Stem cell fate analysis revisited: interpretation of individual clone dynamics in the light of a new paradigm of stem cell organization

Many experimental findings on heterogeneity, flexibility, and plasticity of tissue stem cells are currently challenging stem cell concepts that assume a cell intrinsically predefined, unidirectional differentiation program. In contrast to these classical concepts, nonhierarchical self-organizing systems provide an elegant and comprehensive alternative to explain the experimental data. Here we present the application of such a self-organizing concept to quantitatively describe the hematopoietic stem cell system. Focusing on the analysis of individual-stem-cell fates and clonal dynamics, we particularly discuss implications of the theoretical results on the interpretation of experimental findings. We demonstrate that it is possible to understand hematopoietic stem cell organization without assumptions on unidirectional developmental hierarchies, preprogrammed asymmetric division events or other assumptions implying the existence of a predetermined stem cell entity. The proposed perspective, therefore, changes the general paradigm of thinking about stem cells.     

Cell polarity and asymmetric cell division within human hematopoietic stem and progenitor cells

Like other somatic stem cells, hematopoietic stem cells (HSC) contain the capacity to self-renew and to give rise to committed progenitor cells that are able to replenish all hematopoietic cell types. To keep a constant level of HSC, the decision whether their progeny maintain the stem cell fate or become committed to differentiation needs to be highly controlled. In this context it became evident that HSC niches fulfill important functions in keeping the level of HSC more or less constant. Before discovering such niches, it was widely assumed that HSC divide asymmetrically to give birth to a daughter cell maintaining the stem cell fate and to another one which is committed to differentiation. Here, I summarize some of the experimental data being compatible with the model of asymmetric cell division and review some of our latest findings, which demonstrate the occurrence of asymmetric cell divisions within the HSC and hematopoietic progenitor cell compartment. Since cell polarity is an essential prerequisite for asymmetrically dividing as well as for migrating cells, I will also discuss some aspects of cell polarity of primitive hematopoietic cells.     

Steel factor regulates cell cycle asymmetry.

Asymmetric segregation of cell-fate determinants during mitosis (spatial asymmetry) is an essential mechanism by which stem cells are maintained while simultaneously giving rise to differentiated progenitors that ultimately produce all the specialized cells in the hematopoietic system. Temporal cell cycle asymmetry and heterogeneity are attributes of cell proliferation that are also essential for maintaining tissue organization. Hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) are regulated by a complex network of cytokines, some of which have very specific effects, while others have very broad ranging effects on HSCs. Some cytokines, like steel factor (SLF), are known to synergize with other cytokines to produce rapid expansion of progenitor cells. Using the human growth factor-dependent MO7e cell line as a model for synergistic proliferation, we present evidence that links proliferation asymmetry to SLF synergy with GM-CSF, and suggests that temporal asymmetry and cell cycle heterogeneity can be regulated by SLF in vitro. We also show that CDK-inhibitor and cell cycle regulator, p27kip-1, may be involved in this temporal asymmetry regulation. We propose that SLF/GM-CSF synergy is, in part, due to a shift in proliferation pattern from a heterogeneous and asymmetric one to a more synchronous and symmetric pattern, thus contributing dramatically to the rapid expansion that accompanies SLF synergy observed in MO7e cells. This kinetic model of asymmetry is consistent with recent evidence showing that even though SLF synergy results in a strong proliferative signal, it does not increase primary HSC self-renewal, which is believed to be highly dependent on asymmetric divisions. The factor-dependent MO7e/SCF- synergy/asymmetry model described here may therefore be useful for studies of the effects of various cytokines on cell cycle asymmetry.     

Asymmetric cell kinetics genes: the key to expansion of adult stem cells in culture

A singular challenge in stem cell research today is the expansion and propagation of functional adult stem cells. Unlike embryonic stem cells, which are immortal in culture, adult stem cells are notorious for the difficulty encountered when attempts are made to expand them in culture. One overlooked reason for this difficulty may be the inherent asymmetric cell kinetics of stem cells in postnatal somatic tissues. Senescence is the expected fate of a culture whose growth depends on adult stem cells that divide with asymmetric cell kinetics. Therefore, the bioengineering of strategies to expand adult stem cells in culture requires knowledge of cellular mechanisms that control asymmetric cell kinetics. The properties of several genes recently implicated to function in a cellular pathway(s) that regulates asymmetric cell kinetics are discussed. Understanding the function of these genes in asymmetric cell kinetics mechanisms may be the key that unlocks the adult stem cell expansion problem.     

Dividing cellular asymmetry: asymmetric cell division and its implications for stem cells and cancer

Cell division is commonly thought to involve the equal distribution of cellular components into the two daughter cells. During many cell divisions, however, proteins, membrane compartments, organelles, or even DNA are asymmetrically distributed between the two daughter cells. Here, we review the various types of asymmetries that have been described in yeast and in animal cells. Asymmetric segregation of protein determinants is particularly relevant for stem cell biology. We summarize the relevance of asymmetric cell divisions in various stem cell systems and discuss why defects in asymmetric cell division can lead to the formation of tumors.     

Formation of neurons by non-neural adult stem cells: potential mechanism implicates an artifact of growth in culture

Trans-differentiation is a mechanism proposed to explain how tissue-specific stem cells could generate cells of other organs, thus supporting the emerging concept of enhanced adult stem cell plasticity. Although spontaneous cell fusion rather than trans-differentiation may explain some unexpected cell fate changes in vivo, such a mechanism does not explain potential trans-differentiation events in vitro, including the generation of neural cell types from cultured bone marrow-derived stem cells. Here we present evidence that shows that cultured bone marrow-derived stem cells express neural proteins and form structures resembling neurons under defined growth conditions. We demonstrate that these changes in cell structure and neural protein expression are not consistent with typical neural development. Furthermore, the ability of bone marrow-derived stem cells to adopt a neural phenotype in vitro may occur as a result of cellular stress in response to removing cells from their niche and their growth in alternative environmental conditions. These findings suggest a potential explanation for the growth behavior of cultured bone marrow-derived stem cells and highlight the need to carefully validate the plasticity of stem cell differentiation.     

Divide and conquer: how asymmetric division shapes cell fate in the hematopoietic system

A fundamental mechanism by which cells can give rise to daughters with different fates is via asymmetric division. During asymmetric division, a mother cell generates daughter cells that go on to adopt different fates because of differential segregation of cell fate determinants. Although originally characterized in invertebrates, asymmetric division has recently been shown to regulate cell fate decisions in the mammalian hematopoietic system, playing crucial roles in stem cell renewal, lymphocyte activation, and leukemogenesis. These discoveries have opened new doors to understanding how regulation of division pattern contributes to the normal development and function of the immune system as well as how its dysregulation can lead to cancer.     

Modifying clonal selection theory with a probabilistic cell

Problem-solving strategies in immunology currently utilize a series of ad hoc, qualitative variations on a foundation of Burnet's formulation of clonal selection theory. These modifications, including versions of two-signal theory, describe how signals regulate lymphocytes to make important decisions governing self-tolerance and changes to their effector and memory states. These theories are useful but are proving inadequate to explain the observable genesis and control of heterogeneity in cell types, the nonlinear passage of cell fate trajectories and how the input from multiple environmental signals can be integrated at different times and strengths. Here, I argue for a paradigm change to place immune theory on a firmer philosophical and quantitative foundation to resolve these difficulties. This change rejects the notion of identical cell subsets and substitutes the concept of a cell as comprised of autonomous functional mechanical components subject to stochastic variations in construction and operation. The theory aims to explain immunity in terms of cell population dynamics, dictated by the operation of cell machinery, such as randomizing elements, division counters, and fate timers. The effect of communicating signals alone and in combination within this system is determined with a cellular calculus. A series of models developed with these principles can resolve logical cell fate and signaling paradoxes and offer a reinterpretation for how self-non-self discrimination and immune response class are controlled.     

Organelle asymmetry for proper fitness, function, and fate

During cellular division, centrosomes are tasked with building the bipolar mitotic spindle, which partitions the cellular contents into two daughter cells. While every cell will receive an equal complement of chromosomes, not every organelle is symmetrically passaged to the two progeny in many cell types. In this review, we highlight the conservation of nonrandom centrosome segregation in asymmetrically dividing stem cells, and we discuss how the asymmetric function of centrosomes could mediate nonrandom segregation of organelles and mRNA. We propose that such a mechanism is critical for insuring proper cell fitness, function, and fate.     

Potential of CD34 in the regulation of symmetrical and asymmetrical divisions by hematopoietic progenitor cells

The control of symmetric and asymmetric division in the hematopoietic stem/progenitor cell population is critically important for the regulation of blood cell production. Asymmetric divisions depend on cell polarization, which may be conferred by location and/or interaction with neighboring cells. In this study, we sought evidence for polarization in CD34+ cells, which interact by binding to one another. In these cells, surface molecules became redistributed by mechanisms that included transport by lipid rafts, and the interacting cells were able to communicate via gap junctions. These changes were accompanied by modulation of cell cycle regulating proteins (p16(Ink4a), p27(kip1), cyclins D, and the retinoblastoma pathway proteins) and a reduction in progenitor cell proliferation in vitro. These results are consistent with an increase in asymmetric cell division kinetics. Accordingly, we found that interaction between CD34+ cells influenced the plane of cell division in a way that suggests unequal sharing of Notch-1 between daughter cell progeny. We conclude that interaction between CD34+ cells may coordinate cell function and participate in the control of hematopoietic stem/progenitor cell division kinetics.     

Light experience induces differential asymmetry pattern of GABA- and parvalbumin-positive cells in the pigeon's visual midbrain

The formation of functional and morphological asymmetries within the pigeon's tectofugal system depends on left–right differences in visual input during embryonic development. This asymmetric stimulation presumably affects activity-dependent differentiation processes within the optic tectum. Behavioral studies reveal that prehatch light stimulation asymmetry influences both left- and right-hemispheric processes in a differential way. Thus, we have to assume divergent effects on both hemispheres. This study represents an attempt to test the hypothesis that embryonic light asymmetry induces different, cell-type-specific effects in the left and the right optic midbrain. Since it is likely that inhibitory interneurons play a critical role in the establishment of asymmetries, we examined in both sides of the brain the soma sizes of GABA- and parvalbumin- (PV) immunoreactive (ir) cells of the tectum and the magnocellular isthmic nucleus in controls and in dark-incubated animals. No cell size asymmetries of magnocellular isthmic neurons were found in either dark-incubated or control birds. Dark-incubation also prevented the establishment of lateralized differences in GABAergic and PV-positive tectal cells. However, in control birds GABAergic cells displayed larger somata in the left tectum, whereas PV-ir neurons were enlarged within the right tectum. This complementary asymmetry pattern suggests that PV- and GABA-ir tectal cells represent different cellular populations which react differently to visual input. Thus, our data show that visual lateralization does not result from a mere growth promoting effect that enhances differentiation within the behaviorally dominant left side, but is constituted by different cell type-specific circuits which are divergently adjusted in the left and in the right tectum.     

Asymmetric distribution of histones during Drosophila male germline stem cell asymmetric divisions

It has long been known that epigenetic changes are inheritable. However, except for DNA methylation, little is known about the molecular mechanisms of epigenetic inheritance. Many types of stem cells undergo asymmetric cell divisions to generate self-renewed stem cells and daughter cells committed for differentiation. Still, whether and how stem cells retain their epigenetic memory remain questions to be elucidated. During the asymmetric division of Drosophila male germline stem cell (GSC), our recent studies revealed that the preexisting histone 3 (H3) are selectively segregated to the GSC, whereas newly synthesized H3 deposited during DNA replication are enriched in the differentiating daughter cell. We propose a two-step model to explain this asymmetric histone distribution. First, prior to mitosis, preexisting histones and newly synthesized histones are differentially distributed at two sets of sister chromatids. Next, during mitosis, the set of sister chromatids that mainly consist of preexisting histones are segregated to GSCs, while the other set of sister chromatids enriched with newly synthesized histones are partitioned to the daughter cell committed for differentiation. In this review, we apply current knowledge about epigenetic inheritance and asymmetric cell division to inform our discussion of potential molecular mechanisms and the cellular basis underlying this asymmetric histone distribution pattern. We will also discuss whether this phenomenon contributes to the maintenance of stem cell identity and resetting chromatin structure in the other daughter cell for differentiation.     

The combined influence of substrate elasticity and ligand density on the viability and biophysical properties of hematopoietic stem and progenitor cells

Hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) are adult stem cells with the capacity to give rise to all blood and immune cells in the body. HSCs are housed in a specialized microenvironment known as the stem cell niche, which provides intrinsic and extrinsic signals to regulate HSC fate: quiescence, self-renewal, differentiation, mobilization, homing, and apoptosis. These niches provide a complex, three dimensional (3D) microenvironment consisting of cells, the extracellular matrix (ECM), and ECM-bound or soluble biomolecules that provides cellular, structural, and molecular signals that regulate HSC fate decisions. In this study, we examined the decoupled effects of substrate elasticity, construct dimensionality, and ligand concentration on the biophysical properties of primary hematopoietic stem and progenitor cells (HSPCs) using homologous series of two and three dimensional microenvironments. Microenvironments were chosen to span the range of biophysical environments presented physiologically within the bone marrow, ranging from soft marrow and adipose tissue (<1 kPa), to surrounding cell membranes (1-3 kPa), to developing osteoid (>30 kPa). We additionally investigated the influence of collagen ligand density on HSPC biophysical parameters and compared these behaviors to those observed in HSPCs grown in culture on stiff glass substrates. This work suggests the potential for substrate stiffness and ligand density to directly affect the biophysical properties of primary hematopoietic stem and progenitor cells at the single cell level and that these parameters may be critical design criteria for the development of artificial HSC niches.     

Regulation of asymmetric positioning of nuclei by Wnt and Src signaling and its roles in POP‐1/TCF nuclear asymmetry in Caenorhabditis elegans

In various polarized cells, positions of nuclei are often off‐center. However, extrinsic signals regulating nuclear off‐centering and its biologic roles remain to be elucidated. In Caenorhabditis elegans, polarity of the EMS cell undergoing asymmetric division is regulated by the MOM‐2/Wnt and MES‐1 signals from its posterior neighbor P2 cell. We show that after divisions of different cells including EMS, the nuclei of the posterior but not anterior daughter cells are anchored to the posterior cell cortex via centrosomes. We also show that this nuclear anchoring is regulated by components of the Wnt pathway and SRC‐1 that functions in MES‐1 signaling. To understand the biologic roles of nuclear anchoring, we analyzed its effects on asymmetric nuclear localization of POP‐1/TCF that is also regulated by Wnt and Src signaling. We found that in mom‐2 mutants where the nuclear anchoring and POP‐1 asymmetry is partially inhibited, the proximity of the nucleus to the cell cortex correlated with POP‐1 asymmetry. Furthermore, in mutants of mom‐2, the defect in the anchoring is clearly correlated with that of asymmetric fate determination. These results suggest that the asymmetric nuclear anchoring functions in asymmetric division by enhancing POP‐1 asymmetry.     

The normal flora may contribute to the quantitative preponderance of myeloid cells under physiological conditions

Under physiological conditions, the innate immune cells derived from myeloid lineage absolutely outnumber the lymphoid cells. At present, two theories are attributed to the maintenance of haemopoiesis: the asymmetric cell division and the bone marrow hematopoietic microenvironment or "niche". However, the former only explains the self-renewal of haemopoietic stem cell (HSC) and the start of haemopoietic differentiation but fails to address the inducers of cell fate decisions; the latter has to admit that the hematopoietic cytokines, despite their significance in the maintenance of haemopoiesis, have no specific effect on lineage commitment. Given these flaws, the advantageous mechanism of myeloid haemopoiesis has not yet been uncovered in the current theories. The discoveries that bacterial components (lipopolysaccharide, LPS) and intestinal decontamination affect the mobilization of HSC trigger the interest in normal flora, which together with their components may have an effect on haemopoiesis. In the experiments in dogs and mice, researchers documented that the generation of myeloid cells has undergone changes in the bone marrow and periphery when antibiotics are used to regulate the normal intestinal flora and the concentration of its components. However, the same changes are not involved in lymphoid cells. Therefore, we hypothesize that in human body normal flora and its components are a driving force to maintain myeloid haemopoiesis under physiological conditions. To account for the selectiveness in haemopoiesis, these facts should be taken into consideration, such as HSC and mesenchymal stem cells (MSC) functionally expressed pattern recognition receptors (PRR), and both of them can self-migrate or be recruited by normal flora or its components into periphery. Dynamically monitoring the myeloid haemopoiesis may provide an important complementary program that precludes the abuse of antibiotics, which prevents diseases triggered by the imbalance of normal flora. Meanwhile, the regulation of normal flora and the use of purified microecological modulator may serve as valuable auxiliary treatments to mobilize HSC prior to the HSC transplantation as well as to promote hematopoietic recovery after transplantation or chemotherapy in the blood diseases.     

Les développements de la thérapie cellulaire de l''an 2000

For the past thirty years, hematology has switched from the concept of bone marrow transplantation to the concept of hematopoietic stem cell (HSC) transplantation, from allograft to autograft, from non-manipulated graft to hyper-selection, from hematopoietic cellular therapy to immunotherapy. Indications of these transplantations are now more clear for malignant diseases and are ongoing for auto-immune diseases. A better knowledge of the HSC allows the control of their proliferation and differentiation, opening the field of ex vivo expansion. Very recently, new stem cells have been identified, establishing that a differentiated cell retain its totipotency: a nervous system cell can differentiate into HSC, which will further give hematopoiesis, mesenchymental cells or hepatocytes. New tools are under development: human ES cells, biomaterials, functionalized materials, opening the field of cellular engineering in the year 2000.     

Quiescent human hematopoietic stem cells in the bone marrow niches organize the hierarchical structure of hematopoiesis

Hematopoiesis is a dynamic and strictly regulated process orchestrated by self-renewing hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) and the supporting microenvironment. However, the exact mechanisms by which individual human HSCs sustain hematopoietic homeostasis remain to be clarified. To understand how the long-term repopulating cell (LTRC) activity of individual human HSCs and the hematopoietic hierarchy are maintained in the bone marrow (BM) microenvironment, we traced the repopulating dynamics of individual human HSC clones using viral integration site analysis. Our study presents several lines of evidence regarding the in vivo dynamics of human hematopoiesis. First, human LTRCs existed in a rare population of CD34(+)CD38(-) cells that localized to the stem cell niches and maintained their stem cell activities while being in a quiescent state. Second, clonally distinct LTRCs controlled hematopoietic homeostasis and created a stem cell pool hierarchy by asymmetric self-renewal division that produced lineage-restricted short-term repopulating cells and long-lasting LTRCs. Third, we demonstrated that quiescent LTRC clones expanded remarkably to reconstitute the hematopoiesis of the secondary recipient. Finally, we further demonstrated that human mesenchymal stem cells differentiated into key components of the niche and maintained LTRC activity by closely interacting with quiescent human LTRCs, resulting in more LTRCs. Taken together, this study provides a novel insight into repopulation dynamics, turnover, hierarchical structure, and the cell cycle status of human HSCs in the recipient BM microenvironment.     

Delineation of the human hematolymphoid system: potential applications of defined cell populations in cellular therapy

Summary: Hematopoietic stem cells (HSC) have the capacity to reconstitute ail the blood cells in the body HSC are rare, representing on average 0.0 5% of the mononuclear cells present in healthy human bone marrow. Due to their capacity for self–renewal and their pluripotent, long–term reconstituting potential. HSC are considered ideal for transplantation to reconstitute the hematopoietic system after treatment for various hematologic disorders or as a target for the delivery of therapeutic genes. Human HSC also have potential applications in restoring the immune system in autoimmune diseases and in the induction of tolerance for allogeneic solid organ transplantation. With the increased interest in human HSC for clinical applications, technology for the isolation of candidate HSC and knowledge of human hematopoiesis have been growing rapidly. In this article, we discuss the functional characterization of a human CD34⁺ Thy-1⁺ HSC population which is essentially free of residual disease, our efforts to generate alternate monoclonal antibodies for the isolation of clinically useful stem or progenitor cell populations, and the identification of a novel lymphoid progenitor as part of an exploration towards defining progenitors with potential application as adjuncts to HSC–based cellular therapy.     

JAM-C is an apical surface marker for neural stem cells

Junctional adhesion molecule-C (JAM-C) is an adhesive cell surface protein expressed in various cell types. JAM-C localizes to the apically localized tight junctions (TJs) between contacting endothelial and epithelial cells, where it contributes to cell-cell adhesions. Just as those epithelial cells, also neural stem cells are highly polarized along their apical-basal axis. The defining feature of all stem cells, including neural stem cells (NSCs) is their ability to self renew. This self-renewal depends on the tight control of symmetric and asymmetric cell divisions. In NSCs, the decision whether a division is symmetric or asymmetric largely depends on the distribution of the apical membrane and cell fate determinants on the basal pole of the cell. In this study we demonstrate that JAM-C is expressed on neural progenitor cells and neural stem cells in the embryonic as well as the adult mouse brain. Furthermore, we demonstrate that in vivo JAM-C shows enrichment at the apical surface and therefore is asymmetrically distributed during cell divisions. These results define JAM-C as a novel surface marker for neural stem cells.