Should private payers adopt RBRVS fee schedules?

Independent Blue Cross and Blue Shield plans are adopting RBRVS-based fee schedules for reimbursing physicians. Some argue that private payers should follow suit.     

Constraining Medicare home health reimbursement: what are the outcomes?

The implementation of the Balanced Budget Act (BBA) of 1997 resulted in substantial decreases in the amount of Medicare home health use. Use among home health users decreased by two-fifths from fiscal year (FY) 1997, just before the passage of the BBA to FY 1999, the first full year after the implementation of the home health interim payment system. This article examines whether these dramatic reductions in use resulted in increased incidence of potential adverse outcomes, i.e., increases in hospitalizations, skilled nursing home facility admissions, emergency room (ER) use, or death among home health users.     

Should we change the focus of health promotion in sexual health clinics?

In a response to the recent article by Rudiger Pitroff and Elizabeth Goodburn on changing the focus of health promotion in sexual health clinics, Crouch and Fagan draw attention to the confusion among practitioners between brief interventions in clinics (health education) and the actual nature and scope of sexual health promotion. The response refocuses attention on the Ottawa Charter for Health Promotion and on the social determinants of sexual health inequity as appropriate design drivers of a pilot initiative proposed by Pitroff and Goodburn to re-orient sexual health service provision around the real needs of its clients.     

Should we change the focus of health promotion in sexual health clinics?

The effectiveness of sexual behaviour change interventions in sexual health clinics is unknown. Risk factors for poor sexual and reproductive health such as depression, violence, alcohol and smoking in sexual health clinics are all common and can be identified easily in sexual health services. Targeting these risk factors could be as effective as traditional sexual health promotion and could have additional benefits. The authors propose a pilot to assess the cost-effectiveness and acceptability of incorporating screening and interventions for these risk factors.     

Should the Emergency Department be society's health safety net?

In the US health care system, a core safety net provider has two defining characteristics: (1) either by legal mandate or explicitly adopted mission, they maintain an "open door," offering patients services regardless of their ability to pay; and (2) a substantial portion of their patients are uninsured, on Medicaid, and/or otherwise vulnerable. The hospital Emergency Department (ED), by all accounts, falls within the definition of a core safety net provider. Yet many would argue that this is a primary health care role for which the ED was not originally intended or equipped. Should the ED be society's health-care safety net? Should it be the main provider of care for the indigent? Is this placing an unbearable strain on the ED? Should it be providing primary health-care? If not, what are the alternatives?     

Do health maintenance organizations work for Medicare?

Since 1985, the Health Care Financing Administration (HCFA) has encouraged health maintenance organizations (HMOs) to provide Medicare coverage to enrolled beneficiaries for fixed prepaid premiums. Our evaluation shows that the risk program achieves some of its goals while not fulfilling others. We find that HMOs provide care of comparable quality to that delivered by free-for-service (FFS) providers using fewer health care resources. Enrollees experience substantially reduced out-of-pocket costs and greater coverage. However, because the capitation system does not account for the better health of those who enroll, the program does not save money for Medicare.     

Can the Veterans Affairs health care system continue to care for the poor and vulnerable?

Can the Veterans Affairs (VA) health care system, long an important part of the safety net for disabled and poor veterans, survive the loss of World War II veterans--once its largest constituency and still its most important advocates? A recent shift in emphasis from acute hospital-based care to care of chronic illness in outpatient settings, as well as changes in eligibility allowing many more nonpoor and nondisabled veterans into the VA system, will be key determinants of long-term survivability. Although allowing less needy veterans into the system runs the risk of diluting services to those most in need, the long-run effect may be to increase support among a larger and younger group of veterans, thereby enhancing political clout and ensuring survivability. It may be that the best way to maintain the safety net for veterans is to continue to cast it more widely.     

Should health care workers in the tropics be immunized against varicella?

In tropical regions, chickenpox affects both adults and children. Therefore, healthcare workers in the tropics are vulnerable to hospital-acquired varicella infection and they may transmit infection to susceptible hospitalized individuals. Although the varicella vaccine is safe and effective, its cost is a deterrent to its use in routine immunization programmes. In order to assess whether vaccination of susceptible healthcare workers to prevent hospital-acquired transmission may be justified, we have documented the frequency of varicella among healthcare workers in our hospital. There were 96 admissions for varicella during the 1993-1997 period; staff and student nurses accounted for 76%. The peak season of admission was from February to April. The attack rate in staff and student nurses was 0.78 and 1.54 per 100 person-years, respectively. While community outbreaks of varicella occur in this region once in 4-5 years, hospital outbreaks of varicella occurred every year. This poses the risk of transmission to hospitalized patients, with serious consequences among immunocompromized individuals. Therefore, we recommend systematic selective vaccination of susceptible healthcare workers to break this cycle of annual varicella outbreaks among hospital personnel.