The instability of the membrane skeleton in thalassemic red blood cells

The thalassemias are a heterogeneous group of disorders characterized by accumulation either of unmatched alpha or beta globin chains. These in turn cause the intramedullary and peripheral hemolysis that leads to varying anemia. A partial explanation for the hemolysis came our of our studies on material properties that showed that beta-thalassemia (beta- thal) intermedia ghosts were very rigid but unstable. A clue to this instability came from the observation that the spectrin/band 3 ratio was low in red blood cells (RBCs) of splenectomized beta-thal intermedia patients. The possible explanations for the apparent decrease in spectrin content included deficient or defective spectrin synthesis in thalassemic erythroid precursors or globin chain-induced membrane changes that lead to spectrin dissociation from the membrane during ghost preparation. To explore the latter alternative, samples from different thalassemic variants were obtained, ie, beta-thal intermedia, HbE/beta-thal, HbH (alpha-thal-1/alpha-thal-2), HbH/Constant Spring (CS), and homozygous HbCS/CS. We searched for the presence of spectrin in the first lysate of the standard ghost preparation. Normal individuals and patients with autoimmune hemolytic anemia, sickle cell anemia, and anemia due to chemotherapy served as controls. Using gradient sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis analysis, no spectrin was detected in identical aliquots of the supernatants of normals and these control samples. Varying amounts of spectrin were detected in the first lysate supernatants of almost all thalassemic patients. The identification of spectrin was confirmed by Western blotting using an affinity-purified, monospecific, rabbit polyclonal antispectrin antibody. Relative amounts of spectrin detected were as follows in decreasing order: splenectomized beta-thal intermedia including HbE/beta-thal; HbCS/CS; nonsplenectomized beta-thal intermedia, HbH/CS; and, lastly, HbH. These findings were generally confirmed when we used an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay technique to measure spectrin in the first lysate. Subsequent analyses showed that small amounts of actin and band 4.1 also appeared in lysates of thalassemic RBCs. Therefore, the three major membrane skeletal proteins are, to a varying degree, unstably attached in severe thalassemia. From these studies we could postulate that membrane association of abnormal or partially oxidized alpha- globin chains has a more deleterious effect on the membrane skeleton than do beta-globin chains.     

Defective assembly of membrane proteins in erythroid precursors of beta- thalassemic mice

beta-Thalassemic mice provide a useful model for studying the pathophysiology of human beta-thalassemia in that one can perform experiments that are difficult to perform in humans. The ease of access to beta-thalassemic mouse marrow provided the opportunity to explore the cause of the ineffective erythropoiesis that characterizes severe beta-thalassemia in mouse and man. We hypothesized that the accumulation of excess alpha-globin might interfere with the normal assembly of red blood cell (RBC) membrane proteins, thus contributing to the severe intramedullary lysis. Femoral marrow was obtained from normal and beta-thalassemic mice, and RBC precursors were purified (> 90%) by panning and harvesting CD45- cells. The assembly of RBC membrane proteins was assessed by observing immunofluorescence patterns obtained on fixed permeabilized precursors using rabbit polyclonal antibodies directed against human spectrin, and band 4.1, and murine band 3. The distribution of the proteins was shown with a fluorescein- tagged goat antirabbit antibody. In contrast to normal mice, about 30% of intermediate and late stage erythroblasts in beta-thalassemic mice appear abnormal. Neither spectrin nor band 4.1 formed crisp rim fluorescence in these erythroid precursors of thalassemic mice, whereas assembly of band 3 appeared normal. Therefore, the assembly of membrane skeletal proteins is abnormal in murine beta-thalassemic erythroid precursors perhaps because of the deposition of unmatched alpha-globin chains.     

Accelerated programmed cell death (apoptosis) in erythroid precursors of patients with severe beta-thalassemia (Cooley's anemia) [see comments]

The profound and life-threatening anemia in patients with Cooley's anemia is ascribed primarily to intramedullary hemolysis (ineffective erythropoiesis), the cause of which is obscure. Based on prior morphologic data showing nuclear abnormalities, we hypothesized that accelerated apoptosis could occur in these erythroid precursors. The highly successful bone marrow (BM) transplantation program for patients with Cooley's anemia provided us with a unique opportunity to test this hypothesis. We obtained pretransplantation BM aspiration samples from patients undergoing BM transplantation in Pesaro, Italy and from their allogeneic donors. The erythroid precursors were isolated using ficoll sedimentation and then panning selecting fro CD45- cells. Cytospin and Giemsa staining showed that the separation provided greater than 90% erythroblasts. Five million of these erythroblasts were lysed and their DNA was isolated. There were obvious ladder patterns of DNA breakdown products in beta-thalassemia major samples, with less occurring in beta- thalassemia trait. Normal individuals showed only a slight smear of breakdown of DNA. These results indicate there is enhanced apoptosis in the erythroblasts in the BMs of Cooley's anemia patients. This finding might partially explain why most of these erythroblasts never survive to become mature erythrocytes.     

Enhanced macrophagic attack on beta-thalassemia major erythroid precursors

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: In beta-thalassemia major (Cooley's anemia), ferrokinetic studies show that 60-80% of erythroid precursors die in the marrow or extramedullary sites. However, study of marrow aspirates does not reveal huge numbers of dead and dying erythroid precursors. We explored this apparent discrepancy with the hypothesis that enhanced phagocytosis of thalassemic erythroid precursors was a likely explanation. Prior studies had reported on an increase in thalassemic marrow macrophages and their enhanced state of activation. Therefore this study explored the characteristics of thalassemic erythroid precursors which might lead to enhanced susceptibility to phagocytosis. We have shown that enhanced erythroid apoptosis parallels the extent of ineffective erythropoeisis in thalassemic patients, and apoptotic cells are rapidly phagocytosed. Thus, increased apoptosis and perhaps other features of thalassemic erythroid precursors might be the cause of their enhanced phagocytic removal. DESIGN AND METHODS: Erythroid precursors were isolated from normal and beta-thalassemia major marrow, and incubated with uniform cultures of murine macrophages. The extent of phagocytosis was measured and then specific inhibitors were added to identify some of the messages effete erythroid precursors use to signal their condition to macrophages. RESULTS: Beta-thalassemia major erythroid precursors are phagocytosed twice as effectively as normal erythroid precursors. INTERPRETATION AND CONCLUSIONS: Experiments using inhibitors of phagocytosis showed that enhanced apoptosis is certainly responsible for part of the increased phagocytosis of thalassemic erythroid precursors. Interestingly, normal erythroid precursors are also subject to phagocytosis by qualitatively similar mechanisms.     

betaMinor-globin messenger RNA accumulation in reticulocytes governs improved erythropoiesis in beta thalassemic mice after erythropoietin complementary DNA electrotransfer in muscles

Mechanisms governing the induction of effective erythropoiesis in response to erythropoietin (Epo) oversecretion have been investigated in beta thalassemic C57Bl/6(Hbbth) mice. Naked DNA encoding an expression vector for mouse Epo was introduced into skeletal muscles by electrotransfer. A transient increase of serum Epo concentrations with a proportional augmentation of hematocrit values was observed. Various parameters relevant to beta thalassemia were surveyed in blood samples taken before treatment, at the peak of Epo secretion, and when the phenotype reverted to anemia. We measured globin messenger RNA (mRNA) levels in reticulocytes by real-time quantitative polymerase chain reaction, globin chain synthesis levels, and several indicators of erythrocyte membrane quality, including bound alpha chains, bound immunoglobulins, main protein components, and iron compartmentalization. Data indicated that high serum Epo levels primarily affect betaminor-globin mRNA accumulation in reticulocytes. Other changes subsequent to intense Epo stimulation, like increased betaminor/alpha-globin chain synthesis ratio, reduced levels of alpha chains and immunoglobulins bound to membranes, improved spectrin/band 3 ratio, increased red blood cell survival, and improved erythropoiesis appeared as consequences of increased betaminor-globin mRNA levels. This conclusion is consistent with models postulating that intense Epo stimulation induces the expansion and differentiation of erythroid progenitors committed to fetal erythropoiesis. Although phenotypic correction was partial in mice, and comparable achievements will probably be more difficult to obtain in humans, naked DNA electrotransfer may provide a safe and low-cost method for reassessing the potentials of Epo as an inducer of fetal erythropoiesis reactivation in patients with beta thalassemia.     

Erythrocyte ferritin in thalassemia syndromes

Basic ferritin (liver-type) was measured in erythrocytes of subjects with alpha- and beta-thalassemia trait, thalassemia intermedia and Cooley's disease, and compared with normals and patients with abnormal iron metabolism without erythrocyte metabolic defect (iron deficiency anemia and idiopathic hemochromatosis). In all the thalassemic syndromes considered, erythrocyte ferritin was significantly higher than in normals (p less than 0.001) and increased progressively with the increasing 'severity' of the thalassemic disorder. In both thalassemic and non-thalassemic subjects, erythrocyte ferritin levels were related to body iron status, but in the thalassemic group, the increased erythrocyte ferritin values seemed also to be closely related to the intracellular metabolic abnormality. The severity of the defect in globin chain synthesis seemed to play an important role in determining ferritin accumulation in red cells of thalassemic subjects.     

Pathophysiology of thalassemia

Despite discoveries concerning the molecular abnormalities that led to the thalassemic syndromes, it still is not known how accumulation of excess unmatched alpha-globin in beta thalassemia and beta-globin in alpha thalassemia leads to red blood cell hemolysis in the peripheral blood, and in the beta thalassemias particularly, premature destruction of erythroid precursors in marrow (ineffective erythropoiesis). Oxidant injury may cause hemolysis, but there is no evidence that it causes ineffective erythropoiesis. Hemoglobin E/beta thalassemia is now a worldwide clinical problem. The reasons underlying the heterogeneity and occasional severity of the syndrome remain obscure. Ineffective erythropoiesis now appears to be caused by accelerated apoptosis, in turn caused primarily by deposition of alpha-globin chains in erythroid precursors. However, it is not clear how alpha-globin deposition causes apoptosis. The author uses new observations on the control of erythropoiesis to provide a framework for studying the enhanced thalassemic erythroid apoptosis.     

Partial spectrin deficiency in hereditary pyropoikilocytosis

Hereditary pyropoikilocytosis (HPP) is a severe hemolytic anemia in which an instability of the red cell membrane skeleton has been correlated with structural and functional defects of spectrin. We now report that 13 unrelated HPP subjects have approximately 30% less spectrin than normal as evidenced by a decreased spectrin/band 3 ratio. We also examine the role of spectrin degradation as an underlying cause of this partial spectrin deficiency. Our studies demonstrate that the reduced spectrin content of HPP red cells remains constant during in vivo aging of the cells in the peripheral blood, as well as during in vitro incubation. Furthermore, immunoblotting experiments using an affinity-purified antispectrin antibody indicate that there is no loss of spectrin during membrane preparation and also that neither whole HPP red cells nor ghosts nor cytosol contains any abnormal spectrin degradation products. These data suggest that spectrin is not degraded and that it is stable on the membrane of the circulating HPP red cell. In contrast, however, incubation of free spectrin with a lysate of nucleated erythroid precursor cells indicates that HPP alpha I/46 spectrin, but not HPP alpha I/74 spectrin, is more susceptible to proteolytic degradation than a control. These data imply that the decreased spectrin content of HPP is not due to a single defect but that a more complex mechanism is involved. In HPP Sp alpha I/46 subjects, an increased proteolytic degradation in bone marrow erythroid precursors of cytosolic spectrin, prior to its assembly on the membrane, could contribute toward the partial spectrin deficiency.     

Rare thalassemic syndrome caused by interaction of Hb Questembert (alpha1 codon 131, TCT>CCT, Ser>Pro) with an alpha-thalassemia-2 deletion: implications for diagnosis and management

Abnormal globin chain biosynthesis may result in deficient quantity (thalassemia) or structural variation (abnormal hemoglobins) and traditionally, they represent two phenotypically distinct groups of disorders. However, the phenotypic expression of unstable hemoglobin variants often combine features of thalassemia together with variable peripheral hemolysis. To achieve definitive diagnosis in a child presenting with hemolytic anemia along with features associated with thalassemia intermedia, we evaluated clinical, hematological, biochemical, globin biosynthetic and molecular data. Definitive diagnosis was achieved by DNA analysis which characterized the proband to be a compound heterozygote for a common alpha-thalassemia-2 deletion (3.7 kb) and Hb Questembert (alpha131[H14] Ser>Pro) caused by a C>T mutation in codon 131 of the alpha1 globin gene in trans. The phenotype of thalassemia intermedia with marked dyserythropoiesis, found in patients inheriting alpha-thalassemia mutations along with unstable alpha-globin variants (i.e., alpha-thalassemic hemoglobinopathies), represents a distinct type of thalassemic syndrome. The proband in this study additionally had variable peripheral hemolysis, presumably related to characteristics of the unstable Hb Questembert. There is minimal experience for the management of such atypical cases and this case illustrates that it is probably insufficient to monitor clinical status in patients with such hemoglobinopathies based only on the levels of hemoglobin.     

Erythropoiesis in ha/ha and sph/sph mice, mutants which produce spectrin-deficient erythrocytes

In order to characterize chronically accelerated erythropoiesis, we studied the ultrastructure of bone marrow and spleen of ha/ha and sph/sph mice, two mutants with profound hemolytic anemia secondary to deficiency of the erythrocyte membrane protein spectrin. The marrows and spleens of both varieties were extremely erythropoietic and were without histological abnormalities directly related to spectrin deficiency. Erythropoiesis was consistently associated with distinctive, dark branched cells which constituted large proportions of the stroma of the mutant spleens and marrow. These dark cells were not present in untreated and acutely bled controls. Plasma clot assays for erythroid progenitors revealed that CFU-E concentrations in the mutant marrows were significantly increased over those in untreated controls while BFU-E concentrations were approximately half. In addition, mutant CFU-E often gave rise to abnormal appearing colonies. Spectrin, though crucial to erythrocyte function is probably not important to the process of erythroid differentiation and maturation. The status of erythroid precursors in the marrows of the spectrin deficient mice is similar to that of mice subjected to an acute bleed. The divergent changes in CFU-E and BFU-E may indicate that these two cells play different roles in accelerated erythropoiesis. The dark cells that we describe are similar to stromal cells observed in models of the early stages of erythropoiesis.     

Expression of microRNA-451 in normal and thalassemic erythropoiesis

MicroRNAs (miRNAs) are negative regulators of gene expression that play an important role in hematopoiesis. Thalassemia, a defective globin synthesis leading to precipitate of excess unbound globins in red blood cell precursors, results in defective erythroid precursors and ineffective erythropoiesis. Expression pattern of miR-451, an erythroid-specific miRNA, was analyzed during differentiation of erythroid progenitors derived from normal and thalassemic peripheral blood CD34-positive cells, after 14 days of culture. A biphasic expression with transient up-regulation of miRNA-451 on day 3 of cultures was observed during thalassemic erythroid differentiation. In contrast, the expression pattern of the miR-451 in erythroid cells obtained from the other extravascular hemolytic anemia, i.e., hereditary spherocytosis patients showed no transient up-regulation of miR-451 on day 3 of cultures. Our results suggest that early erythroid progenitors in β-thalassemia have a dysregulated miRNA-451 expression program, and analysis of microRNA is a relevant approach to determine abnormalities of erythropoiesis.     

Improvement of mouse beta-thalassemia by recombinant human erythropoietin

Homozygous beta thalassemic mice received 50 U (1,660 U/kg) of recombinant human erythropoietin (rhEpo) 5 days a week for 2 weeks. Hemoglobin increased from 9.2 +/- 0.6 g/dL to 10.5 +/- 0.4 g/dL (P = .002) and hematocrit increased from 29.2% +/- 0.9% to 34.1% +/- 1.9% (P = .0014). The beta minor/alpha globin chain synthesis ratio increased slightly but significantly between day -4 (0.75 +/- 0.07) and day 4 (0.81 +/- 0.04) (P = .01) and reached a minimum ratio (0.67 +/- 0.03) on day 15 (P = .001), being parallel to reticulocyte counts and to the incorporated trichloracetic acid (TCA)-insoluble radioactivity, therefore parallel to the erythropoietic output in thalassemic mice, as in normal mice. Erythrocyte defects were improved in beta thalassemic mice treated by rhEpo: membrane-associated alpha globin was significantly decreased (P less than .01), thiol group reactivity of ankyrin was significantly improved (P less than .05), spectrin alterations were reduced, and deformability of mouse thalassemic red blood cells was normalized. These results provide experimental criteria for modulating globin chain imbalance necessary for the therapy of human beta thalassemia intermedia, and suggest that rhEpo might be of interest to improve the red blood cell mass and reduce erythrocyte alterations in this disease.     

The importance of erythroid expansion in determining the extent of apoptosis in erythroid precursors in patients with beta-thalassemia major

Beta-thalassemia major is characterized by ineffective erythropoiesis leading to severe anemia and extensive erythroid expansion. The ineffective erythropoiesis is in part due to accelerated apoptosis of the thalassemic erythroid precursors; however, the extent of apoptosis is surprisingly variable. To understand this variability as well as the fact that some patients undergoing allogeneic marrow transplantation are resistant to the myeloablative program, we attempted more quantitative analyses. Two groups of patients totaling 44 were studied, along with 25 healthy controls, and 7 patients with hemolysis and/or ineffective erythropoeisis. By 2 flow cytometric methods, thalassemic erythroid precursors underwent apoptosis at a rate that was 3 to 4 times normal. Because thalassemic marrow has between 5- to 6-fold more erythroid precursors than healthy marrow, this translated into an absolute increase in erythroid precursor apoptosis of about 15-fold above our healthy controls. In searching for the causes of the variability in thalassemic erythroid precursor apoptosis, we discovered tight direct correlations between the relative and absolute extent of apoptosis and the extent of erythroid expansion as measured either by the absolute number of marrow erythroid precursors or by serum soluble transferrin receptor levels. These results could mean that the most extreme rates of erythroid proliferation lend themselves to cellular errors that turn on apoptotic programs. Alternatively, extreme rates of erythroid hyperplasia and apoptosis might be characteristic of more severely affected patients. Lastly, extreme erythroid hyperplasia could generate such numbers of apoptotic erythroid precursors that marrow macrophages are overwhelmed, leaving more apoptotic cells in the sample.     

A correlation of erythrokinetics, ineffective erythropoiesis, and erythroid precursor apoptosis in thai patients with thalassemia

The variety of patients with thalassemia in Thailand offers an opportunity to fully characterize the kinetic causes of the anemia and to study apoptosis of marrow erythroid precursors as a possible factor contributing to its severity. Kinetic studies showed that in hemoglobin H (HbH) disease, the extent of hemolysis, as well as the minimally ineffective erythropoiesis, usually falls within the compensatory capacity of normal erythropoiesis; therefore, anemia in patients with HbH partly represents a failure to expand erythropoiesis adequately. Hemoglobin Constant Spring (HbCS), a common variant of alpha thalassemia in Bangkok, causes more severe hemolysis and a distinct increase in ineffective erythropoiesis. Ineffective erythropoiesis plays a much more prominent role in beta thalassemia/hemoglobin E (beta-thal/HbE) disease, in which the variability of the anemia is puzzling. We compared mild and severe cases and found that patients with severe disease had a maximal marrow erythropoietic response that failed to compensate for very short survival of red blood cells and a marked quantitative increase in ineffective erythropoiesis. Analysis of apoptosis of marrow erythroid precursors done both on shipped samples and in Bangkok showed a moderate increase in HbH disease, consistent with the small increase in ineffective erythropoiesis. In patients with homozygous HbCS, there was a further increase in apoptosis, consistent with the additional increase in ineffective erythropoiesis. Patients with beta-thal/HbE disease had the most ineffective erythropoiesis and the most erythroid apoptosis. Thus, it appears that alpha-chain deposition in erythroid precursors, either alpha(A) or alpha(cs), leads to accelerated apoptosis and ineffective erythropoiesis.     

Oxidative damage and erythrocyte membrane transport abnormalities in thalassemias

Oxidative damage induced by free globin chains has been implicated in the pathogenesis of the membrane abnormalities observed in alpha and beta thalassemia. We have evaluated transport of Na+ and K+ in erythrocytes of patients with thalassemias as well as in two experimental models that use normal human red blood cells, one for alpha thalassemia (methylhydrazine treatment, alpha thalassemia like) and one for beta thalassemia (phenylhydrazine treatment, beta thalassemia like). With the exception of the Na-K pump, similar alterations in membrane transport were observed in thalassemia and thalassemia-like erythrocytes. These were: increased K-Cl cotransport, Na-Li countertransport and reduced Na-K-Cl cotransport. The Na-K pump was reduced in thalassemia-like cells, whereas it was increased in severe alpha thalassemia and in beta thalassemia cells. The increased K- Cl cotransport activity could be observed in light and dense fractions of beta-thalassemic cells. K-Cl cotransport in thalassemic and thalassemia-like erythrocytes was partially inhibited by [(dihydro- indenyl) oxy] alkanoic acid and completely abolished by dithiothreitol. Thus, oxidative damage represents an important factor in the increased activity of the K-Cl cotransport observed in thalassemias, and of the K+ loss observed in beta-thalassemia erythrocytes.     

Sickle and thalassemic erythroid progenitor cells are different from normal.

Blood erythroid progenitors (BFU-E) from patients with sickle and thalassemic syndromes were compared with those from normal individuals. The day of maximal colony formation in methyl cellulose was slightly later in the cultures from the patients with hemoglobinopathies than in the normal cultures. The number of colonies/100,000 mononuclear cells was similar in all cultures on day 13, but was higher in the hemoglobinopathy cultures on the day of maximal growth. The number of BFU-E/mL of blood was significantly higher than normal at all times in both sickle cell anemia and thalassemia. The proportional synthesis of gamma globin was twice normal in all sickle cultures, and 4 times normal in those from beta+-thalassemia. Hemin and interleukin-3 increased the numbers of erythroid colonies in all cultures, but did not consistently alter the globin synthesis patterns. Each progenitor population has a unique pattern in terms of time course, number of BFU-E, and level of gamma globin synthesis. These features indicate distinct types of BFU-E, or differences in accessory cells, or both, which distinguish blood-borne erythropoiesis in normals and those with hemoglobinopathies.     

Sickle and Thalassemic Erythroid Progenitor Cells are Different from Normal

Blood erythroid progenitors (BFU-E) from patients with sickle and thalassemic syndromes were compared with those from normal individuals. The day of maximal colony formation in methyl cellulose was slightly later in the cultures from the patients with hemoglobinopathies than in the normal cultures. The number of colonies/100,000 mononuclear cells was similar in all cultures on day 13, but was higher in the hemoglobinopathy cultures on the day of maximal growth. The number of BFU-E/mL of blood was significantly higher than normal at all times in both sickle cell anemia and thalassemia. The proportional synthesis of γ globin was twice normal in all sickle cultures, and 4 times normal in those from β⁺-thalassemia. Hemin and interleukin-3 increased the numbers of erythroid colonies in all cultures, but did not consistently alter the globin synthesis patterns. Each progenitor population has a unique pattern in terms of time course, number of BFU-E, and level of γ globin synthesis. These features indicate distinct types of BFU-E, or differences in accessory cells, or both, which distinguish blood-borne erythropoiesis in normals and those with hemoglobinopathies.     

Non-Hodgkin disease in beta-thalassemia major

Thalassemia is a spectrum of diseases characterized by the decrease or absence of globin chains. The occurrence of lymphoma in thalassemia has rarely been reported, and our review of the English literature revealed only four cases. Because anemia is always masked by regular transfusions in thalassemic patients, physicians discover a hidden malignancy late in the course of the disease. We hereby report the case of a thalassemic patient developing non-Hodgkin disease and discuss the possibility of a link between the two disease entities. This case is intended to alert physicians of the possibility of a malignancy in thalassemia patients.