Assessing the quality of psychiatric care: research methods and application in clinical practice

The drive to contain the costs of health care in the United States is focusing attention on how quality of care is affected. This article discusses research methods for assessing the quality of psychiatric care and reviews findings from some major studies evaluating care. These findings are mixed, highlighting areas in which quality of care is less than optimal, as well as the importance of continued research and the need to develop better research methods. Evidence-based criteria and more-sensitive risk-adjustment techniques must be employed if data on quality are to yield fair comparisons among health plans. The challenge is to refine the methods now in use at both the research and clinical levels, so that better-quality assessments can be made for policy formulation, physician education, and consumer choice.     

Regression-Based Norms for the Brief Visuospatial Memory Test-Revised in Italian population and application in MS patients

Abstract

Objective: The Brief Visuospatial Memory Test-Revised (BVMT-R) is one of the most widely used tests for the assessment of learning and memory in the visual/spatial domain. The aim of this study was to use multiple regression to derive normative data for the use of BVMT-R in an Italian population. Method: We employed a regression-based norms procedure to maximally utilize a relatively small sample while controlling for a variety of demographic factors in addition to age. Additionally, we used these norms to compare the performance of Italian healthy controls with patients diagnosed with multiple sclerosis (MS), thereby providing evidence of the method’s validity. Results: A total of 200 healthy volunteers and 70 MS patients participated in this study and completed the BVMT-R according to the published procedures. Regression-based norms were generated for the Italian sample and are presented herein. Conclusions: Using these norms, the performance of the MS patients was found to be significantly worse than that of the controls.     

Virtual Week: Translation and adaptation for the Italian population

The present study adapted a computerised version of Virtual Week, a laboratory measure of prospective memory designed to simulate the kinds of prospective memory tasks encountered in daily life. In particular, this study aimed to translate and adapt Virtual Week for an Italian population. We collected data from 198 subjects that were divided into five groups based on age: young-young adults (20–29 years, n?=?47), young adults (30–45 years, n?=?32), middle-age adults (46–59 years, n?=?32), young-old adults (60–69 years, n?=?41), and old-old adults (70 years plus, n?=?39). Results showed that PM performance was best in younger adults, relatively stable over middle adulthood and then decreased with age, with older adults performing the least accurately, in particular for the time-based condition. Results also demonstrated good reliability estimates across a range of ages and task types. Thus, the adaptation of Virtual Week into Italian appears to be a reliable measure of prospective memory for the Italian population.     

Friedreich's disease: survival analysis in an Italian population

This investigation is the first population-based study of survival in Friedreich's disease (FD). All cases of FD diagnosed between 1945 through 1984 among residents of a defined area of northwestern Italy were ascertained (N = 58). These patients were followed to death or to December 31, 1984 (whichever came first) to determine the patterns of survival. The 10-, 20-, and 30-year survival rates were respectively 96%, 80%, and 61%, suggesting a better prognosis than previously reported. Survival of FD patients was poorer than expected from the general population. Survival for males was poorer than for females even after adjustment for expected survival. Age of onset was not a significant prognostic factor. Survival for patients diagnosed in 1960 or later was better than for those diagnosed before 1960; however, the difference was not statistically significant.     

Headache in immigrant patients: similarities and differences with Italian population

Headache is one of the most common neurological diseases. It is well known that there are differences in the perception and in the management of pain in various populations. Immigrants represent a growing portion between neurology outpatients. We analyzed the epidemiological characteristic of headache in immigrants come to our attention, in comparison with Italians. Data collected included age at immigration, age of onset of headache, headache’s type (HIS criteria), and psychiatric comorbidities. There were not substantial differences in the incidence of headache subtypes: migraine was the most frequent diagnosis in both groups, followed by tension-type headache. The incidence of depression was similar, while anxiety was significantly less frequent in immigrants. Studies on neurological diseases in immigrants are few. The data available seem to show no differences in the incidence, but rather in treatment. Our study confirms the evenness of two populations, local and foreign, afferent in a Headache Unit, according to the single similar study, except for anxiety, maybe related to language difficulties or cultural background.     

Objectives and methodology: Guidelines of the Italian Society for Haemostasis and Thrombosis (SISET)

A current goal of the Italian Society for Thrombosis and Haemostasis (SISET) is the production of guidelines for clinical conditions related to haemostasis and thrombosis. In 2006, the Executive Committee of SISET adopted a new program for the production of methodologically and scientifically sound guidelines aimed at both addressing clinical practice and stimulating new research. The first major step for this program was to train methodologists to manage working groups that compose the guidelines, and to create a reference document that describes the development of the program. The aim of the present paper is to report a short version of this methodological document, for those who wish to follow SISET guidelines. We start by giving a brief outline of the SISET mission, then present the SISET guideline development process, which includes: project funding, selection of guidelines topics, multidisciplinary group composition, definition of clinical questions, literature search, evidence appraisal, grading recommendations, guideline implementation, external peer review, and guideline updating.     

Model of neuropathic intermittent claudication in the rat: methodology and application

In the present study we characterize a rat neurogenic intermittent claudication model which was accomplished by placing two pieces of silicone rubber of various sizes into the lumbar (L4 and L6) epidural space. After induction of spinal stenosis walking function was measured using a treadmill apparatus and sensory functions were tested by measuring thermal and tactile withdrawal threshold (von Frey filaments) for the period of 28 days after stenosis. In addition, local spinal cord blood flow (SCBF) was measured, periodically, before and after induction of stenosis using laser Doppler. After implantation of two pieces of silicone rubber (width 1.25 mm, height 1.0 mm, length 4.0 mm) a significant running dysfunction, as evidenced by shortening of running distance, was measured as soon as 24 h after stenosis (178.5+/-59.1 m vs 681.3+/-70.2 m). This effect persisted for 28 days after surgery. Similarly, a significant tactile (but not thermal) hypersensitivity was measured for a period of 28 days (1.2+/-0.3 g vs 14.9+/-0.2 g). In this experimental group the measurement of local SCBF revealed a significant (30-50%) reduction in the territory of spinal stenosis measured at 3,7,14 or 28 days after surgery. Implantation of larger pieces of silicon rubber (1.5 mm width) caused a significant increase in the incidence of urinary retention and mortality rate. These data show that chronic partial spinal compression at L4 and L6 spinal level lead to the development of significant motor/sensory dysfunction which resemble those seen in patients with neurogenic intermittent claudication. The lack of motor dysfunction under resting conditions but its appearance during forced exercise also suggest that the development of local spinal ischemia can represent one of the mechanisms.     

Clinical and genetic study of essential tremor in the Italian population

Essential tremor (ET) is one of the most common movement disorders. The pathogenesis is as yet unknown, although a genetic cause has long been recognised. Clinical and molecular evidence suggested that the ET gene contains a CAG expanded region. We examined a cohort of 240 Italian ET patients, classified as familial (193 cases) and sporadic (47 cases). The clinical manifestations of ET patients confirmed that the disorder is characterised by a large phenotypic variability. Repeat expansion detection (RED) approach did not demonstrate large CAG expansions. Six families were genotyped with 12 microsatellites markers of 2p and 3q regions and analysed according to parametrical methods. Lod scores values obtained in these families excluded the association of ET with 2p and 3q loci. Our findings confirm the presence of genetic heterogeneity and suggest that at least a third locus is involved in the pathogenesis of familial essential tremor.     

Associations between former exposure to manganese and olfaction in an elderly population: Results from the Heinz Nixdorf Recall Study

Occupational exposure to manganese (Mn) has been associated with impairments in olfaction and motor functions, but it has yet to be determined if such effects persist upon cessation of exposure. The objective of this study was to evaluate the influence of former occupational Mn exposure on olfaction within the framework of a prospective cohort study among an elderly German population. Information on job tasks with recognized Mn exposure and data on odor identification assessed with Sniffin’ sticks was collected during the second follow-up of the Heinz Nixdorf Recall Study. The study population consisted of 1385 men aged 55–86 years, 354 of whom ever worked in jobs with potential Mn exposure (median 58.3 μg/m³ years, interquartile range 19.0–185 μg/m³ years). Multiple exposure measures, including job tasks, cumulative Mn exposure, and Mn determined in blood samples (MnB) archived at baseline, were used to estimate effects of Mn on olfaction. Having ever worked as welder was associated with better olfaction compared to other blue-collar workers without Mn exposure. Blue-collar workers identified less odors in comparison to white-collar workers. Concentrations of previous Mn exposure >185 μg/m³ years or MnB ≥15 μg/L were not associated with impaired olfaction. In addition to a strong age effect, participants with lower occupational qualification identified less odors. We found no relevant association of former Mn exposure at relatively low levels with impaired olfaction. Possible neurotoxic Mn effects may not be persistent after cessation.     

SNCA and MAPT genes: Independent and joint effects in Parkinson disease in the Italian population

BackgroundSignificant efforts have been focused on investigating the contribution of common variants to Parkinson disease (PD) risk. Several independent GWAS and metanalysis studies have shown a genome-wide significant association of single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in the α-synuclein (SNCA) and microtubule-associated protein tau (MAPT) regions. Here we investigated the role of SNCA and MAPT as PD susceptibility genes in a large Italian population of 904 patients and 891 controls. An evaluation of gene–gene and gene-environment interactions in association with PD was also attempted.MethodsThe SNCA Rep1 microsatellite was genotyped by a fluorescent PCR assay, whereas the SNPlex genotyping system was used to genotype 12 additional markers across the SNCA gene, and 2 SNPs tagging the risk MAPT H1 haplotype.ResultsSingle-marker analysis demonstrated nominal evidence of association for: i) the 261-bp-long allele of Rep1; ii) 7 SNPs in the SNCA region (top SNP: rs356186, P = 3.08 × 10^?04, intron 4); iii) both SNPs identifying the MAPT H1 haplotype (P = 4.63 × 10^?04 and P = 4.23 × 10^?04 for rs1800547 and rs9468, respectively). Moreover, we found a highly significant protective haplotype spanning ～83 kb from intron 4 to the 3′ end of SNCA (P = 1.29 × 10^?05).ConclusionsOur findings strongly confirm SNCA and MAPT as major PD susceptibility genes for idiopathic PD in the Italian population. Interaction analyses did not evidence either epistatic effects between the two loci or gene-environment interactions.     

Relapse during a 6-month continuation treatment with fluvoxamine in an Italian population: the role of clinical, psychosocial and genetic variables

The efficacy of SSRIs in relapse prevention in major depression has been extensively demonstrated. Considering published data, the relapse rate during a psychopharmacological continuation treatment ranges from 10% to 30%. Since the reasons of depressive relapses could be heterogeneous, we have tested the effect of clinical, psychosocial and genetic variables in sustained remission from an index depressive episode during continuation treatment with fluvoxamine over a 6-month follow-up period. 101 patients maintained the same full dosage treatment after remission from a depressive episode efficaciously treated with fluvoxamine. During the follow-up period, they were clinical assessed monthly by an experienced psychiatrist and SASS was administered, to assess their psychosocial adjustment. From a genetical point of view, SERTPR and CLOCK polymorphisms were analyzed for each patients, using PCR-based techniques. At the end of follow-up period, the 57.4% of the patients maintained remission during fluvoxamine continuation treatment; the 8.9% relapsed within the first 2 months of continuation; the 7.9% switched and the 25.8% dropped-out for poor compliance. Relapsed subjects presented a significantly longer mean duration of the index depressive episode than non-relapsed subjects and a subjective poor social adjustment than non-relapsed also in the euthymia period. None of the analyzed polymorphisms significantly appear to influence the outcome of the whole sample. The present data confirm that patients with severe depression and a long duration of the episode have a major risk of psychosocial disability. These patients could need a different psychopharmacological strategies and peculiar psychological intervention.     

Mini-Mental State Examination: a normative study in Italian elderly population

The Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE), a brief test to assess cognitive status, is heavily influenced by age and education. It was administered to 1019 elderly subjects (aged 65–89 years) living in three different Italian cities. A statistical non-linear regression model was built up in order to obtain adjustment coefficients to reduce the influence of demographic variables on the MMSE raw scores. Age and educational level were significantly and independently associated with the MMSE score. Results of a multiple linear regression with transformation of age and education provided adjustment coefficients of the MMSE raw scores. Data from this study will ameliorate the overall reliability of MMSE as a screening test for cognitive impairment in elderly people.     

Rey-Osterrieth complex figure: normative values in an Italian population sample

The Rey-Osterrieth complex figure test (ROCF) is a neuropsychological test extensively used in clinical practice to investigate visuospatial constructional functions, visuographic memory and some aspects of planning and executive function. The aim of the present study was to collect normative values in an Italian normal population sample (n=280) for the direct copying and delayed (10 min) reproduction of the ROCF. Multiple regression analysis revealed significant effects of age and education on performance of both copying tasks, whereas sex appeared to affect only performance on the delayed copying task. Inferential cut-offs have been determined and equivalent scores computed. The availability of equivalent scores for the ROCF will prove useful in clinical assessment since it allows the comparison of a subject's performance on the ROCF with that on other neuropsychological tests for which normative values collected with similar methods are already available for the Italian population. Received: 23 November 2001 / Accepted in revised form: 12 December 2001     

Kleptomania: clinical features and comorbidity in an Italian sample.

Kleptomania, listed in DSM-IV as an impulse control disorder not elsewhere classified, is a psychiatric condition still poorly understood and subject of only a few systematic studies. The aim of this research was, therefore, to evaluate the clinical features and comorbidity of Italian patients with a DSM-IV diagnosis of kleptomania. Twenty outpatients with a lifetime diagnosis of kleptomania by DSM-IV criteria, were included in the study and underwent a specially designed semistructured interview and the Family History Research Diagnostic Criteria. The majority of patients reported an early and abrupt onset and an episodic course of the disorder, with no gender preponderance. Lifetime comorbidity for other axis I disorders was high, in particular for mood, anxiety, and impulse control disorders. Family history also showed a high prevalence of psychiatric disorders. Our study indicates clear connections between kleptomania and different psychiatric disorders, the exact nature of which has yet to be clarified.     

Schizophrenia in real life: courses, symptoms and functioning in an Italian population

Background

In the general belief, schizophrenia is associated with the concepts of seriousness, incurability, dangerousness: this is incorrect. In recent decades, the interest in course studies increased and different trends emerged, not necessarily chronic, with the possibility of remission. The plan of this research was to draw a picture of the schizophrenia syndrome in a specific geographic area, in the past and at present time: this allows to detect needs, weaknesses and strengths, for a better planning of future interventions.

Methods

The course of all cases diagnosed as schizophrenia (N?=?1,759) in the period 1978?C2008, was retrospectively studied in the entire population of an Italian province by observing, for a mean period of 12 years per person, age at first psychiatric consultation, number and length of admissions for both acute symptoms and residential-rehabilitation programs, number of interventions in outpatients. The cases under treatment (N?=?842), were evaluated in terms of symptoms, using the Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale, and in terms of functioning, using the Personal and Social Functioning Scale.

Results

The disease course differs significantly between genders: males have an earlier age at first consultation (about 7 years earlier), higher admission rates, greater number of outpatient interventions and personal and social functioning significantly worse. Hospitalization resulted often unnecessary: 23.1% of cases were never hospitalized and 67.2% spent less than one week per year in hospital. A quarter of the cases meets the international criteria for remission and more than 75% are asymptomatic or mildly symptomatic; only 5.3% of cases shows severe symptoms. However, Personal and Social Functioning highlights, in about 1/3 of cases, relevant or serious problems mainly in Work and Relationships areas, whilst Aggressiveness is a serious problem only in 9%.

Conclusions

In this population, schizophrenia in real life shows great individual variability in course, symptoms and functioning: in most cases nowadays it appears a less severe and chronic disease than in the past, but further improvements are needed on disability prevention and social inclusion.