Effect of Overpressure on Acoustic Emissions and Treated Tissue Histology in ex Vivo Bulk Ultrasound Ablation

Bulk ultrasound ablation is a thermal therapy approach in which tissue is heated by unfocused or weakly focused sonication (average intensities on the order of 100 W/cm²) to achieve coagulative necrosis within a few minutes exposure time. Assessing the role of bubble activity, including acoustic cavitation and tissue vaporization, in bulk ultrasound ablation may help in making bulk ultrasound ablation safer and more effective for clinical applications. Here, two series of ex vivo ablation trials were conducted to investigate the role of bubble activity and tissue vaporization in bulk ultrasound ablation. Fresh bovine liver tissue was ablated with unfocused, continuous-wave ultrasound using ultrasound image-ablate arrays sonicating at 31 W/cm² (0.9 MPa amplitude) for either 20 min at a frequency of 3.1 MHz or 10 min at 4.8 MHz. Tissue specimens were maintained at a static overpressure of either 0.52 or 1.2 MPa to suppress bubble activity and tissue vaporization or at atmospheric pressure for control groups. A passive cavitation detector was used to record subharmonic (1.55 or 2.4 MHz), broadband (1.2–1.5 MHz) and low-frequency (5–20 kHz) acoustic emissions. Treated tissue was stained with 2% triphenyl tetrazolium chloride to evaluate thermal lesion dimensions. Subharmonic emissions were significantly reduced in overpressure groups compared with control groups. Correlations observed between acoustic emissions and lesion dimensions were significant and positive for the 3.1-MHz series, but significant and negative for the 4.8-MHz series. The results indicate that for bulk ultrasound ablation, where both acoustic cavitation and tissue vaporization are possible, bubble activity can enhance ablation in the absence of tissue vaporization, but can reduce thermal lesion dimensions in the presence of vaporization.     

Bubble dynamics in boiling histotripsy

Boiling histotripsy is a non-invasive, cavitation-based ultrasonic technique which uses a number of millisecond pulses to mechanically fractionate tissue. Though a number of studies have demonstrated the efficacy of boiling histotripsy for fractionation of solid tumours, treatment monitoring by cavitation measurement is not well studied because of the limited understanding of the dynamics of bubbles induced by boiling histotripsy. The main objectives of this work are to (a) extract qualitative and quantitative features of bubbles excited by shockwaves and (b) distinguish between the different types of cavitation activity for either a thermally or a mechanically induced lesion in the liver. A numerical bubble model based on the Gilmore equation accounting for heat and mass transfer (gas and water vapour) was developed to investigate the dynamics of a single bubble in tissue exposed to different High Intensity Focused Ultrasound fields as a function of temperature variation in the fluid. Furthermore, ex vivo liver experiments were performed with a passive cavitation detection system to obtain acoustic emissions. The numerical simulations showed that the asymmetry in a shockwave and water vapour transport are the key parameters which lead the bubble to undergo rectified growth at a boiling temperature of 100°C. The onset of rectified radial bubble motion manifested itself as (a) an increase in the radiated pressure and (b) the sudden appearance of higher order multiple harmonics in the corresponding spectrogram. Examining the frequency spectra produced by the thermal ablation and the boiling histotripsy exposures, it was observed that higher order multiple harmonics as well as higher levels of broadband emissions occurred during the boiling histotripsy insonation. These unique features in the emitted acoustic signals were consistent with the experimental measurements. These features can, therefore, be used to monitor (a) the different types of acoustic cavitation activity for either a thermal ablation or a mechanical fractionation process and (b) the onset of the formation of a boiling bubble at the focus in the course of HIFU exposure.     

Cavitation Properties of Block Copolymer Stabilized Phase-Shift Nanoemulsions Used as Drug Carriers

Cavitation properties of block copolymer stabilized perfluoropentane nanoemulsions have been investigated. The nanoemulsions were stabilized by two biodegradable amphiphilic block copolymers differing in the structure of the hydrophobic block, poly(ethylene oxide)-co-poly(L-lactide) (PEG-PLLA) and poly(ethylene oxide)-co-polycaprolactone (PEG-PCL). Cavitation parameters were measured in liquid emulsions and gels as a function of ultrasound pressure for unfocused or focused 1-MHz ultrasound. Acoustic droplet vaporization preceded generation of acoustic cavitation in liquid matrices and gels. Both stable and inertial cavitation was observed for focused ultrasound while only stable cavitation was observed for unfocused ultrasound. (E-mail: Natasha.rapoport@utah.edu)     

Cavitation-enhanced ultrasound thermal therapy by combined low- and high-frequency ultrasound exposure

This paper demonstrates a novel approach for enhancing ultrasound-induced heating by the introduction of acoustic cavitation using simultaneous sonication with low- and high-frequency ultrasound. A spherical focused transducer (566 or 1155 kHz) was used to generate the thermal lesions, and a low-frequency planar transducer (40 or 28 kHz) was used to enhance the bubble activity. Ex vivo fresh porcine muscles were used as the target of ultrasound ablation. The emitted signals and the signals backscattered from the bubble activity were also recorded during the heating process by a PVDF-type needle hydrophone, and thermocouples were inserted to measure temperatures. Compared with the lesions formed by a single focused transducer, the size of the lesions generated by this approach were as much as 140% larger along the axial direction and 200% larger along the radial direction for combined 566- and 40-kHz sonication. They were 47% and 66% larger along the axial and radial directions, respectively, for combined 1155- and 28-kHz sonication. Cavitation activities enhanced by low-frequency ultrasound were confirmed by the presence of subharmonics in the spectrum and temperature increase as a result of increased tissue absorption. These observations imply that cavitation-enhanced lesions can be generated without reducing the penetration ability; they also show the advantage of producing larger and more uniform thermal lesions by multiple sonications. This technique provides an easy and effective way to achieve cavitation-enhanced heating, and may be useful for generating large and deep-seated thermal lesions.     

Cavitational mechanisms in ultrasound-accelerated thrombolysis at 1 MHz

Inertial cavitation is hypothesized to be a mechanism by which ultrasound (US) accelerates the dissolution of human blood clots when the clot is exposed to a thrombolytic agent such as tissue plasminogen activator (t-PA). To test this hypothesis, radiolabeled fibrin clots were exposed or sham-exposed in vitro to 1 MHz c.w. US in a rotating sample holder immersed in a water-filled tank at 37 degrees C. Percent clot dissolution after 60 min of US exposure was assessed by removing the samples, centrifuging, and measuring the radioactivity of the supernatant fluid relative to the pelletized material. To suppress acoustic cavitation, the exposure tank was contained within a hyperbaric chamber capable of pneumatic pressurization to 10 atmospheres (gauge). Various combinations of static pressure (0, 2, 5, and 7.5 atm gauge), US (0 or 4 W/cm(2) SATA), and t-PA (0 or 10 microg/mL) were employed, showing statistically significant reductions in thrombolytic activity as static pressure increased. To gain further insight, an active cavitation detection scheme was employed in which 1-micros duration tonebursts of 20-MHz US (< 1 kPa peak negative pressure, 1 Hz PRF) were used to interrogate clots subjected to US and static pressure. Results of this cavitation detection scheme showed that scattering from within the clot and broadband acoustic emissions that were both present during insonification were significantly reduced with application of static pressure. However, only about half of the acceleration of thrombolysis due to US could be removed by static pressure, suggesting the possibility of other mechanisms in addition to inertial cavitation.     

Identifying the Inertial Cavitation Threshold and Skull Effects in a Vessel Phantom Using Focused Ultrasound and Microbubbles

Focused ultrasound (FUS) in combination with microbubbles has been shown capable of delivering large molecules to the brain parenchyma through opening of the blood-brain barrier (BBB). However, the mechanism behind the opening remains unknown. To investigate the pressure threshold for inertial cavitation of preformed microbubbles during sonication, passive cavitation detection in conjunction with B-mode imaging was used. A cerebral vessel was simulated by generating a cylindrical hole of 610 μm in diameter inside a polyacrylamide gel and saturating its volume with microbubbles. Definity microbubbles (Mean diameter range: 1.1-3.3 μm, Lantheus Medical Imaging, N. Billerica, MA, USA) were injected prior to sonication (frequency: 1.525 MHz; pulse length: 100 cycles; PRF: 10 Hz; sonication duration: 2 s) through an excised mouse skull. The acoustic emissions due to the cavitation response were passively detected using a cylindrically focused hydrophone, confocal with the FUS transducer and a linear-array transducer with the field of view perpendicular to the FUS beam. The broadband spectral response acquired at the passive cavitation detector (PCD) and the B-mode images identified the occurrence and location of the inertial cavitation, respectively. Findings indicated that the peak-rarefactional pressure threshold was approximately equal to 0.45 MPa, with or without the skull present. Mouse skulls did not affect the threshold of inertial cavitation but resulted in a lower inertial cavitation dose. The broadband response could be captured through the murine skull, so the same PCD set-up can be used in future in vivo applications. (E-mail: ek2191@columbia.edu)     

Contribution of Inertial Cavitation in the Enhancement of In Vitro Transscleral Drug Delivery

In ocular drug delivery, the sclera is a promising pathway for administering drugs to both the anterior and posterior segments of the eye. Due to the low permeability of the sclera, however, efficient drug delivery is challenging. In this study, pulsed ultrasound (US) was investigated as a potential method for enhancing drug delivery to the eye through the sclera. The permeability of rabbit scleral tissue to a model drug compound, sodium fluorescein, was measured after US-irradiation at 1.1 MHz using time-averaged acoustic powers of 0.5–5.4 W (6.8–12.8 MPa peak negative pressure), with a fixed duty cycle of 2.5% for two different pulse repetition frequencies of 100 and 1000 Hz. Acoustic cavitation activity was measured during exposures using a passive cavitation detector and was used to quantify the level of bubble activity. A correlation between the amount of cavitation activity and the enhancement of scleral permeability was demonstrated with a significant enhancement in permeability of US exposed samples compared to controls. Transmission electron microscopy showed no evidence of significant alteration in viability of tissue exposed to US exposures. A pulsed US protocol designed to maximum cavitation activity may therefore be a viable method for enhancing drug delivery to the eye.     

Influence of Acoustic Reflection on the Inertial Cavitation Dose in a Franz Diffusion Cell

The exposure of the skin to low-frequency (20–100?kHz) ultrasound is a well-established method for increasing its permeability to drugs. The mechanism underlying this permeability increase has been found to be inertial cavitation within the coupling fluid. This study investigated the influence of acoustic reflections on the inertial cavitation dose during low-frequency (20?kHz) exposure in an in vitro skin sonoporation setup. This investigation was conducted using a passive cavitation detector that monitored the broadband noise emission within a modified Franz diffusion cell. Two versions of this diffusion cell were employed. One version had acoustic conditions that were similar to those of a standard Franz diffusion cell surrounded by air, whereas the second was designed to greatly reduce the acoustic reflection by submerging the diffusion cell in a water bath. The temperature of the coupling fluid in both setups was controlled using a novel thermoelectric cooling system. At an ultrasound intensity of 13.6 W/cm², the median inertial cavitation dose when the acoustic reflections were suppressed, was found to be only about 15% lower than when reflections were not suppressed.     

The role of cavitation in acoustically activated drug delivery.

Pluronic P105 micelles are potential candidates as chemotherapy drug delivery vehicles using ultrasonic stimulation as a release trigger. Acoustic power has been previously shown to release two anthracycline agents from these polymeric carriers. In this study, an ultrasonic exposure chamber with fluorescence detection was used to examine the mechanism of doxorubicin release from P105 micelles. Acoustic spectra were collected and analyzed, at the same spatial position as fluorescence data, to probe the role of cavitation in drug release. Our study showed a strong correlation between percent drug release and subharmonic acoustic emissions, and we attribute the drug release to collapse cavitation that perturbs the structure of the micelle and releases drug.     

Temporal and Spatial Detection of HIFU-Induced Inertial and Hot-Vapor Cavitation with a Diagnostic Ultrasound System

The onset and presence of inertial cavitation and near-boiling temperatures in high-intensity focused ultrasound (HIFU) therapy have been identified as important indicators of energy deposition for therapy guidance. Passive cavitation detection is commonly used to detect bubble emissions, where a fixed-focus single-element acoustic transducer is typically used as a passive cavitation detector (PCD). This technique is suboptimal for clinical applications, because most PCD transducers are tightly focused and afford limited spatial coverage of the HIFU focal region. A Terason 2000 Ultrasound System was used as a PCD array to expand the spatial detection region for cavitation by operating in passive mode, obtaining the radiofrequency signals corresponding to each scan line and filtering the contribution from scattering of the HIFU signal harmonics. This approach allows for spatially resolved detection of both inertial and stable cavitation throughout the focal region. Measurements with the PCD array during sonication with a 1.1-MHz HIFU source in tissue phantoms were compared with single-element PCD and thermocouple sensing. Stable cavitation signals at the harmonics and superharmonics increased in a threshold fashion for temperatures >90°C, an effect attributed to high vapor pressure in the cavities. Incorporation of these detection techniques in a diagnostic ultrasound platform could result in a powerful tool for improving HIFU guidance and treatment. (E-mail: cfarny@bwh.harvard.edu)     

Optical monitoring of ultrasound-induced bioeffects in glass catfish

This study is an investigation of the therapeutic ultrasound (US) effects on the blood vessels of optically transparent fish in vivo. Although many investigators have characterized cavitation in vivo using remote-sensing methods (i.e., measuring the acoustic emissions caused by oscillating bubbles) very few have made direct observations of cavitation-induced damage. Anesthetized glass catfish, which are optically transparent, was injected with the contrast agent, Optison, and then insonified at pressures that ranged from 0.5-10 MPa (peak negative pressures). Two focused transducers were used in these experiments to cover a frequency range of 0.7-3.3 MHz. Sonications were pulsed with pulse durations of 100, 10, 1, 0.1 and 0.01 ms and a pulse repetition frequency (PRF) of 1 Hz. The entire length of one sonication at a specific pressure level was 20 s. An inverted microscope combined with a digital camera and video monitor were used optically to monitor and record US interaction with the blood vessels in the tail of the anesthetized fish at 200x magnification. The effects of the burst sonication were analyzed visually at each pressure level. For the 1.091-MHz sonications, the first type of damage that occurred due to the US interaction was structural damage to the cartilage rods that comprise the tail of the fish, and was characterized by a disintegration of the lining of the rod. Damage to the rods occurred, starting at 3.5 MPa, 3.1 MPa, 4.1 MPa and 5.5 MPa for the 100-ms, 10-ms, 1-ms and 100-micros sonications, respectively. The formation of large gas bubbles was observed in the blood vessels of the fish at threshold values of 3.8 MPa, 3.8 MPa and 5.3 MPa, for the 100-ms, 10-ms and 1-ms sonications, respectively. Neither gas bubble formation nor hemorrhaging was observed during 100-micros sonications. Bubble formation was always accompanied by an increase of damage to the rods at the area surrounding the bubble. At 1.091 MHz, petechial hemorrhage thresholds were observed at 4.1 MPa, 4.1 MPa and 6.1 MPa, respectively, for the three pulse durations. The thresholds for damage were the lowest for the 0.747-MHz sonications: they were 2.6 MPa for damage to the rods, 3.7 MPa for gas bubble formation and 2.4 MPa for hemorrhaging.     

Interstitial Matrix Prevents Therapeutic Ultrasound From Causing Inertial Cavitation in Tumescent Subcutaneous Tissue

We search for cavitation in tumescent subcutaneous tissue of a live pig under application of pulsed, 1-MHz ultrasound at 8 W cm^?2 spatial peak and pulse-averaged intensity. We find no evidence of broadband acoustic emission indicative of inertial cavitation. These acoustic parameters are representative of those used in external-ultrasound-assisted lipoplasty and in physical therapy and our null result brings into question the role of cavitation in those applications. A comparison of broadband acoustic emission from a suspension of ultrasound contrast agent in bulk water with a suspension injected subcutaneously indicates that the interstitial matrix suppresses cavitation and provides an additional mechanism behind the apparent lack of in-vivo cavitation to supplement the absence of nuclei explanation offered in the literature. We also find a short-lived cavitation signal in normal, non-tumesced tissue that disappears after the first pulse, consistent with cavitation nuclei depletion in vivo.     

A Study of Bubble Activity Generated in Ex Vivo Tissue by High Intensity Focused Ultrasound

Cancer treatment by extracorporeal high-intensity focused ultrasound (HIFU) is constrained by the time required to ablate clinically relevant tumour volumes. Although cavitation may be used to optimize HIFU treatments, its role during lesion formation is ambiguous. Clear differentiation is required between acoustic cavitation (noninertial and inertial) effects and bubble formation arising from two thermally-driven effects (the vapourization of liquid into vapour, and the exsolution of formerly dissolved permanent gas out of the liquid and into gas spaces). This study uses clinically relevant HIFU exposures in degassed water and ex vivo bovine liver to test a suite of cavitation detection techniques that exploit passive and active acoustics, audible emissions and the electrical drive power fluctuations. Exposure regimes for different cavitation activities (none, acoustic cavitation and, for ex vivo tissue only, acoustic cavitation plus thermally-driven gas space formation) were identified both in degassed water and in ex vivo liver using the detectable characteristic acoustic emissions. The detection system proved effective in both degassed water and tissue, but requires optimization for future clinical application. (E-mail: jmclaughlan7@gmail.com)     

Dynamic Changes of Integrated Backscatter,Attenuation Coefficient and Bubble Activities During High-Intensity Focused Ultrasound (HIFU) Treatment

This paper simultaneously investigated the transient characteristics of integrated backscatter (IBS), attenuation coefficient and bubble activities as time traces before, during and after HIFU treatment, with different HIFU parameters (acoustic power and duty cycle) in both transparent tissue-mimicking phantoms and freshly excised bovine livers. These dynamic changes of acoustic parameters and bubble activities were correlated with the visualization of lesion development selected from photos, conventional B-mode ultrasound images and differential IBS images over the whole procedure of HIFU treatment. Two-dimensional radiofrequency (RF) data were acquired by a modified diagnostic ultrasound scanner to estimate the changes of mean IBS and attenuation coefficient averaged in the lesion region, and to construct the differential IBS images and B-mode ultrasound images simultaneously. Bubble activities over the whole procedure of HIFU treatment were investigated by the passive cavitation detection (PCD) method and the changes in subharmonic and broadband noise were correlated with the transient characteristics of IBS and attenuation coefficient. When HIFU was switched on, IBS and attenuation coefficient increased with the appearance of bubble clouds in the B-mode and differential IBS image. At the same time, the level of subharmonic and broadband noise rose abruptly. Then, there was an initial decrease in the attenuation coefficient, followed by an increase when at lower HIFU power. As the lesion appeared, IBS and attenuation coefficient both increased rapidly to a value twice that of normal. Then the changes in IBS and attenuation coefficient showed more complex patterns, but still showed a slower trend of increases with lesion development. Violent bubble activities were visible in the gel and were evident as strongly echogenic regions in the differential IBS images and B-mode images simultaneously. This was detected by a dramatic high level of subharmonic and broadband noise at the same time. These bubble activities caused fluctuations in IBS and attenuation coefficient during HIFU treatment. After HIFU, IBS and attenuation coefficient decreased gradually accompanied by the fadeout of bright hyperechoic spot in the B-mode and differential IBS image, but were still higher than normal when they were stable. The increases of IBS and attenuation coefficient were greater when using higher acoustic power or a higher duty cycle of the therapeutic emission. These experiments indicated that the bubble activities had the dominant effects on the transient characteristics of IBS and attenuation. This should be taken into consideration when using the dynamic acoustic-property changes for the potentially real-time monitoring imaging of HIFU treatment. (E-mail: mxwan@mail.xjtu.edu.cn)     

Cavitation-enhanced extravasation for drug delivery

A flow-through tissue-mimicking phantom composed of a biocompatible hydro-gel with embedded tumour cells was used to assess and optimize the role of ultrasound-induced cavitation on the extravasation of a macromolecular compound from a channel mimicking vessel in the gel, namely a non-replicating luciferase-expressing adenovirus (Ad-Luc). Using a 500 KHz therapeutic ultrasound transducer confocally aligned with a focussed passive cavitation detector, different exposure conditions and burst mode timings were selected by performing time and frequency domain analysis of passively recorded acoustic emissions, in the absence and in the presence of ultrasound contrast agents acting as cavitation nuclei. In the presence of Sonovue, maximum ultraharmonic emissions were detected for peak rarefactional pressures of 360 kPa, and maximum broadband emissions occurred at 1250 kPa. The energy of the recorded acoustic emissions was used to optimise the pulse repetition frequency and duty cycle in order to maximize either ultraharmonic or broadband emissions while keeping the acoustic energy delivered to the focus constant. Cell viability measurements indicated that none of the insonation conditions investigated induces cell death in the absence of a therapeutic agent (i.e. virus). Phase contrast images of the tissue-mimicking phantom showed that short range vessel disruption can occur when ultra-harmonic emissions (nf0/2) are maximised whereas formation of a micro-channel perpendicular to the flow can be obtained in the presence of broadband acoustic emissions. Following Ad-Luc delivery, luciferase expression measurements showed that a 60-fold increase in its bioavailability can be achieved when broadband noise emissions are present during insonation, even for modest contrast agent concentrations. The findings of the present study suggest that drug delivery systems based on acoustic cavitation may help enhance the extravasation of anticancer agents, thus increasing their penetration distance to hypoxic regions and poorly vascularised tumour regions.     

Measurements of bubble-enhanced heating from focused, MHz-frequency ultrasound in a tissue-mimicking material.

Time-resolved measurements of the temperature field in an agar-based tissue-mimicking phantom insonated with a large aperture 1-MHz focused acoustic transducer are reported. The acoustic pressure amplitude and insonation duration were varied. Above a critical threshold acoustic pressure, a large increase in the temperature rise during insonation was observed. Evidence for the hypothesis that cavitation bubble activity in the focal zone is the cause of enhanced heating is presented and discussed. Mechanisms for bubble-assisted heating are presented and modeled, and quantitative estimates for the thermal power generated by viscous dissipation and bubble acoustic radiation are given.     

Cavitational mechanisms in ultrasound-accelerated fibrinolysis

The role of both inertial and stable cavitation was investigated during in vitro ultrasound-accelerated fibrinolysis by recombinant tissue plasminogen activator (rt-PA) in the presence and absence of Optison. A unique treatment configuration applied ultrasound, rt-PA and Optison to the interior of a plasma clot. Lysis efficacy was measured as clot weight reduction. Cavitational mechanisms were investigated by monitoring subharmonic and broadband noise. In the absence of Optison, 1.7 MHz pulsed ultrasound with 1.5 MPa peak-negative pressure applied for 30 min resulted in 45 +/- 19% lysis enhancement relative to rt-PA alone. Cavitation was not detected, indicating a role of noncavitational effects of ultrasound. The addition of Optison increased lysis enhancement to 88 +/- 25%. Inertial cavitation was present only at the start of the exposure, while low-amplitude subharmonic emissions persisted throughout. Additional protocols suggested a possible correlation between the increased lysis in the presence of Optison and the subharmonic emission, indicating a potentially important role of stable rather than inertial cavitation in microbubble-enhanced ultrasound-accelerated rt-PA-mediated thrombolysis.     

Numerical and Experimental Study of Mechanisms Involved in Boiling Histotripsy

The aim of boiling histotripsy is to mechanically fractionate tissue as an alternative to thermal ablation for therapeutic applications. In general, the shape of a lesion produced by boiling histotripsy is tadpole like, consisting of a head and a tail. Although many studies have demonstrated the efficacy of boiling histotripsy for fractionating solid tumors, the exact mechanisms underpinning this phenomenon are not yet well understood, particularly the interaction of a boiling vapor bubble with incoming incident shockwaves. To investigate the mechanisms involved in boiling histotripsy, a high-speed camera with a passive cavitation detection system was used to observe the dynamics of bubbles produced in optically transparent tissue-mimicking gel phantoms exposed to the field of a 2.0-MHz high-intensity focused ultrasound (HIFU) transducer. We observed that boiling bubbles were generated in a localized heated region and cavitation clouds were subsequently induced ahead of the expanding bubble. This process was repeated with HIFU pulses and eventually resulted in a tadpole-shaped lesion. A simplified numerical model describing the scattering of the incident ultrasound wave by a vapor bubble was developed to help interpret the experimental observations. Together with the numerical results, these observations suggest that the overall size of a lesion induced by boiling histotripsy is dependent on the sizes of (i) the heated region at the HIFU focus and (ii) the backscattered acoustic field by the original vapor bubble.     

Ultrasonic characterization of the nonlinear properties of contrast microbubbles

The nonlinear properties of microbubble contrast agents have been used to create contrast-specific imaging modalities such as harmonic imaging and subharmonic imaging. Thus, a better understanding of the nonlinear performance of contrast microbubbles may enhance the diagnostic capabilities of medical ultrasound (US) imaging. The first and second harmonic, the 1/2 order subharmonic and the 3/2 order ultraharmonic components in spectra of scattered signals from Optison microbubbles insonified at 2 and 4 MHz have been investigated using an in vitro laboratory pulse-echo system. The development of these signal components over time is quite different for 2-MHz insonification compared to 4-MHz insonification. Scattered subharmonic and ultraharmonic signals are much more time-dependent than first and second harmonic echoes. The dependence of the first and second harmonic, subharmonic and ultraharmonic components on acoustic pressure for 2-MHz insonification is similar to that for 4-MHz insonification. The first and second harmonic components increase linearly with acoustic pressure (in double logarithmic scales) and the subharmonic and ultraharmonic amplitudes undergo rapid growths in the intermediate acoustic pressure range and much slower increases at both lower and higher acoustic pressures.     

Control of Acoustic Cavitation for Efficient Sonoporation with Phase-Shift Nanoemulsions

Acoustic cavitation can be used to temporarily disrupt cell membranes for intracellular delivery of large biomolecules. Termed sonoporation, the ability of this technique for efficient intracellular delivery (i.e., >50% of initial cell population showing uptake) while maintaining cell viability (i.e., >50% of initial cell population viable) has proven to be very difficult. Here, we report that phase-shift nanoemulsions (PSNEs) function as inertial cavitation nuclei for improvement of sonoporation efficiency. The interplay between ultrasound frequency, resultant microbubble dynamics and sonoporation efficiency was investigated experimentally. Acoustic emissions from individual microbubbles nucleated from PSNEs were captured using a broadband passive cavitation detector during and after acoustic droplet vaporization with short pulses of ultrasound at 1, 2.5 and 5 MHz. Time domain features of the passive cavitation detector signals were analyzed to estimate the maximum size (R_max) of the microbubbles using the Rayleigh collapse model. These results were then applied to sonoporation experiments to test if uptake efficiency is dependent on maximum microbubble size before inertial collapse. Results indicated that at the acoustic droplet vaporization threshold, R_max was approximately 61.7 ± 5.2, 24.9 ± 2.8, and 12.4 ± 2.1 μm at 1, 2.5 and 5 MHz, respectively. Sonoporation efficiency increased at higher frequencies, with efficiencies of 39.5 ± 13.7%, 46.6 ± 3.28% and 66.8 ± 5.5% at 1, 2.5 and 5 MHz, respectively. Excessive cellular damage was seen at lower frequencies because of the erosive effects of highly energetic inertial cavitation. These results highlight the importance of acoustic cavitation control in determining the outcome of sonoporation experiments. In addition, PSNEs may serve as tailorable inertial cavitation nuclei for other therapeutic ultrasound applications.