Systemic and local ibandronate enhance screw fixation.

The trauma involved with inserting implants into bone leads to an activation of the inflammatory response and an activation of osteoclasts. In addition, apoptosis of osteocytes in the surrounding area has been implicated in further activation of osteoclasts. If the balance between resorption and bone formation shortly after implantation favours resorption, an impairment of early fixation might ensue. Because bisphosphonates inhibit resorption, this study analyses whether they can improve early fixation. Stainless steel screws (M 1.7) were inserted into the tibiae of 76 male Sprague-Dawley rats. Daily subcutaneous injections of ibandronate (3 microg) or saline were given to 20 rats. The remaining rats received ibandronate or saline directly applied into the drill hole before the screw was inserted. Tibiae were harvested at 14 days. Mechanical tests were performed on 50 tibiae. Systemically treated tibiae were tested for pull-out strength alone. Locally treated tibiae were tested for either pull-out or torque resistance. The remaining 18 tibiae were prepared for histology. Systemic ibandronate increased the pull-out force at failure by 30% (p=0.04). Local treatment increased the force at failure by 15% (p=0.02) and stiffness by 28% (p=0.01). In the removal torque measurements, local ibandronate increased the torque-moment at failure by 60% (p=0.04), and the maximum friction moment by 51% (p=0.04). Energy for turning the screw 1/4 revolution was increased by 68% (p=0.02). These results demonstrate that early remodeling events plays an important role in screw fixation, and that systemic or local bisphosphonate treatment could be an effective pharmacological path to improve early implant fixation.     

The effects of cyclic loading on pull-out strength of sacral screw fixation: an in vitro biomechanical study

STUDY DESIGN: The pull-out strength of sacral screw fixation after cyclic loading was tested using young human cadaveric specimens. OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the effects of fatigue loading on the pull-out strength of medial and lateral unicortical and bicortical sacral screws and to correlate the pull-out strength with sacral bone density and the screw insertion torque. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: The immediate biomechanical effects of depth of penetration, screw orientation, and bone density on sacral screw fixation have been studied in aged cadaveric specimens. The effect of cyclic loading on the pull-out strength of sacral screw fixation is unknown, however, and data from young specimens is rare. METHODS: Eleven fresh specimens of human sacrum were used in this study. Bone mineral density at the vertebral body and the ala were determined by peripheral quantitative computed tomography. Seven-millimeter compact Cotrel-Dubousset sacral screws were inserted into the sacrum anteromedially and anterolaterally, both unicortically and bicortically, and the insertion torque for each screw was measured. Cyclic loading from 40 to 400 N was applied to each screw at a frequency of 2 Hz up to 20,000 cycles. Pull-out tests were conducted after completion of the fatigue tests. RESULTS: The average bone density was 0.38 +/- 0.08 g/mL at the S1 body and 0.24 +/- 0.05 g/mL at the S1 ala. The insertion torque and average pull-out force after cyclic loading were significantly higher for bicortical fixation than for unicortical fixation for a particular screw alignment. The pull-out strength and insertion torque of medially oriented fixation was always higher than that for lateral fixation, however, regardless of whether the insertion was unicortical or bicortical. The pull-out force of unicortical and bicortical medial screw fixations after cyclic loading showed significant linear correlations with both the insertion torque and the bone mineral density of the S1 body. CONCLUSIONS: In a young population, screw orientation (anterolateral or anteromedial) was more important in determining pull-out strength than screw depth (unicortical or bicortical) after fatigue loading, anteromedially directed screws being significantly stronger than laterallyplaced screws. Bone mineral density of the S1 body andinsertion torque were good preoperative and intraoperative indicators of screw pull-out strength.     

Biomechanical evaluation of a double-threaded pedicle screw in elderly vertebrae

We sought to test the hypothesis that a pedicle screw that has two parallel threads of different heights throughout the full length of the screw could increase both bone purchase and pull-out strength compared with a standard single-threaded screw of similar dimensions. A single-threaded pedicle screw and a double-threaded pedicle screw were respectively placed into the paired pedicles of 21 vertebral bodies. The screws were then pulled out of the pedicles, and output parameters were measured. Although insertional torque was, on average, 14.5% higher (p = 0.039) for the single-threaded screw, maximum pull-out strength (p = 0.12), energy-to-failure (p = 0.39), and stiffness (p = 0.54) were not statistically different for the two screw types. It is concluded that a second, smaller inner thread on a double-threaded pedicle screw does not translate into either increased bone purchase or higher pull-out strengths.     

The role of the dorsal vertebral cortex in the stability of transpedicular screws. A biomechanical study in human cadaveric vertebrae

The aim of this biomechanical study was to investigate the role of the dorsal vertebral cortex in transpedicular screw fixation. Moss transpedicular screws were introduced into both pedicles of each vertebra in 25 human cadaver vertebrae. The dorsal vertebral cortex and subcortical bone corresponding to the entrance site of the screw were removed on one side and preserved on the other. Biomechanical testing showed that the mean peak pull-out strength for the inserted screws, following removal of the dorsal cortex, was 956.16 N. If the dorsal cortex was preserved, the mean peak pullout strength was 1295.64 N. The mean increase was 339.48 N (26.13%; p = 0.033). The bone mineral density correlated positively with peak pull-out strength. Preservation of the dorsal vertebral cortex at the site of insertion of the screw offers a significant increase in peak pull-out strength. This may result from engagement by the final screw threads in the denser bone of the dorsal cortex and the underlying subcortical area. Every effort should be made to preserve the dorsal vertebral cortex during insertion of transpedicular screws.     

Biomechanical comparison of anatomic trajectory pedicle screw versus injectable calcium sulfate graft-augmented pedicle screw for salvage in cadaveric thoracic bone

Many salvage options for failed thoracic pedicle screws exist including the use of a different trajectory or the augmentation of the screw with polymethylmethacrylate cement. Although polymethylmethacrylate immediately increases the construct stiffness and the pull-out strength, it may cause bone necrosis, toxin relaxation, and/or neural injury. On the other hand, calcium sulfate bone grafts have a high potential for biologic incorporation and no thermal damage effect. In the current study, polyaxial pedicle screws were first inserted with a straightforward approach on both sides in 17 fresh human cadaveric thoracic vertebrae. The maximal insertion torque for each screw was measured and then the pull-out strengths were recorded. Afterward, these pedicle screws were randomly assigned to be replaced either by graft augmentation or by anatomic trajectory technique for salvage. The graft-augmented screws were placed using the previous holes. The maximum insertional torque for each anatomic trajectory screw was measured. Finally, the pull-out strengths of the revision screws were recorded. The mean maximum insertional torque decreased with the anatomic trajectory salvage technique when compared with the straightforward approach, 0.23 versus 0.38 Nm, respectively (P=0.003). The anatomic trajectory revision resulted in decreased pull-out strength when compared with the pull-out strength of the straightforward technique, 297 versus 469 N, respectively (P=0.003).The calcium sulfate graft augmentation increased the pull-out strength when compared with the pull-out strength of the straightforward technique, 680 versus 477 N, respectively (P=0.017). The mean pull-out strength ratio of revised screw to original was 0.71 for anatomic trajectory and 1.8 for graft-augmented screws, a statistically significant difference (P=0.002).     

Titanium-alloy enhances bone-pedicle screw fixation: mechanical and histomorphometrical results of titanium-alloy versus stainless steel

Several types of pedicle screw systems have been utilized to augment lumbar spine fusion. The majority of these systems are made of stainless steel (Ss), but titanium-alloy (Ti-alloy) devices have recently been available on the market. Ti-alloy implants have several potential advantages over Ss ones. High bioactivity and more flexibility may improve bone ingrowth and mechanical fixation, and the material also offers superior magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and computed tomography (CT) resolution and significantly less signal interference. However, no data are available from loaded spinal constructs regarding bony ingrowth and mechanical fixation. The aim of this study was to analyse the effect of Ti-alloy versus Ss pedicle screws on mechanical fixation and bone ingrowth in a loaded mini-pig model. Eighteen adult mini-pigs underwent total laminectomy and posterolateral spinal fusion at L3-L4, and were randomly selected to receive either Ss (n = 9) or Ti (n = 9) pedicle screw devices. In both groups, the device used was compact Cotrel-Dubousset instrumentation (Sofamore Danek) of an identical size and shape. The postoperative observation time was ¶3 months. Screws from L3 were used for histomorphometric studies. Mechanical testing (torsional tests and pull-out tests) was performed on the screws from L4. The Ti screws had a higher maximum torque (P < 0.05) and angular stiffness (P < 0.07), measured by torsional testing. In the pull-out tests, no differences were found between the two groups with respect to the maximum load, stiffness and energy to failure. No correlation between removal torque and the pull-out strength was found (r = 0.1). Bone ongrowth on Ti was increased by 33% compared with Ss ¶(P < 0.04), whereas no differences in bone volume around the screws were shown. Mechanical binding at the bone-screw interface was significantly greater for Ti pedicle screws than for Ss, which was explained by the fact that Ti screws had a superior bone ongrowth. There was no correlation between the screw removal torque and the pull-out strength, which indicates that the peripheral bone structure around the screw was unaffected by the choice of metal.     

Triangulated pedicle screw construct technique and pull-out strength of conical and cylindrical screws

To compare the mechanical effectiveness of a new conical screw design with a conventional cylindrical screw design, the screw insertion time, torque, and pull-out strength of single-pedicle screw and triangulated-pedicle screw constructs of each type of screw were compared in human cadaveric vertebral bodies. The time required to insert the conical screws was less than that required for cylindrical screws. Regression analysis revealed a positive correlation between insertion torque and pull-out strength of single and triangulated constructs of each type of screw. The conical screw had a greater increase than the cylindrical screw in the pull-out strength of triangulated pedicle screw constructs. Application of the new conical screw design was significantly faster, and the new screw had better mechanical fixation to the vertebral body than did the conventional cylindrical screw tested.     

Early effect of parathyroid hormone (1-34) on implant fixation.

Intermittent systemic administration of parathyroid hormone increases bone formation by stimulating osteoblastic activity. The current study determined how parathyroid hormone (1-34) administration influences the bony fixation of stainless steel screws with time. A screw was implanted in the left tibia and a metal rod was implanted in the right tibia in 30 adult male rats that then were injected three times a week with human parathyroid hormone (1-34) at 60 microg/kg/injection (n = 15) or saline (n = 15). The animals were euthanized after 1, 2, or 4 weeks of treatment. Eight additional rats received only the screw and were euthanized immediately after implantation. No significant effects of parathyroid hormone on body weight change or ash weight of the femurs were seen. The degree of fixation was assessed by measuring pullout strength of the screws. The mean pullout strength immediately after implantation was 12 N. The pullout strength of the group injected with saline was 33 N after 1 week, 23 N after 2 weeks, and 41 N after 4 weeks. The pullout strength of the group injected with parathyroid hormone increased to 43 N after 1 week, 58 N after 2 weeks, and 100 N after 4 weeks. The increase at 2 and 4 weeks was statistically significant. Strength reflects the mechanical properties of the bone within the screw threads. The contralateral tibia with its metal rod was used for blinded histologic assessment. Parathyroid hormone increased the fraction of the metal surface having contract with bone without an intervening soft tissue layer from 45% to 69% after 1 week. The current results suggest that intermittent parathyroid hormone treatment can enhance early implant fixation by enhancing the density of the surrounding bone and by increasing the implant bone contact.     

The significance of radiolucent zones surrounding pedicle screws. Definition of screw loosening in spinal instrumentation

We examined the radiographs from a prospective clinical study of fixation by pedicle screws and those from an experimental study in a sheep model. In the clinical study, instruments were removed from 21 patients after implantation for 11 to 16 months and the extraction torques of the screws were recorded. A structured protocol was used for the radiological examinations. In the experimental study, loaded pedicle screw instrumentations were implanted in the sheep for six or 12 weeks. After radiological examination the pull-out resistance and the histological characteristics were studied. In the clinical study, all screws with radiolucent zones had a significantly reduced mean extraction torque compared with screws without radiolucent zones (16 +/- 10 Ncm v 403 +/- 220 Ncm; p < 0.0001). In the experimental study the mean maximum pull-out resistance for the screws with radiolucent zones was significantly lower than for those with no radiolucency (243 +/- 156 N v2214 +/- 578 N; p = 0.0006) and the mean bone-to-screw contact was reduced for screws with zones compared with those without zones (8 +/- 9% v 55 +/- 29%; p = 0.0002). Our findings showed that all screws with radiolucent zones had low extraction torques or low pull-out resistance. A radiolucent zone is a good indicator of loosening of a pedicle screw.     

Stress relaxation of bone significantly affects the pull-out behavior of pedicle screws.

The initial fixation strength of pedicle screws is commonly tested using a standard pull-out test with load applied at a constant rate. This method overlooks the cyclic nature of in situ loading responsible for clinical failure. This study was undertaken to determine the effects of stress relaxation properties at the bone-screw interface on screw fixation strength. Pedicle screws were inserted into calf lumbar vertebrae using a paired testing array. After embedding and mounting in a custom fixture, axial pull-out tests were performed at the rates of 1, 5, and 25 mm/min. For each vertebra, one screw was pulled at a continuous rate. The other screw was pulled at increments of 0.5 mm, at the same rate, with 1000 s pause between increments. Peak load, energy-to-failure, displacement-to-failure, and stiffness were calculated for each screw pull-out test. Two-way ANOVA showed that the standard pull-out method yielded significantly higher peak loads (p < 0.05) at faster pull-out rates and higher stiffnesses (p < 0.05) at all rates compared to the stress relaxation pull-out protocol. These results suggest that the stress relaxation properties of bone significantly affect the pull-out behavior of pedicle screws, reducing the peak load and stiffness values observed during testing. This mode of testing may provide a better biomechanical model of screw pull-out failure and a more accurate estimate of initial fixation strength.     

聚甲基丙烯酸甲酯强化对骨质疏松椎弓根螺钉固定的生物力学作用

目的探讨聚甲基丙烯酸甲酯 (polymethylmethacrylate,PMMA)骨水泥强化椎弓根螺钉的方法和评价 PMMA强化骨质疏松椎弓根螺钉后的生物力学性质。方法 6具新鲜老年女性胸腰段骨质疏松脊柱标本 (T10～ L5),使用双能 X线骨密度吸收仪测试每个椎体的骨密度,随机取 16个椎体 (32侧椎弓根 ),一侧椎弓根拧入 CCD螺钉,测量最大旋入力偶矩后拔出螺钉作为正常对照组,用 PMMA骨水泥强化椎弓根螺钉作为修复固定组,行螺钉拔出试验;另一侧经导孔直接强化椎弓根螺钉后拔出作为强化固定组,记录三组螺钉的最大轴向拔出力。结果椎体平均骨密度为 (0.445± 0.019)g/cm2;螺钉最大旋入力偶矩为（ 0.525± 0.104） Nm;正常对照组螺钉最大轴向拔出力为 (271.5± 57.3)N;修复固定组为 (765.9± 130.7)N;强化固定组为 (845.7± 105.0)N。 PMMA骨水泥强化或修复骨质疏松椎弓根螺钉后最大抗压力明显高于强化前,差异有非常显著性意义 (P< 0.01)。结论 PMMA骨水泥强化骨质疏松椎弓根螺钉能显著增加螺钉在椎体内的稳固性。     

Interference screw fixation of cervical grafts: a biomechanical study of a new method of cervical fixation.

The dislodgement of anterior bone graft in the cervical spine is a frequent complication of attempted fusion following discectomy or corpectomy. It has been hypothesized that fixation augmented with interference screws may increase the pull-out strength of the construct and decrease the rate of these complications. Mechanical tests were conducted to compare interference screw fixation methods for enhancing the fixation between the bone graft and the adjacent vertebra. The anterior pull-out strengths of cervical bone grafts were compared using fixation with and without the addition of interference screws. Both discectomy and corpectomy graft models were examined in vitro. The mean pull-out force for a Smith-Robinson type bone graft alone was 58.1 N (SD +/- 11.4 N); for the graft augmented with two 3.5 mm cancellous bone screws, 153.9 N (+/- 58.9 N); for the graft with four 3.5 mm screws, 217.1 N (SD +/- 69.9 N). The pull-out strengths of the two and four 3.5 mm screw constructs were significantly greater than the strength of the graft alone (p less than 0.05). Similarly placed 2.7 mm cortical screws of the same length provided increased pull-out strength (123.7 N +/- 38.6 N and 142.5 N +/- 38.2 N for two and four screws, respectively); however, in comparison to the graft alone, these differences were not statistically significant. For both screw types, the four screw fixations were stronger than the two-screw fixations, although these differences were not statistically different.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

两种长度的颈椎椎弓根螺钉与侧块螺钉拔出试验比较

目的:比较两种长度的颈椎椎弓根螺钉和侧块螺钉的抗拔出力,探讨颈椎经椎弓根短螺钉固定的可行性。方法:5具C3~C5共15节新鲜颈椎标本,用长度为28mm和20mm的皮质骨螺钉分别置入椎弓根,并用20mm的螺钉行侧块双皮质固定,螺钉进入侧块深度约14mm。行拔出试验,比较螺钉的最大轴向拔出力。结果:椎弓根长螺钉的最大拔出力为650N,椎弓根短螺钉为585N,两者比较无显著性差异(P>0.01);侧块螺钉的最大拔出力为360N,与椎弓根短螺钉比较有显著性差异(P<0.0001)。结论:颈椎椎弓根短螺钉固定可提供足够的稳定性,其安全性相对较高。     

Comparative biomechanical analysis of an improved novel pedicle screw with sheath and bone cement

STUDY DESIGN: A human cadaveric biomechanical study of fixation strength of an improved novel pedicle screw (NPS) with cement and a conventional screw. OBJECTIVE: To clarify whether the NPS has adequate fixation strength without leakage in vertebrae with low bone quality. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: The fixation strength of pedicle screws decreases in frail spines of elderly osteoporotic patients. Augmentation of screw fixation with bone cement must be balanced against increased difficulty of screw removal and risk of cement leakage. We developed the NPS consisting of an internal screw and an outer sheath to mitigate the disadvantages of cement augmentation. METHODS: The T12 and L1 vertebrae obtained from 18 formalin preserved cadavers (11 males and 7 females; mean age, 82.7 y) were used. The mean bone mineral density was 0.39 +/- 0.14 g/cm2. The NPS was inserted into one pedicle of each vertebra and the control screw, a Compact CD2 screw, was inserted into the contralateral pedicle. Both screws were 6mm in diameter and 40 mm in length. Pull-out tests were performed at a crosshead speed of 10 mm/min. Cyclic loading tests were performed with a maximum 250 N load at 2 Hz until 30,000 cycles. RESULTS: Cement leakage did not occur in any of the specimens tested. The mean maximum force at pull-out was 760 +/- 344 N for the NPS and 346 +/- 172N for the control screw (P < 0.01). Loosening of 50% of the screws was observed after 17,000 cycles of the NPS and after 30 cycles of the control screw. The hazard ratio of loosening was 19.6 (95% confidence interval 19.3-19.9) (P < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: The NPS showed a significantly higher mechanical strength than the control screw in both pull-out tests and cyclic loading tests. The NPS showed more than adequate strength without cement leakage.     

枢椎后路3种螺钉固定技术生物力学测试的对比研究

目的：评价单皮质和双皮质枢椎椎弓根螺钉、枢椎侧块螺钉和枢椎椎板螺钉的固定强度,为临床选择后路螺钉的固定方式提供生物力学依据。方法：利用30具新鲜尸体枢椎标本,进行单皮质和双皮质的枢椎椎弓根螺钉、枢椎侧块螺钉、枢椎椎板螺钉固定,测试比较其螺钉拔出强度。结果：双皮质枢椎椎弓根螺钉的拔出力量最大,为（1255.8±381.9）N;单皮质枢椎椎弓根螺钉[（901.8±373.3）N]、双皮质枢椎侧块螺钉[（776.1±306.8）N]和双皮质枢椎椎板螺钉[（640.8±302.9）N]之间差异无统计学意义。结论：枢椎后路螺钉固定宜首选椎弓根螺钉,枢椎侧块螺钉和枢椎椎板螺钉可作为枢椎后路补充固定技术,且以双皮质骨固定为宜。     

Importance of bone mineral density in instrumented spine fusions

The effect of equivalent mineral density on pedicular screw fixation strength was investigated. The equivalent mineral density of human vertebral bodies was correlated highly with the pullout force of Kluger screws (r2 = 0.61, P less than 0.02). A moderate to high correlation existed between density and vertical force (r2 = 0.42 for Kluger screws, r2 = 0.55 for Steffee screws, P less than 0.02). In calf vertebral bodies of higher density (146 +/- 14 mg/cc), the forces were significantly higher than in the human vertebral bodies (P less than 0.05). Human lumbosacral spines were instrumented with three different fixators: Steffee plates, AO fixateur interne, and Kluger fixateur interne. Of five specimens with a mean density of 88 +/- 11 mg/cc, one screw loosened. More than one screw loosened in six specimens with a mean density of 63 +/- 12 mg/cc, and no screw loosened in four specimens with a mean density of 114 +/- 38 mg/cc. Measurement of equivalent mineral density correlates with the fixation strength of the intrapedicular screws in vitro and should be considered in patients with signs of osteopenia before using pedicular screws for spinal fusions. It is also concluded that calf spines are a good model for testing implants because they tend to focus failure processes in the implant rather than in the implant-bone interface.     

Defective implant osseointegration under protein undernutrition: prevention by PTH or pamidronate.

Protein deficiency is associated with impaired titanium osseointegration. We studied whether systemic treatment with PTH or pamidronate could influence the resistance to pull-out of titanium rods implanted into rats proximal tibia under normal and isocaloric low protein intake. PTH or pamidronate prevented the deleterious effects of protein undernutrition on bone microarchitecture close to the implant and on mechanical fixation. PTH even significantly improved implant osseointegration. INTRODUCTION: Protein deficiency is highly prevalent among elderly patients hospitalized in orthopedic wards. Reduced protein intake impairs titanium osseointegration in rats. Whether stimulator of bone formation or inhibitor of bone resorption could improve implant osseointegration under protein deprivation is not known. We studied the effects of systemic treatment with PTH or pamidronate on the resistance to pull-out of titanium rods implanted into rats proximal tibia under normal and isocaloric low protein intake. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We measured the resistance to pull-out 1-mm-diameter titanium rods implanted into the proximal tibias of 49 adult female rats receiving a normal or an isocaloric low protein diet. After 2 wk on either diet, the implants were inserted, and the rats received PTH(1-34), pamidronate or saline vehicle for 8 wk. The tibias were removed for microCT morphometry, followed by the evaluation of pull-out strength. RESULTS: Pull-out strength was lower in rats fed an isocaloric low protein diet compared with rats fed a normal protein intake (-29%). PTH and pamidronate significantly increased pull-out strength in animals fed a normal or a low protein diet, the effect of PTH being of higher magnitude. The PTH- or pamidronate-mediated increase in pull-out strength was associated with significant increases of relative bone volume, bone-to-implant contact, and trabecular thickness, whereas trabecular spacing was reduced, in the vicinity of the implants. CONCLUSIONS: We confirmed that isocaloric low protein intake impairs titanium implant osseointegration. PTH or pamidronate prevented the deleterious effects of protein undernutrition and even significantly improved the implant osseointegration. These results indicate that systemic administration of PTH or pamidronate could be considered for preventing uncemented arthroplasty loosening in protein undernourished patients.     

In vitro biomechanical study of pedicle screw pull-out strength based on different screw path preparation techniques

Background:

Poor screw-to-bone fixation is a clinical problem that can lead to screw loosening. Under-tapping (UT) the pedicle screw has been evaluated biomechanically in the past. The objective of the study was to determine if pedicle preparation with a sequential tapping technique will alter the screw-to-bone fixation strength using a stress relaxation testing loading protocol.

Materials and Methods:

Three thoracolumbar calf spines were instrumented with pedicle screws that were either probed, UT, standard-tapped (ST), or sequential tapped to prepare the pedicle screw track and a stress relaxation protocol was used to determine pull-out strength. The maximum torque required for pedicle screw insertion and pull-out strength was reported. A one-way ANOVA and Tukeys post-hoc test were used to determine statistical significance.

Results:

The pedicle screw insertion torques for the probed, UT, ST and sequentially tapped (SQT) techniques were 5.09 (±1.08) Nm, 5.39 (±1.61) Nm, 2.93 (±0.43) Nm, and 3.54 (±0.67) Nm, respectively. There is a significant difference between probed compared to ST (P ≤ 0.05), as well as UT compared to both ST and SQT (P ≤ 0.05). The pull-out strength for pedicle screws for the probed, UT, ST and SQT techniques was 2443 (±782) N, 2353(±918) N, 2474 (±521) N, and 2146 (±582) N, respectively, with no significant difference (P ≥ 0.05) between techniques.

Conclusions:

The ST technique resulted in the highest pull-out strength while the SQT technique resulted in the lowest. However, there was no significant difference in the pull-out strength for the various preparation techniques and there was no correlation between insertion torque and pull-out strength. This suggests that other factors such as bone density may have a greater influence on pull-out strength.     

经口咽前路寰枢椎复位钢板内固定的生物力学研究

目的 研究经口咽前路寰枢椎复位钢板(TARP)的三维运动范围和螺钉拔出力的生物力学. 方法 12例C0～C3新鲜标本,6例用于三维运动测试,分七组:①完整标本(对照)组,②损伤组(去除C1前弓、C2齿突,破坏关节囊和横韧带等),③TARP组,④后路Brooks钢丝组,⑤Magerl经关节螺钉组,⑥Magerl+Brooks组,⑦前路经枢椎体寰椎侧块螺钉组,分别测量其三维运动范围(ROM).另6例(双侧,n=12)分解为单个椎体后用于螺钉拔出力测试,分三组:①寰椎组,②枢椎组,③C,(对照)组,测定最大拔出力、钉道长度和屈服长度.结果 TARP组和Magerl+Brooks组在各个方向上差异均无统计学意义(P>0.05),前者的ROM值略大于后者,二者抗屈伸、侧屈和旋转均强于其他三种内固定方法(P<0.05).寰椎与枢椎、寰椎与C3的最大拔出力之间差异均有统计学意义(P<0.05),枢椎和c3椎体最大拔出力之间差异无统计学意义(P>0.05)[最大拔出力分别为C1=(491.58 4±67.92)N,C2=(396.73±60.99)N,C3=(385.53±96.77)N].寰椎与枢椎、寰椎与C3椎体的钉道长度之间差异均有统计学意义(均为P<0.05),枢椎和C3椎体钉道长度之间差异无统计学意义(P>0.05).三组的屈服长度之间差异.无统计学意义(P>0.05).C1～C3的螺钉最大拔出力与钉道长度和屈服长度均呈显著正相关(P<0.05,r分别为0.810和0.652),但与钉道长度的相关性更高(P<0.05). 结论 TARP与目前临床应用的后路Magerl+Brooks术式等效,较其他三种固定方式(前路经枢椎体寰椎侧块螺钉、后路Magerl经关节螺钉和后路Brooks钢丝固定)具有更坚强的固定作用.TARP的寰椎和枢椎固定螺钉固定牢靠,钉道长度即进钉深度是影响螺钉抗拔出力的主要因素,屈服长度是影响螺钉拔出力的次要因素.