Reproductive planning after genetic counselling: a perspective from the last decade

Studies from the last decade on factors influencing reproductive planning after genetic counselling were reviewed. Increased possibilities of DNA-analysis and prenatal diagnosis might have brought about a shift in the paramountcy of factors influencing reproductive planning after genetic counselling. In contrast to the literature in the seventies, the magnitude of the genetic risk was no longer found to be one of the decisive factors in postcounselling reproductive planning. Instead, the interpretation of the risk as high or low and the desire to have children appeared to be paramount. The impact of new developments in DNA-analysis in prenatal diagnosis and presymptomatic testing will be an important subject for future studies on factors influencing reproductive planning.     

Peutz-Jeghers syndrome and family planning: the attitude towards prenatal diagnosis and pre-implantation genetic diagnosis

Peutz-Jeghers syndrome (PJS) is a hereditary disorder caused by LKB1 gene mutations, and is associated with considerable morbidity and decreased life expectancy. This study was conducted to assess the attitude of PJS patients towards family planning, prenatal diagnosis (PND) and pregnancy termination, and pre-implantation genetic diagnosis (PGD). In a cross-sectional study, 61 adult PJS patients were asked to complete a questionnaire concerning genetic testing, family planning, PND and PGD. The questionnaire was completed by 52 patients (85% response rate, 44% males) with a median age of 44 (range 18-74) years. A total of 37 (71%) respondents had undergone genetic testing. In all, 24 respondents (46%, 75% males) had children. A total of 15 (29%) respondents reported that their diagnosis of PJS had influenced their decisions regarding family planning, including 10 patients (19%, 9/10 females) who did not want to have children because of their disease. Termination of pregnancy after PND in case of a foetus with PJS was considered 'acceptable' for 15% of the respondents, whereas 52% considered PGD acceptable. In conclusion, the diagnosis of PJS influences the decisions regarding family planning in one third of PJS patients, especially in women. Most patients have a negative attitude towards pregnancy termination after PND, while PGD in case of PJS is judged more acceptable. These results emphasise the importance of discussing aspects regarding family planning with PJS patients, including PND and PGD.     

Application of SNP array for rapid prenatal diagnosis: implementation, genetic counselling and diagnostic flow

We report on the validation and implementation of the HumanCytoSNP-12 array (Illumina) (HCS) in prenatal diagnosis. In total, 64 samples were used to validate the Illumina platform (20 with a known (sub) microscopic chromosome abnormality, 5 with known maternal cell contamination (MCC) and 39 normal control samples). There were no false-positive or false-negative results. In addition to the diagnostic possibilities of arrayCGH, the HCS allows detection of regions of homozygosity (ROH), triploidy and helps recognising MCC. Moreover, in two cases of MCC, a deletion was correctly detected. Furthermore we found out that only about 50 ng of DNA is required, which allows a reporting time of only 3 days. We also present a prospective pilot study of 61 fetuses with ultrasound abnormalities and a normal karyotype tested with HCS. In 4 out of 61 (6.5%) fetuses, a clinically relevant abnormality was detected. We designed and present pre-test genetic counselling information on categories of possible test outcomes. On the basis of this information, about 90% of the parents chose to be informed about adverse health outcomes of their future child at infancy and childhood, and 55% also about outcomes at an adult stage. The latter issue regarding the right of the future child itself to decide whether or not to know this information needs to be addressed.     

A child with cystic fibrosis: II. Subsequent family planning decisions, reproduction and use of prenatal diagnosis

In 1984, we interviewed 105 Belgian families with a Cystic Fibrosis (CF) child in order to assess the impact of the birth of their CF-child on subsequent family planning and to evaluate their attitudes towards prenatal diagnosis. Three years later, in 1987, they received a mailed questionnaire for an updating of the reproduction data and to assess their knowledge and intentions with regard to the new possibilities of DNA diagnosis. The birth of a CF-child had a major impact upon subsequent family planning. This effect was found both in the reproductive plans reported by the parents and in the occurrence of pregnancies during the follow-up interval. This effect can be attributed mostly to the recurrence risk and consists of postponing pregnancies as well as of deciding against further offspring. If the CF-child was the firstborn, the chance of having another child was greater than if there was already a healthy child before the birth of the CF-child. Nevertheless, only 47% of the families in which the CF-child was the firstborn, and who could be followed for an average period of 7 years, had another pregnancy. A large majority of families intended to use prenatal diagnosis should a pregnancy occur. In half of the pregnancies that occurred between 1984 and 1987, a prenatal diagnosis was performed. On the other hand, there is less consensus about pregnancy interruption should prenatal diagnosis reveal an affected fetus.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease: New information for genetic counselling

We evaluated the accuracy of ultrasonographic diagnosis of autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease (ADPKD) and factors influencing its prognosis in members of 17 Newfoundland families originally described in 1984. In 10 families showing genetic linkage between ADPKD and markers for the PKD1 locus, rates of false negative ultrasonographic diagnosis are estimated as 36% below the age of 10 years and 8% or less thereafter, comparable with findings of genetic linkage studies of a subset of family members. At ages above 30 years, false negative ultrasonographic diagnosis of PKD1 disease is unlikely. In 2 families in which PKD1 disease is unlikely. In 2 families in which ADPKD is not coinherited with PKD1 markers, only 11% of members aged less than 30 years had kidney cysts. The mean (SE) age of onset of ESRD is 56.3 (1.8) years for persons with the PKD1 form of ADPKD, and 68.7 (1.7) years for affected members of families in which ADPKD is not co-inherited with PKD1 markers (P = 0.01). In the PKD1 families, age of onset of end stage renal disease (ESRD) was unrelated to the sex of the affected individual but was earlier in persons inheriting the disease from their mothers than from their fathers (50.5 vs. 64.8 years, P = 0.004), consistent with an influence of genetic imprinting on disease progresion. In females with a PKD1 mutation, onset of ESRD was not influenced by parity. In PKD1 families, resemblance in age of onset of ESRD was apparent; variation was less within than between families (F = 13.0, P < 0.0001), and risk of false negative ultrasonographic diagnosis appears largely restricted to families in which ESRD occurs relatively late. © 1992 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Reproductive genetic counselling in non-mosaic 47,XXY patients: implications for preimplantation or prenatal diagnosis: Case report and review

With an incidence of approximately 1 in 500 male newborns, the 47,XXY genotype is one the most common sex chromosome anomalies. It is also the most frequent genetic cause of human infertility. Some non-mosaic 47,XXY patients have sperm production which allows infertility treatment to be offered by ICSI. Therefore, the risk of transmitting a chromosome anomaly to the next generation is an important problem in reproductive genetic counselling of these patients. Here, we report on a twin pregnancy where two karyotypically normal neonates 46,XX and 46,XY were born after the use of ICSI in assisted reproduction of a patient with a non-mosaic 47,XXY syndrome. To date, only 38 evolving pregnancies including the present cases, have been reported after ICSI using sperm from non-mosaic 47,XXY patients. Although these data are scarce, they suggest that the risk of chromosome anomaly in the offspring of these patients is low; hence, their reproductive genetic counselling can be reassuring, and management of the pregnancy can proceed with caution.     

Hemophilia A and B — two years ex-perience of genetic counselling and prenatal diagnosis

Haemophilia A . Thirty-one pregnant women, obligate or probable carriers of haemophilia A, requested prenatal diagnosis if sex determination showed the foetus to be a male. In 11 of the 31 cases the foetuses were females; in two, the genetic variant of the disease rendered prenatal diagnosis impossible; and in two, the mother aborted spontaneously. From the remaining 16 male foetuses, blood samples were obtained in uteri in the 17th to 20th week of gestation. Examination of the samples showed that 11 of the foetuses were unaffected and five affected. Haemophilia B . Three carriers of haemophilia B had male foetuses. Examination of foetal blood obtained in utero showed that these three foetuses were affected. Confirmation . All women with an affected foetus requested termination of pregnancy. In one of thecdses of abortion, no blood was obtained for confirmative examination. In the remaining cases, the prenatal prediction was confirmed in the abortus or in the child after birth; three women are still pregnant.     

Reproductive drive and genetic counselling

A proper reproductive decision must take the intensity of the reproductive drive into account. Algebraic argumentation clearly shows that binary transposition of the odds and reproductive roulette are often inevitable, especially if the reproductive drive is not duly considered during the counselling process.     

Outcomes and process in genetic counselling

Although it may be simple to evaluate some elements of clinical genetics, it is difficult to evaluate genetic counselling. We review previous studies of the outcomes of genetic counselling; although the methods used may be valid in research studies, there are practical and ethical difficulties in applying them to the measurement of clinical effectiveness in standard practice. No simple measures of outcomes would be suitable. Research evidence will be helpful in deciding what services it is appropriate to offer, and the quality of a service can then be assured by assessing the quality of the clinical process in three ways: 1) adherence to agreed protocols and standards of care; 2) peer review and audit of clinical activity; and 3) ongoing review of the satisfaction of clients and referring physicians with the service. The assessment of client satisfaction will need to be a sophisticated form of retrospective satisfaction with the service provided, and such a scheme has yet to be fully developed.     

An evaluation of reinforcement of genetic counselling on the consultand

This project studied the effect of reinforcement of genetic counselling in the home, on consultand recall of information discussed in the clinic. Acceptable recall was observed in 84% of 227 patients scored for recall of rate of recurrence, understanding of the nature of the disease at special risk and of its mechanism of origin. Our results show no significant difference in the frequency of acceptable recall after reinforcement of genetic counselling compared with an absence of reinforcement. The consultands' understanding was substantially affected by the type of genetic mechanism involved.     

Evaluation of a counselling protocol for predictive genetic testing for hereditary non-polyposis colorectal cancer

OBJECTIVES—To evaluate the feasibility of a reduced counselling programme for predictive genetic testing for hereditary non-polyposis colorectal cancer (HNPCC) in terms of counsellees' opinions on the extent and significance of genetic counselling and need for psychological support at different phases of the testing procedure.
DESIGN—Prospective follow up study with pre-test questionnaire assessment of background sociodemographic variables. The protocol comprised a pre-test counselling session, a period for reflection, and a test disclosure session. The outcome variables were studied by post-test questionnaires at one month and one year follow up.
SUBJECTS—Two hundred and seventy one high risk members of 36 families with HNPCC who attended both counselling sessions and completed the questionnaires.
RESULTS—The pre-test counselling was considered fairly or very useful by 89% of respondents and one post-test session was considered sufficient by over 80% of respondents at follow up. Fifty three percent would have used extra psychological support had it been offered with the counselling. On enquiry one year after receiving the test result, only 2% stated that the need for support was at its greatest at that time, while the majority (46%) reported that the need for support had been greatest at the moment of test disclosure.
CONCLUSIONS—A protocol that includes one comprehensive pre-test counselling session and a test disclosure session, supplemented with the option of professional psychological support, seems to be sufficient for both the educational and supportive needs of counsellees. Only a minority expressed a need for post-test follow up sessions, which suggests that, in this disorder, resources can be directed to the beneficial surveillance programmes rather than to extensive psychological support.


Keywords: predictive genetic testing; genetic counselling; HNPCC; hereditary non-polyposis colorectal cancer     

Cerebral cavernous malformations: from molecular pathogenesis to genetic counselling and clinical management

Cerebral cavernous (or capillary-venous) malformations (CCM) have a prevalence of about 0.1-0.5% in the general population. Genes mutated in CCM encode proteins that modulate junction formation between vascular endothelial cells. Mutations lead to the development of abnormal vascular structures.In this article, we review the clinical features, molecular and genetic basis of the disease, and management.     

The use of probability trees in genetic counselling

Calculation of genetic risks of persons who may be carriers of X-linked recessive conditions or autosomal dominant diseases with incomplete or delayed penetrance often requires the use of Bayes' theorem. Available methods of computing such risks are often too difficult or too time-consuming for clinicians to use routinely. Probability trees provide a rapid and simple graphical means of estimating genetic risks even in complex clinical situations. The use of probability trees is easily learned because the logic upon which they are based is inherent in their structure.     

Counselling following diagnosis of a fetal abnormality: Comparison of different clinical specialists in Mexico

Most geneticists agree that counselling should be nondirective, and studies report that genetic counselling by geneticists is performed largely in a neutral style. However, couples at risk of having a child with a genetic condition may seek the advice of other physicians. The purpose of the present study was to describe the answers of four groups of specialists from Mexico City (internists, pediatricians, obstetricians, and neurologists) regarding how they would counsel a couple when prenatal diagnosis has shown that a fetus is affected by one of 17 different genetic disorders and to analyze the role of several variables in the development of their opinion. Our results show that physicians in these specialties are more likely to counsel directively than neutrally. Other variables did not influence the directiveness. With respect to direction of influence, internists, pediatricians, and neurologists are more likely to counsel terminating affected pregnancies than are obstetricians (P = 0.0002). Similarly, clinicians older than 37 years of age and those reporting that religion is not important to them counsel terminating affected pregnancies (P = 0.005 and P = 0.003, respectively). Physicians' gender and clinical experience with genetic diseases did not show statistically significant differences. Strong consensus among specialists was reached only on terminating pregnancies in anencephaly. A lowered and moderate consensus (51–75% agreement) was reached on continuing pregnancies with cleft lip and plate. A moderate measure of consensus for nondirective counselling was found among obstetricians regarding 14 of the 17 diseases in the study, whereas neurologists expressed a moderate measure of consensus on counselling the termination of pregnancies when the fetus was affected by neurological disorders. Hence, the approach to counselling was related in part to the fetal condition and in part to the clinician's specialty and age and the self-reported importance of religion. The data presented herein may not be representative of all Mexican physicians within the selected specialties; however, it is important to gather their opinions because they are involved in the care and treatment of genetic diseases and may have an important influence on the demand and availability of prenatal diagnosis and abortion. Am. J. Med. Genet. 69:23–28, 1997. © 1997 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Pitfalls of genetic counselling in brachydactyly type C

A familial case of brachydactyly type C is presented in which hand radiographs of the proposita's parents was considered normal. The metacarpophalangeal profile pattern of the mother's hands demonstrated minimal manifestations typical of brachydactyly type C. © 1994 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Intrafamilial variability in the clinical expression of familial hypercholesterolemia: importance of risk factor determination for genetic counselling

Kotze MJ, Davis HJ, Bissbort S, Langenhoven E, Brusnicky J, Oosthuizen CJJ. Intrafamilial variability in the clinical expression of familial hypercholesterolemia: importance of risk factor determination for genetic counselling.
Clin Genet 1993: 43: 295–299. © Munksgaard, 1993
A specific mutation in the low-density lipoprotein receptor (LDLR) gene causes familial hypercholesterolemia (FH) in about 60% of Afrikaner FH heterozygotes. Molecular diagnosis of this so-called FH Afrikaner-1 mutation was performed in a family with the disease. One individual did not develop coronary heart disease (CHD) by age 84, despite having the FH Afrikaner-1 mutation, while his son who inherited the same gene, developed CHD before age 50 and had to undergo bypass surgery. All the sibs in the third generation inherited the defective LDLR gene allele. This variation in clinical presentation creates a counselling dilemma. It also raises questions about the effect of diet and life style, and the possibility of other genes either contributing to the severity of the disease, or protecting against high lipid levels in plasma. An investigation of the influence of selected factors on the clinical expression of the FH Afrikaner-1 mutation in this family indicated that it was especially the elevated apolipoprotein (a) levels, in addition to low levels of high density lipoprotein cholesterol and raised triglyceride and apolipoprotein B levels, that were associated with a greater risk of developing CHD. These findings are thus in accordance with the view that the severity of CHD in FH patients is not only determined by the nature of the gene defect, but is also influenced by other risk factors.     

Genetic counselling in multiple sclerosis: risks to sibs and children of affected individuals

Genetic factors are recognized as having important roles in both the overall etiology and the familial aggregation of multiple sclerosis (MS), leading to increased requests for genetic counselling. This paper is designed to provide familial risk data in a practical format for use during genetic counselling for MS. Depending on the amount of genetic sharing among family members, the relative risk of MS compared with that for the general population can range from 1 (adopted sibs and children of the MS proband, with whom they share no genetic material) to 190 (monozygotic co-twins of MS patients, with whom they share 100% of their genetic material). When counselling full sibs of MS patients, risks can be better calculated if information is available on the age of MS onset in the patient and whether or not one parent has MS.     

Attitudes of Mexican geneticists towards prenatal diagnosis and selective abortion

Prenatal diagnosis (PD) provides the physician information on whether the unborn fetus has a genetic or chromosomal disorder, and offers patients a new option: selective abortion. In the present study, we analyzed the answers Mexican geneticists provided to a few selected questions from a multi-national survey designed by Wertz and Fletcher [1988: Am J Hum Genet 42:592–600]. The selected questions were related to the use of PD, the acceptance of selective abortion, and the self-reported directiveness of counselling following the diagnosis of a fetal anomaly. Our results show that the great majority of Mexican geneticists participating in the study agree with PD when medically indicated, but not on free demand. Specific cases stimulated the group on thinking more than the general statements provided in the survey. Although the majority agreed that PD should be available to all women, when faced with cases of nonmorbid maternal anxiety, paternity testing, and sex selection, the proportion of geneticists willing to perform the test decreased substantially. When counselling patients on a fetal anomaly, the minority would be as unbiased as possible, and this seems to be the tendency in developing countries where counselling, as stated in the respondents' comments, reflects the belief that the goal of genetics is the prevention of or opposition to abortion. Counselling was influenced by the severity of the disorder. The geneticists' personal attitude toward abortion in the same situations was stronger than when counselling others. Analysis of directiveness in counselling for fetal anomaly showed that older geneticists, with more years of experience in medical genetics, were more likely to be neutral. When counselling directively, the group showed an overall direction toward continuing affected pregnancies. However, older geneticists and those with more than 10 years of practice were more likely than their younger counterparts to counsel towards terminating affected pregnancies. In personal situations of fetal disorder, the general tendency was to abort; however, geneticists seeing more than 5 patients per week, and those who believe that religion is important, were more likely to reject abortion. The sample is representative of Mexican geneticists, and the main limitation of this study is that the geneticists have very little experience in PD, and that their responses were mostly based on theory. However, their opinions may influence the demand and the availability of PD and abortion, as well as the possibility of legalization of abortion on the basis of a fetal defect. Am. J. Med. Genet. 75:426-431, 1998. © 1998 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Evaluation of exclusion prenatal and exclusion preimplantation genetic diagnosis for Huntington's disease in the Netherlands

van Rij MC, de Die‐Smulders CEM, Bijlsma EK, de Wert GMWR, Geraedts JP, Roos RAC, Tibben A. Evaluation of exclusion prenatal and exclusion preimplantation genetic diagnosis for Huntington's disease in the Netherlands. Individuals at 50% risk of Huntington's disease (HD) who prefer not to know their carrier status, might opt for exclusion prenatal diagnosis (ePND) or exclusion preimplantation genetic diagnosis (ePGD). This study aims to provide a better understanding of couples' motives for choosing ePND or ePND, and surveys couples' experiences in order to make recommendations for the improvement of counselling for exclusion testing. This qualitative retrospective interview study focussed on couples who underwent ePND or ePGD for HD in the period 1996–2010. Seventeen couples were included of which 13 had experienced ePND and 6 ePGD. Mean time‐interval since exclusion‐testing was 3.9 years. Couples' moral reservations regarding termination of pregnancy (TOP) or discarding healthy embryos were counterbalanced by the wish to protect their future child against HD. Seven couples had terminated a total of 11 pregnancies with a 50% HD risk, none showed regret. ePGD was used by couples who wanted to avoid (another) TOP. ePND and ePGD are acceptable reproductive options for a specific group of counsellees. To guarantee sound standards of care, it is imperative that candidate couples be given in‐depth non‐directive counselling about all possible scenarios, and adequate professional and psychological support prior to, during and after ePND/ePGD.