Digital slot-scan charge-coupled device radiography versus AMBER and Bucky screen-film radiography for detection of simulated nodules and interstitial disease in a chest phantom

PURPOSE: To evaluate the diagnostic performance of full-field slot-scan charge-coupled device (CCD)-based digital radiography in the detection of simulated chest diseases in clinical conditions versus that of two screen-film techniques: advanced multiple beam equalization radiography (AMBER) and Bucky radiography. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Simulated nodules and interstitial nodular and interstitial linear lesions were attached onto an anthropomorphic chest phantom. One hundred sixty-eight lesions were distributed over 25 configurations. A posteroanterior chest radiograph of each configuration was obtained with each technique. The images were presented to six observers. Each lesion was assigned one of two outcome scores: "detected" or "not detected." False-positive readings were evaluated. Differences between the imaging methods were analyzed by using a semiparametric logistic regression model. RESULTS: For simulated nodules and interstitial linear disease, no statistically significant difference was found in diagnostic performance between CCD digital radiography and AMBER. The detection of simulated interstitial nodular disease was better with CCD digital radiography than with AMBER: Sensitivity was 71% (77 of 108 interstitial nodular lesions) with CCD digital radiography but was 56% (60 of 108 lesions) with AMBER (P =.041). Better results for the detection of all lesion types in the mediastinum were observed with CCD digital radiography than with Bucky screen-film radiography: Sensitivity was 45% (227 of 504 total simulated lesions) with CCD digital radiography but was 24% (119 of 504 lesions) with Bucky radiography (P <.001). There were fewer false-positive observations with CCD digital radiography (35 [5.7%] of 609 observations) than with Bucky radiography (47 [9.5%] of 497 observations; P =.012). CONCLUSION: Differences were in favor of the full-field slot-scan CCD digital radiographic technique. This technique provides a digital alternative to AMBER and Bucky screen-film radiography.     

非晶硒平板探测器DR与CR模拟病变描述和剂量降低的对比研究

目的 比较非晶硒平板探测器DR与CR对模拟肺部病变的描述,并对剂量降低情况进行评价。方法 模拟线状、网状和结节病变结构置入仿真胸部体模内,应用DR和CR分别对不同mAs设置的体模曝光,记录体模的入射体表剂量。收集不同剂量的硬拷贝照片,由4位放射医师随机地实施模拟肺部病变显示度评价。采用秩和(Wilcoxon)检验进行统计学分析。结果 用2.0、3.2 mAs曝光时,DR与CR对模拟线状、网状病变的显示度差异有统计学意义(模拟线状病变:Z=-2.032,P=0.042;Z=-2.375, P=0.018。模拟网状病变: Z=-2.680, P=0.007;Z=-2.670, P=0.008)。用5.0、6.3 mAs曝光时,两者对模拟线状、网状病变的显示度差异无统计学意义(P＞0.05)。2.0、3.2、5.0、6.3 mAs曝光档,对于小结节(直径小于10 mm)的检测DR均优于CR(Z=-2.237, P=0.018; Z=-2.384, P=0.017; Z=-2.388, P=0.017; Z=-2.366, P=0.018)。当3种模拟肺部病变都显示清楚时,用非晶硒DR系统的入射体表剂量降低约65%。结论 对微小低对比病变的描述,非晶硒平板探测器DR优于CR且明显地降低曝光剂量。     

Detection of simulated interstitial lung disease and catheters with selenium, storage phosphor, and film-based radiography.

PURPOSE: To evaluate the diagnostic performance of storage phosphor and digital selenium radiography (DSR) with asymmetric and symmetric screen-film systems at different speeds in the detection of simulated interstitial lung disease and catheters. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Patterns of simulated interstitial lung disease and catheters were superimposed over an anthropomorphic chest phantom. Hard-copy images were generated at DSR (200-, 400-, and 600-speed), storage phosphor radiography (200- and 400-speed), and asymmetric (400-speed) and symmetric (200- and 400-speed) screen-film imaging. Surface doses were measured, and receiver operating characteristic analyses were performed. RESULTS: No statistically significant differences were found between the detector systems with the same speeds for each interstitial pattern. Significantly poorer results were found at 600-speed DSR than at 200-speed DSR. Detection of catheters and nodules over high-attenuation areas was significantly worse with the symmetric screen-film system than with the other detectors. The surface dose with the DSR system, without a grid, was about 50% less than that of the other detector systems, with grids, at the same speed. CONCLUSION: No significant difference was found in the diagnostic performance at DSR, storage phosphor radiography, and film-based radiography for simulated interstitial lung disease at corresponding speeds; there was a reduction in the surface dose of about 50% with the 400-speed DSR system.     

Impact of postprocessing on the detection of simulated pulmonary nodules with digital radiography

The authors compared the impact of five postprocessing algorithms on diagnostic performance in the detection of simulated pulmonary nodules on storage phosphor-based digital chest radiographs. Tissue equivalent paraffin nodules (0.5-2.5 cm diameter) were randomly positioned over the chest of a normal volunteer. Receiver operating characteristics (ROC) analysis of a total of 2500 observations by five readers indicated that the default unenhanced image having the appearance of a conventional chest radiograph (ROC area = 0.87 +/- 0.05) was as good as an image with moderate enhancement of medium frequencies (ROC area = 0.85 +/- 0.03), an image with reversed gray scale polarity (ROC area = 0.84 +/- 0.02), an image with reversed gray scale and moderate enhancement of medium frequencies (ROC area = 0.87 +/- 0.03), and an image with a linear rather than a sigmoid gradation curve and incorporating moderate enhancement of medium frequencies (ROC area = 0.87 +/- 0.03). The authors conclude that the specific algorithms they tested had no effect on the detection of pulmonary nodules.     

Calcification in pulmonary nodules: detection with dual-energy digital radiography

The authors undertook a clinical study to determine the accuracy of dual-energy digital radiography in revealing nodule calcification because calcification in a pulmonary nodule almost excludes the possibility of malignancy. Over a 6-month period, 61 patients with pulmonary nodules (less than or equal to 3 cm) or masses (greater than 3 cm) were examined on a prototype scanned projection unit using a dual-energy detector. In 49 of 61 patients, nodules were noncalcified, and in 12, they were calcified. In 57 patients, the benignancy or malignancy of nodules was established beyond reasonable doubt by pathologic confirmation in 38 and by strong inference in 19 (four patients with noncalcified solitary pulmonary nodules either refused further investigation or surgery or their follow-up was too short to permit exclusion of malignancy). Dual-energy radiography was found to be highly accurate in assessing the presence or absence of calcification in pulmonary nodules and thus in determining their benignancy or possible malignancy.     

Simulated pulmonary nodules: detection with dual-energy digital versus conventional radiography

Performance of a prototype dual-energy digital chest radiography unit in detecting calcified and noncalcified simulated pulmonary nodules was compared with that of a highly optimized, conventional system. Nodules ranging in size (0.5, 1.0, and 1.6 cm), in number (five to 11), and in calcium content (0-25 mg) were superimposed over the lungs of a frozen, unembalmed, human chest phantom. For each technique, six observers examined 50 posteroanterior projections with different randomized nodule locations. Detection consisted of locating and assigning a level of confidence to each perceived nodular opacity. The resulting plots of the true-positive fraction versus the mean number of false-positive calls per projection indicate that for both calcified and noncalcified nodules, the digital unit performed significantly better (P less than .01).     

A ROC study of AMBER and conventional chest imaging in the detection of simulated interstitial lung disease

Purpose: The aim of this study was to compare the detection of simulated interstitial lung disease with Advanced Multiple Beam Equalization Radiography (AMBER) and conventional wide latitude screen-film radiography.Materials and methods: Interstitial disease of varying severity was simulated with overlays on an anthropomorphic chest phantom. A total of 60 images per modality was used in a Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) study.Results: AMBER performed significantly better than conventional radiography for all readers (P < 0.02). The difference was even more significant for the radiologist readers (P = 0.001). In each case the difference in ROC areas was between 5% and 9%.Conclusion: AMBER is superior to conventional wide latitude screen-film imaging in detecting the subtle patterns used to simulate interstitial lung disease.     

数字合成体层成像和X线数字摄影在肺内结节探测中敏感度的比较

目的 比较数字合成体层成像(DTS)和普通X线数字摄影对肺内结节探测的敏感度,评价DTS检测肺内小结节的能力.方法 22名有肺内小结节的患者进行随访性CT检查,由2名放射医师共同对CT扫描图像进行阅读,来证实结节的存在并为其定位,作为结节存在的标准.另外为患者进行了后前位胸部X线数字摄影(PA)和DTS检查.再由另外3位胸部放射医师独立阅读DTS影像和PA影像,来确定CT所证实的结节在这两种影像上的显示情况.结节按以下标准进行分级:肯定可见,不确定,不可见.3个级别按直径大小分为以下三组:＜5,5～10,＞10mm.分析那些标记为肯定可见的结节的真阳性结果.结果 CT断层扫描共检出180个直径范围在3.5～19.5mm的结节,DTS和PA的敏感度分别是67％和23％(P＜0.0001).一致性检验表明,在所有三组不同大小的结节中,DTS和PA对肺内结节的检出率均有统计学差异,其中对小结节(直径＜5mm)的探测敏感度,两者分别达到49％和10％.结论 和PA相比,在各类大小不同的肺内小结节的探测中,DTS都显示出较大的敏感性.     

Detection of simulated nodules on clinical radiographs: dose reduction at digital posteroanterior chest radiography

PURPOSE: To determine to what extent dose reduction results in decreased detection of simulated nodules on patient digital posteroanterior (PA) chest radiographs. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Raw data from 20 clinical digital PA chest images that were reported as having normal findings and that were obtained with a slot-scan charge-coupled device system were used. For research protocol that concerns data with patient identities concealed, institutional review board approval is not required. One hundred twenty nodules varying in size and signal intensity were digitally simulated and added to the chest images. Hard copies were printed to represent a 100% dose and, by adding noise, to represent simulated patient doses of 50%, 25%, and 12%. Four radiologists reviewed images. Each lesion was registered as "detected" or "not detected." A semiparametric logistic regression model was used for statistical analysis. RESULTS: The decrease in radiation dose from 100% to 50%, 25%, or 12% had no effect on lesion detection in the lungs. The decrease in radiation dose had an effect on lesion detection in the mediastinum, as probabilities deteriorated from the 100% dose to the 50%, 25%, and 12% dose with each step. Probabilities of smaller detection rates when compared with that of the reference category (100% dose) were 0.97 (95% confidence interval [CI]: -0.86, 0.012) for the 50% dose, 1 (CI: -0.59, -0.61) for the 25% dose, and 1 (CI: -2.41, -1.22) for the 12% dose. CIs for the effects were on the log(odds). Detection probability decreased with smaller and lower signal intensity lesions. CONCLUSION: At clinical digital radiography, dose reduction resulted in decreased observer detection of simulated nodules in the mediastinum but not in the lungs.     

Comparison of chest radiography,chest digital tomosynthesis and low dose MDCT to detect small ground-glass opacity nodules: an anthropomorphic chest phantom study

Objectives

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the diagnostic performance of chest radiography (CXR), chest digital tomosynthesis (DT) and low dose multidetector computed tomography (LDCT) for the detection of small pulmonary ground-glass opacity (GGO) nodules, using an anthropomorphic chest phantom.

Methods

Artificial pulmonary nodules were placed in a phantom and a total of 40 samples of different nodule settings underwent CXR, DT and LDCT. The images were randomly read by three experienced chest radiologists. Free-response receiver-operating characteristics (FROC) were used.

Results

The figures of merit for the FROC curves averaged for the three observers were 0.41, 0.37 and 0.76 for CXR, DT and LDCT, respectively. FROC analyses revealed significantly better performance of LDCT over CXR or DT for the detection of GGO nodules (P?P?=?0.73).

Conclusion

The diagnostic performance of DT for the detection of pulmonary small GGO nodules was not significantly different from that of CXR, but LDCT performed significantly better than both CXR and DT. DT is not a suitable alternative to CT for small GGO nodule detection, and LDCT remains the method of choice for this purpose.

Key Points

? For GGO nodule detection, DT was not significantly different from CXR. ? DT is not a suitable alternative to CT for GGO nodule detection. ? LDCT is the method of choice for GGO nodule detection.     

Detection of bullous lung disease: conventional radiography vs digital storage phosphor radiography

The detection of fine linear contours and altered aeration are requirements for the radiologic diagnosis of bullous lung disease and are severe measures of the spatial and contrast resolution of chest imaging systems. We compared plain film radiography with five postprocessing algorithms of storage phosphor digital radiography (2144 x 1744 x 10 bit matrix with 0.2-mm pixel size) in the detection of CT-proved bullous lung disease (35 patients and 25 normal control subjects). Receiver-operating-characteristic analysis of 2160 observations by six interpreters was done to evaluate the observers' performance. By analysis of variance (p less than .05), we found that the default digital algorithm and the three edge-enhancing algorithms of high and medium frequencies performed less well than plain films did, but the differences fell short of statistical significance. Gray-scale reversal was the only digital algorithm that performed significantly less well than plain films did. We conclude that any differences between digital algorithms and plain films in the detection of bullous lung disease were too small to be detected in this study. Any difference between the two methods in providing clinically important, diagnostic information is likely to be insignificant.     

计算机辅助检测肺结节在数字化X线胸片肺癌筛查中的应用价值

目的 评价计算机辅助检测(CAD)肺结节系统在数字化X线胸片上肺癌筛查中的应用价值.方法 由1名放射科医师和CAD肺结节检测系统独立阅读100例连续的数字摄影(DR)X线胸片,CAD系统可以检出最长直径在5～15 mm的肺结节.由2名放射科专家(有15年胸部影像诊断经验)进行回顾性阅读,参照相应的CT图像,两人意见达成一致后标记真结节的个数和位置并保存标记结果,将标记结果作为金标准来比较放射科医师和CAD系统的肺结节检测敏感性和假阳性率.结果 放射科医师共检测到95个结节,CAD系统共检测到304个结节.在回顾性检查中2名放射科专家共标记134个真结节,其中放射科医师检测到82个(61.2%),CAD检测到105个(78.4%),CAD系统检测到而被放射科医师漏诊的结节35个,放射科医师检测到而CAD系统漏诊的结节10个.放射科医师应用CAD系统后检测到112个真结节,检测率提高到83.6%.放射科专家意见一致后认为CAD系统检出199个假阳性结节,平均每张胸片约2.0个.结论 在肺癌筛查中放射科医师和CAD系统必须联合应用才可以识别X线胸片中所有的结节.     

A comparison of dual-energy digital radiography and screen-film imaging in the detection of subtle interstitial pulmonary disease

An ROC study is described which compares the performance of three types of images--conventional screen-film, single-energy digital and dual energy bone cancelled (soft tissue) digital--in detecting subtle interstitial pulmonary disease. Marginally detectable nodular and reticulonodular patterns (12 different patterns of each) were superimposed over the lungs of a frozen human chest phantom to simulate the clinical situation. The digital images were formatted on film at full size (ie, 35 cm X 43 cm). A total of 156 images (52 of each type, of which 28 were normal and 24 had simulated pathology) were used in the study and read by five experienced chest radiologists. Using a paired t-test, the areas under the individual ROC curves were compared for three combinations of images--single-energy digital and conventional, soft tissue digital and conventional, and soft tissue and single-energy digital. No statistically significant difference was observed between the conventional and single-energy digital images. The readers performed better with both conventional and single-energy digital images than with the soft tissue digital images at statistically significant levels (P = 0.05 for conventional vs. soft tissue digital and P = 0.02 for single-energy digital vs. soft tissue digital). The results suggest that there is no advantage in employing dual-energy soft tissue images to assist in diagnosing interstitial disease in the clinical setting. They also suggest that spatial resolution requirements are less demanding in digital chest systems that obtain scatter-free images than in digital systems utilizing conventional scatter control techniques.     

Computed radiography and direct radiography: influence of acquisition dose on the detection of simulated lung lesions

PURPOSE: We sought to evaluate the performance of dual-readout and single-readout computed radiography compared with direct radiography for detecting subtle lung abnormalities with a standard and a low-dose technique. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Posteroanterior radiographs of an anthropomorphic chest phantom were obtained with a single-readout storage phosphor radiography system (CRS, pixel size 200 microm), a dual-readout storage phosphor radiography system (CRD, pixel size 100 microm), and a direct detector (DR, pixel size 143 microm) at dose levels of 400 and 800 speed. Ten templates were superimposed to project 4 types of lesions over low- and high-attenuation areas, simulating nodules, micronodules, lines, and patchy opacities. Six radiologists evaluated 60 hard-copy images for the presence or absence of lesions. Statistical significance of differences was evaluated using receiver operating characteristic analysis and analysis of variance. RESULTS: For both low- and high-attenuation areas, CRD (Az = 0.85 and 0.66) was superior to CRS (Az = 0.75 and 0.58) for overall performance and all lesion subtypes (P < 0.05). DR (Az = 0.87 and 0.67) performed slightly better than CRD, being significant only for the detection of micronodules. Acquisition dose significantly affected only the detection of lines and micronodules, whereas the detection of nodules and patchy opacities was not significantly different with reduced exposure, regardless of the system used. CONCLUSION: The dual-readout CR system significantly outperformed the single-readout CR and almost equaled the performance of DR. Dose reduction was more critical for small-sized lesions (micronodules, lines) than for nodular or patchy opacifications and affected mainly the lesions in high attenuation areas.     

Options for radiation dose optimisation in pelvic digital radiography: A phantom study

PurposeTo investigate the effects of phantom orientation and AEC chamber selection on radiation dose and image quality (IQ) for digital radiography (DR) examinations of the pelvis.MethodsA phantom study was conducted using a DR detector, utilising all AEC chamber combinations. Current recommended orientation (Cr-AEC) was with the outer AEC chambers cranially orientated. mAs (given), source-to-skin distance and kV_p data facilitated entrance surface dose and effective dose calculations. Six anatomical areas were blindly graded by two observers (3-point scale) for IQ. Statistical differences in radiation dose were determined using the paired Student’s t-test. IQ data was analysed for inter-observer variability (ICC) and statistical differences (Wilcoxon test).ResultsSwitching phantom orientation (caudally orientated outer AEC chambers: Ca-AEC) reduced mean radiation dose by 36.8%, (p < 0.001). A minor reduction in median IQ (15.5 vs. 15) was seen (p < 0.001). One Ca-AEC orientated image (1.6%) had all anatomical areas graded ‘inadequate’ by at least one observer; all other images were considered ‘adequate’ for all areas. In the Ca-AEC orientation, at least a 44% dose reduction was achievable (p < 0.001) when only the outer AEC chambers were used. In the Cr-AEC orientation, at least 11% dose reduction was achieved (p < 0.001); here the central chamber was used alone, or in combination. IQ scores fell, but remained ‘adequate’.ConclusionSwitching pelvic orientation relative to AEC chamber position can optimise radiation dose during pelvic radiography. AEC chamber position should be clearly marked on equipment to facilitate this. AEC selection should be an active process.     

Evaluation of the usefulness of color digital summation radiography in temporally sequential digital radiographs: a phantom study

Purpose The purpose of this study was to assess the usefulness of color digital summation radiography (CDSR) for detection of nodules on chest radiographs by observers with different levels of experience. Materials and methods A total of 30 radiographs of chest phantoms with abnormalities and 30 normal ones were arranged at random. Set A was conventional radiographs only. Set B consisted of both conventional radiographs and CDSR images, which were colored with magenta. Five chest radiologists and five residents evaluated both image sets on a TFT monitor. The observers were asked to rate each image set using a continuous rating scale. The reading time for each set was also recorded. Results In set A, the performance of chest radiologists was significantly superior to that of the residents (P < 0.05). However, in set B, there was no significant difference in the performance of the chest radiologists and the residents. In both observer groups, the mean reading time per case in set B was significantly shorter than that in set A (P < 0.01). Conclusion By using CDSR, the detection capability of observers with little experience improves and is comparable to that of experienced observers. Moreover, the reading time becomes much shorter using CDSR.     

FDG imaging of lung nodules: a phantom study comparing SPECT, camera-based PET, and dedicated PET

PURPOSE: To evaluate 2-[fluorine-18]fluoro-2-deoxy-D-glucose (FDG) imaging of simulated lung nodules in a realistic chest phantom by using attenuation-corrected and non-attenuation-corrected 511-keV single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT), camera-based positron emission tomography (PET), and dedicated PET imaging. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Spheres with diameters of 6, 10, 13, and 22 mm were placed in the lungs of an anthropomorphic chest phantom to simulate nodules. The lungs, nodules, chest wall, and mediastinum were filled with fluorine-18 activities based on the average radionuclide concentrations in those structures from analysis of attenuation-corrected dedicated FDG PET scans. The image sets were evaluated visually and quantitatively by using contrast and signal-to-noise ratios. RESULTS: Attenuation correction reduced the artificially high apparent uptake in the lungs, restored the spherical shape to the nodules, and provided an accurate outer body contour with appropriate intensity. Dedicated PET depicted all four nodules, camera-based PET depicted the three largest nodules, and SPECT depicted the two largest nodules. Lesion contrast was better on the attenuation-corrected images than on the non-attenuation-corrected images. The signal-to-noise ratio generally was improved with attenuation correction. CONCLUSION: Attenuation correction results in many changes in the images and improves lesion detection.