Clinical Operational Tolerance after Kidney Transplantation

Induction of allograft-specific tolerance and the detection of a "tolerance" state in recipients under immunosuppression with long-term stable graft function are major challenges in transplantation. Clinical "operational tolerance," defined as stable and acceptable graft function without immunosuppression for years, is a rare event. There is no report on the clinical history of such patients. In this article, we report on the medical history of 10 kidney recipients who display an immunosuppressive drug-free "operational tolerance" for 9.4 +/- 5.2 years. Clinical factors that may favor such a tolerant state are underlined. Firstly, most of the patients interrupted immunosuppression over a long time period (until 4 years), which mimics the procedure of intentional immunosuppression weaning following liver transplantation. Secondly, donor age was younger (median 25 years) than the one of the general transplanted population, suggesting that graft quality is one of the conditions favoring "operational tolerance." Moreover, the "operationally tolerant" recipients may be 'low responders' to blood transfusions (PRA 6 +/- 5.4%, six blood transfusions). We also show that "operational tolerance" occurs in the presence of anti-donor class II antibodies, as assessed in two patients. Finally, two patients degraded their renal function 9 to 13 years after treatment withdrawal, however only one presented histological lesions of chronic rejection.     

免疫球蛋白样转录物3和4在肾移植受者树突状细胞中表达的意义

目的 探讨免疫球蛋白样转录物3和4(ILT3和ILT4)在肾移植受者外周血树突状细胞(DC)中的表达情况,并分析其在移植免疫低反应中的作用.方法 选择肾移植后存活5年以上肾功能稳定和慢性排斥反应的受者各10例,分别作为肾功能稳定组和慢性排斥组;另选择10例健康志愿者作为正常对照组.用粒-巨噬细胞集落刺激因子(GM-CSF)和白细胞介素4(IL-4)刺激各组研究对象的外周血单核细胞,诱导培养获得DC.用流式细胞仪测定DC表面分子ILT3和ILT4的表达,并分析各组DC表达的差异;用酶联免疫吸附试验法测定各组血清中ILT3和ILT4的配体HLA-G5的表达水平.结果 ILT3在肾功能稳定组DC中表达水平上调,与正常对照组和慢性排斥组比较,差异有统计学意义(P＜0.05),而ILT4的表达在各组间比较,差异无统计学意义(P＞0.05);肾功能稳定组血清中HLA-G5的表达水平较正常对照组和慢性排斥组显著升高,差异有统计学意义(P＜0.05).结论 长期存活的肾功能稳定受者外周血中高表达ILT3和其配体HLA-G,说明它们可能在外周免疫耐受的诱导和维持中起非常重要的作用.     

Can the Toll-like receptors 4 expression in peripheral blood mononuclear cells help assess the effectiveness of immunosuppression and the chance of a future good renal transplant function?

BackgroundA small percentage of peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) circulating during the kidney transplantation (KT) period remain in the blood long after transplantation. A part of the PBMCs penetrates the graft.AimTo examine if the choice of immunosuppression may change TLR4ex and how TLR4ex affects the transplant function in the future.MaterialThe study population-143 transplanted patients (pts) (55 females, 88 males), mean age on recruitment day 50.33 ± 12.8 years old, mean BMI 25.04 ± 4.18. 41 pts. experienced delayed graft function (DGF+). 55 pts. were treated with cyclosporine A (CsA) and 88 with tacrolimus (Tac). All were treated with mofetil mycophenolate (MMF). The PBMCs acquisition and starting point of the follow-up (TLR-day) was at least one month after KT.MethodWe investigated averaged mRNA expression of Toll-like receptors 4 (TLR4ex) in non-stimulated peripheral blood mononuclear cells with the use of real-time polymerase chain reaction. The KT pts. (All, Tac, CsA, DGF+) were divided by the respective median of their TLR4ex (lower: L-TLR4ex, higher: H-TLR4ex). Main clinical parameters and transplant biopsy files (if available) were assessed on TLR-day and post follow-up.ResultsWe found that TLR4ex was reduced for a long time in patients who experienced delayed graft function. L-TLR4ex had a higher proportion of DGF+ patients, and patients treated with CsA but lower of those treated with Tac than in H-TLR4ex. The amplitude of changes in renal function parameters (ΔEGFR%/ΔsCr/ΔsCr%) was clearly less favorable for L-TLR4ex. Tacrolimus expressed a stabilizing effect. Both the positive vasculitis score and chronic graft nephropathy were more frequent in the L-TLR4ex group. On TLR-day an association of renal function and Tac concentration with TLR4ex was clear only in the tacrolimus population. The TLR4ex was lower in patients with a future deterioration of the graft function.ConclusionIn kidney transplant recipients the occurrence of DGF results in a long-term reduction of the averaged TLR4ex in PBMC. Tacrolimus exerts a clear, stabilizing, positive and dose-dependent effect on TLR4ex. An improvement in renal transplant function may be expected in KT patients with high TLR4ex. Evaluation of the averaged TLR4ex can be used to assess the efficacy of immunosuppression in the treatment with tacrolimus and to estimate the likelihood of deterioration in renal function.     

Recipient Myd88 Deficiency Promotes Spontaneous Resolution of Kidney Allograft Rejection

The myeloid differentiation protein 88 (MyD88) adapter protein is an important mediator of kidney allograft rejection, yet the precise role of MyD88 signaling in directing the host immune response toward the development of kidney allograft rejection remains unclear. Using a stringent mouse model of allogeneic kidney transplantation, we demonstrated that acute allograft rejection occurred equally in MyD88-sufficient (wild-type [WT]) and MyD88^−/− recipients. However, MyD88 deficiency resulted in spontaneous diminution of graft infiltrating effector cells, including CD11b⁻Gr-1⁺ cells and activated CD8 T cells, as well as subsequent restoration of near-normal renal graft function, leading to long-term kidney allograft acceptance. Compared with T cells from WT recipients, T cells from MyD88^−/− recipients failed to mount a robust recall response upon donor antigen restimulation in mixed lymphocyte cultures ex vivo. Notably, exogenous IL-6 restored the proliferation rate of T cells, particularly CD8 T cells, from MyD88^−/− recipients to the proliferation rate of cells from WT recipients. Furthermore, MyD88^−/− T cells exhibited diminished expression of chemokine receptors, specifically CCR4 and CXCR3, and the impaired ability to accumulate in the kidney allografts despite an otherwise MyD88-sufficient environment. These results provide a mechanism linking the lack of intrinsic MyD88 signaling in T cells to the effective control of the rejection response that results in spontaneous resolution of acute rejection and long-term graft protection.     

P-glycoprotein expression is not a useful predictor of acute or chronic kidney graft rejection

Because of the role of P-glycoprotein (P-gp) in multidrug resistance (MDR), it has been suggested that P-gp might play a role in acute and chronic rejection after organ transplantation. The purpose of the present work was to investigate a possible relationship between graft outcome and P-gp expression on peripheral mononuclear cells of renal transplant recipients. We determined P-gp expression in 27 patients with long-term, stable graft function (ST) and in 15 patients with chronic deterioration of graft function (CR). In addition, 40 patients were studied prior to, and at intervals after, transplantation with 21 healthy individuals serving as controls. P-gp values were highest in healthy controls and in ST patients. We found no correlation between P-gp values and acute rejection. CR patients tended to have lower levels of P-gp expression. Our results contradict the opinion that an overexpression of P-gp induces acute or chronic rejection by inhibiting the efficacy of immunosuppressive treatment. Received: 9 June 1998 Accepted: 25 September 1998     

Requirement of MyD88 for macrophage-mediated islet xenograft rejection after adoptive transfer

BACKGROUND: Porcine antigen primed and CD4+ T-cell activated macrophages are able to migrate to and destroy porcine xenografts. However, the specific signaling mechanisms involved remain to be identified. METHODS: In this study macrophages which lack the universal toll-like receptor (TLR) adaptor MyD88 were used to investigate the role of TLR in the recognition and activation of macrophages in islet xenograft rejection. Macrophages were isolated from rejecting MyD88(-/-) and wild-type C57BL/6 mice that were recipients of neonatal porcine pancreatic cell cluster (NPCC) xenografts, and were transferred to NPCC recipient NOD-SCID mice. RESULTS: Both wild-type C57BL/6 and MyD88(-/-) mice rejected NPCC xenografts 8 and 10 days, respectively after transplantation, and the grafts were heavily infiltrated with CD4+ T cells and macrophages. However, graft infiltrating macrophages from rejecting MyD88(-/-) recipients demonstrated impaired up-regulation of TLR expression and impaired activation phenotype, when compared to those from rejecting C57BL/6 recipients. Transfer of NOD-SCID recipients with macrophages from rejecting C57BL/6 mice resulted in NPCC xenograft rejection along with massively infiltrated macrophages 8 days after transfer, whereas NPCC xenografts in NOD-SCID mice transferred with macrophages from rejecting MyD88(-/-) mice remained intact until the end of this study, 90 days after transfer, with insulin-positive islets and no infiltration by macrophages. CONCLUSION: This study demonstrates that deletion of MyD88 causes impaired macrophage activation after pig islet xenotransplantation. However, graft survival is not prolonged and xenografts are rejected rapidly by alternate mechanisms.     

A study of tolerance induced by liver transplantation on intestinal graft in the rat]

In some strain combinations of rats, orthotopic liver transplantation (OLT) permits long-term donor-specific survival of fully allogeneic kidney, heart or skin grafts. The difficulties encountered in the clinical situation to obtain tolerance of small-bowel transplantation (SBT), in spite of massive non-specific immunosuppression, led us to study possible liver-induced tolerance in SBT. Inbred DA (RTIa) and PVG (RT1c) rats were used respectively as donors and recipients and divided in two groups: group 1: SIT alone (n = 6); group 2: combined OLT/SBT (n = 6). SIT was performed 17 days after OLT. No immunosuppressive treatment was given to the recipients. Biopsies of small-bowel grafts were performed in both groups at various times after small bowel engraftment. All animals in group 1 showed evidence of acute rejection of the graft between days 6 and 9 post-graft. The histologic pattern of rejection associated lamina propria (LP) mononuclear cell infiltration, crypt lesions and villous atrophy at the end-point of rejection. In group 2, long-term survival (> 100 days) of small bowel grafts was achieved in five of the six animals in spite of strong mononuclear cell infiltration in the LP, which peaked two months after small bowel grafting but then disappeared partially. This striking mononuclear cell infiltrate contrasted with only minor epithelial damage. These data demonstrate that liver grafting can enhance the survival of a small-bowel graft from the same donor in a rat model. Histological findings show that an intense immunological reaction takes place within liver-induced tolerated small-bowel grafts.     

The Natural History of Clinical Operational Tolerance After Kidney Transplantation Through Twenty‐Seven Cases

We report here on a European cohort of 27 kidney transplant recipients displaying operational tolerance, compared to two cohorts of matched kidney transplant recipients under immunosuppression and patients who stopped immunosuppressive drugs and presented with rejection. We report that a lower proportion of operationally tolerant patients received induction therapy (52% without induction therapy vs. 78.3%[p = 0.0455] and 96.7%[p = 0.0001], respectively), a difference likely due to the higher proportion (18.5%) of HLA matched recipients in the tolerant cohort. These patients were also significantly older at the time of transplantation (p = 0.0211) and immunosuppression withdrawal (p = 0.0002) than recipients who rejected their graft after weaning. Finally, these patients were at lower risk of infectious disease. Among the 27 patients defined as operationally tolerant at the time of inclusion, 19 still display stable graft function (mean 9 ± 4 years after transplantation) whereas 30% presented slow deterioration of graft function. Six of these patients tested positive for pre‐graft anti‐HLA antibodies. Biopsy histology studies revealed an active immunologically driven mechanism for half of them, associated with DSA in the absence of C4d. This study suggests that operational tolerance can persist as a robust phenomenon, although eventual graft loss does occur in some patients, particularly in the setting of donor‐specific alloantibody.     

Ischemia-reperfusion injury-induced abnormal dendritic cell traffic in the transplanted kidney with delayed graft function

Delayed graft function (DGF) in kidney transplantation is associated with an increased risk of acute rejection. Myeloid dendritic cells (DCs) are involved in graft rejection, whereas plasmacytoid DCs may play a role in inducing tolerance. We evaluated the presence and phenotype of the DCs in renal graft biopsies of 15 patients with DGF collected before and 7-15 days after transplantation. Biopsies taken from normal patients and from transplant recipients with acute calcineurin inhibitors (CNIs) nephrotoxicity served as a control group. Specific markers of myeloid, plasmacytoid, and mature DCs were imaged by confocal microscopy and immunohistochemistry. In normal kidneys and pre-transplant biopsies, sparse niches of myeloid and plasmacytoid cells were found but these were significantly increased with few mature cells during DGF. This same pattern was seen in acute rejection but with overall higher cell numbers. In CNI nephrotoxicity, myeloid cells were slightly increased but plasmacytoid cells were significantly higher than in DGF. Using a pig model, we found that a short period of warm ischemia followed by reperfusion led to myeloid cell infiltration of the kidney. Our data suggest that ischemia-reperfusion injury may cause an imbalance between intragraft myeloid and plasmacytoid DCs, which might be related to DGF and acute rejection.     

CD69 expression on peripheral CD8 T cells correlates with acute rejection in renal transplant recipients

BACKGROUND: The development of a noninvasive method to diagnose renal allograft rejection could prevent the complications associated with graft biopsy and allow more accurate surveillance of allograft function. The present study determines whether expression of CD69 on peripheral T lymphocytes of renal allograft recipients correlates with the presence of acute graft rejection. METHODS: Peripheral blood T lymphocytes from healthy volunteers, renal allograft recipients with elevated creatinine but no evidence of rejection on biopsy, and renal allograft recipients with biopsy-proven rejection were analyzed by flow cytometry for the expression of CD69 and various intracellular cytokines (interleukin-2, interferon-gamma). Results were then compared with the degree of rejection on biopsy. RESULTS: CD69 expression on CD3+, CD4+, and CD8+ T-cell subsets was low in controls and transplant recipients without allograft rejection. In contrast, patients with renal allograft rejection showed significantly elevated percentages of CD69+ cells in the CD3+ (P<0.01) and CD8+ subsets (P<0.01). The fraction of CD69+ and CD8+ T cells was found to be a more clinically useful test based on receiver-operator characteristics. CD69 expression on CD4+ T cells did not correlate with rejection. Significant intracellular cytokine levels were not detected in unstimulated T cells from any of the groups; stimulation with mitogens increased expression equally among the three groups. CONCLUSIONS: We demonstrate that expression of CD69 on CD3+ and CD8+ peripheral blood T cells correlates closely with the presence of acute graft rejection in renal allograft recipients. Measurement of this surface marker may provide a rapid, noninvasive, and accurate means by which graft rejection can be identified.     

Variation in numbers of CD4+CD25highFOXP3+ T cells with normal immuno-regulatory properties in long-term graft outcome

Chronic rejection (CR) is a major cause of long-term graft loss that would be avoided by the induction of tolerance. We previously showed that renal transplant patients with CR have lower numbers of peripheral CD4(+)CD25(high) T cells than operationally tolerant patients, patients with stable graft function and healthy volunteers (HV). We explored here the profile of CD4(+)CD25(high) blood T cells in these patients focusing on their expression of the regulatory T cells (Treg) gene Forkhead Box P3 (FOXP3) and their suppressive function. We show that CR is associated with a decreased number of CD4(+)CD25(high)FOXP3(+)T cells with normal regulatory profile, whereas graft acceptance is associated with CD4(+)CD25(high)FOXP3(+)T cell numbers similar to HVs. These data suggest that Treg numbers, rather than their intrinsic suppressive capacity, may contribute to determining the long-term fate of renal transplants.     

Toll-Like Receptor 4 and CD14 Gene Polymorphisms in Tunisian Kidney Transplantation

BackgroundAcute and chronic rejections remain an important cause of graft loss after renal transplantation. Currently, activation of innate immune responses through Toll-like receptors (TLRs) is suspected to be implied in the loss of the transplant tolerance.ObjectivesWe investigated functional single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) of TLR4 and its coreceptor CD14 in kidney transplantation and looked for any potential role in acute rejection (AR) and chronic allograft nephropathy (CAN) and impact on graft survival.Patients and MethodsTLR4 (Asp299Gly) and CD14 (C/T -159) SNPs were detected using polymerase chain reaction-restriction fragment length polymorphism (PCR-RFLP) in 209 kidney transplant recipients (KTRs) including 132 treated with mycophenolate mofetil (MMF+). AR occurred in 59 patients and 24 were identified as having CAN by biopsy and scored according to the Banff criteria.ResultsThere were no significant associations between TLR4 and CD14 genotypes and alleles and the occurrence of both AR episodes and CAN. Moreover, TLR4 and CD14 SNPs did not seem to influence kidney graft survival. Analysis according to human leukocyte antigen (HLA) compatibility status, positivity of anti-HLA antibodies, and immunosuppression by MMF confirmed the absence of correlation of the investigated SNPs with the graft outcome. In addition, incidence of post-transplantation infections, including cytomegalovirus (CMV) infections, was not influenced by both TLR4 and CD14 SNPs.ConclusionThese results suggest that TLR4 (Asp299Gly) and CD14 (C/T -159) functional SNPs do not play a major role in AR, CAN, and kidney graft survival. Therefore, intragraft monitoring of TLR4/CD14 genes expression by messenger RNA (mRNA) would provide clarity on the exact role of these receptors in graft injuries.     

Liver allografts are toleragenic in rats conditioned with posttransplant total lymphoid irradiation

BACKGROUND: Posttransplant total lymphoid irradiation (TLI) treatment has been applied to tolerance induction protocols in heart and kidney transplantation models. METHODS: We examined the efficacy and mechanism of posttransplant TLI treatment in the induction and maintenance of tolerance in a rat orthotopic liver transplantation model. RESULTS: Posttransplant TLI prolonged ACI (RT1(a)) liver allograft survival in Lewis (RT1(b)) hosts, with 50% long-term engraftment without immunosuppression and without evidence of chronic rejection. Injection of donor-type liver mononuclear cells (LMCs) facilitated the prolongation of graft survival, with more than 70% of grafts in LMC recipients surviving more than 100 days without chronic rejection. Recipients with long-term liver allograft survival accepted ACI but not PVG skin grafts. In TLI-conditioned recipients with accepted grafts, apoptosis occurred predominantly in graft-infiltrating leukocytes. In contrast, there were few apoptotic leukocytes in rejecting grafts. Recipients with long-term graft acceptance (>100 days of survival) demonstrated evidence of immune deviation; mixed lymphocyte reaction to ACI stimulator cells was vigorous, but secretion of interferon-gamma and interleukin-2 was reduced. In tolerant recipients, the number of Foxp3(+) CD25(+) CD4(+) regulatory T cells was increased in the liver allograft as well as in the peripheral blood. CONCLUSION: We conclude that posttransplant TLI induces tolerance to liver allografts via a mechanism involving apoptotic cell-deletion and immunoregulation.     

Upregulation of miR-142-3p in peripheral blood mononuclear cells of operationally tolerant patients with a renal transplant

Achieving drug-free tolerance or successfully using only small doses of immunosuppression is a major goal in organ transplantation. To investigate the potential mechanisms by which some kidney transplant recipients can achieve operational tolerance, we compared the expression profiles of microRNA in peripheral blood mononuclear cells of operationally tolerant patients with those of stable patients treated with conventional immunosuppression. B cells from operationally tolerant patients overexpressed miR-142-3p. The expression of miR-142-3p was stable over time and was not modulated by immunosuppression. In Raji B cells, overexpression of miR-142-3p modulated nearly 1000 genes related to the immune response of B cells, including potential miR-142-3p targets and molecules previously identified in the blood of operationally tolerant patients. Furthermore, our results suggested that a negative feedback loop involving TGF-β signaling and miR-142-3p expression in B cells may contribute to the maintenance of tolerance. In summary, miR-142-3p expression in peripheral blood mononuclear cells correlates with operational tolerance. Whether upregulation of miR-142-3p modulates inflammatory responses to promote tolerance or is a result of this tolerance state requires further study.