Transarticular cross-screw fixation. A technique of ankle arthrodesis

Many techniques of ankle arthrodesis have been described. Failure rates of up to 40% have been reported in the past. In this study, a technique for internal fixation of ankle fusions was employed using transarticular crossed-screw fixation. This provides bony coaptation, compression, and immobilization necessary for reliable union. Thirty-five patients had ankle arthrodesis with this technique of internal fixation and 12 patients had ankle fusions with Charnley compression arthrodesis. Follow-up evaluation averaged two years. The fusion rate was 100% (35 fusions of 35 attempts) with the transarticular crossed-screw technique and 83% (ten fusions of 12 attempts) with compression arthrodesis.     

Ankle arthrodesis. A comparison of internal and external fixation

The authors reviewed the results of ankle arthrodesis in 68 ankles in 66 patients. The average follow-up period of the patients was five years (range, two to ten years). There were 40 ankles in which internal fixation was used and 28 ankles in which external fixation was used. The two groups were compared to determine the effect of mode of stabilization on outcome. Outcome was measured by time to union, development of complications, and clinical follow-up result. The groups were similar in regards to gender, age, and preoperative diagnosis. The external fixation group had a significantly higher prevalence of complications, including non-union, delayed union, and infection, than the internal fixation group. It was concluded that ankle arthrodesis with internal fixation is better tolerated and has fewer complications than techniques that use external fixation.     

Ankle arthrodesis for failed total ankle replacement

Between 1999 and 2005, 23 failed total ankle replacements were converted to arthrodeses. Three surgical techniques were used: tibiotalar arthrodesis with screw fixation, tibiotalocalcaneal arthrodesis with screw fixation, and tibiotalocalcaneal arthrodesis with an intramedullary nail. As experience was gained, the benefits and problems became apparent. Successful bony union was seen in 17 of the 23 ankles. The complication rate was higher in ankles where the loosening had caused extensive destruction of the body of the talus, usually in rheumatoid arthritis. In this situation we recommend tibiotalocalcaneal arthrodesis with an intramedullary nail. This technique can also be used when there is severe arthritic change in the subtalar joint. Arthrodesis of the tibiotalar joint alone using compression screws was generally possible in osteoarthritis because the destruction of the body of the talus was less extensive. Tibiotalocalcaneal arthrodesis fusion with compression screws has not been successful in our experience.     

Salvage arthrodesis for failed total ankle arthroplasty

Background and purpose Total ankle arthroplasty (TAA) has gained popularity in recent years. If it fails, however, salvage arthrodesis must be reliable as a rescue procedure. We therefore investigated the clinical, radiographic, and subjective outcome after salvage arthrodesis in a consecutive group of patients, and concentrated on the influence of the method of fixation on union rate and on salvage in inflammatory joint disease.

Patients and methods Between 1994 and 2005, salvage arthrodesis was performed on 18 ankles (18 patients). Diagnosis was inflammatory joint disease (IJD) in 15 cases and osteoarthritis (OA) in 3. Tibio-talar fusion was performed in 7 ankles, and tibio-talocalcaneal fusion in 11. Serial radiographs were studied for time to union. Clinical outcome at latest follow-up was measured by the AOFAS score, the foot function index (FFI) and by VAS scores for pain, function, and satisfaction.

Results Blade plates were used in 7 ankles (4 IJD, 3 OA); all united. Nonunion developed in 7 of the 11 rheumatic ankles stabilized by other methods. 11 patients (8 fused ankles, 3 nonunions) were available for clinical evaluation. Their mean AOFAS score was 62 and mean overall FFI was 70. VAS score for pain was 20, for function 64, and for satisfaction 74. The scores were similar in united and non-united ankles.

Interpretation Blade plate fixation is successful in salvage arthrodesis for failed TAA. A high nonunion rate was found after salvage ankle arthrodesis in IJD with other methods of fixation. Clinical results were fair to good.     

Arthrodesis for failed ankle arthroplasty.

Thirty-eight ankles in 36 patients who underwent fusion for failed total ankle arthroplasty were reviewed. Twenty-two patients were women and 14 were men, and their mean age was 56.8 years. The fusion methods performed in the 38 ankles were malleolar resection in 13, intercalated bone graft in 20, and posterior tibiotalocalcaneal fusion in 5. Fixation was external in 36 ankles and internal in 2. Bone graft was used in 32 ankles. Union was achieved in 33 ankles (89%). The average duration of the follow-up period in 29 patients (31 ankles) was 8.3 years (range, 2-14.4 years). Patients had no or mild pain in 24 ankles (80%). Complications occurred in five ankles (13%). Failed total ankle arthroplasty may be successfully salvaged by arthrodesis.     

Percutaneous arthrodesis

It has been generally accepted that residual cartilage and subchondral bone has to be removed in order to get bony fusion in arthrodeses. In 1998 we reported successful fusion of 11 rheumatoid ankles, all treated with percutaneous fixation only. In at least one of these ankle joint there was cartilage left. This was confirmed by arthrotomy in order to remove an osteophyte, which hindered dorsiflexion. More than 25 rheumatoid patients with functional alignment in the ankle joint have subsequently been operated on with the percutaneous technique, and so far we have had only one failure. Patients with rheumatoid arthritis are known to sometimes fuse at least their subtalar joints spontaneously, and the destructive effect of the synovitis on the cartilage could contribute to fusion when using the percutaneous technique. In a rabbit study we therefore tested the hypothesis that even a normal joint can fuse merely by percutaneous fixation. The patella was fixated to the femur with lag screw technique without removal of cartilage, and in 5 of 6 arthrodeses with stable fixation bony fusion followed. Depletion of synovial fluid seemed to be the mechanism behind cartilage disappearance. The stability of the fixation achieved at arthrodesis surgery is an important factor in determining success or failure. Dowel arthrodesis without additional fixation proved to be deleterious. A good fit of the bone surfaces appears necessary. In the ankle joint, it would be technically demanding to retain the arch-shaped geometry of the joint after resection of the cartilage. Normally the joint surfaces are resected to produce flat osteotomy surfaces that are thus easier to fit together, encouraging healing to occur. On the other hand it is considered an advantage to preserve as much subchondral bone as possible, as the strong subchondral bone plate can contribute to the stability of the arthrodesis. Ankle arthrodesis can be successfully performed in patients with rheumatoid arthritis by percutaneous screw fixation without resection of the joint surfaces. This procedure has two advantages: first, it is less surgically traumatic, second, both the arch-shaped geometry and the subchondral bone are preserved, and thus both could contribute to the postoperative stability of the construct. Intuitively, preservation of the arch-shape should increase rotational stability. The results of our experimental sawbone study indicate that the arch shape and the subchondral bone should be preserved when ankle arthrodesis is performed. The importance of this is likely to increase in weak rheumatoid bone. In a finite element study the initial stability provided by two different methods of joint preparation and different screw configurations in ankle arthrodesis, was compared. Better initial stability is predicted for ankle arthrodesis when joint contours are preserved rather than resected. Overall, inserting the two screws at a 30-degree angle with respect to the long axis of the tibia and crossing them above the fusion site improved stability for both joint preparation techniques. The question rose as to whether patients with osteoarthritis could also be operated on solely by percutaneous fixation technique. The first metatarsophalangeal joint in patients with hallux rigidus was chosen as an appropriate joint to test the percutaneous technique. In this small series we have shown that it is possible to achieve bony fusion with a percutaneous technique in an osteoarthrotic joint in humans, but failed to say anything about the fusion rate.     

Arthrodesis after failed total ankle replacement

We present a series of 16 patients treated between 1993 and 2006 who had a failed total ankle replacement converted to an arthrodesis using bone grafting with internal fixation. We used tricortical autograft from the iliac crest to preserve the height of the ankle, the malleoli and the subtalar joint. A successful arthrodesis was achieved at a mean of three months (1.5 to 4.5) in all patients except one, with rheumatoid arthritis and severe bone loss, who developed a nonunion and required further fixation with an intramedullary nail at one year after surgery, before obtaining satisfactory fusion. The post-operative American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society score improved to a mean of 70 (41 to 87) with good patient satisfaction. From this series and an extensive review of the literature we have found that rates of fusion after failed total ankle replacement in patients with degenerative arthritis are high. We recommend our method of arthrodesis in this group of patients. A higher rate of nonunion is associated with rheumatoid arthritis which should be treated differently.     

Ankle arthrodesis in tubercular arthritis using anterior bridge plating: A report of 2 cases

Ankle arthrodesis is a common procedure for tubercular arthritis in India. However, attaining fusion in osteoporotic bones is difficult to achieve by both external and internal fixation methods described in the literature. We report two cases for ankle arthrodesis using an anterior approach to the ankle and internal fixation with a bridging anteriorly placed AO L/AO T plate. Both ankles were fused. The surgical technique is simple, easily reproducible and gives excellent results.     

Arthrodesis of the ankle in the presence of a large deformity in the coronal plane

A consecutive series of 23 patients (25 ankles) with osteoarthritis of the ankle and severe varus or valgus deformity were treated by open arthrodesis using compression screws. Primary union was achieved in 24 ankles one required further surgery to obtain a solid fusion. The high level of satisfaction in this group of patients reinforces the view that open arthrodesis, as opposed to ankle replacement or arthroscopic arthrodesis, continues to be the treatment of choice when there is severe varus or valgus deformity associated with the arthritis.     

Pantalar and tibiotalocalcaneal arthrodesis for post-traumatic osteoarthrosis of the ankle and hindfoot.

Twenty-one patients had a unilateral extended arthrodesis of the ankle and hindfoot (a tibiotalocalcaneal procedure in thirteen patients and a pantalar procedure in eight) for post-traumatic osteoarthrosis or deformity, or both. The operation was performed through a transfibular extended lateral approach, and autogenous bone graft and rigid internal fixation was used. A final alignment of 0 to 5 degrees of valgus, 0 to 5 degrees of calcaneus, and external rotation equal to that of the contralateral side was sought. Subjective and objective evaluation, including a personal interview, physical examination, and radiographic and dynamic pedobarographic analysis, was performed at a mean interval of thirty-two months (range, twenty-four to fifty-four months) after the operation. A solid fusion was achieved in eighteen (86 per cent) of the twenty-one patients. There were five malunions (24 per cent) and two superficial wound problems (10 per cent). Of the seventeen patients who were not retired from work, eleven returned to work: nine to an occupation that involved standing and two to a sedentary occupation. Although seventeen (81 per cent) of the twenty-one patients reported that they were much improved, twenty (95 per cent) had some pain, and most benefited from modifications in shoe-wear. Patients who had had a tibiotalocalcaneal arthrodesis were more mobile and functioned at a higher level than those who had had a pantalar arthrodesis. Extended arthrodesis of the ankle and hindfoot is a complex, technically demanding procedure, and should be regarded as a salvage operation capable of producing a satisfactory result and usually providing a reasonable alternative to amputation.     

The results of arthrodesis of the ankle for leprotic neuroarthropathy

Twenty-four patients who had arthrodesis of one or both ankles for leprotic neuroarthropathy were followed for an average of nine years and five months. At operation, after the removal of cartilage, joint debris, and sclerotic bone, the ankle joint was transfixed with a Küntscher intramedullary nail, and staples or Kirschner wires were used to control rotation. Fusion of bone was obtained in nineteen (73 per cent) of the twenty-six ankles. Failure to obtain fusion was due to postoperative infection in four patients, deficiency of the site of arthrodesis in one patient, and refracture through the site of fusion in two patients. When arthrodesis was successful, additional neuroarthropathic destruction of the mid-tarsal joint was halted, and the preoperative clinical symptoms of dull pain, local warmth, swelling, and instability were relieved.     

Ankle arthrodesis with cross-screw fixation: Good results in 36/40 cases followed 3-7 years

Tibiotalar arthrodesis by an anterior approach, using internal compression with cancellous screws, offers wide exposure, good possibilities of correcting deformities, and good bony apposition. From 1987 to 1991, we used this technique in 42 ankle joints (40 patients). the indications were posttraumatic arthrosis, rheumatoid arthritis, neurogenic paralysis, sequelae of septic arthritis, necrosis of the talus and failed ankle arthrodesis. in 13 ankles with severe deformity, a bone graft was also used. 38 patients (40 ankle joints) were available for follow-up after 4 (3-7) years. Solid union was achieved in 38 ankles after an average of 13 weeks. the clinical result was good-to-excellent in 36 ankles. We conclude that this is a simple and effective method for ankle arthrodesis in both low-risk and, coupled with bone grafting, in properly selected high-risk patients.     

Ankle arthrodesis using an anterior AO T plate

We describe a surgical technique for ankle arthrodesis using an anterior approach to the ankle and internal fixation with an anteriorly-placed AO T plate. A total of 33 patients who had ankle arthrodeses have been followed retrospectively. Thirty-one (94%) of the ankles fused although two patients developed tibial stress fractures. Four patients had a superficial infection which did not prevent union. The surgical technique is simple, easily reproducible and gives excellent clinical results with a high rate of union.     

Revision of ankle arthrodesis with external fixation for non-union.

We evaluated the cases of twenty-six patients (twenty-six ankles) who had had revision of an ankle arthrodesis with external fixation for a nonunion, to determine the reasons for the failure of the previous arthrodesis. Eighteen patients had had supplemental bone-grafting in addition to the external fixation. The failure of the previous arthrodesis was related to inadequate fixation technique in seven patients and to technical problems in two patients; in the other seventeen patients at least one risk factor was identified. We also determined the functional results of the revision operation with external fixation for all patients. The average duration of follow-up was five years (range, two to ten years) in the twenty-two patients who did not have a reoperation for a persistent nonunion. The results were excellent in eleven patients, good in five, fair in four, and poor in six. The over-all rate of union was twenty (77 per cent) of twenty-six, comparable with that after primary arthrodesis; however, supplemental bone-grafting is usually necessary. In the current series, rigid fixation, precise apposition of bone and alignment of the foot, and early treatment of perioperative infection gave satisfactory results.     

Arthrodesis for failed knee arthroplasty. A report of 20 cases

Twenty consecutive patients treated by arthrodesis for failed knee arthroplasty are reviewed. Eight hinged, five stabilised and seven compartmental prostheses were removed, for infection (15 cases), loosening (4) and instability (1). One patient refused a second-stage operation but the remainder gained sound fusion. Infected knees had a two-stage procedure with temporary insertion of gentamicin-loaded beads after removal of the prosthesis; all infections healed. Six arthrodeses using a Hoffmann-Vidal external fixator resulted in two temporary failures. One Ace-Fischer external fixation was successful. Of 10 primary attempts at arthrodesis with an intramedullary Küntscher nail, nine were successful; the tenth fused after two more attempts by the same method. The two failures of external fixation and two failures after Charnley single-frame compression done elsewhere were successfully fused with intramedullary nails. Delayed union in three cases fused after prolonged fixation and repeated bone grafts. The indications for and methods of arthrodesis after failed knee arthroplasty are discussed.     

Takedown of ankle fusion and conversion to total ankle replacement

The painful ankle arthrodesis is an unsolved clinical problem. In many cases, transtibial amputation may be the best option for functional recovery. Recent reports of early success with second generation ankle implants show takedown of the problematic ankle fusion and conversion to total ankle arthroplasty may be an alternative to amputation. This study is a retrospective review of 23 ankles in 22 patients scheduled to have this procedure. Four patients were lost to followup, leaving 19 ankles in 18 patients at an average followup of 39 months. Three patients chose to have an amputation because of continued pain. In the remaining 16 ankles, the mean AOFAS ankle-hind foot outcome score improved from 42-68. Patients who had a clear source of pain with the ankle arthrodesis (such as subtalar arthrosis) had a better result than patients without a clear source of pain. All the patients who had the lateral malleolus resected during previous arthrodesis had complicated courses after arthroplasty. For patients with a definable source of pain and who have not had previous malleolar resection, conversion of a failed ankle arthrodesis to total ankle arthroplasty may be a viable alternative to amputation.     

Ankle arthrodesis by compression screws in rheumatoid arthritis: primary nonunion in 9/35 patients

INTRODUCTION: Today, percutaneous or open arthrodesis of the ankle, using one or several screws for fixation, is a common method for treatment of the rheumatic ankle. However, there is very little information in the literature on the reliability of the method. METHODS: We performed a retrospective radiographic and clinical study on 35 ankles of 35 patients. Function was evaluated using the Mazur and AOFAS scores. For evaluation of activity of the rheumatic disease, we used the HAQ score. RESULTS: 31 ankles had healed--26 at the first attempt and 5 after repeat arthrodesis. There was no difference between 13 cases operated on percutaneously and 22 cases operated on with open technique with respect to radiographic healing. Mean AOFAS total score was 56 of possible 86 points. The AOFAS total score correlated with the severity of the rheumatic disease. 20 patients were satisfied with the result, 12 were somewhat satisfied and 3 patients were dissatisfied although the ankle in 2 of these 3 patients had fused. INTERPRETATION: The use of compression screws for fusion of the rheumatic ankle does not appear to give acceptable results regarding healing and function.     

Ankle arthrodesis. A comparison of an arthroscopic and an open method of treatment

An arthroscopic technique and an open technique with malleolar ostectomy for ankle arthrodesis is described and compared. Internal fixation with compression across the tibiotalar joint was utilized for both methods using either 6.5-mm or 7.0-mm cannulated screws. The indications, advantages, results, and complications of these two fusion techniques in 33 patients are reported. Arthroscopic arthrodesis was performed in 17 patients, using open arthrotomy and malleolar ostectomy in 16. The mean time to arthrodesis for patients having the procedure arthroscopically was 8.7 weeks (range, six to 14 weeks), compared to 14.5 weeks in the open arthrotomy group (range, eight to 26 weeks; p less than 0.004). Despite differences in patient selection for each of the two groups, it was concluded that disabling ankle arthritis for certain patients may be more appropriately managed with arthroscopic arthrodesis than by arthrotomy and malleolar ostectomy, utilizing similar methods of internal fixation.     

踝关节融合术两种固定方式的三维有限元分析

[目的]通过三维有限元方法对踝关节融合的两种固定方式进行对比评价,并对其固定生物力学机制进行初步分析,为其临床应用提供理论依据.[方法]以正常人体踝关节CT扫描断层数据为基础,建立踝关节三维模型,模拟进行3螺钉固定和腓骨支撑固定手术,对模型中立、背屈、内旋和外旋4种载荷进行加载,分别进行有限元求解.[结果]3螺钉固定与腓骨支撑固定在抗旋转载荷上无明显差别,而在对抗背屈载荷作用优于腓骨支撑固定;在融合加压效果方面,3螺钉固定优于腓骨支撑固定,而腓骨支撑固定在移除外侧支撑腓骨后,加压作用有所下降;与腓骨支撑固定相比,3螺钉固定后的胫骨应力峰值更高且分布更集中,术后发生应力性骨折风险较高.[结论]在正常骨质条件下,3螺钉固定的生物力学稳定性以及融合加压效果均优于腓骨支撑固定,临床上建议首选3螺钉固定;而腓骨支撑固定的安全性较高,更适用于骨质条件较差的患者.