Effects of Thy-1+ cell depletion on the capacity of donor lymphoid cells to induce tolerance across an entire MHC disparity in sublethally irradiated adult hosts

Thy-1+ cell depletion with anti-Thy-1.2 mAb and complement markedly reduced the capacity of C57BL/6J, H-2b bone marrow to establish mixed lymphoid chimerism and induce tolerance to C57BL/6J skin grafts across an entire MHC disparity in BALB/c, H-2d hosts conditioned with sublethal, fractionated 7.5 Gy total-body irradiation. In this model tolerance can be transferred to secondary irradiated BALB/c hosts only by cells of C57BL/6J donor, not host, genotype isolated from the spleens of tolerant hosts. Thy-1+ cell depletion abolished the capacity of C57BL/6J donor cells from tolerant BALB/c host spleens to transfer tolerance. The capacity of semiallogeneic BALB/c x C57BL/6J F1, H-2d/b donor BM and spleen cells to induce chimerism and tolerance to C57BL/6J skin grafts in BALB/c parental hosts was also reduced by Thy-1+ cell depletion. Thus the requirement for donor Thy-1+ cells cannot be explained simply on the basis of alloaggression. It is unlikely that the requisite Thy-1+ cells are nonspecific suppressor cells: Thy-1+ cell depletion had no effect on the slight but significant prolongation of third-party C3H/HeJ, H-2k skin grafts in irradiated BALB/c hosts injected with allogeneic C57BL/6J or semiallogeneic BALB/c x C57BL/6J F1 BM compared to irradiated controls injected with medium only. Furthermore, injections of semiallogeneic F1 spleen cells had no significant effect on the survival of the third-party grafts, although these cells were fully capable of inducing tolerance, and their capacity to induce tolerance was significantly reduced by Thy-1+ cell depletion. The requirement for a specific population of lymphoid cells, i.e. Thy-1+, remains unexplained but suggests that donor cells might play a role in the induction or maintenance of tolerance in this model other than merely providing a circulating source of donor antigens.     

Thy 1+ donor cells that promote allograft tolerance in sublethally irradiated MHC-disparate hosts.

We have previously demonstrated that depletion of Thy 1+ cells impairs the capacity of C57BL/6J, H-2b bone marrow cells, BMC, and BALB/cxC57BL/6J F1 BMC and spleen cells (SC) to establish mixed lymphoid chimerism and tolerance for donor-specific skin grafts in sublethally irradiated (240 cGy x3) BALB/c, H-2d hosts. In the present studies incubation with anti Ly2.2 + C markedly reduced the capacity of BALB/cxC57BL/6J, F1 SC to induce tolerance and chimerism (P less than .001). Incubation with anti-L3T4 + C had an inhibitory effect of borderline significance (P less than .04). Incubation with L-leucyl-L-leucine methyl ester (which removes NK cells, Tc, and precursor Tc) had no effect on the capacity of either C57BL/6J BMC or BALB/cxC57BL/6J F1 BMC or SC to establish chimerism and induce skin graft tolerance. These results suggest that tolerance-promoting Thy 1+ cells are not cytotoxic T cells. Both Ly2+ noncytotoxic CD8+ and L3T4+ noncytotoxic CD4+ cells may be involved. Alternatively the requisite Thy 1+ cells may be immature T cells that express both Ly2 and L3T4.     

Allogeneic chimerism established with a mixture of low dose bone marrow cells and splenocytes in sublethally irradiated mice

BACKGROUND: Allogeneic chimerism has been established in graft-accepting recipients and the donor cells in the host may act in a major way to facilitate the induction of tolerance. In this study, we examined the effects of allogeneic chimerism after injecting donor bone marrow cells (BMCs) mixed with splenocytes (SPLCs) to the sublethally conditioned recipients. METHODS: In BALB/c(H-2(d)) to B6(H-2(b)) combination, B6 recipients were irradiated at 7.5 Gy and were injected a mixture of donor BMCs and SPLCs intravenously. On day 90 after injection, the degree of chimerism in peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) and in the splenocytes was checked by flow cytometry. RESULTS: In groups which were injected varying BMCs, when > 45 x 10(6) BMCs were injected into B6, a large percentage of donor cells were detected in PBL and in the spleen. In contrast, when < 30 x 10(6) BMCs were injected into B6, only a small percentage of donor cells were detected. In the groups which were injected 3 x 10(6) BMCs with varying SPLCs, when > 10 x 10(6) SPLCs were added, a large percentage of donor cells were detected in PBL and SPLCs, but a small percentage of donor cells were detected with the addition of < 3 x 10(6) SPLCs. A high percentage of chimeric mice showed donor specific tolerance in vitro, mixed lymphocyte responses, and in vivo, skin grafting. In contrast, only a small percentage of chimeric mice showed no donor specific tolerance by skin grafting. CONCLUSION: These findings suggested that even a low dose of BMCs can establish a state of allogeneic chimerism and donor specific tolerance if combined with SPLCs.     

Ability of donor splenocytes with costimulation blockade to induce mixed hematopoietic chimerism and transplantation tolerance

We reported stable mixed chimerism and specific tolerance to a fully allogeneic graft after a minimally myelosuppressive regimen including costimulation blockade (CB), donor bone marrow cells (BMC), and busulfan (Bu), a chemotherapeutic conditioning agent that makes niches for engraftment of BMC. For clinical application, the strategy may have the limitation of the number of donor BMC when a deceased donor offers transplants to multiple recipients. Herein, we examined whether donor splenocytes can serve as an alternative source to induce mixed chimerism and tolerance. When a C57BL/6 (H-2b) recipient was treated with CB (CTLA4-Ig and anti-CD154 mAb, on days 0, 2, 4, 6) and donor BALB/c (H-2d) BMC (2 x 10(7) cells on day 0) in the absence of Bu, survival of BALB/c skin graft was remarkably prolonged but not indefinite (median survival time [MST]: 138 days). The recipients never showed durable chimerism. When the recipient was treated with CB and donor splenocytes ([DST] 2 x 10(7) cells on day 0), survival was not indefinite either (MST: 114 days). When the dose of DST was increased to 2 x 10(8) cells, survival was further prolonged; two of six recipients had indefinite survival (MST: 132 days). Moreover, one recipient showed a low level of chimerism. When treated with CB, donor DST (2 x 10(7) cells on day 0) and Bu (20 mg/kg, day -1), six of seven recipients showed a stable, high level of chimerism and enjoyed tolerance of skin allografts. DST combined with CB and Bu may be an alternative source of hematopoietic stem cells to induce mixed chimerism and transplantation tolerance in our model.     

A more persistent tolerance to islet allografts through bone marrow transplantation in minimal nonmyeloablative conditioning therapy

INTRODUCTION: Islet transplantation is a therapeutic approach to prevent diabetes complications. However, the side effects of the required lifelong immunosuppressive regimens to prevent graft rejection restrict the impact of type 1 diabetes. One strategy to overcome these limitations is tolerance induction and graft acceptance through hematopoietic chimerism. In this study we investigated whether tolerance to major histocompatibility complex (MHC) and minor-disparate islet allografts could be induced by minimal nonmyeloablative conditioning and whether more persistent donor-specific islet allografts were accepted if the grafts were implanted with simultaneous bone marrow cells. METHODS: The donor and recipient mice were BALB/c(H-2(b)) and C57BL/6(H-2(d)), respectively. In group 1 streptozotocin-induced diabetic C57BL/6(H-2(d)) mice received only 500 islets of BALB/c(H-2(b)). Group 2 recipients conditioned with antilymphocyte serum, 100 cGy total body irradiation and cyclophosphamide were given islet cells of BALB/c(H-2(b)), but group 3 were simultaneously given 30 x 10(6) BALB/c(H-2(b)) mice BMCs and islet cells similar to group 2. RESULTS: We obtained 5% to 6% allogeneic donor chimerism and 60% graft survival at 80 days after islet transplantation in group 3. We observed lymphocyte infiltration around the islet without destruction of endocrine cells and the presence of strong insulin/glucagon-stained cells in group 3. CONCLUSION: This minimal nonmyeloablative conditioning therapy induced donor chimerism and immune tolerance between MHC- and minor-disparate (BALB/c-->C57BL/6) mice and long-term islet graft survival was obtained through cotransplantation of bone marrow cells.     

Prenatal tolerance induction: relationship between cell dose, marrow T-cells, chimerism, and tolerance

It was reported that the dose of self-antigens can determine the consequence of deletional tolerance and donor T cells are critical for tolerance induction in mixed chimeras. This study aimed at assessing the effect of cell doses and marrow T cells on engraftment and tolerance induction after prenatal bone marrow transplantation. Intraperitoneal cell transplantation was performed in FVB/N (H-2K(q)) mice at gestational day 14 with escalating doses of adult C57BL/6 (H-2K(b)) marrows. Peripheral chimerism was examined postnatally by flow cytometry and tolerance was tested by skin transplantation. Transplantation of light-density marrow cells showed a dose response. High-level chimerism emerged with a threshold dose of 5.0 x 10(6) and host leukocytes could be nearly replaced at a dose of 7.5-10.0 x 10(6). High-dose transplants conferred a steady long-lasting donor-specific tolerance but were accompanied by >50% incidence of graft-versus-host disease. Depletion of marrow T cells lessened graft-versus-host disease to the detriment of engraftment. With low-level chimerism, tolerance was a graded phenomenon dependent upon the level of chimerism. Durable chimerism within 6 months required a threshold of > or = 2% chimerism at 1 month of age and predicted a 50% chance of long-term tolerance, whereas transient chimerism (<2%) only caused hyporesponsiveness to the donor. Tolerance induction did not succeed without peripheral chimerism even if a large amount of injected donor cells persisted in the peritoneum. Neither did an increase in cell doses or donor T-cell contents benefit skin graft survivals unless it had substantially improved peripheral chimerism. Thus, peripheral chimerism level can be a simple and straightforward test to predict the degree of prenatal immune tolerance.     

Active role of chimerism in transplantation tolerance induced by antilymphocyte serum, sirolimus, and bone-marrow-cell infusion

BACKGROUND: A regimen consisting of antilymphocyte serum (ALS), sirolimus, and donor bone-marrow-cell (BMC) infusion induces indefinite skin allograft survival across fully mismatched mouse strain combinations. We investigated the role of chimerism in this transplantation tolerance model. MATERIALS: B10.A (H-2a) mice were treated with ALS on day -1 and 2, sirolimus, and infusion of (C57BL/6xDBA/2)F1 (B6D2F1, H-2(b/d)) BMCs on day 7 relative to DBA/2 (D2) skin grafting on day 0. At postgraft days 30, 50 and 120, the recipient mice were injected intravenously with splenocytes prepared from either naive or D2 mixed chimeric B10.A mice that had been sensitized in vivo to B6. Changes in chimerism and graft survival were monitored. RESULTS: Although D2 skin grafts were rejected with a median survival time of 63.8 days in B10.A mice given ALS and sirolimus alone, they survived more than 200 days in all B10.A mice given ALS, sirolimus, and B6D2F1 BMCs. Chimerism became evident 21 days postgrafting and progressively increased thereafter to 20% at postgraft day 200. Infusion of anti-B6 presensitized cells resulted in depletion of chimeric donor cells and subsequent graft rejection regardless of the timing of injection. Injection of presensitized cells in mice given ALS and sirolimus alone had no effect on graft survival. Injection of presensitized cells that were cytotoxic to alloantigen expressed by BMCs but tolerant to skin reduced, but did not deplete, established chimerism and allowed continued allograft survival. CONCLUSIONS: Chimeric donor cells play a major role in both the early and late phases of transplantation tolerance induced by the ALS, sirolimus, and BMC regimen.     

Induction of transplantation tolerance by intraportal injection of allogeneic bone marrow cells

Intraportal inoculation of C57BL/6 marrow cells into sublethally (400 rad) irradiated BALB/c recipients resulted in durable chimerism and the permanent acceptance of C57BL/6 skin allografts. Sublethally irradiated recipients of a similar number of marrow cells inoculated systemically did not develop chimerism or any significant prolongation of the survival of C57BL/6 skin allografts. Consequently, lethal graft-versus-host disease developed only in recipients of intraportal marrow allografts (80%). The intraportal injection of allogeneic C57BL/6 marrow cells into nonirradiated recipients resulted in significant, although not permanent, prolongation of skin allograft survival without durable chimerism, suggesting that the introduction of alloantigens intraportally may favor the induction of nonresponsiveness to alloantigens even across strong major histocompatibility barriers. The relevance of these findings is discussed regarding the intraportal inoculation of allogeneic bone marrow cells for the treatment of genetic disorders in utero through the induction of neonatal tolerance.     

Induction of transplantation tolerance by intraportal injection of allogeneic bone marrow cells: Possible implications for intrauterine bone marrow transplantation across major histocompatibility barriers

Abstract. Intraportal inoculation of C57BL/6 marrow cells into sublethally (400 rad) irradiated BALB/c recipients resulted in durable chimerism and the permanent acceptance of C57BL/6 skin allografts. Sublethally irradiated recipients of a similar number of marrow cells inoculated systemically did not develop chimerism or any significant prolongation of the survival of C57BL/6 skin allografts. Consequently, lethal graft-versus-host disease developed only in recipients of intraportal marrow allografts (80%). The intraportal injection of allogeneic C57BL/6 marrow cells into nonirradiated recipients resulted in significant, although not permanent, prolongation of skin allograft survival without durable chimerism, suggesting that the introduction of alloantigens intraportally may favor the induction of nonresponsiveness to alloantigens even across strong major histocompatibility barriers. The relevance of these findings is discussed regarding the intraportal inoculation of allogeneic bone marrow cells for the treatment of genetic disorders in utero through the induction of neonatal tolerance.     

The requirement for allogeneic chimerism for second transfer of tolerance from mixed allogeneic chimeras (A+B-->A) to secondary recipients.

We have applied the model of mixed allogeneic chimerism (A+B-->A), in which stem cells from both allogeneic and syngeneic donor engraft, to determine the in vivo cellular requirements for transfer of tolerance from mixed chimeras to secondary recipients. Using two approaches, we have demonstrated that the persistence of donor-specific transplantation tolerance is dependent on the presence of bone-marrow-derived cells. When untreated bone marrow from mixed chimeras was transferred to irradiated secondary recipient mice, most of the secondary recipients were rescued, but only 48% were demonstrably chimeric. This pattern of repopulation, therefore, allowed us to examine whether chimerism was required to maintain transplantation tolerance. In all of our studies, the presence of allogeneic chimerism was required for successful transfer of tolerance from mixed allogeneic chimeras to irradiated secondary recipients. Only those secondary recipients which repopulated with demonstrable allogeneic chimerism exhibited in vivo and in vitro evidence for transfer of donor-specific transplantation tolerance. These results were confirmed by using transfer of bone marrow from mixed chimeras depleted of allogeneic class I elements. In an attempt to identify a putative population of suppressor cells, second transfer of splenic lymphoid cells from mixed allogeneic chimeras, containing approximately 6 times more T-lymphocytes that were functionally tolerant to donor alloantigens, was also performed with similar results. These data suggest that the in vivo maintenance of tolerance to MHC transplantation alloantigens requires persistence of donor bone marrow-derived alloantigens.     

Mixed chimerism, heart, and skin allograft tolerance in cyclophosphamide-induced tolerance

We elucidated the possible role of chimerism in skin and heart allograft tolerance using cyclophosphamide (CP)-induced tolerance. When C3H (H-2k; Thy1.2, Mls-1b) mice were i.v. primed with 1x10(8) spleen cells (SC) from H-2 matched AKR (H-2k; Thy1.1, Mls-1a) mice and then treated i.p. with 200 mg/kg of CP, the survivals of both AKR skin grafts and heart grafts (HG) were permanently prolonged in a tolerogen-specific fashion. After this treatment, a minimal degree of mixed chimerism, the clonal destruction of Mls-1a-reactive CD4+Vbeta6+ T cells in the periphery, and the clonal deletion of Vbeta6+ thymocytes were all observed. When AKR SC and 100 mg/kg CP were used for conditioning, the AKR HG were permanently accepted, but the survival of the AKR skin grafts was only mildly prolonged. The clonal destruction of CD4+Vbeta6+ T cells in the periphery and the intrathymic clonal deletion of Vbeta6+ thymocytes were induced in both the SC and the 100 mg/kg CP-treated C3H mice. A minimal degree of mixed chimerism was detectable at 4 and 12 weeks after AKR SC and 100 mg/kg CP treatment, and still did not disappear at 40 weeks. The degree of mixed chimerism induced with SC and 100 mg/kg CP was significantly lower than that with SC and 200 mg/kg CP during the observation. No posttransplant cardiac allograft vasculopathy (CAV) was observed to develop, while both the Th1 type (interferon-gamma) and Th2 type (interleukin-4 and -10) cytokine expressions decreased in the AKR HG of the tolerant C3H mice treated with both AKR SC plus 200 mg/kg CP, and AKR SC plus 100 mg/kg CP. A second set of skin grafts from donor AKR mice survived for more than 100 days in a tolerogen-specific fashion in all C3H mice treated with AKR SC and 200 mg/kg CP and also accepted the AKR HG for over 200 days, while 80% of the C3H mice treated with AKR SC and 100 mg/kg CP and accepted the AKR HG for more than 200 days. These results strongly suggested the following conclusions: 1) the degree of chimerism can strongly influence the induction of skin and heart allograft tolerance, 2) posttransplant CAV does not develop in the donor HG maintained by chimerism-based CP-induced tolerance, 3) the mRNA expression of both Th1 and Th2 type cytokine decreased in the donor HG maintained by chimerism-based CP-induced tolerance, and 4) the induction of skin allograft tolerance is more difficult than the prevention of posttransplant CAV.     

Distinct roles for major and minor antigen barriers in chimerism-based tolerance under irradiation-free conditions

Eliminating cytoreductive conditioning from chimerism-based tolerance protocols would facilitate clinical translation. Here we investigated the impact of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) and minor histocompatibility antigen (MiHA) barriers on mechanisms of tolerance and rejection in this setting. Transient depletion of natural killer (NK) cells at the time of bone marrow (BM) transplantation (BMT) (20 × 10⁶ BALB/c BM cells → C57BL/6 recipients under costimulation blockade [CB] and rapamycin) prevented BM rejection. Despite persistent levels of mixed chimerism, BMT recipients gradually rejected skin grafts from the same donor strain. Extending NK cell depletion did not improve skin graft survival. However, F1 (C57BL/6×BALB/c) donors, which do not elicit NK cell-mediated rejection, induced durable chimerism and tolerance. In contrast, if F1 donors with BALB/c background only were used (BALB/c×BALB.B), no tolerance was observed. In the absence of MiHA disparities (B10.D2 donors, MHC-mismatch only), temporal NK cell depletion established stable chimerism and tolerance. Conversely, MHC identical BM (BALB.B donors, MiHA mismatch only) readily engrafted without NK cell depletion but no skin graft tolerance ensued. Therefore, we conclude that under CB and rapamycin, MHC disparities provoke NK cell-mediated BM rejection in nonirradiated recipients whereas MiHA disparities do not prevent BM engraftment but impede skin graft tolerance in established mixed chimeras.     

CD8 T cell of donor splenocyte mixed with bone marrow cells is more effective than CD4 T cell for induction of donor-specific tolerance in sublethally irradiated mice

BACKGROUND: We previously demonstrated that even a low dose of bone marrow cells (BMCs) established donor-specific tolerance if mixed with splenocytes (SPLCs). In this study, T-cell subsets CD4 (CD4SP) and CD8 (CD8SP) of donor SPLCs were investigated for their contribution to the enhancement of BMC engraftment leading to donor-specific tolerance in sublethally irradiated mice. METHODS: Sublethally irradiated C57BL/6 recipient mice were intravenously injected BMCs mixing with CD4SP or CD8SP harvested from BALB/c donor mice. The degree of chimerism in the peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBLs) and in the SPLCs was analyzed using FACS, mixed lymphocyte reaction, and skin graft transplantation 3 months after injection. RESULTS: Recipients injected with 3 x 10(6) donor BMCs admixed with 10 x 10(6) donor CD8SP established chimerism. However, recipients injected with the same dose of BMCs admixed with 5 x 10(6) CD4SP, 10 x 10(6) CD4SP, and 5 x 10(6) CD8SP did not established chimerism. CD8SP contained 44% of Ly6A/E (Stem Cell Antigen-1 (Sca-1))-positive cells based on FACS analysis, whereas only 6% of CD4SP were positive for Ly6A/E. MLR supernates of donor SPLCs chimeric mice using admixture with CD8SP dominated by Th2 cytokines. In contrast, mixting with MLR supernates from failed chimera showed dominant Th1 cytokines. CONCLUSIONS: CD8SP seems to make a major contribution to enhance BMC engraftment and induce donor-specific tolerance. Ly6A/E (Sca-1)-positive cells need to be further investigated for their contribution to the establishment of chimerism.     

Requirement of a higher degree of chimerism for skin allograft tolerance in cyclophosphamide-induced tolerance

By using a cyclophosphamide (CP)-induced tolerance system, we previously raised the possibility that the degree of chimerism might determine the induction of heart and skin allograft tolerance. When C3H (H-2^k; Thy1.2, Mls-1^b) mice were intravenously primed with 1×10⁸ spleen cells (SCs) from H-2 matched AKR (H-2^k; Thy1.1, Mls-1^a) mice and then treated intraperitoneally with 200 mg/kg CP, the survival of AKR skin grafts was permanently prolonged in a tolerogen-specific fashion. After this treatment, a minimal degree of mixed chimerism and the clonal destruction of Mls-1^a-reactive CD4⁺V6⁺ T cells in the periphery were observed. When AKR SCs and 100 mg/kg CP were used for conditioning, the survival of the AKR skin grafts was mildly prolonged. The clonal destruction of CD4⁺V6⁺ T cells in the periphery was induced and a minimal degree of mixed chimerism was detectable. The degree of mixed chimerism induced with AKR SCs and 200 mg/kg CP was significantly higher than that with AKR SCs and 100 mg/kg CP during the observation. On the other hand, neither skin allograft prolongation nor permanent mixed chimerism could be induced when C3H mice were treated with AKR SCs and 50 mg/kg CP. In order to increase the degree of mixed chimerism, we injected 1×10⁸ tolerant AKR SCs on day 3 into the recipient C3H mice that had been treated with AKR SCs on day 0 and with 100 mg/kg CP on day 2. The reason that we used tolerant SCs was that untreated AKR SCs caused graft-versus-host disease in most of the recipients. Tolerant AKR SCs were harvested from AKR mice that had been treated with C3H SCs and 200 mg/kg CP 2 weeks earlier, and did not contain regulatory cells. By adoptive transfer, the degree of chimerism was stably and significantly increased in all recipients, and AKR skin graft tolerance was induced in half of the recipients. T-cell-depleted bone marrow cells (BMCs) from untreated AKR mice induced skin allograft tolerance in 83% of recipients. Thus, the present study strongly confirmed the hypothesis that a higher degree of chimerism is required for the induction of skin allograft tolerance in CP-induced tolerance.     

Comparison of chimeric acid and non-chimeric tolerance using posttransplant total lymphoid irradiation: cytokine expression and chronic rejection.

BACKGROUND: Previous studies showed that an intravenous infusion of donor blood cells facilitates tolerance to ACI heart allografts in Lewis rat hosts given posttransplant total lymphoid irradiation (TLI) and anti-thymocyte globulin (ATG). The object of the current study was to compare tolerance induction using donor cells that do or do not induce chimerism. METHODS: Normal peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC), granulocyte colony-stimulating factor (G-CSF)-mobilized PBMC, and bone marrow (BM) cells from ACI donors were tested for their capacity to prolong ACI heart allograft survival in Lewis hosts. Chimerism, anti-donor cell reactivity, and cytokine gene expression in grafts were determined. RESULTS: Intravenous injections of equal numbers of all three donor cells markedly prolonged graft survival (median: >164 to >175 days) as compared to uninjected controls (median: 53 days). Chimerism among T and B cells in the blood was determined by immunofluorescent staining in hosts bearing long-term (> 150 days) grafts. Although no chimerism was detected in hosts given normal or G-CSF-mobilized PBMC, chimerism was detected at variable levels in all hosts given BM cells. Vigorous anti-donor reactivity in the mixed leukocyte reaction was present only in non-chimeric hosts. Long-term grafts from hosts given normal ACI PBMC developed chronic rejection, but those from hosts given ACI BM cells did not. The latter hosts showed the lowest levels of intragraft cytokine mRNA. CONCLUSIONS: Chimeric tolerance is more robust than non-chimeric tolerance in the model of posttransplant TLI, ATG, and donor cell infusion, and is associated with less chronic rejection.     

Donor-specific tolerance in a murine model: the result of extra-thymic T cell deletion?

Previously, we established a murine model, that involves the engraftment of fully allogeneic T cell depleted donor bone marrow cells in sublethally irradiated and single dose anti-CD3 treated recipient mice. These mice developed permanent stable multilineage mixed chimerism and donor-specific tolerance without graft-versus-host disease. Recently, we have shown that donor-specific tolerance is not induced and/or maintained by clonal anergy, neither by a Th1/Th2 shift, nor by suppressor or other regulatory processes. In the present study, we investigated whether clonal deletion plays a role in tolerance induction in our model. We studied the kinetics of TCRVbeta8(+) T cells in BALB/c (H-2L(d+))-->dm2 (H-2L(d-)) chimeras, in which combination of mouse strains TCRVbeta8 predominates the anti-donor response. We found that TCRVbeta8(+) T cells were specifically deleted. To our surprise, this deletion was also found in mixed chimeras, thymectomized prior to the conditioning regimen. We conclude that clonal deletion plays a role in the establishment and maintenance of donor-specific tolerance, and that the thymus is not required for this process. In addition, confocal laser-scanning microscopy clearly showed the presence of abundant amounts of donor T cells and some donor antigen presenting cells in the small intestine in thymectomized chimeras and not in other organs, suggesting that T cell selection might take place in this organ in the absence of the thymus.     

The role of donor lymphoid cells in the transfer of allograft tolerance

Tolerance to murine skin allografts across a MHC disparity was induced by conditioning primary hosts with sublethal fractionated total-body irradiation (FTBI) and transfusion of allogeneic bone marrow (BM). Tolerance could be adoptively transferred to secondary hosts conditioned by FTBI with infusion of spleen cells from hosts bearing intact skin allografts greater than 60 days. Tolerance could not be transferred by tolerant host spleen (THS) preparations from which cells of the donor genotype had been deleted by cytotoxic alloantisera. Deletion of host genotype cells, however, did not diminish the capability of THS to transfer tolerance. All of the tolerizing activity of THS appeared to reside within cells of the donor genotype. Small numbers of normal donor spleen cells could induce tolerance in FTBI hosts but only at the expense of very high mortality, in contrast to the low mortality observed with tolerizing injections of allogeneic donor cells from THS or injections of normal semiallogeneic F1 hybrid spleen cells. If an active immune response is responsible for tolerance induction/transfer in this model, allogeneic donor lymphoid cells derived from BM, in contrast to donor spleen cells, must be capable of mounting this response without concomitant severe GVHD. In future experiments, cells of donor genotype can be isolated from THS and purified in sufficient numbers to compare their tolerizing efficiency vs. that of normal donor cells, detect possible suppression of normal host cell alloreactivity in vitro and identify the donor cell phenotypes involved.     

Induction of stable chimerism and transplantation tolerance to rat islet and heart allografts by ultraviolet-B modulation of bone marrow cells.

Ultraviolet-B irradiation (UV-B) (700 J/m2) of BM cells prior to transplantation into lethally gamma-irradiated (1050 rads) allogeneic rats prevents the development of GVHD and results in stable chimerism. This study was developed to determine if UV-B modulation of BMT is useful for preconditioning recipients for the induction of tolerance to donor islets and heart allografts. Lethally irradiated Lewis rats that received UV-B irradiated (700 J/m2) WF BMT (10(8) BM cells) demonstrated stable chimerism without any evidence of GVHD. The stable Lewis chimeras were made diabetic with streptozotocin (STZ) at 28-35 days after BMT and subdivided into 3 experimental groups that received 1000-1200 islets from WF, Lewis, or BN (third-party), respectively. The results showed that group I diabetic Lewis chimeras accepted permanently (greater than 300 days) BM donor WF islets and became normoglycemic. When 3 of 6 Lewis chimeras transplanted with WF islets were rechallenged with WF hearts 60 days after islet grafts, they accepted both islets and cardiac allografts permanently (greater than 240 days). Similarly, the remaining 3 animals accepted Lewis cardiac allografts permanently, thus indicating tolerance to both donor and recipient alloantigens. Group II diabetic chimeras accepted permanently (greater than 300 days) recipient (Lewis) islets. In contrast, group III chimeras rejected acutely (7-8 days) third-party (BN) islets. However, when these animals that rejected BN islets and again became diabetic were retransplanted with BM donor-type (WF) islets, they became permanently normoglycemic (greater than 200 days). This finding emphasizes the specificity of the induction of tolerance in this model and the apparent lack of organ-specific sensitization. To define the underlying mechanism of tolerance, in vivo adoptive transfer of 10(8) spleen cells to naive Lewis or WF recipients, obtained from tolerant Lewis chimeras carrying donor islets and heart allografts, showed no prolongation of cardiac allografts in the unmodified syngeneic hosts, thus questioning the role of suppressor mechanisms in the tolerant rats. Furthermore, cells from the tolerant chimeras that showed no mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) response to Lewis or; WF alloantigens failed to suppress anti-Lewis and anti-WF MLR-response in coculture MLR. These results suggest that tolerance to donor alloantigens in the UV-B BMT model is most likely due to selective elimination of anti-BM donor helper or effector cell precursors (clonal deletion) rather than induction of suppressor cell activity. This study demonstrates that this relatively simple and effective approach to modulation of T cells in BM treatment may be potentially useful in the induction of tolerance to donor organs.     

Evidence against suppressor cell involvement in naturally acquired tolerance of a minor histocompatibility antigen

The hypothesis was investigated that suppressor cells may be responsible for maintenance of immunologic tolerance of a minor H3 antigen in mice that express the antigen naturally. Lymphoid cell populations from B6.C-H-24c (HW54) mice, a congenic-resistant strain histoincompatible with H-24b-expressing C57BL/6 (B6) mice only with respect to the H-24 locus, were examined in cell-transfer experiments to see if they contained naturally arising H-24c-specific suppressor cells. The H-24 antigen was chosen for these studies because, unlike most other minor and major histocompatibility (H) antigens, it is not detectable on mature lymphoid cells by any of several functional criteria. Thus transfer of HW54 lymphoid cells to B6 hosts could be done without the complication of inducing hyporesponsiveness de novo in the host, as occurs with other minor H antigens that are expressed on lymphocytes. B6 hosts were given HW54 skin grafts along with HW54 lymphoid cells to assess their tolerance of the H-24c-encoded antigen. The hosts were either (1) normal, nonimmune B6 mice; (2) B6 mice rendered immunodeficient by thymectomy and irradiation (TXB) and repopulated with H-24c-immune B6 lymphocytes; or (3) TXB B6 hosts repopulated with nonimmune B6 lymphocytes. In each case it was found that the additionally infused HW54 lymphoid cells did not suppress the ability of these hosts to reject HW54 skin grafts. In other words, HW54 lymphoid cells appear not to possess suppressive activity specific for the H-24c antigen that might maintain antigen-specific natural tolerance. Additional experiments were performed to determine whether HW54 lymphoid cells can inhibit the ability of sublethally irradiated B6 mice to regain the capacity to reject HW54 skin. The purpose of these experiments was to determine whether there are naturally occurring HW54 lymphoid cells that can suppress the development of lymphocytes potentially reactive to H-24c antigen that presumably emerge in B6 mice following sublethal irradiation. Such suppressor cells would be candidate initiators of self-tolerance. Here, too, no evidence for such suppressor cells was obtained.