Anterior septal reconstruction: outcomes after a modified extracorporeal septoplasty technique

OBJECTIVE: To describe a modified extracorporeal septoplasty technique and measure its efficacy with a validated quality-of-life instrument. DESIGN: A prospective observational outcomes study of patients with severe septal deviation who subsequently underwent anterior septal reconstruction. Preoperative and postoperative evaluation was performed using photographs and the Nasal Obstruction Symptoms Evaluation scale. RESULTS: Twelve consecutive patients were enrolled. No complications occurred. All patients noted improved airway function postoperatively. There was a significant improvement in mean Nasal Obstruction Symptoms Evaluation score postoperatively (76.6 vs 12.9; P<.01). Examination of postoperative photographs revealed improved midvault and tip anatomy. CONCLUSIONS: The anterior septal reconstruction technique is effective in improving both nasal airway function and aesthetics in patients with severe septonasal deviation. The technique avoids the most common complication of standard extracorporeal septoplasty by preserving the dorsal strut of septal cartilage and its attachment to the nasal bones at the keystone area.     

Triple-procedure technique in internal nasal valve surgery

In cases of narrowing of the internal nasal valve angle, we address all structures that commonly contribute to the internal valve area obstruction. We term this the “triple-procedure technique”. The aim of this study was to assess the efficacy of this technique in improving patients' subjective nasal patency. A prospective longitudinal case study was conducted in a tertiary hospital in northeast of England. All consecutive patients who complained of nasal obstruction and were diagnosed with the internal nasal valve angle narrowing due to septal deviation were offered to have a triple-procedure operation (septoplasty, turbinate surgery and internal nasal valve surgery). Patients completed a validated nose-related questionnaire (Nasal Obstruction Symptom Evaluation (NOSE)) preoperatively, which was repeated 3?months after the operation. The change in NOSE score was the outcome measure. Eight of the nine patients recruited to the study completed the questionnaires (88% response rate). The total and the domain scores improved after the operation, which were clinically and statistically significant. The effect size proved to be very large (total NOSE score effect size, 4.0). Our study shows that addressing all three structures commonly affecting the internal valve area is an effective technique in improving the obstruction caused by the narrow internal nasal valve angle.     

Treatment of nasal obstruction from nasal valve collapse with alar batten grafts

Nasal obstruction may require treatment with rhinoplasty techniques. One cause of nasal obstruction is known as nasal valve collapse. This refers to narrowness and weakness at the nasal valve, the narrowest part of the nasal airway. There are a number of surgical approaches available to treat nasal valve collapse. Selection of the appropriate surgical intervention depends on proper identification of the anatomic cause of the collapse. Alar batten grafts are especially useful for addressing nasal valve collapse caused by a weak nasal sidewall. In this report, we review the senior author's experience with the use of alar batten grafts for nasal valve collapse. Twenty-one patients had septoplasty with placement of alar batten grafts; all patients noted improvement in their nasal breathing. Seven patients underwent ear cartilage harvest with alar batten grafts, and five of them noted improvement, one noted partial improvement, one noted no improvement. Six patients underwent revision septorhinoplasty with alar batten grafting, and ten patients underwent revision septorhinoplasty with ear cartilage harvest and alar batten grafting. These patients all reported improvement in their nasal breathing postoperatively. Six patients underwent revision rhinoplasty (no septoplasty) with ear cartilage and battens. These patients hold special interest because no other intranasal procedures were performed that affected nasal breathing. All six of these patients reported significant improvement of their nasal breathing and all patients were satisfied with their postsurgical cosmetic appearance. The nasal valve area is considered to be the location of the least cross-sectional area in the nose. When narrowing of the nasal valve is a result of collapse of the nasal sidewall, alar batten grafts are a useful technique to address the patient's nasal obstruction.     

Functional considerations in revision rhinoplasty

The development of nasal obstruction after rhinoplasty is associated with significant patient dissatisfaction. Correction of nasal obstruction requires a thorough evaluation to determine the ANATOMIC EPICENTER of obstruction. The offending structure can usually be traced to abnormalities in the internal nasal valve, intervalve area, or the external nasal valve and may be static or dynamic. Surgical correction of the internal nasal valve using spreader grafts, flaring sutures, and butterfly grafts has been shown to increase the cross-sectional area of this nasal valve, improving nasal airflow and patient satisfaction. External valve dysfunction from cicatricial stenosis may be addressed with local flaps; however, larger stenoses may require composite grafts. Alar base malposition can be addressed by repositioning of the alar base with local island flaps. Intervalve dysfunction involves the important area between the external and internal valves, under the supra-alar crease, and is the most common site of obstruction. Its correction often involves alar batten grafts and reconstruction of the lateral crura. Inferior turbinate hypertrophy and concha bullosa may be addressed as adjunctive therapy to increase nasal airflow. This article on nasal obstruction after rhinoplasty emphasizes the precise anatomic diagnosis and describes successful methods used to correct the dysfunction.     

Outcomes after nasal septoplasty: results from the Nasal Obstruction Septoplasty Effectiveness (NOSE) study.

OBJECTIVE: Our goal was to assess disease-specific quality of life outcomes after nasal septoplasty in adults with nasal obstruction. DESIGN, SETTINGS, AND PATIENTS: We conducted a prospective observational outcomes multicenter study with 14 sites and 16 investigators, including private practice and academic settings. Patients had had septal deviation and symptomatic nasal obstruction for at least 3 months, and medical management had failed. METHODS: Patients with septal deviation completed a validated outcomes instrument (the Nasal Obstruction Septoplasty Effectiveness [NOSE] scale) before and 3 and 6 months after septoplasty, with or without partial turbinectomy. RESULTS: Fifty-nine patients underwent surgery; there was a significant improvement in mean NOSE score at 3 months after septoplasty (67.5 versus 23.1, P < 0.0001), and this improvement was unchanged at 6 months. Patient satisfaction was very high, and patients used significantly fewer nasal medications. CONCLUSIONS: In patients with septal deformity, nasal septoplasty results in significant improvement in disease-specific quality of life, high patient satisfaction, and decreased medication use.     

鼻内窥镜手术中的轮廓化问题

目的探讨鼻腔轮廓化的方法与效果。方法回顾性分析行鼻腔轮廓化109例患者的临床资料,其中下鼻甲肥大16例,中鼻甲肥大14例,中、下鼻甲均肥大35例,鼻中隔偏曲17例,下鼻甲肥大合并鼻中隔偏曲16例,泡状中鼻甲合并鼻中隔偏曲6例;鼻中隔偏曲同时伴有下鼻甲肥大及泡状中鼻甲5例。83例鼻腔或中鼻道见息肉样组织。先在鼻内镜下分别行鼻腔息肉切除,鼻中隔偏曲矫正、下甲外移或部分粘膜下骨切除、中甲部分切除后,再行鼻窦开放手术。结果经鼻腔轮廓化后,鼻窦手术视野扩大,操作顺利。术后5例失访,其余均随访满6个月。除1例鼻腔通气不佳外,余术后鼻腔均清理方便、通气满意。89例窦口上皮化良好;10例窦口不畅;5例复发。结论通过鼻内镜行鼻腔轮廓化后再行鼻窦手术,视野宽阔,操作方便,术后清理方便,使鼻窦炎手术效果更佳。     

Alar expansion and reinforcement: a new technique to manage nasal valve collapse

OBJECTIVE: To describe the new technique of alar expansion and reinforcement as a comprehensive approach to the surgical management of nasal valve collapse. METHODS: Alar expansion and reinforcement expands the narrow nasal valve and reinforces the floppy nasal sidewall. Forty-one patients underwent rhinoplastic surgery for nasal valve collapse between May 1, 2002, and April 30, 2005, using an external rhinoplasty approach; of these, 32 responded to our postoperative questionnaire. Twenty-four patients (75%) underwent primary surgery and 8 (25%) had undergone previous rhinoplasty. All patients had permanent adjustable expansion sutures. Twelve patients (38%) had an excessively floppy nasal sidewall that required a high-density porous polyethylene alar batten implant to anchor the expansion sutures. Patients underwent clinical review from 6 months to 3 years after surgery, and a telephone survey was used to evaluate their functional and cosmetic satisfaction rates. RESULTS: Thirty patients (94%) experienced good improvement in their nasal airway. The improvement in nasal airway patency was statistically significant (P<.001). Two patients (6%) reported no improvement. There were no complications. Cosmetic outcome was satisfactory in all 8 patients who also requested cosmetic improvement. Of the 24 patients who had surgery for nasal obstruction only, 10 (42%) rated their cosmetic appearance as better, with the remaining 14 (58%) indicating that they did not identify any significant change in their nasal appearance. CONCLUSION: Alar expansion and reinforcement is a safe, reliable, and effective technique to manage nasal valve collapse.     

Development and validation of the Nasal Obstruction Symptom Evaluation (NOSE) scale.

OBJECTIVE: The study goal was to validate a disease-specific health status instrument for use in patients with nasal obstruction.Design, settings, and patients The study consisted of a prospective instrument validation conducted at 4 academic medical centers with 32 adults with nasal septal deformity. METHODS: Prospective instrument validation occurred in 2 stages. Stage 1 was the development of a preliminary (alpha-version) instrument of potential items. Stage 2 was a test of the alpha-version for item performance, internal consistency, and test-retest reliability; construct, discriminant, criterion validity, and responsiveness; and creation of the final instrument. RESULTS: Items with poor performance were eliminated from the alpha-version instrument. In testing the final instrument, test-retest reliability was adequate at 0.702; internal consistency reliability was also adequate at 0.785. Validity was confirmed using correlation and comparison analysis, and response sensitivity was excellent. CONCLUSIONS: The Nasal Obstruction Symptom Evaluation Scale is a valid, reliable, and responsive instrument that is brief and easy to complete and has potential use for outcomes studies in adults with nasal obstruction.     

Nasal valve surgery

Nasal obstruction can be due to internal and external valve problems that can be seen before and after rhinoplasty. The main scope of this article is to concentrate on surgical solutions to these problems. To overcome nasal obstruction at the internal valve, spreader grafts, spreader flaps, upper lateral splay graft, butterfly graft, flaring suture, M-plasty, Z-plasty, and suspension sutures have been described. The management of the external valve problems is possible by using lateral crural dissection and repositioning, lateral crural strut grafts, alar battens, lateral crural turn-in flap, alar rim grafts, and various other methods. It is not easy to decide which techniques would work best in every case. After a thorough examination and analysis, the underlying cause of the nasal obstruction can be understood, and one or multiple procedures can be chosen according to each individual problem.     

Functional rhinoplasty: treatment of the dysfunctional nasal sidewall

Treatment of nasal obstruction caused by nasal valve dysfunction requires a thorough evaluation of the mechanics of normal nasal anatomy and function. Surgical correction of nasal valve dysfunction is based on determining the epicenter of dysfunction, whether it is a static obstruction of the internal nasal valve or a dynamic collapse of either the external nasal valve or the intervalve area. Spreader grafts, flaring sutures, and butterfly grafts are used to widen and support the narrow internal nasal valve. Alar batten grafts will add support to the collapsing nasal sidewall seen in external nasal valve and intervalve dysfunction. Correction of dynamic collapse from paradoxical concavity of the lateral crura may be obtained from the lateral crural flip-flop graft or by reconstructing the lateral crura using cartilage grafts. A strut graft may correct dynamic obstruction caused by a malformed, easily collapsible lateral crura. This article discusses the evaluation, treatment, and correction of the dysfunctional nasal sidewall and emphasizes the avoidance of iatrogenic damage to the sidewall while performing cosmetic rhinoplasty.     

The lateral crural J-flap repair of nasal valve collapse.

OBJECTIVES: Nasal valve collapse is a common cause of nasal airway obstruction. Although many techniques have been devised to correct both the functional and aesthetic aspects of this problem, none is uniformly successful. I propose that the true locus and solution to the problem lies lateral to the nasal valve angle in the fibroareolar tissue that connects the lateral aspect of the lateral crus to the bony pyriform aperture. Age-related or surgically induced weakening and loosening of these structurally important, fibroareolar connections result in a prolapse of the lateral aspect of the lateral crura away from the pyriform margin and toward the septum with a consequent narrowing of the nasal valve region. A new method of repair is described. METHODS: Bilateral marginal incisions are made following the curvature of the palpated caudal edge of the lower lateral cartilage starting at the dome region medially. The incision is extended laterally until the entire lateralmost aspect of the lateral crus is freed, generating a J-shaped chondrocutaneous flap that is medially and superiorly based. Following this, supraperichondrial dissection of the lateral crus is carried out, exposing the dome region and the upper lateral cartilage. The J-flap is then pulled caudally and laterally, and the excess overlapping tissue is evaluated. Two composite strips of vestibular skin and cartilage are resected: one parallel to the marginal incision and the second at the lateral edge of the J-flap. The flap is transposed and sutured into position, pulling open the nasal valve angle. RESULTS: Preliminary results are presented for 18 patients who underwent 19 lateral crural J-flap repairs of nasal valve collapse. Nine patients underwent concomitant septal, sinus, or turbinate procedures. Two patients underwent unilateral J-flap repair. One patient required revision. Eighty-nine percent of patients reported markedly improved nasal airway patency and elimination of the subjective sensation of inspiratory collapse. Mean time to follow-up was 257 days. There has thus far been no noticeable decrement in benefit over time. CONCLUSION: This new technique for the treatment of nasal valve collapse may offer a simple and effective approach to the problem of nasal valve collapse with minimal morbidity and a high rate of success. The technique is based on a new view of the structural etiology of nasal valve collapse.     

Intranasal Z-plasty for internal nasal valve collapse

OBJECTIVE: To describe the technique of intranasal Z-plasty and early results for this minimally invasive method to repair internal nasal valve collapse. Intranasal Z-plasty has been well described for nasal valve stenosis and cleft nasal deformities but poorly described for idiopathic nasal valve collapse, the most common indication for nasal valve surgery. DESIGN: A retrospective medical record review was performed for 12 patients undergoing intranasal Z-plasty for nasal valve collapse. Medical records were evaluated for age, sex, indication for surgery, prior surgical procedures, complications, results, and length of follow-up. A visual analog scale was used to rate nasal obstruction preoperatively and postoperatively. RESULTS: A total of 8 men and 4 women underwent surgery, and the procedure was bilateral in 10 of the 12 patients, for a total of 22 nasal valves. Eleven patients noted subjective improvement in airflow on both sides, with the remaining patient noting improvement on one side and no change in the opposite side. Mean follow-up was 16.8 months (range, 5-32 months). The mean preoperative nasal obstruction score was 7.2, and the mean postoperative nasal obstruction score was 3.3 (on a scale of 0 to 10, with 10 being total obstruction). No complications were reported, and no patients complained about postoperative nasal appearance. CONCLUSION: Intranasal Z-plasty appears to be a safe, effective, and relatively noninvasive technique to repair internal nasal valve collapse.     

Powered endoscopic septoplasty for septal deviation and isolated spurs

Septoplasty is commonly performed for nasal airway obstruction or rhinologic headache due to contact irritation, often in conjunction with other nasal procedures, including cosmetic rhinoplasty and endoscopic sinus surgery.Traditionally, it is performed before these procedures via a "headlight" technique. This article describes the use of the microdebrider in 29 cases of endoscopic septoplasty. Many of the procedures were performed in conjunction with functional endoscopic sinus surgery; however, several were performed as an isolated procedure or with inferior turbinoplasty. The technique is described in detail. All 29 patients had significant improvement in their symptoms, and no patient developed a perforation or postoperative hematoma. Conversion to a traditional septoplasty was required in 1 case because of the severity of the deviation. Power-assisted endoscopic septoplasty is a useful adjunct in cases involving isolated septal spurs or moderate septal deviations. Patients with severe nasal obstruction due to caudal deflection of the septum off the nasal spine are better served with traditional headlight septoplasty.     

The utility of concurrent rhinoplasty and sinus surgery: a 2-team approach

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the safety and efficiency of and patient satisfaction with a 2-team approach for combined rhinoplasty and sinus surgery. METHODS: We conducted a retrospective medical chart analysis of consecutive patients with sinus disease and functional nasal obstruction. Forty-four patients (29 women and 15 men; age range, 22-75 years) had severe nasal obstruction with chronic sinusitis and were found to have indications for this procedure. All patients were followed up for a minimum of 6 months after surgery. Patients completed a standardized questionnaire at the time of medical chart review, and 36 patients completed a telephone interview. RESULTS: All 44 patients underwent rhinoplasty with an endoscopic sinus procedure. Twenty-seven procedures (61%) were endonasal, whereas 17 (39%) were open rhinoplasty. Patients with internal nasal valve collapse underwent 28 butterfly grafts, 6 spreader grafts, and 8 batten grafts. The endoscopic sinus procedures consisted of maxillary antrostomy (30/44 [68%]) and ethmoidectomy (28/44 [63%]). Overall, 20 (65%) of 31 patients reported a postsurgical nasal airway that was significantly improved. Most sinus symptoms were resolved postoperatively, with 25 (71%) of 35 patients describing their improvement as significant. Thirty-two (92%) of 36 patients stated that they would recommend the concurrent procedure. CONCLUSION: Patients presenting with nasal obstruction and chronic sinusitis tolerated combined rhinoplasty and sinus procedures without added morbidity.     

Asymptomatic Lacrimal Flow Abnormalities in Patients with Septal Deviations and Turbinate Hypertrophy

Background: This study aimed to investigate the lacrimal flow in patients affected by septal deviations and turbinate hypertrophy and to evaluate changes after rhinoseptoplasty with dacryocystography (DCT) and computed tomographic dacryocystography (CT-DCT). Methods: The study prospectively recruited patients having septal deviations with or without turbinate hypertrophy who underwent surgical evaluation for correction of their respiratory symptoms and were not referred for epiphora. Patients were excluded if they had undergone surgery for cranial vault defects or had experienced septal deviations after traumatic accidents. All patients were studied with DCT and CT-DCT preoperatively and postoperatively. Results: A total of 24 patients (10 men and 14 women) were recruited for the study. Of these patients, 11 (45.8%) had a reduced flow of the medium contrast due to a partial obstruction at the level of the internal ostium. All 11 patients had septal deviations and turbinate hypertrophy, whereas 8 patients had a unilateral obstruction (72.7%), and 3 patients had a bilateral obstruction (27.3%). All flows were corrected after surgery. Conclusions: The safe and well-tolerated radiologic techniques performed in this study provided detailed imaging of the lacrimal outflow system. A high incidence of partial obstruction to the internal ostium was found in patients with septal deviations, turbinate hypertrophy, and no lacrimal symptoms, suggesting a frequent presymptomatic condition.     

Nasal obstruction after rhinoplasty

Nasal obstruction is a frustrating sequel of rhinoplasty to both the patient and the surgeon. Physiologic problems are caused by altered vasomotor mechanisms of the lining. Mechanical obstruction results from (1) over-correction of the nasal supporting structures, (2) infracture of long nasal bones, (3) septal irregularities, and (4) surgical adhesions.Simple and effective techniques for correcting each of these problems are described.     

Comparison of the Effectiveness and Safety of Radiofrequency Turbinoplasty and Traditional Surgical Technique in Treatment of Inferior Turbinate Hypertrophy

OBJECTIVES: Inferior turbinate hypertrophy is one of the major causes of nasal airway obstruction. Medical treatment often produces insufficient improvements. In these cases, surgical reduction of inferior turbinates can be proposed. Many different techniques are currently available. We prospectively evaluate the safety and effectiveness of radiofrequency volumetric tissue reduction (RFVTR) compared with the traditional surgical technique. METHODS: The study was conducted on 3 groups of 75 patients with symptoms and signs of nasal obstruction associated with inferior turbinate hypertrophy refractory to medical therapy. In group A, the turbinoplasty (TP) was performed using the classical surgical submucosal resection; in group B, the RFVTR was applied to inferior turbinate; and group C patients were not treated and served as control subjects. Nasal endoscopy, visual analogue scale (VAS), anterior active positional rhinomanometry, and saccharin tests were used to assess treatment outcomes at the end of week 1 and months 1 and 3 after surgery. RESULTS: Turbinate edema and secretions decreased significantly (P < 0.05) in groups A and B from 1 month after surgery. The secretions in group A increased temporarily on the seventh day after surgery. Concerning the nasal obstruction and related symptoms, significant improvement was observed at 1 month after treatment in all patients (P < 0.05) and continued up to 3 months after surgery (P < 0.0001). Rhinomanometric measurements demonstrated a significant nasal flow increase at 3 months (P < 0.0001). The nasal mucociliary transport time increased in group A at week 1. The difference among the 3 groups at month 1 was observed not significant. CONCLUSION: In this study, we demonstrated that both RFVTR and TP are effective in improving nasal obstruction and related nasal symptoms. In support of the RFVTR, different factors are important: it can be performed in local anaesthesia; it does not require a nasal package; it does not cause either a change of mucociliary function or an increase of secretions and crusts; and the patient can be discharged immediately after treatment. Therefore, we suggest that the RFVTR offers an efficient, gentle, and function-maintaining alternative to TP. However, because of the short follow-up, future investigations are needed for a more exhaustive evaluation of equivalency of the 2 turbinate procedures.     

Railway graft for internal nasal valve reconstruction

Background

Although many methods have been proposed to restore the internal nasal valve (INV) such as suture techniques, various grafts, upper lateral cartilage folding techniques, and combined techniques, the most popular and effective one remains spreader grafts. The aim of the present study is to propose a new graft design for INV reconstruction and to test the reliability and feasibility of the technique.

Methods

Thirty-two primary septorhinoplasty patients divided in three groups underwent surgery with railway, spreader, and no graft techniques. The functional results were evaluated with the Nasal Obstruction Evaluation Scale (NOSE) scores subjectively.

Results

Significant improvements were observed comparing preoperative and postoperative NOSE scores in railway and spreader grafts groups. However, there was no significant difference in NOSE scores between those groups of patients.

Conclusions

Railway graft is an effective method that can be recommended if septal cartilage is limited for reconstruction of INV. Level of Evidence: Level IV, therapeutic study.     

A technique to model the nasal airway for aerodynamic study

This article presents a new technique for creation of a model that can be used to study the aerodynamics of the nasal airway. The model is employed to determine parameters used to calculate nasal resistance and modified to compare various types of nasal obstruction. It quantitatively compares the importance of septal deviation, turbinate size, and nasopharyngeal port size to airflow. A new parameter of nasal resistance is introduced.     

Surgical approach to nasal valves and the midvault in patients with a crooked nose

Management of the crooked nose and valve obstruction is a challenge for even the most experienced rhinoplasty surgeon. Optimal treatment to restore a functional airway and improve cosmesis requires addressing the nasal valves. Several different techniques are available to guide the rhinoplasty surgeon to achieve the best outcome.