Integrative behavioral couple therapy: an acceptance-based, promising new treatment for couple discord

Although traditional behavioral couple therapy (TBCT) has garnered the most empirical support of any marital treatment, concerns have been raised about both its durability and clinical significance. Integrative behavioral couple therapy (IBCT) was designed to address some of these limitations by combining strategies for fostering emotional acceptance with the change-oriented strategies of TBCT. Results of a preliminary clinical trial, in which 21 couples were randomly assigned to TBCT or IBCT, indicated that therapists could keep the 2 treatments distinct, that both husbands and wives receiving IBCT evidenced greater increases in marital satisfaction than couples receiving TBCT, and that IBCT resulted in a greater percentage of couples who either improved or recovered on the basis of clinical significance data. Although preliminary, these findings suggest that IBCT is a promising new treatment for couple discord.     

Traditional versus integrative behavioral couple therapy for significantly and chronically distressed married couples

A randomized clinical trial compared the effects of traditional behavioral couple therapy (TBCT) and integrative behavioral couple therapy (IBCT) on 134 seriously and chronically distressed married couples, stratified into moderately and severely distressed groups. Couples in IBCT made steady improvements in satisfaction throughout the course of treatment, whereas TBCT couples improved more quickly than IBCT couples early in treatment but then, in contrast to the IBCT group, plateaued later in treatment. Both treatments produced similar levels of clinically significant improvement by the end of treatment (71% of IBCT couples and 59% of TBCT couples were reliably improved or recovered on the Dyadic Adjustment Scale; G. B. Spanier, 1976). Measures of communication also showed improvement for both groups. Measures of individual functioning improved as marital satisfaction improved.     

Improving relationships: mechanisms of change in couple therapy

In a sample of 134 married couples randomly assigned to traditional or integrative behavioral couple therapy (TBCT vs. IBCT), a multivariate hierarchical growth curve analysis using latent variable regression revealed that measures of communication, behavior frequency, and emotional acceptance acted as mechanisms of change. TBCT led to greater changes in frequency of targeted behavior early in therapy, whereas IBCT led to greater changes in acceptance of targeted behavior both early and late in therapy. In addition, change in behavioral frequency was strongly related to improvements in satisfaction early in therapy; however, in the 2nd half of therapy, emotional acceptance was more strongly related to changes in satisfaction. Research and clinical implications are discussed.     

Integrative behavioral couple therapy for chronic pain: promoting behavior change and emotional acceptance

Couple therapy has been used with success in treating marital distress, psychological distress, and other problems. Researchers in the pain field have also shown that the inclusion of the spouse in pain treatment may be beneficial to the patient. In this article, we present integrative behavioral couple therapy (IBCT) as one option for therapists treating patients who have pain and marital distress. IBCT improves on traditional behavior therapy because it promotes processes that have been shown to be lacking in pain patients' relationships: emotional acceptance and empathy. After reviewing the use of behavior change and emotional acceptance strategies in couples, we describe a couple for whom IBCT improved functioning.     

Treating infidelity in same-sex couples

Psychotherapy with same-sex couples does not differ markedly from standard couple therapies; this is also true for treating couples facing infidelity. However, same-sex couples often design their relationships differently, without tradition and formal marital contracts to prescribe behavior. Based on clinical experience and the empirical research, this article addresses the differing norms involved in affirmatively treating infidelity in gay and lesbian couples within the framework of integrative behavioral couple therapy (IBCT). Two cases illustrate the process and outcome of IBCT with same-sex couples.     

Couple therapy with combat veterans and their partners

Service members returning from Iraq and Afghanistan face psychological challenges that can exert profound effects on families and couples, but can also be treated within a systemic context. Couple therapy offers a means of increasing social support, decreasing interpersonal conflict, and addressing the experiential avoidance that maintains posttraumatic symptoms. For combat veterans and their partners, we present an adaptation of integrative behavioral couple therapy (IBCT) that reduces conflict and encourages intimacy through acceptance and skills strategies. By doing so, IBCT exposes service members in couple therapy to emotions, interpersonal situations, and activities that facilitate recovery from combat-related distress. We illustrate common presenting problems in this population and the utilization of IBCT with a case example.     

Marital therapy as a treatment for depression

The purpose of this study was to compare cognitive-behavioral therapy (CT; n = 20), behavioral marital therapy (BMT; n = 19), and a treatment combining BMT and CT (CO; n = 21) in the alleviation of wives' depression and the enhancement of marital satisfaction. BMT was less effective than CT for depression in maritally nondistressed couples, whereas for maritally distressed couples the two treatments were equally effective. BMT was the only treatment to have a significant positive impact on relationship satisfaction in distressed couples, whereas CO was the only treatment to enhance the marital satisfaction of nondistressed couples. On marital interaction measures CO was the only treatment to significantly reduce both husband and wife aversive behavior and to significantly increase wife facilitative behavior.     

Cost-utility and cost-effectiveness of internet-based treatment for adults with depressive symptoms: randomized trial

Background

The effectiveness of Internet-based treatments for depression has been demonstrated; their cost-effectiveness, however, has been less well researched.

Objective

Evaluating the relative cost-utility and cost-effectiveness of (1) Internet-based cognitive behavioral therapy, (2) Internet-based problem-solving therapy, and (3) a waiting list for adults with depressive symptoms.

Methods

A total of 263 participants with clinically significant depressive symptoms were randomized to Internet-based cognitive behavioral therapy (n = 88), Internet-based problem-solving therapy (n = 88), and a waiting list (n = 87). End points were evaluated at the 12-week follow-up.

Results

Cost-utility analysis showed that cognitive behavioral therapy and problem-solving therapy had a 52% and 61% probability respectively of being more acceptable than waiting when the willingness to pay is € 30,000 for one quality-adjusted life-year. When society is prepared to pay € 10,000 for a clinically significant change from depression, the probabilities of cognitive behavioral therapy and problem-solving therapy being more acceptable than waiting are 91% and 89%, respectively. Comparing both Internet-based treatments showed no clear preference for one or the other of the treatments.

Conclusions

Both Internet-based treatments have a high probability of being cost-effective with a modest value placed on clinically significant change in depressive symptoms.

Trial Registration

ISRCTN16823487; http://www.controlled-trials.com/ISRCTN16823487 (Archived by WebCite at http://www.webcitation.org/5u8slzhDE)     

Behavioral couples therapy for female substance-abusing patients: effects on substance use and relationship adjustment

Married or cohabiting female drug-abusing patients (N = 75) were randomly assigned to either a behavioral couples therapy condition (BCT; n = 37), which consisted of group, individual, and behavioral couples therapy sessions, or to an equally intensive individual-based treatment condition (IBT; n = 38), which consisted of group and individual counseling. During most of the 1-year follow-up, compared with participants who received IBT, those who received BCT reported (a) fewer days of substance use, (b) longer periods of continuous abstinence, (c) lower levels of alcohol, drug, and family problems, and (d) higher relationship satisfaction. However, differences in relationship satisfaction and number of days of substance use dissipated over the course of the posttreatment follow-up period and were not significantly different by the end of 1 year.     

Treating couples recovering from infidelity: an integrative approach

Infidelity is one of the most difficult problems to address in couple therapy, most likely because it involves a traumatic relationship event that alters the ways in which couples process information about each other and established behavioral patterns. We present a three-stage treatment designed to address the cognitive, behavioral, and emotional sequelae of affairs that integrates cognitive-behavioral and insight-oriented strategies with the literatures on traumatic response and forgiveness. A case study with pretreatment, posttreatment, and 6-month follow-up data is presented to illustrate the treatment methods.     

Behavorial Parent Training and Cognitive-Behavioral Self-Control Therapy With ADD-H Children: Comparative and Combined Effects

We assessed the effects of behavioral parent training and cognitive-behavioral self-control therapy with 24 elementary school-age children diagnosed as having attention deficit disorder with hyperactivity. A randomized-group design with repeated measures and multiple outcome criteria was employed comparing behavioral parent training alone, self-control instruction alone, and a combination of the two treatments. All groups showed significant improvement over time, but the only significant Treatment Group x Time interaction reflected a greater decrease in hyperactivity scores at follow-up for children in the self-control instruction alone group. Furthermore, although there was significant maintenance of change at 1-month follow-up, there was no evidence for generalization of change to the classroom. Stepwise multiple-regression analysis showed that mothers with greater perceived extrafamilial and community social support, and children who were better able to reflect on problems, who admitted to greater self-control problems, and who had a more internal locus of control, evidenced greatest behavioral improvements.     

Behavioral couples therapy (BCT) for alcohol and drug use disorders: a meta-analysis

Narrative reviews conclude that behavioral couples therapy (BCT) produces better outcomes than individual-based treatment for alcoholism and drug abuse problems (e.g., [Epstein, E. E., & McCrady, B. S. (1998). Behavioral couples treatment of alcohol and drug use disorders: Current status and innovations. Clinical Psychology Review, 18(6), 689-711; O'Farrell, T. J., & Fals-Stewart, W. (2003). Alcohol abuse. Journal of Marital and Family Therapy, 29(1), 121-146]). However, the strength and consistency of this effect favoring BCT has not been examined because a meta-analysis of BCT studies has not been reported. This meta-analysis combines multiple well controlled studies to help clarify the overall impact of BCT in the treatment of substance use disorders. A comprehensive literature search produced 12 randomized controlled trials (n=754) that were included in the final analyses. There was a clear overall advantage of including BCT compared to individual-based treatments (Cohen's d=0.54). This was true across outcome domains (frequency of use d=0.36, consequences of use d=0.52, and relationship satisfaction d=0.57). However the pattern of results varied as a function of time. BCT was superior to control conditions only in relationship satisfaction at posttreatment (d=0.64). However, at follow-up BCT was superior on all three outcome domains (frequency of use d=0.45, consequences of use d=0.50, and relationship satisfaction d=0.51). In addition to other control conditions, BCT also outperformed individual cognitive behavioral therapy without couples therapy (d=0.42). Larger sample sizes were associated with higher effect sizes (p=0.02). However, treatment dose and publication year were not related to effect size. Overall, BCT shows better outcomes than more typical individual-based treatment for married or cohabiting individuals who seek help for alcohol dependence or drug dependence problems. The benefit for BCT with low severity problem drinkers has received little attention and one study suggests its efficacy may not extend to this subgroup.     

An evaluation of time-limited psychodynamic psychotherapy for couples: A pilot study

Objectives. Psychodynamic Couple Psychotherapy has developed as a modality in only a few organizations in the public and voluntary sectors in this country. Varieties of couple therapy have evolved due to economic or other constraints, some more open‐ended, others involving differing time limits or behavioural techniques. In this study, a time limit of 40 sessions was imposed on the Psychodynamic therapy to improve comparability with other therapeutic approaches. We examined work with 18 couples, employing various measures which, while not in the context of a full controlled trial, produced some interesting and indicative results. We aimed to investigate (1) the effects of time‐limited psychodynamic couple psychotherapy, and (2) whether the measures used produce interesting results after 40 weeks. Design. Within a normal clinical setting, measurements of individual and couple functioning would be taken at fixed points in the course of 40‐week couple therapies, and analysed for evidence of significant change. Due to funding and clinical limitations within the setting, a baseline period before therapy started was used instead of a control group. Method. Couples were invited to opt in to the study when applying to the agency for therapy. They were provided with 40 weekly sessions of couple therapy. Videotapes of sessions at beginning, middle, and end of the therapies were rated by independent observer, using the Personal Relatedness Profile (PRP) ( Hobson, Patrick, & Valentine, 1998 ) adapted for couples ( Lanman, Grier, & Evans, 2003 ), alongside two individual self‐report measures, Clinical Outcomes in Routine Evaluation (CORE) ( Evans et al., 2000 ), and the Golombok Rust Inventory of Marital Satisfaction (GRIMS) ( Rust, Bennun, Crow, & Golumbok, 1990 ). Results. The couples showed improvement as rated both by therapists and observers (rating the videotaped sessions) on the PRP after 40 sessions. On the CORE measure, participants showed improvement at both 20 and 40 sessions. On the GRIMS measure of marital satisfaction, results were non‐significant. Conclusions. The results provide indicative evidence for the effectiveness of 40‐session couple psychotherapy and provide some convergent validation for the utility of the PRP (as adapted for couples) as a measure of change.     

Alcoholics anonymous and relapse prevention as maintenance strategies after conjoint behavioral alcohol treatment for men: 18-month outcomes

Ninety men with alcohol problems and their female partners were randomly assigned to 1 of 3 outpatient conjoint treatments: alcohol behavioral couples therapy (ABCT), ABCT with relapse prevention techniques (RP/ABCT), or ABCT with interventions encouraging Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) involvement (AA/ABCT). Couples were followed for 18 months after treatment. Across the 3 treatments, drinkers who provided follow-up data maintained abstinence on almost 80% of days during follow-up, with no differences in drinking or marital happiness outcomes between groups. AA/ABCT participants attended AA meetings more often than ABCT or RP/ABCT participants, and their drinking outcomes were more strongly related to concurrent AA attendance. For the entire sample, AA attendance was positively related to abstinence during follow-up in both concurrent and time-lagged analyses. In the RP/ABCT treatment, attendance at posttreatment booster sessions was related to posttreatment abstinence. Across treatment conditions, marital happiness was related positively to abstinence in concurrent but not time-lagged analyses.     

Long-term effectiveness of behavioral versus insight-oriented marital therapy: a 4-year follow-up study

Four-year follow-up data regarding marital status and marital accord were obtained for 59 couples receiving either behavioral (BMT) or insight-oriented (IOMT) marital therapy in a controlled outcome study. Although no significant group differences had been observed between the 2 treatment conditions at either termination or 6-month follow-up, by 4-year follow-up a significantly higher percentage of BMT couples had experienced divorce (38% for BMT couples compared with 3% for IOMT couples). Results are compared with previous outcome research in this area, and recommendations are made for further research.     

Comparison of integrated systemic and emotionally focused approaches to couples therapy.

This study compared couples receiving two marital therapy approaches and a control group over a 10-week treatment period. Integrated systemic therapy (IST) and an emotionally focused approach (EFT) were both found to be superior to the control and to be equally effective in alleviating marital distress, facilitating conflict resolution and goal attainment, and reducing target complaints at termination. IST couples, however, showed greater maintenance of gains from termination to 4-month follow-up on marital satisfaction and goal attainment. Clients' perceptions of how change occurred and issues related to the use of a team of observers in IST are discussed.     

Infidelity and behavioral couple therapy: optimism in the face of betrayal

Infidelity is a common issue with which distressed couples and their therapists grapple. However, there are no data on the efficacy of commonly used therapies to treat couples in which there has been an affair. In the present exploratory study, the authors examined the therapy outcomes of a sample of infidelity couples (n=19) who had participated in a randomized clinical trial of marital therapy (N=134). Results show that infidelity couples began treatment more distressed than noninfidelity couples; however, evidence suggests that couples who had an affair and who revealed this affair prior to or during therapy showed greater improvement in satisfaction than noninfidelity couples. Implications for therapy with infidelity couples are discussed.     

Clinical approach to male infertility

The clinical approach to male infertility involves uncertainties, and various circumstances must be considered: 1. If no pregnancy occurs in the case of a couple whose sexual relations are "normal" and regular, and who have used no form of contraceptive for one year, the evaluation must systematically include both the woman and the man. 2. In the case of a man wishes to know his capacity for procreating, what are the possibilities for improvement? 3. Are there ways of predicting male infertility? If there are, the socioprofessional and iatrogenic risks should be more fully investigated. 4. What are the current possibilities for male contraception? In practical terms, the case of the infertile couple offers the widest field for clinical and paraclinical investigations. An exploratory strategy must guide this evaluation, assuring efficacy and taking account of current therapeutic possibilities, which are still unfortunately limited. The change in attitudes is clearly expressed by the number of couples who resort to adoption or artificial insemination rather than continue examinations and treatments when there is little chance of achieving pregnancy.     

A comparison of weight control and weight control plus body image therapy for obese men and women

Participants were 65 obese men and women who were randomly assigned to either weight control or weight control plus cognitive behavioral body image therapy. Both conditions showed clinically significant improvements in body image at posttreatment and 1-year follow-up. Adding body image therapy to weight control did not result in greater psychological improvements and did not result in better maintenance of body image change when participants regained weight after treatment. Weight loss and maintenance were equivalent between groups. Adding body image therapy did not improve or detract from weight loss. Although body image therapy has been shown to be effective in obese persons, it appears that a well-rounded cognitive-behavioral weight control program is effective as well.     

Six year follow-up of cryopreserved human embryos1

In 1987, we became aware of the importance of remaining in contactwith couples whose embryos had been cryopreserved for >1year. As a result, a questionnaire was designed to follow thefate of these embryos. Of 407 couples with cryopreserved embryos,262 couples opted to use them within 1 year with the intentionof fulfilling a parental plan. The remaining 145 couples werequestioned by six successive questionnaires sent out between1987 and 1992.By the end of the study, 336 of the 407 couples(82.5%)had chosen to utilize their embryos in a parental plan.In most cases, the maximum delay of response (5 years accordingto the Council of State) was respected. The remaining 71 couples(17.5%) either abandoned the parental plan or had not givenany information by the end of the study. Initially, anonymousdonation to another couple was chosen in preference to destroyingthe surplus embryos (32 versus 18 couples, P < 0.05). Latterly,however, these differences have balanced out (24 versus 28,not significant). Only those couples who initially opted todonate embryos to another couple changed their attitude in lateryears. In the long run, 62 couples decided not to pursue theirparental plan; of these, 24 couples chose to make a gift toanother couple, 28 couples opted for destruction,and 10 choseto make a gift to research. Nine couples (out of 71) declinedto make a decision, but they had all achieved a pregnancy duringan in-vitro fertilization (IVF) attempt.Three of these werelost to follow-up, i.e. 0.7% of all couples benefiting fromthe freezing technique.