Approaches to heart valve tissue engineering scaffold design

Heart valve disease is a significant cause of mortality worldwide. However, to date, a nonthrombogenic, noncalcific prosthetic, which maintains normal valve mechanical properties and hemodynamic flow, and exhibits sufficient fatigue properties has not been designed. Current prosthetic designs have not been optimized and are unsuitable treatment for congenital heart defects. Research is therefore moving towards the development of a tissue engineered heart valve equivalent. Two approaches may be used in the creation of a tissue engineered heart valve, the traditional approach, which involves seeding a scaffold in vitro, in the presence of specific signals prior to implantation, and the guided tissue regeneration approach, which relies on autologous reseeding in vivo. Regardless of the approach taken, the design of a scaffold capable of supporting the growth of cells and extracellular matrix generation and capable of withstanding the unrelenting cardiovascular environment while forming a tight seal during closure, is critical to the success of the tissue engineered construct. This paper focuses on the quest to design, such a scaffold.     

组织工程心脏瓣膜支架材料的选择与应用

背景：支架材料的选择在组织工程心脏瓣膜中起着至关重要的作用,支架材料的选择也就影响着组织工程心脏瓣膜的构建效果。 目的：评价组织工程心脏瓣膜支架材料的的优缺点,并对其选择进行总结。 方法：以 “组织工程,心脏瓣膜,支架材料,生物相容性”,为中文关键词;以:“tissue engineering,heart valves, scaffold material, biocompatibility” 为英文关键词,采用计算机检索1993-01/2009-10相关文章。纳入与有关生物材料与组织工程心脏瓣膜的相关的文章;排除重复研究及Meta分析类文章。 结果与结论：人工合成高分子材料有更大的可控性,可预先塑性,大量制备,孔径和孔隙率较容易控制,成本低廉;天然生物材料和合成高分子材料都存在一定不足,将人工可降解材料与天然材料相结合构建瓣膜支架,发挥两者各自的优势构建出性能良好的组织工程心脏瓣膜。组织工程心脏瓣膜的研究前景广阔。但距离临床应用还有很长的路要走,相信随着研究的不断深入以及支架材料的不断优化对组织工程心脏瓣膜构建方法的改进,在不远的将来造福于广大心脏瓣膜病患者。     

组织工程化心脏瓣膜的研究进展

心脏瓣膜置换术是外科治疗瓣膜性心脏病的主要方法，但目前临床应用的人工瓣膜的远期效果尚不满意。近年来，随着组织工程学技术的进展，利用培养的自身组织细胞种植于支架材料表面，体外重新构建理想的心脏瓣膜植物日益成为研究热点。本文简述了心脏瓣膜工程的定义，细胞支架材料的选择，种子细胞的培养、种植方法以及组织工程化心脏瓣膜的评估，并指出下一步研究中尚需解决的问题。     

The in vitro development of autologous fibrin-based tissue-engineered heart valves through optimised dynamic conditioning

Our group has previously demonstrated the synthesis of a completely autologous fibrin-based heart valve structure using the principles of tissue engineering. The present approach aims to guide more mature tissue development in fibrin-based valves based on in vitro conditioning in a custom-designed bioreactor system. Moulded fibrin-based tissue-engineered heart valves seeded with ovine carotid artery-derived cells were subjected to 12 days of mechanical conditioning in a bioreactor system. The bioreactor pulse rate was increased from 5 to 10 b.p.m. after 6 days, while a pressure difference of 20 mmH(2)O was maintained over the valve leaflets. Control valves were cultured under stirred conditions in a beaker. Cell phenotype and extracellular matrix (ECM) composition were analysed in all samples and compared to native ovine aortic valve tissue using routine histological and immunohistochemical techniques. Conditioned valve leaflets showed reduced tissue shrinkage compared to stirred controls. Limited ECM synthesis was evident in stirred controls, while the majority of cells were detached from the fibrin scaffold. Dynamic conditioning increased cell attachment/alignment and expression of alpha-smooth muscle actin, while enhancing the deposition of ECM proteins, including types I and III collagen, fibronectin, laminin and chondroitin sulphate. There was no evidence for elastin synthesis in either stirred controls or conditioned samples. The present study demonstrates that the application of low-pressure conditions and increasing pulsatile flow not only enhances seeded cell attachment and alignment within fibrin-based heart valves, but dramatically changes the manner in which these cells generate ECM proteins and remodel the valve matrix. Optimised dynamic conditioning, therefore, might accelerate the maturation of surgically feasible and implantable autologous fibrin-based tissue-engineered heart valves.     

Tissue engineering in the cardiovascular system: progress toward a tissue engineered heart

Achieving the lofty goal of developing a tissue engineered heart will likely rely on progress in engineering the various components: blood vessels, heart valves, and cardiac muscle. Advances in tissue engineered vascular grafts have shown the most progress to date. Research in tissue-engineered vascular grafts has focused on improving scaffold design, including mechanical properties and bioactivity; genetically engineering cells to improve graft performance; and optimizing tissue formation through in vitro mechanical conditioning. Some of these same approaches have been used in developing tissue engineering heart valves and cardiac muscle as well. Continued advances in scaffold technology and a greater understanding of vascular cell biology along with collaboration among engineers, scientists, and physicians will lead to further progress in the field of cardiovascular tissue engineering and ultimately the development of a tissue-engineered heart.     

Progress in developing a living human tissue-engineered tri-leaflet heart valve assembled from tissue produced by the self-assembly approach

The aortic heart valve is constantly subjected to pulsatile flow and pressure gradients which, associated with cardiovascular risk factors and abnormal hemodynamics (i.e. altered wall shear stress), can cause stenosis and calcification of the leaflets and result in valve malfunction and impaired circulation. Available options for valve replacement include homograft, allogenic or xenogenic graft as well as the implantation of a mechanical valve. A tissue-engineered heart valve containing living autologous cells would represent an alternative option, particularly for pediatric patients, but still needs to be developed. The present study was designed to demonstrate the feasibility of using a living tissue sheet produced by the self-assembly method, to replace the bovine pericardium currently used for the reconstruction of a stented human heart valve. In this study, human fibroblasts were cultured in the presence of sodium ascorbate to produce tissue sheets. These sheets were superimposed to create a thick construct. Tissue pieces were cut from these constructs and assembled together on a stent, based on techniques used for commercially available replacement valves. Histology and transmission electron microscopy analysis showed that the fibroblasts were embedded in a dense extracellular matrix produced in vitro. The mechanical properties measured were consistent with the fact that the engineered tissue was resistant and could be cut, sutured and assembled on a wire frame typically used in bioprosthetic valve assembly. After a culture period in vitro, the construct was cohesive and did not disrupt or disassemble. The tissue engineered heart valve was stimulated in a pulsatile flow bioreactor and was able to sustain multiple duty cycles. This prototype of a tissue-engineered heart valve containing cells embedded in their own extracellular matrix and sewn on a wire frame has the potential to be strong enough to support physiological stress. The next step will be to test this valve extensively in a bioreactor and at a later date, in a large animal model in order to assess in vivo patency of the graft.     

A knitted, fibrin-covered polycaprolactone scaffold for tissue engineering of the aortic valve

State-of-the-art tissue engineered heart valves are not strong enough to withstand aortic blood pressure levels. When a strong and slowly degrading scaffold is used, the starting position of valvular tissue engineering is a stronger valve and seeded cells are allowed more time to create a strong extracellular matrix. A polycaprolactone knitted patch with leaflets was developed as a valvular scaffold. It was sutured into a tube and covered with fibrin gel. The opening and closing behavior and leakage of knitted scaffolds without cells were studied and compared to those of stentless porcine valves. An MTT test was performed on polycaprolactone and fibrin. A loading device was developed to study the durability of the knitted scaffold. The scaffold showed proper opening and it showed coaptation upon closing, but a 39 +/- 3% (n = 3) leakage, compared to a 8 +/- 1% (n = 3) leakage of tested porcine valves. MTT tests showed that polycaprolactone and fibrin are biocompatible materials. Durability testing of the knitted scaffold (n = 1) did not show rupture after ten million loading cycles. A tissue engineering process that includes cell culture will have to show whether this scaffold, besides mechanically reliable and biocompatible, is suitable to lead to a functional, nonregurgitant, durable aortic valve.     

Design and Hydrodynamic Evaluation of a Novel Pulsatile Bioreactor for Biologically Active Heart Valves

Biologically active heart valves (tissue engineered and recellularized tissue-derived heart valves) have the potential to offer enhanced function when compared to current replacement value therapies since they can possibly remodel, and grow to meet the needs of the patient, and not require chronic medication. However, this technology is still in its infancy and many fundamental questions remain as to how these valves will function in vivo. It has been shown that exposing biologically active tissue constructs to pulsatile pressures and flows during in vitro culture produces enhanced extracellular matrix protein expression and cellularity, although the ideal hydrodynamic conditioning regime is as yet unknown. Moreover, in vitro organ-level studies of living heart valves aimed at studying the remodeling processes require environments that can accurately reproduce in vivo hemodynamics under sterile conditions. To this end, we have developed a system to study the effects of subjecting biologically active heart valves to highly controlled pulsatile pressure and flow waveforms under sterile conditions. The device fits inside a standard incubator and utilizes a computer-controlled closed loop feedback system to provide a high degree of control. The mean pressure, mean flow rate, driving frequency, and shape of the pulsatile pressure waveform can be changed automatically in order to simulate both physiologic and nonphysiologic hemodynamic conditions. Extensive testing and evaluation demonstrated the device's ability to subject a biologically active heart valve to highly controlled pulsatile waveforms that can be modulated during the course of sterile incubation.     

组织工程血管研究的新进展

血管组织工程近年来发展的相当快，目前的研究主要着眼于支架材料的设计诸如机械性能和生物活性的改变，种子细胞的选择及体外动态培养系统的应用。进一步改进支架材料的生物特性，深入研究细胞间的相互作用及细胞信号的传导尤其是基因工程，干细胞研究的进展将会促进组织工程血管在临床应用。     

Direct compression as an appropriately mechanical environment in bone tissue reconstruction in vitro

Determining how to apply an appropriately mechanical environment which can improve the quality and function of bone-like construct in vitro is a required problem to be solved for the current development of bone tissue engineering. A specific mechanical force may be a key determinant of tissue development in vitro in bone tissue engineering. From the standpoint of bionics, the mechanical environments applied on bone tissue engineering should work in three aspects: providing adequately mechanical stimuli to the cells seeded in 3-D scaffold; ensuring the efficient mass-transport of the nutrients and waste products of the cells; promoting the development of functionally extracellular matrix in 3-D scaffold. After the analysis of several differently mechanical environments comparing with that in vivo, the directly dynamical compression environment, instead of hydrostatic pressure or microgravity or direct perfusion, can recreate the in vivo mechanisms of mechanosensation, mechanotransduction and mass-transport during engineered bone-like tissue culturing process in vitro. Therefore, it is hypothesized that the directly dynamic compression will be a specific mechanical environment to bone tissue reconstruction in vitro.     

Short-term culture of human neonatal myofibroblasts seeded using a novel three-dimensional rotary seeding device

A crucial factor in the tissue engineering of heart valves is an effective cell seeding with uniform cell distribution on biodegradable scaffolds to eventually form functional tissue constructs in vitro. In our laboratory, we developed a new cell-seeding device for optimal cell distribution for tissue-engineered heart valve constructs. In the present study, we developed a new cell-seeding device made of acrylic glass that is completely transparent (University Hospital Benjamin Franklin, Berlin, Germany). The polymeric heart valve scaffold is fixed in a small-volume, cylindrical cell-seeding chamber, and is surrounded by optimal cell suspension. The cell-seeding chamber is placed in a clear acrylic bowl so that it can be rotated in all directions to provide optimal cell distribution to all areas of the heart valve construct. We thus developed a highly isolated cell-seeding device that is driven by an independently developed rotating machine consisting of two independent motors (University Hospital Benjamin Franklin, Berlin, Germany). The whole system provides a high level of sterility and fits into a humidified incubator. Our newly developed cell-seeding device enables sterile conditions and optimal cell distribution for the controlled fabrication of autologous tissue-engineered heart valve constructs.     

Scaffolds for tissue engineering of cardiac valves

Tissue engineered heart valves offer a promising alternative for the replacement of diseased heart valves avoiding the limitations faced with currently available bioprosthetic and mechanical heart valves. In the paradigm of tissue engineering, a three-dimensional platform – the so-called scaffold – is essential for cell proliferation, growth and differentiation, as well as the ultimate generation of a functional tissue. A foundation for success in heart valve tissue engineering is a recapitulation of the complex design and diverse mechanical properties of a native valve. This article reviews technological details of the scaffolds that have been applied to date in heart valve tissue engineering research.     

Fabrication of a trileaflet heart valve scaffold from a polyhydroxyalkanoate biopolyester for use in tissue engineering

Previously, we reported the implantation of a single tissue engineered leaflet in the posterior position of the pulmonary valve in a lamb model. The major problems with this leaflet replacement were the scaffold's inherent stiffness, thickness, and nonpliability. We have now created a scaffold for a trileaflet heart valve using a thermoplastic polyester. In this experiment, we show the suitability of this material in the production of a biodegradable, biocompatible scaffold for tissue engineered heart valves. A heart valve scaffold was constructed from a thermoplastic elastomer. The elastomer belongs to a class of biodegradable, biocompatible polyesters known as polyhydroxyalkanoates (PHAs) and is produced by fermentation (Metabolix Inc., Cambridge, MA). It was modified by a salt leaching technique to create a porous, three-dimensional structure, suitable for tissue engineering. The trileaflet heart valve scaffold consisted of a cylindrical stent (1 mm X 15 mm X 20 mm I.D.) containing three valve leaflets. The leaflets were formed from a single piece of PHA (0.3 mm thick), and were attached to the outside of the stent by thermal processing techniques, which required no suturing. After fabrication, the heart valve construct was allowed to crystallize (4 degrees C for 24 h), and salt particles were leached into doubly distilled water over a period of 5 days to yield pore sizes ranging from 80 to 200 microns. Ten heart valve scaffolds were fabricated and seeded with vascular cells from an ovine carotid artery. After 4 days of incubation, the constructs were examined by scanning electron microscopy. The heart valve scaffold was tested in a pulsatile flow bioreactor and it was noted that the leaflets opened and closed. Cells attached to the polymer and formed a confluent layer after incubation. One advantage of this material is the ability to mold a complete trileaflet heart valve scaffold without the need for suturing leaflets to the conduit. Second advantage is the use of only one polymer material (PHA) as opposed to hybridized polymer scaffolds. Furthermore, the mechanical properties of PHA, such as elasticity and mechanical strength, exceed those of the previously utilized material. This experiment shows that PHAs can be used to fabricate a three-dimensional, biodegradable heart valve scaffold.     

不同类型生物材料的心脏瓣膜应用及安全性评价

背景:组织工程心脏瓣膜是应用工程学和生命科学的原理和方法构建具有生理功能和生物活性的瓣膜替代物,但仍处于动物实验阶段。 目的：总结常用的组织工程心脏瓣膜,对不同类型生物材料的心脏瓣膜应用的安全性进行评价。 方法：以“生物材料,心脏瓣膜,支架材料,综述文献,组织工程”为中文关键词,采用计算机检索2000-01/2010-12相关文章。纳入与生物材料与组织工程心脏瓣膜研究相关的文章;排除重复研究或Meta分析类文章。 结果与结论：共纳入生物材料与组织工程心脏瓣膜研究相关文献20篇。天然支架材料因其优越的生物相容性和三维空间构象,具有其他材料不可比拟的仿生性。合成可降解高分子材料具有良好的可控性和力学性能也备受研究者青睐,而将天然材料和高分子材料融合一体构建的复合支架材料为组织工程心脏瓣膜的研究提供了新的策略和方向,具有广阔的应用前景。     

Tissue Engineering of Human Heart Valve Leaflets: A Novel Bioreactor for a Strain-Based Conditioning Approach

Current mechanical conditioning approaches for heart valve tissue engineering concentrate on mimicking the opening and closing behavior of the leaflets, either or not in combination with tissue straining. This study describes a novel approach by mimicking only the diastolic phase of the cardiac cycle, resulting in tissue straining. A novel, yet simplified, bioreactor system was developed for this purpose by applying a dynamic pressure difference over a closed tissue engineered valve, thereby inducing dynamic strains within the leaflets. Besides the use of dynamic strains, the developing leaflet tissues were exposed to prestrain induced by the use of a stented geometry. To demonstrate the feasibility of this strain-based conditioning approach, human heart valve leaflets were engineered and their mechanial behavior evaluated. The actual dynamic strain magnitude in the leaflets over time was estimated using numerical analyses. Preliminary results showed superior tissue formation and non-linear tissue-like mechanical properties in the strained valves when compared to non-loaded tissue strips. In conclusion, the strain-based conditioning approach, using both prestrain and dynamic strains, offers new possibilities for bioreactor design and optimization of tissue properties towards a tissue-engineered aortic human heart valve replacement.     

Integration of hollow fiber membranes improves nutrient supply in three-dimensional tissue constructs

Sufficient nutrient and oxygen transport is a potent modulator of cell proliferation in in vitro tissue-engineered constructs. The lack of oxygen and culture medium can create a potentially lethal environment and limit cellular metabolic activity and growth. Diffusion through scaffold and multi-cellular tissue typically limits transport in vitro, leading to potential hypoxic regions and reduction in the viable tissue thickness. For the in vitro generation of clinically relevant tissue-engineered grafts, current nutrient diffusion limitations should be addressed. Major approaches to overcoming these include culture with bioreactors, scaffolds with artificial microvasculature, oxygen carriers and pre-vascularization of the engineered tissues. This study focuses on the development and utilization of a new perfusion culture system to provide adequate nutrient delivery to cells within large three-dimensional (3D) scaffolds. Perfusion of oxygenated culture medium through porous hollow fiber (HF) integrated within 3D free form fabricated (FFF) scaffolds is proposed. Mouse pre-myoblast (C2C12) cells cultured on scaffolds of poly(ethylene-oxide-terephthalate)-poly(butylene-terephthalate) block copolymer (300PEOT55PBT45) integrated with porous HF membranes of modified poly(ether-sulfone) (mPES, Gambro GmbH) is used as a model system. Various parameters such as fiber transport properties, fiber spacing within a scaffold and medium flow conditions are optimized. The results show that four HF membranes integrated with the scaffold significantly improve the cell density and cell distribution. This study provides a basis for the development of a new HF perfusion culture methodology to overcome the limitations of nutrient diffusion in the culture of large 3D tissue constructs.     

Cyclic flexure and laminar flow synergistically accelerate mesenchymal stem cell-mediated engineered tissue formation: Implications for engineered heart valve tissues

Bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells (BMSCs) are relatively accessible and exhibit a pluripotency suitable for cardiovascular applications such as tissue-engineered heart valves (TEHVs). Recently, Sutherland et al. [From stem cells to viable autologous semilunar heart valve. Circulation 2005; 111(21): 2783-91] demonstrated that BMSC-seeded TEHV can successfully function as pulmonary valve substitutes in juvenile sheep for at least 8 months. Toward determining appropriate mechanical stimuli for use in BMSC-seeded TEHV cultivation, we investigated the independent and coupled effects of two mechanical stimuli physiologically relevant to heart valves-cyclic flexure and laminar flow (i.e. fluid shear stress)-on BMSC-mediated tissue formation. BMSC isolated from juvenile sheep were expanded and seeded onto rectangular strips of nonwoven 50:50 blend poly(glycolic acid) (PGA) and poly(l-lactic acid) (PLLA) scaffolds. Following 4 days static culture, BMSC-seeded scaffolds were loaded into a novel flex-stretch-flow (FSF) bioreactor and incubated under static (n=12), cyclic flexure (n=12), laminar flow (avg. wall shear stress=1.1505 dyne/cm(2); n=12) and combined flex-flow (n=12) conditions for 1 (n=6) and 3 (n=6) weeks. By 3 weeks, the flex-flow group exhibited dramatically accelerated tissue formation compared with all other groups, including a 75% higher collagen content of 844+/-278 microg/g wet weight (p<0.05), and an effective stiffness (E) value of 948+/-233 kPa. Importantly, collagen and E values were not significantly different from values measured for vascular smooth muscle cell (SMC) -seeded scaffolds incubated under conditions of flexure alone [Engelmayr et al. The independent role of cyclic flexure in the early in vitro development of an engineered heart valve tissue. Biomaterials 2005; 26(2): 175-87], suggesting that BMSC-seeded TEHV can be optimized to yield results comparable to SMC-seeded TEHV. We thus demonstrated that cyclic flexure and laminar flow can synergistically accelerate BMSC-mediated tissue formation, providing a basis for the rational design of in vitro conditioning regimens for BMSC-seeded TEHV.     

Tissue-engineering bioreactors: a new combined cell-seeding and perfusion system for vascular tissue engineering

One approach to the tissue engineering of vascular structures is to develop in vitro conditions in order ultimately to fabricate functional vascular tissues before final implantation. In our experiment, we aimed to develop a new combined cell seeding and perfusion system that provides sterile conditions during cell seeding and biomechanical stimuli in order to fabricate autologous human vascular tissue in vitro. The cell seeding and perfusion system is made of Plexiglas and is completely transparent (Berlin Heart, Berlin, Germany; University Hospital Benjamin Franklin, Berlin, Germany). The whole system consists of a cell seeding chamber that can be incorporated into the perfusion system and an air-driven respirator pump connected to the bioreactor. The cell culture medium continuously circulates through a closed-loop system. We thus developed a cell seeding device for static and dynamic seeding of vascular cells onto a polymeric vascular scaffold and a closed-loop perfused bioreactor for long-term vascular conditioning. The cell seeding chamber can be easily connected to the bioreactor, which combines continuous, pulsatile perfusion and mechanical stimulation to the tissue-engineered conduit. Adjusting the stroke volume, the stroke rate, and the inspiration/expiration time of the ventilator allows various pulsatile flows and different levels of pressure. The whole system is a highly isolated cell culture setting, which provides a high level of sterility and a gas supply and fits into a standard humidified incubator. The device can be sterilized by ethylene oxide and assembled with a standard screwdriver. Our newly developed combination of a cell seeding and conditioning device provides sterile conditions and biodynamic stimuli for controlled tissue development and in vitro conditioning of an autologous tissue-engineered vessel.     

6-Month aortic valve implantation of an off-the-shelf tissue-engineered valve in sheep

Diseased aortic valves often require replacement, with over 30% of the current aortic valve surgeries performed in patients who will outlive a bioprosthetic valve. While many promising tissue-engineered valves have been created in the lab using the cell-seeded polymeric scaffold paradigm, none have been successfully tested long-term in the aortic position of a pre-clinical model. The high pressure gradients and dynamic flow across the aortic valve leaflets require engineering a tissue that has the strength and compliance to withstand high mechanical demand without compromising normal hemodynamics. A long-term preclinical evaluation of an off-the-shelf tissue-engineered aortic valve in the sheep model is presented here. The valves were made from a tube of decellularized cell-produced matrix mounted on a frame. The engineered matrix is primarily composed of collagen, with strength and organization comparable to native valve leaflets. In vitro testing showed excellent hemodynamic performance with low regurgitation, low systolic pressure gradient, and large orifice area. The implanted valves showed large-scale leaflet motion and maintained effective orifice area throughout the duration of the 6-month implant, with no calcification. After 24 weeks implantation (over 17 million cycles), the valves showed no change in tensile mechanical properties. In addition, histology and DNA quantitation showed repopulation of the engineered matrix with interstitial-like cells and endothelialization. New extracellular matrix deposition, including elastin, further demonstrates positive tissue remodeling in addition to recellularization and valve function. Long-term implantation in the sheep model resulted in functionality, matrix remodeling, and recellularization, unprecedented results for a tissue-engineered aortic valve.