Informational masking in normal-hearing and hearing-impaired listeners

The present study aimed to test whether central, across-channel, informational auditory processing abilities are altered by hearing loss. The informational masking effect exerted on a 1 kHz tone-pip by a simultaneous four-tone masker, whose spectral content changed within as well as across trials, was measured in the left and right ears of normal-hearing subjects and hearing-impaired subjects with either symmetrical or asymmetrical hearing loss between the two ears. In the subjects with normal-hearing or symmetrical hearing loss, the level of the masker was set to 40 dB SL in each ear, in the subjects with asymmetrical hearing loss, the masker was set to 40 dB SL in the best ear and loudness-balanced in the other ear. The results failed to reveal significant differences in informational masking between normal-hearing and hearing-impaired subjects. However, in subjects with asymmetric hearing loss, less informational masking was observed in the ear with the more elevated absolute thresholds than in the opposite ear. Since the latter finding can be explained in terms of across-ear differences in loudness recruitment, it is suggested that central, across-channel, informational processing abilities are not substantially different in hearing-impaired than in normal-hearing ears.     

High-level psychophysical tuning curves: forward masking in normal-hearing and hearing-impaired listeners.

Forward-masked psychophysical tuning curves (PTCs) were obtained for 1000-Hz probe tones at multiple probe levels from one ear of 26 normal-hearing listeners and from 24 ears of 21 hearing-impaired listeners with cochlear hearing loss. Comparisons between normal-hearing and hearing-impaired PTCs were made at equivalent masker levels near the tips of PTCs. Comparisons were also made of PTC characteristics obtained by fitting each PTC with three straight-line segments using least-squares fitting procedures. Abnormal frequency resolution was revealed only as abnormal downward spread of masking. The low-frequency slopes of PTCs from hearing-impaired listeners were not different from those of normal-hearing listeners. That is, hearing-impaired listeners did not demonstrate abnormal upward spread of masking when equivalent masker levels were compared. Ten hearing-impaired ears demonstrated abnormally broad PTCs, due exclusively to reduced high-frequency slopes in their PTCs. This abnormal downward spread of masking was observed only in listeners with hearing losses greater than 40 dB HL. From these results, it would appear that some, but not all, cochlear hearing losses greater than 40 dB HL influence the sharp tuning capabilities usually associated with outer hair cell function.     

Growth of masking in sensorineural hearing loss.

The purpose of the present study was to measure the growth of masking in both normal-hearing and sensorineural hearing-impaired subjects. The masker was a narrow band of noise centered at 1,000 Hz, and masked thresholds for signal frequencies both above and below the masker frequency were obtained for a range of masker levels. For signal frequencies above the masker frequency, the slopes of the growth of masking functions were greater than 1 dB/dB for the normal-hearing group, while for the hearing-impaired subjects the slopes were less than those of the normal subjects, and in many cases slopes were less than 1. The slope of masking was inversely related to the threshold at the signal frequency. These data support the concept that a loss of nonlinearity at the signal place is responsible for the slower growth of masking in hearing-impaired subjects for signal frequencies greater than the masker. In addition, the slower-than-normal growth of masking of the hearing-impaired subjects suggests that some hearing aid signal-processing strategies which provide greater amounts of high-frequency emphasis at high input levels may not be appropriate.     

Use of low-pass noise in word-recognition testing.

This study attempted to determine whether word-recognition scores obtained in noise were more sensitive to the presence of a hearing loss than recognition scores obtained in quiet. Subjects with normal hearing, high-frequency cochlear hearing loss, and flat cochlear hearing loss were tested in quiet and in the presence of a 500-Hz low-pass noise. Two signal-to-noise conditions were employed, -4 dB and -12 dB. Words were presented at 40dB SL in one experiment and at 96 dB SPL for normal-hearing subjects in a second experiment. The results indicated that, while the word-recognition scores of groups were similar in quiet, the more negative the signal-to-noise ratio, the greater the separation of group scores, with hearing-impaired subjects having poorer recognition scores than normal-hearing subjects. When the speech and noise were presented at high SPLs, however, the normal-hearing subjects had poorer word recognition than those with flat cochlear losses. The results are interpreted as indicating greater spread of masking in normal-hearing than hearing-impaired subjects at high sound pressure levels.     

Upward spread of masking in normal and abnormal ears

Upward spread of masking was studied for normals and sensorineurally hearing-impaired subjects with high-frequency hearing loss. Hearing-impaired listeners were recruited in such a way as to present normal hearing on the frequency of the masker, that is a narrow band of noise centered at 1 000 Hz. Levels of the masker were set at 70, 80 and 90 dB, respectively. Results first indicated the presence of a relationship between masked and elevated absolute thresholds for a masker level of 70 dB. At masker levels of 80 and 90 dB, hearing-impaired listeners showed excessive upward spread of masking in spite of normal hearing sensitivity at the masker frequency: with 80 and 90 dB of noise, upward spread of masking grew, respectively, 2.6 and 1.6 times faster than in normals. Furthermore, excessive upward spread of masking was shown to progress as a function of hearing loss. Results were interpreted as additional evidence of abnormal frequency selectivity in sensorineurally hearing-impaired listeners.     

Débordement de masquage normal et anormal sur les aigus

Upward Spread of Masking in Normal and Impaired Ears

Upward spread of masking was studied for normals and sensorineurally hearing-impaired subjects with high-frequency hearing loss. Hearing-impaired listeners were recruited in such a way as to present normal hearing on the frequency of the masker, that is a narrow band of noise centered at 1 000 Hz. Levels of the masker were set at 70, 80 and 90 dB, respectively. Results first indicated the presence of a relationship between masked and elevated absolute thresholds for a masker level of 70 dB. At masker levels of 80 and 90 dB, hearing-impaired listeners showed excessive upward spread of masking in spite of normal hearing sensitivity at the masker frequency: with 80 and 90 dB of noise, upward spread of masking grew, respectively, 2.6 and 1.6 times faster than in normals. Furthermore, excessive upward spread of masking was shown to progress as a function of hearing loss. Results were interpreted as additional evidence of abnormal frequency selectivity in sensorineurally hearing-impaired listeners.     

中枢掩蔽与耳声发射对侧抑制相关性研究

目的：探讨中枢掩蔽与耳发射对侧抑制的相关性。方法：通过对一组耳科正常青年人及4例蜗后聋患者同时进行相同条件下中枢掩蔽及耳声发射对侧抑制的测试，观察中枢掩蔽与耳声发射对侧抑制在同一实验对象的表现。结果：在正常人组中，当对侧掩蔽声小于60 d BHL时，中枢掩蔽效应及耳声发射的对侧抑制均随对侧掩蔽声增加而增大，掩蔽强度大于60 d BHL时，则出现过度掩蔽。耳声发射记录过程中，本底噪声明显升高。当对侧掩蔽声固定为60 d BHL时，中频1.0、2.0kHz中枢掩蔽效应及耳声发射对侧抑制明显高于低频及高频，2.0kHz处最为明显；在蜗后聋组中，健耳或听力损伤较轻耳，中枢掩蔽及耳声发射对侧抑制接近正常人耳，而患者或听力损失较重耳，中枢掩蔽效应为负值或零，对侧抑制表现为反抑制或不抑制。结论：中枢掩蔽与对侧抑制存在相同的发生机理，表现出相同的频率特异性及强度特异性，无论在正常人耳还是病变耳，均表现出高度的相关性。     

Auditory temporal and spectral resolution in normal and impaired hearing

Temporal, spectral, and combined temporal-spectral resolution of hearing was assessed by recording masked hearing thresholds. The masker was an octave band noise. Spectral resolution was assessed by introducing a spectral gap of half an octave bandwidth in the masker. A 50-msec gap assessed temporal resolution. The spectral and temporal gaps were used separately or simultaneously. Normal-hearing and hearing-impaired subjects participated. For each masking condition, the subjects were tested at masker levels 50, 60, 70, and 80 dB SPL and at test-tone frequencies 0.5, 1, 2, and 4 kHz. Normal-hearing subjects showed reduced masking with spectral and temporal gaps. The combination of spectral and temporal gap reduced masking further. The release of masking was dependent upon the masker level. Hearing-impaired subjects showed less release of masking than normal-hearing subjects. The degree of hearing impairment was inversely related to release of masking. Reliability of the test procedure was assessed.     

Effect of contralateral noise on speech detection and speech reception thresholds.

Speech detection thresholds (SDT) and speech reception thresholds (SRT) for spondee words were obtained on 20 normal hearing listeners while white or speech noise making was presented to the contralateral ear. Each masker was presented continously or pulsed simultaneously with the onset of each spondee word. Several masker sensation levels (SL) of 30, 40, 50, 60, 70, and 80 dB were employed, and the amount of masking (threshold shift) was determined for each condition. Small but consistent SDT and SRT shifts were apparent at low masker SLs (30 dB). FOR 60-80 DB masker SLs, the shifts were about 3.5 dB for each 10-dB increase in the masker. The greater threshold shifts at the higher masker SLs may have resulted from transcranial conduction and/or activation of the acoustic reflex. The pulsed masker condition had more of an effected on the SDT than on the SRT; SDT shifts were consistently larger for each masker SL when the masker was pulsed compared to continuous presentation. Overall, the average threshold shifts ranged from about 1 to 11 dB as the masker SL was increased from 30 to 80 dB. These data suggest that central masking is operating for masker SLs below 60 dB; for higher masker SLs, the increased threshold shifts probably result from a combination of central masking, transcranial conduction, and acoustic stapedius reflex action. The clinical implications of central masking are also discussed.     

Effects of noise and hearing loss upon frequency discrimination

Frequency discrimination in quiet and in the presence of several levels of low-frequency masking noise was measured at 500, 1,000 and 2,000 Hz in both normal-hearing and hearing-impaired subjects. The test signals were presented at 80 dB SPL; all test signals were at least 10 dB above each subject's masked threshold. As a group, the hearing impaired subjects had larger frequency difference limens than the normal subjects, especially in frequency regions of greatest sensitivity loss. The masking noise produced a similar increase in frequency difference limens in both groups. Although several previous speech recognition studies have demonstrated an interactive effect between the presence of hearing loss and masking noise, the results of the present study demonstrate that frequency discrimination performance for normal-hearing and hearing-impaired subjects is not differentially affected by the addition of masking noise.     

The post-auricular muscle response: an objective electrophysiological method for evaluating hearing sensitivity

Post-auricular muscle responses (PAMRs) were recorded in sixteen adults with normal hearing and twenty adults with sensorineural hearing loss. Click stimuli were presented at 20 to 80 dB nHL via insert earphones. Only one ear was tested in hearing-impaired subjects, but normal-hearing subjects were tested monaurally and binaurally. PAMR amplitudes declined and latencies increased with decreasing click intensity. Both binaural stimulation and eye turn enhanced the PAMR. In hearing-impaired subjects, PAMR thresholds were correlated with audiometric thresholds for the eyes-turned condition. All normal-hearing subjects had PAMR when recording conditions were optimized and half had responses for the least optimal condition (20 dB nHL, monaural, eyes front). With eyes turned and monaural clicks at 35 dB nHL, the level widely used for infant hearing screening, most normal-hearing adults had a PAMR. Thus the PAMR is a robust response that may be a useful adjunct to ABR for objective hearing assessment.     

Further interpretation of the threshold of octave masking (TOM) test

The threshold of octave masking (TOM) test was administered to normal-hearing and sensorineural-impaired listeners at four test frequencies; 500, 1000, 2000 and 4000 Hz. The TOM value was found to be inversely proportional to the degree of hearing loss at the masker frequency. Results indicate that the TOM test is capable of distinguishing subjects with sensorineural involvement from those with normal hearing and of providing a measure of the degree of sensory dysfunction. Examination of the slope of octave masking dysfunction. Examination of the slope of octave masking revealed that once the influence of hearing loss is overcome at higher intensities the sensorineural ear performs essentially the same as the normal ear in a tone-on-tone masking task.     

Auditory-filter characteristics for listeners with real and simulated hearing impairment

Functional simulation of sensorineural hearing impairment is an important research tool that can elucidate the nature of hearing impairments and suggest or eliminate compensatory signal-processing schemes. The objective of the current study was to evaluate the capability of an audibility-based functional simulation of hearing loss to reproduce the auditory-filter characteristics of listeners with sensorineural hearing loss. The hearing-loss simulation used either threshold-elevating noise alone or a combination of threshold-elevating noise and multiband expansion to reproduce the audibility-based characteristics of the loss (including detection thresholds, dynamic range, and loudness recruitment). The hearing losses of 10 listeners with bilateral, mild-to-severe hearing loss were simulated in 10 corresponding groups of 3 age-matched normal-hearing listeners. Frequency selectivity was measured using a notched-noise masking paradigm at five probe frequencies in the range of 250 to 4000 Hz with a fixed probe level of either 70 dB SPL or 8 dB SL (whichever was greater) and probe duration of 200 ms. The hearing-loss simulation reproduced the absolute thresholds of individual hearing-impaired listeners with an average root-mean-squared (RMS) difference of 2.2 dB and the notched-noise masked thresholds with an RMS difference of 5.6 dB. A rounded-exponential model of the notched-noise data was used to estimate equivalent rectangular bandwidths and slopes of the auditory filters. For some subjects and probe frequencies, the simulations were accurate in reproducing the auditory-filter characteristics of the hearing-impaired listeners. In other cases, however, the simulations underestimated the magnitude of the auditory bandwidths for the hearing-impaired listeners, which suggests the possibility of suprathreshold deficits.     

Speech identification difficulties of hearing-impaired elderly persons: the contributions of auditory processing deficits

This study examined the performance of four subject groups on several temporally based measures of auditory processing and several measures of speech identification. The four subjects groups were (a) young normal-hearing adults; (b)-hearing-impaired elderly subjects ranging in age from 65 to 75 years; (c) hearing-impaired elderly adults ranging in age from 76 to 86 years; and (d) young normal-hearing listeners with hearing loss simulated with a spectrally shaped masking noise adjusted to match the actual hearing loss of the two elderly groups. In addition to between-group analyses of performance on the auditory processing and speech identification tasks, correlational and regression analyses within the two groups of elderly hearing-impaired listeners were performed. The results revealed that the threshold elevation accompanying sensorineural hearing loss was the primary factor affecting the speech identification performance of the hearing-impaired elderly subjects both as groups and as individuals. However, significant increases in the proportion of speech identification score variance accounted for were obtained in the elderly subjects by including various measures of auditory processing.     

Informational Masking in Listeners with Sensorineural Hearing Loss

Measures of energetic and informational masking were obtained from 46 listeners with sensorineural hearing loss. The task was to detect the presence of a sequence of eight contiguous 60-ms bursts of a pure tone embedded in masker bursts that were played synchronously with the signal. The masker was either a sequence of Gaussian noise bursts (energetic masker) or a sequence of random-frequency 2-tone bursts (informational masker). The 2-tone maskers were of two types: one type that normally tends to produce large amounts of informational masking and a second type that normally tends to produce very little informational masking. The two informational maskers are called "multiple-bursts same" (MBS), because the same frequency components are present in each burst of a sequence, and "multiple-bursts different" (MBD), because different frequency components are presented in each burst of a sequence. The difference in masking observed for these two maskers is thought to occur because the signal perceptually segregates from the masker in the MBD condition but fuses with the masker in MBS. In the present study, the effectiveness of the MBD masker, measured as the signal-to-masker ratio at masked threshold, increased with increasing hearing loss. In contrast, the signal-to-masker ratio at masked threshold for the MBS masker changed much less as a function of hearing loss. These results suggest that sensorineural hearing loss interferes with the ability of the listener to perceptually segregate individual components of complex sounds. The results from the energetic masking condition, which included critical ratio estimates for all listeners and auditory filter characteristics for a subset of the listeners, indicated that increasing hearing loss also reduced frequency selectivity at the signal frequency. Overall, these results suggest that the increased susceptibility to masking observed in listeners with sensorineural hearing loss is a consequence of both peripheral and central processes.     

Contralateral masking in cochlear implant users with residual hearing in the non-implanted ear

Contralateral masking was investigated in cochlear implant users with residual hearing in the non-implanted ear. Threshold elevations for acoustic probes were observed when electrical maskers were presented in the opposite ear. Also, threshold elevations for electrical probes were observed when acoustic contralateral maskers were presented. The amount of threshold shift expressed in decibels charge or decibels sound pressure level produced by either contralateral acoustic or electric maskers was within the range found in normal listeners for similar stimuli (i.e. 4-8 dB). There was a correlation between the sensation level of acoustic maskers and the maximum amount of masking observed which is consistent with data for normally hearing subjects. The width of the masking patterns was similar to that expected from forward masking patterns in severely sensorineurally impaired ears and implanted ears. The maximum amount of acoustic masking tended to occur for electrode positions that were more basal than expected from characteristic frequency positions. However, where a relatively high-frequency 4-kHz masker could be used, there was a good match between the characteristic frequency position of the maximum threshold elevation and that of the masker.     

Auditory time constants for off-frequency forward masking in normal-hearing and hearing-impaired listeners

Previous research has shown that frequency-specific estimates of auditory time constants for recovery from short-term adaptation can be made using a fixed-probe forward-masking procedure (Nelson & Freyman, 1987) if the masker and the probe stimuli are at the same frequency. This study examines the validity of time-constant estimates for off-frequency forward-masking conditions in which the masker frequency is below (900 Hz) or above (1100 Hz) the probe frequency (1000 Hz). Fixed-probe-level temporal masking functions were obtained from four normal-hearing and four hearing-impaired listeners. Auditory time constants were estimated with iterative least-squares procedures to derive parameter values for an exponential model of recovery from forward masking. After appropriate corrections were made for attenuation to the maskers provided by the auditory filter centered at the probe frequency, recovery from forward masking produced by either off-frequency or on-frequency maskers could be described by a single time constant. That time constant was around 50 ms in normal-hearing listeners and was larger in those hearing-impaired listeners who demonstrated moderate hearing loss at the probe frequency.     

Modulation detection interference in listeners with normal and impaired hearing.

Listeners were asked to detect amplitude modulation (AM) of a target (or signal) carrier that was presented in isolation or in the presence of an additional (masker) carrier. The signal was modulated at a rate of 10 Hz, and the masker was unmodulated or was modulated at a rate of 2, 10, or 40 Hz. Nine listeners had normal hearing, 4 had a bilateral hearing loss, and 4 had a unilateral hearing loss; those with a unilateral loss were tested in both ears. The listeners with a hearing loss had normal hearing at 1 kHz and a 30- to 40-dB loss at 4 kHz. The carrier frequencies were 984 and 3952 Hz. In one set of conditions, the lower frequency carrier was the signal and the higher frequency carrier was the masker. In the other set, the reverse was true. For the impaired ears, the carriers were presented at 70 dB SPL. For the normal ears, either the carriers were both presented at 70 dB SPL or the higher frequency carrier was reduced to 40 dB SPL to simulate the lower sensation level experienced by the impaired ears. There was considerable individual variability in the results, and there was no clear effect of hearing loss. These results suggest that a mild, presumably cochlear hearing loss does not affect the ability to process AM in one frequency region in the presence of competing AM from another region.     

Frequency specificity of ABR evaluated by tuning curves

A tone on tone simultaneous masking paradigm was used to determine tuning curves of ABR both from the normal and hearing-impaired subjects. ABR tuning curves were constructed to define masker intensity that resulted in a 50% reduction in probe elicited wave V amplitude. The frequency specificity of each probe stimulus was evaluated by Q10, low cut-off slope, high cut-off slope and the maximum masker frequency calculated for the tuning curves. The results were as follows; 1) Q10, low cut-off slope and high cut-off slope increased gradually with the increase in rise time. However, prolongations of the rise time beyond 3 cycles of probe frequency yielded little improvement in Q10, low cut-off slope and high cut-off slope. 2) Q10, low cut-off slope and high cut-off slope for normal-hearing subjects increased gradually with the increase in stimulus frequency or the decrease in stimulus pressure. Maximum masker frequency of the tuning curves was not always equal to the frequency of probe without the 2-kHz. For the 0.5, 1kHz probe, the maximum masker frequency of the tuning curves showed higher values than the frequency of probe. For the 4kHz probe, the maximum masker frequency of the tuning curves showed lower values than the frequency of probe. The results indicate that the tone pip stimuli will allow to assess certain conditions of auditory function at different frequencies, and they show wider frequencies' spread in the cochlea area near stimulus frequencies. 3) For subject with abrupt high-frequency hearing loss (30dB/oct), a pronounced down-ward shift of maximum masker frequency, down-ward shift of high cut-off slope and up-ward shift of low cut-off slope were found when the probe was placed in the region of elevated threshold. For subject with low-frequency hearing loss (25dB/oct), a pronounced up-ward shift of maximum masker frequency, down-ward shift of low cut-off slope were found. Maximum masker frequency, low and high cut-off slope of hearing-impaired subjects were not always equal to those of normal subjects for same probe. Especially the value of the maximum masker frequency shifted to the direction in which the most sensitive frequency was observed in audiogram. The threshold of ABR reflected the cochlea function of the most sensitive area near stimulus frequencies. Greatest predictive error was observed in steeply sloping audiograms.