Diagnosis and treatment of thoracic outlet syndrome

Patients who develop symptoms of thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS) have a predisposing anatomic abnormality. In most patients with TOS, the symptoms are caused by entrapment of the brachial plexus and they do not arise from compression of the subclavian artery, as was previously thought. The tests advocated for diagnosing this common syndrome (i.e., evaluating the positional compression of the artery when the arms are raised, the neck is turned, or the shoulders are braced) cannot accurately diagnose this syndrome. There are two reasons for this. The symptoms of TOS are not related to the compression of the artery in the outlet in 98% of patients, and 75% of normal individuals without symptoms show diminished radial pulse on various provocation tests. We employed four timed provocation tests (minute tests) to diagnose TOS: the timed Morley test, timed Wright test, timed Eden test, and elevated arm stress exercise, all of which are very sensitive. In normal individuals without symptoms, 20% experience transitional symptoms such as slight pain and tiredness, on these tests indicating a subclinical state. TOS is treated by keeping the thoracic outlet wide, this being done either conservatively or surgically. In 1993 and 1994, we conservatively treated 418 of 422 patients with TOS by means of active exercise, a brace, and by block therapy. These measures did not reduce the symptoms in 23 of these patients, so surgical treatment was indicated. In the remaining 4 of the 422 patients, conservative treatment was not indicated and surgery was performed directly. All the patients showed significant clinical improvement of varying degree. Presented at the 69th Annual Meeting of the Japanese Orthopaedic Association, Tokyo, April 12, 1996     

胸廓出口综合征的诊疗体会

目的探讨胸廓出口综合征(TOS)的诊断和手术治疗。方法我院自1997-2003年诊断和手术治疗胸廓出口综合征23例24侧，诊断为臂丛上千型TOS2例，下千型17例18侧，全臂丛型1例，血管型2例，混合型1例。手术切除颈肋及过长的横突，同时作臂丛神经外膜松解术。术中发现23例有纤维束带压迫臂丛神经，均切断前斜角肌，松解臂丛神经及受压的锁骨下血管，如果发现中、小斜角肌压迫臂丛神经血管，则予切断。术后当天行颈肩部活动。结果按Ross的疗效评定标准评定疗效，本组优10例11例，良9例，可2例，差2例，优良率83.33％。结论胸廓出口综合征应早期手术探查，彻底松解臂丛神经血管。     

儿童胸廓出口综合征的诊断与治疗

目的探讨儿童胸廓出口综合征的诊断与治疗效果。方法分析5例儿童胸廓出口综合征患者手术治疗的临床资料。结果参考陈德松等的标准评定，优4例，良1例。结论儿童胸廓出口综合征主要病理改变是斜角肌的肥厚与挛缩，病因是包括感染在内的多种因素共同作用造成，一旦保守治疗无效应及早手术。     

Diagnosis of thoracic outlet syndrome

Thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS) is a nonspecific label. When employing it, one should define the type of TOS as arterial TOS, venous TOS, or neurogenic TOS. Each type has different symptoms and physical findings by which the three types can easily be identified. Neurogenic TOS (NTOS) is by far the most common, comprising well over 90% of all TOS patients. Arterial TOS is the least common accounting for no more than 1%. Many patients are erroneously diagnosed as "vascular" TOS, a nonspecific misnomer, whereas they really have NTOS. The Adson Test of noting a radial pulse deficit in provocative positions has been shown to be of no clinical value and should not be relied upon to make the diagnosis of any of the three types. The test is normal in most patients with NTOS and at the same time can be positive in many control volunteers. Arterial TOS is caused by emboli arising from subclavian artery stenosis or aneurysms. Symptoms are those of arterial ischemia and x-rays almost always disclose a cervical rib or anomalous first rib. Venous TOS presents with arm swelling, cyanosis, and pain due to subclavian vein obstruction, with or without thrombosis. Neurogenic TOS is due to brachial plexus compression usually from scarred scalene muscles secondary to neck trauma, whiplash injuries being the most common. Symptoms include extremity paresthesia, pain, and weakness as well as neck pain and occipital headache. Physical exam is most important and includes several provocative maneuvers including neck rotation and head tilting, which elicit symptoms in the contralateral extremity; the upper limb tension test, which is comparable to straight leg raising; and abducting the arms to 90 degrees in external rotation, which usually brings on symptoms within 60 seconds.     

Diagnosis, treatment, and complications of thoracic outlet syndrome

New concepts regarding the diagnosis and treatment of thoracic outlet syndrome, double crush syndrome related to thoracic outlet syndrome, and minor traumatic dystrophy related to thoracic outlet syndrome are explained. Received for publication on May 22, 1998     

Conservative treatment for thoracic outlet syndrome

Conservative treatment of thoracic outlet syndrome consists initially of pain control and medicinal and physical measures. Therapy then addresses tight muscles, with strengthening of weakened neck and shoulder girdle muscles. Range of motion and nerve gliding exercises are instituted simultaneously, and the patient is educated in proper posture and ergonomics at home and in the work setting.     

Surgical treatment of the thoracic outlet syndrome

In 63 patients with severe symptoms of thoracic outlet syndrome, transaxillary rib resection was performed. The series was re-evaluated after a mean postoperative observation time of 2.5 years. Complete relief of all symptoms was obtained in 64% of the patients and marked improvement in 17%. The result was classified as fair in 12%. In 7% of the series no improvement of symptoms was obtained.     

Modernizing the treatment of venous thoracic outlet syndrome

This study aims to quantify the management and outcomes of patients treated for venous thoracic outlet syndrome (vTOS) over a seven-year period. A retrospective case-note review of all patients undergoing first rib resection at a regional vascular unit between January 1, 2002 and December 31, 2009 was performed. Treatment pathways and outcomes recorded as freedom from symptoms and venous patency were analyzed. Thirty-five patients were identified with vTOS. Ninety-one percent of patients had patent veins at discharge from clinical follow-up and were symptom-free at a median of 44 months. Patients treated within seven days of symptoms (94.7 versus 85.7, P = 0.060), with catheter-directed thrombolysis (94 versus 87.5% P = 0.702) and excision of first rib in less than 30 days (100 versus 85.7%, P = 0.002), had improved symptom-free rates. In conclusion, early referral, immediate catheter-directed thrombolysis, perioperative balloon venoplasty and early thoracic outlet decompression may provide a suitable model for improving outcomes in vTOS.     

Current trends in treatment of thoracic outlet syndrome

Even though the response from this survey was decent, it is not large enough to draw statistical conclusions. The data therefore are being presented from an interest standpoint and do reflect the current trends of treatment for TOS. Physicians who do not treat TOS do not have an accurate view of this disorder, its treatment, or the success rate of treatment. Surgeons who deal with this problem have encouraging results. Conservative treatment seems effective in approximately half of the patients afflicted with this condition. Surgery carries what seems to be a long-term cure rate of 65% and partial relief in 20% of patients. Significant complications are rare.     

Surgical treatment of thoracic outlet syndrome in pediatrics

AimThoracic outlet syndrome (TOS) is a condition that occurs when the cervical neuro-vascular bundle becomes compressed at one of the three narrow areas of the thoraco-cervico-axillary region. Conservative management is the first line of treatment. Patients who do not respond to conservative management should be treated surgically. The aim of this review is to present our experience with the surgical management of TOS in pediatric patients.MethodsWe retrospectively reviewed the outcomes of all patients with TOS operated at our Hospital between 2001 and 2020. We collected all demographic data, clinical features, imaging data, type of operation performed, intraoperative findings, complications and recurrence.ResultsWe operated 9 patients within the study period. The median age at surgery was 14 (7 to 17) years. A transaxillary approach was used in 7 patients and a supraclavicular approach in 2. There was only one minor intraoperative complication (violation of the pleural space). There were no postoperative complications. The median length of stay was 3 (2 to 4) days. All patients were extubated in the operating room. Two patients developed symptoms on the contralateral side. One of these underwent a successful contralateral transaxillary Roos operation. The follow-up was 4 months to 20 years. All patients are asymptomatic.ConclusionWe believe that the Roos operation is a safe and effective treatment with excellent long-term outcomes for children with TOS that fail conservative management.     

Surgical treatment of the thoracic outlet compression syndrome

Narrowing of the thoracic outlet may give rises to symptoms in the arm from compression of the nerves, the subclavian artery, and the subclavian vein. Anatomic studies show that nerve compression may affect fibers from T-1, C-8, and not infrequently C-7, providing an explanation for the diffuse nature of the nerve symptoms in the arm. Relief from this compression at the thoracic outlet is readily accomplished by transaxillary resection of the first rib together with any associated cervical rib, fibrous cervical rib analogues, or other fibrous bands encroaching on the neurovascular structures. A study of 40 patients with the syndrome who were treated in this way and followed up after an interval of three to ten years shows that those with nerve and vein symptoms can expect a good result but the results of treatment in those with arterial symptoms is less satisfactory.     

Vascular thoracic outlet syndrome

Abstract The surgical treatment of 30 cases of vascular thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS) in 25 patients is presented. Patients included 17 women and 8 men with average age of 26.1 years. The causes of compression were cervical rib (n = 16), soft tissue anomalies (n = 12), and scar tissue after clavicle fracture (n = 2). Ten subclavian artery aneurysms containing intraluminal thrombus as well as one subclavian artery occlusion were found. All such cases had multiple distal arterial embolization. Presenting features of cases with arterial TOS included: hand ischemia (n = 11), transient ischemic attack (TIA) (n = 1), and claudication or vasomotor phenomena during the arm hyperabduction (n = 11). Two patients with venous TOS developed hand edema during arm hyperabduction, and five other patients had axillary-subclavian venous thrombosis. In all cases decompressive procedures using a combined supraclavicular and infraclavicular approach were performed. Decompression was achieved by cervical rib excision (n = 12), combined cervical and first rib excision (n = 4), and first rib excision (n = 14). In all cases division of all soft tissue elements was also accomplished. Associated vascular procedures included resection and replacement of 10 subclavian artery aneurysms, one subclavian-axillary and one axillary-brachial bypass, as well as nine brachial embolectomies. All five cases with axillary-subclavian vein thrombosis before decompression were treated with anticoagulant therapy. The mean follow-up period was 3 years and 2 months (range 1 to 6 years). Two pleural entry injuries and two transient brachial plexus injuries were noted. All reconstructed arteries were patent during the follow-up period. Complete resolution of symptoms with a return to full activity was noticed in all cases with arterial TOS and in two cases with venous TOS without axillary-subclavian vein thrombosis. In cases with axillary-subclavian vein thrombosis relief of symptoms was mild, and there were limitations on daily activity. Vascular TOS is seen less frequently than the neurogenic form; however, in most cases it requires surgical treatment. We prefer a combined supraclavicular and infraclavicular approach because it offers complete exposure of the subclavian artery, cervical and first ribs, and all soft tissue anomalies. Electronic Publication     

Recurrent thoracic outlet syndrome

Recurrent symptoms develop in 15% to 20% of patients undergoing either first rib resection or scalenectomy for thoracic outlet syndrome. Over the past 22 years 134 operations for recurrence were performed in 97 patients. Four operations were used: transaxillary first rib resection (26); supraclavicular first rib resection with neurolysis (15); scalenectomy with neurolysis (58); and brachial plexus neurolysis (35). Complications included temporary plexus injury (0.7%), temporary phrenic palsy (3.7%), and permanent phrenic palsy (1.4%). The combined primary success rate of all four operations for recurrence was 84% in the first 3 months. This fell to 59% at 1 to 2 years; 50% at 3 to 5 years; and 41% at 10 to 15 years. No significant difference was found in results between the four operations used for recurrence. When recurrence was caused by trauma the results of reoperations were better than when recurrence was spontaneous. The primary success rates of three initial operations for thoracic outlet syndrome were compared to their secondary success rates (improved after reoperation). By use of life-table methods, reoperation improved the 5- to 10-year success rate of transaxillary first rib resection from 69% to 86% and for scalenectomy from 69% to 84%. Reoperation is successful in most cases of recurrent thoracic outlet syndrome and better when recurrence is the result of a neck injury.     

Venous thoracic outlet syndrome

Venous thoracic outlet syndrome is caused by subclavian vein obstruction with or without thrombosis. The primary symptom is arm swelling, frequently accompanied by cyanosis, pain, and occasionally paresthesias. Venography is the only reliable diagnostic tool. Therapy has three goals: (1) remove the thrombus (in thrombotic cases), (2) remove the extrinsic compression, and in a minority of cases, (3) remove the intrinsic stenosis.     

Neurogenic thoracic outlet syndrome

Current concepts for the diagnosis of neurogenic thoracic outlet syndrome are presented together with the surgical experience and results in series of 51 patients caused by a cervical rib. Surgical treatment is recommended in patients with persistent and disabling symptoms not responding to conservative therapy. In carefully selected patients good to excellent results can be achieved.     

Diagnosing thoracic outlet syndrome

Diagnosing and treating thoracic outlet syndrome can be challenging and frustrating. It must be emphasized that the diagnosis of TOS is a clinical one based on a detailed history and physical examination. This takes time and effort and is often confounded by the patient's research on the internet and emotional problems usually resulting from the symptoms and lack of appropriate treatment. Years of inappropriate diagnosis and ineffective therapy take a heavy toll on these patients. Some have psychologic problems to the point that no treatment, no matter how well indicated, will make them well. Some have had symptoms so long that there is permanent neurologic damage. Each patient presents his or her own diagnostic challenge. Solving the problem and providing effective therapy can be rewarding for doctor and patient.     

Superior thoracic outlet syndrome

The authors discuss Superior Thoracic Outlet Syndrome (STOS), which is characterized by aspecific symptomatology. However, some tests may be used to reveal the specificity of the disease. In the past, treatment was often followed by recurrence of the disease. In the last ten years, the Roos operation has been used with a high success rate.