Restriction fragment length polymorphisms within proximal 15q and their use in molecular cytogenetics and the Prader-Willi syndrome

Restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLPs) are described in detail for 6 DNA probes (D15S9-13, D15S18) that localize to the proximal long arm of human chromosome 15 (15q11-15q13: this report and Tantravahi et al., Am. J. Med. Genet. 33:78-87. Multiple RFLPs are detected by the probe that identifies locus D15S13, and these RFLPs are shown by genomic mapping to result from a nearby insertion or deletion of 1.8 kilobases (kb) of DNA. This set of RFLPs detected by proximal 15q probes can be used for studies on the Prader-Willi syndrome (PWS) and on mentally retarded individuals with a supernumerary inv dup(15) chromosome. Five of the polymorphic loci (D15S9-13) map to the region implicated in the cause of the PWS (15q11.2-15q12). Each of 4 families tested with these probes, as well as an additional "PWS-like" patient, was informative by RFLP analysis. The two PWS deletions studied, which occurred de novo, were inherited from the chromosome 15 provided by the father. By contrast, the 2 inv dup(15) chromosomes analyzed were of maternal origin. The use of RFLPs can also simplify the molecular determination of copy number in chromosomal aneuploidy, as exemplified by analysis of individuals with the PWS and a deletion, patients with an inv dup(15), and one patient with a more complex rearrangement involving chromosome 15. Our studies demonstrate the application of DNA probes for both molecular cytogenetic studies on this chromosome region and the development of diagnostic molecular markers to aid early clinical diagnosis of the PWS.     

A case of an atypically large proximal 15q deletion as cause for Prader–Willi syndrome arising from a de novo unbalanced translocation

We describe an 11 month old female with Prader–Willi syndrome (PWS) resulting from an atypically large deletion of proximal 15q due to a de novo 3;15 unbalanced translocation. The 10.6 Mb deletion extends from the chromosome 15 short arm and is not situated in a region previously reported as a common distal breakpoint for unbalanced translocations. There was no deletion of the reciprocal chromosome 3q subtelomeric region detected by either chromosomal microarray or FISH. The patient has hypotonia, failure to thrive, and typical dysmorphic facial features for PWS. The patient also has profound global developmental delay consistent with an expanded, more severe, phenotype.     

Unique and atypical deletions in Prader-Willi syndrome reveal distinct phenotypes

Prader-Willi syndrome (PWS) is a multisystem, contiguous gene disorder caused by an absence of paternally expressed genes within the 15q11.2-q13 region via one of the three main genetic mechanisms: deletion of the paternally inherited 15q11.2-q13 region, maternal uniparental disomy and imprinting defect. The deletion class is typically subdivided into Type 1 and Type 2 based on their proximal breakpoints (BP1-BP3 and BP2-BP3, respectively). Despite PWS being a well-characterized genetic disorder the role of the specific genes contributing to various aspects of the phenotype are not well understood. Methylation-specific multiplex ligation-dependent probe amplification (MS-MLPA) is a recently developed technique that detects copy number changes and aberrant DNA methylation. In this study, we initially applied MS-MLPA to elucidate the deletion subtypes of 88 subjects. In our cohort, 32 had a Type 1 and 49 had a Type 2 deletion. The remaining seven subjects had unique or atypical deletions that were either smaller (n=5) or larger (n=2) than typically described and were further characterized by array-based comparative genome hybridization. In two subjects both the PWS region (15q11.2) and the newly described 15q13.3 microdeletion syndrome region were deleted. The subjects with a unique or an atypical deletion revealed distinct phenotypic features. In conclusion, unique or atypical deletions were found in ～8% of the deletion subjects with PWS in our cohort. These novel deletions provide further insight into the potential role of several of the genes within the 15q11.2 and the 15q13.3 regions.     

Analysis of the Prader-Willi syndrome chromosome region using quantitative microsphere hybridization (QMH) array

We previously developed a novel quantitative microsphere suspension hybridization (QMH) assay for high-throughput determination of genomic copy number by direct hybridization of unique sequence probes to genomic DNA followed by flow cytometric analysis. Herein, we describe the first clinical application of this assay examining the Prader-Willi syndrome (PWS) chromosome region at 15q11-13. We designed 30 unique sequence test probes (approximately 60 nucleotides each) spanning 11.37 Mb of chromosome 15q11.2-q13.3 and a disomic reference probe (Actin Beta, chromosome 7p22.1), conjugated to spectrally distinct polystyrene microsphere levels. All probes were hybridized to biotin-labeled genomic DNA in multiplex QMH reactions, and hybridization was detected using phycoerythrin-labeled streptavidin and analyzed by dual-laser flow cytometry. Copy number differences were distinguished by comparing mean fluorescence intensities (MFI) of the test probes to the reference probe in 20 individuals with PWS and six controls. The mean MFI ratio for deleted loci was 0.56 +/- 0.09 (n = 88) as compared to the MFI ratios for normal loci, 0.96 +/- 0.06 (n = 236), and duplicated loci, 1.44 +/- 0.10 (n = 22). A multiplex QMH assay could readily distinguish type I from type II deletions in PWS subjects, as well as small (approximately 4.3 kb) imprinting center (IC) deletions, with no overlap in MFI values compared with normal loci. Using this diagnostic QMH assay, the precise deleted genomic interval could be ascertained in all PWS subjects examined in the present study.     

Molecular study of the Prader-Willi syndrome: deletion, RFLP, and phenotype analyses of 50 patients.

Deletion and RFLP studies with 5 cloned DNA markers localized at 15q11.2 were performed in 50 patients with the Prader-Willi syndrome (PWS). A one-copy density (deletion) for at least one of 4 loci, D15S9, D15S11, D15S10, D15S12, was detected in 32 (64%) of the 50 patients; deletions of each of the 4 loci were found in 29, 30, 29, and 28 patients, respectively. Three patients showed 4 or more copy density for D15S12 locus, in addition to deletions. The remaining 18 patients showed two-copy densities for each of the 4 loci. A common site of rearrangements among our 32 patients as well as the reported patients seemed to be confined to a segment between D15S9 and D15S11, suggesting the putative PWS gene locus in this segment. Of 6 patients who have cytologic deletions but did not show any molecular deletions, 3 have normal size of hands and feet, and 4 have normally pigmented skin and hair. The normal pigmentation was also observed in 3 patients who had small molecular deletions in the examined 5-locus segment. These observations may support the conception of contiguous gene syndrome. RFLP analysis demonstrated maternal uniparental isodisomy of chromosomes 15 in both a patient with 45,t(15q;15q) and a karyotypically normal patient. Based on the results of the present study, a new model is proposed to explain the occurrence of PWS with a variety of chromosome abnormalities, including partial monosomy, disomy, trisomy, and/or tetrasomy for 15q11.2. The normal development may require an even or more "number ratio" of paternally derived allele(s) to maternally derived allele(s) of the gene(s) localized at 15q11.2, and a disturbance of the ratio would lead to the PWS phenotype.     

Prader-Willi syndrome resulting from an unbalanced translocation: characterization by array comparative genomic hybridization

Prader-Willi syndrome (PWS) is caused by lack of expression of paternally inherited genes on chromosome 15q11-->15q13. Most cases result from microdeletions in proximal chromosome 15q. The remainder results from maternal uniparental disomy of chromosome 15, imprinting center defects, and rarely from balanced or unbalanced chromosome rearrangements involving chromosome 15. We report a patient with multiple congenital anomalies, including craniofacial dysmorphology, microcephaly, bilateral cryptorchidism, and developmental delay. Cytogenetic analysis showed a de novo 45,XY,der(5)t(5;15)(p15.2;q13), -15 karyotype. In effect, the proband had monosomies of 5p15.2-->pter and 15pter-->15q13. Methylation polymerase chain reaction analysis of the promoter region of the SNRPN gene showed only the maternal allele, consistent with the PWS phenotype. The proband's expanded phenotype was similar to other patients who have PWS as a result of unbalanced translocations and likely reflects the contribution of the associated monosomy. Array comparative genomic hybridization (array CGH) confirmed deletions of both distal 5p and proximal 15q and provided more accurate information as to the size of the deletions and the molecular breakpoints. This case illustrates the utility of array CGH in characterizing complex constitutional structural chromosome abnormalities at the molecular level.     

Molecular study of the Prader-Willi syndrome: Deletion,RFLP, and phenotype analyses of 50 patients

Deletion and RFLP studies with 5 cloned DNA markers localized at 15q11.2 were performed in 50 patients with the Prader–Willi syndrome (PWS). A one-copy density (deletion) for at least one of 4 loci, D15S9, D15S11, D15S10, D15S12, was detected in 32 (64%) of the 50 patients; deletions of each of the 4 loci were found in 29, 30, 29, and 28 patients, respectively. Three patients showed 4 or more copy density for D15S12 locus, in addition to deletions. The remaining 18 patients showed two-copy densities for each of the 4 loci. A common site of rearrangements among our 32 patients as well as the reported patients seemed to be confined to a segment between D15S9 and D15S11, suggesting the putative PWS gene locus in this segment. Of 6 patients who have cytologic deletions but did not show any molecular deletions, 3 have normal size of hands and feet, and 4 have normally pigmented skin and hair. The normal pigmentation was also observed in 3 patients who had small molecular deletions in the examined 5-locus segment. These observations may support the conception of contiguous gene syndrome. RFLP analysis demonstrated maternal uniparental isodisomy of chromosomes 15 in both a patient with 45,t(15q;15q) and a karyotypically normal patient. Based on the results of the present study, a new model is proposed to explain the occurrence of PWS with a variety of chromosome abnormalities, including partial monosomy, disomy, trisomy, and/or tetrasomy for 15q11.2. The normal development may require an even or more “number ratio” of paternally derived allele(s) to maternally derived allele(s) of the gene(s) localized at 15q11.2, and a disturbance of the ratio would lead to the PWS phenotype.     

Molecular characterization of a unique de novo 15q deletion associated with Prader-Willi syndrome and central visual impairment

We report a 2-year-old boy with Prader-Willi Syndrome (PWS) caused by a deletion of the PWS critical region as a result of an unbalanced translocation t(3;15). Additional features, including central visual impairment, relative macrocephaly, retrognathia, preauricular tags, and bilateral club-feet, were noticed. The extension of the deletion was determined by fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) analysis using 11 region-specific YAC clones. Nine YACs were found to be deleted, allowing us to determine that the deletion is larger than in patients with typical PWS deletions. The karyotype of this patient can thus be designated: 45,XY,-15,der(3)t(3;15)(qter;q14).ish der(3)t(3;15)(qter;q14) (wcp3+,wcp15+,D15S10-,PML+,D15Z1-,D3S4560+,801_f_9x1, 815_e_6x2) de novo. Molecular analyses using seven polymorphic markers helped to narrow down the breakpoint between marker ACTC.PC3 and the distal end of the YAC 815_e_6. These results provide evidence that haploinsufficiency for genes in 15q13-q14, not affected in common PWS deletions, is associated with the additional features found in the patient, including a central visual impairment.     

Defining the breakpoints of proximal chromosome 14q rearrangements in nine patients using flow-sorted chromosomes

The breakpoints of deletions and translocations in the proximal chromosome 14q region were defined in nine patients, four of whom have not been reported previously. The aberrant chromosomes were isolated by flow cytometry and used to map the chromosome 14 deletion or translocation breakpoints. The parental origins of deletions were ascertained as paternal in five cases and maternal in one. With the draft genomic sequence for human chromosome 14 available, gene searches were performed on selected intervals of the 14q11.2-q21 region to identify candidate genes for the observed phenotype in some of those affected. Gain of function of the gene PAX9 on chromosome 14 is a possible candidate for a t(14;18) patient affected with mesomelic bone dysplasia. Furthermore, a compilation of other human chromosome 14q proximal deletion and translocation cases was obtained from a search on cytogenetic databases. These findings suggest a locus for myelofibrosis at chromosome 14q13. This study contributes to useful information for identifying disease genes in this region.     

A case of Prader – Willi syndrome arising as a result of familial unbalanced translocation t(11;15)(q25;q13)

We report on a case of Prader-Willi syndrome (PWS) with a true reciprocal unbalanced translocation, 45,XX,-15,der(11)t(11;15)pat. The proposita was diagnosed clinically as having severe PWS. Molecular studies revealed loss of the paternal methylation pattern at locus D15S63 and a deletion encompassing the loci from at least D15S10 to D15S97 of paternal chromosome 15. FISH studies confirmed the deletion of 15q11-q13 region and the presence of two telomeres on all chromosomes. The proposita's father, the father's sister and their mother are all carriers of the same balanced translocation t(11;15)(q25;q13). By genomic imprinting we would expect that if the father's sister were to give birth to a child with the same unbalanced translocation as the proband, it would be affected by Angelman syndrome.
To date, a similar familial unbalanced translocation due to loss of the small chromosome 15 derivative has not been described.     

Cytogenetic and molecular study of the Angelman syndrome

Six patients, including two sibs, with Angelman syndrome (AS; three females and three males, aged 11 to 18 years) were studied cytogenetically. Molecular analysis was also performed. Using high-resolution banding technique, we detected a microdeletion in the proximal region of chromosome 15q in four cases. The deleted segment was heterogenous between these patients, and the common deleted region appeared to be 15q11.2. Four patients with deleted 15q were all sporadic cases, whereas in the sib cases we could not detect a visible deletion in the long arm of chromosome 15. However, there was no clinical difference between sporadic cases and sib cases. Densitometric analysis of autoradiographic bands of Southern hybridization using two DNA segments, pML34 and pTD3-21, as probes demonstrated that two patients had only one copy for each of the probes. In the remaining four patients, including the sibs, two copies of each sequence were retained. The probes used here detect a molecular deletion in most Prader-Willi syndrome patients. Thus the segment causing AS is localized adjacent to the critical segment of Prader-Willi syndrome. There seemed to be heterogeneity for the molecular deletion within AS individuals.     

Cytogenetic and molecular study of Angelman syndrome

Six patients, including two sibs, with Angelman syndrome (AS; three females and three males, aged 11 to 18 years) were studied cytogenetically. Molecular analysis was also performed. Using high-resolution banding technique, we detected a microdeletion in the proximal region of chromosome 15q in four cases. The deleted segment was heterogenous between these patients, and the common deleted region appeared to be 15q11.2. Four patients with deleted 15q were all sporadic cases, whereas in the sib cases we could not detect a visible deletion in the long arm of chromosome 15. However, there was no clinical difference between sporadic cases and sib cases. Densitometric analysis of autoradiographic bands of Southern hybridization using two DNA segments, pML34 and pTD3-21, as probes demonstrated that two patients had only one copy for each of the probes. In the remaining four patients, including the sibs, two copies of each sequence were retained. The probes used here detect a molecular deletion in most Prader-Willi syndrome patients. Thus the segment causing AS is localized adjacent to the critical segment of Prader-Willi syndrome. There seemed to be heterogeneity for the molecular deletion within AS individuals.     

Candidate region for cardio‐facio‐cutaneous syndrome

The breakpoints of deletions and translocations in the proximal chromosome 14q region were defined in nine patients, four of whom have not been reported previously. The aberrant chromosomes were isolated by flow cytometry and used to map the chromosome 14 deletion or translocation breakpoints. The parental origins of deletions were ascertained as paternal in five cases and maternal in one. With the draft genomic sequence for human chromosome 14 available, gene searches were performed on selected intervals of the 14q11.2–q21 region to identify candidate genes for the observed phenotype in some of those affected. Gain of function of the gene PAX9 on chromosome 14 is a possible candidate for a t(14;18) patient affected with mesomelic bone dysplasia. Furthermore, a compilation of other human chromosome 14q proximal deletion and translocation cases was obtained from a search on cytogenetic databases. These findings suggest a locus for myelofibrosis at chromosome 14q13. This study contributes to useful information for identifying disease genes in this region. © 2001 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Cloning of the breakpoints of a submicroscopic deletion in an Angelman syndrome patient

The majority of cases of the two distinct disorders Prader–Willisyndrome (PWS) and Angelman syndrome (AS) result from cytogeneticdeletions of chromosome 15q11–q13. These deletions areexclusively of maternal origin in AS but of paternal originin PWS indicating that the 15q11–q13 region is subjectto genomic imprinting. Transmission of a submicroscopic deletionin one three generation family resulted in AS only upon maternaltransmission of the deletion with no clinical phenotype associatedwith paternal transmission (1, 2). The breakpoint of this submicroscopicdeletion has been cloned and sequenced. This is the first deletionjunction from the AS/PWS region which has been so characterized.The nucleotide sequence of the deletion junction revealed a19 bp insertion of unknown origin with no evidence of repetitiveelements. A probe from the proximal deletion breakpoint, PB11,lies within the currently defined minimum region of deletionoverlap in PWS, which contains the SNRPN and D15S63 locl. Ourresults suggest that the imprinted gene(s) responsible for thePWS phenotype are proximal of pB11 in this deletion overlapregion.     

Deletion of small nuclear ribonucleoprotein polypeptide N (SNRPN) in Prader-Willi syndrome detected by fluorescence in situ hybridization: Two sibs with the typical phenotype without a cytogenetic deletion in chromosome 15q

The small nuclear ribonucleoprotein polypeptide N (SNRPN) gene is regarded as one of the candidates for Prader-Willi syndrome (PWS). We describe two sibs with typical PWS presenting deletion of SNRPN detected by fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH). Neither a cytogenetically detectable 15q12 deletion nor a deletion for the D15S11, D15S10, and GABRB3 cosmid probes were found in either patient. This implies a smaller deletion limited to the PWS critical region. FISH with a SNRPN probe will permit analysis of PWS patients with limited deletions not detectable with other probes. © 1996 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

A 5-year-old white girl with Prader-Willi syndrome and a submicroscopic deletion of chromosome 15q11q13

We report on a 5-year-old white girl with Prader-Willi syndrome (PWS) and a submicroscopic deletion of 15q11q13 of approximately 100–200 kb in size. High resolution chromosome analysis was normal but fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH), Southern hybridization, and microsatellite data from the 15q11q13 region demonstrated that the deletion was paternal in origin and included the SNRPN, PAR-5, and PAR-7 genes from the proximal to distal boundaries of the deletion segment. SNRPN and PW71B methylation studies showed an abnormal pattern consistent with the diagnosis of PWS and supported the presence of a paternal deletion of 15q11q13 or an imprinting mutation. Biparental (normal) inheritance of PW71B (D15S63 locus) and a deletion of the SNRPN gene were observed by microsatellite, quantitative Southern hybridization, and/or FISH analyses. Our patient met the diagnostic criteria for PWS, but has no reported behavior problems, hyperphagia, or hypopigmentation. Our patient further supports SNRPN and possibly other genomic sequences which are deleted as the cause of the phenotype recognized in PWS patients. © 1996 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Deletions of proximal 15q and non-classical Prader-Willi syndrome phenotypes

A deletion of the long arm of chromosome 15 (usually involving bands 15q11-q12) has been seen in approximately 50% of Prader-Willi syndrome (PWS) patients [Ledbetter et al, 1982]. However, 14 patients with non-PWS (or atypical PWS) phenotype with 15q deletion indicate great clinical variability. A deletion was found in a propositus with a de novo translocation [45,XY, -15, -22, +rec(15;22) (22pter----22q13.2::15q14----15qter)], who had anomalies not normally observed in PWS patients. Activities of several enzymes mapped to the involved chromosomes were studied in the patient and control individuals. A 50% decrease in the level of arylsulfatase-A confirmed a small deletion in 22q(22q13.2----qter), and additional studies localized more precisely the loci for alpha-mannosidase (cytoplasmic) and beta-galactosidase.     

Molecular and cytogenetic studies of the Prader-Willi syndrome.

Twenty-seven subjects with the Prader-Willi syndrome (PWS) were studied. Sixteen (59%) had a cytogenetic deletion involving chromosome 15q11-13. Nine were non-deletional and two patients had structural rearrangements of chromosome 15: 47,XY, + del(15)(pter----q12), var(15)(p11) and 45,XX,t(14q15q). At the DNA level, a greater proportion of patients (74%) showed loss of one chromosome 15q11-13 allele using a combination of densitometry and RFLP analysis. Deletion sizes were variable with 13 of 20 detectable both cytogenetically and with probe pML34 (D15S9). The remaining seven had microdeletions at the pML34 locus. Heterogeneity was further seen in three subjects who had cytogenetic deletions but normal DNA studies. In one patient there was evidence of a duplication at the pML34 locus. A new molecular rearrangement was identified with probe p3.21 (D15S10) in two patients and their mothers. Fifteen family studies were performed. In all 10 families where there was a molecular deletion, this was shown to have arisen de novo. DNA mapping confirmed that the paternal 15q allele was lost in three patients with PWS.     

Prader-Willi syndrome: current understanding of cause and diagnosis

Prader-Willi syndrome (PWS) is characterized by hypotonia, obesity, hypogonadism, short stature, small hands and feet, mental deficiency, a characteristic face, and an interstitial deletion of the proximal long arm of chromosome 15 in about one-half of the patients. The incidence is estimated to be about 1 in 25,000, and PWS is the most common syndromal cause of human obesity. DNA abnormalities, usually deletions or duplications of chromosome 15, have been identified in individuals with PWS with or without recognizable chromosome 15 deletions. Paternal origin of the chromosome 15 deletion by cytogenetic and DNA studies has been found in nearly all PWS individuals studied. No cytogenetic evidence for chromosome breakage has been identified, although an environmental cause (e.g., paternal hydrocarbon-exposed occupations) of the chromosome 15 abnormality has been proposed. PWS patients with the chromosome 15 deletion are more prone to hypopigmentation compared with PWS individuals with normal chromosomes, but no other clinical differences are consistently identified between those with and without the chromosome deletion. Anthropometric, dermatoglyphic, and other clinical findings indicate homogeneity of PWS patients with the chromosome deletion and heterogeneity of the nondeletion patients. A review of our current understanding of the major clinical, cytogenetic, and DNA findings is presented, and clinical manifestations and cytogenetic abnormalities are summarized from the literature.