Therapeutic implications of left, right, and bilateral varicocelectomy

It now appears that the incidence of bilateral varicoceles in infertile men with varicocele may be around 50 per cent to 60 per cent. Infertile men should be examined carefully for varicoceles on both sides, and bilateral varicocelectomy should be performed when indicated. Furthermore, we have demonstrated that selected infertile patients who have failed to improve after left varicocelectomy may yet improve after correction of the right varicocele.     

High prevalence of bilateral varicoceles confirmed with ultrasonography

Objective: To determine the incidence ofbilateral varicoceles in men presenting to asingle infertility clinic.Subjects and methods: From March 1999 toMarch 2000, 60 men presenting with an inabilityto initiate pregnancy (consecutive andunselected), were determined by clinical examto have varicoceles. These men were sent forcolor Doppler ultrasound to evaluate theincidence of varicocele bilaterality. Two menwith a solitary testis were excluded from thestudy.Results: Of the 58 men, 45 (77.5%) hadultrasound verified bilateral varicoceles. Inthe 13 remaining patients, 8 (13.8%) had aunilateral left varicocele, 4 (6.9%) had novaricoceles demonstrated by ultrasound, and asingle patient (1.7%) was reported to have aunilateral right varicocele.Conclusions: Routine scrotal ultrasoundprovides valuable information in the diagnosticevaluation of infertile men. Based onadvancements in diagnostic techniques,investigators have recently observed that theincidence of bilateral varicoceles to besignificantly greater than the previouslyreported. Our study demonstrated theincidence of bilaterality in infertile men tobe a substantial 77.5%. An overlooked rightvaricocele (whether subclinical or not) may bedetrimental to future fertility and needsfurther investigation.     

Varicocele

Approximately one third of infertile men present with varicocele, while the incidence among males in the general public is approximately 15 per cent. The etiology may be a longer left spermatic vein with its right-angle insertion into the left renal vein and/or absence of valves, which causes a higher hydrostatic pressure in the left spermatic vein causing dilatation. The nutcracker phenomenon is also a possible etiology. Much of the pathophysiology is still unknown, but increased blood flow causing an elevated intratesticular temperature may be of significance. Though there are many recent reports on the importance of a subclinical varicocele, we are not convinced of its significance. The best method for diagnosis remains a good clinical examination. The incidence of adolescents with varicocele is about the same as men with varicocele (approximately 15 per cent). Adolescents with varicocele should be treated if the testicular mass is decreased or if they are symptomatic. Surgical ligation is still the preferred method of treatment. Percutaneous treatment of varicoceles has an approximately 11 per cent incidence of minor complications and an occlusion rate of 73 per cent with a recurrence rate of 5 per cent. We reserve percutaneous treatment for recurrent varicoceles after surgical ligation, but primary percutaneous therapy is a reasonable approach.     

COMPARISON OF BILATERAL VERSUS UNILATERAL VARICOCELECTOMY IN MEN WITH PALPABLE BILATERAL VARICOCELES

PURPOSE: The left varicocele is usually larger in men with bilateral varicoceles. We hypothesized that most of the benefit of varicocelectomy would derive from repair of the larger varicocele. To test this hypothesis we prospectively compared the effect of unilateral versus bilateral microsurgical varicocelectomy in men with large (grade III) or moderate (II) left varicocele associated with small but palpable (I) right varicocele. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A total of 91 patients were prospectively followed and included in the study. Of the patients 65 underwent bilateral and 26 underwent unilateral left repair. All patients underwent preoperative and postoperative semen analysis. RESULTS: Motile sperm concentration increased from 12.1+/-1.7 to 23.7+/-31.8 (95.8% change) in the bilateral group compared with an increase from 19.5+/-21.4 to 27.8+/-34.8 (42.6% change) in the unilateral group (p<0.05). Similarly, sperm concentration increased from 23.8+/-29.5 to 48.6+/-61.3 (157.6% change) in the bilateral group compared with an increase from 41.1+/-40.9 to 59.5+/-66.7 (44.8% change) in the unilateral group (p<0.05). CONCLUSIONS: Bilateral varicocelectomy resulted in significantly greater improvement in post-operative seminal parameters than unilateral repair in patients with grades II to III left varicocele associated with grade I right varicocele. Even a small, unrepaired palpable right varicocele continues to have a detrimental effect on bilateral testis function. Men with bilateral palpable varicoceles require bilateral repair.     

Microsurgical varicocelectomy for clinical varicocele: A review for potential new indications

Microsurgical varicocelectomy is considered the gold‐standard technique treating varicocele in both adults and adolescents, due to relatively more favourable outcomes and lower post‐operative recurrence and complication rates. Despite of mounting literature on this topic, several aspects are still not well defined. We summarised the most recent literature and presented findings that might extend its indications. Microsurgical varicocelectomy and intracytoplasmic sperm injection are both effective to father a child for infertile men with clinical varicocele even for those with worst condition of spermatozoa, nonobstructive azoospermia, and prior varicocele repair has substantial benefits for couples with a clinical varicocele. Microsurgical subinguinal and inguinal varicocelectomy seem to have comparable effectiveness for adolescents and infertile men with varicoceles. However, the subinguinal approach may have some advantages to deal with painful varicocele. The superior outcomes of bilateral varicocelectomy for patients with clinical left varicocele and concomitant clinical right varicocele are justified, while the benefit is still uncertain for concomitant subclinical right varicocele. Varicocelectomy may have the potential to improve sexual function along with serum testosterone. In conclusion, indications for microsurgical varicocelectomy may be extended by the concomitant right and left clinical varicocele and sexual dysfunction with varicocele.     

Pituitary Gonadal Function in Infertile Men with Varicocele

Infertile men with varicocele or idiopathic infertility were compared with a control group. Spermocytograms were taken and the following radioimmunological plasma analyses carried out: testosterone, FSH and LH before and after 50 micrograms LRH, Prolactin (PRL) before and after 200 micrograms TRH; in addition, 8 patients with varicoceles and 3 controls received LRH intravenously (0.4 microgram/min.) for 4 hours. The binding of [125I] human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) to testicular tissue obtained by biopsy from 10 infertile men was also investigated. Of the parameters studied, no differences were found between the unilateral or bilateral varicoceles. In the two groups of infertile men, sperm motility and percentage normal forms were similar and significantly lower than in controls. As compared to the controls, in the groups of infertile men, basal LH and testosterone levels were no different but basal FSH levels was increased, basal PRL was higher (p less than 0.05) in the varicocele group. Responses of the LH, FSH and PRL to LRH and TRH stimulations were generally higher in infertile men than in controls. As compared to the idiopathic infertile men, testosterone levels and responses of plasma FSH to LRH injection were lower in varicocele group. Moreover, in infertile men with varicocele, age was correlated negatively with sperm motility and testosterone level and it was correlated positively with LH response to LRH injection. For each patient, testicular tissue was able to specifically bind [125I]hCG, but in some cases of varicoceles, hCG binding capacity was different in the two testes and seemed higher than that observed in men with obstructive azoospermia. These results suggest: 1) dysfunction in both spermatogenesis and Leydig cells with a compensatory hyperfunction of the pituitary gland in infertile men with varicocele; 2) worsening in Leydig cells and tubular lesions with longer duration of varicocele; and 3) absence of any gross abnormality in hCG binding to its specific receptors in the testis of men with varicocele. These data suggest varicoceles may play a causal role in infertility.     

Correlation of testicular color Doppler ultrasonography, physical examination and venography in the detection of left varicoceles in men with infertility

High resolution color Doppler ultrasound is a noninvasive means of simultaneously imaging and evaluating the blood flow to the testes. To define the ability of color Doppler ultrasound to detect clinically evident as well as subclinical varicoceles men referred to our urology division with oligospermia and infertility underwent spermatic vein venography of the left testis if there was physical examination and/or color Doppler ultrasound evidence of a varicocele. The detection of valvular incompetence on venography was considered diagnostic for a varicocele. Of 17 study patients physical examination detected 10 of 14 venographically evident varicoceles (71%), whereas color Doppler ultrasound detected 13 of 14 (93%). Of 5 patients with a normal physical examination but with color Doppler ultrasound evidence of a varicocele 4 had a confirmatory venogram, and 1 of 2 patients with a varicocele on physical examination and a normal Doppler ultrasound had a positive venogram. These data suggest that color Doppler ultrasound of the testis may more appropriately direct further invasive testing and therapy of infertile men than physical examination alone.     

亚临床精索静脉曲张的诊治体会

对７５例体检正常的男性不育患者行高分辨彩色多普勒血流显像（ＣＤＦＩ）检查，发现亚临床精索静脉曲张（ＳＣＶ）４０例，其中左侧者２６例（６５％），双侧者１４例（３５％），行精索静脉高位结扎术３３例，行经皮精索胸脉栓塞术７例，术后３５例获得６个月随访，结果显示术后精子密度，精子活动率及正常形态精子率均明显改善，认为ＣＤＦＩ是诊断ＳＣＶ的一种简便，可靠的方法，其治疗应依据患者具有情况而定。     

Semen and reproductive hormone parameters in fertile men with and without varicocele

Although varicoceles are a widely accepted identifiable male factor in infertile couples, the benefit of varicocele repair in improving pregnancy and live birth rates remains uncertain. The Study for Future Families obtained semen and reproductive hormone samples from US men whose partners were currently pregnant. In our analysis cohort of 709 men, a varicocele was detected by clinical examination in 56 (8%) of men. Men with varicocele had smaller left testis, and lower total and total motile sperm counts than men without varicocele. Gonadotropin levels were higher as well in men with varicocele. Interestingly, testosterone levels were also slightly higher in men with varicocele. Despite these differences, there was no difference between the groups in the time to achieve the study pregnancy or percentage of men with a previous pregnancy. We conclude that even in fertile men, varicoceles are associated with some degree of testicular hypofunction. This would support current recommendations to consider varicocele repair in male partners in infertile couples who demonstrate both a varicocele and abnormal semen parameters and after evaluation for treatable female factors.     

Multiparametric evaluation of testicular atrophy due to varicocele

63 men with palpable left varicoceles were evaluated by semen analysis, scrotal ultrasonography, Doppler sonography, scrotal contact thermography, and radionuclide scanning. 11 (17.4%) patients had bilateral varicoceles detected by scrotal ultrasonography as compared with an incidence of 3.1% by scrotal palpation. Testicular atrophy was found in 29 (46%) patients by scrotal ultrasonography. This was found to be 39.6% by scrotal palpation alone. In this study using advanced diagnostic procedures, the incidences of bilateral varicocele and testicular atrophy due to varicocele were found to be much higher than when scrotal palpation alone was performed.     

Incidence of varicoceles in patients with ankylosing spondylitis evaluated by physical examination and color duplex sonography

Objectives. To assess the incidence of varicocele in ankylosing spondylitis (AS) in comparison to healthy age-matched controls.Methods. Twenty-one male patients with AS who were not taking disease-modifying antirheumatic drugs (eg, sulfasalazine, a well-known cause of drug-induced infertility) and age-matched healthy controls were evaluated with both physical examination and color duplex sonography for varicocele. The maximal vein diameters of pampiniform plexus and duration of reflux were recorded. Semen samples were also analyzed in both groups.Results. Patients with AS had a higher incidence of clinical varicoceles (52%) compared with the healthy age-matched controls (20%). On color Doppler examination, 12 patients (57%) had varicocele (3 bilateral and 9 on the left side) and 6 controls had varicocele on the left side. The patients with AS had significantly greater vein diameters of pampiniform plexus on the left and right side compared with the controls.Conclusions. The incidence of varicocele is increased in patients with AS, and its clinical relevance needs to be evaluated.     

Improvement of semen characteristics after surgical repair of bilateral testicular varicocele as compared to unilateral varicocele patients

The operative treatment for surgical repair of bilateral testicular varicoceles was evaluated in terms of the improvement achieved in the sperm density and percentage progressive motile sperm. These parameters were compared for 27 cases of bilateral varicocele diagnosed by palpation and subjected to bilateral high ligation of the internal spermatic vein and for 40 cases of left unilateral testicular varicocele. There were no significant differences in preoperative values (such as sperm density; progressive motile sperm; serum levels of luteinizing hormone, follicle-stimulating hormone, and testosterone; and Johnson's score count) between the bilateral and unilateral testicular varicocele groups. The improvement in postoperative sperm density in the cases with bilateral testicular varicocele was apparently less satisfactory than in the cases with testicular varicocele only on the left side.     

Diagnosis of pediatric varicoceles by physical examination and ultrasonography and measurement of the testicular volume: using the prader orchidometer versus ultrasonography

INTRODUCTION: The differentiation of unilateral versus bilateral varicoceles and testicular volume measurements are important in determining the need for adolescent varicocele surgery and also in following patients after varicocelectomy. The aim of this study was to prospectively compare the findings of physical examination and color Doppler ultrasonography in the diagnosis of pediatric varicoceles and to compare the findings using the Prader orchidometer and scrotal ultrasonography in the measurement of testicular volumes. PATIENTS AND METHODS: This study included 68 boys with varicoceles, ranging in age from 8 to 19 years. Varicoceles were diagnosed using both physical examination and scrotal color Doppler ultrasonography. The testicular volumes of 136 testicles were measured using the Prader orchidometer and scrotal ultrasonography. A difference of more than 10% or 2 ml in each testicular volume was considered significant. RESULTS: The mean age of the boys was 13.5 +/- 2.3 years. On physical examination, a left unilateral varicocele was diagnosed in 46 boys (67.6%). The other 22 boys (32.4%) had bilateral varicoceles. Color Doppler ultrasonography detected bilateral varicoceles in 4 of the 46 boys (8.7%) who were diagnosed by physical examination as having only left unilateral varicoceles (grade 3 in 3 patients and grade 2 in 1 patient). A different of more than 10% or 2 ml in testicular volume using the Prader orchidometer versus scrotal ultrasonography was detected in 3 out of 136 testicles (2.2%). The correlation between ultrasonography and Prader orchidometer results in the measurement of testicular volumes was statistically highly significantly consistent using the intraclass correlation test (r = 0.997 and p < 0.001 for the left testis; r = 0.998 and p < 0.001 for the right testis). CONCLUSIONS: Although the management of subclinical varicoceles remains controversial, these data show that color Doppler ultrasonography may be necessary in the diagnosis of bilateral varicoceles, especially in boys with high-grade left varicoceles. In contrast, scrotal ultrasonography, if considered the gold standard, did not show superiority over the Prader orchidometer in measuring testicular volumes.     

Incidence and clinical significance of subclinical scrotal varicoceles

A total of 40 infertile men with a normal physical examination underwent gonadal venography to determine the presence of a subclinical varicocele. Of the patients 19 had a left and 3 had a right subclinical varicocele. A total of 21 patients underwent radiographic occlusion of the varicoceles, while 1 required surgical ligation of the internal spermatic vein. Of the 22 patients 13 have been followed for greater than 6 months after correction of the varicocele. In these patients there has been a small but significant increase in sperm number after varicocele occlusion. No significant changes in either sperm motility or morphology have occurred. Although most patients do not have any major improvement after occlusion of a subclinical varicocele, some may experience a significant improvement in sperm number after occlusion. The effect on pregnancy rates is not yet known.     

Bilateral Varicocele: Impact of Right Spermatic Vein Ligation on Fertility

The most frequent cause of male infertility is left varicocele. The surgical or laparoscopic approach for spermatic vein ligation is considered the best method of treatment. The approach to a clinically significant left varicocele associated with a right varicocele (frequently of a smaller size) is not univocal. We analyzed the seminal responses obtained in 65 patients with bilateral varicocele (grades 2 to 3 on the left side and grade 1 on the right side) assigned randomly to undergo unilateral or bilateral ligation. There were no significant differences between the 2 groups with regard to seminal recovery.     

不育男性双侧Ⅰ度精索静脉曲张对睾丸体积和生殖激素水平的影响

目的 评价不育男性双侧I度精索静脉曲张对睾丸体积和生殖激素水平的影响.方法 185例不育男性双侧I度精索静脉曲张(A组)和149例正常生育男性(B组),比较其睾丸体积、卵泡刺激素(FSH)、黄体生成素(LH)和睾酮(T)水平.结果 A组患者两侧睾丸体积均小于B组,但睾丸体积绝对差异和睾丸体积相对差异与B组比较,无统计学意义.A组患者血清FSH水平高于B组,而LH、T与B组相比,差异无统计学意义.结论 不育男性双侧I度精索静脉曲张可导致患者双侧睾丸体积减小,血清FSH水平升高.     

The effects of unilateral, experimental varicocele are not mediated through the ipsilateral testis

Unilateral varicocele has been associated with diminished male fertility in humans and with bilateral physiologic and histologic changes in the testis of humans and laboratory animals. In particular, left varicocele in Sprague-Dawley rats results in bilateral increases in testicular temperature and blood flow. The mechanism by which unilateral varicocele can cause testicular changes is not known. The purpose of the present study was to determine whether or not the presence of either the ipsilateral or contralateral testicle is necessary for these effects of the varicocele to occur in the opposite testis. Varicoceles were created in adult, male rats by partial constriction of the left renal vein. Bilateral testicular blood flow was measured by a radiolabelled microsphere distribution technique and testicular temperature was taken with a needle probe thermometer. Right or left orchiectomies were performed on selected animals at the time of surgery to establish the unilateral left varicocele. Animals were studied 30 days after surgery. Mean testicular blood flow was significantly increased (P less than 0.01) in all animals having a left varicocele when compared with animals not having a varicocele regardless of whether a unilateral orchiectomy was performed. Likewise, the mean difference between intraabdominal temperature and intratesticular temperature (delta T) was significantly decreased in all groups of animals having varicoceles when compared with groups without varicoceles whether or not an orchiectomy had been performed. Thus, the studied bilateral effects of left-sided, experimental varicocele in the rat are not dependent upon the presence of a left testicle.     

Bilateral is superior to unilateral varicocelectomy in infertile males with left clinical and right subclinical varicocele: a prospective randomized controlled study

Purpose

The purpose of this study is to compare the effect of bilateral versus unilateral varicocelectomy on seminal response and spontaneous pregnancy rates in infertile male patients with left clinical and right subclinical varicocele.

Methods

A total of 358 infertile men with left clinical and right subclinical varicocele were randomized to group that underwent bilateral (n = 179) and group that underwent unilateral microsurgical subinguinal varicocelectomy (n = 179). Baseline data regarding male age, female partner age, grade of varicocele body mass index, bilateral testicular volume and serum follicle-stimulating hormone, luteinizing hormone, total testosterone levels and infertility duration and semen parameters were gathered. One year after the surgery, semen parameters including sperm volume, sperm concentration, normal sperm morphology, progressive motility and sperm DNA fragmentation index were recorded and any pregnancy was also documented via telephone calls and hospital visits.

Results

We found the baseline characteristics were comparable between the two groups. The seminal parameters had significant improvements 1 year postoperatively in both groups. However, the bilateral group showed significantly greater improvements than the unilateral group in sperm concentration, normal sperm morphology and progressive motility. Besides, the pregnancy rate was statistically higher in the bilateral group after the surgery (42.5 versus 26.0%, bilateral versus unilateral group).

Conclusion

In conclusion, our study indicated that bilateral is superior to unilateral varicocelectomy in infertile males with left clinical and right subclinical varicocele, which is associated with greater improvements in sperm concentration, normal sperm morphology and progressive motility and spontaneous pregnancy rate after the surgery.

     

Predictive parameters of successful varicocele repair

A total of 130 men presenting with oligospermia and clinically identifiable scrotal varicoceles was evaluated, treated surgically and followed for 1 year for pregnancy rate. The treatment outcome was compared to an age-matched cohort of 83 oligospermic men who had received empirical medical therapy with clomiphene citrate (25 mg. per day) for the same 1-year interval. This study was done to contrast treatment modalities in infertility and not as a strict control. Only eugonadotropic patients in both groups were used for comparison. In the varicocele group the over-all pregnancy rate was 38.5 per cent. Four variables (a lack of testicular atrophy, sperm density greater than 50 million per ejaculate, sperm motility 60 per cent or more and serum follicle-stimulating hormone values less than 300 ng. per ml.) proved to be accurate preoperative predictors of postoperative pregnancy success. Four other variables (varicocele size and laterality, sperm forward progression greater than 2 and normal sperm morphology 60 per cent or more) did not yield statistically significant rates of improvement in pregnancy postoperatively. The pregnancy rate of the eugonadotropic patients undergoing varicocele repair was 45.8 per cent. Despite statistical similarity in patient age, sperm density and mean gonadotropin levels the medically treated patients had a pregnancy rate of only 25.5 per cent, significantly lower than the surgically treated patients. In summary, patients with an identifiable varicocele had a greater chance of achieving a pregnancy following surgical correction than did those treated with empirical drug therapy. In addition, certain preoperative variables in the physical and laboratory analyses appeared to portend a greater surgical response.     

Scleroembolization techniques in the treatment of varicocele.

Varicocele is a common finding in adolescents and adult men. Its association with male infertility has been well documented: varicoceles are reported to be present in 20% to 40% of infertile men. It has been demonstrated that varicocele correction leads to an improvement in the quality of semen in most cases. Percutaneous sclerotization is an established method for treatment of varicocele performed on an outpatient basis. In our report we intend to review our experience in venographic study and transcatheter sclerotherapy based on 560 cases of infertile patients with varicocele. Our study confirms that percutaneous therapy of varicocele may lead to improved spermatogenesis in the majority of patients.