breathy, hoarse, or diplophonic voice productions can be observed. Videokymography visualizes small left-right asymmetries, open quotient differences along the glottis, lateral propagation of mucosal waves, and movements of the upper margin and, sometimes in the closing phase, the lower margin of the vocal folds. Conclusion: Videokymography is advantageous for a more accurate diagnosis of voice disorders. Videokymography provides a simple way to study irregular vibrations of the vocal folds. Information is directly available for further processing and allows a first-time quantification of vibrations registered.     

Vocal fold vibrations: high-speed imaging, kymography, and acoustic analysis: a preliminary report

OBJECTIVES: To evaluate a new analysis system, High-Speed Tool Box (H. Larsson, custom-made program for image analysis, version 1.1, Department of Logopedics and Phoniatrics, Huddinge University Hospital, Huddinge, Sweden, 1998) for studying vocal fold vibrations using a high-speed camera and to relate findings from these analyses to sound characteristics. STUDY DESIGN: A Weinberger Speedcam + 500 system (Weinberger AG, Dietikon, Switzerland) was used with a frame rate of 1,904 frames per second. Images were stored and analyzed digitally. Analysis included automatic glottal edge detection and calculation of glottal area variations, as well as kymography. These signals were compared with acoustic waveforms using the Soundswell program (Hitech Development AB, Stockholm, Sweden). METHODS: The High-Speed Tool Box was applied on two types of high-speed recordings: a diplophonic phonation and a tremor voice. Relations between glottal vibratory patterns and the sound waveform were analyzed. RESULTS: In the diplophonic phonation, the glottal area waveform, as well as the kymogram, showed a specific pattern of repetitive glottal closures, which was also seen in the acoustic waveform. In the tremor voice, fundamental frequency (F0) fluctuations in the acoustic waveform were reflected in slow variations in amplitude in the glottal area waveform. For studying details of mucosal movements during these kinds of abnormal vibrations, the glottal area waveform was particularly useful. CONCLUSIONS: Our results suggest that this combined high-speed acoustic-kymographic analysis package is a promising aid for separating and specifying different voice qualities such as diplophonia and voice tremor. Apart from clinical use, this finding should be of help for specification of the terminology of different voice qualities.     

High-precision measurement of the vocal fold length and vibratory amplitudes

OBJECTIVE/HYPOTHESIS: Standard laryngoscopy suffers from a lack of information about the actual size of the observed objects (i.e., vocal fold length and oscillating amplitudes). However, there is much interest in absolute measures for both clinical and research purposes. Therefore, a laser projection device has been developed that enables the precise determination of absolute units in endoscopic investigation during respiration and phonation. STUDY DESIGN: An experimental study in which 9 adults underwent high-speed endoscopy combined with a laser projection device. METHODS: The projection system consists of two parallel laser beams with a distance of 3.8 mm. It is mounted on the tip of a rigid endoscope, which is attached to a digital high-speed camera During development and design, examination situations were taken into account. Two laser spots are projected onto the vocal folds and enable the definition of a metric scale within the endoscopic image. Knowledge-based image processing algorithms were used for evaluation. RESULTS: First measurements of the vocal fold length during phonation were performed in a group of nine healthy male students. The determination of glottal length during phonation agrees with former results. Quantifying vocal fold velocities in absolute units makes it possible to estimate the initial collision forces. CONCLUSIONS: The presented laser projection system allows the determination of absolute measures in the larynx. Because of the simple functional principle, the system is open for use without digital high-speed recording as well. Absolute units may also be helpful in voice diagnosis and in monitoring during voice therapy.     

DiHA (dextranomers in hyaluronan) injections for treatment of insufficient closure of the vocal folds: early clinical experiences

OBJECTIVE: To determine the clinical effects of injecting DiHA (a mixture of dextranomer molecules and 1% hyaluronan solution in equal proportions) as a "space filler" into the vocal folds of patients experiencing insufficient closure of the vocal folds resulting from either unilateral vocal fold paralysis or bowed vocal folds. STUDY DESIGN: A consecutive series of patients with insufficient closure of the vocal folds treated with DiHA injections and prospectively followed up with videostroboscopy and voice recordings that were evaluated by expert panels. METHODS: During a 21/2-year period, 14 patients with insufficient closure of the vocal folds were included. Six had a unilateral vocal fold palsy and 8 patients had "bowed" vocal folds. DiHA was injected into one vocal fold. Laryngoscopic examination and voice recordings were performed pre- and postoperatively. Expert panels did the evaluation of the stroboscopy examination and the perceptual voice analysis. RESULTS: Three patients were operated on with local and 11 under general anesthesia. All patients with unilateral palsy improved their stroboscopic status regarding both the wave and the closure after injection. Also, their voice parameters were significantly improved. Among the patients with bowed vocal folds, all except 2 showed an improvement in the glottic wave, 5 of 8 improved in glottic closure, and 3 improved their voice parameters significantly. CONCLUSION: This early clinical experience indicates that DiHA fulfills most of the requirements of an ideal "space-filling" substance for voice restoration in patients experiencing insufficient vocal fold closure.     

Anterior and posterior medialization (APM) thyroplasty

OBJECTIVE: In unilateral vocal fold paralysis with dysphonia, most of the paralyzed vocal folds may be medialized effectively by medialization laryngoplasty. However, if the posterior glottal gap is wide, these procedures may sometimes have a limit to medialize the posterior glottis and cannot be effective for acceptable voice quality. The objective of this study is to introduce a new surgical technique for medializing the membranous and cartilaginous portions of the paralyzed vocal fold: anterior and posterior medialization (APM) thyroplasty. METHOD: Six patients underwent APM thyroplasty. They completed preoperative and postoperative evaluation with acoustic analysis and video laryngoscopy. RESULTS: All patients satisfied their voice subjectively after surgery. The paralyzed vocal folds, membranous and cartilaginous parts, were medialized well, and the paralyzed arytenoid showed less anterior tipping postoperatively. On voice analysis all patients showed prolonged phonation times and decreased perturbations after surgery. CONCLUSION: The advantages of this procedure are to medialize the membranous and cartilaginous portions of the paralyzed vocal fold directly and to correct vertical mismatch between two vocal folds. This procedure might be especially indicated in the lateralized position of the paralyzed vocal fold but not in the higher paralyzed vocal fold compared with the normal vocal fold.     

Phonovibrogram visualization of entire vocal fold dynamics

OBJECTIVES: High-speed (HS) video recordings are the up-to-date method for visualizing irregular vocal fold vibrations. However, perceptive evaluation during offline replay is time consuming and shows high inter-rater variability. METHOD: A visualization procedure is presented that extracts vocal fold vibrations from HS videos and transfers the motion information into a set of three phonovibrogram (PVG) images that make visual vocal fold displacements (PVG-0), velocities (PVG-1), and accelerations (PVG-2). RESULTS: The principles of PVG computation as well as their application to three clinical examples (normal voice, laryngeal nerve paralysis, functional voice disorder with vocal nodules) are presented. For normal and dysphonic subjects, the PVG images show the characteristics of vocal fold vibrations as concern the dynamic patterns of displacements, velocities, and accelerations. CONCLUSION: The PVG approach makes visual the entire range of motion of vibrating vocal fold edges in easy-to-read color images for differentiation of normal and pathologic voices. PVG images are printable and can be stored on a hard-disc drive, enabling the documentation of the course of voice disorders that is essential for evidenced-based medicine. PVG visualization has the potential to overcome the subjective quality of assessing HS videos, which makes it a valuable tool with broad clinical application.     

Vocal nodules and edema may be due to vibration-induced rises in capillary pressure

HYPOTHESIS: Vocal fold vibration may physically raise intravascular pressure to levels high enough to damage capillaries and result in leakage of erythrocytes. This type of injury is commonly seen in benign vocal fold lesions and is not well explained. STUDY DESIGN: Theoretical, retrospective. METHODS: The relationship of intravascular pressure to vibration frequency and amplitude is derived and confirmed with a physical blood vessel model, then applied to published human measurements to estimate human intravascular pressures. RESULTS: Vocal fold intravascular pressure is predicted to have a quadratic dependence on both frequency and amplitude. During speaking, the pressure may rise to over 20 cmH2O, and may reach levels far higher for screaming and singing. Such pressure magnitudes are known to trigger inflammatory cascades and can lead to fluid leakage. They also have the potential for pharmacologic control with beta-agonists. CONCLUSIONS: Intravascular pressure likely rises significantly during vocal fold vibration and may lead to the type of injury seen in benign vocal fold lesions. The results support voice therapy aimed at reducing vibratory amplitude. More vibratory amplitude measurements need to be performed in a wider range of subjects before the full range of human vocal fold vascular pressures can be estimated.     

Videostrobokymography: a new method for the quantitative analysis of vocal fold vibration

OBJECTIVES: To develop a new analysis method for the quantitative assessment of vibration of the vocal folds, using conventional videostroboscopic image data. METHODS: We used prerecorded videostroboscopic images to evaluate quantitatively the vibration of the vocal folds. Successive images were converted as digital images by means of an image-grabbing board, processed for analysis, and reconstructed as kymograms by rearranging the same lines of all processed images along the time axis. RESULTS: We developed a new technique for evaluating the vibration of the vocal folds. The vibrations of multiple vocal fold regions were easily and objectively evaluated by this technique. The objective parameters, such as open quotient and asymmetry index, could be obtained easily using this technique. CONCLUSIONS: Videostrobokymography demonstrated objectively the vibrations of several vocal fold regions at the same time. This technique has the potential to be a new tool to analyze and monitor the pathological changes and treatment results of vocal fold movement in a more refined quantitative fashion, using videostroboscopic images.     

Low-cost high-speed imaging system for observing vocal fold vibration in voice disorders

Purpose: The aim of this study was to establish a method to observe vocal fold vibration using a low-cost high-speed laryngeal imaging system. Procedures: We assembled a high-speed imaging system with a consumer digital camera and a rigid laryngeal endoscope. The camera can shoot digital images at a rate of 1,200 frames per second and be purchased for about USD 1,000 in Japan. Results: We examined the normal and pathological vocal folds of 215 subjects with our new system and analyzed the vocal fold vibration in these subjects by playback of a video and kymograph images. Conclusions: Our high-speed laryngeal imaging system is highly cost-effective and can be a useful tool for examining the vocal folds of patients with voice disorders.     

Physical and technical elements of short-interval,color-filtered double strobe flash-stroboscopy

INTRODUCTION: Quantitative measurement of vocal fold movements can be done either with high-speed imaging or with short interval, color-filtered double strobe flash-stroboscopy. The physical and technical elements of this new technique are described. METHODS: Two special strobe units (KAY Elemetrics RLS 9100) are used in a master-slave configuration. In this way an adjustable interval of 0.1-2.0 ms between flashes is introduced. The strobe flashes are color filtered and are separated by a brief interval. By this means a double exposure is created in each video frame.Real-time visualization of opening and closing velocities over the entire length of the vocal fold from anterior to posterior is possible.Quantification is possible off-line after image calibration. CONCLUSION: Short-interval, color-filtered double-strobe flash stroboscopy allows quantitative measurement of the velocity of vocal fold movements during vibration at different pitches and sound pressure levels (SPL). Images gained with this new technique provide information about a dynamic property (velocity) of the vocal fold within a single image.Therefore, its use could be helpful from the aspect of clinical documentation.     

High-speed imaging used to detect vocal fold paresis: a case report

High-speed imaging has been used to study vocal fold vibration and has been shown to provide additional information in aid of our understanding of pathologic vocal fold vibration. This is the first case report of vocal fold paresis diagnosed by high-speed imaging. An 18-year-old girl presented with intermittent voice loss that had been present for 4 years. The patient had been seen by other otolaryngologists and had been given proton pump inhibitors without any improvement in her voice. Her voice was diplophonic. The patient was examined by rigid stroboscopy and was found to have a predominantly open phase pattern but a normal vibratory pattern. High-speed photography showed a distinct vibratory frequency for each vocal fold, suggestive of a paresis pattern. Laryngeal electromyography confirmed the diagnosis of vocal fold paresis. A computed tomographic scan of the larynx and chest showed a thymoma. After thymectomy, the patient recovered full voice function. High-speed imaging is useful for the clinical evaluation of pathologic vocal fold vibration and can detect subtle features of paralysis that may not be detected on fiberoptic endoscopy and rigid stroboscopy. The additional information from high-speed imaging helped to make the diagnosis of vocal fold paresis in this patient.     

What have we learned about laryngeal physiology from high-speed digital videoendoscopy?

PURPOSE OF REVIEW: The purpose of this review is to describe recent developments in high-speed videoendoscopy. The applications of this technique are highlighted and important findings regarding vocal fold physiology and voice pathology are discussed. RECENT FINDINGS: The number of applications for digital high-speed imaging has increased during recent years because of the development of camera image sensor systems with increased image resolution of video and television quality. Other improvements are related to computer processing speed and storage capacity and the development of automatic algorithms for quantification and measurements both in time and room dimensions. This is enhanced by combining high-speed videoendoscopy with laser-based measurement systems, acoustic analyses or other glottographic methods, such as flow glottography or electroglottography. High-speed videoendoscopy is currently used in studies of voice mechanisms of phonation (e.g., the voice source can be examined with a high sampling rate, from 1000 to over 8000 frames per second), and in phonation onset or offset. High-speed imaging is also useful in linguistic studies and in the examination of different artistic singing styles, such as extremely high-pitched singing, throat singing, or different pop and rock styles. High-speed videoendoscopy is also used in the examination of patients with voice disorders, particularly with irregular vocal fold vibrations, ventricular phonation, or the phonation of individuals who have had a laryngectomy. SUMMARY: Findings from studies of normal voice physiology and of voice disorders using high-speed imaging are presented and their relevance is discussed.     

Phonomicrosurgery for benign vocal Fold lesions - our experience

Benign lesions of glottis creates stiffness of the vocal fold and inefficient glottal valve, aerodynamically effecting the vocal quality by preventing smooth vocal edge closure. Introduction of phonomicrosurgical techniques based on Hirano ’s principle of vocal fold epithelium have revolutionized results of voice surgery. Our experience in the management of benign vocal fold lesions by phonomicrosurgical techniques with pre and post operative stroboscopic, perceptual and computerized acoustic voice analysis is described.     

Functional results after external vocal fold medialization thyroplasty with the titanium vocal fold medialization implant

OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS: A persistent insufficiency of glottal closure is mostly a consequence of a unilateral vocal fold movement impairment. It can also be caused by vocal fold atrophy or scarring processes with regular bilateral respiratory vocal fold function. Because of consequential voice, breathing, and swallowing impairments, a functional surgical treatment is required. The goal of the study was to outline the functional results after medialization thyroplasty with the titanium vocal fold medialization implant according to Friedrich. METHODS: In the period of 1999 to 2001, an external vocal fold medialization using the titanium implant was performed on 28 patients (12 women and 16 men). The patients were in the age range of 19 to 84 years. Twenty-two patients had a paralysis of the left-side vocal fold, and six patients, of the right-side vocal fold. Detailed functional examinations were executed on all patients before and after the surgery: perceptive voice sound analysis according to the "roughness, breathiness, and hoarseness" method, judgment of the s/z ratio and voice dysfunction index, voice range profile measurements, videostroboscopy, and pulmonary function tests. In case of dysphagia/aspiration, videofluoroscopy of swallowing was also performed. The respective data were statistically analyzed (paired t test, Wilcoxon-test). RESULTS: All patients reported on improvement of voice, swallowing, and breathing functions postoperatively. Videostroboscopy revealed an almost complete glottal closure after surgery in all of the patients. All voice-related parameters showed a significant improvement. An increase of the laryngeal resistance by the medialization procedure could be excluded by analysis of the pulmonary function test. CONCLUSIONS: The results confirm the external medialization of the vocal folds as an adequate method in the therapy of voice, swallowing, and breathing impairment attributable to an insufficient glottal closure. The titanium implant offers, apart from good tissue tolerability, the advantage of an easy, time-saving, and individually adjustable application during the operation.     

Effects of thyroplasty type I on vocal fold vibration

OBJECTIVE: To ascertain effects of medialization thyroplasty on vocal fold vibration in glottic incompetence dysphonia. STUDY DESIGN: Quantitative videostroboscopic glottic measurements and vocal function study were perioperatively undertaken in 20 patients undergoing Isshiki's thyroplasty type I. METHODS: In digitized images, the glottal area, glottal width, posterior glottal width, and amplitude over an entire glottal cycle were measured and normalized by membranous vocal fold length. The ratio of closed phase to total phase of vibratory cycle was calculated from the data of the glottal area and the glottal width at the middle point of the membranous vocal fold. Well-accepted acoustic, aerodynamic, and perceptual measures analyzed vocal function. RESULTS: Glottal area and glottal width were reduced after surgery. While preoperative closure of glottal area was incomplete in all 20 patients, incomplete closure was obtained in 16 patients after surgery. In these 16 patients, closure of glottal width at the middle point of the membranous vocal fold was complete, whereas a posterior glottal gap remained in 14 patients. Closed phase over one cycle of glottal width waveform and amplitude of vocal fold vibration were increased after surgery. Glottal area, glottal width, posterior glottal width, and closed phase over one cycle of glottal width waveform correlated with vocal function measures. CONCLUSIONS: Thyroplasty type I reduces a glottal gap and increases closed phase over one cycle and amplitude of vocal fold vibration, although a posterior glottal gap remains. With the improved glottic vibration, thyroplasty type I provides more efficient phonation in patients with glottic incompetence dysphonia.     

Long-term effects of micronized Alloderm injection for unilateral vocal fold paralysis

OBJECTIVES: Micronized Alloderm (Cymetra) is a relatively new product used for vocal fold augmentation. Previous studies evaluating possible long-term effectiveness of this product have shown mixed results. The objective of this present study is to reassess possible long-term results of Cymetra injection laryngoplasty in patients with unilateral true vocal fold paralysis. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective review of patients with unilateral true vocal fold paralysis who received Cymetra injection laryngoplasty between March 2001 and March 2004. METHODS: Preoperative voice samples and videostroboscopic findings were compared with the most recently available postoperative data to assess efficacy of the procedure. A panel of voice experts analyzed both vocal and vibratory function in these samples. In addition, pre- and postoperative voice-related quality of life measures and patients' self-ratings of voice outcomes were compared. RESULTS: Twenty patients (7 male, 13 female; 14 with left-sided paralysis, 6 with right-sided paralysis) were identified in the study population. Cymetra injection was performed an average of 45.1 months after onset of vocal fold paralysis (range -216 months), and average follow-up postinjection was 11.2 (range -35) months. Comparing pre- and postoperative measures, voice quality (P < .0001), glottal closure (P < .0001), and degree of vocal fold bowing (P < .0001) were all improved by injection. Quality of life measures and patients' self-perceptions of vocal quality were also improved (P < .01). Fifteen (75%) patients showed long-lasting results. Eight patients showed improvement for more than 12 months after injection. CONCLUSION: Cymetra injection laryngoplasty offers improved vocal and vibratory function to patients with unilateral true vocal fold paralysis. The benefits of such medialization may be longer lasting than previously reported, and further long-term study is warranted.     

Thyroplasty to improve the voice in patients with a unilateral vocal fold paralysis

Unilateral vocal fold paralysis may cause incomplete closure of the glottis and a poor voice. Thyroplasty is a relative new operation to improve the voice by‘medialization’of the paralysed vocal fold. In our series of 29 patients 24 (83%) were satisfied and 26 (90%) had a better voice. After the operation the voice was louder, clearer and easier to understand. The dynamic and melodic ranges on the phonetogram were wider; maximum loudness and maximum phonation time were improved. There were no complications during the follow-up of 4 months to 5 years. In the three patients whose voice was not improved, the vocal fold paralysis was due to local trauma and scarring     

Videostrobokymographic Analysis of Benign Vocal Fold Lesions

Objectives—Videostrobokymography (VSK) has recently been introduced. The aim of this study was to analyze vibratory patterns and objective parameters in various benign vocal fold lesions using VSK and to examine the efficacy of VSK in clinical applications.

Material and Methods—Using VSK, we analyzed the vibration patterns of normal vocal folds, various benign lesions such as nodules, polyps, cysts and Reinke's edema and cases of unilateral vocal fold paralysis. We also calculated the objective parameters open quotient and asymmetric index and compared them with their mean values in normal controls.

Results—In nodules, polyps and cysts, the open quotient at the site of the lesion was similar to the mean value in the normal controls; however, on the other parts of the vocal folds, it was much larger than the normal mean value. In Reinke's edema, irregular and asymmetric vibrations were observed. The posterior area of the vocal folds showed larger open quotients than the anterior area. In unilateral vocal fold paralysis, irregular vocal fold vibration and incomplete closure of the vocal folds were documented. Much larger asymmetric indices were calculated for unilateral vocal fold paralysis than in normal controls or for other lesions. The asymmetric index may be a good quantitative parameter of vibration in patients with vocal fold paralysis.

Conclusion—This study demonstrated that VSK could generate clear quantitative documentation of fine vibrations of vocal folds in many different types of benign lesion. VSK has the potential to be an effective tool for the quantitative analysis of vibratory patterns of vocal folds in clinical settings.