Influence of contralateral stimulation by two-tone complexes,narrow-band and broad-band noise signals on the 2f1-f2 distortion product otoacoustic emission levels in humans

In order to test the frequency specificity of the efferent suppressive effect on otoacoustic emissions, changes in the 2f1-f2 distortion product otoacoustic emission (DPOAE) levels induced by contralateral stimuli of different spectra were measured in 10 normally hearing adults. Three types of contralateral stimuli were used: (i) a set of 6 pairs of pure tones with the same frequencies as used for DPOAE stimulation; (ii) 6 narrow-band noise signals with cut-off frequencies equal to the frequencies of the primary tones used for DPOAE stimulation; and (iii) broad-band noise with a bandwidth of 840-6,000 Hz. A small suppressive effect was observed mainly in the mid-frequency region. Broad-band noise was more effective at suppressing DPOAEs than narrow-band noises and two-tone complexes. Occasionally, small enhancements in DPOAE amplitudes were observed. Based on the results of this study, it is concluded that DPOAE changes induced by contralateral stimuli are not frequency-specific, and are too small to have routine clinical value.     

Influence of contralateral acoustic stimulation on distortion-product and spontaneous otoacoustic emissions in the barn owl

The avian auditory papilla provides an interesting object on which to study efferent influences, because whereas a significant population of hair cells in birds is not afferently innervated, all hair cells are efferently innervated (Fischer, 1992, 1994a, b). Previous studies in mammals using contralateral sound to stimulate the efferent system demonstrated a general suppressive effect on spontaneous and click-evoked, as well as on distortion-product otoacoustic emissions (DPOAE). As little is known about the effects of contralateral stimulation on hearing in birds, we studied the effect of such stimuli (broadband noise, pure tones) on the amplitude of the DPOAE 2f(1)-f(2) and on spontaneous otoacoustic emissions (SOAE) in the barn owl, Tyto alba. For the DPOAE measurements, fixed primary-tone pairs [f(1)=8.875 kHz (ratio=1.2), f(1)=8.353 kHz (ratio=1.15) and f(1)=7.889 kHz (ratio=1.1)] were presented and the DPOAE measured in the presence and absence of continuous contralateral stimulation. The DPOAE often declined in amplitude but in some cases we observed DPOAE enhancement. The changes in amplitude were as large as 9 dB. The influence of the contralateral noise changed over time, however, and the effects of contralateral tones were frequency-dependent. SOAE were suppressed in amplitude and shifted in frequency by contralateral broadband noise. Control measurements in animals after middle-ear muscle resection showed that these phenomena were not attributable to the acoustic middle-ear reflex. The finding of DPOAE enhancement is interesting, because a type of efferent fiber that suppressed its discharge rate during stimulation has been described in birds (Kaiser and Manley, 1994).     

耳声发射对侧抑制效应的频率特异性研究

目的　观察耳声发射对侧抑制效应是否有频率特异性。方法　分别测试７ 例正常人（１４耳） 畸变产物耳声发射（ＤＰＯＡＥ） 和２ 例正常人（２ 耳） 自发性耳声发射（ＳＯＡＥ） 的对侧抑制效应,对侧声刺激为窄带噪声（ＮＢＮ） 。结果　当对侧ＮＢＮ 中心频率等于ＤＰＯＡＥ 的初始音ｆ２ 频率和ＳＯＡＥ 频率时,ＤＰＯＡＥ 和ＳＯＡＥ 发生最大抑制。结论　本实验进一步表明耳声发射对侧抑制效应有频率特异性,提示内侧橄榄耳蜗系统和耳蜗外毛细胞参与了耳蜗频率特性的主动调谐过程,提高了耳蜗频率分辨率。文中讨论了频率特异性的发生机理     

Rapid adaptation of the 2f1-f2 DPOAE in humans: binaural and contralateral stimulation effects

The present data were collected in humans to characterize the effects of monaural and binaural stimulation and contralateral noise on the 2f1-f2 distortion-product otoacoustic emission (DPOAE) adaptation response. DPOAE levels (f2/f1=1.21, L1=70 dB SPL, L2=65 dB SPL) were measured in both ears for a range of f2 frequencies (1.2 to 10.0 kHz). The f2 frequency producing the largest amplitude DPOAE was used for further testing employing three different stimulus conditions: the primary tones were presented to only one ear for 4 s; the two tones were presented simultaneously in both ears; and, contralateral broadband noise (60 dB SPL) was presented for 5 s, beginning 4 s after the onset of the monaural primaries in the test ear. Acoustic reflex thresholds were measured to verify that the middle-ear muscles played no systematic role in the measured DPOAE reductions. Estimates of monaural rapid adaptation levels and time constants agreed well with previous human findings. The magnitude of the rapid adaptation under binaural stimulation, as compared with monaural primaries, was 25% greater on average, though adaptation time constants were comparable. With added contralateral noise, the average DPOAE suppression was 1.1 dB (0.3-2.7 dB). The magnitude of the monaural adaptation and the effects of binaural and contralateral stimulation, however, were smaller than those measured previously in experimental animals, though the time constants were in good agreement.     

畸变产物耳声发射对侧抑制效应的研究

利用ＩＬＯ９２耳动态分析仪，测试２３例（４６耳）正常青年人的畸变产物耳声发射（ＤＰＯＡＥ）和对侧窄带噪声（ＮＢＮ）的影响。结果：（１）对侧ＮＢＮ对ＤＰＯＡＥ的抑制非常明显，随ＮＢＮ强度增加ＤＰＯＡＥ幅值下降增加，二者呈显著负相关（Ｆ２为１～６ｋＨｚ，γ为－０．４９～－０．２４，均Ｐ〈０．０５，斜率０．２６～０．０８ｄＢ／１０ｄＢ）。（２）在Ｆ２为中频（１．２ｋＨｚ）且为中等强度（４５～６５ｄＢＳＰ     

Effects of electrical stimulation of the inferior colliculus on 2f1-f2 distortion product otoacoustic emissions in anesthetized guinea pigs

The effects of electrical stimulation of the inferior colliculus (IC) on the activation of olivocochlear nerve fibers were investigated in guinea pigs in which the 2f₁−f₂ distortion product otoacoustic emissions (DPOAE) were recorded. Animals were anesthetized with ketamine (33 mg/kg) and xylazine (6.6 mg/kg). Bipolar electrical stimulation of the IC by a train of pulses with currents less than the threshold for evoking muscle twitches resulted in a small depression of the DPOAE amplitude by 0.1–2 dB. The maximal effect was observed when the stimulating electrodes were located in the rostro-medial or ventral parts of the IC. The suppression of electrically evoked DPOAE was similar to the DPOAE suppression produced by acoustical stimulation of the contralateral ear by a broad-band noise. Suppression of DPOAE amplitude in response to both acoustical and electrical stimulation was abolished 1–2 h after a single intramuscular injection of gentamicin (210–250 mg/kg). The results indicate that electrical stimulation of the IC can activate the efferent system and produce DPOAE changes by similar mechanisms as does acoustical stimulation of the contralateral ear.     

豚鼠畸变产物耳声发射潜伏期的对侧抑制效应现象

目的 通过观察对侧抑制效应中畸变产物耳发射（distortion productotoacousticemissions,DPOAE)各指标的改变,探讨耳蜗生理机制及传出神经的调节机能。方法 12只健康杂色豚鼠分A、B2组,在对侧耳无声刺激及给予70dB SPL宽带噪声条件下,分别使用不同的原始纯音强度组合测定在f2＝2、4、6kHz时测试耳DPOAE之幅值及潜伏期。次日,A组动物背侧径路开放右耳听泡,圆窗膜给予60mmol/L卡因酸1μL,作用3h后拭去。给药后6h测试右耳无声刺激和给予70dB SPL宽带噪声刺激下,左耳的DPOAE幅值、潜伏期等指标。结果 ①用药前,A组对侧耳给声时以等强度原始音诱发的测试耳DPOAE各频率幅值与给声前基本无变化,而潜伏期显著延长;②用药前,B组对侧耳给声以差强度原始音（L2＝L1－10dB)诱发的测试耳DPOAE在2、4kHz的幅值与给声前相比有显著减小,潜伏期也显著延长;③A组用药后,对侧耳给声对测试耳DPOAE幅值和潜伏期均无显著影响。结论 潜伏期亦是对侧抑制研究中的敏感指标。对侧抑制效应在调制耳蜗转导机制中发挥负反馈作用。     

Distortion-product otoacoustic emission (DPOAE) following pure tone and wide-band noise exposures

The aim of our investigations was to determine how the intensity of distortion-product otoacoustic emission (DPOAE) changes following different sound and noise exposures. We performed examinations on 20 healthy people with normal hearing. DPOAEs were recorded scanning the 0.5-6 kHz frequency interval before and after the exposures. We exposed the subjects to 0.5, 1, 2, 4 and 6 kHz pure tones and wide-band noise (intensity: 80 dB HL, duration: 3 minutes). We conclude that the amplitudes of DPOAEs changed immediately after exposures at most frequencies. DPOAE intensities decreased at some frequencies in the middle frequency range (1-2 kHz), and increased at low and particularly at high frequencies.     

Attention effects on distortion-product otoacoustic emissions with contralateral speech stimuli

This study investigated the effect of selective attention on the distortion-product otoacoustic emission (DPOAE) level through the use of environmentally meaningful, contralateral auditory stimuli. Four different conditions were used for measurement: quiet, contralateral noise, contralateral speech (unattended), and contralateral speech (attended). A statistically significant suppression effect for both the noise and speech conditions was found. However, there was no support for an auditory selective attention effect on the distortion-product amplitude.     

Physiological Mechanisms of Onset Adaptation and Contralateral Suppression of DPOAEs in the Rat

An investigation was undertaken to measure medial olivocochlear (MOC) reflexes in anesthetized rats before and after sectioning of the middle-ear muscles. Distortion product otoacoustic emission (DPOAE) magnitude and phase temporal responses were measured ipsilaterally to study MOC-mediated "DPOAE onset adaptation" and in the presence of a contralateral noise to study MOC-mediated contralateral "suppression" (terms as used by previous researchers). Distortion product otoacoustic emission onset adaptation and contralateral suppression had predictable changes in direction of magnitude and phase that were dependent on the input-output function. After sectioning of the middle-ear muscles (MEMs), DPOAE onset adaptation and contralateral suppression were greatly reduced, and there were little, if any, changes in phase. These "residual" changes were interpreted as a result of the MOC reflex. The results suggest that what appears to be DPOAE onset adaptation and contralateral suppression can be mediated primarily by MEM reflexes. When studying MOC effects on otoacoustic emissions (OAEs) using acoustic stimulation, it is necessary to make recordings over a span of stimulus levels. In addition, looking at both magnitude and phase of the OAE may help separate what is due to the MOC reflex from MEM reflex.     

Effects of contralateral white noise stimulation on distortion product otoacoustic emissions in myasthenic patients.

Myasthenia gravis (MG) induces a reduction of transient evoked otoacoustic emissions (TEOAEs) and distortion product otoacoustic emissions (DPOAEs) that reverses partially after administration of an acetylcholinesterase (AChE) inhibitor. In normal subjects a contralateral acoustic stimulation (CAS) produces an amplitude reduction of TEOAEs and DPOAEs. This effect, called contralateral suppression (CS), is mediated by the efferent auditory system. Twenty subjects affected by MG underwent DPOAE recording with and without contralateral white noise in a drug-free baseline period ('basal') and 1 h ('post') after administration of a reversible AChE inhibitor. In 'basal' condition CAS did not induce significant DPOAE amplitude changes but a paradoxical slight increase was observed. After drug administration, CAS produced a significant decrease of DPOAE amplitudes for middle frequencies (f(2) between 1306 and 2600 Hz). In normal controls CAS caused a significant decrease (P<0.001) for all frequencies. The amount of CS in controls and in the MG 'post' condition was not significantly different. The increased acetylcholine (ACh) availability following drug consumption seems to partially restore outer hair cell function and enhances their electromotility; a further influx of ACh due to CAS yields to restoration of the CS. These findings also suggest that DPOAEs may be useful in the diagnosis of MG and for monitoring the effectiveness of treatment.     

Effect of efferent-induced changes on acoustical reflex

The efferent auditory pathway is known to alter the cochlear electrical properties, at low stimulus levels. This study aims to identify the effect of activation of the efferent auditory pathway through contralateral wide- and narrow-band noise at high sound levels. Acoustical reflex threshold and acoustical reflex amplitude (at ART + 10 dB) were obtained at three frequencies (500 Hz, 1 kHz, 2 kHz) in 60 normally hearing subjects, in the presence and absence of contralateral wide-and narrow-band noise (centred around reflex activating stimuli) at 30 dB SL. Results showed a consistent reduction in amplitude, and an increase in threshold, for 1- and 2-kHz tones in the presence of contralateral wideband but not narrow-band noise. Results are discussed with reference to the electrical properties of the cochlea, and the response properties of the efferent auditory pathway and cochlear nucleus.     

Distortion product otoacoustic emissions: comparison of sequential vs. simultaneous presentation of primary tones

Distortion product otoacoustic emissions are one form of evoked otoacoustic emissions. DPOAEs provide the frequency specific information about the hearing status in mid and high frequency regions. But in most screening protocols TEOAEs are preferred as it requires less time compared to DPOAE. This is because, in DPOAE each stimulus is presented one after the other and responses are analyzed. Grason and Stadler Incorporation 60 (GSI-60) offer simultaneous presentation of four sets of primary tones at a time and checks for the DPOAE. In this mode of presentation, all the pairs are presented at a time and following that response is extracted separately whereas, in sequential mode primaries are presented in orderly fashion one after the other. In this article simultaneous and sequential protocols were used to compare the Distortion product otoacoustic emission amplitude, noise floor and administration time in individuals with normal hearing and mild sensori-neural (SN) hearing loss. In simultaneous protocols four sets of primary tones (i.e. 8 tones) were presented together whereas, in sequential presentation mode one set of primary tones was presented each time. Simultaneous protocol was completed in less than half the time required for the completion of sequential protocol. Two techniques yielded similar results at frequencies above 1000 Hz only in normal hearing group. In SN hearing loss group simultaneous presentation yielded signifi cantly higher noise floors and distortion product amplitudes. This result challenges the use of simultaneous presentation technique in neonatal hearing screening programmes and on other pathologies. This discrepancy between two protocols may be due to some changes in biomechanical process in the cochlear and/or due to higher distortion/noise produced by the system during the simultaneous presentation mode.     

Occupational exposure to noise decreases otoacoustic emission efferent suppression

With the discovery of otoacoustic emissions (OAEs), the efferent cochlear system has become accessible for investigation in humans. Recently, it has been suggested that contralateral sound activated OAE efferent suppression may provide an early indication of auditory damage due to exposure to noise. In this study, OAE efferent suppression in normally hearing subjects, occupationally exposed to noise, was compared with respective effects in healthy, non-exposed subjects. The noise-exposed group exhibited higher mean hearing thresholds at frequencies 4, 6 and 10 kHz (p < 0.01) and lower-level transient-evoked otoacoustic emission (TEOAE) and distortion-product otoacoustic emission (DPOAE) at a frequency of 4 kHz (not significant). TEOAE efferent suppression was moderately decreased, whereas DPOAE efferent suppression was negligible, in the exposed group compared to non-exposed subjects. The results of the study suggest that OAEs, particularly DPOAE contralateral suppression, are likely to become a valuable method for assessing early hearing damage caused by exposure to noise.     

畸变产物耳声发射测试对噪声性聋诊断的敏感度和特异度

目的 探讨畸变产物耳声发射测试对噪声性聋的诊断价值。方法 对115名军人（204耳）进行DPOAE幅值测试,采用两个等强度L1＝L2＝70dB SPL的纯音信号f1、f2＝1．2。测试1、2、4kHz和6kHz DPOAE幅值,根据DPOAE幅值是否大于或小于标准值,判断听力正常与否。并同纯音听阈进行对照。结果 1、2、4和6kHz各频率的敏感度分别是70％、67％、85％和73％;特异度分别是71％、66％、84％和75％。结论 DPOAE幅值测试用于诊断噪声性聋,缺乏足够的敏感性和特异性,单一的DPOAE幅值测试,不能诊断噪声性聋。     

Olivocochlear reflex effect on human distortion product otoacoustic emissions is largest at frequencies with distinct fine structure dips

Activity of the medial olivocochlear efferents can be inferred by measuring the change of the level of distortion product otoacoustic emissions (DPOAE) during ipsilateral or contralateral acoustic stimulation, the so-called medial olivocochlear reflex (MOCR). A limitation of this measurement strategy, however, is the distinct variability of MOCR values depending on DPOAE primary tone levels and frequency, which makes selection of the stimulus parameters difficult. The objective of this study was to evaluate the dependence of MOCR values on DPOAE fine structure in humans. MOCR during contralateral acoustic stimulation was measured at frequencies with distinct non-monotonicity ("dip") in the DPOAE fine structure, and in frequencies with flat fine structure. One hundred and twenty one different primary tone level combinations were used (L(1)=50-60dB SPL, L(2)=35-45dB SPL, 1dB steps). The measurement was repeated on another day. The major findings were: (1) Largest MOCR effects can be found in frequencies which exhibit a distinct dip in DPOAE fine structure. (2) Primary tone levels have a critical influence on the magnitude of the MOCR effect. MOCR changes of up to 23dB following a L(1) change of only 1dB were observed. Averages of the maximum MOCR change per 1dB step were in the 3-5dB-range. Both findings can be interpreted in the light of the DPOAE two-generator model [Heitmann, J., Waldmann, B., Schnitzler, H.U., Plinkert, P.K., Zenner, H.P. 1998. Suppression of distortion product otoacoustic emissions (DPOAE) near 2f1-f2 removes DP-gram fine structure - evidence for a secondary generator. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 103, 1527-1531]. According to the present results we propose, that assessing MOCR specifically at frequencies with a distinct dip in the DPOAE fine structure, in combination with fine variation of the stimulus tone levels, allows for a more targeted search for maximum MOCR effects. Future studies must show if this approach can contribute to the further clarification of the physiological roles of the olivocochlear efferents.     

Effects of contralateral sound on auditory-nerve responses. I. Contributions of cochlear efferents

The response properties of single auditory-nerve fibers in barbiturate-anaesthetized cats were recorded with and without simultaneous presentation of sound to the contralateral ear. The tendons to the middle ear muscles on both sides were cut before all experiments, and contralateral stimuli were restricted to levels below the threshold for crosstalk to the ipsilateral ear. Contralateral tones and broad-band noise were found to suppress the responses of auditory-nerve afferents to ipsilateral tones at their characteristic frequency (CF), but not to tones off CF. The suppression due to contralateral sound required approximately 100-200 ms to develop and to decay. When the contralateral stimuli were tones at the CF, the strongest suppression was observed in low- and medium-spontaneous-rate units with CFs between 1 and 2 kHz. The suppressive effect of contralateral sound completely disappeared immediately after severing the entire olivocochlear bundle (OCB) within the internal auditory meatus. the completeness of the OCB cuts was assessed histologically. Most of the suppressive effect remained after lesions to the OCB in the floor of the IVth ventricle which eliminated the crossed olivocochlear projection but spared most of the uncrossed projection. It is argued that this suppressive effect of contralateral sound is mediated by the uncrossed olivocochlear efferents to the outer hair cells.     

Assessment of the medial olivocochlear efferent system in children. pure tone 1.0 kHz and 2.0 kHz suppressive effects on transient evoked otoacoustic emission

The role of medial efferent system in regulating outer hair cell function has been studied by many investigators. Usually narrow band noise or white noise as contralateral stimulation (CS) suppressors have been used and changes in OAE amplitudes estimated. Thirty children aged 6-15 years (mean 12.5 +/- 4.7), without any changes in tonal and impedance audiometry and with negative history regarding otiatric diseases were examined. Transient evoked otoacoustic emissions (TEOAE) were recorded using ILO 92 Otodynamics Analyser. CS was performed using 1.0 kHz and 2.0 kHz continuous pure tones of 30 dB SL or 50 dB SL. Effects of CS on TEOAE evoked by click of 80, 70 and 60 dB SPL were investigated. TEOAE analysis included assessment of TEOAE amplitude of half octave frequency bandwidth (HOFBW-1.0; HOFBW-1.5; HOFBW-2.0; HOFBW-3.0 and HOFBW-4.0 kHz) and 0.8 kHz frequency bandwidth (0.8-FBW) amplitudes centred at 1.0; 2.0; 3.0; 4.0 and 5.0 kHz. TEOAE amplitude recorded for stimuli 80, 70 and 60 dB SPL without CS decreased: mean values respectively 6.1 +/- 4.2; 5.4 +/- 4.5 and 3.3 dB SPL +/- 4.3. CS effect on TEOAE was observed for all CS options, however, larger suppressive effect was recorded on TEOAE elicited by 70 dB SPL stimulus using 1 kHz/50 dB SL tone as a suppressor and on TEOAE elicited by 60 dB SPL stimulus using 2 kHz/50 dB SL tone as a suppressor. HOFBW and 0.8-FBW analyses showed the association between the frequency/intensity of the suppressors and decreasing of amplitudes of adequate frequency bands. It is concluded that the described method of investigating of the medial olivocochlear efferent system seems to be sensitive and confirms frequency-dependent suppressive effect on OAE.     

Age-related declines in distortion product otoacoustic emissions utilizing pure tone contralateral stimulation in CBA/CaJ mice

One role of the medial olivocochlear (MOC) auditory efferent system is to suppress cochlear outer hair cell (OHC) responses when presented with a contralateral sound. Using distortion product otoacoustic emissions (DPOAEs), the effects of active changes in OHC responses due to the MOC as a function of age can be observed when contralateral stimulation with a pure tone is applied. Previous studies have shown that there are age-related declines of the MOC when broad band noise is presented to the contralateral ear. In this study, we measured age-related changes in CBA/CaJ mice by comparing DPOAE generation with and without a contralateral pure tone at three different frequencies (12, 22, and 37 kHz). Young (n = 16), middle (n = 10) and old-aged (n = 10) CBA mice were tested. DPOAE-grams were obtained using L1 = 65 and L2 = 50 dB SPL, F1/F2 = 1.25, using eight points per octave covering a frequency range from 5.6-44.8 kHz. The pure tone was presented contralaterally at 55 dB SPL. DPOAE-grams and ABR levels indicated age-related hearing loss in the old mice. In addition, there was an overall change in DPOAEs in the middle-aged and old groups relative to the young. Pure tone stimulation was not as effective as a suppressor compared to broadband noise. An increase in pure tone frequency from 12 to 22 kHz induced greater suppression of DPOAEs, but the 37 kHz was least effective. These results indicate that as the mouse ages, there are significant changes in the efficiency of the suppression mechanism as elicited by contralateral narrowband stimuli. These findings reinforce the idea that age-related changes in the MOC or the operating points of OHCs play a role in the progression of presbycusis - age-related hearing loss in mammals.     

Contralateral suppression of distortion product otoacoustic emissions and the middle-ear muscle reflex in human ears

Distortion product otoacoustic emissions (DPOAEs) were measured in the absence and presence of contralateral noise at five levels--below, equal to, and above the middle-ear muscle (MEM) reflex threshold. The resultant changes in DPOAE level and phase were dependent on stimulus frequency and noise level. Both low-level noise, believed to elicit the medial olivocochlear (MOC) reflex, and high-level noise, thought to activate both MOC and MEM reflexes, significantly decreased the DPOAE level. However, the shift from sole MOC effect to mixed MOC and MEM effects was not as dramatic as we thought. While low-level noise resulted in a minimum DPOAE phase change, high-level noise caused a substantial phase lead for 1 and 2kHz. With increasing frequency, phase lag became more notable. The present study suggests the following: (1) DPOAE contralateral suppression by low-level sound most likely does not involve the effect of the MEM reflex and signal crossover; and (2) combined analysis of DPOAE level and phase changes warrants further investigations to overcome the difficulty in separating the effects of MOC efferents and MEM contraction. The results also imply that OAE measurement has the potential for being used to investigate the effect of the MEM reflex on sound transmission.