Differences in assembly or stability of complex I and other mitochondrial OXPHOS complexes in inherited complex I deficiency

NADH-ubiquinone oxidoreductase (complex I) deficiency is amongst the most encountered defects of the mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS) system and is associated with a wide variety of clinical signs and symptoms. Mutations in complex I nuclear structural genes are the most common cause of isolated complex I enzyme deficiencies. The cell biological consequences of such mutations are poorly understood. In this paper we have used blue native electrophoresis in order to study how different nuclear mutations affect the integrity of mitochondrial OXPHOS complexes in fibroblasts from 15 complex I-deficient patients. Our results show an important decrease in the levels of intact complex I in patients harboring mutations in nuclear-encoded complex I subunits, indicating that complex I assembly and/or stability is compromised. Different patterns of low molecular weight subcomplexes are present in these patients, suggesting that the formation of the peripheral arm is affected at an early assembly stage. Mutations in complex I genes can also affect the stability of other mitochondrial complexes, with a specific decrease of fully-assembled complex III in patients with mutations in NDUFS2 and NDUFS4. We have extended this analysis to patients with an isolated complex I deficiency in which no mutations in structural subunits have been found. In this group, we can discriminate between complex I assembly and catalytic defects attending to the fact whether there is a correlation between assembly/activity levels or not. This will help us to point more selectively to candidate genes for pathogenic mutations that could lead to an isolated complex I defect.     

Mutant NDUFS3 subunit of mitochondrial complex I causes Leigh syndrome

Respiratory chain complex I deficiency represents a genetically heterogeneous group of diseases resulting from mutations in mitochondrial or nuclear genes. Mutations have been reported in 13 of the 14 subunits encoding the core of complex I (seven mitochondrial and six nuclear genes) and these result in Leigh or Leigh-like syndromes or cardiomyopathy. In this study, a combination of denaturing high performance liquid chromatography and sequence analysis was used to study the NDUFS3 gene in a series of complex I deficient patients. Mutations found in this gene (NADH dehydrogenase iron-sulphur protein 3), coding for the seventh and last subunit of complex I core, were shown to cause late onset Leigh syndrome, optic atrophy, and complex I deficiency. A biochemical diagnosis of complex I deficiency on cultured amniocytes from a later pregnancy was confirmed through the identification of disease causing NDUFS3 mutations in these cells. While mutations in the NDUFS3 gene thus result in Leigh syndrome, a dissimilar clinical phenotype is observed in mutations in the NDUFV2 and NDUFS2 genes, resulting in encephalomyopathy and cardiomyopathy. The reasons for these differences are uncertain.     

Rapid screening for nuclear genes mutations in isolated respiratory chain complex I defects

Complex I or reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NADH): ubiquinone oxydoreductase deficiency is the most common cause of respiratory chain defects. Molecular bases of complex I deficiencies are rarely identified because of the dual genetic origin of this multi-enzymatic complex (nuclear DNA and mitochondrial DNA) and the lack of phenotype–genotype correlation. We used a rapid method to screen patients with isolated complex I deficiencies for nuclear genes mutations by Surveyor nuclease digestion of cDNAs. Eight complex I nuclear genes, among the most frequently mutated (NDUFS1, NDUFS2, NDUFS3, NDUFS4, NDUFS7, NDUFS8, NDUFV1 and NDUFV2), were studied in 22 cDNA fragments spanning their coding sequences in 8 patients with a biochemically proved complex I deficiency. Single nucleotide polymorphisms and missense mutations were detected in 18.7% of the cDNA fragments by Surveyor nuclease treatment. Molecular defects were detected in 3 patients. Surveyor nuclease screening is a reliable method for genotyping nuclear complex I deficiencies, easy to interpret, and limits the number of sequence reactions. Its use will enhance the possibility of prenatal diagnosis and help us for a better understanding of complex I molecular defects.     

A novel NDUFA1 mutation leads to a progressive mitochondrial complex I-specific neurodegenerative disease

Mitochondrial diseases have been shown to result from mutations in mitochondrial genes located in either the nuclear DNA (nDNA) or mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA). Mitochondrial OXPHOS complex I has 45 subunits encoded by 38 nuclear and 7 mitochondrial genes. Two male patients in a putative X-linked pedigree exhibiting a progressive neurodegenerative disorder and a severe muscle complex I enzyme defect were analyzed for mutations in the 38 nDNA and seven mtDNA encoded complex I subunits. The nDNA X-linked NDUFA1 gene (MWFE polypeptide) was discovered to harbor a novel missense mutation which changed a highly conserved glycine at position 32 to an arginine, shown to segregate with the disease. When this mutation was introduced into a NDUFA1 null hamster cell line, a substantial decrease in the complex I assembly and activity was observed. When the mtDNA of the patient was analyzed, potentially relevant missense mutations were observed in the complex I genes. Transmitochondrial cybrids containing the patient’s mtDNA resulted in a mild complex I deficiency. Interestingly enough, the nDNA encoded MWFE polypeptide has been shown to interact with various mtDNA encoded complex I subunits. Therefore, we hypothesize that the novel G32R mutation in NDUFA1 is causing complex I deficiency either by itself or in synergy with additional mtDNA variants.     

Cellular rescue-assay aids verification of causative DNA-variants in mitochondrial complex I deficiency

Mitochondrial complex I deficiency is a frequent biochemical condition, causing about one third of respiratory chain disorders. Partly due to the large number of genes necessary for its assembly and function only a small proportion of complex I deficiencies are yet confirmed at the molecular genetic level. Now, next generation sequencing approaches are applied to close the gap between biochemical definition and molecular diagnosis. Nevertheless such approaches result in a long list of novel rare single nucleotide variants. Identifying the causative mutations still remains challenging. Here we describe the identification and functional confirmation of novel NDUFS1 mutations using a cellular rescue-assay. Patient-derived complex I-defective fibroblast cell lines were transduced with wild type and mutant NDUFS1-cDNA and subsequently analyzed on the functional and protein level. We established the pathogenic nature of identified rare variants in four out of five disease alleles. This approach is a valuable add-on in disease genetics and it allows the analysis of the functional consequences of genetic variants in metabolic disorders.     

Nuclear genes of human complex I of the mitochondrial electron transport chain: state of the art

The mitochondrial electron transport chain (mtETC) consists of four multi-subunit enzyme complexes. Complex I or NADH:ubiquinone oxidoreductase, the largest mtETC multisubunit complex, consists of approximately 41 subunits. Seven of these subunits are encoded by the mitochondrial genome, the remainder by the nuclear genome. Among the mitochondriocytopathies, complex I deficiencies are encountered frequently. Although some complex I deficiencies have been associated with mitochondrial DNA mutations, the genetic defect has not been elucidated in the majority of complex I-deficient patients. It is expected that many of these patients have mutations in the nuclear- encoded subunits of this complex, so vital for cellular energy production. After a brief summary of the current knowledge of complex I from cow, bacteria and fungi, this review presents the state of the art of the knowledge of the human nuclear-encoded complex I genes which, in the last 18 months, has made enormous progress. At present, the complete gene structure of four subunits and the cDNA structure of 18 of the 34 complex I nuclear-encoded subunits are known. Mapping of these subunits shows a random distribution over the chromosomes. The chromosomal localization is known for 14 complex I genes. Recently, the first mutation, a 5 bp duplication in the 18 kDa (AQDQ) subunit, has been reported. We expect that within 1 year all human nuclear-encoded complex I subunits will be cloned. Mutational analysis of these subunits is warranted in complex I-deficient patients and will not only be important for genetic counselling but will also extend the knowledge regarding the functional properties of the individual human complex I subunits.      

Heterozygous mutation in the X chromosomal NDUFA1 gene in a girl with complex I deficiency

Respiratory chain enzymes consist of multiple subunits encoded either by the mitochondrial or by the nuclear genome. Recently the first X-chromosomal mutations in complex I deficient males have been described. Heterozygous female carriers did not seem to be affected. Here, we describe a girl initially presenting with mild muscular hypotonia, a moderate lactic acidosis and an increased beta-hydroxybutyrate/acetoacetate ratio. Biochemical investigations of a muscle biopsy revealed a deficiency in the amount and activity of complex I. Mutation screening of all structural subunits of complex I identified a heterozygous mutation c.94G>C, p.Gly32Arg in the X-chromosomal NDUFA1 gene. Analysis of the cDNA showed that 72% of the expressed mRNA was mutated in the muscle biopsy sample. Investigation of the X-inactivation pattern demonstrated that 74% of the paternally inherited allele was active in the muscle. This is the first report of an X-chromosomally inherited respiratory chain defect in a heterozygous female.     

Respiratory chain complex I deficiency caused by mitochondrial DNA mutations

Defects of the mitochondrial respiratory chain are associated with a diverse spectrum of clinical phenotypes, and may be caused by mutations in either the nuclear or the mitochondrial genome (mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA)). Isolated complex I deficiency is the most common enzyme defect in mitochondrial disorders, particularly in children in whom family history is often consistent with sporadic or autosomal recessive inheritance, implicating a nuclear genetic cause. In contrast, although a number of recurrent, pathogenic mtDNA mutations have been described, historically, these have been perceived as rare causes of paediatric complex I deficiency. We reviewed the clinical and genetic findings in a large cohort of 109 paediatric patients with isolated complex I deficiency from 101 families. Pathogenic mtDNA mutations were found in 29 of 101 probands (29%), 21 in MTND subunit genes and 8 in mtDNA tRNA genes. Nuclear gene defects were inferred in 38 of 101 (38%) probands based on cell hybrid studies, mtDNA sequencing or mutation analysis (nuclear gene mutations were identified in 22 probands). Leigh or Leigh-like disease was the most common clinical presentation in both mtDNA and nuclear genetic defects. The median age at onset was higher in mtDNA patients (12 months) than in patients with a nuclear gene defect (3 months). However, considerable overlap existed, with onset varying from 0 to >60 months in both groups. Our findings confirm that pathogenic mtDNA mutations are a significant cause of complex I deficiency in children. In the absence of parental consanguinity, we recommend whole mitochondrial genome sequencing as a key approach to elucidate the underlying molecular genetic abnormality.     

Mutated NDUFS6 is the cause of fatal neonatal lactic acidemia in Caucasus Jews

NADH:ubiquinone oxidoreductase (complex I; EC 1.6.5.3), the largest respiratory chain complex is composed of 45 proteins and is located at the mitochondrial inner membrane. Defects in complex I are associated with energy generation disorders, of which the most severe is congenital lactic acidosis. We report on four infants from two unrelated families of Jewish Caucasus origin with fatal neonatal lactic acidemia due to isolated complex I deficiency. Whole genome homozygosity mapping, identified a 2.6 Mb region of identical haplotype in the affected babies. Sequence analysis of the nuclear gene encoding for the NDUFS6 mitochondrial complex I subunit located within this region identified the c.344G>A homozygous mutation resulting in substitution of a highly evolutionary conserved cysteine residue by tyrosine. This is the second report of NDUFS6 mutation in humans. Both reports describe three diverse homozygous mutations with variable consequential NDUFS6 protein defects that result in similar phenotype. Our study further emphasizes that NDUFS6 sequence should be analyzed in patients presenting with lethal neonatal lactic acidemia due to isolated complex I deficiency.     

High frequency of mitochondrial complex I mutations in Parkinson's disease and aging

Idiopathic Parkinson’s disease (PD) involves a systemic loss of activity of complex I of the mitochondrial electron transport chain. This biochemical lesion plays a key pathogenic role. Transfer of PD mitochondrial DNA recapitulates this loss of activity and several other pathogenic features of PD suggesting that this lesion may arise, at least in part, from mitochondrial DNA. We investigated this possibility by an extensive clonal sequencing of the seven mitochondrial genes encoding complex I subunits in PD and age-matched control frontal cortex. Each gene was completely sequenced an average of 94.4 times for each subject. Aminoacid-changing mutations were found at the frequency of 59.3 per million bases in both PD and controls, corresponding to approximately 32% of the mitochondrial genomes in the average sample having at least one mutation in a complex I gene. Individual low frequency mutations had an abundance of 1–10%. Significant interindividual variation in mutation frequency was observed. Several aminoacid-changing mutations were identified and multiple PD brains but not in controls. Genetic algorithm analysis detected areas in ND genes with a higher mutation frequency in PD that allowed differentiation of PD from controls. Total mutational burden due to low-abundance heteroplasmy is high and may play a role in human disease.     

NDUFAF3 variants that disrupt mitochondrial complex I assembly may associate with cavitating leukoencephalopathy

Genetic abnormalities in mitochondrial complex assembling factors are associated with leukoencephalopathy. We present a 1‐year‐old girl with consciousness disturbance after a respiratory infection. Brain MRI revealed leukoencephalopathy with bilaterally symmetrical hyperintensity in the substantia nigra, medial thalamic nuclei, and basal nuclei, as well as cavities in the cerebral white matter and corpus callosum. Lactate levels in the spinal fluid were high, while magnetic resonance spectroscopy of the cerebral white matter and basal nuclei showed high peak lactate levels, suggesting mitochondrial dysfunction. The respiratory enzyme activity of complex I was reduced to 17% to 21% in skeletal muscle. Whole exome sequencing identified compound heterozygous variations in NDUFAF3, involved in the assembly of mitochondrial complex I (c.342_343insGTG:p.117Valdup, c.505C > A:p.Pro169Thr). Two‐dimensional, blue‐native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) and sodium dodecyl sulfate‐PAGE revealed reductions in Q‐module (NDUFS2, NDUFS3, and NDUFA9) and P‐module (NDUFB10 and NDUFB11) subunits, indicating disruption of mitochondrial complex I assembly. Our report expands the spectrum of clinical phenotypes associated with pathogenic variants of NDUFAF3.     

A nonsense mutation in the NDUFS4 gene encoding the 18 kDa (AQDQ) subunit of complex I abolishes assembly and activity of the complex in a patient with Leigh-like syndrome

Sequence analysis of mitochondrial and nuclear candidate genes of complex I in children with deficiency of this complex and exhibiting Leigh-like syndrome has revealed, in one of them, a novel mutation in the NDUFS4 gene encoding the 18 kDa subunit. Phosphorylation of this subunit by cAMP-dependent protein kinase has previously been found to activate the complex. The present mutation consists of a homozygous G-->A transition at nucleotide position +44 of the coding sequence of the gene, resulting in the change of a tryptophan codon to a stop codon. Such mutation causes premature termination of the protein after only 14 amino acids of the putative mitochondrial targeting peptide. Fibroblast cultures from the patient exhibited severe reduction of the rotenone-sensitive NADH-->UQ oxidoreductase activity of complex I, which was insensitive to cAMP stimulation. Two-dimensional electrophoresis showed the absence of detectable normally assembled complex I in the inner mitochondrial membrane. These findings show that the expression of the NDUFS4 gene is essential for the assembly of a functional complex I.     

Isolated complex I deficiency in children: clinical, biochemical and genetic aspects

We retrospectively examined clinical and biochemical characteristics of 27 patients with isolated enzymatic complex I deficiency (established in cultured skin fibroblasts) in whom common pathogenic mtDNA point mutations and major rearrangements were absent. Clinical phenotypes present in this group are Leigh syndrome (n = 7), Leigh-like syndrome (n = 6), fatal infantile lactic acidosis (n = 3), neonatal cardiomyopathy with lactic acidosis (n = 3), macrocephaly with progressive leukodystrophy (n = 2), and a residual group of unspecified encephalomyopathy (n = 6) subdivided into progressive (n = 4) and stable (n = 2) variants. Isolated complex I deficiency is one of the most frequently observed disturbance of the OXPHOS system. Respiratory chain enzyme assays performed in cultured fibroblasts and skeletal muscle tissue in general reveal similar results, but for complete diagnostics we recommend enzyme measurements performed in at least two different tissues to minimize the possibility of overlooking the enzymatic diagnosis. Lactate levels in blood and CSF and cerebral CT/MRI studies are highly informative, although normal findings do not exclude complex I deficiency. With the discovery of mutations in nuclear encoded complex I subunits, adequate pre- and postnatal counseling becomes available. Finally, considering information currently available, isolated complex I deficiency in children seems to be caused in the majority by mutations in nuclear DNA.     

Mitochondrial complex I deficiency of nuclear origin II. Non-structural genes

Complex I deficiency is the most frequent cause of respiratory chain diseases. This large multiprotein complex is composed in human of 45 structural subunits, of which 7 are mitochondrial-encoded and 38 are nuclear-encoded. Most of the pathological mutations responsible for complex I deficiencies have been identified to date in complex I structural subunits. Numerous studies from last decade gave some insight into the biogenesis of this huge multi subunit complex of double genetic origin. A sequential incorporation of the structural subunits as well as ten complex I assembly factors has been described. Here, we present a short overview of the human complex I biogenesis and we review the pathological mutations identified to date in eight of the ten known complex I assembly factors.     

A novel mutation of the NDUFS7 gene leads to activation of a cryptic exon and impaired assembly of mitochondrial complex I in a patient with Leigh syndrome

Complex I deficiency is a frequent cause of mitochondrial disease as it accounts for one third of these disorders. By genotyping several putative disease loci using microsatellite markers we were able to describe a new NDUFS7 mutation in a consanguineous family with Leigh syndrome and isolated complex I deficiency. This mutation lies in the first intron of the NDUFS7 gene (c.17-1167 C>G) and creates a strong donor splice site resulting in the generation of a cryptic exon. This mutation is predicted to result in a shortened mutant protein of 41 instead of 213 amino acids containing only the first five amino acids of the normal protein. Analysis of the assembly state of the respiratory chain complexes under native condition revealed a marked decrease of fully assembled complex I while the quantity of the other complexes was not altered. These results report the first intronic NDUFS7 gene mutation and demonstrate the crucial role of NDUFS7 in the biogenesis of complex I.     

Early complex I assembly defects result in rapid turnover of the ND1 subunit

Complex I (CI, NADH ubiquinone oxidoreductase), the largest complex of the respiratory chain, is composed of 45 structural subunits, 7 of which are encoded in mtDNA. At least 10 factors necessary for holoenzyme assembly have been identified; however, the specific roles of most of them are not well understood. We investigated the role of NDUFAF3, NDUFAF4, C8orf38 and C20orf7, four early assembly factors, in the translation of the mtDNA-encoded CI structural subunits. Transient, or stable, siRNA-mediated knock-down of any of these factors abrogated the assembly of CI, and resulted in a specific decrease in the labeling of the ND1 subunit in a pulse translation experiment, whereas knock-down of NDUFAF2, a late assembly factor, did not affect ND1 translation. Pulse-chase experiments in cells knocked down for NDUFAF3 showed that the half-life of ND1 in the chase was reduced 4-fold, fully accounting for the decrease in pulse labeling. Transient, short-term knock-down of the m-AAA protease AGF3L2 in cells that had been depleted of any of the early CI assembly factors completely rescued the ND1 labeling phenotype, confirming that it is not a synthesis defect, but rather results from rapid proteolysis of newly synthesized ND1. NDUFAF3 co-immunoprecipitated with NDUFAF4, and three matrix arm structural subunits (NDUFS2, NDUFA9, NDUFS3) that are found in a 400 kDa assembly intermediate containing ND1. These data suggest that the four early CI assembly factors have non-redundant functions in the assembly of a module that docks and stabilizes newly synthesized ND1, nucleating assembly of the holoenzyme.     

A novel mutation in the human complex I NDUFS7 subunit associated with Leigh syndrome

Defects in NADH:ubiquinone oxidoreductase, the complex I of the mitochondrial respiratory chain represents the most frequent cause of mitochondrial diseases and is associated with a wide clinical spectrum varying from severe lactic acidosis in infants to muscle weakness in adults. Here, we report a patient with Leigh syndrome (LS), born to consanguineous parents, with severe complex I defect and a novel mutation in the NDUFS7 gene subunit. The homozygous mutation at nucleotide (nt) 434 G>A resulted in the modification of the arginine 145 to histidine in a highly conserved region of the protein. Parents were heterozygous carriers for this mutation. The mutation was absent from over than 100 healthy controls from the same ethnic origin. Identifying nuclear mutations as a cause of respiratory chain disorders will enhance the possibility of prenatal diagnosis and help us to understand how moleculardefects can lead to complex I deficiency.     

Mutant NDUFV2 subunit of mitochondrial complex I causes early onset hypertrophic cardiomyopathy and encephalopathy

Respiratory chain complex I deficiencies represent a genetically heterogeneous group of diseases resulting from mutations in either mitochondrial or nuclear DNA. Combination of denaturing high performance liquid chromatography and sequence analysis allowed us to show that a 4-bp deletion in intron 2 (IVS2+5_+8delGTAA) of the NDUFV2 gene (encoding NADH dehydrogenase ubiquinone flavoprotein 2) causes complex I deficiency and early onset hypertrophic cardiomyopathy with trunk hypotonia in three affected sibs of a consanguineous family. The homozygous mutation altering the consensus splice-donor site of exon 2 resulted in 70% decreased NDUFV2 protein and complex I deficiency. While mutation in a number of genes encoding complex I subunits essentially result in neurological symptoms, this first mutation in NDUFV2 is strikingly associated with cardiomyopathy, as previously observed in the unique case of NDFUS2 mutations.     

NDUFA10 mutations cause complex I deficiency in a patient with Leigh disease

Mitochondrial complex I deficiency is the most common defect of the oxidative phosphorylation system. We report a patient with Leigh syndrome who showed a complex I deficiency expressed in cultured fibroblasts and muscle tissue. To find the genetic cause of the complex I deficiency, we screened the mitochondrial DNA and the nuclear-encoded subunits of complex I. We identified compound-heterozygous mutations in the NDUFA10 gene, encoding an accessory subunit of complex I. The first mutation disrupted the start codon and the second mutation resulted in an amino acid substitution. The fibroblasts of the patient displayed decreased amount and activity, and a disturbed assembly of complex I. These results indicate that NDUFA10 is a novel candidate gene to screen for disease-causing mutations in patients with complex I deficiency.