Acquisition of HLA-DR and Costimulatory Molecules by T Cells from Allogeneic Antigen Presenting Cells

There is accumulating evidence that cell surface molecules may be transferred between cells during an encounter. The aim of these experiments was to determine whether transfer of allogeneic material to T cells could influence human alloresponses. CD4(+) cells were cocultured with M1 cell (human fibroblast) transfectants expressing HLA-DR1, CD80 and CD86 alone or in combination. Up to 95% of the allogeneic T cells became positive for HLA-DR and the appropriate costimulatory molecules after only 4 h of coculture. The phenomenon required cell contact and cell membrane fluidity because transfer was abolished by transwell separation of the M1 cells and the T cells or by pre-treatment of the APC with paraformaldehyde. Flow cytometric sorting of T cells after coculture and subsequent mixed lymphocyte assays demonstrated that the T cells that had acquired both HLA-DR and costimulatory molecules could act as potent antigen presenting cells. Finally, matured human dendritic cells were also shown to transfer these molecules to CD4(+) cells, which could then act as antigen presenting cells for unprimed T cells and for a cell line specific for an HLA-peptide complex acquired from the DCs. Taken together, these data suggest a novel pathway for the amplification of human alloresponses.     

Rapamycin-Treated, Alloantigen-Pulsed Host Dendritic Cells Induce Ag-Specific T Cell Regulation and Prolong Graft Survival

Tolerogenic properties of dendritic cells (DC), particularly those in the immature state, and their therapeutic potential are increasingly being recognized. Among several distinct approaches to generate stably immature DC, pharmacologic manipulation stands out as a promising and clinically applicable option. We have shown recently that the immunophilin ligand rapamycin (Rapa) can inhibit DC maturation and their effector functions. Here, we examined the impact of Rapa exposure on subsequent alloantigen (Ag) presentation by myeloid DC via the indirect pathway. Rapa-treated, allogeneic lysate-pulsed host DC (Rapa-DC) were inferior stimulators of syngeneic T cells, compared to lysate-pulsed control DC. Rapa exposure did not block alloAg uptake by DC nor impair their in vivo homing to splenic T cell areas after adoptive transfer. T cells primed by Rapa-treated, alloAg-pulsed DC showed decreased capacity to produce IL-2 and IFNgamma, and were hyporesponsive to subsequent challenge via both the direct and indirect pathways, in an Ag-specific manner. When infused 1 week before transplantation, these Rapa-DC significantly prolonged alloAg-specific heart graft survival. This effect was reversed by systemic IL-2 administration but enhanced by either repeated infusion of the cells or a short post-transplant course of FK506. These therapeutic effects, achieved by targeting both major pathways of allorecognition, provide the basis for a clinically applicable strategy to suppress graft rejection.     

Hyperlipidemia Alters Regulatory T Cell Function and Promotes Resistance to Tolerance Induction Through Costimulatory Molecule Blockade

Recent work from our laboratory has shown that hyperlipidemia promotes accelerated rejection of vascularized cardiac allografts in mice by inducing anti‐donor Th17 reactivity and production of IL‐17. Here, we show that hyperlipidemia also affects FoxP3⁺ regulatory T cells (Tregs). Hyperlipidemia promotes the development of Tregs that express low levels of CD25. Hyperlipidemia also promotes a decrease in central Tregs and an increase in effector Tregs that appears to account for the increase in the frequency of CD25^low Tregs. Alterations in Treg subsets also appear to lead to alterations in Treg function. The ability of FoxP3⁺, CD25^high_, CD4⁺ Tregs from hyperlipidemic mice to inhibit proliferation of effector T cells stimulated with anti‐CD3 and CD28 was reduced when compared with Tregs from control mice. Regulatory T cells isolated from hyperlipidemic recipients exhibit increased activation of Akt, and a reduction in Bim levels that permits the expansion of FoxP3⁺CD25^lowCD4⁺ T cells. Hyperlipidemic mice were also resistant to tolerance induction using costimulatory molecule blockade consisting of anti‐CD154 and CTLA4Ig, a strategy that requires Tregs. Together, our data suggest that hyperlipidemia profoundly affects Treg subsets and function as well as the ability to induce tolerance.     

Role of the Liver in Peripheral Tolerance: Induction Through Oral Antigen Feeding

Using a murine liver transplant model, we studied the liver's role in peripheral tolerance. Livers from BALB/c mice fed with ovalbumin (OVA) at either a low or high dose were transplanted into syngeneic recipients. Non‐fed recipients were controls. Orthotopic liver transplantation (OLTx) was followed by OVA immunization and delayed‐type hypersensitivity (DTH) challenge. The ex vivo adoptive transfer effect of liver nonparenchymal cells (NPCs) or spleen cells (SCs) from OVA‐fed mice was examined. In vitro proliferative assays and cytokine profiles were conducted on NPCs and SCs from transplant recipients. Livers from all OVA‐fed mice after 10 days transferred tolerance to OVA‐naïve mice. The time course of adoptive transfer of liver NPCs from high‐dose OVA‐fed mice transferred OVA tolerance within 24 h; low‐dose OVA‐fed mice required ≥ 4 days to transfer tolerance. The in vitro proliferative response of the NPCs to OVA revealed a decreased response in both dosage groups over the control group. Our results suggest that the liver plays an important role in inducing peripheral tolerance in a mucosal tolerance model, especially feeding high‐dose OVA.     

Porcine Antigen Presenting Cells Produce Soluble Adjuvants That Stimulate B cells Within and Across the Species

Interactions between porcine antigen presenting cells (pAPCs) and host lymphocytes may be important in cellular and humoral rejection of porcine organ xenografts. To investigate the role of pAPCs in the activation of xenogeneic lymphocytes, porcine bone marrow cells were stimulated using porcine GM-CSF with or without porcine IL-4 to generate populations of pAPCs that had phenotypic characteristics of myeloid dendritic cells. These bone marrow-derived pAPCs were weak stimulators of xenogeneic (mouse and human) T cells in vitro but induced primary B-cell proliferation and augmented CD40-induced B-cell proliferation. Inoculation of mice with small numbers of pAPCs resulted in localized expansion of lymph node B cells. The mitogenic effect on xenogeneic B cells could be reproduced by medium in which pAPCs had been cultured, implicating one or more soluble products. In blocking experiments IL-12, IL-6, and IL-10 were found not to contribute to the mitogenic effect of pAPC medium. In contrast, pIFN was found to be capable of augmenting CD40-induced proliferation of xenogeneic B-cell proliferation but did not act as a B-cell mitogen. We conclude that myeloid APCs from the pig produce soluble factors that are capable of acting as primary mitogens for xenogeneic B cells as well as augmenting additional B-cell activating stimuli. This direct interaction between porcine APCs and xenogeneic B cells may serve as an important adjuvant for the stimulation of humoral immunity to porcine xenografts.     

Abortive alloantigen presentation by donor dendritic cells leads to donor-specific tolerance: a study with a preoperative CTLA4Ig inoculation

Donor dendritic cells (DCs) within allografts initiate the induction of an allospecific T cell response, while an abortive alloantigen presentation by DCs may induce allospecific unresponsiveness. We thus investigated the tolerogenic effect of donor DCs that were made incompetent in alloantigen presentation by treatment of CTLA4Ig. When we treated rats with donor DCs (2 × 10⁶/rat i.v.) on the preoperative day, nine rejected allografts in an accelerated manner (5.0 ± 2.2 vs. 8.2 ± 1.6 days in the control group). Preoperative inoculation of DCs pulsed with CTLA4Ig, a procedure which suppresses an allogeneic mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR), also provoked an accelerated rejection (5.6 ± 1.7 days). When DCs and CTLA4Ig (500 μg/rat i.p. on days −9, −7 and −5) were concomitantly inoculated, allograft survival was significantly prolonged (>38.7 ± 40.0 days); a preoperative CTLA4Ig inoculation alone failed to do so (7.5 ± 1.2 days). Long-term graft survivors tolerated skin grafts from the donor but not from those from a third party. These results indicate that abortive alloantigen presentation by donor DCs, upon which an accessory signal pathway is suppressed by CTLA4Ig, leads to prolonged graft survival and donor-specific tolerance. Received: 12 June 1999 / Accepted: 1 October 1999     

CD154 Regulates Primate Humoral Immunity to Influenza

Current methods of immunosuppression for the purposes of allowing solid organ transplantation in humans are broadly inhibitory and thus are associated with an increased risk of opportunistic infections and neoplasia. We have shown previously that a selective blockade of CD40-CD154 interactions during heart transplantation in cynomolgus macaques significantly delays immune-mediated graft injury. Here, we determined the effect of anti-CD154 mAb therapy on primate serologic responses to immunization with influenza virus hemagglutinin (HA), a T-cell-dependent Ag. We found that CD154 blockade attenuated primary and secondary serum Ab responses of IgM and IgG isotypes to influenza, even when anti-CD154 treatment was discontinued prior to reimmunization. These findings show that in primates CD40-CD154 interactions are necessary for both primary and secondary Ab responses to viral Ags. Furthermore, the data suggest that viral Ag stimulation of primates in the absence of CD154 stimulation may have a tolerizing effect on that Ag.     

The Role of Non-Deletional Tolerance Mechanisms in a Murine Model of Mixed Chimerism with Costimulation Blockade

Peripheral and central clonal deletion are important tolerance mechanisms in models using bone marrow transplantation (BMT) with costimulation blockade (CB). However, since tolerance can be found before peripheral deletion is complete and since elimination of recipient CD4(+) cells at the time of BMT prevents tolerance induction, we investigated the potential roles of regulation and anergy in such a murine model. We found that transient elimination of CD25(+) cells or neutralization of IL2 immediately after BMT and CB prevented the induction of skin graft tolerance. Cotransfer into SCID mice of CD4(+) cells taken from chimeras early after BMT, together with naive recipient-type CD4(+) cells significantly prolonged donor skin graft survival. In contrast, cotransfer of CD4(+) cells harvested from chimeras late after BMT did not prolong donor skin graft survival. Besides, depletion of CD25(+) cells in established chimeras several months post-BMT did not break tolerance. In vivo administration of recombinant IL2 inhibited chimerism and tolerance neither early nor late post-BMT, arguing against a decisive role for classical anergy. Thus, CD4 cell-mediated regulation contributes significantly to tolerance induction early after BMT, but appears to have no critical role in the maintenance of tolerance.     

Persistence of Antigen Is Required to Maintain Transplantation Tolerance Induced by Genetic Modification of Bone Marrow Stem Cells

Genetic modification of hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) resulting in a state of molecular chimerism can be used to induce donor-specific tolerance to allografts. However, the requirements for maintaining tolerance in molecular chimeras remain unknown. Here, we examined whether long-term expression of a retrovirally encoded alloantigen in hematopoietic cells is required to maintain donor-specific tolerance in molecular chimeras. To this end, mice were reconstituted with syngeneic bone marrow transduced with retroviruses carrying the gene encoding the allogeneic MHC class I molecule Kb. Following induction of molecular chimerism, mice were depleted of cells expressing Kb by administration of the anti-Kb monoclonal antibody Y-3. Mice that were effectively depleted of cells expressing the retrovirally encoded MHC class I antigen rejected Kb disparate skin allografts. In contrast, control molecular chimeras accepted Kb disparate skin allografts indefinitely. These data suggest maintenance of tolerance in molecular chimeras requires long-term expression of retrovirally transduced alloantigen on the progeny of retrovirally transduced HSCs.     

Combined Islet and Hematopoietic Stem Cell Allotransplantation: A Clinical Pilot Trial to Induce Chimerism and Graft Tolerance

To prevent graft rejection and avoid immunosuppression-related side-effects, we attempted to induce recipient chimerism and graft tolerance in islet transplantation by donor CD34+hematopoietic stem cell (HSC) infusion. Six patients with brittle type 1 Diabetes Mellitus received a single-donor allogeneic islet transplant (8611 ± 2113 IEQ/kg) followed by high doses of donor HSC (4.3 ± 1.9 × 10⁶ HSC/kg), at days 5 and 11 posttransplant, without ablative conditioning. An 'Edmonton-like' immunosuppression was administered, with a single dose of anti-TNFα antibody (Infliximab) added to induction. Immunosuppression was weaned per protocol starting 12 months posttransplant. After transplantation, glucose control significantly improved, with 3 recipients achieving insulin-independence for a short time (24 ± 23 days). No severe hypoglycemia or protocol-related adverse events occurred. Graft function was maximal at 3 months then declined. Two recipients rejected within 6 months due to low immunosuppressive trough levels, whereas 4 completed 1-year follow-up with functioning grafts. Graft failure occurred within 4 months from weaning (478 ± 25 days posttransplant). Peripheral chimerism, as donor leukocytes, was maximal at 1-month (5.92 ± 0.48%), highly reduced at 1-year (0.20 ± 0.08%), and was undetectable at graft failure. CD25+T-lymphocytes significantly decreased at 3 months, but partially recovered thereafter. Combined islet and HSC allotransplantation using an 'Edmonton-like' immunosuppression, without ablative conditioning, did not lead to stable chimerism and graft tolerance.     

Dendritic Cells: Tools and Targets for Transplant Tolerance

Our knowledge of the role of dendritic cells (DC) in the generation and maintenance of T-cell tolerance has expanded rapidly and is now a key area of research in basic and applied DC biology. This minireview highlights recent developments in the field that are leading to new avenues for exploiting DC in the promotion of transplant tolerance.     

Rapamycin and CTLA4Ig Synergize to Induce Stable Mixed Chimerism Without the Need for CD40 Blockade

The mixed chimerism approach achieves donor‐specific tolerance in organ transplantation, but clinical use is inhibited by the toxicities of current bone marrow (BM) transplantation (BMT) protocols. Blocking the CD40:CD154 pathway with anti‐CD154 monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) is exceptionally potent in inducing mixed chimerism, but these mAbs are clinically not available. Defining the roles of donor and recipient CD40 in a murine allogeneic BMT model, we show that CD4 or CD8 activation through an intact direct or CD4 T cell activation through the indirect pathway is sufficient to trigger BM rejection despite CTLA4Ig treatment. In the absence of CD4 T cells, CD8 T cell activation via the direct pathway, in contrast, leads to a state of split tolerance. Interruption of the CD40 signals in both the direct and indirect pathway of allorecognition or lack of recipient CD154 is required for the induction of chimerism and tolerance. We developed a novel BMT protocol that induces mixed chimerism and donor‐specific tolerance to fully mismatched cardiac allografts relying on CD28 costimulation blockade and mTOR inhibition without targeting the CD40 pathway. Notably, MHC‐mismatched/minor antigen‐matched skin grafts survive indefinitely whereas fully mismatched grafts are rejected, suggesting that non‐MHC antigens cause graft rejection and split tolerance.     

Induction of Alloimmune Tolerance in Heart Transplantation Through Gene Silencing of TLR Adaptors

Toll‐like receptors (TLRs) activate biochemical pathways that evoke activation of innate immunity, which leads to dendritic cell (DC) maturation and initiation of adaptive immune responses that provoke allograft rejection. We aimed to prolong allograft survival by selectively inhibiting expression of the common adaptors of TLR signaling, namely MyD88 and TRIF, using siRNA. In vitro we demonstrated that blocking expression of MyD88 and TRIF led to reduced DC maturation. In vivo treatment of recipients with MyD88 and TRIF siRNA significantly prolonged allograft survival in the BALB/c > C57BL6 cardiac transplant model. Moreover, the combination of MyD88 and TRIF siRNA along with a low dose of rapamycin further extended the allograft survival (88.8 ± 7.1 days). Tissue histopathology demonstrated an overall reduction in lymphocyte interstitium infiltration, vascular obstruction and hemorrhage in mice treated with MyD88 and TRIF siRNA vector plus rapamycin. Furthermore, treatment was associated with an increase in the numbers of CD4⁺CD25⁺FoxP3⁺ regulatory T cells and Th2 deviation. To our knowledge, this study is the first demonstration of prolonging the survival of allogeneic heart grafts through gene silencing of TLR signaling adaptors, highlighting the therapeutic potential of siRNA in clinical transplantation.     

Regulatory T Cells Are Critical to Tolerance Induction in Presensitized Mouse Transplant Recipients Through Targeting Memory T Cells

Memory T cells are a significant barrier to induction of transplant tolerance. However, reliable means to target alloreactive memory T cells have remained elusive. In this study, presensitization of BALB/c mice with C57BL/6 skin grafts generated a large number of OX40⁺CD44^hieffector/memory T cells and resulted in rapid rejection of donor heart allografts. Recognizing that anti‐OX40L monoclonal antibody (mAb) (α‐OX40L) monotherapy prolonged graft survival through inhibition and apoptosis of memory T cells in presensitized recipients, α‐OX40L was added to the combined treatment protocol of LF15–0195 (LF) and anti‐CD45RB (α‐CD45RB) mAb—a protocol that induced heart allograft tolerance in non‐presensitized recipients but failed to induce tolerance in presensitized recipients. Interestingly, this triple therapy restored donor‐specific heart allograft tolerance in our presensitized model that was associated with induction of tolerogenic dendritic cells and CD4⁺CD25⁺Foxp3⁺ T regulatory cells (Tregs). Of note, CD25⁺ T cell depletion in triple therapy recipients prevented establishment of allograft tolerance. In addition, adoptive transfer of donor‐primed effector/memory T cells into tolerant recipients markedly reduced levels of Tregs and broke tolerance. Our findings indicated that targeting memory T cells, by blocking OX40 costimulation in presensitized recipients was very important to expansion of Tregs, which proved critical to development of tolerance.     

Clinical Trials of Transplant Tolerance: Slow But Steady Progress

The search for tolerance therapies that would thwart the alloimmune response following organ transplantation while preserving a patient's protective immune response has been a formidable goal for clinical immunologists. Over the past few decades, a more detailed understanding of the molecular events associated with T-cell recognition and activation has demonstrated the feasibility of various tolerance approaches, such as costimulation blockade, in numerous animal models of both autoimmunity and transplantation. Yet, only a few promising new therapies have reached the early stages of human clinical development. In contrast, the use of T-cell depleting induction therapy has become widespread, and new trials have been designed with immunosuppressive drug withdrawal in mind. Furthermore, nonmyeloablative mixed chimeric approaches have allowed complete immunosuppressive withdrawal in some limited cases. In the course of these investigations, however, what has become increasingly clear is that the distinctions between immunosuppression and tolerance have been blurred as the success and durability of the therapies rely as much on the state of the organ and organism as they do the mechanism of action of the drug. In this review, we provide a summary of the progress and lessons in promoting clinical transplant tolerance and an overview of promising agents.     

Origin of Enriched Regulatory T Cells in Patients Receiving Combined Kidney–Bone Marrow Transplantation to Induce Transplantation Tolerance

We examined tolerance mechanisms in patients receiving HLA‐mismatched combined kidney–bone marrow transplantation (CKBMT) that led to transient chimerism under a previously published nonmyeloablative conditioning regimen (Immune Tolerance Network study 036). Polychromatic flow cytometry and high‐throughput sequencing of T cell receptor‐β hypervariable regions of DNA from peripheral blood regulatory T cells (Tregs) and CD4 non‐Tregs revealed marked early enrichment of Tregs (CD3⁺CD4⁺CD25^highCD127^lowFoxp3⁺) in blood that resulted from peripheral proliferation (Ki67⁺), possibly new thymic emigration (CD31⁺), and, in one tolerant subject, conversion from non‐Tregs. Among recovering conventional T cells, central memory CD4⁺ and CD8⁺ cells predominated. A large proportion of the T cell clones detected in posttransplantation biopsy specimens by T cell receptor sequencing were detected in the peripheral blood and were not donor‐reactive. Our results suggest that enrichment of Tregs by new thymic emigration and lymphopenia‐driven peripheral proliferation in the early posttransplantation period may contribute to tolerance after CKBMT. Further, most conventional T cell clones detected in immunologically quiescent posttransplantation biopsy specimens appear to be circulating cells in the microvasculature rather than infiltrating T cells.     

The Natural History of Clinical Operational Tolerance After Kidney Transplantation Through Twenty‐Seven Cases

We report here on a European cohort of 27 kidney transplant recipients displaying operational tolerance, compared to two cohorts of matched kidney transplant recipients under immunosuppression and patients who stopped immunosuppressive drugs and presented with rejection. We report that a lower proportion of operationally tolerant patients received induction therapy (52% without induction therapy vs. 78.3%[p = 0.0455] and 96.7%[p = 0.0001], respectively), a difference likely due to the higher proportion (18.5%) of HLA matched recipients in the tolerant cohort. These patients were also significantly older at the time of transplantation (p = 0.0211) and immunosuppression withdrawal (p = 0.0002) than recipients who rejected their graft after weaning. Finally, these patients were at lower risk of infectious disease. Among the 27 patients defined as operationally tolerant at the time of inclusion, 19 still display stable graft function (mean 9 ± 4 years after transplantation) whereas 30% presented slow deterioration of graft function. Six of these patients tested positive for pre‐graft anti‐HLA antibodies. Biopsy histology studies revealed an active immunologically driven mechanism for half of them, associated with DSA in the absence of C4d. This study suggests that operational tolerance can persist as a robust phenomenon, although eventual graft loss does occur in some patients, particularly in the setting of donor‐specific alloantibody.