Detection of hepatitis C virus sequences in sera with controversial serology by nested polymerase chain reaction.

The specificity of first-generation enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (ELIAs) for antibody detection in individuals with hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection has been questioned in some pathological situations. We observed a surprisingly high prevalence of anti-HCV antibodies in alcoholic patients, and thus, false-positive reactions in anti-HCV tests were strongly suspected. The introduction of new epitopes, particularly a core protein, C22 (second-generation tests), seems to increase the sensitivity of anti-HCV detection. In order to study the specificity of the second-generation tests, 60 serum samples from alcoholic patients found to be positive by the first-generation anti-HCV ELISA (Ortho) were reexamined by a second-generation anti-HCV enzyme immunoassay (Abbott) and a recombinant immunoblot assay (RIBA II; Chiron). Fifteen serum samples gave contradictory results when they were tested by the two assays. We performed nested polymerase chain reactions (PCRs) to confirm that the discrepancies that we observed could be due to the presence of low levels of anti-HCV antibodies, which were detected by a more sensitive test, or to unspecific positive reactions. Nested PCR revealed the presence of HCV RNA sequences in all anti-HCV-positive sera or sera that were weakly positive by ELISA. Anti-HCV positive by RIBA II was always correlated with the presence of viral RNA in serum, but HCV RNA was detected in RIBA II-negative sera. These results indicate that the specificity of the second-generation tests is an important improvement but that an HCV infection can still persist without detectable antibodies. PCR remains the reference assay to clear up controversial serology results and to detect HCV infection in patients with no anti-HCV-detectable immune response.     

Significance of indeterminate third-generation hepatitis C virus recombinant immunoblot assay.

Indeterminate hepatitis C virus (HCV) third-generation recombinant immunoblot assay (RIBA3.0; Ortho Diagnostic Systems) patterns were arbitrarily defined by the manufacturer as the detection of only one antibody out of the four that were sought, namely, c100 (NS4 encoded), c22 (core encoded), c33c (NS3 encoded), and NS5 (NS5 encoded). The aims of the present study were (i) to determine the prevalence of indeterminate RIBA3.0 patterns in patients consecutively tested for anti-HCV antibodies in a university hospital; (ii) to evaluate the significance of these patterns in terms of viral replication, liver disease, and risk factors for HCV; and (iii) to get an insight into the mechanism underlying this peculiar immune response. Among 3,074 serum samples consecutively tested for anti-HCV antibodies, 588 were found to be positive by screening assays. Fifty-nine of them (10%) were RIBA3.0 indeterminate and were compared with 59 RIBA3.0-positive ones. Thirty-one RIBA3.0-indeterminate and 53 RIBA3.0-positive serum samples were HCV RNA positive by PCR (53 versus 90%; P < 10(-6). RIBA3.0-indeterminate and RIBA-3.0-positive patients with positive PCR results were not significantly different for the prevalence of risk factors for HCV infection and elevated serum alanine aminotransferase activities. Immunosuppression, attributable to coexisting human immunodeficiency virus infection, organ transplantation, or the administration of immunosuppressive drugs, was significantly more frequent in PCR-positive, RIBA3.0-indeterminate patients than in PCR-negative, RIBA3.0 indeterminate patients (P < 0.001) and PCR-positive patients with a positive RIBA3.0 result (P < 0.01). The distribution of HCV genotypes did not differ significantly between HCV RNA-positive patients with indeterminate or positive RIBA3.0 results. In conclusion, the prevalence of indeterminate RIBA3.0 patterns in virology laboratories is about 10%; in about half of these patients HCV replication is detected by PCR; the main factor responsible for indeterminate RIBA3.0 patterns could be immunosuppression, whereas HCV genotypes do not seem to play major role.     

Study on reliability of commercially available hepatitis C virus antibody tests.

The serodiagnosis of hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection was analyzed by a recombinant immunoblot assay (RIBA) with recombinant proteins encoded by the viral RNA isolated from our patients in Hamburg, Germany. The HCV RNA was amplified by PCR, and proteins encoded by the viral core and the NS3, NS4, and NS5 regions were expressed subsequently in Escherichia coli. The results obtained with our UKE RIBA were compared with the results of the Abbott HCV second-generation enzyme immunoassay (EIA). Serum samples from 270 patients, which were sent to us on the suspicion of HCV hepatitis and which were negative for hepatitis A virus and hepatitis B virus antibodies, were examined. In 227 cases (84.1%), there were identical positive (204 cases, 75.6%) or negative (23 cases, 8.5%) results in both tests. In 32 cases (11.9%), the reactive Abbott second-generation HCV EIA results could not be confirmed by the UKE RIBA and the HCV PCR. In follow-up studies conducted over 1 year, these results did not change. In three cases (1.1%), the UKE RIBA presented a positive result while the Abbott second-generation HCV EIA was negative. All three cases were positive in the HCV PCR and showed seroconversion in an HCV EIA 4 to 6 weeks later. In addition, 33 patient serum samples were examined by UKE RIBA in parallel with the Ortho RIBA 2.0. In three cases (9.1%), a positive Ortho RIBA 2.0 result could not be confirmed by the UKE RIBA and the HCV PCR. All three patients were free of complaints. The UKE RIBA showed also a smaller number of indeterminate results (3.0%) than the Ortho RIBA 2.0 (24.2%). This comparison study demonstrates that the commercially available HCV antibody tests should be further improved.     

Antibodies to a putative hepatitis C virus polyprotein in Japanese patients with chronic liver disease.

To investigate the frequency of exposure to hepatitis C virus (HCV) in chronic liver disease, sera from Japanese patients were tested with the original anti-HCV assay (Ortho) and an anti-HCV assay based on synthetic peptides corresponding to a variety of regions in the HCV genome. Thirty-one (67%) of 46 patients with chronic non-A,non-B hepatitis were anti-HCV-positive by the Ortho ELISA, 20 of whom were also positive by ELISA based on synthetic HCV peptides. Eight (53%) of the 15 patients negative by the Ortho ELISA tested positive for anti-HCV by ELISA based on HCV peptides. Serum HCV RNA was detected in all cases positive for antibody to the HCV peptide and in 14 (78%) of 18 cases without antibody. Thirty-seven hepatitis B virus carriers were without anti-HCV by the Ortho ELISA and were negative for serum HCV RNA, six (16%) of whom were positive by ELISA based on HCV peptides. Antibody responses were directed against each synthetic HCV peptide used, with a considerable difference in incidence, indicating possible expression of the corresponding region in the course of HCV propagation. These findings indicate that exposure to HCV may be more common than expected based on the results of the Ortho ELISA.     

Hepatitis C virus antibody prevalence among human immunodeficiency virus-1-infected individuals: Analysis with different test systems

Sera of 383 human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-l-infected individuals from Frankfurt (Main)/Germany were assayed by two hepatitis C virus (HCV) screening tests (Abbott second generation, Ortho second generation). This population showed a prevalence for reactivity with both tests of 20.8% (80/383). Examination of all reactive sera (91/383) by a supplemental assay (Chiron RIBA 2) gave for 46 sera a positive, for 33 sera an indeterminate, and for 12 sera a negative result. Further analysis focussed on these RIBA 2-indeterminate and -negative samples. Analysis of the sera using an in-house Western blot with three different Escherichia coli-expressed HCV proteins revealed that none of the RIBA 2-nega-tive, but 24 of the 33 RIBA 2-indeterminate sera, including 3 of 4 c33c (NSS)-reactive samples, were reactive with a recombinant core protein. Twenty-one of 22 c22-3 (core) indeterminates stained the core antigen in the in-house Western blot and 3 of them in addition a NS5 moiety. HCV-polymerase chain reaction (PCR) was positive for 14 of the 24 RIBA 2 -indeterminate sera, but for none of the RIBA 2-negative or Western blot nonreactive samples. Discrepant results between the two screening tests could not be explained by differences in the antigen compositions (i.e., a NS3-NS4 moiety of 111 amino acids present in the Ortho enzyme-linked immunosor-bent assay (ELISA), not present in the Abbott or RIBA 2 assays). © 1994 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

A comparison between one first generation and three second generation anti-HCV ELISAs: an investigation in high- and low-risk subjects in correlation with recombinant immunoblot assay and polymerase chain reaction

One first generation assay (manufactured by Ortho, test I) and 3 second generation anti-HCV ELISAs (manufactured by Ortho, Abbott, and UBI, tests II-IV) were compared. Sera from 4 different sources were used: (1) intravenous drug-users (IVDUs, n = 50), (2) blood donors (n = 1055), (3) all clinical samples from one day of routine anti-HCV testing (n = 89), (4) hemodialysis patients previously found negative by test I but clinically suspected to have a HCV infection (n = 11). Confirmatory anti-HCV tests were carried out with a second generation recombinant immunoblot assay (RIBA II). In sera positive exclusively by test IV, one antibody consumption test (UBI HCV Neutralization EIA) and one further immunoblot assay (INNO-LIA HCV Ab) were used. PCR for HCV RNA was carried out on all hemodialysis patient sera and in the RIBA II positive blood donor sera. The second generation ELISAs discriminated 11 more positive samples than the first generation test (2 IVDUs, 5 blood donors, 4 clinical samples). The 9 sera from blood donors and clinical samples were all RIBA II positive or indeterminate. The second generation tests thus showed increased sensitivity. The second generation tests also showed increased specificity in that 4 samples that were positive by test I but negative by the second generation tests, were also negative by RIBA II. With few exceptions, all RIBA II-positive and most of the indeterminate samples were positive by the second generation ELISAs. With few exceptions, all the RIBA II-negative samples were negative by the second generation ELISAs. Eleven blood donor sera were positive by test IV exclusively where RIBA II and other supplementary assays were negative. The recently introduced second generation anti-HCV ELISAs were found to have a higher sensitivity than the first generation test. The tests also showed a good concordance with the exception of test IV in the group of blood donor sera.     

Prevalence of hepatitis C virus infections among heterosexuals with multiple partners

A study among heterosexual men and women with multiple sexual partners was carried out to assess the seroprevalence of antibody against hepatitis C virus (HCV). The 468 participants were recruited among visitors to the Clinic for Sexually Transmitted Diseases in Amsterdam. Sera were tested by an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA; Ortho), a recombinant-based immunoblot assay (RIBA; Chiron), and the polymerase chain reaction (PCR). A total of 468 persons were tested, and seven (1.5%) were found ELISA positive. Another 25 (5%) were ELISA indeterminate. Six of the seven ELISA-positive cases were RIBA positive. Further serum samples from five HCV ELISA-positive persons were tested by PCR, and four were found to be positive. The HCV ELISA-positive/RIBA-indeterminate reaction was PCR negative. None of the 17 RIBA-tested sera of the ELISA-indeterminate group yielded a positive result. There was a good correlation between an ELISA optical density/cut-off ratio greater than 2 and a positive RIBA result. The risk factor for HCV appeared to be the type of sexual partner, i.e., belonging to a "high-risk" group for human immunodeficiency virus infection and origin from hepatitis B-endemic countries. It is concluded that HCV may be transmitted through heterosexual contact but probably with low efficiency.     

Hepatitis C virus infection among pregnant women in Yaounde,Cameroon: prevalence,viremia, and genotypes

Central Africa is considered to be an area of high endemic hepatitis C infection. To determine the prevalence of anti-HCV antibodies, HCV RNA, and the genotype distribution in Cameroon, 1,494 pregnant women attending antenatal care units in Yaounde, Cameroon were screened for HCV infection. Anti-HCV antibodies were detected with a 3rd generation ELISA (Monolisa anti-HCV plus version 2, BioRad, Richmond, CA). All anti-HCV antibody-positive sera were then tested with another 3rd generation ELISA (AxSYM) HCV version 3, Abbott Laboratories, Abbott Park, IL) and subsequently for HCV RNA (Amplicor HCV, Roche Diagnostics, Basel, Switzerland). Genotype was determined by phylogenetic analysis of the NS5b gene. Seventy-three pregnant women were found to be anti-HCV antibody positive by the first ELISA, but only 28 were anti-HCV positive by both ELISA. The prevalence of anti-HCV antibodies was thus 1.9% (28/1,494) (95% CI: 1.3-2.7%). 21/28 (75%) of the positive samples by both ELISA were HCV RNA positive. The 45 samples that were HCV antibody negative by the second ELISA were also HCV RNA negative. The HCV subtypes identified were 1a (24%), 2f (38%) and 4f (38%). In contrast to previous studies, anti-HCV antibodies were rare among pregnant women in Cameroon. The percentage of HCV seropositive pregnant women who had circulating HCV RNA was similar to that observed in Europe. Several HCV genotypes were found in Cameroon.     

Retrospective study of the value of the RIBA-3 test in 68 patients with discordant serologies with regard to hepatitis C obtained with third generation ELISA tests. Is there still a value in RIBA-3?]

The aim of the present study is to evaluate the ability of RIBA-3 to resolve cases with controversial ELISA results, since modifications have been introduced by the manufacturer in July 1997 to analyse immunoblot patterns. Sera from 68 patients are studied: 49 controversial cases Ortho/Murex, 17 Ortho/Abbott and 2 cases tested by the three ELISA kits. Indeterminate patterns by ELISA assays remain unresolved in 65% of the samples. RIBA analysis performed in patients with controversial results Ortho/Murex seems to reveal a lack in sensitivity of the Murex kit, but does not show differences in the specificity between these two immunoassays. The RIBA patterns among the samples with Ortho/Abbott controversial results do not demonstrate any discrepancy in the sensitivity of these ELISA tests but it appears that Ortho could be less specific. Our data need to be further confirmed by the analysis of more samples. At last, when the ELISA result is included in the grayzone, the RIBA pattern is generally indeterminate and it is negative in other cases. Finally, the controversial ELISA results, that are mainly found in patients with severe immunosuppression, remain indeterminate depending on the RIBA test. Moreover, the immunoblot is less sensitive and more expensive than any other HCV ELISA test, so there is no convenience to use it for confirmation of a preliminary positive or indeterminate screening.     

Detection of hepatitis C viraemia in Caucasian patients with hepatocellular carcinoma.

Potential risk factors for the development of hepatocellular carcinoma were analysed in 40 Caucasian patients with this malignancy. A higher proportion (14 of 40; 35%) had evidence of hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection than had evidence of either hepatitis B virus (HBV) carriage (17.5%) or alcohol abuse (30%). In all 14 patients whose sera were reactive by HCV ELISA (Ortho second generation test), the presence of antibodies to HCV were confirmed by recombinant immunoblot assay (Ortho RIBA-2). Furthermore, two independent laboratories detected HCV-RNA in 10 of the 14 (71%) anti-HCV positive sera. Two additional sera were shown to contain HCV-RNA when reanalysed by a modified PCR using oligonucleotide primers designed to amplify a shorter fragment of the 5' noncoding region of the genome. Seven of the anti-HCV positive patients also had evidence of prior HBV infection and 2 admitted to alcohol abuse. HCV infection was the only identifiable risk factor in 6 patients. These data confirm the association between HCV infection and hepatocellular carcinoma and suggest that persistent viral replication accompanies tumour development in the majority of patients whose serum contains anti-HCV.     

Hepatitis C virus antibodies and hepatitis C virus RNA in Chinese blood donors determined by ELISA, recombinant immunoblot assay and polymerase chain reaction.

Antibodies to hepatitis C virus (anti-HCV) were determined in Chinese blood donors from the city of Wuhan by a second generation ELISA screening test and a confirmatory recombinant immunoblot assay (RIBA II). Two materials of 281 and 222 sera were sampled under similar conditions in 1989 and 1990, respectively. The first collection of sera was sent to Sweden in lyophilized form, the second directly as fresh unfrozen sera. A high proportion (7.1%) of the lyophilized sera reacted positively in the anti-HCV screening assay, but only seven (2.5%) were positive by the RIBA confirmatory test. In four of these sera HCV-RNA could be detected by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) analysis. In the second material of fresh sera six reacted positively in the screening anti-HCV ELISA, but only one was RIBA positive and four were RIBA indeterminate. None of these sera was positive for HCV-RNA. Thus, the overall prevalence of anti-HCV among the 503 Chinese blood donors, as identified by RIBA, was 1.6%, and of HCV-RNA by PCR 0.8%. The confirmed antibody prevalence is higher than reported from the Western world. Caution about using data from the screening ELISA only, especially if sera have been handled in an unorthodox way, is emphasized.     

Development of low cost peptide-based anti-hepatitis C virus screening and confirmatory assays: comparison with commercially available tests.

Screening and confirmatory low cost reagent tests have been developed for detection of anti-hepatitis C virus (HCV). Assays are based on the use of specific synthetic peptides from several structural and non-structural viral proteins. The efficacy of the screening anti-HCV EIA-Spep assay was compared with both Abbott EIA 2.0 (Abbott Laboratories, North Chicago, IL) and Ortho EIA 2.0 (Ortho Diagnostic Systems, Raritan, NJ) anti-HCV detection kits and the confirmatory EIA-Cpep assay was compared with the Abbott Matrix anti-HCV confirmation test. In the EIA-Spep, a pool of 3 peptides was added to each well of a microtiter plate. In EIA-Cpep, each well was separately coated with 1 of 4 peptides and 1 recombinant protein. A total of 867 blood donor samples from Costa Rica tested simultaneously with the 3 screening assays yielded the same specificity and negative predictive values of > or =99.9% and 100%, respectively. A comparative study on voluntary blood donor samples from Honduras, Nicaragua, and El Salvador using the 2 anti-HCV confirmatory assays revealed different patterns that are 46% positive, 24% indeterminate, and 30% negative with the EIA-Cpep assay vs. 31% positive, 48% indeterminate, and 21% negative with the Matrix assay. A study of 71 patient samples from Costa Rica showed a higher correlation between initially reactive samples when analyzed by the Abbott and Ortho kits, than when the assay results were compared between the Abbott and EIA-Spep kits; the latter detected 7 and 15 non-reactive samples, respectively. These results could reflect the use of a similar antigen source for the 2 commercial assays. The presence of HCV RNA in a group of 29 samples analyzed was related to the simultaneous reactivity in all 3 screening assays. None of the discordant samples had detectable levels of HCV RNA. Economic difficulties for health care services in the developing countries of Central America have prevented implementation of routine anti-HCV blood donor screening tests. This is likely to be the primary reason for uncontrolled dissemination of HCV, and the lack of identification of potential high risk groups. Alternative low cost reagents developed locally as described in this article could be a useful tool in the control of HCV spread throughout the developing world.     

Confirmation of hepatitis C virus antibody in blood donors

Of 103,203 donations collected in Scotland and Northern Ireland over a 3-month period and screened for HCV antibody by Ortho or Abbott second-generation ELISAs, 340 were found repeatedly reactive. Supplementary testing with RIBA-2 resulted in 77 being classified as positive, 130 as indeterminate, and 133 as negative. PCR analysis of the positives and indeterminates indicated viraemia in 65 (84%) of the positives and 7 (5.5%) of the indeterminates. To determine if PCR analysis could be eliminated or reduced by further serological testing, all RIBA-2 positives and indeterminates were tested by UBI and Wellcozyme ELISAs and Innolia and RIBA-3 immunoblots. All RIBA-2 positives with bands to more than 1 gene product were detected in all 4 systems, but >60% of RIBA-2 indeterminates were negative in those tests that contain either recombinant antigens or synthetic peptides derived independently from those used by Ortho/Abbott tests. A comparison of data from the 79 reactive with the core (c22) region revealed only 16 samples reactive in all 4 systems as well as Ortho and Abbott. These 16 included all 6 of the PCR positives in the 79 c22 indeterminate samples. ELISAs and immunoblots using independently derived antigens can offer a useful method of screening out nonspecific reactions in Ortho or Abbott ELISAs, hence reducing the need for PCR testing. Some caution is required as all such tests do not contain identical mixes of antigenic material.     

Monitoring antibody titers to recombinant Core-NS3 fusion polypeptide is useful for evaluating hepatitis C virus infection and responses to interferon-alpha therapy.

To evaluate the clinical feasibility of the antibody titer against a chimeric polypeptide (named Core 518), in which a domain of Core and NS3 of hepatitis C virus (HCV) was fused, ELISA was performed in a total of 76 serum samples. Each serum was serially diluted using two-fold dilution method with distilled water into 10 concentrations. They were all positive for second generation anti-HCV assay (HCV EIA II; Abbott Laboratories). Genotyping RT-PCR, quantitative competitive RT-PCR, and RIBA (Lucky Confirm; LG Biotech) were also assayed. Anti-Core 518 antibody was detected in x 12800 or higher dilutions of sera from 35 of 43 chronic hepatitis C (81.4%) and nine of 16 hepatocellular carcinoma sera (56.3%), one of four cirrhosis (25%), 0 of four acute hepatitis C, and one of nine healthy isolated anti-HCV-positive subjects (p=0.0000). The anti-Core 518 antibody titers were well correlated with the presence of HCV RNA in serum (p=0.002). The anti-Core 518 antibody titers decreased significantly in nine of ten responders to IFN-alpha treatment. Monitoring anti-Core 518 titers may be helpful not only for differentiating the status of HCV infection among patients with various type C viral liver diseases, but also for predicting responses to IFN-alpha treatment.     

Evaluation of hepatitis C virus kits.

Hepatitis C virus (HCV) antibodies were detected in 85.9% of the samples by commercial enzyme immunoassay (EIA) kits. Most EIA-positive samples were reactive (80%) by the RIBA HCV test (Ortho Diagnostics). Samples with optical density values greater than or equal to 2.0 were mostly reactive (87%) by RIBA HCV test, in contrast to those with values less than or equal to 1.0 (6.6%). Samples which were indeterminate by the RIBA HCV test were positive (88.4%) by HCV neutralization EIA (Abbott Laboratories), along with 29.4% of samples which were nonreactive by the RIBA HCV test.     

Hepatitis C virus seroconversion by a third generation ELISA screening test in blood donors.

The significance of seroconversion as detected by an ELISA screening test for hepatitis C virus (HCV) antibody with a negative supplemental/confirmatory recombinant immunoblot assay (RIBA) result was investigated. Of 118,220 established West Midlands blood donors with at least one negative HCV antibody screen, 43 had seroconverted in 1994 according to the ELISA but had negative RIBA-3 results. The paired archive serum samples of the pre- and postseroconversion donations of 29 seroconverting donors were tested by nested polymerase chain reaction (PCR) for the detection of HCV RNA. All 58 samples were negative by PCR. The absence of detectable viraemia in all tested seroconverting donors suggests that HCV infection was not responsible for seroconversion by ELISA.     

Hepatitis C virus infection in hemodialysis patients in southern Sweden: Epidemiological,clinical, and diagnostic aspects

A prevalence of hepatitis C virus (HCV) antibodies of 12% was found in 276 patients from 11 dialysis units. Between zero and 22% of the patients in the different units were anti-HCV positive. The epidemiology of HCV was studied in two units during a 2 year period by antibody assays and the polymerase chain reaction and correlated with clinical manifestations. Two types of epidemiologic patterns were found that may explain the wide difference of HCV prevalence described in different dialysis units. In one unit there was no evidence of spread within the unit, and the prevalence of HCV was dependent on the status of the patients entering for treatment. In the other unit, a clustering of infected patients could be seen in which 13 of 36 were infected during a 3 year period. Some patients who had not received blood transfusions were among the infected. Hepatitis C infection was the most common explanation for repeated abnormal transferase levels. Most of the HCV-infected patients reacted both for anti-HCV and HCV RNA. HCV RNA was in general detected earlier than anti-HCV seroconversion. Among 20 HCV RNApositive serum samples that were anti-HCV ELISA-positive 18 had indeterminate and two negative reactions by immunoblot (RIBA 2). Thus the RIBA 2 test should be used with caution as a confirmatory antibody test in this group of patients. © 1993 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Evaluation of first- and second-generation RIBA kits for detection of antibody to hepatitis C virus.

Samples reactive by first-generation recombinant immunoblot assay (RIBA) to detect antibody to hepatitis C virus (anti-HCV) (RIBA-1 [Chiron, Calif.]) remained reactive by a second-generation test (RIBA-2) for HCV antibodies. A total of 75% of specimens indeterminate by RIBA-1 became reactive, 12.5% were nonreactive, and 12.5% remained indeterminate by RIBA-2. Among RIBA-1-nonreactive specimens, 12.0% became positive and 5.1% became indeterminate by RIBA-2. The antigens c33c and c22-3 have increased the sensitivity of RIBA-2.