Genetic heterogeneity of Usher syndrome type II: localisation to chromosome 5q

Usher syndrome is a group of autosomal recessive disorders that includes retinitis pigmentosa (RP) with hearing loss. Usher syndrome type II is defined as moderate to severe hearing loss with RP. The USH2A gene at 1q41 has been isolated and characterised. In 1993, a large Usher II family affected with a mild form of RP was found to be unlinked to 1q41 markers. Subsequent linkage studies of families in our Usher series identified several type II families unlinked to USH2A and USH3 on 3q25. After a second unlinked family with many affected members and a mild retinal phenotype was discovered, a genome search using these two large families showed another Usher II locus on 5q (two point lod = 3.1 at D5S484). To date, we have identified nine unrelated 5q linked families (maximum combined multipoint lod = 5.86) as well as three Usher II families that show no significant linkage to any known Usher loci. Haplotype analysis of 5q markers indicates that the new locus is flanked by D5S428 and D5S433. Review of ophthalmological data suggests that RP symptoms are milder in 5q linked families; the RP is often not diagnosed until patients near their third decade. Enamel hypoplasia and severe, very early onset RP were observed in two of the three unlinked families; dental anomalies have not been previously described as a feature of Usher type II.     

Further refinement of the Usher 2A locus at 1q41.

Usher syndrome (USH) is characterised by congenital sensorineural hearing loss and progressive pigmentary retinopathy. All three subtypes (USH1, USH2, and USH3) are inherited as recessive traits. People with Usher type 2 (USH2) have normal vestibular responses and moderate to severe hearing loss. These syndromes have been found to be genetically heterogeneous, with a single locus for USH2 at 1q41 (USH2A), six loci for USH1, and one for USH3. Some USH2 families have been excluded from the 1q41 locus suggesting that a second, as yet unidentified, locus (USH2B) must exist. Linkage studies suggest that around 90% of USH2 families are USH2A. Four USH2 families were analysed for linkage to markers flanking the USH2A locus. In one of these families a recombination event was observed in an affected subject which excludes the USH2A gene from proximal to the marker AFM143XF10 and defines this as the new centromeric flanking marker for the USH2A locus. A further recombination event in another patient from this family confirmed AFM144XF2 as the telomeric flanking marker. The interval between these polymorphic markers is estimated to be 400 kb. This region is completely contained in each of three YACs from the CEPH library: 867g9, 919h3, and 848b9. This refinement more than halves the critical genetic interval and will greatly facilitate positional cloning of the USH2A gene.     

Genetic heterogeneity of Usher syndrome type II in a Dutch population.

The Usher syndromes are a group of autosomal recessive disorders characterised by retinitis pigmentosa (RP) with congenital, stable (non-progressive) sensorineural hearing loss. Profound deafness, RP, and no vestibular responses are features of Usher type I, whereas moderate to severe hearing loss and RP with normal vestibular function describe Usher type II. The gene responsible for most cases of Usher II, USH2a, is on chromosome 1q41; at least one other Usher II gene (as yet unlinked) is known to exist. Usher III presents with a progressive hearing loss that can mimic the audiometric profile seen in Usher II. A gene causing Usher III in a group of Finnish families, USH3, resides on chromosome 3q. Since the phenotypes for Usher II and III overlap, it is important to determine how frequently Usher IIa, Usher IIb, and Usher III occur in a clinical population of non-Usher I patients. DNA was collected from 29 Dutch families and genotyped with six DNA markers known to flank the USH2a gene closely, and with five markers that flank USH3. Results of haplotype and linkage analysis were consistent with linkage to the USH2a locus in 26 of these 29 Dutch families. Three families displayed no linkage to 1q41 markers, and one of these three families appeared unlinked to 3q markers as well; current haplotypes of the other two families are inconclusive for linkage with the USH3 locus without further genotyping. While an A test for heterogeneity of USH2a was statistically significant, no convincing evidence of linkage to USH3 was found in this Dutch sample. Consequently, the frequency of the unlinked variety of Usher IIa (Usher IIb) in The Netherlands was estimated as 0.104. To determine if marker alleles could be used to differentiate Usher type IIa from Usher IIb, parental chromosomes of the 26 Usher IIa families were analysed for significant non-random association of specific alleles from flanking loci with USH2a, but no linkage disequilibrium was observed in this Dutch population.     

Genetic heterogeneity of Usher syndrome type II.

Usher syndrome is an autosomal recessive disorder characterised by retinitis pigmentosa and congenital sensorineural hearing loss. A gene for Usher syndrome type II (USH2) has been localised to chromosome 1q32-q41. DNA from a family with four of seven sibs affected with clinical characteristics of Usher syndrome type II was genotyped using markers spanning the 1q32-1q41 region. These included D1S70 and D1S81, which are believed to flank USH2. Genotypic results and subsequent linkage analysis indicated non-linkage of this family to these markers. The A test analysis for heterogeneity with this family and 32 other Usher type II families was statistically significant at p < 0.05. Further clinical evaluation of this family was done in light of the linkage results to determine if any phenotypic characteristics would allow for clinical identification of the unlinked type. No clear phenotypic differences were observed; however, this unlinked family may represent a previously unreported subtype of Usher type II characterised by a milder form of retinitis pigmentosa and mild vestibular abnormalities. Heterogeneity of Usher syndrome type II complicates efforts to isolate and clone Usher syndrome genes using linkage analysis and limits the use of DNA markers in early detection of Usher type II.     

Three novel mutations and twelve polymorphisms identified in the USH2A gene in Israeli USH2 families

The Usher syndromes are autosomal recessive hereditary disorders characterized by hearing impairment and progressive visual loss due to Retinitis Pigmentosa (RP). Moderate to severe sensorineural hearing loss and progressive RP characterizes Usher syndrome type IIa (USH2A), which maps to the long arm of chromosome 1q41. Recently, three deletions carried by USH2 patients, which were found in a novel gene isolated from the critical 1q41 region, defined this gene as responsible for USH2A. The USH2A gene is predicted to encode a 1546 amino acid protein which possesses domains that are observed in basal lamina and extracellular matrix proteins and in cell adhesion molecules. Affected individuals and additional members from eleven USH2 Israeli families of diverse ethnic origin were screened for the presence of changes in all 20 coding exons of the USH2A gene. Three novel mutations (239-242insCGTA, R334W, T1515M) were identified in three families of Jewish Moroccan and Jewish Iranian origins. Twelve polymorphisms were found in the families, four of which are novel. None of the known USH2 mutations were identified in the families studied in this work. Hum Mutat 15:388, 2000.     

A novel locus for Usher syndrome type II, USH2B, maps to chromosome 3 at p23-24.2

Usher type II syndrome is defined by the association of retinitis pigmentosa, appearing in the late second to early third decade of life, with congenital moderate to severe non-progressive hearing loss. This double sensory impairment is not accompanied by vestibular dysfunction. To date, only one Usher type II locus, USH2A, at chromosome band 1q41, has been defined. Here, we demonstrate by linkage analysis, that the gene responsible for Usher type II syndrome in a Tunisian consanguineous family maps to chromosome 3 at position p23-24.2, thus providing definitive evidence for the genetic heterogeneity of the syndrome. A maximum lod score of 4.3 was obtained with the polymorphic microsatellite markers corresponding to loci D3S1578, D3S3647 and D3S3658. This maps the gene underlying USH2B to a chromosomal region which overlaps the interval defined for the non-syndromic sensorineural recessive deafness DFNB6, raising the possibility that a single gene underlies both defects. However, the audiometric features in the patients affected by USH2B and DFNB6 are very different.     

Linkage analysis in Usher syndrome type I (USH1) families from Spain.

Usher syndrome (USH) is an autosomal recessive hereditary disorder characterised by congenital sensorineural hearing loss and gradual visual impairment secondary to retinitis pigmentosa (RP). The disorder is clinically and genetically heterogeneous. With regard to Usher type I (USH1), several subtypes have been described, the most frequent being USH1B located on chromosome 11q13.5. Of 18 USH1 families studied by linkage analysis, 12 (67%) showed significant lod score values for locus D11S527 (Zmax=14.032, theta=0.000) situated on chromosome 11q. Our findings suggest considerable genetic heterogeneity in the Spanish USH1 population. It is important to note that one of our families linked to the USH1B locus shows interesting intrafamilial clinical variability. As regards the remaining six USH1 families, the linkage analysis did not provide conclusive data, although two of them show slight linkage to markers located on chromosome 3q (Zmax=1.880, theta=0.000 for D3S1279), the same location that had previously been assigned to some USH3 families.     

A newly identified locus for Usher syndrome type I, USH1E, maps to chromosome 21q21

Usher syndrome (USH) is a clinically and genetically heterogeneous disorder characterized by congenital hearing loss combined with retinitis pigmentosa. This dual sensorineural deficiency is transmitted in an autosomal recessive mode. Usher syndrome type I (USH1) is the most severe form. Four loci responsible for USH1 (USH1A, 1B, 1C and 1D) have previously been mapped, among which only the USH1B gene has been cloned. Using homozygosity mapping in a consanguineous family from Morocco, we identified a novel locus for USH1, USH1E, mapping to chromosome band 21q21. The delimited 15 cM interval is flanked by the loci D21S1905 and D21S1913. Subsequent segregation analysis of two families affected by USH1, in which the A, B, C and D loci had been excluded, also excluded the involvement of the USH1E locus, therefore indicating the existence of at least one more locus for USH1.      

USH1H, a novel locus for type I Usher syndrome, maps to chromosome 15q22-23

Usher syndrome (USH) is a hereditary disorder associated with sensorineural hearing impairment, progressive loss of vision attributable to retinitis pigmentosa (RP) and variable vestibular function. Three clinical types have been described with type I (USH1) being the most severe. To date, six USH1 loci have been reported. We ascertained two large Pakistani consanguineous families segregating profound hearing loss, vestibular dysfunction, and RP, the defining features of USH1. In these families, we excluded linkage of USH to the 11 known USH loci and subsequently performed a genome-wide linkage screen. We found a novel USH1 locus designated USH1H that mapped to chromosome 15q22-23 in a 4.92-cM interval. This locus overlaps the non-syndromic deafness locus DFNB48 raising the possibility that the two disorders may be caused by allelic mutations.     

A novel D458V mutation in the SANS PDZ binding motif causes atypical Usher syndrome

Homozygosity mapping and linkage analysis in a Turkish family with autosomal recessive prelingual sensorineural hearing loss revealed a 15-cM critical region at 17q25.1–25.3 flanked by the polymorphic markers D17S1807 and D17S1806. The maximum two-point lod score was 4.07 at =0.0 for the marker D17S801. The linkage interval contains the Usher syndrome 1G gene (USH1G) that is mutated in patients with Usher syndrome (USH) type 1g and encodes the SANS protein. Mutation analysis of USH1G led to the identification of a homozygous missense mutation D458V at the –3 position of the PDZ binding motif of SANS. This mutation was also present homozygously in one out of 64 additional families from Turkey with autosomal recessive nonsyndromic hearing loss and heterozygously in one out of 498 control chromosomes. By molecular modeling, we provide evidence that this mutation impairs the interaction of SANS with harmonin. Ophthalmologic examination and vestibular evaluation of patients from both families revealed mild retinitis pigmentosa and normal vestibular function. These results suggest that these patients suffer from atypical USH.E. Kalay and A.P.M. de Brouwer contributed equally to this work     

Haplotype analysis of the USH1D locus and genotype-phenotype correlations

Usher syndrome (USH) is characterised by hearing impairment and progressive pigmentary retinopathy. USH can be divided into three subtypes based on the severity and progression of the major clinical findings. These subtypes are genetically heterogeneous, with at least six loci for USH1, three for USH2 and one for USH3. In the present study, five unrelated consanguineous families with USH1 were analysed for linkage to markers flanking the six USH1 loci. Two of these families, one Pakistani and one Turkish, demonstrated linkage to the USH1D locus. In another family, haplotype segregation was consistent with linkage to USH1C. The remaining families were not linked to any of the six USH1 loci, providing support for the existence of at least one additional USH1 locus. Analysis of these two new USH1D families allowed us to narrow the USH1D candidate region to a 7.3-cM interval with a telomeric flanking marker at D10S1752. Comparison of the affected haplotypes in our Pakistani family with the original Pakistani USH1D family yielded no evidence for a founder effect. The identification of two additional affected families suggests that the USH1D may be a more common form of USH1 than originally suspected. The USH1D (CDH23) gene has recently been cloned. Mutation analysis has shown two different CDH23 mutations in the two Pakistani USH1D families studied, which confirmed our finding that there was no evidence for a founder effect by haplotype analysis. The interesting correlations between genotype and phenotype in CDH23 are also summarised.     

Evidence for a fourth locus in Usher syndrome type I.

Usher syndrome type I (US1) is an autosomal recessive condition in which three different genes have been already localised (USH1A, USH1B, and USH1C on chromosomes 14q32, 11q13, and 11p15 respectively). The genetic heterogeneity of US1 has been confirmed in a previous study by linkage analysis of 20 French pedigrees. Here, we report the genetic exclusion of the three previously reported loci in two large multiplex families of Moroccan and Pakistani origin, suggesting the existence of at least a fourth locus in Usher syndrome type I.     

Twelve novel myosin VIIA mutations in 34 patients with Usher syndrome type I: confirmation of genetic heterogeneity

Usher syndrome is a heterogeneous autosomal recessive trait and the most common cause of hereditary deaf-blindness. Usher syndrome type I (USH1) is characterised by profound congenital sensorineural hearing loss, vestibular dysfunction, and prepubertal onset of retinitis pigmentosa. Of the at least six different loci for USH1, USH1B maps on chromosome 11q13, and the MYO7A gene has been shown to be defective in USH1B. MYO7A encodes myosin VIIA, an unconventional myosin, and it consists of 48 coding exons. In this study, MYO7A was analysed in 34 unrelated Usher type I patients by single-strand conformation polymorphism analysis and direct sequencing. We identified a total of 12 novel and unique mutations, all single base changes. In addition, we found a previously reported nonsense mutation (C31X) on nine alleles of a total of six patients from Denmark.     

Profound, prelingual nonsyndromic deafness maps to chromosome 10q21 and is caused by a novel missense mutation in the Usher syndrome type IF gene PCDH15

We studied a consanguineous family (Family A) from the island of Newfoundland with an autosomal recessive form of prelingual, profound, nonsyndromic sensorineural hearing loss. A genome-wide scan mapped the deafness trait to 10q21-22 (max LOD score of 4.0; D10S196) and fine mapping revealed a 16 Mb ancestral haplotype in deaf relatives. The PCDH15 gene was mapped within the critical region and was an interesting candidate because truncating mutations cause Usher syndrome type IF (USH1F) and two missense mutations have been previously associated with isolated deafness (DFNB23). Sequencing of the PCDH15 gene revealed 33 sequencing variants. Three of these variants were homozygous exclusively in deaf siblings but only one of them was not seen in ethnically matched controls. This novel c.1583 T>A transversion predicts an amino-acid substitution of a valine with an aspartic acid at codon 528 (V528D). Like the two DFNB23 mutations, the V528D mutation in Family A occurs in a highly conserved extracellular cadherin (EC) domain of PCDH15 and is predicted to be more deleterious than the previously identified DFNB23 missense mutations (R134G and G262D). Physical assessment, vestibular and visual function testing in deaf adults ruled out syndromic deafness because of Usher syndrome. This study validates the DFNB23 designation and supports the hypothesis that missense mutations in conserved motifs of PCDH15 cause nonsyndromic hearing loss. This emerging genotype–phenotype correlation in USH1F is similar to that in several other USH1 genes and cautions against a prognosis of a dual sensory loss in deaf children found to be homozygous for hypomorphic mutations at the USH1F locus.     

The usher syndromes

Mutations in the gene (MYO7A) encoding myosin-VIIa, a member of the large superfamily of myosin motor proteins that move on cytoplasmic actin filaments, and in the USH2A gene, which encodes a novel protein resembling an extracellular matrix protein or a cell adhesion molecule, both cause Usher syndrome (USH), a clinically heterogeneous autosomal recessive disorder comprising hearing and visual impairment. Patients with USH1 have severe to profound congenital hearing impairment, vestibular dysfunction, and retinal degeneration beginning in childhood, while those with USH2 have moderate to severe hearing impairment, normal vestibular function, and later onset of retinal degeneration. USH3 is characterized by progressive hearing loss and variable age of onset of retinal degeneration. The phenotype resulting from MYO7A and USH2A mutations is variable. While most MYO7A mutations cause USH1, some cause nonsyndromic hearing impairment, and one USH3 phenotype has been described. USH2A mutations cause atypical USH as well as USH2. MYO7A is on chromosome region 11q13 and USH2A is on 1q41. Seven other USH genes have been mapped but have not yet been identified. USH1A, USH1C, USH1D, USH1E, and USH1F have been assigned to chromosome bands 14q32, 11p15.1, 10q, 21q21, and 10, respectively, while USH2B is on 5q, and USH3 is at 3q21-q25. Myosin VIIa mutations also result in the shaker-1 (sh1) mouse, providing a model for functional studies. One possibility is that myosin-VIIa is required for linking stereocilia in the sensory hair bundle; another is that it may be needed for membrane trafficking. The ongoing studies of myosin-VIIa, the USH2A protein, and the yet to be identified proteins encoded by the other USH genes will advance understanding of the Usher syndromes and contribute to the development of effective therapies. Am. J. Med. Genet. (Semin. Med. Genet.) 89:158-166, 1999.     

Localization of the Usher syndrome type ID gene (Ush1D) to chromosome 10

The Usher syndromes (USH) are a group of autosomal recessive diseases characterized by progressive pigmentary retinopathy and sensorineural hearing loss. Five USH genes have been mapped and at least one additional gene is known to exist. By homozygosity mapping in a consanguineous family, a sixth USH gene has been localized. Clinical findings in the four affected children are consistent with established diagnostic criteria for Ush1. Linkage to known USH loci was excluded, and using two genomic DNA pools, one from the affected children and the other from the parents, 161 polymorphic markers evenly spaced across the autosomal human genome were screened. The location of the Ush1D gene was defined by the only region showing homozygosity by descent in the affected siblings, a 15 cM interval on chromosome 10q bounded by D10S529 and D10S573.      

Clinical findings in obligate carriers of type I Usher syndrome

Seventeen obligate carriers from nine families with autosomal recessive Usher syndrome type I underwent otological, audiological, vestibular, and ophthalmological examination in order to identify possible manifestations of heterozygosity. Linkage studies were performed and six families showed linkage to chromosome region 11q13.5 while 3 families have so far failed to show linkage to the candidate regions. Eight obligate carriers had an abnormal puretone audiogram. Two different audiometric patterns could be distinguished when hearing loss was corrected for age and sex. Four carriers (24%) had significant sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL) which increased at higher frequencies. The other 13 carriers had SNHL of about 10 dB at 0.25 and 0.5 kHz, but less at higher frequencies. Vestibular findings were generally normal. Electrooculography demonstrated a significant lower mean light peak/dark trough ratio in Usher type I carriers compared to normal control individuals. The methods used in this study were found not to be specific enough to clinically identify carriers of Usher type I syndrome. Nevertheless it is remarkable that a number of obligate carriers showed significant audiological and ophthalmological abnormalities. © 1995 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Familial 14-Mb deletion at 21q11.2-q21.3 and variable phenotypic expression

We report a familial case with a proximal interstitial deletion of chromosome 21q [del(21q)]. Although the mother in the family was phenotypically normal, her first child was affected with both sensorineural hearing loss and moderate mental retardation, and the second affected child had mild mental retardation but not sensorineural hearing loss. We determined breakpoints of the del(21q) in the mother and her two affected children by fluorescence in situ hybridization analysis using 45 DNA clones and the molecular analysis using 21 DNA markers. The proximal breakpoint of the del(21q) was located at a region between 0.33 Mb and 0.46 Mb distal to the centromere, and the distal breakpoint was at a region between 14.6 Mb and 14.9 Mb. The finding indicates that the three individuals had an approximate 14-Mb deletion within 21q11.2-q21.3. Molecular analysis showed that both affected children shared the same maternal haplotype of their del(21q), but a crossover was detected in the paternally inherited normal chromosome 21. These data suggest that unmasking of deleterious genes on the paternally derived chromosome 21 of the two children as a result of the deletion may affect the extent of their mental retardation and/or sensorineural hearing loss. Usher syndrome 1E may be a candidate disease locus related to the sensorineural hearing loss of the first child.     

Mutation spectrum of MYO7A and evaluation of a novel nonsyndromic deafness DFNB2 allele with residual function

Recessive mutations of MYO7A, encoding unconventional myosin VIIA, can cause either a deaf-blindness syndrome (type 1 Usher syndrome; USH1B) or nonsyndromic deafness (DFNB2). In our study, deafness segregating as a recessive trait in 24 consanguineous families showed linkage to markers for the DFNB2/USH1B locus on chromosome 11q13.5. A total of 23 of these families segregate USH1 due to 17 homozygous mutant MYO7A alleles, of which 14 are novel. One family segregated nonsyndromic hearing loss DFNB2 due to a novel three-nucleotide deletion in an exon of MYO7A (p.E1716del) encoding a region of the tail domain. We hypothesized that DFNB2 alleles of MYO7A have residual myosin VIIA. To address this question we investigated the effects of several mutant alleles by making green fluorescent protein (GFP) tagged cDNA expression constructs containing engineered mutations of mouse Myo7a at codons equivalent to pathogenic USH1B and DFNB2 alleles of human MYO7A. We show that in transfected mouse hair cells an USH1B mutant GFP-myosin VIIa does not localize properly to inner ear hair cell stereocilia. However, a GFP-myosin VIIa protein engineered to have an equivalent DFNB2 mutation to p.E1716del localizes correctly in transfected mouse hair cells. This finding is consistent with the hypothesis that p.E1716del causes a less severe phenotype (DFNB2) than the USH1B-associated alleles because the resulting protein retains some degree of normal function.     

Identification of two new mutations in the GPR98 and the PDE6B genes segregating in a Tunisian family

Autosomal recessive retinitis pigmentosa (ARRP) is a genetically heterogeneous disorder. ARRP could be associated with extraocular manifestations that define specific syndromes such as Usher syndrome (USH) characterized by retinal degeneration and congenital hearing loss (HL). The USH type II (USH2) associates RP and mild-to-moderate HL with preserved vestibular function. At least three genes USH2A, the very large G-protein-coupled receptor, GPR98, and DFNB31 are responsible for USH2 syndrome. Here, we report on the segregation of non-syndromic ARRP and USH2 syndrome in a consanguineous Tunisian family, which was previously used to define USH2B locus. With regard to the co-occurrence of these two different pathologies, clinical and genetic reanalysis of the extended family showed (i) phenotypic heterogeneity within USH2 patients and (ii) excluded linkage to USH2B locus. Indeed, linkage analysis disclosed the cosegregation of the USH2 phenotype with the USH2C locus markers, D5S428 and D5S618, whereas the ARRP perfectly segregates with PDE6B flanking markers D4S3360 and D4S2930. Molecular analysis revealed two new missense mutations, p.Y6044C and p.W807R, occurring in GPR98 and PDE6B genes, respectively. In conclusion, our results show that the USH2B locus at chromosome 3p23-24.2 does not exist, and we therefore withdraw this locus designation. The combination of molecular findings for GPR98 and PDE6B genes enable us to explain the phenotypic heterogeneity and particularly the severe ocular affection first observed in one USH2 patient. This report presents an illustration of how consanguinity could increase familial clustering of multiple hereditary diseases within the same family.