Prevention of the dystrophic phenotype in dystrophin/utrophin-deficient muscle following adenovirus-mediated transfer of a utrophin minigene

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is a progressive muscle wasting disorder caused by the lack of a subsarcolemmal protein, dystrophin. We have previously shown that the dystrophin-related protein, utrophin is able to compensate for the lack of dystrophin in the mdx mouse, the mouse model for DMD. Here, we explore whether utrophin delivered to the limb muscle of dystrophin/utrophin-deficient double knockout (dko) neonatal mice can protect the muscle from subsequent dystrophic damage. Utrophin delivery may avoid the potential problems of an immune response associated with the delivery of dystrophin to a previously dystrophin-deficient host. Dko muscle (tibialis anterior) was injected with a first generation recombinant adenovirus containing a utrophin minigene. Up to 95% of the fibres continued expressing the minigene 30 days after injection. Expression of utrophin caused a marked reduction from 80% centrally nucleated fibres (CNFs) in the uninjected dko TA to 12% in the injected dko TA. Within the region of the TA expressing the utrophin minigene, a significant decrease in the prevelance of necrosis was noted. These results demonstrate that the utrophin minigene delivered using an adenoviral vector is able to afford protection to the dystrophin/utrophin-deficient muscle of the dko mouse. Gene Therapy (2000) 7, 201-204.     

Successful compensation for dystrophin deficiency by a helper-dependent adenovirus expressing full-length utrophin.

Helper-dependent adenovirus vector (AdV)-mediated full-length dystrophin expression leads to significant mitigation of the dystrophic phenotype of the mdx mouse. However, dystrophin, as a neoantigen, elicits antibody formation. As an alternative approach, we evaluated gene transfer of full-length murine utrophin, a functional homologue of dystrophin that is normally present only at the neuromuscular junction. A single injection in the tibialis anterior (TA) muscle of the helper-dependent adenovirus vector encoding utrophin provided very good transduction, with 58% of fibers demonstrating sarcolemmal utrophin expression in the neonates, and 35% utrophin-positive (Utr(+)) fibers in adults. The presence of utrophin prevented extensive necrosis in the neonates, halted further necrosis in the adults, and led to restoration of sarcolemmal expression of dystrophin-associated proteins up to 1 year after injection. Marked physiological improvement was observed in both neonates and adults. Neither increased humoral responses nor cellular immune responses were evident. However, there was a time-related decline of the initial high utrophin expression. Although viral DNA persisted in animals that were injected in the neonatal stage, viral DNA levels decreased in muscles of adult mice. These results demonstrate that although utrophin gene transfer leads to amelioration of the dystrophic phenotype, the effects are not sustained upon loss of utrophin expression.     

AAV vector-mediated microdystrophin expression in a relatively small percentage of mdx myofibers improved the mdx phenotype.

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is a lethal disorder of skeletal muscle caused by mutations in the dystrophin gene. Adeno-associated virus (AAV) vector-mediated gene therapy is a promising approach to the disease. Although a rod-truncated microdystrophin gene has been proven to ameliorate dystrophic phenotypes, the level of microdystrophin expression required for effective gene therapy by an AAV vector has not been determined yet. Here, we constructed a recombinant AAV type 2 vector, AAV2-MCKDeltaCS1, expressing microdystrophin (DeltaCS1) under the control of a muscle-specific MCK promoter and injected it into TA muscles of 10-day-old and 5-week-old mdx mice. AAV2-MCKDeltaCS1-mediated gene transfer into 5-week-old mdx muscle resulted in extensive and long-term expression of microdystrophin and significantly improved force generation. Interestingly, 10-day-old injected muscle expressed microdystrophin in a limited number of myofibers but showed hypertrophy of microdystrophin-positive muscle fibers and considerable recovery of contractile force. Thus, we concluded that AAV2-MCKDeltaCS1 could be a powerful tool for gene therapy of DMD.     

Immune response to adenovirus-delivered antigens upregulates utrophin and results in mitigation of muscle pathology in mdx mice

The upregulation of endogenous utrophin in skeletal muscle may lead to a new approach to the treatment of Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD). We found that injection of an E1, E3-deleted adenovirus vector expressing beta-galactosidase (beta-Gal) or green fluorescent protein (GFP) into the skeletal muscle of neonatal dystrophin-deficient mdx mice alleviated dystrophic pathology. In the adenovirus-infected muscles, an evaluation of sarcolemma stability showed low permeability and immunohistochemistry revealed utrophin upregulation at the extrasynaptic sarcolemma of mature muscle fibers. This utrophin upregulation was concomitant with endomysial cellular infiltration from a host immune reaction. There was no evidence of active muscle regeneration. In normal C57BL/10 mice, utrophin was also upregulated in adenovirus-injected skeletal muscles, where upregulated utrophin often coexisted with dystrophin. FK506 and anti-CD4 antibody administration decreased utrophin expression in adenovirus-injected mdx muscles and prevented the dystrophic phenotype from being mitigated, suggesting that an immune reaction is involved in utrophin upregulation. This is the first report demonstrating the improvement of the dystrophic phenotype as a result of the acquired overexpression of endogenous utrophin. Our findings provide an important clue to understanding the mechanism of utrophin expression and the development of an effective treatment for DMD.     

Expression of Dog Microdystrophin in Mouse and Dog Muscles by Gene Therapy

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is characterized by the absence of dystrophin. Several previous studies demonstrated the feasibility of delivering microdystrophin complementary DNA (cDNA) into mouse and normal nonhuman primate muscles by ex vivo gene therapy. However, these animal models do not reproduce completely the human DMD phenotype, while the dystrophic dog model does. To progress toward the use of the best animal model of DMD, a dog microdystrophin was transduced into human and dystrophic dog muscle precursor cells (MPCs) with a lentivirus before their transplantation into mouse muscles. One month following MPC transplantation, myofibers expressing the dog microdystrophin were observed. We also used another approach to introduce this transgene into myofibers, i.e., the electrotransfer of a plasmid coding for the dog microdystrophin. The plasmid was injected into mouse and dog muscles, and brief electric pulses were applied in the region of injection. Two weeks later, the transgene was detected in both animals. Therefore, ex vivo gene therapy and electrotransfer are two possible methods to introduce a truncated version of dystrophin into myofibers of animal models and eventually into myofibers of DMD patients.     

Genetic correction of dystrophin deficiency and skeletal muscle remodeling in adult MDX mouse via transplantation of retroviral producer cells.

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is an X-linked, lethal disease caused by mutations of the dystrophin gene. No effective therapy is available, but dystrophin gene transfer to skeletal muscle has been proposed as a treatment for DMD. We have developed a strategy for efficient in vivo gene transfer of dystrophin cDNA into regenerating skeletal muscle. Retroviral producer cells, which release a vector carrying the therapeutically active dystrophin minigene, were mitotically inactivated and transplanted in adult nude/mdx mice. Transplantation of 3 x 10(6) producer cells in a single site of the tibialis anterior muscle resulted in the transduction of between 5.5 and 18% total muscle fibers. The same procedure proved also feasible in immunocompetent mdx mice under short-term pharmacological immunosuppression. Minidystrophin expression was stable for up to 6 mo and led to alpha-sarcoglycan reexpression. Muscle stem cells could be transduced in vivo using this procedure. Transduced dystrophic skeletal muscle showed evidence of active remodeling reminiscent of the genetic normalization process which takes place in female DMD carriers. Overall, these results demonstrate that retroviral-mediated dystrophin gene transfer via transplantation of producer cells is a valid approach towards the long-term goal of gene therapy of DMD.     

Autologous transplantation of SM/C-2.6(+) satellite cells transduced with micro-dystrophin CS1 cDNA by lentiviral vector into mdx mice.

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is a lethal muscle disorder caused by mutations in the dystrophin gene. Transplantation of autologous myogenic cells genetically corrected ex vivo is a possible treatment for this disorder. In order to test the regenerative efficiency of freshly isolated satellite cells, we purified quiescent satellite cells from limb muscles of 8-12-week-old green fluorescent protein-transgenic (GFP-Tg) mice using SM/C-2.6 (a recently developed monoclonal antibody) and flow cytometry. Freshly isolated satellite cells were shown to participate in muscle regeneration more efficiently than satellite cell-derived myoblasts passaged in vitro do, when transplanted into tibialis anterior (TA) muscles of 8-12-week-old cardiotoxin-injected C57BL/6 mice and 5-week-old dystrophin-deficient mdx mice, and analyzed at 4 weeks after injection. Importantly, expansion of freshly isolated satellite cells in vitro without passaging had no detrimental effects on their regenerative capacity. Therefore we directly isolated satellite cells from 5-week-old mdx mice using SM/C-2.6 antibody and cultured them with lentiviral vectors expressing micro-dystrophin CS1. The transduced cells were injected into TA muscles of 5-week-old mdx mice. At 4 weeks after transplantation, the grafted cells efficiently contributed to regeneration of mdx dystrophic muscles and expressed micro-dystrophin at the sarcolemma. These results suggest that there is potential for lentiviral vector-mediated ex vivo gene therapy for DMD.     

AAV-mediated Overexpression of Human α7 Integrin Leads to Histological and Functional Improvement in Dystrophic Mice

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is a severe muscle disease caused by mutations in the DMD gene, with loss of its gene product, dystrophin. Dystrophin helps link integral membrane proteins to the actin cytoskeleton and stabilizes the sarcolemma during muscle activity. We investigated an alternative therapeutic approach to dystrophin replacement by overexpressing human α7 integrin (ITGA7) using adeno-associated virus (AAV) delivery. ITGA7 is a laminin receptor in skeletal and cardiac muscle that links the extracellular matrix (ECM) to the actin skeleton. It is modestly upregulated in DMD muscle and has been proposed to be an important modifier of dystrophic symptoms. We delivered rAAV8.MCK.ITGA7 to the lower limb of mdx mice through isolated limb perfusion (ILP) of the femoral artery. We demonstrated ~50% of fibers in the tibialis anterior (TA) and extensor digitorum longus (EDL) overexpressing α7 integrin at the sarcolemma following AAV gene transfer. The increase in ITGA7 in skeletal muscle significantly protected against loss of force following eccentric contraction-induced injury compared with untreated (contralateral) muscles while specific force following tetanic contraction was unchanged. Reversal of additional dystrophic features included reduced Evans blue dye (EBD) uptake and increased muscle fiber diameter. Taken together, this data shows that rAAV8.MCK.ITGA7 gene transfer stabilizes the sarcolemma potentially preserving mdx muscle from further damage. This therapeutic approach demonstrates promise as a viable treatment for DMD with further implications for other forms of muscular dystrophy.     

Restoration of dystrophin expression in mdx mice by intravascular injection of naked DNA containing full-length dystrophin cDNA

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is a lethal, X-linked, recessive disease caused by a defect in the dystrophin gene. No effective therapy is available. Dystrophin gene transfer to skeletal muscle has been proposed as a treatment for DMD. However, successful treatment for DMD requires restoration of dystrophin in the affected muscle fibers to at least 20% of the normal level. Current gene transfer methods such as intramuscular injection of viral vector or naked DNA can only transfect a small area of muscle, and therefore is of little clinical utility. We have developed a semisystemic method for gene transfer into skeletal muscle of mdx mice, an animal model for DMD. Naked DNA was injected through the tail artery or vein of mice, in which the aorta and the vena cava were clamped at the location just below the kidneys. The DNA solution was thus forced into the blood vessels of both legs. Luciferase gene expression was detected in all muscle groups in both legs. The effects of injection speed, injection volume, and ischemia time on gene expression were also optimized. LacZ staining was used to check the spread of gene expression in muscle. Although the percentage of transfected fibers was modest (approximately 10%), beta-galactosidase was found in all muscle groups of both legs. Finally, plasmid DNA encoding full-length dystrophin gene was injected into mdx mice and widespread restoration of dystrophin protein was observed in all muscles of both hind limbs. In conclusion, these results demonstrate that the semisystemic delivery of naked DNA is a potential approach towards the long-term goal of gene therapy for DMD.     

Prevention of Dystrophic Pathology in Severely Affected Dystrophin/Utrophin-deficient Mice by Morpholino-oligomer-mediated Exon-skipping

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is a severe neuromuscular disorder caused by mutations in the dystrophin gene that result in the absence of functional protein. Antisense-mediated exon-skipping is one of the most promising approaches for the treatment of DMD because of its capacity to correct the reading frame and restore dystrophin expression, which has been demonstrated in vitro and in vivo. In particular, peptide-conjugated phosphorodiamidate morpholino oligomers (PPMOs) have recently been shown to induce widespread high levels of dystrophin expression in the mdx mouse model. Here, we report the efficiency of the PPMO-mediated exon-skipping approach in the utrophin/dystrophin double-knockout mouse (dKO) mouse, which is a much more severe and progressive mouse model of DMD. Repeated intraperitoneal (i.p.) injections of a PPMO targeted to exon 23 of dystrophin pre-mRNA in dKO mice induce a near-normal level of dystrophin expression in all muscles examined, except for the cardiac muscle, resulting in a considerable improvement of their muscle function and dystrophic pathology. These findings suggest great potential for PPMOs in systemic treatment of the DMD phenotype.     

Muscle Function Recovery in Golden Retriever Muscular Dystrophy After AAV1-U7 Exon Skipping

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is an X-linked recessive disorder resulting from lesions of the gene encoding dystrophin. These usually consist of large genomic deletions, the extents of which are not correlated with the severity of the phenotype. Out-of-frame deletions give rise to dystrophin deficiency and severe DMD phenotypes, while internal deletions that produce in-frame mRNAs encoding truncated proteins can lead to a milder myopathy known as Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD). Widespread restoration of dystrophin expression via adeno-associated virus (AAV)-mediated exon skipping has been successfully demonstrated in the mdx mouse model and in cardiac muscle after percutaneous transendocardial delivery in the golden retriever muscular dystrophy dog (GRMD) model. Here, a set of optimized U7snRNAs carrying antisense sequences designed to rescue dystrophin were delivered into GRMD skeletal muscles by AAV1 gene transfer using intramuscular injection or forelimb perfusion. We show sustained correction of the dystrophic phenotype in extended muscle areas and partial recovery of muscle strength. Muscle architecture was improved and fibers displayed the hallmarks of mature and functional units. A 5-year follow-up ruled out immune rejection drawbacks but showed a progressive decline in the number of corrected muscle fibers, likely due to the persistence of a mild dystrophic process such as occurs in BMD phenotypes. Although AAV-mediated exon skipping was shown safe and efficient to rescue a truncated dystrophin, it appears that recurrent treatments would be required to maintain therapeutic benefit ahead of the progression of the disease.     

CTLA4Ig delivered by high-capacity adenoviral vector induces stable expression of dystrophin in mdx mouse muscle

Adenoviral (Ad) vector-mediated gene delivery of normal, full-length dystrophin to skeletal muscle provides a promising strategy for the treatment of Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD), an X-linked recessive, dystrophin-deficient muscle disease. Studies in animal models suggest that successful DMD gene therapy by Ad vector-mediated gene transfer would be precluded by cellular and humoral immune responses induced by vector capsid and transgene proteins. To address the immunity induced by Ad vector-mediated dystrophin gene delivery to dystrophic muscle, we developed high-capacity adenoviral (HC-Ad) vectors expressing mouse dystrophin driven by the muscle creatine kinase promoter (AdmDys) and mCTLA4Ig (AdmCTLA4Ig) individually, or together from one vector (AdmCTLA4Ig/mDys). We found stable expression of dystrophin protein in the tibialis anterior muscles of mdx mice, coinjected with AdmCTLA4Ig and AdmDys, or injected alone with AdmCTLA4Ig/mDys, whereas the expression of dystrophin protein in the control group coinjected with AdmDys and an empty vector decreased by at least 50% between 2 and 8 weeks after administration. Additionally, we observed reductions in Ad vector-induced Th1 and Th2 cytokines, Ad vector-specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte activation and neutralizing anti-Ad antibodies in both experimental groups that received a mCTLA4Ig-expressing vector as compared to the control group. This study demonstrates that the coexpression of mCTLA4Ig and dystrophin in skeletal muscle provided by HC-Ad vector-mediated gene transfer can provide stable expression of dystrophin in immunocompetent, adult mdx mouse muscle and applies a potentially powerful strategy to overcome adaptive immunity induced by Ad vector-mediated dystrophin gene delivery toward the ultimate goal of treatment for DMD.     

Phenotypic improvement of dystrophic muscles by rAAV/microdystrophin vectors is augmented by Igf1 codelivery.

The absence of dystrophin in Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) leads to sarcolemmal instability and enhances the susceptibility of muscle fibers to contraction-induced injury. Various viral vectors have been used to deliver mini- and microdystrophin expression cassettes to muscles of dystrophin-deficient mdx mice, significantly increasing both the morphological and the functional properties of the muscles. However, dystrophin delivery to adult mdx mice has not yielded a complete rescue of the dystrophic phenotype. Here we investigated a novel strategy involving dual gene transfer of recombinant adeno-associated viral vectors expressing either microdystrophin (rAAV-muDys) or a muscle-specific isoform of Igf-1 (rAAV-mIgf-1). Injection of mdx muscles with rAAV-muDys reduced myofiber degeneration and turnover and increased their resistance to mechanical injury, but did not increase muscle mass or force generation. Injection of mdx muscles with rAAV-mIgf-1 led to increased muscle mass, but did not provide protection against mechanical injury or halt myofiber degeneration, leading to loss of the vector over time. In contrast, co-injection of the rAAV-muDys and rAAV-mIgf-1 vectors resulted in increased muscle mass and strength, reduced myofiber degeneration, and increased protection against contraction-induced injury. These results suggest that a dual-gene, combinatorial strategy could enhance the efficacy of gene therapy of DMD.     

A simplified immune suppression scheme leads to persistent micro-dystrophin expression in duchenne muscular dystrophy dogs

Highly abbreviated micro-dystrophin genes have been intensively studied for Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) gene therapy. Following adeno-associated virus (AAV) gene transfer, robust microgene expression is achieved in murine DMD models in the absence of immune suppression. Interestingly, a recent study suggests that AAV gene transfer in dystrophic dogs may require up to 18 weeks' immune suppression using a combination of three different immune-suppressive drugs (cyclosporine, mycophenolate mofetil, and anti-dog thymocyte globulin). Continued immune suppression is not only costly but also may cause untoward reactions. Further, some of the drugs (such as anti-dog thymocyte globulin) are not readily available. To overcome these limitations, we developed a novel 5-week immune suppression scheme using only cyclosporine and mycophenolate mofetil. AAV vectors (either AV.RSV.AP that expresses the heat-resistant human alkaline phosphatase gene, or AV.CMV.μDys that expresses the canine R16-17/H3/ΔC microgene) at 2.85×10(12) vg particles were injected into adult dystrophic dog limb muscles under the new immune suppression protocol. Sustained transduction was observed for nearly half year (the end of the study). The simplified immune suppression strategy described here may facilitate preclinical studies in the dog model.     

Immune responses to dystropin: implications for gene therapy of Duchenne muscular dystrophy

Introduction of dystrophin by gene transfer into the dystrophic muscles of Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) patients has the possibility of triggering an immune response as many patients will not have been exposed to some (or all) of the epitopes of dystrophin. This could in turn lead to cytotoxic destruction of transfected muscle fibres. We assessed such concerns in the dystrophin-deficient mdx mouse using plasmid DNA as the gene transfer system. This avoids complications associated with the administration of viral proteins. Gene transfer of cDNAs encoding mouse full-length or a truncated minidystrophin did not evoke either a humoral or cytotoxic immune response. Mdx mice may be tolerant due to the presence of rare 'revertant' dystrophin-positive fibres in their skeletal muscles. In contrast, gene transfer of human full-length or minidystrophin provoked both humoral and cytotoxic responses leading to destruction of the transfected fibres. These experiments demonstrate the potential risk of deleterious effects following gene therapy in DMD patients and lead us to suggest that patients enrolled in gene therapy trials should ideally have small, preferably point, mutations and evidence of 'revertant' dystrophin-positive muscle fibres.     

Matching host muscle and donor myoblasts for myosin heavy chain improves myoblast transfer therapy

Intensive efforts have been made to develop an effective therapy for Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD). Although myoblast transplantation has been found capable of transiently delivering dystrophin and improving the strength of the injected dystrophic muscle, this approach has been hindered by the immune rejection problems as well as the poor survival and limited spread of the injected cells. In the present study, we have investigated whether the careful selection of donor myoblasts and host muscle for the myosin heavy chain expression (MyHCs) plays a role in the success of myoblast transfer. Highly purified normal myoblasts derived from the m. soleus and m. gastrocnemius white of normal mice were transplanted into the m. soleus (containing 70% of type I fibers) and gastrocnemius white (100% of type II fibers) of dystrophin deficient mdx mice. At several time-points after injection (10, 20 and 30 days), the number of dystrophin-positive fibers was monitored and compared among the different groups. A significantly higher number and better persistence of dystrophin-positive myofibers were observed when the injected muscle and donor myoblasts expressed a similar MyHC in comparison with myoblast transfer between host muscle and donor myoblasts that were not matched for MyHC. These results suggest that careful matching between the injected myoblasts and injected muscle for the MyHC expression can improve the efficiency of myoblast-mediated gene transfer to skeletal muscle. Gene Therapy (2000) 7, 428-437.     

Chronic administration of membrane sealant prevents severe cardiac injury and ventricular dilatation in dystrophic dogs

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is a fatal disease of striated muscle deterioration caused by lack of the cytoskeletal protein dystrophin. Dystrophin deficiency causes muscle membrane instability, skeletal muscle wasting, cardiomyopathy, and heart failure. Advances in palliative respiratory care have increased the incidence of heart disease in DMD patients, for which there is no cure or effective therapy. Here we have shown that chronic infusion of membrane-sealing poloxamer to severely affected dystrophic dogs reduced myocardial fibrosis, blocked increased serum cardiac troponin I (cTnI) and brain type natriuretic peptide (BNP), and fully prevented left-ventricular remodeling. Mechanistically, we observed a markedly greater primary defect of reduced cell compliance in dystrophic canine myocytes than in the mildly affected mdx mouse myocytes, and this was associated with a lack of utrophin upregulation in the dystrophic canine cardiac myocytes. Interestingly, after chronic poloxamer treatment, the poor compliance of isolated canine myocytes remained evident, but this could be restored to normal upon direct application of poloxamer. Collectively, these findings indicate that dystrophin and utrophin are critical to membrane stability–dependent cardiac myocyte mechanical compliance and that poloxamer confers a highly effective membrane-stabilizing chemical surrogate in dystrophin/utrophin deficiency. We propose that membrane sealant therapy is a potential treatment modality for DMD heart disease and possibly other disorders with membrane defect etiologies.