Exclusion of a major role for the PTEN tumour-suppressor gene in breast carcinomas

PTEN is a novel tumour-suppressor gene located on chromosomal band 10q23.3. This region displays frequent loss of heterozygosity (LOH) in a variety of human neoplasms including breast carcinomas. The detection of PTEN mutations in Cowden disease and in breast carcinoma cell lines suggests that PTEN may be involved in mammary carcinogenesis. We here report a mutational analysis of tumour specimens from 103 primary breast carcinomas and constitutive DNA from 25 breast cancer families. The entire coding region of PTEN was screened by single-strand conformation polymorphism (SSCP) analysis and direct sequencing using intron-based primers. No germline mutations could be identified in the breast cancer families and only one sporadic carcinoma carried a PTEN mutation at one allele. In addition, all sporadic tumours were analysed for homozygous deletions by differential polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and for allelic loss using the microsatellite markers D10S215, D10S564 and D10S573. No homozygous deletions were detected and only 10 out of 94 informative tumours showed allelic loss in the PTEN region. These results suggest that PTEN does not play a major role in breast cancer formation.     

Frequent 3p allele loss and epigenetic inactivation of the RASSF1A tumour suppressor gene from region 3p21.3 in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma

Studies of allelic imbalance and suppression of tumourigenicity have consistently suggested that the short arm of chromosome three (3p) harbours tumour suppressor genes (TSGs) whose inactivation leads to the development of various types of neoplasia including head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC). Previously, we defined a critical minimal region of 120kb at 3p21.3 that contains overlapping homozygous deletions in lung and breast tumour lines and isolated eight genes from the minimal region. Mutation analysis in a large panel of lung and breast cancers revealed only rare mutations, but the majority of lung tumour lines showed loss of expression for one of the eight genes (RASSF1A) due to hypermethylation of a CpG island in the promoter region of RASSF1A. We found RASSF1A to be methylated in the majority of lung tumours, but to a lesser extent in breast and ovarian tumours. In order to define the role of 3p TSGs, in particular RASSF1A in HNSCC, we (a) analysed 43 primary HNSCC for allelic loss in regions proposed to contain 3p TSGs (3p25-26, 3p24, 3p21-22, 3p14 and 3p12), (b) analysed 24 HNSCC for evidence of RASSF1A methylation and (c) undertook mutation analysis of RASSF1A in HNSCC. We found that 81% of HNSCC showed allele loss at one or more 3p markers, 66% demonstrated loss for 3p21.3 markers and 56% showed allelic losses at 3p12 loci. Thus, 3p loss is common in HNSCC and extensive 3p loss occurs even in early stage tumours. RASSF1A promoter region hypermethylation was found in 17% (4/24) of the sporadic HNSCC, but RASSF1A mutations were not identified. Furthermore, we found RASSF1A methylation to be significantly higher in poorly differentiated then in moderate to well differentiated HNSCC (P=0.0048). Three of the four tumours showing RASSF1A methylation also underwent 3p21.3 allelic loss, hence RASSF1A behaves as a classical TSG (two hits, methylation and loss). One tumour with RASSF1A methylation had retention of markers at 3p providing further evidence of specific inactivation of RASSF1A as a critical step in some HNSCC. Although the frequency of 3p21.3 allele loss was substantially higher than that of RASSF1A methylation this does not necessarily suggest that other genes from 3p21.3 are also implicated in HNSCC, as 3p21.3 LOH was invariably found with LOH at other 3p loci. Thus, the presence of 3p21.3 allele loss without RASSF1A methylation might reflect a propensity for 3p21.3 loss to occur as a secondary consequence of large 3p deletions targeted at other 3p TSG regions. Furthermore, in the presence of homozygous inactivation of other 3p TSGs, RASSF1A haploinsufficiency might be sufficient to promote tumourigenesis in many HNSCC.     

Loss of heterozygosity in sporadic breast tumours at the BRCA2 locus on chromosome 13q12-q13.

Loss of heterozygosity (LOH) on chromosome 13 occurs on 25-30% of breast tumours. This may reflect the inactivation of the retinoblastoma susceptibility gene RB1. However, recently another candidate tumour-suppressor gene has been identified on chromosome 13 by linkage analysis, the breast cancer susceptibility gene BRCA2. To investigate the involvement of BRCA2 in sporadic breast cancer 200 breast tumours were tested for LOH on chromosome band 13q12-q14, using 11 highly polymorphic microsatellite markers. LOH was found in 65 tumours, which all showed simultaneously loss of BRCA2 and RB1. Of 12 breast tumour cell lines tested with polymorphic microsatellite markers, seven showed a contiguous region of homozygosity on 13q12-q14, suggesting LOH in the tumour from which the cell line had been derived. One cell line showed homozygosity in the BRCA2 region and heterozygosity at RB1. This is the only indication that BRCA2 is a distinct target for LOH on chromosome 13 in addition to RB1.     

Loss of Heterozygosity in Bilateral Breast Cancer

Women who develop bilateral breast cancer at an early age are likely to harbour germline mutations in breast cancer susceptibility genes. The aim of this study was to test for concordant genetic changes in left and right breast cancer of young women (age <50) with bilateral breast cancer that may suggest an inherited breast cancer predisposition. Microsatellite markers were used to test for loss of heterozygosity (LOH) in left and right tumours for 31 women with premenopausal bilateral breast cancer. Markers adjacent to or within candidate genes on 17p (p53), 17q (BRCA1), 13q (BRCA2), 11q (Ataxia Telangiectasia-ATM) and 3p (FHIT) were chosen. Mutational testing for BRCA1 and BRCA2 was performed for cases where blood was available. Concordant LOH in both left and right tumours was demonstrated for at least one of the markers tested in 16/31(54%) cases. Where allelic loss was demonstrated for both left and right breast cancer, the same allele was lost on each occasion. This may suggest a common mutational event. Four cases showed concordant loss of alleles in both left and right breast cancer at D17S791 (BRCA1). BRCA1 mutations were identified in two of these cases where blood was available. Four cases showed concordant LOH at D13S155 (BRCA2). Concordant LOH was further demonstrated in seven cases for D11S1778 (ATM) and four cases for D3S1300 (which maps to the FHIT gene), suggesting a possible role for these tumour suppressor genes in this subgroup of breast cancer patients. No concordant allelic loss was demonstrated for D17S786 suggesting that germline mutations in p53 are unlikely in such cases of bilateral breast cancer.     

Association between loss of heterozygosity of BRCA1 and BRCA2 and morphological attributes of sporadic breast cancer

Germline mutations in the breast cancer-associated genes BRCA1 and BRCA2 confer a lifetime risk of malignancy. Distinctive morphological features have been attributed to these familial tumours; however, in sporadic breast cancer, the inter-relationship between loss of heterozygosity (LOH) of these loci and tumour morphology remains to be fully elucidated. We studied a series of 120 sporadic breast carcinomas using microsatellite markers to identify LOH of BRCA1, BRCA2, p53 and PTEN. The associations between loss at each of the loci were examined and related to tumour morphology. LOH of the 4 loci did not occur independently; there were highly significant associations between LOH of BRCA1 and both BRCA2 (p < 0.001) and p53 (p < 0.001). LOH at all 4 loci was significantly associated with a high degree of nuclear pleomorphism. Tumours with LOH of BRCA1 also had high mitotic indices, few tubules and a paucity of DCIS, all of which are morphological features similar to those described for familial cases. Following Bonferroni's correction for multiple tests, we found that the tumours with LOH of BRCA1 were still significantly associated with a high mitotic index (p = 0.0006) and a high degree of nuclear pleomorphism (p = 0.001).     

Analysis of the 10q23 chromosomal region and the PTEN gene in human sporadic breast carcinoma

We examined a panel of sporadic breast carcinomas for loss of heterozygosity (LOH) in a 10-cM interval on chromosome 10 known to encompass the PTEN gene. We detected allele loss in 27 of 70 breast tumour DNAs. Fifteen of these showed loss limited to a subregion of the area studied. The most commonly deleted region was flanked by D10S215 and D10S541 and encompasses the PTEN locus. We used a combination of denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis and single-strand conformation polymorphism analyses to investigate the presence of PTEN mutations in tumours with LOH in this region. We did not detect mutations of PTEN in any of these tumours. Our data show that, in sporadic breast carcinoma, loss of heterozygosity of the PTEN locus is frequent, but mutation of PTEN is not. These results are consistent with loss of another unidentified tumour suppressor in this region in sporadic breast carcinoma.     

Chromosome alterations and E-cadherin gene mutations in human lobular breast cancer

We have studied a set of 40 human lobular breast cancers for loss of heterozygosity (LOH) at various chromosome locations and for mutations in the coding region plus flanking intron sequences of the E-cadherin gene. We found a high frequency of LOH (100%, 31/31) at 16q21-q22.1. A significantly higher level of LOH was detected in ductal breast tumours at chromosome arms 1p, 3p, 9p, 11q, 13q and 18q compared to lobular breast tumours. Furthermore, we found a significant association between LOH at 16q containing the E-cadherin locus and lobular histological type. Six different somatic mutations were detected in the E-cadherin gene, of which three were insertions, two deletions and one splice site mutation. Mutations were found in combination with LOH of the wild type E-cadherin locus and loss of or reduced E-cadherin expression detected by immunohistochemistry. The mutations described here have not previously been reported. We compared LOH at different chromosome regions with E-cadherin gene mutations and found a significant association between LOH at 13q and E-cadherin gene mutations. A significant association was also detected between LOH at 13q and LOH at 7q and 11q. Moreover, we found a significant association between LOH at 3p and high S phase, LOH at 9p and low ER and PgR content, LOH at 17p and aneuploidy. We conclude that LOH at 16q is the most frequent chromosome alteration and E-cadherin is a typical tumour suppressor gene in lobular breast cancer.     

Allele loss and mutation screen at the Peutz-Jeghers (LKB1) locus (19p13.3) in sporadic ovarian tumours.

Germline mutations in the LKB1 (STK11) gene (chromosome sub-band 19p13.3) cause characteristic hamartomas and pigmentation to develop in patients with Peutz-Jeghers syndrome. Peutz-Jeghers syndrome carries an overall risk of cancer that may be up to 20 times that of the general population and Peutz-Jeghers patients are at increased risk of benign and malignant ovarian tumours, particularly granulosa cell tumours. Loss of heterozygosity (allele loss, LOH) has been reported in about 50% of ovarian cancers on 19p13.3. LKB1 is therefore a candidate tumour suppressor gene for sporadic ovarian tumours. We found allele loss at the marker D19S886 (19p13.3) in 12 of 49 (24%) sporadic ovarian adenocarcinomas. Using SSCP analysis, we screened ten ovarian cancers with LOH, 35 other ovarian cancers and 12 granulosa cell tumours of the ovary for somatic mutations in LKB1. No variants were detected in any of the adenocarcinomas. Two mutations were detected in one of the granulosa cell tumours: a mis-sense mutation affecting the putative 'start' codon (ATG --> ACG, M1T); and a silent change in exon 7 (CTT --> CTA, leucine). Like BRCA1 and BRCA2, therefore, it appears that LKB1 mutations can cause ovarian tumours when present in the germline, but occur rarely in the soma. The allele loss on 19p13.3 in ovarian cancers almost certainly targets a different gene from LKB1.     

Somatic mutation of PTEN in bladder carcinoma.

The tumour suppressor gene PTEN/MMAC1, which is mutated or homozygously deleted in glioma, breast and prostate cancer, is mapped to a region of 10q which shows loss of heterozygosity (LOH) in bladder cancer. We screened 123 bladder tumours for LOH in the region of PTEN. In 53 informative muscle invasive tumours (> or = pT2), allele loss was detected in 13 (24.5%) and allelic imbalance in four tumours (overall frequency 32%). LOH was found in four of 60 (6.6%) informative, non-invasive tumours (pTa/pT1). We screened 63 muscle invasive tumours for PTEN mutations by single-strand conformation polymorphism (SSCP) analysis and for homozygous deletion by duplex quantitative polymerase chain reaction (PCR). Two homozygous deletions were identified but no mutations. Of 15 bladder tumour cell lines analysed, three showed homozygous deletion of all or part of the PTEN gene, but none had mutations detectable by SSCP analysis. Our results indicate that PTEN is involved in the development of some bladder tumours. The low frequency of mutation of the retained allele in tumours with 10q23 LOH suggests that there may be another predominant mechanism of inactivation of the second allele, for example small intragenic deletions, that hemizygosity may be sufficient for phenotypic effect, or that there is another target gene at 10q23.     

p16INK4a inactivation is not frequent in uncultured sporadic primary cutaneous melanoma

In an attempt to examine whether the inactivation of p16INK4a is an important early event in the development of sporadic melanoma in vivo, we have systematically analysed 46 uncultured primary cutaneous melanomas. Loss of heterozygosity (LOH) of chromosome region 9p21-22 (where the p16INK4a resides) was detected in 11 tumours (24%) by PCR-based LOH analyses. Direct sequencing of all three exons of the p16INK4a gene in these 11 tumours revealed no somatic mutation although germline mutations which have not been reported previously as common polymorphisms were detected in two patients. Further sequencing analyses of the p16INK4a gene exon 2 in 19 additional tumours with no evidence of LOH on 9p21-22 identified only one heterozygous C- >T mutation at codon 81 altering a proline to a leucine. A sensitive methylation-specific PCR assay did not reveal de novo methylation of the 5'CpG island in exon 1 of the p16INK4a gene in any of the tumours showing 9p21-22 allelic loss or a heterozygous p16INK4a mutation. Complete loss of p16INK4a protein, most likely due to homozygous deletion of the p16INK4a gene, was observed in 6 (15%) out of 39 evaluable cases by immunohistochemical analyses on frozen sections using two different anti-p16INK4a antibodies. The results show that inactivation of p16INK4a is not as frequent in primary melanoma as has been reported in cell lines, and warrant further search for another tumour suppressor on 9p21-22. This study also emphasizes the importance of examining uncultured primary tumours rather than cell lines to define early events in tumorigenesis.     

Allelotype of non-small cell lung cancer

Loss of heterozygosity (LOH) studies have been used extensively to identify regions on chromosomes that may contain putative tumour suppressor genes. We have undertaken extensive allelotyping of 45 specimens of non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) using 92 polymorphic microsatellite markers on 39 chromosome arms. The most frequent allelic imbalances were found on chromosome arms 3p, 9p and 17p. Significant allelic imbalance was found on other chromosome arms including, 5q (21%), 8p (19%), 13q (24%) and 17q (18%). The LOH data on 3p was subdivided into the four chromosomal regions considered to contain putative tumour suppressor genes 3p25-p24 (10%), 3p21 (10%), 3p14 (25%) and 3p13-p12 (22%). The frequency of loss in the different regions on 9p were: 9pter-p23 (31%), 9p23-p22 (45%) and 9p21-cent (30%). LOH on 17p was separated into three regions: 17pter-p13 (9%), 17p13 (33%) and 17p13-cent (22%). No correlation was found between LOH on any of the chromosomal arms and any of the clinicopathological parameters such as pathology, level of differentiation, TNM staging or alcohol intake. Only one significant association was found between LOH and tumour types. A significant difference was found between LOH on 17q in adenocarcinomas and squamous cell carcinomas (p=0.037). The fractional allele loss (FAL) values for this group of 45 NSCLC gave a median value of 0.9 (range 0-0.45). No correlation was found between FAL and nodes at pathology (p>0.05) and between FAL and tumour grade (p>0.05). No correlation was found between p53 or ras mutations in these NSCLC specimens and their FAL values. Accumulated genetic damage, as provided by this allelotype analysis, provides a useful molecular parameter by which to assess NSCLC and may, in time, assist in the determination of the clinical behaviour and clinical outcome of these tumours.     

Allele loss from 5q21 (APC/MCC) and 18q21 (DCC) and DCC mRNA expression in breast cancer.

Thirty-four primary, untreated sporadic breast cancers were examined for loss of heterozygosity (LOH) at tumour suppressor loci involved in colorectal cancer: APC/MCC at 5q21 and DCC at 18q21. LOH was identified in 28% informative patients at 5q21 and 31% at 18q21. LOH at 5q21 and 18q21 was compared with allele loss at 17p13 and concurrent LOH at two or more of the loci was noted in 24% of tumours. Expression of a 12 kb DCC mRNA was demonstrated in 14/34 (42%) of the cancers and in all five tumours with LOH at the DCC locus there was an additional 11 kb DCC mRNA. Abnormalities of three loci involved in colorectal cancer (5q21, 17p13 and 18q21) therefore also occur in sporadic breast cancer. The accumulation of such genetic abnormalities may confer a growth advantage important in the development of breast cancer.     

High levels of loss at the 17p telomere suggest the close proximity of a tumour suppressor.

High levels of loss of distal markers on 17p13.3 in breast cancer suggested the presence within the region of at least one tumour-suppressor gene. Here we describe the derivation of two biallelic polymorphisms from the 17p telomeric yeast artificial chromosome (YAC) TYAC98. Polymerase chain reaction-restriction fragment length polymorphism (PCR-RFLP) and multiplex PCR analysis demonstrated that the high level of allelic imbalance observed in breast tumours represented loss of constitutional heterozygosity (LOH) and that this LOH extended to the telomere. Lung carcinoma (but not Wilms'' tumour)-derived DNA again revealed a high level of loss of subtelomeric 17p sequences. Telomeric microsatellite polymorphisms from other chromosome arms did not show such elevated loss in either tumour type. This suggested that the 17p loss observed did not reflect a general telomeric instability and provided further evidence for the presence of a breast cancer tumour-suppressor gene in the distal region of 17p13.3.     

Methylation associated inactivation of RASSF1A from region 3p21.3 in lung, breast and ovarian tumours

Previously we analysed overlapping homozygous deletions in lung and breast tumours/tumour lines and defined a small region of 120 kb (part of LCTSGR1) at 3p21.3 that contained putative lung and breast cancer tumour suppressor gene(s) (TSG). Eight genes including RASSF1 were isolated from the minimal region. However, extensive mutation analysis in lung tumours and tumour lines revealed only rare inactivating mutations. Recently, de novo methylation at a CpG island associated with isoform A of RASSF1 (RASSF1A) was reported in lung tumours and tumour lines. To investigate RASSF1A as a candidate TSG for various cancers, we investigated: (a) RASSF1A methylation status in a large series of primary tumour and tumour lines; (b) chromosome 3p allele loss in lung tumours and (c) RASSF1 mutation analysis in breast tumours. RASSF1A promoter region CpG island methylation was detected in 72% of SCLC, 34% of NSCLC, 9% of breast, 10% of ovarian and 0% of primary cervical tumours and in 72% SCLC, 36% NSCLC, 80% of breast and 40% of ovarian tumour lines. In view of the lower frequency of RASSF1 methylation in primary breast cancers we proceeded to RASSF1 mutation analysis in 40 breast cancers. No mutations were detected, but six single nucleotide polymorphisms were identified. Twenty of 26 SCLC tumours with 3p21.3 allelic loss had RASSF1A methylation, while only six out of 22 NSCLC with 3p21.3 allele loss had RASSF1A methylation (P=0.0012), one out of five ovarian and none out of six cervical tumours with 3p21.3 loss had RASSF1A methylation. These results suggest that (a) RASSF1A inactivation by two hits (methylation and loss) is a critical step in SCLC tumourigenesis and (b) RASSF1A inactivation is of lesser importance in NSCLC, breast, ovarian and cervical cancers in which other genes within LCTSGR1 are likely to be implicated.     

Destabilization of chromosome 9 in transitional cell carcinoma of the urinary bladder.

The most frequent genetic alteration in transitional cell carcinoma of the urinary bladder (TCC) is loss of chromosome 9 which targets CDKN2A on 9p. The targets on 9q are not confirmed. Here, 81 advanced TCC specimens were investigated for loss of heterozygosity (LOH) and homozygous deletions (HD) on chromosome 9q using multiplex analysis of microsatellite markers. 41/81 tumours (51%) showed LOH on 9q, with LOH at all markers in 33 cases. Eight partial losses involved three regions in 9q12, 9q22.3, and 9q33- 9q34. No mutations were identified in the candidate tumour suppressor gene DBCCR1 in three tumours showing restricted LOH at 9q32-33. 22% of the specimens had HD at CDKN2A, but no HD was found on 9q. Two tumours had lost 9p only and five 9q only. 9q LOH was not related to tumour grade or stage and present or absent with equal frequency in recurrent TCC. LOH on 9q correlated with the extent of genome-wide hypomethylation (P < 0.0001) which extended into satellite sequences located in 9q12 juxtacentromeric heterochromatin. While the high frequency of chromosome 9q loss in TCC may reflect destabilization of the chromosome related to hypomethylation of repetitive DNA, the data are compatible with the existence of tumour suppressor genes on this chromosome arm.     

Somatic mutations in the BRCA2 gene and high frequency of allelic loss of BRCA2 in sporadic male breast cancer

Breast cancer occurs rarely in men and risk factors for the disease include germline mutations of the BRCA2 gene. High frequency of allelic loss at the BRCA2 locus has been reported in sporadic breast tumors, but somatic mutations of BRCA2 are very rare. Here we report the first case of somatic BRCA2 mutation in male breast cancer with demonstrated loss of heterozygosity. We analyzed a series of 27 archival samples from male breast cancer patients for BRCA2 mutations and loss of heterozygosity at BRCA2 locus. The mutation analysis of BRCA2 gene was performed using SSCA-HA and sequencing methods. PCR was used to detect LOH at 3 highly polymorphic microsatellite markers spanning BRCA2 region on 13q by comparing the allelic pattern in matched tumor and blood DNA samples. In this study LOH at the BRCA2 locus was observed in 82.6% of informative cases, confirming previous observations on high frequency of LOH affecting the BRCA2 region in male breast cancer. We identified 5 somatic BRCA2 mutations in a set of 23 sporadic male breast cancers (21%). Two silent and 1 missense alterations were novel BRCA2 variants. Here we also report first somatic frameshift BRCA2 mutation in male breast cancer 8138del5. In 3 tumors with somatic BRCA2 alterations, 1 missense, 1 silent and frameshift LOH at chromosome 13q12-13 were detected and losses involved a wild-type allele of BRCA2 gene.     

Molecular genetic analysis of the von Hippel-Lindau disease (VHl) tumour suppressor gene in gonadal tumours

Chromosome 3p allele loss is frequent in ovarian and testicular tumours. The von Hippel-Lindau (VHL) disease tumour suppressor gene maps to chromosome 3p25. Gonadal tumours may occur in patients with VHL disease, so somatic VHL gene mutations might be involved in the pathogenesis of sporadic gonadal tumours. To investigate this hypothesis, we screened 60 gonadal tumours (36 ovarian and 24 testicular) for VHL gene mutations and chromosome 3p allele loss. Although 38% (10/26) of informative ovarian and 54% (7/13) of testicular tumours demonstrated 3p allele loss, no somatic VHL gene mutations were detected in the 60 gonadal tumours analysed. This suggested that chromosome 3p tumour suppressor gene(s) other than VHL are involved in gonadal tumorigenesis.     

Molecular genetic investigation of sporadic renal cell carcinoma: analysis of allele loss on chromosomes 3p, 5q, 11p, 17 and 22.

To investigate the role of tumour-suppressor genes on the short arm of chromosome 3 in the mechanism of tumorigenesis in non-familial renal cell carcinoma, we analysed 55 paired blood-tumour DNA samples for allele loss on chromosome 3p and in the region of known or putative tumour-suppressor genes on chromosomes 5, 11, 17 and 22. Sixty-four per cent (35/55) of informative tumours showed loss of heterozygosity (LOH) of at least one locus on the short arm of chromosome 3, compared with only 13% at the p53 tumour-suppressor gene and 6% at 17q21. LOH at chromosome 5q21 and 22q was uncommon (2-3%). Detailed analysis of the regions of LOH on chromosome 3p suggested that, in addition to the VHL gene in chromosome 3p25-p26, mutations in one or more tumour-suppressor genes in chromosome 3p13-p24 may be involved in the pathogenesis of sporadic renal cell carcinoma (RCC). We also confirmed previous suggestions that chromosome 3p allele loss is not a feature of papillary RCC (P < 0.05).