Antigen-specific responses and ANA production in B6.Sle1b mice: A role for SAP

B6.Sle1b mice, which contain the Sle1b gene interval derived from lupus prone NZM2410 mice on a C57BL/6 background, present with gender-biased, highly penetrant anti-nuclear antibody (ANA) production. To obtain some insight into the possible induction mechanism of autoantibodies in these mice we compared antigen-specific T dependent (TD) and T independent (TI-II) responses between B6.Sle1b and B6 mice before the development of high ANA titers. Our results show that B6.Sle1b mice mount enhanced responses to a TI-II antigen. Additionally, the memory T cell response generated by a TD antigen also increased. This enhancement correlates with the greater ability of B cells from B6.Sle1b mice to present antigen to T cells. The SLAM Associated Protein (SAP) is critical for signaling of many of the molecules encoded by the SLAM/CD2 gene cluster, candidates for mediating the Sle1b phenotype; therefore, we also investigated the effect of sap deletion in these strains on the TD and TI-II responses as well as on ANA production. The results of these studies of responses to non-self-antigens provide further insight into the mechanism by which responses to self-antigens might be initiated in the context of specific genetic alterations.     

Association of extensive polymorphisms in the SLAM/CD2 gene cluster with murine lupus

Susceptibility to autoimmunity in B6.Sle1b mice is associated with extensive polymorphisms between two divergent haplotypes of the SLAM/CD2 family of genes. The B6.Sle1b-derived SLAM/CD2 family haplotype is found in many other laboratory mouse strains but only causes autoimmunity in the context of the C57Bl/6 (B6) genome. Phenotypic analyses have revealed variations in the structure and expression of several members of the SLAM/CD2 family in T and B lymphocytes from B6.Sle1b mice. T lymphocytes from B6.Sle1b mice have modified signaling responses to stimulation at 4-6 weeks of age. While autoimmunity may be mediated by a combination of genes in the SLAM/CD2 family cluster, the strongest candidate is Ly108, a specific isoform of which is constitutively upregulated in B6.Sle1b lymphocytes.     

The role of NK cells in the development of autoantibodies

The systemic lupus erythematosus (Sle1) interval from the NZM2410 mouse strain has been shown to be responsible for high levels of autoantibody production against antinuclear antibodies (ANA) when transferred into C57BL/6 mice. B cells derived from the B6.Sle1 strain are required for the production but help from both T-dependent and independent sources have been documented. Using radiation chimeras constructed in a strain of mice that is chronically depleted of Natural killer (NK) cells, but not NKT cells, we have examined the role of NK cells in the development of ANA in this context. Our results show that in the presence of intact T cell help depletion of NK cells does not affect ANA production. However, when T cell help is compromised, the prevalence of animals producing ANA is significantly decreased suggesting that NK cells can provide help for the T-independent production of ANA. Further experiments provide a possible mechanism for the NK-cell dependence.     

The role of NK cells in the development of autoantibodies

The systemic lupus erythematosus (Sle1) interval from the NZM2410 mouse strain has been shown to be responsible for high levels of autoantibody production against antinuclear antibodies (ANA) when transferred into C57BL/6 mice. B cells derived from the B6.Sle1 strain are required for the production but help from both T-dependent and independent sources have been documented. Using radiation chimeras constructed in a strain of mice that is chronically depleted of Natural killer (NK) cells, but not NKT cells, we have examined the role of NK cells in the development of ANA in this context. Our results show that in the presence of intact T cell help depletion of NK cells does not affect ANA production. However, when T cell help is compromised, the prevalence of animals producing ANA is significantly decreased suggesting that NK cells can provide help for the T-independent production of ANA. Further experiments provide a possible mechanism for the NK-cell dependence.     

Defective B-cell response to T-dependent immunization in lupus-prone mice

Lupus anti-nuclear Ab show the characteristics of Ag-driven T-cell-dependent (TD) humoral responses. If autoAg elicit the same response as exogenous Ag, lupus should enhance humoral responses to immunization. Blunted responses to various immunizations have, however, been reported in a significant portion of lupus patients. In this study, we show that lupus-prone C57BL/6.Sle1.Sle2.Sle3 (B6.TC) mice produce significantly less Ab in response to TD immunization than congenic controls, while producing significantly more total Ig. This blunted Ab response to TD Ag could be reconstituted with B6.TC B and CD4+ T cells. Multiple defects were found in the B6.TC response to 4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenylacetyl-keyhole limpet hemocyanin (NP-KLH) compared with total Ig, including a smaller percentage of B cells participating in the NP-response, a reduced entry into germinal centers, and highly defective production of NP-specific long-lived plasma cells (PC) in the bone marrow. B6.TC PC expressed reduced levels of FcgammaRIIb, which suggests that reduced apoptosis in resident PC prevents the establishment of newly formed NP-specific PC in bone marrow niches. Overall, these results show that lupus-prone mice responded differently to auto- and exogenous Ag and suggest that low FcgammaRIIb, hypergammaglobulinemia, and high autoAb production would be predictive of a poor response to immunization in lupus patients.     

Distinct and synergistic roles of FcγRIIB deficiency and 129 strain-derived SLAM family proteins in the development of spontaneous germinal centers and autoimmunity

The inhibitory IgG Fc receptor (FcγRIIB) deficiency and 129 strain-derived signaling lymphocyte activation molecules (129-SLAMs) are proposed to contribute to the lupus phenotype in FcγRIIB-deficient mice generated using 129 ES cells and backcrossed to C57BL/6 mice (B6.129.RIIBKO). In this study, we examine the individual contributions and the cellular mechanisms by which FcγRIIB deficiency and 129-derived SLAM family genes promote dysregulated spontaneous germinal center (Spt-GC) B cell and follicular helper T cell (Tfh) responses in B6.129.RIIBKO mice. We find that B6 mice congenic for the 129-derived SLAM locus (B6.129-SLAM) and B6 mice deficient in FcγRIIB (B6.RIIBKO) have increased Spt-GC B cell responses compared to B6 controls but significantly lower than B6.129.RIIBKO mice. These data indicate that both FcγRIIB deficiency and 129-SLAMs contribute to elevated Spt-GC B cell responses in B6.129.RIIBKO mice. However, only 129-SLAMs contribute significantly to augmented Tfh responses in B6.129.RIIBKO mice, and do so by a combination of T cell-dependent effects and enhanced B cell and DC-dependent antigen presentation to T cells. Elevated Spt-GC B cell responses in mice with FcγRIIB deficiency and polymorphic 129-SLAMs were associated with elevated metabolic activity, improved GC B cell survival and increased differentiation of naïve B cells into GC B cell phenotype. Our data suggest that the interplay between 129-SLAM expression on B cells, T cells and DCs is central to the alteration of the GC tolerance checkpoint, and that deficiency of FcγRIIB on B cells is necessary to augment Spt-GC responses, pathogenic autoantibodies, and lupus disease.     

Intrafollicular location of marginal zone/CD1d(hi) B cells is associated with autoimmune pathology in a mouse model of lupus

Marginal zone (MZ) B cells contain a large number of autoreactive clones and the expansion of this compartment has been associated with autoimmunity. MZ B cells also efficiently transport blood-borne antigen to the follicles where they activate T cells and differentiate into plasma cells. Using the B6.NZM2410.Sle1.Sle2.Sle3 (B6.TC) model of lupus, we show that the IgM+ CD1d(hi)/MZ B-cell compartment is expanded, and a large number of them reside inside the follicles. Contrary to the peripheral B-cell subset distribution and their activation status, the intrafollicular location of B6.TC IgM+ CD1d(hi)/MZ B cells depends on both bone marrow- and stromal-derived factors. Among the factors responsible for this intrafollicular location, we have identified an increased response to CXCL13 by B6.TC MZ B cells and a decreased expression of VCAM-1 on stromal cells in the B6.TC MZ. However, the reduced number of MZ macrophages observed in B6.TC MZs was independent of the IgM+ CD1d(hi)/B-cell location. B7-2 but not B7-1 deficiency restored IgM+ CD1d(hi)/MZ B-cell follicular exclusion in B6.TC mice, and it correlated with tolerance to dsDNA and a significant reduction of autoimmune pathology. These results suggest that follicular exclusion of IgM+ CD1d(hi)/MZ B cells is an important B-cell tolerance mechanism, and that B7-2 signaling is involved in breaching this tolerance checkpoint.     

Heterogeneous and monoclonal helper T cells induce similar anti-(4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl (NP) antibody populations in the primary adoptive response. II. Lambda light chain dominance and idiotope expression

When the hapten (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl (NP) is presented on different carrier molecules, different anti-NP antibody responses are stimulated. On stimulation with NP-lipopolysaccharide (LPS) [T-independent type 1 (TI-1) antigen] kappa + antibodies are the major population, whereas on stimulation with NP-Ficoll [T-independent type 2 (TI-2) antigen], NP-keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) or NP-chicken gamma globulin (CG) [T-dependent (TD) antigens], lambda 1+ antibodies dominate. The relative contribution of idiotopes Ac38 or Ac146 to the lambda 1+ anti-NP response was also different on comparison of TI-1 with TI-2 or TD anti-NP responses. We investigated whether light chain- or idiotype-specific T cells are responsible for these differences. Analysis of the anti-NP response of nude mice after immunization with NP-Ficoll showed lambda 1 dominance. Likewise primary adoptive transfer experiments using carrier-specific T cell lines to reconstitute the TD anti-NP response to NP-KLH or NP-CG, showed that help from carrier-specific T cells alone is capable of stimulating the characteristic lambda 1 dominant response. No significant difference could be found in the levels of Ac38 and Ac146 idiotope expression between mice reconstituted with splenic T cells and those reconstituted with T cell lines. These results suggest that light chain- or idiotype-specific T cells are required neither for the production of lambda 1 light chain dominance, nor for the appearance of idiotopes characteristic of the primary anti-NP response. The possible reasons for differences seen in both light chain and idiotope expression between primary anti-NP responses to the TI-1 antigen NP-LPS and those to TD or TI-2 antigens are discussed.     

Enhanced expression of stem cell antigen-1 (Ly-6A/E) in lymphocytes from lupus prone mice correlates with disease severity

B6.Sle1 mice, congenic for the NZM2410-derived lupus susceptibility locus, Sle1 on chromosome 1 exhibit many of the features seen in human lupus including activated lymphocytes and high titers of antinuclear autoantibodies. Among the different surface molecules that were aberrantly expressed on the B6.Sle1 lymphocytes was Ly-6A/E. Splenic B- and T-lymphocytes but not myeloid cells from B6.Sle1 mice exhibited enhanced levels of Ly-6A/E compared to B6 controls. In particular, MZ B cells, GC B cells and B-cell blasts expressed the highest levels of Ly-6A/E in both strains, with the levels being even higher on B6.Sle1 derived cells. Following stimulation with LPS or anti-IgM, there was a profound up-regulation in Ly-6A/E, particularly on MZ B cells and B-cell blasts. CD4 and CD8 T cells also up-regulated Ly-6A/E after stimulation with anti-CD3 and anti-CD28. These studies were extended to additional autoimmune strains including B6.Sle3, B6.Sle1.lpr and BXSB. Importantly, Ly-6A/E levels on lymphocytes were commensurate with the degree of disease exhibited by these lupus strains. Finally, it appears that increased interferon levels, in addition to antigen receptor stimulation, may also be a factor accounting for elevated Ly-6A/E in lupus. Given these observations it is important to elucidate the functional role of Ly-6A/E in lupus in future studies.     

Anti-receptor antibody-induced suppression of murine H-Y-specific delayed-type hypersensitivity responses

A putative anti-H-Y receptor antiserum (ARA) was raised in C57BL/6 male mice against splenic T lymphocytes from syngeneic females immunized against H-Y antigen. When this antiserum is given i.v. to C57BL/6 females it prevents the expression of H-Y-specific delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH). The suppressive activity in ARA was selectively retained on rabbit anti-mouse immunoglobulin columns, and could be absorbed by H-Y-immune spleen cells from C57BL/6 female mice. The abrogation of H-Y DTH reactivity was at least in part due to the generation of suppressor T cells which are generated by ARA in naive female mice. ARA-generated suppressor cells specifically inhibit the induction phase of DTH responses to the H-Y antigen, having no effect on (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl (NP)-specific cutaneous sensitivity responses or on DTH responses to minor histocompatibility antigens. Furthermore, there is a requirement for Igh gene homology between the strain producing the ARA and the strain in which the DTH response is induced. Thus, C57BL/6 ARA given to A.BY (H-2b, Igh-1e) or to B.C-8 (H-2b, Igh-1a) mice was unable to suppress homologous H-Y DTH responses in these strains. However, C57BL/6 ARA induced suppressor cells in B.C-8 mice which were capable of inhibiting H-Y DTH responses when adoptively transferred to C57BL/6 females.     

The costimulatory molecule SLAM is critical for pulmonary allergic responses

T-cell activation plays an essential role in the generation of the pulmonary inflammation that is manifest in allergic asthma. Optimal T-cell activation requires not only presentation of antigen with the major histocompatibility complex, but also concurrent signaling through costimulatory molecules. The costimulatory molecule SLAM (Signaling Lymphocytic Activation Molecule, CD150) is a glycoprotein expressed on activated lymphocytes and antigen-presenting cells. Disruption of the SLAM gene demonstrated that SLAM-induced signal transduction pathways regulate cytokine production by T helper (Th)2 cells and macrophages. Here we tested the postulate that the costimulatory molecule SLAM may be critical for allergic inflammation in a murine model. SLAM-deficient mice did not manifest allergen-induced bronchoalveolar lavage eosinophilia, increased serum IgE, or heightened airway responses compared with wild-type mice. Allergen-induced Th2 cytokines and Th1 cytokines were decreased in SLAM-deficient mice. These data support the concept that SLAM plays a crucial role in allergic responses.     

Expression of the autoimmune Fcgr2b NZW allele fails to be upregulated in germinal center B cells and is associated with increased IgG production

The inhibitory receptor FcgammaRIIb regulates B-cell functions. Genetic studies have associated Fcgr2b polymorphisms and lupus susceptibility in both humans and murine models, in which B cells express reduced FcgammaRIIb levels. Furthermore, FcgammaRIIb absence results in lupus on the appropriate genetic background, and lentiviral-mediated FcgammaRIIb overexpression prevents disease in the NZM2410 lupus mouse. The NZM2410/NZW allele Fcgr2b is, however, located in-between Sle1a and Sle1b, two potent susceptibility loci, making it difficult to evaluate Fcr2b(NZW) independent contribution. By using two congenic strains that each carries only Sle1a (B6.Sle1a(15-353)), or Fcr2b(NZW) in the absence of Sle1a or Sle1b (B6.Sle1(111-148)), we show that the Fcr2b(NZW) allele does not upregulate its expression on germinal center B cells and plasma cells, as does the C57BL/6 allele on B6.Sle1a(15-353) B cells. Furthermore, in the absence of the flanking Sle1a and Sle1b, Fcr2b(NZW) does not produce an autoimmune phenotype, but is associated with an increased number of class-switched plasma cells. These results show that while a lower level of FcgammaRIIb does not by itself induce the development of autoreactive B cells, it has the potential to amplify the contribution of autoreactive B cells induced by other lupus-susceptibility loci by enhancing the production of class-switched plasma cells.     

Signal transduction through Vav-2 participates in humoral immune responses and B cell maturation

B and T lymphocytes develop normally in mice lacking the guanine nucleotide exchange factor Vav-2. However, the immune responses to type II thymus-independent antigen as well as the primary response to thymus-dependent (TD) antigen are defective. Vav-2-deficient mice are also defective in their ability to switch immunoglobulin class, form germinal centers and generate secondary immune responses to TD antigens. Mice lacking both Vav-1 and Vav-2 contain reduced numbers of B lymphocytes and display a maturational block in the development of mature B cells. B cells from Vav-1(-/-)Vav-2(-/-) mice respond poorly to antigen receptor triggering, both in terms of proliferation and calcium release. These studies show the importance of Vav-2 in humoral immune responses and B cell maturation.     

Systemic IFN-alpha drives kidney nephritis in B6.Sle123 mice

The impact of IFN-alpha secretion on disease progression was assessed by comparing phenotypic changes in the lupus-prone B6.Sle1Sle2Sle3 (B6.Sle123) strain and the parental C57BL/6 (B6) congenic partner using an adenovirus (ADV) expression vector containing a recombinant IFN-alpha gene cassette (IFN-ADV). A comprehensive comparison of cell lineage composition and activation in young B6 and B6.Sle123 mice revealed a variety of cellular alterations in the presence and absence of systemic IFN-alpha. Most IFN-alpha-induced phenotypes were similar in B6 and B6.Sle123 mice; however, B6.Sle123 mice uniquely exhibited increased B1 and plasma cells after IFN-alpha exposure, although both strains had an overall loss of mature B cells in the bone marrow, spleen and periphery. Although most of the cellular effects of IFN-alpha were identical in both strains, severe glomerulonephritis occurred only in B6.Sle123 mice. Mice injected with IFN-ADV showed an increase in immune complex deposition in the kidney, together with an unexpected decrease in serum anti-nuclear antibody levels. In summary, the predominant impact of systemic IFN-alpha in this murine model is an exacerbation of mechanisms mediating end organ damage.     

Pregnancy-induced expansion of regulatory T-lymphocytes may mediate protection to multiple sclerosis activity

The role of activated CD8⁺ T cells in shaping the dynamics of in vivo antigen presentation and immune responses is a subject receiving more attention. We studied whether cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) would limit antibody responses by targeting antigen-specific B cells. A modified in vivo CTL assay was developed and used herein to demonstrate cytotoxicity in vivo, and to show that antigen-specific B cells that process exogenous antigen and present peptide in association with MHC class I can be the targets of CD8⁺ T cells. B cells from C57BL/6 mice immunized with ovalbumin (OVA)/alum were pulsed with OVA in vitro, and transferred into C57BL/6 recipient mice that had been immunized with vaccinia virus expressing SIINFEKL minigene to generate CD8⁺ CTL against K^b/SIINFEKL. OVA-pulsed B220⁺ B cells from OVA-immunized mice were killed to a greater extent than B220⁺ B cells from naïve mice (28 ± 20% versus 12 ± 16%, p = 0.0042). However, mice receiving vaccinia-SIINFEKL and generating CTL, did not appear to target endogenous B cells, since both primary and secondary antibody responses to OVA were unaffected. Our findings indicate that CTL responses to the protein antigen do not interfere with endogenous B cell responses, even though exogenous B cells expressing the CTL epitope can be efficiently lysed.     

Murine lupus susceptibility locus Sle2 activates DNA-reactive B cells through two sub-loci with distinct phenotypes

The NZM2410-derived Sle2 lupus susceptibility locus induces an abnormal B-cell differentiation, which most prominently leads to the expansion of autoreactive B1a cells. We have mapped the expansion of B1a cells to three Sle2 sub-loci, Sle2a, Sle2b and Sle2c. Sle2 also enhances the breach of B-cell tolerance to nuclear antigens in the 56R anti-DNA immunoglobulin transgenic (Tg) model. This study used the Sle2 sub-congenic strains to map the activation of 56R Tg B cells. Sle2c strongly sustained the breach of tolerance and the activation of anti-DNA B cells. The production of Tg-encoded anti-DNA antibodies was more modest in Sle2a-expressing mice, but Sle2a was responsible for the recruitment for Tg B cells to the marginal zone, a phenotype that has been found for 56R Tg B cells in mice expressing the whole Sle2 interval. In addition, Sle2a promoted the production of endogenously encoded anti-DNA antibodies. Overall, this study showed that at least two Sle2 genes are involved in the activation of anti-DNA B cells, and excluded more than two-thirds of the Sle2 interval from contributing to this phenotype. This constitutes an important step toward the identification of novel genes that have a critical role in B-cell tolerance.     

T cell-independent and T cell-dependent immunoglobulin G responses to polyomavirus infection are impaired in complement receptor 2-deficient mice

Polyomavirus (PyV) infection induces protective T cell-independent (TI) IgM and IgG antibody responses in T cell-deficient mice, but these responses are not generated by immunization with viral proteins or virus like particles. We hypothesized that innate signals contribute to the generation of isotype-switched antiviral antibody responses. We studied the role of complement receptor (CR2) engagement in TI and T cell-dependent (TD) antibody responses to PyV using CR2-deficient mice. Antiviral IgG responses were reduced by 80-40% in CR2-/- mice compared to wild type. Adoptive transfer experiments demonstrated the need for CR2 not only in TD, but also in TI IgG responses to PyV. Transfer of CR2-/- B lymphocytes to SCID mice resulted in TI antiviral IgG responses that corresponded to 10% of that seen in wild-type B cell-reconstituted mice. Thus, our studies revealed a profound dependence of TI and TD antiviral antibody responses on CR2-mediated signals in PyV-infected mice, where the viral antigen is abundant and persistent.     

Haptenated streptococcal antigens elicit either T cell-dependent type 1 or T cell-independent type 2 immune responses

Antigens of Streptococcus mutans 6715 (alternatively designated serotype g Streptococcus sobrinus), including whole cells (WC g), cell walls (CW g), peptidoglycan (PG g) and serotype carbohydrate (Ml g) were coupled with trinitrophenyl (TNP), and the nature of the immune response to each immunogen was determined in normal and X-linked immunodeficient (xid) murine spleen cell cultures. Responses to TNP-WC g, -CW g and -PG g and to the classical type 1 antigen TNP-Brucella abortus occurred in both xid and normal splenic cultures, while TNP-Ml g only triggered immune responses in normal spleen cell cultures, suggesting that the former three antigens are type 1 and the latter type 2. Further support for the type 2 nature of TNP-Ml g was the finding that Peyer's patch cell cultures from both xid (which contain mature B cells) and normal mice supported responses to TNP-Ml g and TNP-Ficoll, while xid splenic cultures failed to support responses to either type 2 antigen. The three type 1 TNP-S. mutans antigens induced responses in nude spleen cell and in purified splenic B cell cultures, but required T cells for in vitro responses to lower doses of immunogen. On the other hand, TNP-Ml g induced anti-TNP PFC responses at several antigen concentrations in purified B cell cultures, without requirement for added T cells. These studies show that the intact S. mutans cell, as well as CW g and PG g, acts as a T cell-dependent (TD) type 1 antigen, while the serotype carbohydrate (Ml g) induces a T cell-independent (TI) type 2 response. Thus, the intact bacterium is a TD type 1 antigen, whereas its purified components are either type 1 or type 2 antigens and differ significantly in terms of their T cell dependence.     

Impaired B cell maturation in mice lacking Bruton's tyrosine kinase (Btk) and CD40

Mutations in Bruton's tyrosine kinase (Btk) gene, in mice, result in reduced numbers and responses of peripheral B cells. Surface Ig- mediated signaling is defective in Btk mutant B cells as they do not proliferate upon slg cross-linking and lack thymus-independent (TI) type II responses. Signals through sIg and CD40 play a critical role in B cell maturation. To investigate the consequences of the lack of both Btk and CD40 on B cell development and function, mice were generated that were homozygous for targeted mutations in the Btk and the CD40 genes (BtkMCD40M). The CD40 mutation (CD40M) had a synergistic effect on the BtkM defects. In BtkMCD40M mice the number of B cells was reduced 3- to 4-fold compared to BtkM mice and mature B cells (IgMlow/IgDhigh) were virtually absent; serum levels of all Ig isotypes were diminished; and antibody responses to TI-I TI-II and thymus- dependent antigens were impaired. Furthermore, although wild-type BtkM and CD40M mice produced germinal centers in response to TI-I antigen, the BtkMCD40M mice did not. Maturational and functional B cell defects in BtkMCD40M mice may result from a combination of intrinsic B cell defects, lack of CD40L-dependent T cell help and microenvironmental defects. These data suggest that signals through Btk and CD40 are necessary for the production and maintenance of the mature B cell.      

Antigen requirements for priming of IgG producing B memory cells specific for Type III pneumococcal polysaccharide.

B cells from mice primed with various amounts of the T-independent (TI) antigen Type III pneumococcal polysaccharide (S3) or with the T-dependent (TD) form of S3, i.e. S3-HRBC, were transferred to irradiated recipients with T cells from S3-HRBC primed mice. After immunization with S3-HRBC, significant S3-specific IgG memory responses were produced only by those mice which received B cells from mice primed with the TD antigen. Activation of amplifier T cells (TA) at the time of priming with S3 resulted in increased IgG production by transferred B cells although the amount of IgG produced was still substantially less than that produced by B cells from S3-HRBC primed mice. An amount of S3 (0.6 microgram) which induces optimal primary IgM responses was found to suppress the induction of B memory cells by S3-HRBC. Lower amounts of S3 were not suppressive yet they were still unable to induce IgG memory in B cells. Taken together the results suggest that the TI antigen S3 does not induce differentiation of B cells to IgG producing memory cells because S3 is unable to activate a cell type (presumably T helper cells) which is required for this inductive process to occur.