Pelvic injuries in child abuse

Three cases of child abuse are described in which pelvic injuries were prominent findings on radiologic examination: Two patients had pelvic fractures, and one was found to have heterotopic ossification of the soft tissues of the pelvis and thighs corresponding to extensive bruising in the pubic, genital, buttock, and thigh areas, resulting from physical and sexual abuse. These represent uncommon radiographic findings. Skeletal survey in cases of suspected child abuse should include the entire pelvis, and special attention should be paid to the ischiopubic rami the most common site of these rare pelvic injuries.     

Ischio-pubic-patellar hypoplasia: is it a new syndrome?

Aplasia/hypoplasia of the patella has been described as an isolated finding or, more commonly, as a part of congenital syndromes. We describe here bilateral absence of the patella in an 11-year-old girl with absence of the ischial and inferior pubic rami bilaterally. Other associated skeletal and soft-tissue deformities are also reported. To our knowledge, the constellation of these findings has not been described previously and represents a unique syndrome. Received/accepted: 8 December 1995     

Genital injury in girls — accidental or not?

For 33 months a prospective study was made of girls attending a paediatric accident and emergency department with genital injury. The clinical features were related to age and the stated mechanism of the injury. Indicators for non-accidental injury were sought. A clear history was given in 82 of 87 girls to account for the findings on examination. Straddle injuries occurred in 74, accidental penetrating injuries in 5, stretch injuries in 3, and 2 had self-inflicted scratch injuries. Sexual abuse was alleged by 3 girls. Surgery was required in 6. Accidental injuries to the genital area are common and should have a clear history, with findings on examination consistent with that history. An absent or vague history or injury to the hymen, fourchette, or perineum must raise suspicions of child sexual abuse. Correspondence to: A. M. Pierce     

How common is abuse in Greece? Studying cases with femoral fractures

AIMS—To examine the extent of undiagnosed child abuse in Greece by studying young children with femoral fractures, which may be associated with abuse.
METHODS—Fifty seven consecutive cases of children under 6 years of age with femoral fracture were identified from the Emergency Department Injury Surveillance System database. Controls were 4162 children with other orthopaedic injuries from the same database.
RESULTS—Whereas in the literature about one third of femoral injuries among young children are attributed to child abuse, no child in the studied series had been diagnosed or even investigated in this context. Nevertheless, the pattern of occurrence of femoral injuries was compatible with that of child abuse, in that patients were frequently very young boys of low socioeconomic status, and the accident had frequently occurred under poorly identified or implausible conditions at time periods when most family members were crowded at home.
CONCLUSIONS—Epidemiological risk factors for child abuse characterise femoral fractures in young children in Greece. It appears that child abuse is present in this country as in most other cultures. There is a clear need for refocusing medical personnel and hospital social services so that the problem is revealed, quantified, and appropriately dealt with.

     

Lichen sclerosus in the differential diagnosis of suspected child abuse cases

Lichen sclerosus in young females can present as traumatic injuries on the vulva which can mimic sexual abuse. The case of an unconscious 6-year-old girl presenting in a reported inflicted drug overdose and with a clinical picture of ecchymosis and abrasions of the anogenital area is presented and discussed. The following case underscores the need for clinicians evaluating children for suspected abuse, to consider alternate conditions and causes that may not be related to sexual abuse.     

How common is abuse in Greece? Studying cases with femoral fractures.

AIMS: To examine the extent of undiagnosed child abuse in Greece by studying young children with femoral fractures, which may be associated with abuse. METHODS: Fifty seven consecutive cases of children under 6 years of age with femoral fracture were identified from the Emergency Department Injury Surveillance System database. Controls were 4162 children with other orthopaedic injuries from the same database. RESULTS: Whereas in the literature about one third of femoral injuries among young children are attributed to child abuse, no child in the studied series had been diagnosed or even investigated in this context. Nevertheless, the pattern of occurrence of femoral injuries was compatible with that of child abuse, in that patients were frequently very young boys of low socioeconomic status, and the accident had frequently occurred under poorly identified or implausible conditions at time periods when most family members were crowded at home. CONCLUSIONS: Epidemiological risk factors for child abuse characterise femoral fractures in young children in Greece. It appears that child abuse is present in this country as in most other cultures. There is a clear need for refocusing medical personnel and hospital social services so that the problem is revealed, quantified, and appropriately dealt with.     

Metaphyseal fractures mimicking abuse during treatment for clubfoot

Background. Metaphyseal injuries resembling the classic metaphyseal lesion (CML) of abuse may occur as the result of serial casting during treatment of clubfoot deformity. Mentioned in the orthopedic literature in 1972, this iatrogenic fracture has not been described in the radiologic literature nor has the similarity to injuries occurring with abuse been previously recognized. Objective. To describe the mechanism and radiographic appearance of metaphyseal injury observed during serial casting of clubfoot. Note similarities to the CML of abuse. Materials and methods. Eight children ranging in age from 1 to 4 months underwent casting for clubfoot. Five orthopedic surgeons from three different institutions performed the casting. Two patients had spina bifida and one, arthrogryposis. A complete skeletal survey was performed on one child who was abused; there was no suspicion of abuse in the remaining seven. Results. All children manifest injury with periosteal new bone. One child had clear evidence of abuse with 24 rib fractures. X-rays of lower extremities in short leg casts revealed bilateral tibial metaphyseal fractures. Four other children had metaphyseal fractures resembling the CML of abuse, and three developed an area of sclerosis within the metaphysis. Conclusion. In the setting of serial casting for equinovarus deformity, metaphyseal injury even the CML of abuse may be noted. Since inflicted injuries are almost always unobserved and explanations rarely offered, the fact that the CML occurs as a result of orthopedic maniuplation may offer some further insight concerning the pathogenesis of this well-described abuse injury. Received: 29 December 2000 Accepted: 3 April 2001     

Surgical treatment of pediatric femoral shaft fractures

PURPOSE OF REVIEW: Femoral shaft fractures are among the most common fractures in children. Depending on the patient's age, fracture location, pattern, mechanism of injury, and associated injuries, several different treatment options exist. The purpose of this review is to discuss these different clinical situations and the recommended treatment methods, as well as to characterize the latest literature and recommendations. RECENT FINDINGS: In the past several years, there have been significant changes in the approach to the treatment of pediatric femoral shaft fractures, particularly in school-aged children. Young children have traditionally been treated conservatively with good results, and this method is still currently advocated. Adolescents over the age of 12 are generally treated with rigid intramedullary rods. However, in children between the ages of 5 and 12, new surgical treatment modalities have been tested with good outcomes, and, as new data emerge, these methods are becoming preferable to conservative treatment. SUMMARY: Children who sustain femoral shaft fractures can present difficult challenges to both orthopedists and pediatricians. A recent shift in treatment in children between ages of 5 and 12 from nonoperative to surgical intervention has led to shorter hospital stays and earlier return to activity with reliable fracture healing.     

Long bone fractures in children under 3 years of age: Is abuse being missed in Emergency Department presentations?

OBJECTIVE: Distinguishing injuries due to accidents from those due to child abuse in young children is important to prevent further abuse. We aimed to study the presenting features, mechanism of injury, type of fracture and indicators of possible abuse in children under 3 years of age, presenting to the Emergency Department (ED) of a tertiary referral Children's Hospital, to see whether those injuries that were more likely abusive were distinguished from those that were more likely accidental. METHODS: We analysed the medical records from the Emergency Department Information System of all children below 3 years of age, who were treated for a long bone fracture at the Sydney Children's Hospital, Randwick, NSW, over a 1-year period. Demographic details, presenting complaint, mechanism of injury, type of fracture, other historical and examination data and action taken were noted. Nine indicators that raise suspicion of abuse were developed from the literature. Using these indicators, patients' ED notes were reviewed to establish whether long bone fractures suspicious for abuse had been referred for further evaluation. RESULTS: One hundred patients with a total of 103 fractures presented during the study period. No child had multiple fractures at a single visit. The fractures included 36 radius/ulna, 27 tibia/fibula, 20 humeral, 17 clavicular and three femoral. The mean age of patients was 21.6 months (range 13 days - 35 months). Fourteen patients were younger than 12 months. Review of the notes revealed 31 children with indicators suspicious for abuse, of whom 17 children had one indicator, 11 children had two indicators, and three children had three indicators. Only one child was referred for further evaluation to child protection. CONCLUSION: Abuse cannot usually be determined by fracture type alone. Doctors in the ED miss indicators for abuse because they do not look for these indicators in the history and examination. Knowledge of indicators that raise suspicion of abuse is needed for a further forensic assessment to occur. The development of specific referral guidelines, ongoing education and a comprehensive injury form may improve referral of children from the ED to child protection.     

Evidence for sexual transmission of genital herpes in children

Introduction

Genital herpes in a prepubertal child presents a child protection clinician with a difficult problem: how likely is it that transmission occurred as a consequence of sexual abuse? Published guidelines on the management of sexually transmitted infections in children provide varying recommendations and refer to a limited literature.

Objective

To review the evidence for the likelihood of sexual transmission in a child with proven genital herpes.

Methods

Structured literature search for reports of series of children presenting with genital herpes where an assessment for possible sexual transmission or child sexual abuse had been made.

Results

Five suitable papers were identified. Although just over half of reported cases of genital herpes in children had evidence suggestive of a sexual mode of transmission, the quality of assessment of possible sexual abuse was too weak to enable any reliable estimation of its likelihood. Sexual transmission is reported more commonly in older children (aged ⩾5 years), in children presenting with genital lesions alone and where type 2 herpes simplex virus is isolated.

Conclusions

Child protection clinicians should be aware of the weakness of the evidence on the likelihood of sexual transmission of genital herpes in prepubertal children. The US guidance that child sexual abuse is “suspicious” reflects the evidence better than the UK guidance that it is “probable”. A larger, more up‐to‐date, methodologically sound, population based study is required.     

Unexplained subdural hematoma in young children: Is it always child abuse?

Background : In the published reports of the developed society, subdural hematoma and/or retinal hemorrhages, in the absence of documented history of major trauma, should be considered diagnostic of child abuse. Many people used the above criteria for diagnosis, but subsequently found that retinal hemorrhages were more common in non‐accidental injuries (NAI). To what extent is the proposed pathognomonic association between unexplained subdural hematoma/retinal hemorrhages and child abuse a self‐fulfilling prophecy? Methods : Clinical details of nine children under 2 years with unexplained subdural hematoma admitted to Prince of Wales Hospital between 1995 and 1998 were reviewed. Results : Four had no other physical signs of injury, five had retinal hemorrhages and one had multiple bruises over the body. Following multidisciplinary case conferences for seven children, a diagnosis of NAI was concluded in four cases, but in no case could the abuser be definitely identified. Clinical outcome was poor with seven children showing either profound disability (n = 5) or evidence of developmental delay (n = 2). Conclusion : In this series, NAI were not established in three of the seven cases. Did we underdiagnose child abuse in these cases? Despite a magnitude of opinion to the contrary, the issue of whether ‘trivial’ head injury can cause subdural hemorrhages and/or retinal hemorrhages is yet unresolved. Clearly much more information on this very sensitive and serious issue is required and these data should be collected with an open mind.     

Diagnosing abuse: a systematic review of torn frenum and other intra-oral injuries

Introduction

A torn labial frenum is widely regarded as pathognomonic of abuse.

Methods

We systematically reviewed the evidence for this, and to define other intra‐oral injuries found in physical abuse. Nine studies documented abusive torn labial frena in 30 children and 27 were fatally abused: 22 were less than 5 years old. Only a direct blow to the face was substantiated as a mechanism of injury.

Results

Two studies noted accidentally torn labial frena, both from intubation. Abusive intra‐oral injuries were widely distributed to the lips, gums, tongue and palate and included fractures, intrusion and extraction of the dentition, bites and contusions.

Conclusions

Current literature does not support the diagnosis of abuse based on a torn labial frenum in isolation. The intra‐oral hard and soft tissue should be examined in all suspected abuse cases, and a dental opinion sought where abnormalities are found.     

Rib fractures in infants: red alert! The clinical features, investigations and child protection outcomes

OBJECTIVE: To examine clinical features, investigation methods and outcomes of infants with rib fractures. METHODOLOGY: All infants aged 2 years or younger who presented over a 5-year period with documented rib fractures were identified from the medical records database of a tertiary referral paediatric hospital and data collected by retrospective chart review. Additional data regarding notifications and placements were obtained from the Department of Families Youth and Community Care, Queensland. RESULTS: Rib fractures were attributed to child abuse in 15 of 18 infants identified. The initial presentation in the abused infants was most often as a result of intracranial pathology and limb fractures. In four cases the rib fractures were incidental findings when abuse had not been suspected. Bone scintigraphy revealed eight previously undetected rib injuries in four cases. In three cases of abuse, the rib fractures were an isolated finding. Three of the infants with inflicted rib injuries were discharged home. In one such infant a significant re-injury occurred. Three returned home with implicated adults no longer in residence, and nine spent a mean period of 12 months in foster care. CONCLUSIONS: Rib fractures in infancy are usually caused by severe physical abuse. Accidental rib fractures are rare in infants and result from massive trauma. Rib fractures, multiple or single, may occur in isolation in abused infants. The implications of such injuries must be recognized to ensure appropriate, safe and consistent child protection outcomes. Bone scintigraphy is more sensitive than radiographs in the detection of acute rib fractures and should be performed in all cases of suspected infant abuse.     

Successful rescue of a child with fall-related multi-organ injuries

Background

Fall-related injury is a major cause of accidental death and is rarely reported in children. Even successful treatment of children with multi-organ injuries caused by fall from the extreme height has been rarely reported.

Methods

We herein report a 2-year-old girl who fell from the 10th floor, had multi-organ injuries, and was successfully rescued.

Results

The girl sustained multi-organ injuries, such as head injury, closed abdominal injury, as well as fractures of the left limbs, and successfully recovered after two surgeries and supportive treatment.

Conclusions

This case illustrates that a child who falls from extreme heights can occasionally be rescued. Early neuroprotective strategies help to improve neurological recovery.     

Anogenital human papillomavirus in non-abused preschool children

AIM: To estimate the prevalence of human papillomavirus (HPV) in anogenital samples from children selected for non-abuse. METHODS: A letter of invitation was sent to 2731 girls and 1042 boys, all of them aged 5 or 6 y. Inclusion was based on self-selection, whereby parents who did not suspect any occurrence of sexual abuse of their child gave informed consent to participate. Several mechanisms were undertaken to exclude abused children. A complete examination was done of each child, including anogenital examination with a colposcope and microbiological sampling from the genitals and anus. Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) using primers MY09 and MY11 was used to identify HPV, and sequencing was done on each positive amplicon. RESULTS: PCR was performed on 325 adequate specimens from 211 children enrolled. Seven samples from 5 girls were HPV-positive, making 2/161 (1.2%) of the anal and 5/164 (3.0%) of the genital specimens positive. HPV was not detected in any of the boys. In four girls strong associations with HPV 6 genotypes were found, while one girl probably had a mixed infection with HPV 6 and 16. Three girls (1.8%) had clinically detectable anogenital warts. CONCLUSION: Since our results are comparable with a prevalence reported from allegedly abused children, and higher rates have been reported from the oral cavity in healthy children, we find detection of HPV unreliable as an indicator of sexual abuse in 5-6-y-old children. The rate of anogenital warts found in our study is comparable with a rate reported in abused children.     

Safeguarding children in trauma and orthopaedics

Safeguarding, the action taken to protect children from harm, is an important aspect of paediatric care. Orthopaedic surgeons are often the first healthcare professionals to suspect physical abuse or non-accidental injury (NAI) on the basis of children presenting with unexplained bony injury. Physical harm from inflicted injury, a concept that most orthopaedic surgeons are familiar with, is not the only cause for a safeguarding referral and a comprehensive assessment may reveal concerns regarding: neglect, emotional abuse or sexual abuse. Clinicians caring for children, have to consider all of these factors as a cause for concern and organize onward referral. This article focuses on inflicted skeletal injury, how to recognize and investigate it. Typical fractures of concern are discussed and illustrated along with consideration of differential diagnoses.     

Nutritional neglect and physical abuse in children of alcoholics

Objective: Children of alcoholics are at higher risk for physical injuries and malnutrition. In this study nutritional neglect and physical abuse in children of alcoholics has been compared with children of non-alcoholics in a General Hospital attached to a Medical College.Methods: 72 children of alcoholics were compared with 81 normal controls. 86.1% in case group and 49.4% in control group had malnourishment of various grades.Results; 45% of the children of alcoholics had physical injuries in contrast to 23.4% of children of non-alcoholics. Malnutrition co-existed in almost all injured children of alcoholics.Conclusion: Alcoholism in parents of malnourished and injured children are frequently ignored in routine clinical evaluation. If the risk children are identified early some of the morbidity can be avoided.     

Differential diagnosis of child physical abuse: conditions that may be mistaken for child abuse

Child protection is one of the most difficult aspects of paediatric practice. Physical abuse is the commonest form of maltreatment identified by clinicians. Suspicious injuries are rarely accompanied by an admission of inflicted harm, even when this is the cause. Clinicians therefore must have a high index of suspicion and where injuries appear consistent with physical abuse or are inadequately explained they must follow safeguarding procedures. However, as for any clinical problem, there is a differential diagnosis to consider. Medical conditions can sometimes mimic signs suggestive of physical abuse. Other conditions can increase a child's vulnerability to specific injuries. In this article we discuss the differential diagnosis of bruising, fractures and head injuries which are the three commonest presenting features of physical abuse. Awareness of the differential diagnosis and appropriate assessment of the injured child can assist in reaching the correct diagnosis and therefore protect children from harm.