MPGN II – genetically determined by defective complement regulation?

MPGN II is a rare disease which is characterized by complement containing deposits within the GBM. The disease is characterized by functional impairment of the GBM causing progressive loss of renal function eventually resulting in end stage renal disease.It now becomes evident that in addition to C3NeF, which inhibits the inactivation of the alternative C3 convertase C3bBb, different genetically determined factors are also involved in the pathogenesis of MPGN II. These factors though different from C3NeF also result in defective complement regulation acting either through separate pathways or synergistically with C3NeF. Following the finding of MPGN II in Factor H deficient animals, patients with MPGN II were identified presenting with an activated complement system caused by Factor H deficiency. Factor H gene mutations result in a lack of plasma Factor H or in a functional defect of Factor H protein. Loss of Factor H function can also be caused by inactivating Factor H autoantibodies, C3 mutations preventing interaction between C3 and Factor H, or autoantibodies against C3. Identification of patients with MPGN II caused by defective complement control may allow treatment by replacement of the missing factor via plasma infusion, thus possibly preventing or at least delaying disease progress.     

Hemolytic uremic syndrome: a factor H mutation (E1172Stop) causes defective complement control at the surface of endothelial cells

Defective complement regulation results in hemolytic uremic syndrome (HUS), a disease that is characterized by microangiopathy, thrombocytopenia, and acute renal failure and that causes endothelial cell damage. For characterization of how defective complement regulation relates to the pathophysiology, the role of the complement regulator factor H and also of a mutant factor H protein was studied on the surface of human umbilical vein endothelial cells. The mutant 145-kD factor H protein was purified to homogeneity, from plasma of a patient with HUS, who is heterozygous for a factor H gene mutation G3587T, which introduces a stop codon at position 1172. Functional analyses show that the lack of the most C-terminal domain short consensus repeats 20 severely affected recognition functions (i.e., binding to heparin, C3b, C3d, and the surface of endothelial cells). Wild-type factor H as well as the mutant protein formed dimers in solution as shown by cross-linking studies and mass spectroscopy. When assayed in fluid phase, the complement regulatory activity of the mutant protein was normal and comparable to wild-type factor H. However, on the surface of endothelial cells, the mutant factor H protein showed severely reduced regulatory activities and lacked protective functions. Similarly, with the use of sheep erythrocytes, the mutant protein lacked the protective activity and caused increased hemolysis when it was added to factor H-depleted plasma. This study shows how a mutation that affects the C-terminal region of the factor H protein leads to defective complement control on cell surfaces and damage to endothelial cells in patients with HUS. These effects explain how mutant factor H causes defective complement control and in HUS-particularly under condition of inflammation and complement activation-causes endothelial cell damage.     

Binding of factor H to tubular epithelial cells limits interstitial complement activation in ischemic injury

Factor H is a regulator of the alternative pathway of complement, and genetic studies have shown that patients with mutations in factor H are at increased risk for several types of renal disease. Pathogenic activation of the alternative pathway in acquired diseases, such as ischemic acute kidney injury, suggests that native factor H has a limited capacity to control the alternative pathway in the kidney. Here we found that an absolute deficiency of factor H produced by gene deletion prevented complement activation on tubulointerstitial cells after ischemia/reperfusion (I/R) injury, likely because alternative pathway proteins were consumed in the fluid phase. In contrast, when fluid-phase regulation by factor H was maintained while the interaction of factor H with cell surfaces was blocked by a recombinant inhibitor protein, complement activation after renal I/R increased. Finally, a recombinant form of factor H, specifically targeted to sites of C3 deposition, reduced complement activation in the tubulointerstitium after ischemic injury. Thus, although factor H does not fully prevent activation of the alternative pathway of complement on ischemic tubules, its interaction with the tubule epithelial cell surface is critical for limiting complement activation and attenuating renal injury after ischemia.     

The development of atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome depends on complement C5

Gene variants in the alternative pathway of the complement system strongly associate with atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome (aHUS), presumably by predisposing to increased complement activation within the kidney. Complement factor H (CFH) is the major regulator of complement activation through the alternative pathway. Factor H-deficient mice transgenically expressing a mutant CFH protein (Cfh(-/-).FHΔ16-20) that functionally mimics the CFH mutations reported in aHUS patients spontaneously develop thrombotic microangiopathy. To investigate the role of complement C5 activation in this aHUS model, we generated C5-deficient Cfh(-/-).FHΔ16-20 mice. Both C5-sufficient and C5-deficient Cfh(-/-).FHΔ16-20 mice had abnormal C3 deposition within the kidney, but spontaneous aHUS did not develop in any of the C5-deficient mice. Furthermore, although Cfh(-/-).FHΔ16-20 animals demonstrated marked hypersensitivity to experimentally triggered renal injury, animals with concomitant C5 deficiency did not. These data demonstrate a critical role for C5 activation in both spontaneous aHUS and experimentally triggered renal injury in animals with defective complement factor H function. This study provides a rationale to investigate therapeutic inhibition of C5 in human aHUS.     

Mutations in complement factor I predispose to development of atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome

Mutations in the plasma complement regulator factor H (CFH) and the transmembrane complement regulator membrane co-factor protein (MCP) have been shown to predispose to atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome (HUS). Both of these proteins act as co-factors for complement factor I (IF). IF is a highly specific serine protease that cleaves the alpha-chains of C3b and C4b and thus downregulates activation of both the classical and the alternative complement pathways. This study looked for IF mutations in a panel of 76 patients with HUS. Mutations were detected in two patients, both of whom had reduced serum IF levels. A heterozygous bp change, c.463 G>A, which results in a premature stop codon (W127X), was found in one, and in the other, a heterozygous single base pair deletion in exon 7 (del 922C) was detected. Both patients had a history of recurrent HUS after transplantation. This is in accordance with the high rate of recurrence in patients with CFH mutations. Patients who are reported to have mutations in MCP, by contrast, do not have recurrence after transplantation. As with CFH- and MCP-associated HUS, there was incomplete penetrance in the family of one of the affected individuals. This study provides further evidence that atypical HUS is a disease of complement dysregulation.     

C-reactive protein and natural IgM antibodies are activators of complement in a rat model of intestinal ischemia and reperfusion

BACKGROUND: The role of C-reactive protein (CRP), natural immunoglobulin M (IgM), and natural IgM against phosphorylcholine (anti-Pc IgM) was investigated in relation with complement activation in a rat model of intestinal ischemia and reperfusion (II/R). The effect of C1-esterase inhibitor (C1-Inh) on this complement activation along with other inflammatory mediators was also studied. METHODS: Rats were subjected to 1 h of superior mesenteric artery occlusion and 3 h of reperfusion. Intravenous administration of vehicle (human albumin) or C1-Inh (200 U/kg) was performed before (n = 8) or after ischemia (n = 8). II/R increased levels of C4b/c, CRP, IgM, anti-Pc IgM, and myeloperoxidase activity in the intestinal homogenates and induced vascular leakage. RESULTS: A good correlation was observed in the intestinal homogenates between C4b/c and CRP levels. Clear depositions of C3, CRP, and IgM in intestinal tissue were demonstrated after II/R, and a strong correlation of both CRP and IgM with complement was observed. C1-Inh administered before ischemia reduced the complement activation response after II/R, as reflected by decreased levels of C4b/c in conjunction with reduced anti-Pc IgM in the intestinal homogenates. C1-Inh also decreased leakage of albumin when administered before ischemia. C1-Inh after ischemia reduced C4b/c levels and myeloperoxidase activity in the homogenates. CONCLUSIONS: CRP and IgM depositions correlated well with local complement activation, which suggests a role of these molecules in complement activation. Furthermore, C1-Inh inhibited potentially II/R injury either administered before or after ischemia, by attenuating complement activation induced by CRP and/or natural IgM antibodies.     

Mesangial immune complex glomerulonephritis due to complement factor D deficiency

Complement factor D is a serine protease essential for the activation of the alternative pathway and is expressed in the kidney, adipocytes, and macrophages. Factor D is found at relatively high levels in glomeruli suggesting that this component of the complement cascade could influence renal pathophysiology. In this study, we utilize mice with a targeted deletion of the activating complement factor D gene and compare these results to mice with targeted deletion of the inhibitory complement factor H gene. Eight-month-old mice with a deleted factor D gene spontaneously develop albuminuria and have reduced creatinine clearance due to mesangial immune complex glomerulonephritis. These mesangial deposits contain C3 and IgM. In contrast to the mesangial location of the immune deposits in the factor D-deficient mice, age-matched factor H-deficient mice develop immune deposits along the glomerular capillary wall. Our observations suggest that complement factor D or alternative pathway activation is needed to prevent spontaneous accumulation of C3 and IgM deposits within the mesangium. Our studies show that the complement factor D gene knockout mice are a novel model of spontaneous mesangial immune complex glomerulonephritis.     

Phenotypic expression of factor H mutations in patients with atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome

We investigated the phenotypic expression of factor H mutations in two patients with atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome (HUS). Factor H in serum was assayed by rocket immunoelectrophoresis, immunoblotting, and double immunodiffusion and in tissue by immunohistochemistry. Functional activity was analyzed by hemolysis of sheep erythrocytes and binding to endothelial cells. A homozygous mutation in complement control protein (CCP) domain 10 of factor H was identified in an adult man who first developed membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis and later HUS. C3 levels were very low. The patient had undetectable factor H levels in serum and a weak factor H 150 kDa band. Double immunodiffusion showed partial antigenic identity with factor H in normal serum owing to the presence of factor H-like protein 1. Strong specific labeling for factor H was detected in glomerular endothelium, mesangium and in glomerular and tubular epithelium as well as in bone marrow cells. A heterozygous mutation in CCP 20 of factor H was found in a girl with HUS. C3 levels were moderately decreased at onset. Factor H levels were normal and a normal 150 kDa band was present. Double immunodiffusion showed antigenic identity with normal factor H. Factor H labeling was minimal in the renal cortex. Factor H dysfunction was demonstrated by increased sheep erythrocyte hemolysis and decreased binding to endothelial cells. In summary, two different factor H mutations associated with HUS were examined: in one, factor H accumulated in cells, and in the other, membrane binding was reduced.     

Ocular involvement in hemolytic uremic syndrome due to factor H deficiency—are there therapeutic consequences?

Factor H deficiency is responsible for thrombotic microangiopathy (TMA) via uncontrolled activation of the alternative pathway of the complement system. Ocular TMA has never been reported in patients with factor H abnormalities. A male patient with congenital homozygote factor H deficiency reached end-stage renal disease at the age of 10 years. Hemodialysis was uneventful for 3 years, when, suddenly, unilateral ocular pain and blurred vision occurred while he had febrile pharyngitis. Ophthalmologic examination found vitreous bleeding, elevated ocular pressure, choroidal hemorrhage (ultrasound biomicroscopy) and retinal ischemia (fluorescein angiography). C-reactive protein concentration was increased, while haptoglobin levels remained normal. We suspected that TMA due to factor H deficiency was responsible for the ocular manifestations and immediately initiated daily plasma exchanges (PEs) with fresh frozen plasma (FFP) for 10 days followed by three sessions per week. Factor H serum level increased from 6% to 82%, and C3 level normalized. Progressively, ocular pain decreased, and visual acuity and ophthalmologic findings showed improvement. When there is permanent activation of the alternative pathway in patients with end-stage renal disease (ESRD), the search for secondary targets might be of interest. In nephrectomized patients, no biological parameter can predict isolated ocular TMA. Early ophthalmologic investigation and substitution of factor H via FFP may avoid irreversible damage. Anis Larakeb and Sandrine Leroy have contributed equally to this work     

Control of complement activation in membranous and membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis

Renal biopsy specimens from 22 membranous (MGN) and 19 membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis (MPGN) patients were examined for the presence of the three regulators of the complement system; C1- inhibitor (C1--INH), C3b inactivator (C3b-INA), and beta 1H. The serum concentrations of these proteins, at the time of biopsy, were also measured. To study the modulation of complement activation by these three control proteins in MGN and MPGN, we examined the relationship between each control protein and the protein whose activity it regulates, in four ways; (a) the concordance between the presence of the control proteins and the components regulated was studied, (b) the correlations in intensity of deposition of the control and complement proteins were measured, (c) the patterns of distribution of the proteins within the glomeruli were compared, and (d) the serum levels of control proteins and components, regulated were examined. C1--INH (23 of 35 biopsies) and beta 1H (34 of 36 biopsies) were frequently deposited in both disease groups. C3b-INA was found only rarely in MPGN (4 of 19 biopsies). This is probably because the former two proteins modulate complement activation stoichiometrically, whereas C3b-INA acts enzymatically. A relationship was demonstrated between C1--INH and C1s and between beta 1H and C3 in both groups, but no such relationship was found between C3bINA and C3. Conclusion. There is no generalized deficiency in modulation of complement activation in MGN or MPGN.     

Evaluation of urinary factor H excretion in patients with idiopathic membranous nephropathy

BACKGROUND: The complement system plays an important role in renal pathogenesis, and C5b-9, a terminal complement complex, is regarded as the principal mediator of proteinuria in idiopathic membranous nephropathy(MN). Since factor H regulates complement activation at the C3 step and is a crucial factor in complement-mediated tissue injury, the urinary excretion of factor H in patients with idiopathic MN was investigated. METHODS: Seven patients with biopsy-proven idiopathic MN were studied for twenty-four weeks. Urinary factor H levels were measured by ELISA from regularly collected urine samples, and then evaluated and compared with assays of urinary protein and C5b-9 excretion. RESULTS: During the study, five patients were treated with steroid therapy. All seven patients maintained stable renal function and showed a decline in urinary protein excretion. The mean level of urinary factor H was markedly elevated (156.1 +/- 47.1 U/mg U-Cr) before treatment (0 week), and gradually declined to 127.2 +/- 43.5 U/mg U-Cr at 12 weeks, and to 64.7 +/- 26.9 U/mg U-Cr) at 24 weeks. This followed decreases in urinary protein and urinary C5b-9 excretion. Percent change in urinary factor H level significantly decreased 24 weeks after treatment without affecting the plasma factor H level. CONCLUSION: These results suggest that factor H contributes to the regulatory mechanism of in situ complement activation, and thus the study of urinary factor H levels, as well as urinary C5b-9, may be significant in idiopathic MN.     

Plasma fibronectin and complement in surgical patients

Plasma fibronectin and a fragment of the third component of complement (C3b) are both opsonins of the reticulo-endothelial system. Twenty patients undergoing uncomplicated gastro-intestinal surgery were studied. There was a significant reduction in plasma fibronectin and total haemolytic complement, but not C3, in the early postoperative period (days 1 to 3). In six surgical patients critically ill with severe sepsis both plasma fibronectin concentrations and C3 concentration were reduced significantly when compared with the early postoperative period of uncomplicated surgery. In addition, in the critically ill patients, direct evidence of complement activation was demonstrated. These studies show a transient reduction of humoral host defence mechanisms following surgery which may be permissive to bacteraemia and complement activation.     

Factor H and the pathogenesis of renal diseases

Complement factor H is a potent inhibitor of alternative pathway complement activation. The factor H gene, a member of the regulators of complement activation (RCA) gene cluster, encodes two plasma proteins, one 150 kilodaltons (kDa) and one 43 kDa. Homozygous deficiency of factor H results in low plasma levels of complement factor B and C3 and depletion of the terminal complement proteins C5-C9; heterozygotes may have reduced or normal levels of factor B, C3, and C5-C9. Although factor H deficiency is infrequently reported, it has been associated with a number of types of renal disease, the most common being atypical membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis and idiopathic (non-diarrhea-associated) hemolytic uremic syndrome (HUS). The molecular defects responsible for factor H deficiency have been described in only two cases; clearly more research is needed in this area. The possible role of factor H deficiency or dysfunction in the pathogenesis of HUS is discussed.     

Hypersensitivity reactions during haemodialysis: role of complement fragments and ethylene oxide antibodies

IgE-antibodies against ethylene oxide (EtO) and activation of the complement system have been suspected as causative factors for acute hypersensitivity reactions at the onset of haemodialysis. The present study was conducted to determine which of the two mechanisms is mainly responsible for the occurrence of reactions. According to clinical criteria, 13 of the 129 patients studied were identified as having suffered from at least one episode of acute hypersensitivity. Seven of them experienced severe symptoms, including five with elevated circulating serum EtO antibodies. Of the remaining six patients who experienced moderate symptoms, only one had elevated serum EtO antibodies, and of the 114 patients not exhibiting symptoms, two had enhanced serum concentrations of EtO antibodies. In-vivo complement activation was determined during haemodialysis by measurement of both C3adesarg and C5adesarg fragments. No differences in the onset levels and the degree of complement activation were found between patients suffering from severe, moderate, or no hypersensitivity reactions. In-vitro activation of the complement cascade by zymosan, measured in plasma samples obtained from patients prior to dialysis, revealed no differences in the extent of C3adesarg generation. Finally, we determined the activity of the C3a- and C5a-inactivating enzyme, carboxypeptidase N1 (CN1), in plasma samples of patients both with and without hypersensitivity reactions. No difference in the CN1 activity between the two groups of patients was found. These data lead us to conclude that sensitisation to ethylene oxide is responsible for the majority of severe hypersensitivity reactions in haemodialysis patients. However, a small subgroup of patients having anaphylactoid reactions displayed neither elevated serum EtO antibodies with excessive complement activation nor a tendency towards reduced inactivation of anaphylatoxins.     

Anaphylatoxin release in association with methylmethacrylate fixation of hip prostheses

In a prospective study, thirty patients in whom a Charnley hip prosthesis was implanted with cement (methylmethacrylate) and fifteen who received a prosthesis without cement were studied. The activation of complement, as indicated by the release of anaphylatoxins (C3a and C5a), reduced activity of whole complement, and decreased levels of C3, C4, and C5 in plasma, was evaluated. Activation of complement was found when methylmethacrylate was used. In patients in whom components were fixed without cement, no formation of anaphylatoxins occurred, and only slightly reduced whole-complement activity and concentrations of C3, C4, and C5 in plasma were found. A dose-correlated release of the anaphylatoxins was found when monomethylmethacrylate was incubated in fresh serum. One explanation for the hemodynamic instability in these patients might be the biological effects of anaphylatoxins that are released in association with fixation by cement.     

Complement Mutation-Associated De Novo Thrombotic Microangiopathy Following Kidney Transplantation

Mutations in one or more genes encoding complement-regulatory proteins predispose to atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome (aHUS) and its recurrence following kidney transplantation. We evaluated plasma complement level and performed a screening for mutations in genes encoding complement Factors H and I (CFH, CFI) and membrane cofactor protein (MCP) in 24 kidney transplant recipients experiencing de novo thrombotic microangiopathy (TMA). Six patients presented with low C3 and/or low Factor B levels suggestive complement alternative pathway. A mutation in the CFH or CFI gene was found in 7/24 patients (29%), two of whom had a mutation in both genes. On the contrary, no mutation was identified in a control kidney transplant patients group (n = 25) without TMA. Patients with or without mutations were similar with regard to clinical features. Eight out of 24 patients lost their graft within 1 year of posttransplantation including six patients with a CFH mutation or a decrease of C3 or CFB in plasma. To conclude, kidney transplant patients with de novo TMA exhibit an unexpectedly high frequency of CFH and CFI mutations. These results suggest that genetic abnormalities may represent risk factors for de novo TMA after kidney transplantation and raise the question of the best therapeutic strategy.     

Characterization of a Factor H Mutation That Perturbs the Alternative Pathway of Complement in a Family with Membranoproliferative GN

Complement C3 activation is a characteristic finding in membranoproliferative GN (MPGN). This activation can be caused by immune complex deposition or an acquired or inherited defect in complement regulation. Deficiency of complement factor H has long been associated with MPGN. More recently, heterozygous genetic variants have been reported in sporadic cases of MPGN, although their functional significance has not been assessed. We describe a family with MPGN and acquired partial lipodystrophy. Although C3 nephritic factor was shown in family members with acquired partial lipodystrophy, it did not segregate with the renal phenotype. Genetic analysis revealed a novel heterozygous mutation in complement factor H (R83S) in addition to known risk polymorphisms carried by individuals with MPGN. Patients with MPGN had normal levels of factor H, and structural analysis of the mutant revealed only subtle alterations. However, functional analysis revealed profoundly reduced C3b binding, cofactor activity, and decay accelerating activity leading to loss of regulation of the alternative pathway. In summary, this family showed a confluence of common and rare functionally significant genetic risk factors causing disease. Data from our analysis of these factors highlight the role of the alternative pathway of complement in MPGN.     

Membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis with C3NeF and genetic complement dysregulation

The development of membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis (MPGN) is associated with uncontrolled activation of the complement alternative pathway. This dysregulation is related either to C3 nephritic factor (C3NeF), an auto-antibody directed against the alternative C3 convertase, or to homozygous loss-of-function mutation of the complement regulatory protein factor H. Heterozygous mutations in the genes coding for factor H, or for the other alternative pathway inhibitory proteins factor I and membrane cofactor protein, have recently been identified in a small number of patients with MPGN with exclusive C3 deposits. We report three hypocomplementemic children with dense deposit disease (n = 1) or immune-complex-mediated MPGN type I (n = 2), associated with both C3NeF activity and heterozygous mutation of factor H or factor I. These observations highlight the possible combination of genetic and acquired defect in complement control in various subtypes of MPGN, a finding that may influence the treatment strategy in some patients.     

C3 glomerulonephritis: clinicopathological findings, complement abnormalities, glomerular proteomic profile, treatment, and follow-up

C3 glomerulonephritis (C3GN) is a recently described disorder that typically results from abnormalities in the alternative pathway (AP) of complement. Here, we describe the clinical features, kidney biopsy findings, AP abnormalities, glomerular proteomic profile, and follow-up in 12 cases of C3GN. This disorder equally affected all ages, both genders, and typically presented with hematuria and proteinuria. In both the short and long term, renal function remained stable in the majority of patients with native kidney disease. In two patients, C3GN recurred within 1 year of transplantation and resulted in a decline in allograft function. Kidney biopsy mainly showed a membranoproliferative pattern, although both mesangial proliferative and diffuse endocapillary proliferative glomerulonephritis were noted. AP abnormalities were heterogeneous, both acquired and genetic. The most common acquired abnormality was the presence of C3 nephritic factors, while the most common genetic finding was the presence of H402 and V62 alleles of Factor H. In addition to these risk factors, other abnormalities included Factor H autoantibodies and mutations in CFH, CFI, and CFHR genes. Laser dissection and mass spectrometry of glomeruli from patients with C3GN showed accumulation of AP and terminal complement complex proteins. Thus, C3GN results from diverse abnormalities of the alternative complement pathway leading to subsequent glomerular injury.