Suppression of the melanogenic potential of migrating neural crest‐derived cells by the branchial arches

The development of melanocytes from neural crest‐derived precursors that migrate along the dorsolateral pathway has been attributed to the selection of this route by cells that are fate‐restricted to the melanocyte lineage. Alternatively, melanocytes could arise from nonspecified cells that develop in response to signals encountered while these cells migrate, or at their final destinations. In most animals, the bowel, which is colonized by crest‐derived cells that migrate through the caudal branchial arches, contains no melanocytes; however, the enteric microenvironment does not prevent melanocytes from developing from crest‐derived precursors placed experimentally into the bowel wall. To test the hypothesis that the branchial arches remove the melanogenic potential from the crest‐derived population that colonizes the gut, the Silky fowl (in which the viscera are pigmented) was studied. Sources of crest included Silky fowl and quail vagal and truncal neural folds/tubes, which were cultured or explanted to chorioallantoic membranes alone or together with branchial arches or limb buds from Silky fowl, White Leghorn, or quail embryos. Crest and mesenchyme‐derived cells were distinguished by using the quail nuclear marker. Melanocytes developed from Silky fowl and quail crest‐derived cells. Melanocyte development from both sources was inhibited by quail and White Leghorn branchial arches (and limb buds), but melanocyte development was unaffected by branchial arch (and limb buds) from Silky fowl. These observations suggest that a factor(s) that is normally expressed in the branchial arches, and is lacking in animals with the Silky mutation, prevents cells with a melanogenic potential from colonizing the bowel. Anat Rec 268:16–26, 2002. © 2002 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

The distribution of ephrin-B1 and PNA-positive glycoconjugates is correlated with atypical melanoblast migration in Japanese Silky fowl embryos

Melanoblasts are positively stimulated to migrate in the dorsolateral pathway of the avian embryo by ephrins, but are inhibited by PNA-binding glycoconjugates. We analyzed the potential role of these molecules in the Japanese Silky fowl, which displays intense internal pigmentation. The distribution of ephrin ligands was analyzed using Eph receptor-human Fc fusion proteins. Glycoconjugates were labeled using PNA-FITC. In Japanese Silky embryos, ventral areas, including the anterior- and posterior-half somites, expressed ephrin-B1 in a pattern that correlates with the atypical migratory pathways taken by Japanese Silky melanoblasts. White Leghorn embryos displayed little to no ephrin-Bs in the ventral paths. Conversely, PNA-binding barrier tissues, proposed to prevent melanoblasts from migrating ventrally in White Leghorn, are missing or have significant gaps in Japanese Silky embryos. Thus, studies of a naturally occurring pigmentation mutant confirm that a combination of cues regulates melanoblast migration in the chick embryo.     

Origin of spinal cord meninges, sheaths of peripheral nerves, and cutaneous receptors including Merkel cells

Summary The origin of cells covering the nervous system and the cutaneous receptors was studied using the quail-chick marking technique and light and electron microscopy. In the first experimental series the brachial neural tube of the quail was grafted in place of a corresponding neural tube segment of the chick embryo at HH-stages 10 to 14. In the second series the leg bud of quail embryos at HH-stages 18–20 was grafted in place of the leg bud of the chick embryos of the same stages and vice versa. It was found that all meningeal layers of the spinal cord, the perineurium and the endoneurium of peripheral nerves, as well as the capsular and inner space cells of Herbst sensory corpuscles, develop from the local mesenchymal cells. Schwann cells and cells of the inner core of sensory corpuscles are of neural crest origin. The precursors of Merkel cells migrate similarly to the Schwann cells into the limb bud where they later differentiate. This means that in addition to the Schwann cells and the melanocytes a further neural crest-derived subpopulation of cells enters the limb.     

Cooperative and indispensable roles of endothelin 3 and KIT signalings in melanocyte development.

The development of melanocytes from neural crest-derived precursor cells depends on signaling by the receptor tyrosine kinase KIT and the G protein-coupled endothelin receptor B (EDNRB) pathways. Loss-of-function mutations in either of these two signaling receptor molecules cause a loss or a marked reduction in the number of melanocyte precursors in the embryo and finally lead to loss of the coat color. Using cultures of embryonic stem (ES) cells to induce melanocyte differentiation in vitro, we investigated the requirement for EDNRB signaling during the entire developmental process of the melanocyte, in association with that for KIT signaling. During the 21-day period necessary for the induction of mature melanocytes from undifferentiated ES cells, endothelin 3 (EDN3), a ligand for EDNRB, increased the number of melanocytes in proportion to the period during which it was present. We tested the compensatory effect of EDNRB signaling on KIT signaling in vivo by using Kit(W-LacZ)/Kit(W-LacZ) ES cells and confirmed that the ectopic expression of EDN3 in the skin reduced the white spotting of Kit(W57)/Kit(W57)mice. KIT ligand (KITL) and EDN3 worked synergistically to induce melanocyte differentiation in vitro; however, the complete lack of EDNRB signaling attained by the use of EDN3-/- ES cells and an EDNRB antagonist, BQ788, revealed that the resulting failure of melanocyte development was not compensated by the further activation of KIT signaling by adding KITL. Simultaneous blockade of EDNRB and KIT signalings eliminated melanocyte precursors completely, suggesting that the maintenance or survival of early melanocyte precursors at least required the existence of either EDNRB or KIT signalings.     

The capacity of normal and talpid3 mutant fowl myogenic cells to migrate in quail limb buds

Summary Talpid ³ is a recessive lethal mutant of the fowl. It has been shown previously that, in vitro, talpid ³ limb mesenchyme cells are more adhesive and less mobile than normal cells. It is therefore of interest to investigate the effect of the gene on cell movement in vivo, in the limb bud itself, in cells in which it is known to occur in normal embryos. Myogenic cells, which normally migrate into the limb bud from the somites, continue to move distalwards when grafted into the limb bud at a later stage. Blocks of normal or talpid ³ limb mesenchyme containing myogenic cells were transplanted into quail limb buds in ovo. Since quail cells are histologically distinguishable from chick cells the progress of myogenic cell movement 5 days after transplantation could be observed. In 10 out of 14 cases normal myogenic cells migrated extensively in a proximo-distal direction within the limb bud for the quail host. In contrast, only 2 out of 11 talpid ³ transplants showed a moderate degree of distalwards movement.     

Colonization of the developing pancreas by neural precursors from the bowel.

Neurons in ganglia of the myenteric plexus of the duodenum and stomach have recently been demonstrated to innervate pancreatic ganglia and transsynaptically to excite acinar and islet cells. The hypothesis that crest-derived cells first colonize the foregut and secondarily enter the pancreas by way of the pancreatic buds was tested. Studies were done with fetal rats (days E11-E15). Pancreatic rudiments and foregut were explanted separately and in co-culture. The development of neurons in the explants, identified by demonstrating the immunoreactivities of neurofilaments and growth-associated protein-43 (GAP-43), provided an indirect assay for the presence of neural precursors in the tissue at the time of explantation. Cells of putative neural crest origin were visualized immunocytochemically using the monoclonal antibody, NC-1. Additional markers included the immunoreactivities of dopamine-beta-hydroxylase (DBH), which is expressed by vagal crest-derived cells that colonize the bowel, neuropeptides (substance P and neuropeptide Y [NPY]) found in mature pancreatic neurons, and serotonin (5-HT), which is located in the cell bodies of enteric but not pancreatic neurons. Neurons were detected in cultures of foregut, but not pancreas, when these tissues were explanted by themselves at days E11 and E12. At E11 neural precursors did not leave explants of bowel or migrate into co-cultured pancreatic rudiments. When the foregut was explanted at E12, however, neural precursors migrated away from the bowel, giving rise both to distant ganglia and to neurons within co-cultured pancreatic rudiments. Intrapancreatic ganglia developed in the co-cultures even when the pancreatic attachment to the bowel was severed. Neurons appeared in pancreatic rudiments explanted by themselves on day E13. Neurons developing in pancreatic explants expressed the immunoreactivities of DBH, substance P, and NPY, but not 5-HT. These observations support the idea that pancreatic ganglia develop from crest-derived cells that first colonize the fetal rat foregut and there acquire the ability to colonize the pancreas. A later migration into the pancreatic rudiments of a subset of the original émigrés or their progeny between days E12 and E13 gives rise to a network of pancreatic ganglia that can be regarded as an extension of the enteric nervous system.     

Hyperpigmentation in the Silkie fowl correlates with abnormal migration of fate-restricted melanoblasts and loss of environmental barrier molecules.

In most homeothermic vertebrates, pigment cells are confined to the skin. Recent studies show that the fate-restricted melanoblast (pigment cell precursor) is the only neural crest lineage that can exploit the dorsolateral path between the ectoderm and somite into the dermis, thereby excluding neurons and glial cells from the skin. This does not explain why melanoblasts do not generally migrate ventrally into the region where neurons and glial cell derivatives of the neural crest differentiate, or why melanoblasts do not escape from the dorsolateral path once they have arrived at this destination. To answer these questions we have studied melanogenesis in the Silkie fowl, which is a naturally occurring chicken mutant in which pigment cells occupy most connective tissues, thereby giving them a dramatic blue-black cast. By using markers for neural crest cells (HNK-1) and melanoblasts (Smyth line serum), we have documented the development of the Silkie pigment pattern. The initial dispersal of melanoblasts is the same in the Silkie fowl as in Lightbrown Leghorn (LBL), White Leghorn (WLH), and quail embryos. However, by stage 22, when all ventral neural crest cell migration has ceased in the WLH, melanoblasts in the Silkie embryo continue to migrate between the neural tube and somites to occupy the sclerotome. This late ventral migration was confirmed by filling the lumen of the neural tube with DiI at stage 19 and observing the embryos at stage 26. No DiI-labeled cells were observed in the sclerotome of LBL embryos, whereas in the Silkie embryos DiI-filled cells were found as far ventral as the mesentery. In addition to this extensive ventral migration, we also observed considerable migration of melanoblasts from the distal end of the dorsolateral space into the somatic mesoderm (the future parietal peritoneum), and into the more medioventral regions where they accumulated around the dorsal aorta and the kidney. The ability of melanoblasts in the Silkie embryos to migrate ventrally along the neural tube and medially from the dorsolateral space is correlated with a lack of peanut agglutinin (PNA) -binding barrier tissues, which are present in the LBL embryo. The abnormal pattern of melanoblast migration in the Silkie embryo is further exaggerated by the fact that the melanoblasts continue to divide, as evidenced by BrdU incorporation (but the rate of incorporation is not greater than seen in the LBL). Results from heterospecific grafting studies and cell cultures of WLH and Silkie neural crest cells support the notion that the Silkie phenotype is brought about by an environmental difference rather than a neural crest-specific defect. We conclude that melanoblasts are normally constrained to migrate only in the dorsolateral path, and once in that path they generally do not escape it. We further conclude that the barriers that normally restrain melanoblast migration in the chicken are not present in the Silkie fowl. We are now actively investigating the nature of this barrier molecule to complete our understanding of melanoblast migration and patterning.     

Successful xenogeneic transplantation in embryos: induction of tolerance by extrathymic chick tissue grafted into quail.

In previous experiments, we have demonstrated that limb buds engrafted during embryonic life at E4, between MHC-mismatched chick embryos, are not only tolerated after birth, but induce in the recipient a state of split tolerance toward cells expressing the donor MHC haplotype: donor's skin grafts are permanently tolerated while a proliferative response of host's T cells is generated in MLR by donor-type blood cells. If the same experiment is performed, using quail embryo as a donor and chick as a recipient, acute rejection of the quail limb starts during the first two weeks after birth, thus suggesting that the peripheral type of tolerance induced in these experiments can be obtained only in allogeneic but not in xenogeneic combinations. We report here the unexpected result that when a chick limb bud is grafted into a quail at E4, it is tolerated and, like allogeneic grafts in chickens, induces adult skin-graft tolerance without modifying the MLR response. Similar results were obtained with grafts from another closely related species of bird, the guinea fowl from the Phasianidae family. In contrast, xenogeneic combinations involving more distant species (chick and quail as recipients and duck, an Anatidae, as donor) resulted in strong and early rejection from both recipients. As a whole, quails exhibit a greater ability than the chick to become tolerant to antigens presented peripherally from early developmental stages. In adult quails, however, skin grafts performed in either direction (i.e., quail to chick or the reverse) are rejected according to a similar temporal pattern. Moreover, lymphocytes of both species are able to respond equally well to quail or chick IL-2. Several hypotheses are envisaged to account for these observations. It seems likely that this type of tolerance is directly related to antigenic load because the load in chick to quail wing chimeras is larger than that in quail to chick chimeras. This view is supported by the protracted delay in graft rejection observed when two quail wing buds instead of one are grafted into chickens.     

Successful Xenogeneic Transplantation in Embryos: Induction of Tolerance by Extrathymic Chick Tissue Grafted into Quail

In previous experiments, we have demonstrated that limb buds engrafted during embryonic life at E4, between MHC-mismatched chick embryos, are not only tolerated after birth, but induce in the recipient a state of split tolerance toward cells expressing the donor MHC haplotype: donor''s skin grafts are permanently tolerated while a proliferative response of host''s T cells is generated in MLR by donor–type blood cells. If the same experiment is performed, using quail embryo as a donor and chick as a recipient, acute rejection of the quail limb starts during the first two weeks after birth, thus suggesting that the peripheral type of tolerance induced in these experiments can be obtained only in allogeneic but not in xenogeneic combinations.We report here the unexpected result that when a chick limb bud is grafted into a quail at E4, it is tolerated and, like allogeneic grafts in chickens, induces adult skin-graft tolerance without modifying the MLR response. Similar results were obtained with grafts from another closely related species of bird, the guinea fowl from the Phasianidae family. In contrast, xenogeneic combinations involving more distant species (chick and quail as recipients and duck, an Anatidae, as donor) resulted in strong and early rejection from both recipients. As a whole, quails exhibit a greater ability than the chick to become tolerant to antigens presented peripherally from early developmental stages. In adult quails, however, skin grafts performed in either direction (i.e., quail to chick or the reverse) are rejected according to a similar temporal pattern. Moreover, lymphocytes of both species are able to respond equally well to quail or chick IL-2. Several hypotheses are envisaged to account for these observations. It seems likely that this type of tolerance is directly related to antigenic load because the load in chick to quail wing chimeras is larger than that in quail to chick chimeras. This view is supported by the protracted delay in graft rejection observed when two quail wing buds instead of one are grafted into chickens.     

PNA-positive glycoconjugates are negatively correlated with the access of neural crest cells to the gut in chicken embryos

Neural crest cells give rise to many derivatives, including the neurons and glia of the peripheral nervous system, adrenomedulary cells, and melanocytes, and migrate through precise pathways that differ according to their axial level and/or state of specification. The migratory routes taken by neural crest cells are reported to be regulated by extracellular matrix molecules. We examined the possible influence of glycoconjugates on the establishment of barriers to neural crest access to ventral regions leading to the gut, by labeling stage-16-28 white Leghorn (WL) and Silky (SK) embryos with peanut agglutinin (PNA) at vagal, thoracic, and sacral levels. We observed a transitory expression of glycoconjugates that correlate with a barrier to the entrance of neural crest cells into the gut at the thoracic level, which is not present at vagal and sacral levels. In later stages, neural crest cells of melanocytic lineage were observed entering the gut in embryos of the SK chicken, a mutant with an altered pattern of pigmentation. The ventral regions occupied by melanoblasts in SK embryos were free of PNA labeling, while in WL embryos, in which PNA-positive molecules are strongly expressed, melanoblasts were restricted to peripheral regions. We suggest that PNA-binding glycoconjugates are good molecular marker for barriers that control the access of neural crest cells to the gut.     

On the migration of epidermal melanoblasts in the avian embryonic wing bud

Summary After heterotopic grafting of quail neural crest cells to the wing buds of embryos of an unpigmented chicken strain, epidermal melanocytes of donor origin are found almost exclusively distal from the graft in the host's epidermis. This directed cell migration ceases, if the apical ectodermal ridge (together with a small amount of subridge mesoderm) is removed from the operated wing buds or if impermeable materials are interposed between it and the rest of the wing bud. Under these conditions epidermal melanocytes are found not only distal from but also proximal to the grafts. From this it may be deduced that the apical ectodermal ridge directs the migration of epidermal melanoblasts in the avian embryonic wing bud, possibly by a chemotactic mechanism. The presence or absence of the apical ectodermal ridge had no observable effect on the migratory behaviour of other neural crest derived cell populations (Schwann cells and non-epidermal melanocytes) in the wing bud. This shows that the apical ectodermal ridge specifically influences epidermal melanocytes.This work was supported by the Österreichischer Fonds zur Förderung der wissenschaftlichen Forschung (P 4680)     

Spatial relations between avian craniofacial neural crest and paraxial mesoderm cells.

Fate maps based on quail-chick grafting of avian cephalic neural crest precursors and paraxial mesoderm cells have identified the majority of derivatives from each population but have not unequivocally resolved the precise locations of and population dynamics at the interface between them. The relation between these two mesenchymal tissues is especially critical for the development of skeletal muscles, because crest cells play an essential role in their differentiation and subsequent spatial organization. It is not known whether myogenic mesoderm and skeletogenic neural crest cells establish permanent relations while en route to their final destinations, or later at the sites where musculoskeletal morphogenesis is completed. We applied beta-galactosidase-encoding, replication-incompetent retroviruses to paraxial mesoderm, to crest progenitors, or at the interface between mesodermal and overlying neural crest as both were en route to branchial or periocular regions in chick embryos. With respect to skeletal structures, the results identify the avian neural crest:mesoderm boundary at the junction of the supraorbital and calvarial regions of the frontal bone, lateral to the hypophyseal foramen, and rostral to laryngeal cartilages. Therefore, in the chick embryo, most of the frontal and the entire parietal bone are of mesodermal, not neural crest, origin. Within paraxial mesoderm, the progenitors of each lineage display different behaviors. Chondrogenic cells are relatively stationary and intramembranous osteogenic cells move only in transverse planes around the brain. Angioblasts migrate invasively in all directions. Extraocular muscle precursors form tightly aggregated masses that en masse cross the crest:mesoderm interface to enter periocular territories, while branchial myogenic lineages shift ventrally coincidental with the movements of corresponding neural crest cells. En route to the branchial arches, myogenic mesoderm cells do not maintain constant, nearest-neighbor relations with adjacent, overlying neural crest cells. Thus, progenitors of individual muscles do not establish stable, permanent relations with their connective tissues until both populations reach the sites of their morphogenesis within branchial arches or orbital regions.     

Comparative analysis of the development of wing-flapping and flight in the fowl

The development of wing-flapping rate, lateral flight, wing area, and the ratio of wing area to body weight are described in the Japanese quail (Coturnix coturnix japonica) and three chickens (Gallus gallus) to determine common developmental phenomena and to assess the effects of domestication. The chickens were the White Leghorn (a comercial egg producer), the Cornish X Rock (a commercial meat producer), and the Red Jungle fowl (the probable ancestor of domestic chickens). All birds performed drop-evoked wing-flapping on the day of hatching, at least 1 week before lateral flight was possible. Flapping rate of chickens doubled between hatching (4–6 Hz) and 13 days (～ 9–12 Hz), after which it leveled off. Japanese quail (JQ) maintained a high flapping rate (11–13 Hz) during the 21 days after hatching. The Jungle fowl (JF) and JQ flapped the fastest and the White Leghorn (WL) and Cornish × Rock (CR) chickens flapped the slowest. The JF, WL, and JQ developed lateral flight at 7–9 days. The CR first flew 1–2 weeks later but subsequently became flightless. The WL, JF, and JQ had similar ratios of wing area to body weight; the ratios increased to a peak at 11–15 days and later declined. The ratio of the very heavy, essentially flightless, CR was approximately one-half that of the flighted JQ, WL, and JF. The wing-flapping frequencies of the domestic WL and CR chickens approximated that of the JF, suggesting that domestication did not affect the motor pattern generatior for flight. The artificial selection of the CR for high body weight drastically diminished its flight performance by producing an unfavorable ratio of wing area to body weight. The JF and the domestic WL both flew well and had similar ratios. Domestication affected flight performance but not the neural circuitry producing wing-flapping. The central nervous system is much more conservative in its response to selection than the peripheral effector structures that it drives.     

The origin of epidermal melanocytes. Implications for the histogenesis of nevi and melanomas

Among the most venerable concepts in dermatopathology is Unna's 19th century notion of Abtropfung, ie, that melanocytes drop off from the epidermis to the dermis during the histogenesis of melanocytic tumors. Paradoxically, however, Unna's basic premise of an epidermal origin for melanocytes has been seriously questioned for over 40 years, based on experimental evidence favoring a neural crest origin for melanocytes. Recent work has strengthened the evidence for a neural crest origin of epidermal melanocytes, and it has been suggested that the concept of Abtropfung be replaced by the concept of Hochsteigerung. The concept of Hochsteigerung holds that melanocytes migrate up from the dermis into the epidermis-not only in normal development, but also during normal tissue maintenance. It now seems likely that the precursor of melanocytes, in both normal and abnormal differentiation, may not be a melanoblast (a primitive cell committed to melanocytic differentiation) but rather a pluripotential cell. Although axon-investing Schwann cells have been the traditional focus as the closest relative of the epidermal melanocyte, recent studies suggest that another nerve sheath cell, the perineural cell, might be a better candidate. These concepts have profound implications for the histogenesis of melanocytic nevi and melanomas.     

Developmental origin of avian Merkel cells

We have investigated the developmental origin and ultrastructure of avian Merkel cells by electron microscopy and chick/quail transplantation experiments. On embryonic day 3, chick leg primordia were homotopically grafted onto Japanese quail host embryo. Fourteen days later, quail cells that had migrated into grafted chick legs were identified according to the masses of heterochromatin associated with the nucleolus that are characteristic for quail. Both in chick and quail, Merkel cells are usually located in the dermis just below the epidermis. They are placed between nerve terminals either individually or in small groups wrapped in sheaths that are formed by glial cell processes. Occasionally, some Merkel cells appear in nerve fascicles and within Herbst corpuscles. Merkel cells, as well as glial cells, in grafted chicken legs were of quail origin. This finding provides evidence against the epidermal origin of avian Merkel cells and indicates that Merkel cells are derived from neural crest cells that colonise, together with glial cells and melanocytes, the developing limb primordium. Accepted: 30 May 2000     

Experimental analysis of blood vessel development in the avian wing bud.

Shortly after its appearance, the avian limb bud becomes populated by a rich plexus of vascular channels. Formation of this plexus occurs by angiogenesis, specifically the ingrowth of branches from the dorsal aorta or cardinal veins, and by differentiation of endogenous angioblasts within limb mesoderm. However, mesenchyme located immediately beneath the surface ectoderm of the limb is devoid of patent blood vessels. The objective of this research is to ascertain whether peripheral limb mesoderm lacks angioblasts at all stages or becomes avascular secondarily during limb development. Grafts of core or peripheral wing mesoderm, identified by the presence or absence of patent channels following systemic infusion with ink, were grafted from quail embryos at stages 16-26 into the head region of chick embryos at stages 9-10. Hosts were fixed 3-5 days later and sections treated with antibodies that recognize quail endothelial cells and their precursors. Labeled endothelial cells were found intercalated into normal craniofacial blood vessels both nearby and distant from the site of implantation following grafting of limb core mesoderm from any stage. Identical results were obtained following grafting of limb peripheral mesoderm at stages 16-21. However, peripheral mesoderm from donors older than stage 22 did not contain endothelial precursors. Thus at the onset of appendicular development angioblasts are present throughout the mesoderm of the limb bud. During the fourth day of incubation, these cells are lost from peripheral mesoderm, either through emigration or degeneration.     

Experimental analysis of blood vessel development in the avian wing bud

Shortly after its appearance, the avian limb bud becomes populated by a rich plexus of vascular channels. Formation of this plexus occurs by angiogenesis, specifically the ingrowth of branches from the dorsal aorta or cardinal veins, and by differentiation of endogenous angioblasts within limb mesoderm. However, mesenchyme located immediately beneath the surface ectoderm of the limb is devoid of patent blood vessels. The objective of this research is to ascertain whether peripheral limb mesoderm lacks angioblasts at all stages or becomes avascular secondarily during limb development. Grafts of core or peripheral wing mesoderm, identified by the presence or absence of patent channels following systemic infusion with ink, were grafted from quail embryos at stages 16–26 into the head region of chick embryos at stage 9–10. Hosts were fixed 3–5 days later and sections treated with antibodies that recognize quail endothelial cells and their precursors. Labeled endothelial cells were found intercalated into normal craniofacial blood vessels both nearby and distant from the site of implantation following grafting of limb core mesoderm from any stage. Identical results were obtained following grafting of limb peripheral mesoderm at stages 16–21. However, peripheral mesoderm from donors older than stage 22 did not contain endothelial precursors. Thus at the onset of appendicular development angioblasts are present throughout the mesoderm of the limb bud. During the fourth day of incubation, these cells are lost from peripheral mesoderm, either through emigration or degeneration.