Fragile site X chromosomes and X-linked mental retardation in severely retarded boys in a northern Swedish county. A prevalence study

In an unselected series of 96 severely mentally retarded boys (IQ < 50) born 1959–70 in a northern Swedish county, six had a fragile site on the distal end of the X chromosome (FraXq 28). The prevalence of the fragile X syndrome in severely retarded boys was 6 %. Next to trisomy 21, this fragile X syndrome appears to be the most common single cause of severe mental retardation in boys.     

Fragile site X chromosomes in mentally retarded boys.

The fragile X syndrome is a common X-linked mental retardation and autism, affecting females as well as males. The fragile site X chromosomes were studied in a series of 153 mentally retarded boys of unknown etiology to determine the frequency of fragile X syndrome, and to assess the feasibility of making a clinical diagnosis of the fragile X syndrome in young boys before cytogenetic results were known. The 10 boys (6.4%) were positive for fra (X) (q27). The phenotype of fra (X) (q27) positive patients were typical except one who also had sex chromosomal mosaicism. There were three pairs of siblings among the fra (X) (q27) positive patients. Frequency of expression of the fragile site was in 10 to 47 per cent of cells. In addition, 19 boys showed a previously unsuspected chromosomal abnormality. The frequency of the fragile X syndrome in the present study is not significantly different from those in Caucasians and Japanese population. The fragile X syndrome can be recognized by noting key aspects of family history as well as the clinical features in mentally retarded boys.     

Martin-Bell syndrome in Greece,with report of another 47,XXY fragile X patient

A cytogenetic investigation was carried out among 200 mentally retarded boys in Greece for the detection of the fragile X [fra(X)] syndrome. Thirteen patients were found to carry fra(X) (6.5%). Of those, six boys had a history of familial X-linked mental retardation, two had the phenotype of the Martin-Bell syndrome, four had only mental retardation of unknown etiology, and one was a mentally retarded patient with Klinefelter syndrome. The remaining 187 boys were fra(X) negative. Our findings emphasize the importance of early identification of this syndrome in the diagnosis and prevention, through proper genetic counselling, of mental retardation.     

Fragile X syndrome in mildly mentally retarded children in a Northern Swedish county. A prevalence study

In an extensive etiological study of an unselected series of mildly mentally retarded children (MMR) (IQ 50–70) born 1959–1970 in a northern Swedish county, 5 of 110 boys (4.5%) and none of 61 girls had a fragile site on the distal end of the X-chromosome (Fra Xq 28). Consequently fragile X was seen in 2.9% of the total series of 171 children. In a combined series of severe and mild mental retardation, the incidence of the fragile X syndrome was calculated to be 1:3000 in the county of Vasterbotten. Next to trisomy 21 the fragile X syndrome was the most common single identified cause of MMR in boys. A cytogenetic investigation using special cultural conditions and banding techniques should be performed in cases of mental retardation of unclear etiology and in possible female carriers.     

Fragile (X) syndrome: a study of the psychological profile in 23 prepubertal patients

In this study a further analysis of the psychological profile in the prepubertal fragile (X) (fra(X] male was performed. The results of the psycho-diagnostic examination of 23 fra(X) boys were compared to a control group of 17 males of the same age with 'non-specific' mental retardation. A number of important quantitative and qualitative differences were observed between the two groups. In the preschool age group the majority of fra(X) boys was mildly mentally retarded. In the school-age group, however, most boys were moderately to severely mentally retarded. This indication of a decline in intellectual performance with age in the fra(X) syndrome was confirmed by a longitudinal individual follow-up of seven fra(X) boys in this age group. In contrast to intellectual performance, appearance of the attention deficit disorder (or hyperkinesis), with its attendent overactivity and impulsiveness, decreases with age, and is independent of the intellectual level. Autistic behaviour was more frequently observed in the youngest fra(X) males, and was more pronounced in the moderately mentally retarded. In more than 50% of the boys of preschool age the association of hyperkinesis and autistic features was found. Language and speech development in the fra(X) syndrome is both symptomatic and specific. Beside a severe, global speech retardation, there are some distinct speech characteristics in the young fra(X) males such as rapid speech rhythm, speech impulsiveness and perseverative speech.     

Autosomal folate sensitive fragile sites in normal and mentally retarded individuals in Greece

The frequencies of autosomal folate sensitive fragile sites were compared in populations of mentally retarded fra(X) negative (N = 220) and normal children (N = 76) in Greece. In addition, the frequency of autosomal fragile sites was studied in 20 known fra(X) children in order to test if the fra(X) syndrome is associated with general chromosome instability. The frequencies of both common and rare autosomal fragile sites did not differ significantly between the mentally retarded and the normal children, although the rate of expression was considerably higher in the retarded group. Autosomal fragile sites were not increased in the fra(X) patients. Fra(3)(p14) was by far the most frequent one in all groups. The frequency of fra(6)(q26) was found to be considerably higher among the mentally retarded children, this difference being almost statistically significant. Further cytogenetic studies of normal and retarded individuals are required in order to elucidate this point further.     

Fragile X families in a northern Swedish county: a genealogical study of possibly affected individuals in the nineteenth century

Most studies of fragile X [fra(X)] families are able to document mental impairment only by family history. Using Swedish historical archives and the unique parish catechetical meeting records it is possible to document qualitative phenomena such as literacy for over 100 years. In this way it was possible to identify 7 individuals with mental retardation living in the nineteenth century in an earlier published fra(X) pedigree. Four of them were female. At the present time another 4 severely mentally retarded females with the fra(X) syndrome have been diagnosed in this family. The high prevalence of mentally retarded females might indicate a variant form of the fra(X) syndrome in this family.     

Fragile X screening program in a Spanish region.

In a Spanish region with a population of one million, we screened 371 mentally retarded males, who had no previous diagnosis for fragile X [fra(X))] syndrome. Fifty-three of the 371 males were fra(X) positive. Of these 44 of 362 or 12.1% were unrelated. Family studies identified a large number of obligate carriers and women at risk for being carriers who were given genetic counseling including prenatal diagnostic information. Considering the age of the carriers and the fertility rate, 23 affected males could be born to these women. The prevention potential of this program suggests that it is highly cost-effective.     

Effect of X inactivation on fragile X frequency and mental retardation

The probability of a heterozygote being affected was estimated from the distribution of frequencies of early-replicating fragile X [fra(X)] chromosome in normal and mentally retarded heterozygotes, taking into account the prior probabilities of 0.35 for mental retardation and 0.65 for normality. The estimated probability of a heterozygote with 100% early-replicating fra(X) being mentally retarded was 78%, which coincides with the value of penetrance in males. Therefore, the manifestation of retardation in females seems to differ from that in males due solely to X inactivation. The frequencies of early-replicating fra(X) were significantly increased among the heterozygotes with the highest frequencies of fra(X) both in the normal group and in the mentally retarded. The mean frequencies of early-replicating fra(X) were 0.42 and 0.68 for normal and mentally retarded heterozygotes, respectively. Considering the overall frequency of retarded heterozygotes as 0.35, the mean frequency of early-replicating fra(X) obtained for all heterozygotes was 0.51, which is in accordance with the hypothesis of random X inactivation. Thus the fragile site appears to have equal chances of being detected when located either on the early- or on the late-replicating X. This leads to the conclusion that the frequency of the fragile site is a consequence of the proportion of cells with the active Martin-Bell syndrome (MBS) gene and not the result of a better visualization of the site on the early-replicating X.     

Anthropometric and craniofacial patterns in mentally retarded males with emphasis on the fragile X syndrome

Butler MG, Pratesi R, Watson MS, Breg WR, Singh DN. Anthropometric and craniofacial patterns in mentally retarded males with emphasis on the fragile X syndrome. Clin Genet 1993: 44: 129–138. © Munksgaard, 1993 Anthropometric and craniofacial profile patterns indicating the percent difference from the overall mean were developed on 34 physical parameters with 31 white, mentally retarded males (23 adults and 8 children) with the fra(X) syndrome matched for age with 31 white, mentally retarded males without a known cause of their retardation. The fra(X) syndrome males consistently showed larger dimensions for all anthropometric variables, with significant differences for height, sitting height, arm span, hand length, middle finger length, hand breadth, foot length, foot breadth, and testicular volume. A craniofacial pattern did emerge between the two groups of mentally retarded males, but with overlap of several variables. Significant differences were noted for head circumference, head breadth, lower face height, bizygomatic diameter, inner canthal distance, ear length and ear width, with the fra(X) syndrome males having larger head dimensions (head circumference, head breadth, head length, face height and lower face height), but smaller measurements for minimal frontal diameter, bizygomatic diameter, bigonial diameter, and inner canthal distance. Several significant correlations were found with the variables for both mentally retarded males with and without the fra(X) syndrome. In a combined anthropometric and craniofacial profile of 19 variables comparing 26 white fra(X) syndrome males (13 with high expression (>30%) and 13 with low expression (<30%), but matched for age), a relatively flat profile was observed with no significant differences for any of the variables. Generally, fra(X) syndrome males with increased fragile X chromosome expression have larger amplifications of the CGG trinucleotide repeat of the FMR-1 gene. No physical differences were detectable in our study between fra(X) males with high expression and apparently larger amplifications of the CGG trinucleotide repeats compared with those patients with low expression. Our research illustrates the use of anthropometry in identifying differences between mentally retarded males with or without the fra(X) syndrome and offers a comprehensive approach for screening males for the fra(X) syndrome and selecting those individuals for cytogenetic and/or molecular genetic testing.     

Intelligence and cognitive profile in the fra(X) syndrome: a longitudinal study in 18 fra(X) boys.

A longitudinal study of IQ and cognitive profile in 18 fra(X) positive boys is reported. At the time of diagnosis, four of the boys were mildly retarded, seven were moderately retarded, and five were severely mentally retarded. Intelligence was borderline in one child and normal in another. A decline in intellectual performance with age in the fra(X) syndrome indicated in previous studies was not confirmed and we review the reported data on this subject.     

The fragile X syndrome in a large family. III. Investigations on linkage of flanking DNA markers with the fragile site Xq27.

In a large family with the fragile X syndrome, we performed linkage investigations with six probes, detecting RFLPs at both sides of the fragile site Xq27. The nearest flanking markers were cX55.7 (DXS105) on the centromeric side (theta = 0.04, lod 5.0) and St14 (DXS52) on the telomeric side (theta = 0.08, lod 4.0). Non-penetrance could be shown by the presence of the grandpaternal X chromosome in three mentally retarded fra(X) positive males. A second non-penetrant male in this family had inherited an abnormal grandmaternal X chromosome. His carrier mother had two retarded fra(X) positive brothers. Intermediate between the non-penetrant and fully penetrant males was a non-retarded male, who expressed the fragile site in 6% of his cells. His X chromosome showed the same polymorphisms as were found in his seven severely retarded brothers. In five fra(X) negative females the presence of an abnormal X chromosome could be demonstrated. Despite the existence of non-penetrance in this pedigree, there was no close linkage between a factor IX polymorphism and the fragile site (theta = 0.16, lod 1.9). However, in six descendants of a non-penetrant male, the change to penetrance appeared to be accompanied by a low recombination frequency for flanking markers.     

Fragile X syndrome: incidence, clinical and cytogenetic findings in the black and white populations of South Carolina

Individuals in South Carolina with the Fragile X [fra(X)] or Martin-Bell syndrome have been ascertained by referral for evaluation of facial abnormalities, macroorchidism or mental deficit; by screening patients in residential and day programs for the mentally retarded; and by family follow up after an index case has been identified. Between 1982 and 1987, 100 positive fra(X) males were diagnosed. Of these, 35 were residents of residential facilities for the mentally retarded representing 2.5% of the population of institutionalized males. Another 23 were found in community day programs for the mentally retarded. Of these 58 cases, 28 (48%) were ascertained by screening for the craniofacial characteristics of the Martin-Bell syndrome, namely long face, midface hypoplasia, prominent forehead, large mandible and large simple pinnae. Although this screening procedure proved to be productive, it was found that the craniofacial traits of long face, midface hypoplasia, large jaw and simple pinnae were found less frequently in black fra(X) positive males and in prepubertal boys of both races.     

Fragile X screening program in New York State

Most fragile X [fra(X)] males in New York State have not been identified. Hence, a large number of female relatives are unaware of their risks for having an affected child. A program was established in New York State in 1987 to screen for the fra(X) syndrome in mentally retarded males with living relatives. The goal of the program is to identify affected males and inform their families about the diagnosis. In this way relatives would be able to assess their risks for having a fra(X) male. In order to identify the males a screening form was developed to assess 10 features which included physical characteristics, behavior, and family history. Males who exhibited at least 5 of these manifestations were selected for cytogenetic analysis. Any male who had macroorchidism or a family history of mental retardation was also included. A total of 995 males have been screened of which 352 (35%) were selected for cytogenetic analyses. Seventeen (10.5%) of the 161 completed studies were positive for fra(X). A large number of possible female carriers were identified in the families of the propositi. This program identifies fra(X) males in a population of the mentally retarded for whom there had been no previous diagnosis. By using a two-step procedure, it is possible to screen a large population of the mentally retarded for fra(X) without testing each male cytogenetically.     

Fragile (X)(q27) sites in a pedigree with female carriers showing mild to severe mental retardation.

A pedigree showing the fragile site at Xq27 in a severely retarded female and in other less retarded carriers is described. Two of the four moderately retarded males with the fra(X)(q27) show macro-orchidism, and a variety of other features usually used to support the effects of the fra(X)(q27) are also inconsistent. A second fragile site at (10)(q23) is also present and in the two oldest females its frequency is not decreased, whereas the fra(x)(q27) is not detectable in these females although probably present. It is concluded that pedigrees showing mentally retarded females and probable X linkage should be included in studies of the fra(X)(q27).     

X chromosome inactivation in fibroblasts of mentally retarded female carriers of the fragile site Xq27.3: application of the probe M27 beta to evaluate X inactivation status.

Over 30% of female carriers of the fragile X [fra(X)] syndrome are clinically affected. A nonrandom X chromosome inactivation in these cases could be a plausible explanation. A review of previous studies addressing this question showed inconclusive results; thus, we analysed the X inactivation pattern in fibroblasts of 4 unrelated, mentally retarded fra(X) carriers with a high expression of the fragile site Xq27.3. Using Southern analysis with a highly polymorphic probe M27 beta that recognizes methylation differences between the active and inactive X chromosome we found a 50/50 inactivation pattern in 2 cases and skewed patterns in the other 2. As biased patterns were also observed in control females we conclude that at present no evidence exists for a nonrandom X chromosome inactivation in the fra(X) syndrome in females.     

Fragile X expression in normal and mentally retarded subjects: effect of treatment with an antifolic agent

Expression of the fragile site fra(X) (q27.3) in peripheral lymphocytes was evaluated in mentally retarded patients and in normal control individuals before and after administration of the antifolic agent trimethoprim for 7 days. This treatment was effective in converting the status of some individuals from fra(X)-negative to fra(X)-positive. However, the induced level of fra(X) expression was very low and not significantly different in patients and in control subjects and did not increase in those individuals where it was already present before treatment. These data support the contention that fra(X)(q27.3) is a common fragile site and that treatment in vivo with an antifolic agent is not effective in enhancing its degree of expression in vitro. Therefore, such treatment seems to be of no diagnostic value in those cases where the fra(X) syndrome is suspected clinically, but where there is no or very low cytogenetic expression of the fra(X).     

Fragile X frequency in a mentally retarded population in Brazil

Seventy-five male and 50 female students from 2 special schools for mildly, moderately retarded, or borderline individuals were screened clinically and cytogenetically in order to estimate the contribution of fragile X [fra(X)] syndrome to the cause of mental retardation in Brazil. We found 6 males (8%) from 4 families and 2 unrelated females (4%) with fra(X) chromosomes. One male and one female were isolated cases. The estimated frequency of Martin-Bell [fra(X)] syndrome among mentally impaired individuals in Brazil was similar to that previously reported in other countries.     

Three families with high expression of a fragile site at Xq27.3, lack of anomalies at the FMR-1 CpG island, and no clear phenotypic association.

We report on 3 families where the presence and segregation at high frequency of a fragile Xq27.3 site is not associated with the mutations and methylation anomalies typically seen in the fragile X [Fra(X)] syndrome. In one family, a folate insensitive fragile site was associated with Robin sequence in the propositus. In a second family a fra(X) negative mother has two fra(X) positive sons (one mentally retarded and the other newborn). The third family presents very high expression of a folate sensitive site, unlinked to mental retardation, and was described previously by Voelckel et al. [1989]. The fragile sites in these or similar families recently described must be different from the one associated with the fra(X) syndrome. Their association with a clinical phenotype or with mental retardation is certainly not consistent, and may represent an ascertainment bias. However, the relatively high frequency with which they have been found among previously diagnosed fra(X) families suggests that, at least in some cases, the association with mental impairment may be significant. In two families reported up to now, a male with high expression of such variant fra(X) site failed to transmit it to his daughter, which may reflect an imprinting effect. Previously diagnosed families should be reinvestigated before direct DNA analysis is used for prenatal or carrier diagnosis of the fra(X) syndrome.     

Fragile X syndrome with extra microchromosome

A mentally retarded male with Martin-Bell syndrome, who has an extra microchromosome and is fra X negative in cytogenetic study is reported. Because of its small size, the origin of the microchromosome could not be determined. Two other affected males in this family (a cousin and a nephew of the proband) were fragile X positive, 24% and 26%, respectively. Cytogenetic studies and DNA analysis with the probe St B 12.3 were performed on several members of the family. The proband and the two other affected males showed a similar full mutation on the molecular study. This study emphasizes the importance of molecular analysis in the diagnosis of fragile X syndrome, particularly when cytogenetic studies demonstrate fra X negative in individuals in families likely to have X-linked mental retardation.