Complications of type I thyroplasty and arytenoid adduction

OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS: Unilateral vocal fold paralysis resulting in glottal incompetence can cause significant morbidity attributable to impaired speech, swallowing, and ability to protect the airway. Type I thyroplasty in combination with arytenoid adduction is a proven technique for medialization of the paralyzed vocal fold but must be evaluated in light of potential complications following laryngeal framework surgery. STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: The charts of 237 patients who underwent unilateral vocal fold medialization surgery between July 1, 1991, and August 30, 1999, at a tertiary care cancer referral center were retrospectively reviewed. RESULTS: There were 98 cases of type I thyroplasty alone and 96 cases of type I thyroplasty with arytenoid adduction. The two groups had similar patient characteristics. Mean time of surgery (45 vs. 73 min, P <.0001) and length of hospital stay (1.1 vs. 1.8 d, P <.0001) were increased when arytenoid adduction was performed. Overall improvement of symptoms was similar in both groups (93%-94%), but posterior glottic closure appeared subjectively improved when arytenoid adduction was used (P =.0054). Overall complication rates were slightly higher in the arytenoid adduction group (14% vs. 19%), primarily because of transient vocal fold edema and wound complications (9 vs. 19 cases), but the increase was not statistically significant (P =.1401). Complications warranting medical or surgical intervention occurred in 8% of cases. Two patients who underwent type I thyroplasty with arytenoid adduction required tracheotomy as a consequence of postoperative complications. The three patients who had extrusion of the implant underwent type I thyroplasty alone. CONCLUSION: Using the appropriate technique, the potential benefits of improved glottic function following type I thyroplasty with arytenoid adduction outweigh the small risk of significant complications observed.     

Collagen injection as a supplement to arytenoid adduction for vocal fold paralysis

OBJECTIVES: Dysphonia associated with vocal fold paralysis can persist even after successful medialization procedures, including arytenoid adduction. It is hypothesized that laryngeal collagen injection could improve phonation following arytenoid adduction in selected patients. Our objective was to evaluate how collagen injection could result in measurable improvements in vocal function and voice quality. METHODS: Forty patients with unilateral vocal fold paralysis who had undergone arytenoid adduction underwent transoral injection of non-cross-linked bovine dermal collagen by means of indirect laryngoscopy and a curved injection device. A control group of 40 patients underwent arytenoid adduction but not collagen injection. The patients' voice quality was assessed perceptually with the GRBAS scale, and vocal function was assessed by acoustic and aerodynamic measures (maximum phonation time and transglottal DC flow). The relative glottal area was also assessed by videostroboscopy. RESULTS: Significant improvements in vocal function and voice quality were observed with collagen injection for those patients who did not achieve satisfactory glottal competence with arytenoid adduction alone. Glottal area measurements revealed that glottic insufficiency was significantly reduced after arytenoid adduction as well as after collagen injection. CONCLUSIONS: The findings suggest that collagen injection could be an effective supplementary treatment for improving voice following arytenoid adduction. It has the advantage of being a minimally invasive outpatient office procedure. The long-term efficacy of the procedure should be explored.     

Glottic configuration after arytenoid adduction

It has been recently noted that laryngeal paralysis results in a complex alteration of the glottis. The membranous segment of the paralyzed vocal fold is shortened, and, during phonation, patients use hyperfunction to shorten the normal vocal fold to about the same length. Additionally, if the paralyzed vocal fold is not near the midline, the angle between the membranous and cartilaginous segments of the vocal fold is decreased, resulting in a “posterior” gap which cannot be closed by hyperadduction of the normal side. To determine whether arytenoid adduction addresses these problems, videolaryngoscopy was analyzed in 11 patients before and after surgery, and results were compared to patient satisfaction and acoustic and aerodynamic assessment. The posterior gap and glottic competence were improved in all patients, but only 6 had improvement in symptoms. Two had persistent vocal fold bowing but achieved good function after Teflon® injection. Three patients, all with paralysis for more than 20 years, had no increase in vocal fold length and very little subjective vocal improvement. Arytenoid adduction is most effective in acute cases. Poor functional results in chronic paralysis are related to failure to achieve vocal fold lengthening, presumably due to soft-tissue contracture.     

Effects and use of the suture direction mimicking only the force action of the lateral cricoarytenoid muscle in arytenoid adduction combined with thyroplasty type I

Isshiki's arytenoid adduction combined with thyroplasty type I is a useful procedure for correcting the membranous vocal fold atrophy and the height difference between the two vocal folds, particularly in patients with a large posterior glottal chink and atrophy. Conventional arytenoid adduction (Isshiki's arytenoid adduction) is designed to place a suture through the muscular process of the arytenoid attached anteriorly to the thyroid ala, stimulating the function of the thyroarytenoid muscle and lateral cricoarytenoid muscle. Combining with thyroplasty type I, the suture direction of conventional arytenoid adduction prevented inserting implant material into the pocket of the thyroid cartilage window. In contrast to conventional arytenoid adduction, the suture direction in our approach is anchored anteroinferiorly, mimicking only the action of the lateral cricoarytenoid muscle (the major adductor of the larynx). It is used the thyroid cartilage window in thyroplasty type I to determine the direction of the lateral cricoarytenoid muscle. After approaching the muscular process based on Isshiki's arytenoid adduction, two nylon sutures are tied across the muscular process or the lateral cricoarytenoid muscle nearby the muscular process. The cricoarytenoid joint is not dislocated. One of the sutures was anchored to the inferior rear corner of the thyroid cartilage window to be used with thyroplasty type I and the other was anchored to the rear lower margin of the thyroid lamina. Gore-tex medialization thyroplasty is done after tying the sutures on the thyroid ala. Subjects were 30 unilateral paralytic dysphonia. Maximum phonation of all patients improved significantly after surgery. The preoperative and postoperative mean maximum phonation times were 6.0 and 17.9 seconds. No major complications occurred in this study. Our approach effectively combined arytenoid adduction and thyroplasty type I for patients with severe insufficient glottic closure.     

Glottal configuration,acoustic, and aerodynamic changes induced by variation in suture direction in arytenoid adduction procedures

Arytenoid adduction is a phonosurgical procedure in which the arytenoid cartilages are approximated to reduce posterior glottal gap size and improve voice. Voice outcomes following arytenoid adduction are not always optimal. The goal of this study was to systematically vary suture direction and force of pull on the arytenoid cartilages in a human excised laryngeal model to determine the optimal combination of factors for reducing glottal gap and improving voice. Several factors demonstrated significant effects. Changes in suture direction and force of pull affected glottal configuration in both the horizontal and vertical planes. Increased force of pull on the muscular process resulted in increased adduction of the vocal process for all suture directions. Changes in suture direction and force of pull also affected acoustic and aerodynamic measures of induced voice. Therefore, voice outcomes can be optimized with arytenoid adduction if the vocal fold plane is accurately adjusted.     

Injection laryngoplasty according to the pathologic condition

Injection laryngoplasty is done based on the pathologic condition of the larynx. Autologous fat was harvested and endolaryngeal microsurgery conducted for injection laryngoplasty under general anesthesia. For glottic incompetence caused by bilateral atrophy of vocal fold mucosa lamina propria, autologous fat was injected into vocal fold mucosa and into the muscle just below mucosa. For glottic incompetence with a unilateral midcord gap caused by unilateral atrophy of the vocalis muscle, fat was injected into the thyroarytenoid muscle at the membranous portion of the vocal fold. In a patient with a unilateral midcord gap and a large posterior gap, autologous fat was injected into the thyroarytenoid muscle lateral to the oblong fovea of the arytenoid cartilage to arytenoid adduction. For glottic incompetence with a unilateral midcord gap and a large posterior gap, consequently afflicted with voice disorder and aspiration, fat was injected into the vocal fold, false vocal fold, aryepiglottic fold of the larynx, and the medial wall of the piriform sinus of the hypopharynx. Lipoinjection into the vocal fold, false vocal fold, and aryepiglottic fold enabled laryngeal closure. Lipoinjection into the piriform sinus lowered its capacity and residual food was reduced and pharyngeal clearance on the affected side was improved. The injected portion and the amount of injected material should be modified at injection laryngoplasty based on the pathologic condition of the larynx.     

The study of vocal fold vibratory patterns in patients with unilateral vocal fold paralysis before and after type I thyroplasty with or without arytenoid adduction

Type I thyroplasty and arytenoid adduction have been used for the treatment of symptomatic unilateral vocal fold paralysis since the mid-1970s. To this date, the vibratory patterns of the vocal folds in patients with unilateral vocal fold paralysis undergoing thyroplasty have not been studied in depth. Abnormal vibration of the vocal fold mucosa often contributes to voice problems in persons diagnosed with vocal diseases or disorders. The preoperative and postoperative videostroboscopic vibratory patterns including mucosal wave, amplitude, glottic closure, and symmetry were studied in 12 patients who underwent unilateral type I thyroplasty separately or in combination with an arytenoid adduction. The observed changes and clinical implications are discussed.     

Effects of arytenoid adduction on laryngeal function following ansa cervicalis nerve transfer for vocal fold paralysis in an in vivo canine model

Laryngeal reinnervation with the ansa cervicalis has been proposed as a treatment for human unilateral vocal fold paralysis (UVFP). This study tested the assumption that results from reinnervation could be improved if combined with medialization surgery. Six canine subjects underwent recurrent laryngeal nerve section and reinnervation with a branch of the ansa cervicalis. After reinnervation, vocal function was assessed before and after arytenoid adduction. Although laryngeal function improved significantly following reinnervation, results were significantly enhanced by the addition of medialization surgery. The implications for the treatment of human unilateral vocal fold paralysis are discussed.     

Timing of glottic closure during swallowing: a combined electromyographic and endoscopic analysis

OBJECTIVES: We performed a case series to enhance our understanding of the coupling between neuromuscular events and glottic closure. METHODS: We performed combined flexible video laryngoscopy and electromyography in 4 healthy human subjects. Hooked-wire electrodes were placed in the superior pharyngeal constrictor, longitudinal pharyngeal, cricopharyngeus, thyroarytenoid, genioglossus, suprahyoid, and posterior cricoarytenoid muscles. A flexible endoscope tip was positioned in the oropharyngeal-hypopharyngeal region. The subjects performed multiple trials each of 10-mL normal and super-supraglottic liquid swallows. RESULTS: Arytenoid movement consistently preceded full glottic closure and was associated with cessation of activity of the posterior cricoarytenoid muscle. In 89% of normal swallows, the glottis was partially open in the video frame before bolus passage. The maximum amount of thyroarytenoid electromyographic activity occurred during endoscopic whiteout. When subjects executed a super-supraglottic swallow, early thyroarytenoid activity coincided with arytenoid contact. CONCLUSIONS: The initial medialization of the arytenoids is due to a decrease in motor tone of the posterior cricoarytenoid muscle. Full glottic closure typically occurs late in the process of swallowing, with activation of the thyroarytenoid muscle. Shifting of arytenoid medialization and glottic closure earlier in the super-supraglottic swallow indicates that glottic closure is under significant voluntary control.     

Combined arytenoid adduction and laryngeal reinnervation in the treatment of vocal fold paralysis

OBJECTIVE/HYPOTHESIS: Glottal closure and symmetrical thyroarytenoid stiffness are two important functional characteristics of normal phonatory posture. In the treatment of unilateral vocal cord paralysis, vocal fold medialization improves closure, facilitating entrainment of both vocal folds for improved phonation, and reinnervation is purported to maintain vocal fold bulk and stiffness. A combination of medialization and reinnervation would be expected to further improve vocal quality over medialization alone. STUDY DESIGN: A retrospective review of preoperative and postoperative voice analysis on all patients who underwent arytenoid adduction alone (adduction group) or combined arytenoid adduction and ansa cervicalis to recurrent laryngeal nerve anastomosis (combined group) between 1989 and 1995 for the treatment of unilateral vocal cord paralysis. Patients without postoperative voice analysis were invited back for its completion. A perceptual analysis was designed and completed. METHODS: Videostroboscopic measures of glottal closure, mucosal wave, and symmetry were rated. Aerodynamic parameters of laryngeal airflow and subglottic pressure were measured. A 2-second segment of sustained vowel was used for perceptual analysis by means of a panel of voice professionals and a rating system. Statistical calculations were performed at a significance level of P = .05. RESULTS: There were 9 patients in the adduction group and 10 patients in the combined group. Closure and mucosal wave improved significantly in both groups. Airflow decreased in both groups, but the decrease reached statistical significance only in the adduction group. Subglottic pressure remained unchanged in both groups. Both groups had significant perceptual improvement of voice quality. In all tested parameters the extent of improvement was similar in both groups. CONCLUSION: The role of laryngeal reinnervation in the treatment of unilateral vocal cord paralysis remains to be established.     

Arytenoid adduction technique for correction of Paralytic Dysphonia

Development of phonosurgical techniquec like Medialization Laryngoplasty (M. L.) or Thyroplasty has opened new horizon in the management of paralytic dysphonia. The Arytenoid Adduction (A. A.) technique as originally described by professor Isshiki of Japan added a new dimension for improvement of voice in cases of paralytic dysphonia particularly in large posterior commissure defects. 9 cases of primary and secondary arytenoid adduction technique done as complementary to medialization laryngoplasty over a period of 2 years are described.     

Posterior glottic diastasis: mechanically deceptive and often overlooked

Dysphonia secondary to posterior glottic aerodynamic incompetence can often be recognizable acoustically, but difficult to document visually. This mechanical impairment in posterior glottic closure is the result of injury caused by airway instrumentation. The difficulty of recognition of this entity is due to posterior supraglottic soft tissue that obscures the complete view during posterior glottic adduction, the lack of a structural organization of the cricoarytenoid region injury that leads to this disorder, and the lack of nomenclature. A retrospective assessment was done on 3 patients who underwent surgical reconstruction to correct posterior phonatory incompetence subsequent to laryngotracheal intubation. All 3 had sustained an injury to the cricoarytenoid joints, and 2 of the 3 had undergone paraglottic space medialization laryngoplasty that failed to solve the posterior glottic insufficiency. New procedures were designed and performed in these patients to correct the posterior glottic incompetence and are described: laryngofissure and partial posterior cricoid resection, endoscopic pharyngoepiglottic-aryepiglottic fold advancement-rotation flap with interarytenoid interposition, and interarytenoid submucosal implant augmentation. Although the academic literature is replete with reports describing stenosis resulting from impaired cricoarytenoid joint abduction, the term glottic diastasis provides nomenclature for the inability to normally adduct the arytenoid cartilages. The initial experience with surgical reconstruction is preliminary, but encouraging.     

Vocal fold fixation in laryngeal carcinomas

The mechanisms of vocal fold fixation were determined by means of a whole-organ serial section study. A total of 80 laryngectomy specimens, 36 supraglottic and 44 glottic carcinomas, was investigated. In the supraglottic carcinomas, the most frequent cause of fixation of the ipsilateral vocal fold was a deep massive tumor invasion in the arytenoid eminence and the second most frequent cause was an extensive involvement of the thyroarytenoid (TA) muscle. Fixation of the contralateral vocal fold resulted from a deep tumor invasion in the contralateral arytenoid eminence. In the glottic carcinomas, fixation of the ipsilateral vocal fold resulted from an extensive invasion into the TA muscle. Fixation of the contralateral vocal fold was caused chiefly by an invasion into the contralateral TA muscle through the anterior commissure region. It resulted occasionally from an invasion into the interarytenoid muscle and contralateral arytenoid cartilage and cricoarytenoid joint via the posterior part of the larynx.     

Arytenoid adduction and medialization laryngoplasty

Arytenoid adduction and medialization laryngoplasty have become the mainstay of static surgical rehabilitation of the larynx after vocal fold paralysis. The rationale for considering one versus a combination of the two procedures has not been well addressed. This article outlines the basic science of the procedures and the clinical technical modifications necessary to make the surgery easier.     

Early Arytenoid Adduction for Vagal Paralysis After Skull Base Surgery

Objectives To evaluate the efficacy of early arytenoid adduction in the management of vagal paralysis after skull base surgery. Study Design Retrospective evaluation at a tertiary care skull base center. Methods Aggressive surgical management of skull base lesions has become increasingly popular owing to advances in surgical technique and intraoperative monitoring. Temporary and permanent lower cranial neuropathies occur frequently, especially after the surgical management of lesions involving the vertebrobasilar system and the jugular foramen. An injury to the proximal vagus nerve is usually associated with dysphonia and swallowing dysfunction. An early arytenoid adduction has been employed in 26 patients with a vagal paralysis after skull base surgery. Most commonly, the neurosurgical patient underwent an arytenoid adduction under general anesthesia on postoperative day 2. Results Videostroboscopy after arytenoid adduction demonstrated 76% of patients had complete glottic closure. Of those with inadequate glottic closure, all demonstrated a well‐medialized posterior glottis with a persistent anterior glottal gap. These patients were easily treated with a secondary type I thyroplasty under local anesthesia with sedation resulting in complete glottic closure. Despite excellent voice outcomes, 66% of these patients had dysphagia requiring enteral feedings for nutritional support. Conclusions An early arytenoid adduction is an excellent medialization technique that can be performed safely in the early postoperative period under general anesthesia after skull base surgery.     

Unilateral arytenoid adduction improves voice in a patient with bilateral vocal fold immobility

Bilateral vocal fold immobility (BVFI) due to prolonged endotracheal intubation resulted in aphonia without any airway morbidity and was treated by several reconstructive procedures. Laryngeal reinnervation and silicone implantation failed to medialize one of those two fixed cords. Arytenoid adduction (AA) eventually achieved this goal. To select an optimal reconstructive procedure, a careful perusal of the history and head and neck examination including laryngeal electromyography, are necessary to determine the causes. AA procedure played an essential clinical indication in this study, not just an adjunct to the medialization laryngoplasty as usual. Since both the vocal cords positions were ranked as lateral positions subjectively, the full adduction for one of those two fixed vocal cords was performed without significant airway obstruction. The practice in this study provided an experience in correcting the voice in patients with BVFI. We need further experience to medialize the vocal cord in an appropriate magnitude since its counterpart may position variously and compromise the airway.     

Analysis of Voice Changes After Thyroplasty Using Linear Predictive Coding

Objective measurement of vocal quality is difficult in patients with severe voice disorders. Improved success has been reported using a modeling technique known as linear predictive coding. This technique uses an inverse filter to estimate a glottic excitation signal. The pitch amplitude is defined as the height of the first peak of the autocorrelation of the glottic excitation signal. In this study linear predictive coding was used to analyze voice disorders in patients with vocal fold immobility. Voice recordings were made in 16 patients undergoing vocal fold medialization and 10 patients who had no surgical procedure between measurements. The voice quality was rated by three speech pathologists. Five acoustic parameters were calculated from the samples. The best agreement with the listeners' perceptual analysis was achieved using the pitch amplitude. Both pitch amplitude and the perceptual ratings of voice quality improved in patients undergoing vocal fold medialization. Therefore the linear model of speech production and inverse filtering are useful in measuring vocal quality in patients with vocal fold immobility.     

Cricothyroid subluxation: a new innovation for enhancing the voice with laryngoplastic phonosurgery

Laryngoplastic phonosurgery has evolved to become a dominant treatment modality for paralytic dysphonia. Current surgical procedures have addressed primarily the position of the musculomembranous vocal fold and the arytenoid in the axial and vertical planes. However. dynamic range capabilities and vocal flexibility have been limited secondary to the flaccid, denervated vocal fold tissue. Therefore. a new procedure was conceived to enhance the acoustic vocal outcome from operations that reposition the vocal edge. Cricothyroid (CT) subluxation was designed as a technique to increase the distance between the cricoarytenoid joint and the insertion of the anterior commissure ligament. Cricothyroid subluxation was done without complication in 9 patients who underwent combined adduction arytenopexy and medialization laryngoplasty, and in 4 patients with medialization laryngoplasty alone. Postoperative stroboscopic assessment was done in all of the 13 patients, while complete analysis of vocal function was available in 10 of the 13 patients; this revealed improvement (as a group) on almost all objective measures over the preoperative state. All patients who underwent CT subluxation had a normal maximum frequency range (pitch variation of more than 2 octaves), as compared with 22% of a prior similar cohort of patients who did not undergo CT subluxation. All patients who underwent CT subluxation had normal glottal airflow and a normal noise-to-harmonics ratio. Cricothyroid subluxation is a relatively easily adjustable procedure that increases the length and viscoelastic tension of the denervated vocal fold. The modified biomechanical properties resulted in improved vocal outcome in all of our patients, which was most remarkable in terms of maximal range capabilities. Cricothyroid subluxation enhanced the postoperative voice of patients regardless of whether they required medialization laryngoplasty alone or whether they also required adduction arytenopexy.     

Arytenoid adduction: controlling vertical position

In flaccid laryngeal paralysis, the vocal process (VP) is displaced laterally and superiorly. The arytenoid adduction procedure (AA) moves the VP medially and caudally, closing the glottic gap. However, clinical evidence suggests that the VP is more caudal after AA than in physiological phonation. The neurally intact arytenoid is supported by tonic and phonatory activity of the posterior cricoarytenoid muscle (PCA). We hypothesize that a posterior anchoring suture could replace PCA support, achieving a more natural VP location. Cadaver larynges were scanned with computed tomography at rest and after AA, alone or in combination with a second arytenoid suture anchored to either the posterior midline cricoid (PC) or the inferior thyroid cornu (IC). Each posterior suture reduced caudal displacement of the VP during AA, but the glottic gap was wider with the PC suture. In 3 patients undergoing AA for laryngeal paralysis, the IC suture improved arytenoid posture and voice quality.