Dystrophin or a “related protein” in Duchenne muscular dystrophy?

Previously we have shown low levels of dystrophin immunoreactivity in muscle from patients with DMD. According to the "frame-shift hypothesis" DMD muscle should not synthesize any dystrophin through to the C-terminus and it has been suggested that the protein detected is not dystrophin, but a related autosomal homologue. We have labelled serial sections of DMD muscle with specific monoclonal antibodies to the amino, rod and C-terminal domains of dystrophin and find labelling on the same individual fibres, allowing us to conclude that the protein detected is Xp21-encoded dystrophin. This has an impact on the interpretation of myoblast transfer experiments. The abundance (on blots) of "C-terminal dystrophin" appears lower than "rod dystrophin" in both BMD and DMD.     

Dystrophin in skeletal muscle. II. Immunoreactivity in patients with Xp21 muscular dystrophy

In the preceding paper a sensitive Western blotting analysis system based on the use of a monoclonal antibody to dystrophin was described. Here we report the immunoreactivity on blots and on unfixed frozen sections of muscle from patients with Duchenne (DMD) and Becker (BMD) muscular dystrophy. Muscle from 3 BMD patients showed variation both in the band pattern observed on blots and in the immunocytochemical labelling of dystrophin on frozen sections. In contrast to previous reports, we were able to detect some minor dystrophin bands on blots from 6 of 9 DMD biopsy samples. Tissue sections from 8 of the 9 contained isolated fibres with dystrophin-positive labelling. We conclude that the majority of DMD patients have muscle fibres which can synthesize dystrophin in a limited manner.     

Dystrophin analysis using a panel of anti-dystrophin antibodies in Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophy.

Dystrophin, the protein product of the Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) gene, was studied in 19 patients with Xp21 disorders and in 25 individuals with non-Xp21 muscular dystrophy. Antibodies raised to seven different regions spanning most of the protein were used for immunocytochemistry. In all patients specific dystrophin staining anomalies were detected and correlated with clinical severity and also gene deletion. In patients with Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD) the anomalies detected ranged from inter- and intra-fibre variation in labelling intensity with the same antibody or several antibodies to general reduction in staining and discontinuous staining. In vitro evidence of abnormal dystrophin breakdown was observed reanalysing the muscle of patients, with BMD and not that of non-Xp21 dystrophies, after it has been stored for several months. A number of patients with DMD showed some staining but this did not represent a diagnostic problem. Based on the data presented, it was concluded that immunocytochemistry is a powerful technique in the prognostic diagnosis of Xp21 muscular dystrophies.     

A homologue of dystrophin is expressed at the blood vessel membrane of DMD and BMD patients: immunological evidence.

Muscles from Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD) and Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) patients were analysed using monoclonal and polyclonal antibodies raised against different regions of the dystrophin molecule. On blot, two of the antibodies detected a protein of Mr 400K in muscle extracts from all patients, including a BMD patient with a deletion which spanned more than 40% of the central rod domain of the Xp21 encoded dystrophin. Immunocytochemical labelling of tissue sections from the same patients showed that the same two antibodies labelled a protein at the surface membrane of smooth muscle fibers in blood vessels of both BMD and DMD muscles. Thus we have demonstrated a 400K blood vessel-associated protein, which is immunologically homologous with dystrophin, for at least two epitopes from the carboxy terminal and the central rod domains must be encoded by another gene than the dystrophin gene.     

Abnormal dystrophin expression in patients with limb girdle syndromes

Clinical differential diagnosis between Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD) and limb gridle muscular dystrophy (LGMD) may be difficult because the BMD clinical phenotype tends to overlap with other limb girdle syndromes, especially with LGMD. Therefore we studied the expression of dystrophin, the protein product of the Becker and Duchenne muscular dystrophy gene, in muscle biopsy specimens of 30 patients (18 males, of whom 15 represented spradic cases, and 12 females) diagnosed as having LGMD according to traditional clinical, electrophysiological and histological criteria. For dystrophin analysis, six different monoclonal antibodies directed against different epitopes of the dystrophin molecule were used. Immunocytochemically, five of the 30 LGMD patients (17%) showed abnormal dystrophin staining patterns diagnostic of BMD. Western blotting in these five patients, all sporadic cases, showed dystrophin of reduced size and/or abundance. Analysis of blood or muscle DNA using multiplex polymerase chain reaction revealed deletions in the dystrophin gene in three of the five. Thus, 5 of 15 (33%) sporadic male patients previously thought to have LGMD were identified as having BMD.     

Localization and characterization of dystrophin in muscle biopsy specimens from Duchenne muscular dystrophy and various neuromuscular disorders

Dystrophin, surmised to be the causative protein of Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD), was studied for its intracellular localization and characterization by immunostaining and Western blotting using antidystrophin antibodies. In normal controls and in patients with various neuromuscular diseases other than DMD and Becker's muscular dystrophy (BMD), dystrophin was detected homogeneously on the entire surface membrane of the muscle fibers, whereas it was absent in DMD patients and partially observed in BMD cases. The density of dystrophin was low in BMD and female DMD patients. In mouse skeletal and cardiac muscles, too, dystrophin localized in the muscle surface membrane, and its presence in the brain was also suggested. However, dystrophin was not detected in mdx mice. These data suggest that myofiber necrosis in DMD patients and mdx mice is likely to be the result of plasma membrane instability.     

The abnormal expression of utrophin in Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophy is age related

J. Taylor, F. Muntoni, V. Dubowitz and C. A. Sewry (1997) Neuropathology and Applied Neurobiology 23, 399–405 The abnormal expression of utrophin in Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophy is age related Utrophin is a 395 kDa protein with considerable homology to dystrophin. It is highly expressed in the sarcolemma of normal fetal muscle fibres but is confined to neuromuscular and myotendinous junctions, and blood vessels in adult muscle. Sarcolemmal expression occurs on regenerating fibres, irrespective of the disease, and is also seen on mature fibres in Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophies (DMD, BMD), and inflammatory myopathies. The reasons for the abnormal expression in DMD and BMD are unclear. We have studied this expression of utrophin immunocytochemically on mature fibres in 42 cases of DMD and BMD, aged 3 months–24 years of age. All cases had some mature fibres, with no detectable fetal myosin, that showed sarcolemmal expression of utrophin. The number of these fibres and the intensity of fluorescence was low in young cases before the age of 2 years and increased with age. The fluorescence was graded on a scale of 0 to ++++ and there were significantly more cases under 2 years of age (10/12) with a grading of utrophin of only +, compared with those over 2 years (4/30, P < 0.001). Some revertant fibres, but not all, expressed utrophin and dystrophin. Our data show that the abnormal expression of utrophin on mature muscle fibres in DMD and BMD is not a continuation of the expression that occurs in fetal or regenerating muscle, but is a secondary event caused by unknown factors. The immunocytochemical intensity of utrophin is variable between cases and there is no correlation with clinical severity. As all cases studied had some expression of utrophin on mature fibres, this may be a useful additional tool for distinguishing BMD from other dystrophies, especially in cases with minimal abnormalities in dystrophin expression and/or no detectable mutation in the gene.     

Molecular deletion patterns in Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophy patients from KwaZulu Natal

There exists much phenotypic heterogeneity in Duchenne muscular dystrophy and its allelic variant, Becker muscular dystrophy. The molecular findings on 53 patients with Duchenne and 15 patients with Becker type muscular dystrophy in KwaZulu Natal, South Africa are reported. Multiplex PCR was performed using primers targeting 18 hot-spot exons throughout the dystrophin gene. Analysis of the multiplex PCR data revealed that 39/68 (57.0%) patients included in the study showed a deletion (33 DMD and 6 BMD patients). Twenty-five patients were Black, 4 were White and 10 were Indian. Using the Chamberlain and Beggs multiplex PCR assays, the region of the genome most frequently affected by a deletion includes exons 47-51. The distal region of the dystrophin gene was most frequently affected by the deletion in both Black and Indian patients. There were too few White patients for conclusions to be drawn concerning the most frequently affected part of the gene. Although the numbers are insufficient to determine whether ethnic differences are present, the Chamberlain and Beggs multiplex PCR assays detect deletions with the same frequency in South African DMD/BMD patients as that reported in the literature.     

Absence of neuronal nitric oxide synthase (nNOS) as a pathological marker for the diagnosis of Becker muscular dystrophy with rod domain deletions

Immunohistochemistry using antibodies to dystrophin is the pathological basis for the diagnosis of Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophy (DMD and BMD). While the sarcolemma of DMD muscle is negative, BMD muscle generally shows variable labelling because of the translation of a partially functional dystrophin that is localized to the sarcolemma. In rare cases, however, this labelling is equivocal and similar to that observed in controls making diagnosis difficult. We report here that in such instances immunolabelling with antibodies to the neuronal form of nitric oxide synthase (nNOS) can be useful in suspecting a dystrophinopathy with a mutation in the 'hot-spot' rod domain and help to direct molecular analysis. nNOS localizes to the sarcolemma of mature muscle fibres via several components of the dystrophin-associated protein complex (DAPC) including dystrophin but sarcolemmal nNOS is lost when dystrophin levels are very low or absent because of deletions in critical regions of the rod domain. We report three cases who presented with only mild or no muscle weakness but had elevated serum creatine kinase activity and dystrophin immunolabelling indistinguishable from normal, making a pathological diagnosis difficult. All three cases had a complete absence of sarcolemmal nNOS and were subsequently found to have an in-frame deletion in the common rod domain exons (in these cases 48, 45-51, 47-53) compatible with a BMD. In addition, we observed that nNOS appears to be developmentally regulated with the antibody used and was often absent from the sarcolemma of immature fibres. These findings demonstrate the value of including antibodies to nNOS in routine immunohistochemical studies and that absence of nNOS can be a more sensitive marker than up-regulation of utrophin for diagnosis of BMD. Immaturity of fibres, however, needs to be taken into account, especially in neonates.     

Dystrophin-associated protein abnormalities in dystrophin-deficient muscle fibers from symptomatic and asymptomatic Duchenne/Becker muscular dystrophy carriers

The absence of dystrophin in muscle fibers is associated with a major reduction in dystrophin-associated proteins (DAPs) and disruption of the linkage between the subsarcolemmal cytoskeleton and the extracellular matrix. We investigated the expression of the DAPs β-dystroglycan, α-sarcoglycan, γ-sarcoglycan and syntrophin as well as utrophin in the muscles of 13 Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) carriers (with variable percentages of dystrophin-deficient fibers and with a range of clinical symptoms), 2 Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD) carriers (expressing a highly truncated protein in some fibers), 2 girls with a DMD-like phenotype, and 11 BMD carriers with almost normal dystrophin expression (reduced or patchy distribution in a few fibers only and rare dystrophin-deficient fibers). DAPs were highly reduced in all fibers lacking dystrophin in the DMD carriers, but were almost normal in the dystrophin-deficient fibers of the 2 BMD carriers with highly truncated dystrophin. In the 11 BMD carriers with nearly normal dystrophin, the few fibers with reduced or patchy dystrophin immunostaining also showed reduced DAP expression in correlation with dystrophin expression. Immunoblot for β-dystroglycan and α-sarcoglycan confirmed the immunohistochemical findings. Utrophin expression was slightly increased in a proportion of fibers in the DMD and BMD carriers with dystrophin mosaicism. We found no correlation between utrophin expression and DAP expression. We conclude that absence or reduction of dystrophin in muscle fibers of DMD and BMD carriers causes a reduction of DAPs in the same fibers, as observed in DMD and BMD patients, while utrophin does not seem to play a role in DAP expression in adult muscle. Received: 11 January 1996 / Revised, accepted: 16 April 1996     

Dystrophin as a diagnostic marker in Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophy. Correlation of immunofluorescence and western blot

Dystrophin is the gene product of the Duchenne (DMD) and Becker (BMD) muscular dystrophy gene locus on the short arm of the X chromosome. Complete lack of dystrophin is pathognomonic for DMD and variable changes of the molecule may be observed in the milder allelic form of BMD. In the present study the two methods available for dystrophin assessment, immunofluorescence detections on cryosections (IF) and Western blotting (WB) were systematically compared using polyclonal and monoclonal antibodies to various regions along the dystrophin molecule. A total of 95 patients with DMD or BMD were investigated including two female patients. Dystrophin assessment revealed abnormal abundance and/or distribution in all 95 patients with DMD or BMD. Only trace amounts of dystrophin were detected in 29% of the DMD patients and complete lack of dystrophin was found in 71%. In two females with DMD but with normal karyotype single dystrophin-positive fibres were found among more than 90% negative fibres. Out of 26 patients with BMD 19 (73%) had a dystrophin molecule of abnormal molecular weight. The results of IF were largely compatible with those from WB but differences were also observed, e.g. one barely symptomatic BMD patient with dystrophin of increased molecular weight showed normal IF. Out of four carriers of BMD three showed evidence of reduced dystrophin immunostaining in some muscle fibres. In 20 other patients limb girdle muscualar dystrophy with "Duchenne-like" or "Becker-like" phenotype was suspected because dystrophin showed normal abundance and distribution. Focal discontinuity of muscle cell-surface dystrophin staining was observed in one patient with a congenital, autosomal recessive muscular dystrophy and in one out of five patients with polymyositis/dermatomyositis. The study emphasizes the need for, and value of, dystrophin assessment in every case of suspected BMD or DMD.     

Dystrophin immunohistochemistry in a symptomatic carrier of becker muscular dystrophy

Summary Immunohistochemical localization of dystrophin was studied in a symptomatic carrier of Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD). Muscle biopsy specimens from a female carrier showed findings compatible with slowly progressive muscular dystrophy by ordinary histochemical examinations. Immunohistochemical study, using an antiserum raised against a synthetic peptide fragment of dystrophin, demonstrated a mixture of staining patterns, including continuous but faint positive fibres, partially disrupted fibres and negative fibres. These findings were identical to those of patients with BMD and appear to differ from previous findings in female carriers of Duchenne muscular dystrophy. This report is the first immunohistochemical study of a symptomatic female proven by molecular genetic analysis to be a carrier of BMD.     

The “rescue” of dystrophin synthesis in boys with Duchenne muscular dystrophy

Over the last few years it has become clear that a proportion of biopsies from patients with Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) contain fibres which show dystrophin-positive immunolabelling. We have collected evidence to demonstrate that low level restoration of the reading frame must have been taking place and that a BMD-like protein was being synthesized in DMD muscle. We have also found a relationship between the abundance of dystrophin (determined by densitometric analysis of blots) and the age at which boys lose the ability to walk independently. Thus, even the low levels of dystrophin in DMD patients may have a functional significance. We now suggest that exon skipping, whereby an existing frame-shifting deletion is modified and extended to an in-frame mutation, may be responsible for the limited rescue of dystrophin synthesis in the muscle from many DMD patients.     

Dystrophin and nebulin in the muscular dystrophies

Skeletal muscle from patients with 5 different forms of muscular dystrophy and from 6 fetuses at high risk (95%) for Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) were probed with specific antibodies for the presence of dystrophin and nebulin. Dystrophin was absent in all 5 patients with DMD and 4 of 6 fetuses at high risk for DMD and present in trace amounts in the remaining two. Dystrophin was also undetectable in one borderline DMD/Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD) case and reduced in 2 of 4 cases of BMD. In contrast, dystrophin was present in all 16 biopsies from 4 other types of muscular dystrophy (congenital, limb girdle, Emery-Dreifuss and facioscapulohumeral). Nebulin profiles varied with the type, severity and duration of the dystrophic process. Nebulin was present in 5 of 6 DMD fetal samples but vastly reduced or absent in all samples of clinically manifest DMD.     

Dystrophin immunostaining in muscles from patients with different types of muscular dystrophy: a Brazilian study.

The localization of the protein dystrophin was studied using the immunofluorescence method, in muscle biopsies from 74 patients affected by different types of muscular dystrophy and 4 normal controls. In 15 patients with limb-girdle muscular dystrophy (LGMD) the pattern was indistinguishable from normal. Among 42 Duchenne patients (DMD), 3 were totally negative and 39 showed a variable proportion (4-30%) of partially labelled fibers. With one exception 17 Becker dystrophy patients (BMD), showed a positive sarcolemmal reaction. A diffuse reaction inside the fibers, which was not observed in normal controls, was seen in the majority of DMD and also in some of the BMD patients. Based on these observations it is suggested that in DMD, a small quantity of protein is still present or there is a cross-reaction with other proteins which share some homology with dystrophin. The present results suggest that it is possible to make a differential diagnosis between DMD and BMD through dystrophin immunohistochemistry. However, to distinguish between patients with BMD and LGMD phenotypes, or DMD and outliers, complementary immunoblot studies and quantitative determination of dystrophin are necessary.     

Becker muscular dystrophy: detection of unusual disease courses by combined approach to dystrophin analysis.

The rapid progress of research on the structure of the dystrophin gene has enormously increased our understanding of the molecular basis of Duchenne (DMD) and Becker (BMD) muscular dystrophy. Apart from "classical" clinical presentations, asymptomatic or only mildly affected individuals with deletions in the dystrophin gene have now been reported. We describe two families which were initially classified as metabolic myopathies, until the diagnosis of atypical BMD was established after dystrophin analysis at the protein and DNA level. A modern diagnostic approach to myopathies should, therefore, not only include morphological and biochemical investigations, but also be extended to the analysis of the dystrophin gene.     

Isoprostanes in dystrophinopathy: Evidence of increased oxidative stress

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) and Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD) are degenerative disorders of muscle. Although the mechanisms underlying muscle degeneration are still uncertain, oxidative-damage has been proposed to play a key role. Isoprostanes are markers of free radical-catalyzed lipid peroxidation; the aim of our study was to evaluate plasma isoprostane levels in group of patients affected by Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophies. PF₂-isoprostane levels were measured by colorimetric enzyme immunoassay in the plasma of 17 patients with DMD and 24 with BMD. When compared to a group of healthy controls, affected patients showed significantly higher plasma levels of isoprostanes (p = 0.001). When patients were stratified according to the clinical diagnosis, isoprostane levels were not statistically different between DMD and BMD patients. In conclusion whether the condition of oxidative stress found in plasma depends on the degenerative process occurring in muscles or on different mechanisms, such as the release of myoglobin in the blood, should be ascertained. However, our study confirms that oxidative stress findings in DMD/BMD patients are effectively present at the plasma levels. The condition of oxidative stress might act as an adjunctive cause of extra-muscular cell damage to which these patients are exposed for their entire life.     

Entries in the Leiden Duchenne muscular dystrophy mutation database: an overview of mutation types and paradoxical cases that confirm the reading-frame rule

The severe Duchenne and milder Becker muscular dystrophy are both caused by mutations in the DMD gene. This gene codes for dystrophin, a protein important for maintaining the stability of muscle-fiber membranes. In 1988, Monaco and colleagues postulated an explanation for the phenotypic difference between Duchenne and Becker patients in the reading-frame rule: In Duchenne patients, mutations induce a shift in the reading frame leading to prematurely truncated, dysfunctional dystrophins. In Becker patients, in-frame mutations allow the synthesis of internally deleted, but largely functional dystrophins. Currently, over 4700 mutations have been reported in the Leiden DMD mutation database, of which 91% are in agreement with this rule. In this study we provide an update of the mutational variability in the DMD gene, particularly focusing on genotype-phenotype correlations and mutations that appear to be exceptions to the reading-frame rule.     

Duchenne型肌营养不良的临床和病理及抗肌萎缩蛋白表达

目的：归纳总结Duchenne型肌营养不良（DMD）的临床表现,组织病理特点及抗肌萎缩蛋白表达情况。方法：通过临床、病理及免疫组化染色方法,对16例DMD患者的临床表现,肌肉病理改变和肌肉抗肌萎缩蛋白表达情况进行观察分析。结果：年龄〉4岁的14例患儿均有比较典型的DMD临床表现;而年龄〈4岁的2例患儿症状较轻。肌肉病理显示2例为早期改变、11例为中期改变、3例为晚期改变,病理改变严重程度与年龄相关。免疫组化染色显示16例患者的肌肉标本抗肌萎缩蛋白均完全缺失。结论：DMD患者的临床和病理表现的严重程度与年龄有关,检查抗肌萎缩蛋白在肌纤维膜上表达是诊断DMD的金标准。