Open vs laparoscopic partial posterior fundoplication

Objective This study compares outcomes following open and laparoscopic partial posterior fundoplication for gastroesophageal reflux disease concerning perioperative course, postoperative complications, symptomatic relief, recurrent disease, and the need for reinterventional surgery. Methods A prospective randomized trial was performed. Pre- and postoperative testing included endoscopy, esophageal function testing, patient questionnaire, and clinical assessment. Patients were followed for three years. Materials Ninety-three patients were randomized to open and 99 to laparoscopic surgery. Results Complication rates were higher, and length of stay (LOS) [5 (3–36) vs 3 (1–12) days] and time off work [42 (12–76) vs 28 (0–108) days] was longer in the open group (p < 0.01). Early side effects and recurrences were more common (p < 0.05) in the laparoscopic group. One patient in the open group and 8 patients in the laparoscopic group required surgery for recurrent disease and 7 patients required surgery for incisional hernias after open surgery. Overall, at one and three years, there were no differences in patient-assessed satisfactory outcome (93.5/93.5 vs 88.8/90.8%) or reflux control (p = 0.53) between the open and laparoscopic groups. Conclusions The finding of fewer general complications, shorter length of stay and recovery, similar need for reoperations, and comparable 3-year outcomes, makes the laparoscopic approach the primary choice when considering surgical options for the treatment of gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD).     

Early reoperation for acute dysphagia following laparoscopic fundoplication

BACKGROUND: A small number of patients develop acute severe dysphagia for which reoperation is necessary within 10 days of laparoscopic fundoplication. The aim of this study was to identify clinical variables that might predict the likelihood of this condition occurring, such that it could be avoided in the future. METHODS: This was a prospective cohort study from three tertiary referral centres, using reoperation for acute dysphagia as the main outcome variable. Gastrointestinal symptom rating scale, and psychological well-being index questionnaires were undertaken before laparoscopic fundoplication, and dysphagia scores were determined before operation and 1 year later. Standard preoperative assessment included gastroscopy, oesophageal manometry and pH studies. RESULTS: Twelve (1.9 per cent) of the 617 patients suffered acute dysphagia, which was predicted by older age and female sex, and resulted in a longer duration of hospital stay. This condition was not predicted by any other demographic, clinical, investigative or operative variables. CONCLUSION: The study did not identify useful criteria by which severe acute dysphagia could be anticipated and thereby avoided following laparoscopic fundoplication.     

Gastrointestinal quality of life before and after laparoscopic heller myotomy with partial posterior fundoplication

OBJECTIVE: To assess the outcome of laparoscopic Heller myotomy for achalasia using a specific quality of life (QoL) instrument for gastrointestinal disorders. SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA: Current therapies for achalasia do not restore normal esophageal motility but aim at palliating dysphagia. However, many other symptoms may persist that cannot be assessed objectively by currently available symptom scores. Although generic QoL instruments have shown improvement in QoL after myotomy, disease-specific QoL instruments may be more responsive to change and therefore more reliable for comparing outcomes of therapeutic options for achalasia. METHODS: The Gastrointestinal Quality of Life Index (GIQLI) was studied before and after laparoscopic Heller myotomy associated with posterior partial fundoplication. RESULTS: Starting in January 1991, 73 consecutive patients were operated on laparoscopically for various clinical stages of achalasia. Since 1996, 40 patients completed a GIQLI questionnaire both preoperatively and after a minimum postoperative follow-up of 1 year. Median preoperative GIQLI score was 84 (range 34-129) out of a theoretical maximum score of 144. At a median follow-up of 31 months (range 12-54), the score had significantly improved to 119 (range 77-143), close to the range for the normal French population. Not only items assessing gastrointestinal symptoms but also the domains of physical, social, and emotional function were significantly improved. The most marked improvements were achieved in patients with the lowest preoperative scores. CONCLUSIONS: The GIQLI allows us to objectify the impact of achalasia symptoms on health-related QoL. At medium-term follow-up, laparoscopic Heller myotomy, performed either as primary treatment or after endoscopic dilation, significantly improves most health-related QoL aspects. Short of randomized comparisons between the different therapeutic options available for achalasia, reported series could be made more comparable if validated QoL instruments specific for gastrointestinal disorders were used routinely for outcome evaluation.     

Laparoscopic partial fundoplication vs laparoscopic Nissen-Rosetti fundoplication

Background: Since 1992, all patients at our institution who have met standard accepted criteria for surgical intervention for complicated gastroesophageal reflux disease have been entered into a prospective sequential clinical study to evaluate outcomes of the laparoscopic approach to the Nissen-Rosetti procedure and a modified Toupet procedure. Methods: A standardized workup with upper GI series, esophagography, and endoscopy was used in all patients. Manometry, pH testing, and other special tests were used selectively. A measuring technique was used to determine wrap size without the use of dilators. The short gastric vessels were left intact in all patients. A cosurgeon approach was used, with technical factors described herein. Results: Some 226 of 231 cases were completed laparoscopically (98%)—125 patients in the Nissen-Rosetti group and 101 in the partial fundoplication group. There were no clinical failures in either group. The partial fundoplication group performed better than the Nissen-Rosetti group in all categories of comparison. Return to normal eating habits was much earlier in the partial wrap group (p < 0.0001). Postop distal esophageal sphincter pressures in the two groups were equal at 15 mmHg. Eight patients suffered significant dysphagia requiring endoscopy and dilatation, all in the Nissen-Rosetti group (p < 0.01). Minor complications occurred in 12% of the total group. There was a total surgical revision rate of 3%. There were no gastric or esophageal perforations. Average operative time was 30 min. Average hospital stay was 1.4 days. Hospital charges for the laparoscopic approach averaged $6,000 dollars compared to $12,000 for the open approach. Conclusion: Laparoscopic partial fundoplication is as effective as laparoscopic Nissen-Rosetti fundoplication, with a higher satisfaction rate and fewer side effects. Measuring for wrap and hiatus size eliminates the need for and risk of using stiff dilators. By utilizing cosurgeons and currently available technology, cost, operative time, hospital time, and complications can be reduced to a finite minimum. Received: 12 December 1995/Accepted: 12 August 1996     

Symptoms and reflux competence in relation to anatomical findings at reoperation after laparoscopic total fundoplication.

OBJECTIVE: To investigate the mechanisms and anatomical failures after total laparoscopic fundoplication using the symptoms and findings at reoperation. DESIGN: Prospective open study. SETTING: University hospital, Sweden. PATIENTS: Twenty-one patients who were reoperated on a median of 33 (0.5-102) months after laparoscopic fundoplication. INTERVENTIONS: The patients were divided into three groups according to the mode of presentation. The first group presented with dysphagia and no gastro-oesophageal reflux (GOR) (n = 6). The second group (n = 11) had recurrent GOR and the third group (n = 4) complained of a sense of excessive fullness. RESULTS: In the dysphagia group the reason for it in 4 patients was severe fibrosis in the hiatal region including the right part of the fundoplication. One patient had correctly located fundoplication but it was too tight. In the last patient the part of the stomach used was too low down. All patients in the GOR group had a slippage and rupture of the fundoplication. Ten patients also had a recurrent hernia. In 6/11 patients the fundal mobilisation was incomplete. In the last group (excessive fullness) one patient had a postoperative leak from the fundal part, one patient a para-oesophageal hernia, and one patient an intact but herniated repair. One further patient had an intact abdominal oesophagus and crural repair, but a large portion of the stomach had herniated through the left part of the fundoplication and acted as a volvulus. CONCLUSIONS: Dysphagia was caused by hiatal fibrosis or other technical failures rather than a normal tight fundoplication. Using the wrong part of the stomach causes recurrent heartburn. The laparoscopic suturing technique must be improved.     

Gastric emptying and vagus nerve function after laparoscopic partial fundoplication

OBJECTIVE: To establish the relation between vagus nerve dysfunction, gastric emptying, and antireflux surgery. SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA: Delayed gastric emptying occurs in up to 40% of reflux patients. After antireflux surgery, gastric emptying becomes normal or is even accelerated. Occasionally, severe gastric stasis is found and is associated with a negative outcome of the antireflux procedure. It has been suggested that injury to the vagus nerve could be the cause of this delayed emptying. METHODS: We evaluated in a prospective study gastric emptying of solids and vagus nerve function (pancreatic polypeptide response to hypoglycemia) before and after surgery in 41 patients (22 women; age 43 +/- 1.6 years) who underwent laparoscopic hemifundoplication. RESULTS: All patients had relief of reflux symptoms varying from adequate (n = 8) to complete relief (n = 33). Gastric emptying of solids increased significantly (P < 0.001) after operation: lag phase from 19 +/- 2 to 10 +/- 1 minute, emptying rate (%/h) from 37 +/- 2 to 48 +/- 5 and half emptying time from 110 +/- 8 to 81 +/- 4 minutes. Gastric emptying improved to a similar extent in patients with delayed and normal preoperative gastric emptying. Postoperative signs of vagus nerve damage (PP peak < 47pmol/L) were present in 4 patients (10%). In these 4 patients gastric emptying both before and after operation did not differ from patients with normal vagus nerve function. In fact, none of the 41 patients had severely delayed emptying after laparoscopic hemifundoplication. CONCLUSIONS: Laparoscopic hemifundoplication affects vagus nerve integrity in 10% of patients, but this does not lead to a delay in gastric emptying. In fact, gastric emptying improved significantly after fundoplication.     

Hiatus calibration decreases postoperative dysphagia after laparoscopic fundoplication: case-report study

STUDY AIM: The risk of dysphagia after antireflux surgery seems to be increased with laparoscopy compared with open surgery. Calibration of the hiatus is usually done by the surgeon's finger during open surgery. The aim of this study was to assess the results of laparoscopic calibration with a Fogarty balloon catheter. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Between 1999 and 2001, 21 patients had a laparoscopic Toupet 240 degrees fundoplication with hiatus calibration using a 4 ml-inflated 8G Fogarty balloon catheter. These patients were compared with a group of 21 patients without hiatus calibration, matched for age, sex, preoperative dysphagia and esophageal dysmotility. Judgment criteria was early and/or late postoperative dysphagia (> 3 months). RESULTS: Median follow-up was 13 months. The rate of early dysphagia with and without calibration were 66% and 48% respectively (NS). Median duration of early dysphagia with and without calibration were 25 and 43 days respectively (p = 0.05). No patient with calibration had late dysphagia. One patient (5%) without calibration had unexplained late dysphagia for 2 years. He had preoperative esophageal dysmotility without oesophagitis. CONCLUSION: Hiatus calibration with a Fogarty balloon catheter decreased early postoperative dysphagia duration after Toupet laparoscopic fundoplication. This easily reproducible technical point standardizes the hiatus closure and should be recommended.     

Early reoperation following laparoscopic antireflux surgery

PURPOSE: To assess the outcome for patients undergoing early reoperation following laparoscopic antireflux surgery. METHODS: The outcome was prospectively determined for 28 patients who underwent 30 reoperative procedures within 4 weeks of their initial laparoscopic fundoplication between 1992 and 1998. Follow-up ranged from 3 months to 4 years (median 2 years). Before mid 1994, patients were assessed and managed based on clinical findings (first 192 patients in overall series), whereas subsequently (for the most recent 530 patients) all patients underwent routine early postoperative barium swallow radiography, and laparoscopic exploration during the first postoperative week if problems were suspected. RESULTS: The reoperations were performed for acute paraoesophageal hiatus hernia (8 patients), tight oesophageal hiatus (7), postoperative haemorrhage (3), tight Nissen fundoplication (8), early recurrent reflux (1), and coeliac/superior mesenteric artery thrombosis (1). Two patients required a second operation for persistent dysphagia due to a tight hiatus. Both patients initially underwent loosening of their fundoplication. Before mid 1994, reoperations were usually undertaken by an open approach, whereas subsequently a laparoscopic approach has usually been successful. Laparoscopic reintervention was easily achieved within 7 days of the first procedure whereas subsequent surgery was more difficult and often required open surgery. The change in protocol was associated with an improvement in overall patient satisfaction and dysphagia in the latter part of this experience. CONCLUSIONS: Routine early contrast radiology following laparoscopic fundoplication and a low threshold for laparoscopic reexploration facilitates early identification of postoperative problems at a time when laparoscopic correction is easily achieved. This may result in an improved overall outcome for patients requiring early reintervention following laparoscopic antireflux surgery.     

Repeat antireflux surgery: effectiveness of a toupet partial posterior fundoplication.

OBJECTIVE: To report the feasibility and efficacy of posterior partial fundoplication for patients with recurrent reflux after previous antireflux operations. DESIGN: Prospective non-randomised single hospital study. SETTING: University hospital, Sweden. PATIENTS: 32 consecutive patients who required reoperation after failure of previous operations for gastro-oesophageal reflux disease. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Control of symptoms, oesophageal acid reflux. RESULTS: Most patients were referred for reoperation because of recurrent reflux, but six patients had a symptomatic intrahoracic herniation of the wrap with a life-threatening perforation in one patient. Three patients had recurrent reflux within 6 months of the operation and another two were classified as failures. The remaining 27 (84%) were classified as having a successful outcome during a mean follow-up period of 20 months. CONCLUSION: A posterior partial fundoplication can be done safely in a repeat operation for patients whose antireflux operation has failed.     

Prospective study of symptoms and gastro-oesophageal reflux 10 years after posterior partial fundoplication.

BACKGROUND: This was a prospective study of symptoms, and short-term and long-term reflux competence after partial fundoplication. METHODS: Some 101 patients were operated consecutively with posterior partial (270 degrees ) fundoplication. Indications for surgery were reflux disease without erosive oesophagitis in 25 patients, moderate oesophagitis in 43, severe oesophagitis in 25 and paraoesophageal hernia in eight. Symptom score, manometry and pH tests were performed before operation, 6 months after operation and after 6-14 years. RESULTS: All patients (n = 101) were free from heartburn and regurgitation at early follow-up. There was evidence of clinical recurrence at late follow-up (n = 87) in two of 22 patients without oesophagitis before operation, two of 39 with moderate oesophagitis before operation and three of 19 patients with severe oesophagitis before operation; 92 per cent had good reflux control at late follow-up. CONCLUSION: Posterior partial fundoplication shows excellent reflux control at early follow-up. Ten years later fewer than 10 per cent of patients have recurrence, which is more common in patients who had severe oesophagitis before operation.     

Early postoperative seizures after posterior fossa surgery

A review is reported of the seizure incidence in 726 patients who underwent 740 posterior fossa operations via a suboccipital craniectomy without prophylactic anticonvulsant agents. Thirteen patients (1.8%) experienced seizures within 2 weeks postoperatively. Five of these patients (0.7% of the series) had seizures within 24 hours after operation. The incidence was highest for patients with medulloblastoma (7.2%) followed by those with astrocytoma (2.3%). Also, a higher percentage was found in patients with preoperative ventriculoperitoneal shunt or intraoperative ventriculostomy (2.7%) than in those without (1%), but the difference was not statistically significant. Metabolic acidosis (80%) and hyponatremia (20%) were the major causes of the seizures that developed within 24 hours after operation. Follow-up computerized tomography showed no definite lesion in these patients. Hydrocephalus (75%) and supratentorial hemorrhage remote from the operative site (25%) were detected in the patients who developed seizures between the 2nd and 14th postoperative day. Two of these patients also had postoperative bacterial meningitis. This review suggests that seizures are a possible complication in the early postoperative period after suboccipital craniectomy for posterior fossa lesions.     

Postprandial bloating after laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication.

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the prevalence and possible contributing factors to postprandial bloating in patients having chronic gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) before and after laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication. DESIGN: A prospective cohort study. SETTING: A tertiary care teaching hospital. PATIENTS: Five hundred and seventy-eight patients with proven GERD. INTERVENTION: Laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication. OUTCOME MEASURES: Symptom severity scores for postprandial bloating and dysphagia, esophageal motility and 24-hour pH measurement before and at 6 months, 2 years and 5 years after laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication. RESULTS: Of the 598 patients, 436 (73%) reported some postprandial bloating before the procedure. The symptom score for bloating significantly improved after surgery (p < 0.0001). There were no significant differences in the lower esophageal sphincter basal pressures or 24-hour pH scores between those who reported improvement or worsening of their postprandial bloating. At 6 months after surgery, 54% of patients experienced postprandial bloating; of these, 49% reported improvement, 21% reported worsening and 30% reported no change in bloating symptoms compared with the preoperative state. Of the patients who reported worsening of postprandial bloating 6 months after surgery, 86 were reassessed 2 years after surgery and 71% reported improvement of this symptom over this time interval. CONCLUSIONS: Bloating is a common symptom in patients who suffer from chronic GERD. Laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication lessens the severity of this symptom in most patients. In a small subgroup of patients, antireflux surgery may exacerbate the bloating, but this improves over time.     

Complications and reoperation after Nissen fundoplication in childhood

Over a 10 year period, 429 Nissen fundoplications were performed on children with gastroesophageal reflux. Postoperative complications occurred in 69 children (16 percent), including wrap herniation or breakdown in 29; postoperative bowel obstruction in 18; stricture in 10; intraabdominal abscess and enterocutaneous fistula in 3 patients each; and wound infection, wound dehiscence, and inadvertent splenectomy in 2 patients each. The postoperative mortality rate was 0.9 percent (4 of 429 patients) and was related to sepsis in 1 patient, a metabolic disorder in 1 patient, and underlying pulmonary disease in 2 patients. All four patients were neurologically impaired. Fundoplication successfully controlled symptoms of gastroesophageal reflux in 395 children (92 percent) over a follow-up period ranging from 6 months to 10 years. Thirty-eight patients (8.8 percent) required a second antireflux operation because of recurrent symptoms. Twenty-nine patients had severe neurologic impairment (76 percent), 5 had associated congenital malformations (13 percent), and 3 had significant pulmonary problems (8 percent). Only one child requiring reoperation was considered otherwise normal. Indications for reoperation included wrap breakdown or herniation (28 patients), stricture (6 patients), and inadequate wrap (4 patients). Twenty-four of 28 children with wrap herniation or breakdown had neurologic impairment. A second fundoplication was successful in 35 of 38 patients (92 percent). A second procedure failed in three children, who required subsequent resection and colon interposition.