Ectopic sonic hedgehog signaling impairs telencephalic dorsal midline development: implication for human holoprosencephaly

Holoprosencephaly (HPE) is the most common developmental anomaly of the human forebrain, and in its severe form, the cerebral hemispheres fail to completely separate into two distinct halves. Although disruption of ventral forebrain induction is thought to underlie most HPE cases, a subset of HPE patients exhibits preferential dysgenesis of forebrain dorsal midline structures with unknown etiology. In this study, we show that Sonic hedgehog (Shh) lacking cholesterol moiety in one allele (ShhN/+) in mice can elicit ectopic Shh signaling in early telencephalon to induce ventral progenitor marker expression in the cortical region and impair telencephalic dorsal midline development. Prolonged ectopic ShhN signaling impaired Bmp and Wnt signaling from the dorsal patterning center through upregulation of Fgf8, leading to augmented cell proliferation, decreased cell death and impaired roof plate morphogenesis. Accordingly, ShhN/+ mutant telencephalic dorsal midline structures, including cortical hem, hippocampus and choroid plexus, either failed to form or were hypoplastic. Strikingly, ShhN/+ mutants displayed a spectrum of phenotypic features such as failure of anterior cerebral hemisphere to divide, hydrocephalus and cleft palate which have been observed in a human patient with milder HPE predicted to produce SHHN protein due to a truncation mutation in one SHH allele. We propose that elevated ectopic Shh signaling can impair dorsal telencephalic midline morphogenesis, and lead to non-cleavage of midline structures mimicking human HPE with dorsal midline defects.     

Signaling cascade coordinating growth of dorsal and ventral tissues of the vertebrate brain,with special reference to the involvement of Sonic hedgehog signaling

The vertebrate brain is a complex and highly organized structure with numerous neurons and glial cells. During development, undifferentiated progenitor cells proliferate from neural stem/precursor cells and gradually restrict their fates according to their environment. Differentiated cells are arranged precisely to accomplish their function and to maintain integrity as a whole brain. In this respect, cells must receive signals to know where and when they determine their fates. Secreted and membrane molecules convey the information between cells. The secreted glycoprotein Sonic hedgehog (Shh) is one of such signaling molecules. Sonic hedgehog is widely known to specify ventral neuronal types according to the concentration of Shh, whereas differentiation of dorsal neurons is largely independent of Shh. However, in the diencephalon and midbrain, dorsal parts are also affected in Shh-mutant embryos. Detailed analysis demonstrated that Shh signaling indirectly regulates the growth of the dorsal tissue in these regions. One of the fibroblast growth factor (FGF) members, namely FGF15, has been reported to be downstream to Shh signaling in the mouse embryonic brain. Luciferase assays and transgenic analysis revealed that the Fgf15 gene is a direct target of Shh. Downregulation of Tcf4 and upregulation of Bmp4 in Shh mutants suggest that Wnt and BMP signals from the dorsal midline are also involved in the dorsal brain phenotype. These data suggest the coordinating role of the Shh-FGF15-Wnt/BMP signaling cascade between the ventral and dorsal parts of the brain.     

Autonomous and nonautonomous roles of Hedgehog signaling in regulating limb muscle formation

Muscle progenitor cells migrate from the lateral somites into the developing vertebrate limb, where they undergo patterning and differentiation in response to local signals. Sonic hedgehog (Shh) is a secreted molecule made in the posterior limb bud that affects patterning and development of multiple tissues, including skeletal muscles. However, the cell-autonomous and non-cell-autonomous functions of Shh during limb muscle formation have remained unclear. We found that Shh affects the pattern of limb musculature non-cell-autonomously, acting through adjacent nonmuscle mesenchyme. However, Shh plays a cell-autonomous role in maintaining cell survival in the dermomyotome and initiating early activation of the myogenic program in the ventral limb. At later stages, Shh promotes slow muscle differentiation cell-autonomously. In addition, Shh signaling is required cell-autonomously to regulate directional muscle cell migration in the distal limb. We identify neuroepithelial cell transforming gene 1 (Net1) as a downstream target and effector of Shh signaling in that context.     

Hedgehog signaling in the posterior region of the mouse gastrula suggests manifold roles in the fetal-umbilical connection and posterior morphogenesis

Although many fetal birth defects, particularly those of the body wall and gut, are associated with abnormalities of the umbilical cord, the developmental relationship between these structures is largely obscure. Recently, genetic analysis of mid‐gestation mouse embryos revealed that defects in Hedgehog signaling led to omphalocoele, or failure of the body wall to close at the umbilical ring (Matsumaru et al. [ 2011 ] PLos One 6:e16260). However, systematic spatiotemporal localization of Hedgehog signaling in the allantois, or umbilical precursor tissue, and the surrounding regions has not been documented. Here, a combination of reagents, including the Ptc1:lacZ and Runx1:lacZ reporter mice, immunohistochemistry for Smoothened (Smo), Sonic Hedgehog (Shh), and Indian hedgehog (Ihh), and detailed PECAM‐1/Flk‐1/Runx‐1 analysis, revealed robust Hedgehog signaling in previously undocumented posterior sites over an extended period of time (～7.0–9.75 dpc). These included the recently described proximal walls of the allantois (Ventral and Dorsal Cuboidal Mesothelia; VCM and DCM, respectively); the ventral embryonic surface continuous with them; hemogenic arterial endothelia; hematopoietic cells; the hindgut; ventral ectodermal ridge (VER); chorionic ectoderm; and the intraplacental yolk sac (IPY), which appeared to be a site of placental hematopoiesis. This map of Hedgehog signaling in the posterior region of the mouse conceptus will provide a valuable foundation upon which to elucidate the origin of many posterior midline abnormalities, especially those of the umbilical cord and associated fetal defects. Developmental Dynamics 240:2175–2193, 2011. © 2011 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Wnt-dependent regulation of inner ear morphogenesis is balanced by the opposing and supporting roles of Shh

The inner ear is partitioned along its dorsal/ventral axis into vestibular and auditory organs, respectively. Gene expression studies suggest that this subdivision occurs within the otic vesicle, the tissue from which all inner ear structures are derived. While the specification of ventral otic fates is dependent on Shh secreted from the notochord, the nature of the signal responsible for dorsal otic development has not been described. In this study, we demonstrate that Wnt signaling is active in dorsal regions of the otic vesicle, where it functions to regulate the expression of genes (Dlx5/6 and Gbx2) necessary for vestibular morphogenesis. We further show that the source of Wnt impacting on dorsal otic development emanates from the dorsal hindbrain, and identify Wnt1 and Wnt3a as the specific ligands required for this function. The restriction of Wnt target genes to the dorsal otocyst is also influenced by Shh. Thus, a balance between Wnt and Shh signaling activities is key in distinguishing between vestibular and auditory cell types.     

Slow dorsal-ventral rhythm generator in the lamprey spinal cord

In the isolated lamprey spinal cord, a very slow rhythm (0.03-0.11 Hz), superimposed on fast N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA)-induced locomotor activity (0.26-2.98 Hz), could be induced by a blockade of GABA(A) or glycine receptors or by administration of (1 s, 3 s)-l-aminocyclopentane-1,3-dicarboxylic acid a metabotropic glutamate receptor agonist. Ventral root branches supplying dorsal and ventral myotomes were exposed bilaterally to study the motor pattern in detail. The slow rhythm was expressed in two main forms: 1) a dorsal-ventral reciprocal pattern was the most common (18 of 24 preparations), in which bilateral dorsal branches were synchronous and alternated with the ventral branches, in two additional cases a diagonal dorsal-ventral reciprocal pattern with alternation between the left (or right) dorsal and the right (or left) ventral branches was observed; 2) synchronous bursting in all branches was encountered in four cases. In contrast, the fast locomotor rhythm occurred always in a left-right reciprocal pattern. Thus when the slow rhythm appeared in a dorsal-ventral reciprocal pattern, fast rhythms would simultaneously display left-right alternation. A longitudinal midline section of the spinal cord during ongoing slow bursting abolished the reciprocal pattern between ipsilateral dorsal and ventral branches but a synchronous burst activity could still remain. The fast swimming rhythm did not recover after the midline section. These results suggest that in addition to the network generating the swimming rhythm in the lamprey spinal cord, there is also a network providing slow reciprocal alternation between dorsal and ventral parts of the myotome. During steering, a selective activation of dorsal and ventral myotomes is required and the neural network generating the slow rhythm may represent activity in the spinal machinery used for steering.     

A critical role for sonic hedgehog signaling in the early expansion of the developing brain.

The mechanisms that coordinate the three-dimensional shape of the vertebrate brain during development are largely unknown. We have found that sonic hedgehog (Shh) is crucial in driving the rapid, extensive expansion of the early vesicles of the developing midbrain and forebrain. Transient displacement of the notochord from the midbrain floor plate resulted in abnormal folding and overall collapse of the vesicles, accompanied by reduced cell proliferation and increased cell death in the midbrain. Simultaneously, expression of Shh decreased locally in the notochord and floor plate, whereas overt patterning and differentiation proceeded normally. Normal midbrain expansion was restored by implantation of Shh-secreting cells in a dose-dependent manner; conversely, expansion was retarded following antagonism of the Shh signaling pathway by cyclopamine. Our results indicate that Shh signaling from the ventral midline is essential for regulating brain morphogenesis during early development.     

A direct requirement for Hedgehog signaling for normal specification of all ventral progenitor domains in the presumptive mammalian spinal cord

The hedgehog signaling pathway organizes the developing ventral neural tube by establishing distinct neural progenitor fates along the dorsoventral axis. Smoothened (Smo) is essential for all Hedgehog (Hh) signaling, and genetic inactivation of Smo cells autonomously blocks the ability of cells to transduce the Hh signal. Using a chimeric approach, we examined the behavior of Smo null mutant neural progenitor cells in the developing vertebrate spinal cord, and we show that direct Hh signaling is essential for the specification of all ventral progenitor populations. Further, Hh signaling extends into the dorsal half of the spinal cord including the intermediate Dbx expression domain. Surprisingly, in the absence of Sonic hedgehog (Shh), we observe the presence of a Smo-dependent Hh signaling activity operating in the ventral half of the spinal cord that most likely reflects Indian hedgehog (Ihh) signaling originating from the underlying gut endoderm. Comparative studies of Shh, Smo, and Gli3 single and compound mutants reveal that Hh signaling acts in part to specify neural cell identity by counteracting the repressive action of Gli3 on p0, p1, p2, and pMN formation. However, whereas these cell identities are restored in Gli3/Smo compound mutants, correct stratification of the rescued ventral cell types is lost. Thus, Hh signaling is essential for organizing ventral cell pattern, possibly through the control of differential cell affinities.     

Xenopus sonic hedgehog guides retinal axons along the optic tract

The role of classic morphogens such as Sonic hedgehog (Shh) as axon guidance cues has been reported in a variety of vertebrate organisms (Charron and Tessier‐Lavigne [ 2005 ] Development 132:2251–2262). In this work, we provide the first evidence that Xenopus sonic hedgehog (Xshh) signaling is involved in guiding retinal ganglion cell (RGC) axons along the optic tract. Xshh is expressed in the brain during retinal axon extension, adjacent to these axons in the ventral diencephalon. Retinal axons themselves express Patched 1 and Smoothened co‐receptors during RGC axon growth. Blocking Shh signaling causes abnormal ventral pathfinding, and targeting errors at the optic tectum. Misexpression of exogenous N‐Shh peptide in vivo also causes pathfinding errors. Retinal axons grown in culture respond to N‐Shh in a dose‐dependent manner, either by decreasing extension at lower concentrations, or retracting axons in the presence of higher doses. These data suggest that Shh signaling is required for normal RGC axon pathfinding and tectal targeting in the developing visual system of Xenopus. We propose that Shh serves as a ventral optic tract repellent that helps to define the caudal boundary for retinal axons in the diencephalon, and that this signaling is also required for initial target recognition at the optic tectum. Developmental Dynamics 239:2921–2932, 2010. © 2010 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Absence of ventral cell populations in the developing brain in a rat model of the Smith-Lemli-Opitz syndrome

The Smith-Lemli-Opitz syndrome (SLOS) is an autosomal recessive condition involving craniofacial and central nervous system malformations with occasional holoprosencephaly (HPE). It is caused by a defect in the 7-dehydrocholesterol (7-DHC) reductase, the enzyme catalyzing the last step of cholesterol biosynthesis. Treatment of pregnant rats with inhibitors of 7-DHC reductase, either AY9944 or BM15.766, has provided a valuable model to study the pathogenesis in SLOS. Recently, cholesterol has been shown to be involved in the post-translational activation of the signaling protein Sonic Hedgehog. To identify the early defects associated with HPE in a rat model of SLOS, and to compare the phenotype of the treated embryos with that of the Shh(-/-) mutants, we examined brain morphology and expression of three developmental genes (Shh, Otx2, and Pax6 ) in 23-somite stage embryos from AY9944-treated dams. We report clearly abnormal morphology of the developing brain, concerning primarily the ventral aspect of the neural tube. We observed a reduced or absent expression of Shh and Otx2 in their ventral domain associated with extended ventral expression of Pax6. The results suggest an absence of the midline ventral cell type at all levels of the cranial neural tube. They provide further evidence that cholesterol-deficiency-induced HPE originates from impaired Shh signaling activity in the ventral neural tube.     

Sonic hedgehog patterning in chick neural plate is antagonized by a Wnt3-like signal.

Sonic hedgehog (Shh) patterns the dorsal-ventral axis of the neural tube by promoting the differentiation of ventral neural cell types while suppressing dorsal neural fates. Other signals impinge upon the Shh response, biasing the differentiation of a cell. Three dorsally expressed transforming Wnts, of which the most broadly expressed is Wnt3, may be among the signals that influence the Shh response. We demonstrate that activation of Wnt signaling results in an inhibition of the Shh response in neural tissue. Additionally, we show that the expression pattern of chick Wnt3 is consistent with a role in neural patterning. These results indicate that differentiating neural tube cells, besides integrating signals from Hedgehogs and BMPs, may also incorporate a Wnt response to make cell fate decisions.     

The seven-transmembrane receptor smoothened cell-autonomously induces multiple ventral cell types

Sonic Hedgehog (Shh) is a secreted protein that controls cell fate and mitogenesis in the developing nervous system. Here we show that a constitutively active form of Smoothened (Smo-M2) mimics concentration-dependent actions of Shh in the developing neural tube, including activation of ventral marker genes (HNF3beta, patched, Nkx2.2, netrin-1), suppression of dorsal markers (Pax-3, Gli-3, Ephrin A5) and induction of ventral neurons (dopaminergic, serotonergic) and ventrolateral motor neurons (Islet-1+, Islet-2+, HB9+) and interneurons (Engrailed-1+, CHX10+). Furthermore, Smo-M2's patterning activities were cell autonomous, occurring exclusively in cells expressing Smo-M2. These findings suggest that Smo is a key signaling component in the Hh receptor and that Shh patterns the vertebrate nervous system as a morphogen, rather than through secondary relay signals.     

Somatotopic organization in cat spinal cord segments with fused dorsal horns: caudal and thoracic levels

We have explored the somatotopic organization of the two cat spinal cord regions where the dorsal horns are fused (i.e., continuous across the midline): the caudal and thoracic segments. We have mapped the low-threshold component of dorsal horn cell receptive fields (RFs) in these segments and have charted the locations of dorsal root low-threshold mechanoreceptive dermatomes. We also have determined the projections of caudal and thoracic dorsal roots to laminae III and IV by using degeneration techniques. The dorsal skin of the tail or thorax is represented laterally, and ventral skin is represented at the midline, in the fused dorsal horns. Many caudal and thoracic dorsal horn units had RFs that crossed the dorsal or ventral midline of the skin; these units were encountered near the edges or the midline, respectively, of the fused dorsal horns. The tail is fully represented within dorsal root dermatomes S3 to Ca5. Roots more caudal than Ca5 represent progressively smaller skin areas of the distal tail. Adjacent dermatomes overlapped 15-65%. Thoracic dermatomes had a nearly vertical orientation; adjacent dermatomes overlapped by 30-75%. Dorsal roots in caudal and thoracic regions have crossed projections to the medial and lateral (but not middle) portions of the contralateral dorsal horn. These crossed projections are a possible anatomical substrate for RFs that cross the ventral or dorsal midline. The dorsal root projection patterns are consistent with those that would be predicted from the dorsal root dermatomes and dorsal horn cell somatotopy, assuming that the presynaptic terminals' somatotopy is in register with that of dorsal horn cells (the presynaptic somatotopy hypothesis; see Ref. 12).     

Ventral specification and perturbed boundary formation in the mouse midbrain in the absence of Hedgehog signaling.

Although Hedgehog (HH) signaling plays a critical role in patterning the ventral midbrain, its role in early midbrain specification is not known. We examined the midbrains of sonic hedgehog (Shh) and smoothened (Smo) mutant mice where HH signaling is respectively attenuated and eliminated. We show that some ventral (Evx1+) cell fates are specified in the Shh-/- mouse in a Ptc1- and Gli1-independent manner. HH-independent ventral midbrain induction was further confirmed by the presence of a Pax7-negative ventral midbrain territory in both Shh-/- and Smo-/- mice at and before embryonic day (E) 8.5. Midbrain signaling centers are severely disrupted in the Shh-/- mutant. Interestingly, dorsal markers are up-regulated (Wnt1, Gdf7, Pax7), down-regulated (Lfng), or otherwise altered (Zic1) in the Shh-/- midbrain. Together with the increased cell death seen specifically in Shh-/- dorsal midbrains (E8.5-E9), our results suggest specific regulation of dorsal patterning by SHH, rather than a simple deregulation due to its absence.     

Dynamic expression pattern of Sonic hedgehog in developing cochlear spiral ganglion neurons

Sonic hedgehog (Shh) signaling plays important roles in the formation of the auditory epithelium. However, little is known about the detailed expression pattern of Shh and the cell sources from which Shh is secreted. By analyzing Shh^CreEGFP/+ mice, we found that Shh was first expressed in all cochlear spiral ganglion neurons by embryonic day 13.5, after which its expression gradually decreased from base to apex. By postnatal day 0, it was not detected in any spiral ganglion neurons. Genetic cell fate mapping results also confirmed that Shh was exclusively expressed in all spiral ganglion neurons and not in surrounding glia cells. The basal‐to‐apical wave of Shh decline strongly resembles that of hair cell differentiation, supporting the idea that Shh signaling inhibits hair cell differentiation. Furthermore, this Shh^CreEGFP/+ mouse is a useful Cre line in which to delete floxed genes specifically in spiral ganglion neurons of the developing cochlea. Developmental Dynamics 239:1674–1683, 2010. © 2010 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.