Cost containment and the physician's ethical obligations

The chairman of the American Medical Association's Council on Ethical and Judicial Affairs evaluates the ethical relationship between physicians and payers, and cautions that physicians must use great restraint and diligence to maintain professionalism in an environment of cost constraints.     

Management of the patient with do not resuscitate status: compassion and cost containment

An interdisciplinary approach to the management of patients with do not resuscitate status on a supportive care team is an alternative to traditional intensive care unit management. This approach focuses on the physical, psychological, and spiritual needs of the patient and family. We describe our experience with 131 patients managed by the supportive care team that resulted in humane care of dying patients and reduced hospital costs as evidenced by reduced Therapeutic Intervention Scoring System values. Although our goal is comprehensive terminal care, financial savings have resulted as well. We describe the elements of care that contribute to compassionate management and to reduced interventions and costs. This approach may have application in other critical care settings that are faced with the same challenges of providing humane care to hopelessly ill patients.     

Cost containment in medicine: Why cardiology?

In 1984, expenditures for health care in the United States were nearly $350 billion, more than 10% of the gross national product, and continued increases exceeding the general economic growth are projected. Cardiology and cardiovascular surgery represent a large part of this cost, reflecting the many new diagnostic and therapeutic procedures developed over the past 2 decades. Previous cost containment attempts failed because they provided no incentive to reduce spending for advanced technologies and procedures. A method of payment based on a case mix of 467 diagnosis related groups (DRGs), average duration of hospital stay and location of hospitals has been developed for Medicare. A 4-year trial using this method in New Jersey resulted in lower hospital costs per capita than in the rest of the country. In October 1983, a 3-year phase-in for all Medicare payments by the DRG method began. The 43 DRGs assigned to cardiology and cardiovascular surgery are among the highest-weighted for large reimbursement; thus, with the great number of aging patients with cardiac diagnoses, cardiology represents a very large share of the cost of medical care today. Because the quality of care can be determined and compared directly with costs, cardiology DRGs lend themselves to careful analysis. Three components will be examined. Coronary bypass surgery is the largest single reimbursement, thus the rationale for its use should be carefully studied. Coronary care units have markedly increased hospital costs for acute myocardial infarction, but have also improved care.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Cost and health-related quality of life for children hospitalized with respiratory syncytial virus in Central China

Background

The economic burden of respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) infection and its impact on health-related quality of life (HRQoL) are not well-understood in China. This study assessed total cost and HRQoL for children hospitalized with RSV in Central China.

Methods

Based on a prospective case series study in Henan Province in 2020–2021, inpatients aged 0–59 months with RSV-related acute respiratory infections (ARIs) were included into analysis. Total cost included direct medical cost (sum of medical cost before and during hospitalization), direct non-medical cost, and indirect cost. Direct medical cost during hospitalization data were extracted from the hospital information system. Other costs and HRQoL status were obtained from a telephone survey conducted in the caregivers of the enrolled patients.

Results

Among 261 RSV-infected inpatients, caregivers of 170 non-severe cases (65.1%, 170/261) were successfully interviewed. Direct medical cost per episode was 1055.3 US dollars (US$) (95% CI: 998.2–1112.5 US$). Direct non-medical cost and indirect cost per episode were 83.6 US$ (95% CI: 77.5–89.7 US$) and 162.4 US$ (95% CI: 127.9–197.0 US$), respectively. Quality adjusted life years (QALY) loss for non-severe RSV hospitalization was 8.9 × 10⁻³ (95% CI: 7.9 × 10⁻³–9.9 × 10⁻³). The majority of inpatients were <1 year of age comprising significantly higher cost and more QALY loss than older children.

Conclusions

RSV-associated hospitalization poses high economic and health burden in Central China particularly for children <1 year old. Our findings are crucial for determining the priority of interventions and allocation of health resources.     

Improving patient quality of life with feedback to physicians about functional status

OBJECTIVE: To improve functional status among primary care patients. INTERVENTION: 1) Computer-generated feedback to physicians about the patient’s functional status, the patient’s self-reported “chief complaint,” and problem-specific resource and management suggestions; and 2) two brief interactive educational sessions for physicians. DESIGN: Randomized controlled trial. SETTING: University primary care clinic. PARTICIPANTS: All 73 internal medicine houseofficers and 557 of their new primary care patients. MEASURES: 1) Change in patient functional status from enrollment until six months later, using the Functional Status Questionnaire (FSQ); 2) management plans and additional information about functional status abstracted from the medical record; and 3) physician attitude about whether internists should address functional status problems. RESULTS: Emotional well-being scores improved significantly for the patients of the experimental group physicians compared with those of the control group physicians (p<0.03). Limitations in social activities indicated as “due to health” decreased among the elderly (>70 years of age) individuals in the experimental group compared with the control group (p<0.03). The experimental group physicians diagnosed more symptoms of stress or anxiety than did the control group physicians (p<0.001) and took more actions recommended by the feedback form (p<0.02). CONCLUSIONS: Computer-generated feedback of functional status screening results accompanied by resource and management suggestions can increase physician diagnoses of impaired emotional well-being, can influence physician management of functional status problems, and can assist physicians in improving emotional well-being and social functioning among their patients. Supported by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. The opinions and conclusions herein are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the views of the Sepulveda VA, UCLA, CSUF, Rand, or the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.     

Cost containment analysis of childhood vaccination against varicella in Israel

OBJECTIVES: The low cost of safe and effective vaccines prompted a cost-containment evaluation of a nationwide vaccination campaign against varicella. METHODS: A model incorporating demographic, epidemiologic and economic data from Israeli sources (supplemented by data from International literature) was constructed to estimate the decrease in morbidity and the consequent reductions in treatment costs and time-off work of a nationwide programme vaccinating children at 12 months. RESULTS: A policy of aiming to immunize a cohort of all 1-year-olds in Israel in the year 2002, for an annual cost of $1.10 million to the health services and $1.27 million to society (including lost work and transport costs), would reduce the number of cases of varicella during the lifetime of a cohort from 123,984 to 10,170 cases. This morbidity reduction would reduce national expenditures by $1.80 million in health service resources alone and by $24.5 million to society, mainly due to inaverted work absences. In addition an estimated 0.93 lives, representing 38.6 life years will be saved in the cohort. CONCLUSIONS: Under an assumption of neutrality relating to the potential effects of vaccination on herpes zoster virus, our model based calculations show that a national varicella vaccination programme is likely to be cost saving, not only from a societal perspective but also from the narrower health service perspective.     

Cost and quality of life in thoracic surgery--a health economic analysis in a German center

BACKGROUND: A critical look at the effectiveness of medical procedures and therapies is important with the increasing limitations on resources in health care. METHOD: The costs for treatment and the quality of life according to the SF-36 were analyzed in a retrospective health economic study on 65 patients who had undergone surgery for primary non-small-cell lung cancer. RESULTS: The mean cost for all patients was 7,169 euro per patient. 38.8 % resulted from surgery, 31.6 % were attached to the preoperative phase on the general ward, 11 % postoperatively to the general ward. Intensive care costs accounted for 18.7 %. The cost of each surgical procedure ranged from 4,634 euro for a pneumonectomy to 8,366 euro for a lobectomy with sleeve resection of the bronchus. The most expensive factors were staff, disposable materials, pathological investigations, and radiology services. There was no difference in these proportions with stage of tumor or the surgical procedures undertaken. Quality of life as assessed by the SF-36 questionnaire ranged from 31.82 (physical functioning) to 75.0 (social functioning) one year after the operation. These scores were lower than for those with other chronic diseases. On average, 4.62 quality-adjusted life years were achieved. The cost per QALY was 1,970 euro. The extent of resection and the tumor staging correlates significantly with the mean cost per QALY. CONCLUSION: Thoracic surgery is cost intensive. With increasing staging of the tumor, the cost for treatment increased as with increased operation complexity.     

An overview of obesity-specific quality of life questionnaires

The measurement of quality of life in patients with obesity is useful to evaluate the effects of treatment (including bariatric surgery) and may influence the development of clinical pathways, service provision, healthcare expenditures and public health policy. Consequently, clinicians, researchers and policy makers must rely on valid measurement instruments. We reviewed 11 obesity-specific quality of life questionnaires and classified them according to their domain of interest and described their measurement properties (specifications, validity, reliability, responsiveness and interpretability). We found that (i) nine questionnaires were developed specifically to be used as evaluative instruments in clinical trials; (ii) only three targeted populations with morbid obesity (body mass index > 40 kg m(-2)); (iii) construct validity was properly studied in three questionnaires; (iv) demonstration of responsiveness from independent randomized controlled trials was available for two of the 11 questionnaires; (v) keys to interpretation of scores were provided for three questionnaires. Future research should include further validation and a better definition of the interpretability of existing instruments.