Shear Wave Elastography Quantifies Stiffness in Ex Vivo Porcine Artery with Stiffened Arterial Region

Five small porcine aortas were used as a human carotid artery model, and their stiffness was estimated using shear wave elastography (SWE) in the arterial wall and a stiffened artery region mimicking a stiff plaque. To optimize the SWE settings, shear wave bandwidth was measured with respect to acoustic radiation force push length and number of compounded angles used for motion detection with plane wave imaging. The mean arterial wall and simulated plaque shear moduli varied from 41 ± 5 to 97 ± 10 kPa and from 86 ± 13 to 174 ± 35 kPa, respectively, over the pressure range 20–120 mmHg. The results revealed that a minimum bandwidth of approximately 1500 Hz is necessary for consistent shear modulus estimates, and a high pulse repetition frequency using no image compounding is more important than a lower pulse repetition frequency with better image quality when estimating arterial wall and plaque stiffness using SWE.     

Comparing Myocardial Shear Wave Propagation Velocity Estimation Methods Based on Tissue Displacement,Velocity and Acceleration Data

Shear wave elastography (SWE) is a promising technique used to assess cardiac function through the evaluation of cardiac stiffness non-invasively. However, in the literature, SWE varies in terms of tissue motion data (displacement, velocity or acceleration); method used to characterize mechanical wave propagation (time domain [TD] vs. frequency domain [FD]); and the metric reported (wave speed [WS], shear or Young's modulus). This variety of reported methodologies complicates comparison of reported findings and sheds doubt on which methodology better approximates the true myocardial properties. We therefore conducted a simulation study to investigate the accuracy of various SWE data analysis approaches while varying cardiac geometry and stiffness. Lower WS values were obtained by the TD method compared with the FD method. Acceleration-based WS estimates in the TD were systematically larger than those based on velocity (～10% difference). These observations were confirmed by TD analysis of 32 in vivo SWE mechanical wave measurements. In vivo data quality is typically too low for accurate FD analysis. Therefore, our study suggests using acceleration-based TD analysis for in vivo SWE to minimize underestimation of the true WS and, thus, to maximize the sensitivity of SWE to detect stiffness changes resulting from pathology.     

Fast Shear Compounding Using Robust 2-D Shear Wave Speed Calculation and Multi-directional Filtering

A fast shear compounding method was developed in this study using only one shear wave push-detect cycle, such that the shear wave imaging frame rate is preserved and motion artifacts are minimized. The proposed method is composed of the following steps: 1. Applying a comb-push to produce multiple differently angled shear waves at different spatial locations simultaneously; 2. Decomposing the complex shear wave field into individual shear wave fields with differently oriented shear waves using a multi-directional filter; 3. Using a robust 2-D shear wave speed calculation to reconstruct 2-D shear elasticity maps from each filter direction; and 4. Compounding these 2-D maps from different directions into a final map. An inclusion phantom study showed that the fast shear compounding method could achieve comparable performance to conventional shear compounding without sacrificing the imaging frame rate. A multi-inclusion phantom experiment showed that the fast shear compounding method could provide a full field-of-view, 2-D and compounded shear elasticity map with three types of inclusions clearly resolved and stiffness measurements showing excellent agreement to the nominal values.     

Stiffness and Anisotropy Effect on Shear Wave Elastography: A Phantom and in Vivo Renal Study

Tissue elasticity is related to the pathologic state of kidneys and can be measured using shear wave elastography (SWE). However, SWE quantification has not been rigorously validated. The aim of this study was to evaluate the accuracy of SWE-measured stiffness and the effect of tissue anisotropy on SWE measurements. Point SWE (pSWE), 2-D SWE and dynamic mechanical analysis (DMA) were used to measure stiffness and evaluate the effect of tissue anisotropy on the measurements. SWE and DMA were performed on phantoms of different gelatin concentrations. In the tissue anisotropy study, SWE and DMA were performed on the outer cortex of sheep kidneys. In the in vivo study, 15 patients with different levels of interstitial fibrosis were recruited for pSWE measurements. Another 10 healthy volunteers were recruited for tissue anisotropy studies. SWE imaging revealed a non-linear increase with gelatin concentration. There was a significant correlation between pSWE and 2-D SWE, leading to the establishment of a linear regression equation between the two SWE ultrasound measurements. In the anisotropy study, the median difference in stiffness between shear waves oriented at 0° and 90° towards the pyramid axis was significant. In the in vivo study, there was a strong positive linear correlation between pSWE and the percentage of interstitial fibrosis. There was a significant difference in the Young's modulus (YM) between severities of fibrosis. The mean YM values were lower in control patients than in patients with mild, moderate and severe fibrosis. YM values were also significantly higher when shear waves were oriented at 0° toward the pyramid axis. Tissue stiffness and anisotropy affects SWE measurements. These factors should be recognized before applying SWE for the interpretation of measured values.     

Quantitative Assessment of Keloids Using Ultrasound Shear Wave Elastography

This study was aimed at investigating the value of shear wave elastography (SWE) in quantitative evaluation of keloids. A total of 87 patients with 139 keloids were enrolled. Vancouver scar scale (VSS) scores were recorded. Thickness and blood flow grade were evaluated using high-frequency ultrasound. Skin stiffness (mean speed of shear wave, C_mean) was evaluated using SWE in both transverse and longitudinal sections. All measurements were performed in both keloids and site-matched unaffected skin (normal controls). The reliability of measurements was evaluated using intra- and inter-class correlation coefficients by two observers. Inter- and intra-observer repeatability was excellent (correlation coefficient > 0.99, p < 0.01). The SWE results revealed a significant increase in C_mean in keloids (p < 0.001) compared with the normal controls. C_mean in the longitudinal section was greater than that in the transverse section for keloids (p < 0.001). C_mean was highly positively correlated with VSS score (r = 0.904, p < 0.001), moderately positively correlated with thickness (r = 0.490, p < 0.001) and less positively correlated with blood flow (r = 0.231, p < 0.01). This non-invasive, tolerable and convenient imaging technique could be an effective tool for objectively evaluating keloid stiffness in the future, thus laying a foundation for the treatment and evaluation of keloids.     

Image Processing Pipeline for Liver Fibrosis Classification Using Ultrasound Shear Wave Elastography

The purpose of this study was to develop an automated method for classifying liver fibrosis stage ≥F2 based on ultrasound shear wave elastography (SWE) and to assess the system's performance in comparison with a reference manual approach. The reference approach consists of manually selecting a region of interest from each of eight or more SWE images, computing the mean tissue stiffness within each of the regions of interest and computing a resulting stiffness value as the median of the means. The 527-subject database consisted of 5526 SWE images and pathologist-scored biopsies, with data collected from a single system at a single site. The automated method integrates three modules that assess SWE image quality, select a region of interest from each SWE measurement and perform machine learning-based, multi-image SWE classification for fibrosis stage ≥F2. Several classification methods were developed and tested using fivefold cross-validation with training, validation and test sets partitioned by subject. Performance metrics were area under receiver operating characteristic curve (AUROC), specificity at 95% sensitivity and number of SWE images required. The final automated method yielded an AUROC of 0.93 (95% confidence interval: 0.90–0.94) versus 0.69 (95% confidence interval: 0.65–0.72) for the reference method, 71% specificity with 95% sensitivity versus 5% and four images per decision versus eight or more. In conclusion, the automated method reported in this study significantly improved the accuracy for ≥F2 classification of SWE measurements as well as reduced the number of measurements needed, which has the potential to reduce clinical workflow.     

Shear Wave Elastography (SWE): An Analysis of Breast Lesion Characterization in 83 Breast Lesions

Qualitative and quantitative shear wave elastography (SWE) criteria were assessed to differentiate between malignant and benign breast lesions. This prospective study included 83 lesions. SWE features measured included maximal stiffness values inside the lesion (E_lesion) and in the peri-lesion area (E_perilesion) and ratio values (R_lesion and R_perilesion) according to the formula E_lesion or E_perilesion/E_fat, with E_fat corresponding to normal fatty tissue. We compared ultrasonography (B-mode), SWE and histologic sizes. With qualitative and quantitative SWE analysis, sensitivity was 94% and specificity 73%. Malignant lesions appeared more heterogeneous, with higher stiffness and ratio values than benign lesions (p < 0.001). For malignant lesions, SWE size was better correlated to histologic size than B-mode size. Using benign SWE signs to selectively downgrade category 4a and 4b lesions, the specificity improved from 13% to 51% without loss in sensitivity (100%) compared to ultrasound.     

Shear Wave Elastography in Rectal Cancer Staging,Compared with Endorectal Ultrasonography and Magnetic Resonance Imaging

The goal of the study described here was to investigate the value of shear wave elastography (SWE) in pre-operative staging of rectal cancer. Fifty-five patients with rectal cancer underwent pre-operative conventional endorectal ultrasonography (ERUS), SWE and enhanced magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) examinations. Pathologic results were used as the gold standard for cancer staging. The concordance rate with pathologic stage by ERUS and MRI and the stiffness values measured by SWE for tumors in different stages were compared. The concordance rates for cancer staging were 72.7% and 70.9% for conventional ERUS and enhanced MRI, respectively; the difference was not significant (p > 0.05). SWE indicated that the mean and maximum stiffness values of the tumors increased with advance in stage. The differences in stiffness values between T1 and T2, T1 and T3–4, as well as T2 and T3–4, were all statistically significant (p < 0.001). When the maximum stiffness values of 65.0 and 90.7 kPa are used for the diagnosis of T1, T2 and local advanced rectal cancer, the concordance rate of cancer staging was 85.5%, which was slightly higher than those of ERUS and MRI, although the difference was not statistically significant (p > 0.05). SWE is useful in judging the depth of invasion of rectal tumors. The value of tumor stiffness can provide a quantifiable indicator for pre-operative diagnosis of cancer staging and can be used as a supplement to conventional ERUS. Further studies with larger sample sizes are needed.     

Performance of Shear Wave Elastography in Delineating the Radiofrequency Ablation Boundary: An in Vivo experiment

This study was aimed at exploring the cutoff value of Young's modulus of ablated tissue and the optimal scale at which shear wave elastography (SWE) can delineate the ablation boundary. The livers of 30 rabbits were radiofrequency (RF) ablated, and ultrasonic imaging, including SWE and contrast-enhanced ultrasound (CEUS), was performed. The ablation boundary in the SWE image was located using CEUS, and the SWE parameters of the boundary were measured to calculate the cutoff value of Young's modulus. The cutoff value of the ablated tissue was 48–50 kPa 2 h to 28 d post-ablation. The regions of increased stiffness in SWE images at a scale of 0–50 kPa overlapped well with the non-enhanced regions of CEUS images in 88% of specimens. Therefore, elasticity values differed significantly between ablated and non-ablated tissues, and the cutoff value for Young's modulus differentiated these tissues. SWE delineated the ablation boundary well at the optimal SWE scale with respect to the cutoff value.     

Predicting Prognostic Factors of Breast Cancer Using Shear Wave Elastography

The purpose of the study described here was to investigate the correlation between histologic factors, including immunohistochemical factors, related to the prognosis of breast cancer and shear wave elastography (SWE) measurements. One hundred twenty-two breast cancers from 116 women were subjected to sonoelastography. Of the SWE features, mean and maximum elasticity and SWE ratio were extracted. The SWE ratio was calculated as the ratio of the stiffness of a portion of the lesion to that of a similar region of interest in fatty tissue. High ratios indicate stiffer lesions. The Mann-Whitney U-test, Kruskal-Wallis test and receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve were used for statistical analysis. Estrogen receptor negativity, progesterone receptor negativity, p53 positivity, Ki-67 positivity, high nuclear grade, high histologic grade and large tumor (invasive) size were associated with a significantly high SWE ratio (p < 0.05). ROC curve analysis yielded SWE ratio cutoff values of 2.74–3.69 for significant immunohistochemical factors and 4.21 for the basal-like subtype by maximizing specificity while ensuring more than 80% sensitivity. Breast cancers with aggressive histologic features had high SWE ratios. Shear wave elastography may provide useful information for determining prognosis.     

Evaluation of Accuracy of Shear Wave Elastography and Superb Microvascular Imaging Methods in Diagnosis of Piriformis Syndrome: A Preliminary Study

Piriformis syndrome is a neuromuscular disease resulting from sciatic nerve compression caused by an abnormal condition in the piriformis muscle. Superb microvascular imaging (SMI) is a new ultrasound imaging technique that visualizes low-velocity and small-diameter blood vessel flow. In our prospectively designed study, we aimed to evaluate the accuracy of diagnosis of piriformis syndrome with innovative methods such as shear wave elastography (SWE) and SMI. Thirty-two patients diagnosed with unilateral piriformis syndrome were accepted to the statistical stage. The side without symptoms was considered the “unaffected side.” Bilateral piriformis muscles were examined by ultrasonography. Muscle thickness was determined on gray scale, stiffness on SWE and vascularity characteristics on power Doppler and SMI by two independent radiologists. Piriformis muscle stiffness on the non-pathological (unaffected) side was measured by SWE as 18.27 ± 7.301 kPa, and the mean stiffness on the pathological side was 29.70 ± 10.095 kPa. Pathological side muscle stiffness was significantly higher (p < 0.05). Using innovative methods such as SWE and SMI in addition to conventional ultrasonography as much as possible in our daily practice and research helps us in making the correct diagnosis in piriformis syndrome.     

Evaluation of the Effect of an Anisotropic Medium on Shear Wave Velocities of Intra-Muscular Gelatinous Inclusions

In highly anisotropic biological tissues such as muscle or tendons, calculating Young's modulus from the shear wave speed (c_sw) by using shear wave elastography (SWE) involves a complex transversally isotropic rheological model not yet used in common practice. To our knowledge, the effect of muscle anisotropy on c_sw of intra-muscular lesions has not yet been investigated. The objective of our study was to define the effect of an anisotropic medium on c_sw of intra-muscular gelatinous inclusions. We conducted a prospective monocentric, in vitro study in order to examine the quantitative and qualitative SWE behavior of a 9-mm gelatinous intra-muscular implant depending on the orientation of the probe relative to the muscle fibers. There were very significant differences in the prevalence of SWE signal void (p < 0.01) and in the c_sw (p < 0.01) in the gelatinous intra-muscular implants depending on the orientation of the probe relative to the fibers. Performing the c_sw measurements of centimetric intra-muscular lesions by orienting the probe perpendicular to the fibers decreases the probability of artifacts occurring at high intensity interfaces.     

Vascular Shear Wave Elastography in Atherosclerotic Arteries: A Systematic Review

Ischemic stroke is a leading cause of death and disability worldwide, so adequate prevention strategies are crucial. However, current stroke risk stratification is based on epidemiologic studies and is still suboptimal for individual patients. The aim of this systematic review was to provide a literature overview on the feasibility and diagnostic value of vascular shear wave elastography (SWE) using ultrasound (US) in (mimicked) human and non-human arteries affected by different stages of atherosclerotic diseases or diseases related to atherosclerosis. An online search was conducted on Pubmed, Embase, Web of Science and IEEE databases to identify studies using US SWE for the assessment of vascular elasticity. A quality assessment was performed using Quality Assessment of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies 2 (QUADAS-2) checklist, and relevant data were extracted. A total of 19 studies were included: 10 with human patients and 9 with non-human subjects (i.e., [excised] animal arteries and polyvinyl alcohol phantoms). All studies revealed the feasibility of using US SWE to assess individually stiffness of the arterial wall and plaques. Quantitative elasticity values were highly variable between studies. However, within studies, SWE could detect statistically significant elasticity differences in patient/subject characteristics and could distinguish different plaque types with good reproducibility. US SWE, with its unique ability to assess the elasticity of the vessel wall and plaque throughout the cardiac cycle, might be a good candidate to improve stroke risk stratification. However, more clinical studies have to be performed to assess this technique's exact clinical value.     

Characterization of Testicular Masses in Adults: Performance of Combined Quantitative Shear Wave Elastography and Conventional Ultrasound

We prospectively evaluated the performance of combined shear wave elastography (SWE) and conventional ultrasound (US) for the characterization of 89 testicular focal masses. Testes were evaluated with B-mode, color Doppler and SWE measurements, locating a region of interest on the normal and pathologic parenchyma. Thirty-seven malignant tumors (MTs), 12 burned out tumors (BOTs), 28 Leydig cell tumors (LCTs), 2 dermoid cysts and other benign lesions were included. MTs?+?BOTs exhibited more microliths and macrocalcifications compared with benign lesions (p < 10^–4). LCTs manifested mostly a dominant peripheral vascularization pattern compared with other lesions. MTs?+?BOTs were stiffer compared with benign lesions (p < 2?×?10^–4) but with a moderate area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUROC) of 80%. By focusing on LCTs versus MTs?+?BOTs, diagnostic performance led to an AUROC of 89% for the best stiffness parameter. For combined conventional US and SWE, the diagnostic performance to differentiate all benign lesions versus MTs?+?BOTs and LCTs versus MTs?+?BOTs increased to AUROCs of 93% and 98%, respectively.     

Quantitative and Qualitative Approach for Shear Wave Elastography in Superficial Lymph Nodes

The diagnostic contribution of 2-D shear-wave elastography (SWE) in management of superficial lymph nodes (LNs) of any origin was evaluated in 222 patients referred for needle core biopsy. Each patient underwent conventional B-mode/Doppler ultrasound examinations (conventional ultrasound) and SWE. Quantitative SWE parameters and qualitative SWE map features were extracted. Carcinomas were found to be significantly stiffer than benign LNs (29.5 ± 32.3 kPa vs. 6.7 ± 12.3 kPa). Lymphomas exhibited intermediate stiffness (11.4 ± 5.2 kPa). Qualitative SWE analysis provided color patterns specific to histopathology (stiff rim, nodular and undetermined patterns related to malignancy and blue pattern to benignity). Adding SWE to conventional ultrasound improved the sensitivity of LN diagnosis (from 81.1% to 92.0%) but decreased its specificity (from 73.2% to 67.6%) because of the high prevalence of lymphomas compared with carcinomas. Inter-observer agreement for quantitative SWE was good (intra-class correlation coefficient = 0.82) as was inter-observer diagnostic agreement for qualitative SWE (κ = 0.65). LN location and histology type were found to influence the reported diagnostic performance of SWE.     

Diagnostic Accuracy of Shear Wave Elastography as a Non-invasive Biomarker of High-Risk Non-alcoholic Steatohepatitis in Patients with Non-alcoholic Fatty Liver Disease

In this study, we evaluated the diagnostic accuracy of shear wave elastography (SWE) for differentiating high-risk non-alcoholic steatohepatitis (hrNASH) from non-alcoholic fatty liver and low-risk non-alcoholic steatohepatitis (NASH). Patients with non-alcoholic fatty liver disease scheduled for liver biopsy underwent pre-biopsy SWE. Ten SWE measurements were obtained. Biopsy samples were reviewed using the NASH Clinical Research Network Scoring System and patients with hrNASH were identified. Receiver operating characteristic curves for SWE-based hrNASH diagnosis were charted. One hundred sixteen adult patients underwent liver biopsy at our institution for the evaluation of non-alcoholic fatty liver disease. The area under the receiver operating characteristic curve of SWE for hrNASH diagnosis was 0.73 (95% confidence interval: 0.61–0.84, p < 0.001). The Youden index-based optimal stiffness cutoff value for hrNASH diagnosis was calculated as 8.4 kPa (1.67 m/s), with a sensitivity of 77% and specificity of 66%. SWE may be useful for the detection of NASH patients at risk of long-term liver-specific morbidity and mortality.     

Influence of Measurement Depth on the Stiffness Assessment of Healthy Liver with Real-Time Shear Wave Elastography

The purpose of this study was to determine the measurement depth range within which liver stiffness can be reliably assessed using real-time shear wave elastography (SWE) technology. Measurements were performed on phantoms and healthy volunteers. In the first group of patients, measurements were performed at depths of 2–8 cm from the probe surface. In the second group of patients, measurements were conducted 0–7 cm below the liver capsule. Success rate of measurements (SRoM), success rate of patients (SRoS) and coefficients of variation (CVs) of repeated measurements were compared. The SRoMs at 3–7 cm and the CVs at 2–5 cm from the probe surface were significantly higher and lower than those at other depths (p < 0.001), respectively. SRoS was zero 0–1 cm below the liver capsule. Furthermore, the features of 2-D stiffness mapping images were also found to change with depth. According to our results, the depth range for the most reliable liver stiffness assessment using SWE should be 3–5 cm from the probe surface and simultaneously 1–2 cm below the liver capsule.     

Shear Wave Elastography of Breast Lesions: Quantitative Analysis of Elastic Heterogeneity Improves Diagnostic Performance

The aim of this study was to evaluate whether quantitative analysis of elastic heterogeneity (EH) could improve the diagnostic performance of shear wave elastography (SWE) in breast lesions. From August 2016 to August 2017, 280 patients were enrolled in this prospective study. All lesions were evaluated with the ultrasound Breast Imaging Reporting and Data System (BI-RADS) and SWE with Virtual Touch tissue imaging quantification. The shear wave velocity (SWV) of the three areas of highest stiffness and lowest stiffness within the lesions were measured to calculate the maximum SWV (SWV_max), mean SWV (SWV_mean) and EH. The EH was determined as the difference between the averaged highest SWV and lowest SWV. The diagnostic performance—including the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC) and the sensitivity and specificity of BI-RADS, EH, SWV_max and SWV_mean—were analyzed. The AUC of EH, SWV_max and SWV_mean were 0.963, 0.949 and 0.937, respectively. The sensitivity of EH was 93.75%, which was significantly higher than that of SWV_max (84.37%) and SWV_mean (84.37%) (p < 0.001); there was no significant difference in the specificity among EH, SWV_max and SWV_mean (p > 0.05). For category 4A lesions, EH predicted all the malignant lesions, while two cancers were misdiagnosed by SWV_max and SWV_mean, respectively. Quantitative analysis of EH can improve the sensitivity of SWE for the differential diagnosis of breast lesions without loss of specificity.     

Effect of a Thin Fluid Layer on Surface Wave Speed Measurements: A Lung Phantom Study

Lung ultrasound (US) surface wave elastography (SWE) is a novel technique that measures superficial lung tissue elastic properties. A thin pleural fluid layer covers a lung, but its effect on lung measurements in SWE is unknown. We modeled a lung and pleural fluid with sponges and a thin layer of US transmission gel. Sponge surface wave speeds measured from SWE were compared for sponges without and with the thin US gel layer at 3 wave excitation frequencies. The comparison showed that the sponge surface wave speed measurements were not affected by the thin gel layer.     

Association of low back pain with muscle stiffness and muscle mass of the lumbar back muscles,and sagittal spinal alignment in young and middle-aged medical workers

BackgroundMuscle stiffness of the lumbar back muscles in low back pain (LBP) patients has not been clearly elucidated because quantitative assessment of the stiffness of individual muscles was conventionally difficult. This study aimed to examine the association of LBP with muscle stiffness assessed using ultrasonic shear wave elastography (SWE) and muscle mass of the lumbar back muscle, and spinal alignment in young and middle-aged medical workers.MethodsThe study comprised 23 asymptomatic medical workers [control (CTR) group] and 9 medical workers with LBP (LBP group). Muscle stiffness and mass of the lumbar back muscles (lumbar erector spinae, multifidus, and quadratus lumborum) in the prone position were measured using ultrasonic SWE. Sagittal spinal alignment in the standing and prone positions was measured using a Spinal Mouse. The association with LBP was investigated by multiple logistic regression analysis with a forward selection method. The analysis was conducted using the shear elastic modulus and muscle thickness of the lumbar back muscles, and spinal alignment, age, body height, body weight, and sex as independent variables.FindingsMultiple logistic regression analysis showed that muscle stiffness of the lumbar multifidus muscle and body height were significant and independent determinants of LBP, but that muscle mass and spinal alignment were not. Muscle stiffness of the lumbar multifidus muscle in the LBP group was significantly higher than that in the CTR group.InterpretationThe results of this study suggest that LBP is associated with muscle stiffness of the lumbar multifidus muscle in young and middle-aged medical workers.